A very sound and clear thinking strategist. No hype, no nationalistic fervor. Just pure logic. I hope India will listen to Pravin. Then there will be no war between India and China.
As we people from north east india we like China, right now we can't compete to China, We have to cooperate with China is very important right now for our countries infrastructure development and modernization . Even USA can't compete with China in terms of infrastructure development right now, how can we !
I like Indian people and I have lots of Indian friends. It would be a bigger win for India and China if Indian government is willing to collaborate with China. China does not want war with any countries.
Pravin. Thank you for educating your audience on these actual facts despite the pressure you would get from those that doesn't want the truth and facts. History books would/should record and credit you.
A very important reality check of the situation on the Sino- Indian border contrary to the media reports.Situation has become much more complex and dangerous for India
Very true , Even China and Russia had dispute few decades ago and they are now the both super power best allies , India is egoistic , Ignorant , Proud but incapable and racist even among their minorities and more ever most India didn't monitor or ban their social media for provoking in internet especially RW , First Post and HT , All these provoking media will make the whole world get hated and down grade India , India choose to become a spiting cobra instead of an up coming Serpent in Asia by being close allies with the west .
As a Vietnamese, I'm hoping that both India and China must settle this (in the grand scheme of things) little border dispute difference! I'm not picking a side, but allow me to make some observations here: 1. China does not want war with India, period. 2. It's more of the India's side that is beating the drum of war, and I suspect the West is encourging this too 3. Modi is just not as honest as Xi, period 4. India mass media is propagandizing this "conflict" to drum up a war, which is never a good thing 5. the dispute terriroty, ultimately, means very little for both China and India 6. India trying to take on China and Pakistan is even worse than the US trying to take on Russia and China 7. in the eyes of the global south nations, they see India as the troublemaker right now, not China 8. China is firmly committed to Russia in an "unlimted partnership" to combat the Western hegemony, and what does Modi do? go kiss Biden. This is not good in the eyes of the global south. 9. Ultimatly, India must remember that, despite their border dispute with China, the biggest raper of India is the Anglos, not the Chinese. India must remember that siding with the Anglos will be seen by the global south as a traitor. India must remember that their energy and raw material needs, it's geography, is deeply tied with the global south, not with America or Europe. It is mindboggling that Modi would lead India down the geopolitical path that he is leading. I'm a Vietnamese and I support all Asian country that stand up to Western hegemony, but as soon as that Asian country conspire with the West, then I'm sorry that is where I will stop. Asia is done with colonialism, let's not turn to these colonists for help with our neighbor disputes, ok. Mr Pavin's analyse of the China-India situaiton is RIGHT ON!!! Replace Modi with Pravin and the China-India conflict will be solved virtually overnight. Mr Pavin is a deep longterm strategic thinker, he cares for the longterm well-being of India. Modi, on the other hand, is turning out to be a Western tool much like Zelensky of Ukraine.
No one talk about bad things of India in China and no media is advocating anything against India. In India, opposite is true. I believe there are too much internal problem of India so that the politician and intellectual are handling the situation in a proved traditional way. To Godify the leader (Modi is god), to promise an eternal happy life in the future (tell ordinary people India will be the super power in the world without details), and most of all to unify people and divert their attention away from the problem they could not handle. ( in the form of a powerful enemy). This is what I believe directing the behaviors of Indian leaders. But people should take lessons from the history. China's Chairman Mao did this and failed.
Yes , All these politician bastard wanted to created hatred between India and China in order to get voted again , That's why India never ban those provoking media like RW , First Post and HT . Don't forget that Russia and China dispute for many decades and now they are the 2 most powerful best allies in the world , Going against China is an enemy with Russia .
Jaishankar's entire family is settled outside India and have given up Indian citizenship. He is doing what he has to do to keep his job as minister. Smart man.
