GTA SA - Why Remaster is Garbage? [Part 2] - Feat. BadgerGoodger
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 чер 2024
- In this video I am going to continue to show you why the official HD port of Grand Theft Auto San Andreas on the consoles or so called “Remastered version” is a huge disappointment. We are continuing to look at Xbox 360, Xbox One and Playstation 3 versions here.
##########
Today's narrator:
●Badger Goodger
/ @badgergoodger
/ badgergoodger
●Rockstar, Modding, and the Take Two Take-downs
• Rockstar, Modding, and...
●Another one of those "GTA VI map" leaks
• Another one of those "...
##########
● My Twitter ●
/ nationalpepper
##########
● Paid music provided by
www.epidemicsound.com
●ES_Brazen - [ocean jams]
●ES_On the Head - A P O L L O
●ES_Muses - Ballpoint
●ES_Unfettered - Jobii
●ES_Stay in Skul - Smartface
●ES_Pajamas - Timothy Infinite
●ES_Space Rebels - _91nova
●ES_Timely - A P O L L O
●ES_Unbuttoned - Timothy Infinite
●ES_Wiseman - Smartface
●ES_Blue Purple - Guustavv
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Time stamps
00:00 Introduction
1:25 Just a mobile port
2:30 Broken game mechanics
20:02 Downgrades from mobile port
24:39 Enhanced car models
28:18 Enhanced shadow system
33:39 Problematic in-game camera
38:10 Corrections and new information
41:21 Announcing part 3
41:58 End screen
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
● My Patreon page ●
/ nationalpepper
● This is the place where I post early access videos as well as updates and other goodies. Starting from $1 per month.
#VadimComparison #GTA #GTAcomparison - Ігри
![GTA SA - Why Definitive Edition is Garbage? [Part 1] - Feat. BadgerGoodger](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZSvoC6lZl5s/mqdefault.jpg)
![GTA SA - Why Definitive Edition is Garbage? [Part 1] - Feat. BadgerGoodger](/img/tr.png)
![GTA SA - Why Remaster is Garbage? [Part 1] - Feat. BadgerGoodger](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jhVdb4K1M-M/mqdefault.jpg)
This video is voiced by Badger Goodger. Check out his channel UA-cam channel as well!
ua-cam.com/users/badgergoodger
●Rockstar, Modding, and the Take Two Take-downs ua-cam.com/video/W1S4ul78NtI/v-deo.html
●Another one of those "GTA VI map" leaks ua-cam.com/video/4owFUAg9EpQ/v-deo.html
Good to know
@Barikoga -_- it's up
Even with all the bugs I still managed to 100% this version, wasn't easy!
Why not just voice it yourself you silly goose.
Vadim M, what I’ve experienced in the remaster is the gunshot sounds are a lot more compressed than in the original version.
What is worse than that is that War Drum Studios changed their name to “Grove Street Games” and they seem proud about the work they have done on these ports ! What an insult to our childhoods
Your Heisenberg dp along with the last line feels something really not good is going to happen.
@Shakhbulat Gazgireev they are located in the Grove Street Neighborhood in
Gainesville, Florida.
But still - I think it's intentional.
@@automation7295 ohhh watch out,we got ourselves a tough guy over here.
I hope that they dont do the remastered trilogy.
@@tomjackjack960 I wouldn't push their buttons, dudes prolly not having a good day. Or a good life for that matter lmao
CJ: *wanted by the military*
"Our hood is under attack"
The army, FBI and police: Understandable, have a nice day
Lol 😂
@@diobrando4063 DIO!
Damn, the FIB knows to respect Grove Street
@@J.M91843 that’s the name there a problem
@@diobrando4063 DIO Is this you?
History repeat itself.
Can't wait for part 3 definitive edition.
i've seen huge eyes while during cutscene. I've seen it worse.
Nope, DE will be featured in a completely seperate series. Part 3 is still about the 10th anniversary edition.
@@Meesmoth So is it confirmed? Why definitive edition is garbage?
@@skyon619 In my opinion it kinda is graphics are amazing and all, but some things they have removed lowkey disappointed me such as the movement buff cj had in the og.
I had no idea they even had this version of gta San Andreas. So after the failure of this version they took the same version again?! The same glitches and fails are still there 7 years later!?
Now time for "Why the definitive edition is garbage"
Can't wait to watch it.
GmanLives has a great video regarding this. Its like a good appetizer for whats to come here.
Definitive edition = remaster edition with changed engine... It's the same garbage but with more bugs
@@andreivanatoru2549 the old remaster seemed like a straight emulated Version with minor changes back then.
Would explain all the bugs + PlayStation 3 and xbox 360 were quiet difficult plattforms from a hardware standpoint.
Its just sad for the community. Atleast the modders are quick to react and adapt
You should check the Badger Goodger channel. He talked some things about that release.
"There will be a part 3"
See y'all in 2 years.
Still waiting for him to mention the pitched down vehicle sounds in first gear
Yea n itll be bout the remastered versions releasing this year lol
y'all
@@HowellQ
There, fixed it. Are you happy now?
@@kowaletzki Very much so. Thank you.
This remastered version's lighting is abysmal. The PS2 version's lighting looks really good, even today
did you get GTA 3 in October 2001 ?
@Paul Bell Did you get Vice City in October 2002?
I prefer the Xbox models of cars.
I dont get it why cant they do better than 15 years ago
I don't know, I somehow prefer the remaster on this particular issue
Can’t wait for part three with "definitive edition".
It's definitely in production :P
definitive garbage
It could be really good tho
It will take a bloody lot of parts for the Definitive Edition
@@YOMARTINPRODUCTIONS i mean… the definitive edition could be good 🤷🏿♂️
It's just bafflingly unbelievable that it gets worse than this in the definitive edition.
I recently just installed the original GTA 3 PC version from Steam. Game has been out for 20 years and it doesn't have proper gamepad support out of the box.
@@deeppurplefan San Andreas is coming to oculus quest. Now that's a way to re-experience the game. I'd rather do that for the full cost of a quest 2 + the game than I'd buy into these fucking remasters and definitive editions. I don't understand why gamers keep shitting money away on nothing burgers
Definitively worse edition
No actualy DE is much better than this trash. Not that I'm denying the fact that DE is trash as well
@@shrekgaming6593 trueee
dude the first part was my favorite video on your channel. So glad we’re getting sequels!
amen to that
Hello Gypsy
true
also his most popular lol
Yeah, shame that Part 3 will probably be out in 2023.
2004: police cheat code activated
2014: our hood is under attack
B, right, B Right, Left, X, Y, up (I still remember it after all of these years.)
@@JaysasterGaming good job king
TURNDOWNTHEHEAT
@@rydersherm2490 ASNAEB
@@rydersherm2490 pretty sure it's aezakmi
Vadim M: I still got things to talk about this remastered release, so yes, there will be a third part to this series.
GTA Trilogy Definitive Edition: Allow me to introduce myself.
Oh boy, 3 of them at the same day, oh boy.
@Sharad Kumar Singh remasters*
@@No-cs2xf retrashers
it's literally not bad... y'all are just Brats looking for something to complain about 🤦♀️
41:24
Rockstar is so nice to have doubled the length of this series for you. They can be so generous sometimes.
Underrated comment
Definitive Edition is literally not bad... y'all are just Brats looking for something to complain about 🤦♀️
@@warriorgrl3076 No we aren't fucking brats. It's that bad for a company as big as Rockstar.
@@warriorgrl3076 it gets more patches😇
@@thelibertyking6735 gta definition edition is a disgrace.
Missed bug: In the beginning cutscene in "Big Smoke" where Carl looks at a photo of his mother who sadly died, you can see that the picture, while on the floor, clips through the ground. Should I mention that you can clearly see the photo in the original never did that?
@Super SP that's actually a cutscene bug when the remastered version added a widescreen patch and now you can see the things you aren't meant to see in cutscenes and it happens all the time
On PS2 that bug wasn't there, was it?
@@kedinamite579 It wasn’t, nor was it also on the PC and original Xbox.
Who else read this in Badger Goodger's Voice
I have a good feeling that these problems were caused by Rockstar being so confident that nobody would end up playing at high enough aspect ratios to notice the extras. That is why you can see Carl and the company outside Drive-Thru when Big Smoke buys them food, when they could've been placed in the car already and _then_ animated when the close-up shows.
This channel is the perfect definition of "Quality over Quantity"
And also let me remind you that the guy makes TWO videos at the same time. Both eng and ru versions,so that's two scripts,two packs of pictures,two separate editing projects
you forget your "."
There's not even that much quantity either in the remaster. Like, they cut so much shit out for no reason.
There's no quality nor quantity.
@@struggler6864 I was talking about the channel not the remaster
@@struggler6864 Can you read? 😂
At this point I'm convinced Rockstar just lost the original code for the game and are trying to hide that fact
One more reason why rockstar needs to make an actual remake
@@bimisikocheng ,One more reason not to because that would push new gta game way too behind.
@@muhammedraashid3667 yeah then the new gta game will be even worse
@@muhammedraashid3667 As much as I would love a gta trilogy up from the ground, I would prefer gta 6
No, they still have the original code. But it really isn't very useful. It was made for machines that no longer are used and wasn't at all made to be expandable.
If the Crash trilogy or the Spyro trilogy had tried to just build on the original code it would have turned out badly too. However Toys for Bob knew that so they remade the game from scratch and it's what Rockstar also needs to do with GTA.
I love how the old version is so realistic then the remastered gets so canned out of realism in the game.
Finally the sequel we have been waiting for.
Yeah gotta watch this before i sleep
Yeah cannot believe it took 1 years to release part 2
Annnd we'll have to wait another years to have part 3
I know right.