Pakistani don't grow up, 😂😂 Forian Manister is big thing, even in India if you are government employee you can not have double citizenship, leave it for applying you need to be only Indian citizenship. 😂😂😂😂
@@GeneralInfoSystem 🤣🤣🤣 Ye fuddu bs conspiracy theories bna rha h.. Isko lagta Pakistan k politicians aur generals australia me island lete h retirement k baad to hindustan me bhi aisa hi hota hoga🤡🤡🤡 Dr. Jayshankar ki wife Japanese h.. Wo Japan me bahot time tk ambassador rhe h.. Aur sochne wali baat h.. Agar indian citizenship na ho to india me External n foreign affairs Minister bn hi nhi skte. 🤷♂️🤷♂️ Chaho to Google kr lo😉😉
@@debasismohanty1952 ye fuddu abdul bol rha h Dr jayshankar ne indian citizenship chor kr kissi aur country ku citizenship li huyi h.. Jaise pakistani pm London se operate krte h aur pakistani generals retirement k baad America aur australia settled ho jate h😜😜😜 Bajwa ka ek beta Paris me h aur ek dubai me🤭🤭
Why India is so adamant ? And always playing the angelic american way. We need to maintain a peaceful and healthy relationship with our neighbours with a priority to build and strengthen our nation
Jaishankar is no doubt a very witty man. But his too egoistic -- thinking too highly of himself, and exploiting every opportunity to boost his personal image and ego. Part of the India-China problem is made a lot worse by India joining the QUAD, willingly becoming a lapdog of the USA. China is thus compelled to make it known to India in no uncertain terms that this opportunistic siding of the USA has to come at a price!
Or China India is a small player with outdated tech. Unless we are willing to spend on tech China will always have an upper hand. Make in India will take a long time to produce strategic weapons. Relying on Israel and America is foolish strategy.
Such an informative and educational insight! Thanks so much, Sir Pravin. As a Cambodian, I must also say that both India and China are time-tested century-old friends of Cambodia. Our most sincere desire is these two giants are in good sincere term with each others and cooperate with each other for the interest of people of both nations and the world. God bless India and God bless China, and God bless Cambodia. Amen.
It is common view by Indian geopolitical analysts that a mini conflict between India and China will benefit India. What Jaishankar said is this very tactic that India is using to boost their status in the world.
I thought of the same but that will never be allowed. We the citizens have to decide upon the merits of the govt's statements n those like him who can keep a clear conscience n tick off lies n miscalculations, until one day, when it will be too late.
I do not understand why India keeps behaving in a way that does little or nothing to resolve the Border Issue. Since Nehru's agreement with Zhou EngLai on the border issue, India has been consistently renagading on her promises...either by not honouring what has been agreed or distorting the agreement for domestic consumption. Doesn't India realise that if there is this constant huge distraction, she cannot fully focus on her domestic development plans??? Besides she will be manipulated by foreign anti-China forces to create an even bigger dispute between the nations! For example......US has persuaded India to train with US forces around the border region!!! Now how can this be in any way beneficial towards creating an amicable relation with China??? Against such an attitude how does anybody expect China not to react!!!? And so ...the border issue remains a thorn between them.
We are fired by bragging shamelessly. We are geo politically an important country, no doubt about that but we lack nobility n dont know what is modesty. Hyped up filmy status is what we're charged with, just like the our trash TV serials.
These two countries need to settle their border. The fight is ridiculous. They fight over land that has practically no inhabitants, no traffic value, no historical or emotional value, no minerals. They argue over border that is not settled because nobody was there until the armies showed up. They are wasting resources and attention of the governments. The issue is poisoning relationship between the two countries so that they cannot cooperate to solve problems of common interest. I would like to hear someone explaining why this land is so important.
Thanks for doing an honest analysis, Dr. Sawhney. You are correct in calling Mr. Jayshankar's failure and untruthful statements. This man will leave his post in a couple of years, but the damage he has done will stay with the people of India for years to come. Therefore, there was no need for the August 5, 2019 action; Mr. Modi's shortsighted approach and Mr. Jayshankar and Mr. Doval's incompetence will cost India a couple of trillion dollars in the next three decades of misappropriating resources to support flawed policy.
Hello, Pakistan will breakup earlier than 1 to 1 1/2 Yrs., which will save India at least 1 - 2 Trillion Dollars. China's economy is down at least 5 - 10 % & in all probability start breaking-up in 2 Yrs. & total break up in about 7 - 9 Yrs. U pakistanis are fit only for day-dreaming with empty stomach. Just one Yr.; may be even less. Keep Ur mouth SHUT & just wait & watch.
@@chandrashekaragupta8628 Hahahahaha, wait, I guess Pakistanis will take half of India in the Indian Ocean with them if they drown. Stop living with delusions.
India has a border with Tibet not China . China has illegally occupied Tibet who is socio culturally ,political a different entity who are religious and who wanted to remain Independent.