Agreed
In the words of Count Dooku: *”I’ve been looking forward to this!”*
yes
Count Dracula* ??
@@JVLeroy223 I hate Garlic it's Course and Rough and it gets Everywhere
Garlic diverts me to the other lane!
I can't wait for Vadim M to slam the Definite Edition to Oblivion.
My body is sooo ready. This gun be good
I am from the future, he did a video about it and it was entertaining
As expected, War Drum Studios aka Grove Street Games fucked up the Definitive Edition like the Broken GTA San Andreas 10 year Anniversary Remaster! There's a lot of Graphical Bugs and Texture issues FILLED in all 3 games!
It gets patched and even more of it is patched in the future
This just makes me appreciate the original version even more.
Right lol I'm glad I never bought this so called remaster now
poor CJ! in this looks a shiny turd!
Maybe that's why the remaster exist
Well atleast they’re making a better remaster sweetheart
Edit: Regret these words now
the game ain't even out and they're throwing shit at it
This is straight up a mobile emulator with and skin over everything. That would explain all the bugs and visual glitches as well as the simplify mechanics.
Funny thing is that android version of San andreas is straight up broken in newer revisions of the OS
Mine just cannot launch in android 10
@@7U57HTJRYGHG it struggles on my galaxy s8 plus but runs smoother on my 2 gb ram tablet which is android 6.0 vs 9.0
Yes i can confirm because i've played both versions and mobile had simplified mechanics even when you used a controller for it just like the remaster along with the on screen buttons but the strange part about that is when you use the controller on mobile a small fraction of it is seen like phone calls the gym etc, and the remaster has the thing by default with the addition of full touch controls shown by the click of a button.
@@7U57HTJRYGHG Oh good. I thought that was just me. I updated my S21 U5G at some point, and when I went to go kill some time by playing SA, it refused to open. A reinstall doesn't fix it either. So now it just sits there :/ It was really nice to be able to whip out my phone and play GTA on it. even if it's not the most definitive edition.
is it broken on android 11? very weird because on ios it’s working just fine even on ios 15 beta
An underrated line from sweet
"If it ain't broken don't fix it.
You know what made me do a 180 degree turn from buying the definitive edition? It's basically the remastered version with better graphics and a gta v weapon wheel.
More like shaders instead of better graphics.
Thankfully mods are our friend with og
@@quarreneverett4767 Unless you manage to break your entire game by modding it to hell with CLEO scripts
@@bmhater1283 Modloader exist.
Just pirate the old pc version and install some mods suchs ginput (or maybe a hd graphics mod)
It's been 1 year and 8 months since Part 1 was uploaded, and now we're on Part 2.
This channel and its videos are a by the book example of quality over quantity.
azunyan
Or incompetence.
Nothing to be proud of tbh, if it takes so long you lose interest from some ppl.
@@royale7620 I'd rather have content i could be proud of than high viewer count. Notice he shows things you can't find anywhere else, those take time to discover and properely test.
@@royale7620 lost interest? until today people have literally been begging for a part 2 lmao. and theyre already asking for a part 3 too. everyone in the comments seems to actually be pretty patient with this content besides you and the reply above you.
I'm just still mindblown how R*/Take-Two or whoever allowed this to pass. Like all of their games are gems and quality and then they allow a studio to butcher a gem like that
Probably R* didn't have the time, and Take-Two simply doesn't care lol
It's not like their PC port is stellar work, but remastered definitely takes the cake 😆
I just pray that the definitive edition is actually good.
It will be
Impossible, War Drum Studios aka Grove Street Games is the dev behind the definitive edition
The same studio who made this buggy game is making the Definitive Edition so I highly doubt it will be playable due to bugs and glitches
@@illegalpic6814 new employees dummy. Remember how good rockstar was? now look at it
@@Vedant9710 I'm actually looking forward on this one tbh.. War Drum Studios is closer to the modders than Rockstar nowadays.
can't wait for "Why Definitive Edition is Garbage"
same
Lol I like how people had high expectations for it and it came out terrible
@@JessicaGarcia-xf9wr personally I had the worst possible expectations and they were confirmed 100%
@@JessicaGarcia-xf9wr we had high expectations for it because we thought Rockstar was making it. As soon as it was revealed War Drum Studios was making it we all realised it was going to be a dumpster fire
it's literally not bad... y'all are just Brats looking for something to complain about 🤦♀️
11:30 In the mobile version, you bail out of a moving vehicle by just tapping on the widget, not holding it. Idk why it’s like this though.
It's still backwards than the original though, which they didn't bother to swapped back in Remastered. But at least it can be adapted.
But besides that, CJ can't actually get out of the car without closing the door. This causes the game feels a little bit slower than the original version. All of that are caused by a mistake of Rockstar to hire a developers that are so lazy just to port a game control mechanics.
I think you need to double tap it or it won't do shit
Tap tap and done
I can only imagine how frustrating it is as a developer to see graphics and presentation that you crunched on being completely broken in a sloppy “remaster” for modern consoles.
Fantastic follow up video to your other one!
Even tho original had it flaws, but the so called "remaster" had more issues than the original game released. Way to call it a "remaster" "re-release"...
Funny you should say that
Remember Halo CE PC gearbox port? And the fact that Anniversary used that game as a base?
Thank goodness it was recently fixed, otherwise we the pc gamers would have no idea of how the original was supposed to look like.
@The Blue Gamer and Animal lover. well I said that already..
@@sjsiemka 7 xy7
@@whippyfunnyman BMW
sad news,
war drum studios (grove street games) are making the new remastered and what's even worse that you legally have no way to play the originals now. a big F.
They have so much presure on his hands so i hope they do better now
bro no fucking way dude...... i can't believe this shit, i had to google it..... bro i was so excited about the remasters, i can't believe they hired those same idiots to remaster these legendary games. and like i don't care bro even if it was a REMAKE they could not have removed the original versions from everywhere like they did those games are irreplaceable, what a freaking shame F
They'll never take away my PS2 copies. Physical media FTW!
@@LinkinVerbz44 true, physical is the way to go, or pirating too since they're doing this to the fans, screw them hehe
@@LinkinVerbz44 agree
Oh boy you're gonna have a field day with "Definitive Edition"
Finally, it's worth waiting over 1 year for sequel.
The aircraft shadow is an interesting one.
Here’s my old man story. Towards the end of the PS2 era developers began to understand that the player needs something to telegraph where they’ll land in platform games. The fix was to have a forced shadow directly underneath the player so they could see where they were landing while in the air. In GTA SA they used this on the aircraft, so a duplicate shadow will be made always cast directly under the vehicle regardless of how light/dark or where other shadows are cast from. It’s an interesting and subtle game design mechanic that you’d not notice unless pointed out, but Nintendo uses it all the time. It’s even in GTAIV and V, try landing any aircraft in Vice City without it though.
That’s why the shadows appear when you enter a flying vehicle, it’s a duplicate to assist in landing which disappears when you get out.
and since the original shadow doesnt exist, you can only see the duplicate in remastered version
@@Krim4444
Correct!
Most recently I noticed something similar in Psychonauts 2.
Raz casts a normal angled shadow like in most modern games. However when you jump another shadow will appear directly below you to help with platforming/positioning which is nice.
Towards the end of the PS2 era? Really? The forced shadow underneath the player or a vehicle to judge depth has been present and implemented in PS1 games!
Nintendo?
NINTENDO!?
WHAT THE HELL!?
THAT CURSED COMPANY THAT MAKES SIMPLE PORTS OF LAST-GEN GAMES AND CHARGE FULL PRICE FOR IT!?
It's Rockstar, alright?
Get ready for another part to this series
Just played this version for a couple hours but I dont even remember it being that Bad. Its just ridiculous. Will stick to the og Xbox Version. However you can go straight to the new definitive Edition crap and continue this series 😂
I’m pleased you picked up on things like speed blur and heat haze - atmosphere is SO important and removing these simple features kills it.
Which is why I never liked the PC port, all the effects of the PS2 were removed.
Those effects are there to hide shitty textures
@@itsporter Exactly, just like the Silent Hill fog, but at the same time it's exactly those limitations that made them get creative to build an atmosphere, what's the point of making "better textures" if it looks worse than the original version?
Right?! Also the underwater effect 🙄
This comment either really well, or really poorly
Its a shame considering how iconic this game was back then. New gamers that hear about how great this game was will probably end up trying one of these versions and then they won't fully understand what made this game so good! There was so much potential to make a proper remaster, but instead they tarnished the name!
They are now refining it again :)
Don't get your hopes up
Trust have you seen how the graphics ain’t really got any better 😂😂
Yea true I recently got it on sale on ps5 before they removed it, it’s so good I’m glad I could play it for the first time even if it’s a little weird to get use to the controls
@@emma6648 I'm excited about it.
The new Tommy looks like he ate the old Tommy 🍔🍟
Almost 3 years later and no part 3. Is it not happening?
Everytime Vadim uploads a video it feels like christmas 😂
Someone should make a virgin Chad chart of GTA UA-camrs
Indeed
Vadim blyat
@@Grulaz
Virgin mrbossFTW : doesn't makes good content, crap editing, milks GTA 6, videos are all the same but with different title, fucking overrated
Chad Vadim : good content, doesn't milks one content, various type of topic, God editing, fucking underrated
@@nikto7297 Wizard Zaccox Incel Nought Neckbeard Mrboss the Virgin Jelly the Brad PRG The Chad Gtamen Thad Gypsy The Lad Badger the Gad Vadim
The holes in the cars are a result of shadow faces. As you can see, every one of these holes appears at the top of an inset in the mesh. That's where a shadow face was displayed, a black semi-transparent face that was emulating a shadow. Now, any part of the car past the semi-transparent is not rendered. The hole is a little dimmer than the world behind it, because of the shadow material on the face.