Boss what is your logic here - You are saying China, because they formed a large army ( which is incapable to a large extent no matter how much a hype they want to showcase ) has the right to bring in their army to borders and break any agreement at will and that’s why Jaishankar is wrong in stating China broke the agreement .. ? Great logic
The very fact that the Chinese created the western command means they had started amassing soldiers against India. This dude brushes that off as just the PLA's restructuring. Like I said before this dude is full of hatred for India for a failed Army career. I see dudes who failed miserably in India all over the world, who become venomously anti Indian.
@@bsobro - then why have rules based order, UN, or courts, justice.. throw away all that .. let’s take all island nations, invade whosoever we like to.. nuke any country we like to ..
@@AzamSheikh We don't do that in India, unlike in some countries where everyone with a different opinion is a Raaaw agent 😁. He is just a disgruntled old man, with a failing Magazine business and skewed and pessimistic world view of his own.
Time to resolve all issues and make our countries rich so people get good life . India Pakistan and China should come together. Modi cannot do this because of Rss. Message from Pakistan
PM modi dont have any need to such kind of silly things .Do you people produce lot of crude oil like saudi arabia so that you would be able to supply india ?do you people produce so much rare earth minarel like china so that you would be able to support indias electronic industry?Do you people produce lot of semi conducter like taiwan so that you would be able to support the information technology industry of india?do you people produce lot of edible oil like ukrain so that you would be able to supply india for house hold use ?Do you people have advanced space tech like usa so that you would be able to support our space mission ?do you people advance wepons like france and russia so that you people would be able to support indian armed forcess with your wepons ?just give one reason for which pm modi will come together with pakistan?He is the prime minister of 130 crore people of india .Have 200 other countries to manage .Managing the whole globe is not a small thing.if tomorrow rahul gandhi became pm then still the things will be remain unchanged.Friendship always happend among equals.In 1947 both the countries were liberated together .Today african countries are requesting to our pm to forgive their loans worth of 12 billion dollars .on the pakistani pm is very happy after reciving the promise for 9 billion dollars flood relief from international community.Today 1 indian currency is equal to 3 pakistani rupees .if we will say that to the normal pakistanis fighting for wheat that look if you will join to india then not only the value of your properties will enhance to 300 percent overnight but also every your single rupee you have will turned into three rupees then at least half of pakistan living out side the punjab would beready to join india .It seems crazy but thats how west have suceeded to convince the germans from east germany to merge with west germany.china is also weponising their currency against the taiwan to turn the public opinion of taiwan in favour of chineese communist party by
Pakistan has nothing to do with it. It is a failed state with radicalized Islamist society. It is gonna be next Syria of Asia. If we would want economic framework with China.. It would include Bangladesh instead.
How do you know that the Chinese are occupying 2000 sq km of new Indian territory since 2020 ? Ex Army chief General Naravane clarified that the PLA has been moved back to the LAC at all 7 points.
Sir, ye banda jhoot pe jooth bole Jaa rha he. Ye banda pehle army me hi tha but iski kaali kartooto ki vjh se iska court Marshall hua hai.. aur ab ye ek jehadi ladki ke saath milke ye saare kaam krta hai. Like journalism Krna, secularism promotion Krna aur dusri countries ka agenda chlana
The big statement i am going to make is this.. Aside from LAC.. What HOSTILITIES has India reacted to China in compared with what Hostilities China has reacted to India? Did India join an organisation called Quad to deal with China? Did China joined any organisation to deal with India? Did India keep poking into Taiwan issue? How often did China poke into Kashmir issue? Did India block Chinese apps , Hiawei etc? Did China block anything from India? ANSWER THAT TRUTHFULLY...then anyone will know why the LAC cannot be resolved.. Who is the real Hostile one?
Not any worse then being called "piss drinkers" by the whole world and China kicking your ass! We like watching this from the sidelines. The tea is ready by the way! Your agony is our joy!
Sir, you must be very strongly PRO-CHINA ! Say, how many times India should continue Negotiation? DO you really believe that it is Chine who does not show any interest in Northern boarder?