I thought it was because of back face culling, especially after it was mentioned in the video, it's known, that rockstar messed up a lot of 3d models in the 3d era
Normals facing the wrong way?
@@silentwraith3464 I’d presume it’s the rendering order. Normally translucent materials should be rendered at the end (on top of everything else rendered). Because windows work normally, I think alpha flags still work. For optimisation, when faces obscure some other geometry, it won’t even render what’s not seen. When alpha flags are set, transparent materials are exempt from this rule (i.e. other materials behind these faces are rendered) but are then subsequently overridden with alpha materials (can be a solid alpha throughout or an alpha map).
For this, transparent surfaces need to be processed and rendered last on the object only. This way other objects in front can obscure it, but the object itself cannot.
@@i3d3 Reminds me of how glitchy the cars in Mafia DE can be. Like instead of undercarriage, you get stretched out textures of ingame companies, or on the Bolt Mail Truck, you get this weird triangle on the left rear wheel that moves when you're driving, that is even present on it's cutscene model. or the broken texture on the Shubert Luxe Cab that's both in the interior and the running boards and it's bumpers, giving them a barcode and checked effect.
or the nonfunctional see through bumper mounted lights on the Culver Airmaster.
or the never ending starting noise on the Houston Coupe after you destroy the engine.
Or the glitched horn on the Shubert Six Police.
Or the messed up license plate on the Eckhardt Elite.
@@jbiehlable Sounds like Hanger 13 should shut down and cancel Maifa series because of this.
It's a 2020 game, yet Hanger 13 didn't bothered to give vehicles an undercarriage?
Watch_Dogs Legion have fully complete undercarriage, EVs even have warning stickers on the undercarriage, just like real life EVs.
I feel bad. Vadim wasn’t even done talking about the issues of the 360 and PS3 remaster of SA and a couple months later there’s an even more infamous remaster of *three* games
Bruh i just found out that the definitive edition remastered the mobile version instead of the original, lmfaooo im dead
For real?? 😂 I knew this definitive edition shit couldn't be trusted. R* disgusts me these days
who told you?
@@EdwardLopez2x There's literally a proof that the new definitive ports came from this mobile ports. Someone can trigger a button option selection on definitive just like on mobile where it starts after you play a new game.
its pretty sad to see how many adjustements the mobile port had when they were working on that compared to how lazily done this remasterd port is,
it basically tells you which one they had more faith/expectations in knowing will sell more copies
To be fair, the mobile version has everything to sell better than the console versions. There are certainly more people with phones than consoles, and most console players would rather get a new AAA game instead of an old one. Right now in my country GTA V is cheaper than this GTA SA remaster on the Microsoft Store. This is no excuse for the laziness though.
I remember watching your Dragon Ball Multiverse videos as a young kid lol
Yeah, War Drum is HORRIBLE. They had somewhat of a bad reputation, I doubt they worked on a console before and this is also kinda on Rockstar. Wouldn't QA testers catch the errors, at least one?
On android you can't even play it anymore since they wont update it to work with android 11
@DarkoMan64 • 16 years ago • 16 years ago i managed to rip the files and put it on my modded vita and it works great so I'm not going to seek a refund as i bought it years ago and still can use it, even if it's not on my phone lol
40 minutes? Gotta get some snacks! This will be one of the best videos I've seen this year!
I have popcorn at the ready
Did you love the second movie? (Which is this movie)
hold up, I'm going to buy some indomie
@@depressormk2afton54 indomie is the best😻
literally all of these bugs are in the definitive edition. Thanks Rockstar.
No?
@@extremegrief1525 They are. For example you can't put sirens on or off, gym issues aswell as various others.
@@callumclarke3458 no I have the game
@@callumclarke3458 at least no crashes, i played for 6 hours (cracked version too) and no crash. Also at least it plays well with widescreen monitors and morern operating systems.
@@extremegrief1525 For the few hours I got to play GTA 3 on pc it had a couple crashes. San Andreas seemed quite stable though and performed well despite the bugs
It's time for GTA Remastered 2: Electric Boogaloo
I always played on the remastered version being, so even seeing the difference in vegetation is crazy, me growing up thinking the desert is supposed to look like this in game
Deserts in America have more vegetation unlike deserts from the rest of the world
If you have an available PC, google for the full 1.0 version and look for some patches and PS2 version visual restores. You will be amazed by how dope the game looked in the OG versions
Should i feel bad for only being able to play the 360 version of the game i feel like i am losing so much after watching this video
this is really sad seeing younger generations getting screwed out of what we had growing up. san andreas is a legendary game and everyone should be able to enjoy the full experience no matter what platform they're playing on
@@cxeroannuki2840 i was able to play GTA San Andreas on PS2, and even though Mine was a modified version which had the first mission bugged and i was not able to progres, i spent lots of hours roaming Los santo
Bodes really well for the "new" "remakes", assuming they're not just ports of the mobile version too, of course...
don't jinx it!
From what we know, they'll be done in Unreal Engine (presumably UE4), so I'd imagine there will be all sorts of weirdness. After all, these remakes were still the GTA3/VC/SA engine.
I'd be surprised if they're flawless.
Samr
@@DarkPuIse dont even imagine it being so, R* nowdays only dissapoing
@@DarkPuIse lmao it's not a remake is just a simple remaster with hd textures probably remade with an AI. Why everyone taking it like it's a remake with rdr2 graphics lol.
Can’t wait to see this made about the trilogy games aswell.
Grove Street Games cannot make a good port, ever.
at least the controls seem to be non-simplified. there's a video of the intro mission, and the hint does say to hold x to accelerate and press it rapidly to speed up when getting on a bike
@@ArtyIF The gym minigame is the simplified version though
Called it, this is as bad as the Cyberpunk release.
Can't wait for you guys to tear apart the "definitive" edition
it's literally not bad... y'all are just Brats looking for something to complain about 🤦♀️
@@warriorgrl3076 I bet you thought Back 4 Blood was a definitive upgrade over Left 4 Dead. Also those lives do NOT matter*
If there's one thing Take-Two should've taken down instead of those mods, it's this remaster.
It's been 2 years already , and part 3 still didn't exist
Considering the first came out 4 years ago and the second one came out 2 years, I can assume it will come out this year.
15:00 well atleast they're polite enough to let you protect your turf
Insane how a game as big as this had its “remastered” release funneled so hard
It’s not insane . They know y’all will buy anything and only complain after . It’s basically saying u buy weed from em and they gave you spices from ya kitchen u ask for a refund and they never hit u back then only complain after this is basically how games do now . Y’all are gamers/addicts n buy anything if it’s a wave .
@@JaySantanaofficial lol not the truth people wanna hear, but damn well need to.
Ever heard of Warcraft III Reforged?
@@JaySantanaofficial The weed/spices from ya kitchen analogy is amazing.
This is that sequel you waited years unnanounced and when it finally released it's just as good as the original
"unannounced" It was said in the 1st video that there would be a part 2.
I bought some pizza.
It was announced like a week ago.
Blade Runner: 2049
I really appreciate that you went back and corrected/clarified some things near the end of the video. Good work!
Can't wait for the Definitive Edition version of this video...
This is why I'm not hyped about upcoming remasters, especially given that they will use Unreal Engine. It is more than certain that a lot of things will be broken or unavailable
Very true there even was an article saying that they will remove some of the more risky jokes and other elements to suit modern time's.
but it's made by a completely different studio so it could be very different from this
@@YGK- yes by R* Dundee, so they should hopefully have similar knowledge and quality to R* North, considering R* bought them and turned em into their Dundee office for UK
@@zombathon3370 That would be too much effort, that isn't goin to happen.
@@Nixton1996 muting radio stations and voice overs wouldn't be that hard at all and considering it will be made in a completely new engine I'd have to disagree with you.
You know the remastered version is hot garbage when he literally needed two 40 minute episodes to talk about the bad things
And thats not it, theres a 3rd part comming.
Literally
Cant wait for you to tear apart "definitive" edition as well once it comes out. That version gives me the same feeling of misguided approach of how to remaster classic game because from what I've seen it looks trash and uninspired compared to the og version.
And now the same people are making another "remaster". Rockstar just doesn't care.
@@TheMagicalMudkip2 nope it’s the same people who made this. we can only hope it’s better
@@TheMagicalMudkip2 It looks terrible, it just runs on a different engine that has stock shaders and effects that weren't supported back then. Even characters are still greasy like in mobile version.
@@Dr.Strangelewd don’t care still buying the trilogy
@@Unknown-56763 nobody cares
15:07
CJ: Hey, my hood is on hot, I need this vehicle.
FBI: Ok, CJ. You the man.
With the supposed rumors about the GTA Trilogy being remastered/remade soon, I am *afraid* to say the least.
I only hope for a gta 3 remake it deserves it for 20 year anniversary :(
Considering that this time Rockstar aren't out sourcing the work to other developers and are instead doing it in one of their own studios, i think we can expect the rockstar games quality we're used to
@@bz_animations Soooo, terrible quality?
@@tqu5759 Rockstar quality refers to the 20+ bangers Rockstar has released
@@tqu5759 what game has rockstar released that has poor quality tf?
For one second I read the tittle as "GTA SA - Remember Why is Garbage?"
I was about to send you a hitman.
Awesome channel dude can't wait to see part 3
The reason for not being able to swim faster in the console versions is due to the fact that, as you mentioned, in order to simplify swimming in the mobile version, you only hold the swimming button and can't swim faster by rapidly tapping or anything. Thus they ported the mobile version to consoles without adding that option to swim faster.