So much for the hate of Narender Modi......the Indian Army is wrong......the FM Jaishanker is wrong.......the people of India are wrong and specifically don't have the MOJO to stand up against China. This guy even made a pariah of China and Shi Jing Ping (the bear)......lol. Don't know what the presenters background is.......but seems he is on the payrolls of Chinese PLA and specifically for senior people like these today India is at such a disadvantage with loosing territory in 1962 and maybe even later on. I would invite the presenter to tag along with me and let's visit some Chinese villages together to know the ground truth on both sides of the border or so called Line Of Control ( And Sir your security is on me and my village friends). With my upbringing all across the NE region of India......who more can know what and how the Chinese think and act. Chinese are into active defence and fight in enemy territory.......my foot.....these PLA troops doesn't have the stomach to see blood.....let alone fight in Himalayan heights. China can only fire missiles and shells from a distance or from the air.......but to conquer territory u need boots on the ground. And Sir.....what do you think......leave aside the India army......you think the people of the NE India will sit quite and seek peace with the Chinese. Are you aware our Naga Brothers keep the enemies skull as trophy with them.....and you think China will send troops to face US.......pfff. Today the whole country and related lack of development/s are largely because of poor/self inflicting wounds policy followed by Jawaharlal Nehru/Congress/Mahatma Gandhi/etc and people like you during the last 70 odd years. Had Netaji been at the helm of affairs we would have seen a different India with our head held high always. Pls at this age all these bigotemy doesn't suit you even if it means for you to stay relevant. Jai Hind.
While I found the observations interesting, a word of advice. At some point (12min 40sec) you mention an observation shared with you by an army commander. I respectfully suggest that observations made in private and in confidence should not be attributed by name to anyone. The other party should remain anonymous, unless their consent was obtained to name them.
we indians are the decendents of the maurian emperor samrat asoka .we belive in vijaya through dharmik means but not without compromising the capabilities needed for yuddha vijay
@@coconutpunch123 in that case Pakistan will be stand by with the Western powers as a pakistani I can confirm that because West needs Pakistan to neutralize any riseup in asia for their own interests
@@coconutpunch123 Britain partitioned India. Subjects must obey their masters. Therefore, India is allowed only to fight China, never mind Pakistan. Dalai Lama belongs to India, and so does Tibet. India must go to war with China and take back Tibet. Because British left Tibet to India, when a master left something with its subject, the subject must fight to death to keep it.
Where did you get the information that Chinese were already there illegally. This is a wrong premise. He seems to be doing to highlight Chinese to be superior to Indian defence strengths.
China May be big country with world’s largest Army .And richest country.Does it makes country strong militarily The strength of it military is proved in-terms of winning a war .not it’s numbers .Perhaps Chinese Army is one of the weakest armies .Their Will to fight is questionable .Indian Army is battle hardened force .Allied power would not have won 2nd WW but for Indian Army..You seem to be a Congress spokes person to run down our foreign policy and Army..Please remember this not Nehru era ,when military and foreign policy blunder resulted in losing 1962 war
why you pakistanis are feeling so much happy. He is saying about the over estimated chineese capabilities .Not about pakistani capabilities .It seems that you people have actually started to thinking yourself as chineese ,not pakistani.some times you people claimed mohammad bin kasim as the first pakistani.some times imran khan claimed the ertugal as the show on your ancestors ,some times you people claimed the remins from sikh empire as the ancient pakistan. some times you people claime jinnah as the baba e quam,it seems that you people have lot of confusion about the origins of your gather ,grand father ,great grand father and other ancestors.probably your mothers have not told you people who was the father of your race .not knowing about the father of the children is a normal thing for prostitutes
I just don't understand why Modi and other defense experts are WASTING their time and resources to study china and its moves, if they only ask Mr. Pravin Shawney about the next move of Chinese I am sure they will save so much on military resources. This guys has so much inside information about Chinese. GURU on china. 😂😂😂
Good Morning General Pravain Excellent explanation. If possible- kindly if you can explain with the maps and names of place etc. would give the best understanding. thanks
@@blackswan6963 He has more intelligent and analytic skills than all Indian generals combined who had been invited by PLA touring military compounds and setups in China in the past years.
MR lam.....Generals when visiting MILITARY AREAS abroad are supposed to absorb things, presented to them...and what they can discern otherwise !! Nobody makes the mistake of showing their analytical skills....bad manners, and bad diplomacy ! You seem to have a shortage of Generals with such skills......you are welcome to borrow PRAVIN FOR THE SAME...on second thought may like to keep him with you permanently....what are friends for !!
Couple of questions: 1. How do you know what the Chinese side was/were thinking? 2. How is violation LAC agreement any different from crossing over LAC and occupying area. 3. India also says there should be peaceful relations with China and Pakistan. How is it any different from when Chinese leaders are saying that. 4. Why is Chinese non-acceptance of Cartographic modifications so sacrosanct when the borders themselves are not agreed upon. However I do agree that the Chinese bogey card is overplayed and that its military strategy and equipment is far superior, notwithstanding opinion of experts/analysts.