I seriously can’t believe there’s a part 2! This shows how bad the remaster really is
is this even real remaster???? cuz i dont remeber rockstar officially releasing remaster trilogy
@@yashraj1365 yes its real
@@Promuch971 wtf it literally looks like mobile version, tf is going on
@@yashraj1365 it came out a year after the mobile version, silently, on the Xbox 360 store, there was never an announcement, then they did the same thing for the PS3 version, deleted the original PS2 version to replace it for this shitty remaster, and I believe there are some physical copies of the remaster using the original box with the screenshots of the original.
Vice City, III and Liberty City Stories also have remasters but only for iOS and Android. IIRC those aren't as bad as the San Andreas remaster
@@santiagofranco4235 i see, thx for info
They choose Chad CJ to represent PS2 version
Yeah
To people in the comments, this video is NOT about the definitive edition in the gta trilogy, its about the 2014 ps3/xbox360 HD mobile port
Most of the issue listed here still exist in the "Definitive" version tho
@@illegalpic6814 yeah thats really fucked up, really terrible definitive edition
"developers had zero care for the quality of their product".... that's true for the most of the AAA titles released in today's time period as well
No its not. dont blame developers. Its managements doing 95% of the time they are the ones to blame. rushing games out before they are finished. devs just have to get the game as close to playable as they can before its ripped from their hands and thrown out to the market then take 90% of the blame. remember Rockstar management signed off on this version getting released.
disagree on that
Same with cold War which completely broke the hype for the new 'vanguard'
Bro what...
There are devs that still produce high quality products. Rockstar every 10 years, Ubisoft (except for unity they don't really have too many bugs or glitches in their games), Blizzard, Valve just to name a few.
Even if we had to wait nearly 2 years for this video, it absolutely was worth the wait
Your pfp is from burnout 3 isn’t it? Man of culture right here.
@@Gold171 correct
@@Gold171 that was the best burnout game I swear
@@rezcellent I’d say it’s a tie between revenge and 3
Ok, as a mobile player who have beaten the game 3 times now. I'm just gonna clear out the "Bailing out of the car" part at around 11:01. So to put it simply, it works differently like on the Original version. On the remastered version, you NEED to just tap it, holding the exit button will just stop your car like in the video. That's only on the mobile port, not sure about the others
That's true
This video will get a remaster.
More like a "DEFINITIVE" version.
See, this is why I'm holding my tongue with these NEW remasters that Rockstar are working on.
But rockstar didnt work on these, so - fingers crossed
Someone else is helping them
@@spiderklanblaze3124 damn
Yup
@@spiderklanblaze3124 Rockstar dundee did the new remasters, it's a strictly Rockstar project
I had GTA SA on ps2 and i remember aggressive drivers being a thing. When you hit some npcs car they chsse you down as revenge, I remember this clearly happening alot
APHEX TWIN??
@@frstwhsprs Richard Deeznuts James
@@TotinosOtherBoy He cares even if you dont!
It happens on the mobile version as well.
@@CDRW24 even in pc too
The fact the definitive edition now uses the mobile version mini game too. No spamming buttons, no difficulty, just hit A when the time is right. £60 for a shitty mobile port. Anybody else miss when R* made good games and weren’t just a cash grab company??
Rockstar still does make good games, they didn't make the remaster.
@@ayyLumao They outsourced it to a shitty company that makes mobile games. They’ve even left in a ton of code from the mobile remasters, all this is is a shitty port on new engine. R* used to put love and passion into their projects and now they just get it done as quick as possible for as cheap as possible
@@MrSapperb3 They still didn't make the game, GTA SA's original remaster was also incredibly bad, yet afterwards Rockstar went on to make the amazing PS4/XB1/PC versions of GTA V, and RDR2.
@@ayyLumao But they’re responsible and could’ve easily made the game! You’re just being difficult on purpose here 🥴 they are more than capable of making good games yet they choose a developer who have already fucked up R* games in the past to carry this out too
@@MrSapperb3 I'm not being difficult, you're just acting as if them outsourcing the port like they almost always do/have suddenly makes them incapable of making a good game.
Aaaaannnnnddddd the SA Footage from australia looks to use the mobile version. That gym minigame, the forklift is binary up and down, bicycles seems to go 100% speed and finally Autoclimb is in the options.
When you're at the barber shop, Cj will automatcly exit the shop after changing his haircut unlike pc/ps2 versions where He stays sit in the chair untill you press the button to exit yourself
Not true on ps2 he will auto exit barbershop
Yeah that's pretty frustrating
I remember I accidentally managed to see firefighters putting out a fire on the remaster and it felt so weird because you don't ever see them in this version
I saw them putting out a fire on pc before they removed songs from the radio station.
You should include the definitive edition lol
anyone waiting for the part 3?
33:06
"What?"
"Oh, just ballas trying to kill me."
Literally today I found out there was a remastered version of this game, but I’m glad I was never aware of it nor have I ever played it. Ill stick to my ps2 version
The PS2 version (and its original PS2 classics port on PS3) are hands down the best versions of the game. PC port and this new remaster might have better resolution, but that's pretty much it. When you play the PS2-version like it was originally intended to be played, with a smaller CRT television instead of a 60" 4k flatscreen, the smaller textures and lower resolution do not matter, but then you have all the cool effects and lighting that gave the original version its own atmosphere and hid its graphical shortcomings. PC port and this new remastered version look hideous and cold, as if everything is plastic.
I own standard ps4 version
@@dragoontype00alphaz19 it's PS2 emulated
@Cody Hess I hope this is true. I hope they do a legit remaster like remapping controllers. As with everything else I won't believe it to be true unless Rockstar games says that it is true.
if you want to enjoy the best version you can pirate the game
Aight who’s ready for the next bad remaster vid with the definitive edition?
November 11th 2021
"Awe shit! Here we go again..."
This is why the idea of a remastered GTA trilogy doesnt excite me. Im afraid they will find a away to fck it up.
It's even worse, given to how Rockstar have threatened legal action against modders for trying to fix their broken PC ports.
@@Megaspartan23 Correction: while R* may have been involved in this, it's mainly the parent company Take Two. R* as far as we're concerned is pretty lenient with the modding scene.
I hope they don’t hire war drum studios to work on it war drum made the San Andreas port shit
@@JayCeeCreates Yeah R* never minded mods, Take2 took action to delete big graphic mods for 3d trilogy but probably only because they'd contradict with their remaster.
@@Deadchannel1737 nah they’re using the same team that helped with the halo remasters so we’re good at least until they come out
If you told me that the “Enhanced” edition was the Alpha/Beta version of GTA SA on PS2 I would believe you.
Ahaha and the ironic thing bout that is i bet the actual beta was still better than both 1st version and remastered version
It s so bad it should be omega
@@anthonys904 beta and cut contents are generally better and more interesting than their final release
@@anthonys904 this “remaster” crawled so Definitive Edition could bolt.
Is it me or just rockstar just updated the remastered version and presented as the definitive edition.
You are correct
Its actually just the mobile version
I believe you're right, there are a ton of very specific bugs and quirks in the definitive edition that point to it basically being the same game with improved textures and lighting
Ya they should have used the ps2 version or maybe even the xbox original version.
Grove Street Studios was given TWO CHANCES to do this right… AND FUMBLED BOTH
The amusing thing about the various props on the map (breakable trees, rocks etc.) is that as a SAMP player, you practically never see them anyways as they're not part of the map over there.
I have been playing SAMP for 5 odd years and I forgot that the game even had those details in, I started thinking that the game map was always this empty and bland.
This applies to a lot of the other small details aswell (blurry screen when speeding, heat effect etc.)
yeah me too man i havent played singleplayer in years
I can only imagine how fantastic this game could be remastered if a good mod team had access to the code.
There is already a ton of mods for the pc version that makes the game work a lot better.
@@TommyTom21 Can u recommend any mods? I bought the steam version but couldnt move properly ingame, but never found a good fix
@@SweetyMitSchnabel silent patch
Recently they announced they would remaster the classic GTA games, as well as Red Dead Redemption, and seeing the success of remasters/remakes in recent years from Yakuza to Resident Evil to Diablo II, it seems very likely it will be really good
@@hushamfusion Nothing has been officially announced as of yet by Rockstart though, its speculation for the moment. And if their previous remasters have been anything but 'good' so I will be cautiously optimistic. Remastering something like san andreas is a particular can of worms that would require quite some investment if they want to do it right.
With the new release, Rockstar keeps giving this guy content mine for life.
12:27 This change really annoys me with the forklift because there’s absolutely no reason that CJ should have to raise the forklift ALL the way up just to pick up a box, and then slowly put it back down. He should just be able to pick it up a little bit off the ground, then set it back down. There’s no need to raise the boxes that high. The whole thing takes twice as long because of it.
Was this change in the mobile version of VCS?
Yes, I'm looking at you, Boomshine Blowout.
@@scoundrel8440 Yeah it was
@@scoundrel8440 you mean the PSP version?
I remember when i played the mobile version, some peds on the street would have an invisible lower part of their body and look like they're floating, i think the bug corrects itself when you punch or run them over but i'm not exactly sure
This bug has been fixed in version 2.00
There is, another worst annoying bug, where peds or vehicles are flickering when you see on a far distance where they are supposed to spawn. Unlike on the originals, they spawn smoothly. There is your remastered.
Vadim M, what I’ve experienced in the remaster is the gunshot sounds are a lot more compressed than in the original version.
I think compressed sounds in general were covered in first part of the vid
@@user-fs8rn4cb6c True but not the gunshot part tho
@@JonnyTheRWBYDude2004 Gunshots are still SFX, which were mentioned in the first video. :P
Yet more disgruntled effort from porting from a mobile platform.
This has me very worried about the upcoming trilogy release.
Same. Cautiously optimistic about the incoming trilogy but absolutely will be waiting until after release and reviews to see if I will pick it up or if its broken like this game.
I actually found that War Drum Studios is known as Grove Street Games