While you have few questions, lemme share one observation and ask a question to you. On 20th August 2020, in Russia there was a press conference where Jaishankhar was present. It was supposed to be a joint press conference, but only China's points were shared in the press conference. Neither did Jaishankhar protest or say anything and was silent. In fact, they have shared bits of that on the MEA website but there is no official press release of the entire thing, why so ???
I hope you answer it, that actually made China's stand much more stronger. And this is before the Chinese-Russian friendship thing happened, that statement was over a month later, September 2020 onwards.
China's goodwill makes Indians believe that they can be unscrupulous. Senior Indian officials know China's strength, so they retreat after every provocation, and China also preserves India's face.
Mr.Pravin Sawhney are you doing the video at the behest of Chineese ? You always talk in favour of China !! You always talk about India getting defeated in case of War. Yes economically speaking, War is not welcome. I never heard you saying Chineese violet LAC given differing perceptions. First you answer when Chineese are vacating occupied 2000 sq.kilometer ???? Yes you are right about Indian Military ' s exclusive focus on Pakistan neglecting north-eastern Chineese Border. Govt. since 1971 missed opportunity to widen chicken neck substantially in consultation with Bangladesh & that was possible.This strategy like that of POK after surrender of Pak Army when India could have leveraged POK as J&K is inseparable part of India. I admit our people lack foresight and long term strategic plan. According to you Xi deserve Noble Peace Prize.
He talks about the Eastern problem where India occupies an area that China claims. There is also a Western problem where China occupies an area that India claims. It seems nobody knows the whole story.
But what sawhney will never quote about is AK Anthony statement in parliament about the pathetic state of infrastructure in the indo china border prior to 2014 so the present government is having a fire 🔥 fighting exercise trying to do its best to overcome the existing weakness 🤔
Uh, my brother dont waste your time, dont you feel he does nothing but gathers Pakistani audience? he is the only person you can listen to without pain in your ears Acc. to this man whatever Indian does, whatever action the India govt. or military takes is wrong and is eventually going to cost India Just listening to pleasant things which susuitour taste not gonna help. reality is India is rapidly growing economy, Global player which world recognizes and Pakistan is just 📉
There is another reality is that 18.000 Indian people have applied for asylum seeker just in one year 2022 . It is a huge figure for a smallest country like Austria , what about another 27 European states ? I guess there must be a number of people trying to get asylum on behalf of that India is not a safer country
One should NOT forget salami slicing tactics. It is naive not to take it seriously. Do not forget regular encouragement given to Pakistan to create tensions within India. Wonder how these experts forget that Chinese Communist Party is driven by a take two steps forward one step back. Leave aside these agreements that are treated with convinience rather than honour. The question is WHY do you want to build such military build up unless it has ugly plan. It is ok for China to build up in questionable areas while when India does it it is foul!! Get real and balanced and look at geopolitics. Pakistan has been used as a proxy for a long time as it gets paid to do so.
I agree with pravin sir on Jaishankar telling the world, china tried to change border status quo in 2020 when in reality chinese already grabbed some 2000 sq km indian and still sitting on it. I don’t understand why indian forces left doklam plateau when the chinese troops are still there. Jaishankar should tell the truth on situation on chinese border instead of covering up for his boss Modi.
Abbye mister bean, funny fellow is that old idiot measure the land saying 2000sqkm, at the old age he lost the brain don't be so happy . Bean will be knocked down soon. 🤣🤣🤣
Well! If he tells the truth then Mr Modi is no Demi god and BJP might loose face … enough to be kicked out of power in 2024 … so no , he can’t tell the truth!
Where the fuck is the proof of this land occupation Such a thing without war means a complete collapse of the indian line so again where is the proof of that collapse??
@@Pop23ygcxdrtyhbnniyeesd where is the proof indians still holding to pre April 2020 LAC line in ladakh? Are indians still in control of finger 4 till finger 8 areas in pango lake ? Can indians patrol pt 14,15,16 & 17 areas in depsang?
Absolutely baseless things you are mentioning sir, first of all your whole argument is based on media facts which you said in the starting and surprisingly you are believing those reports over what our Foreign minister, Military chief defence chief are saying . So according to you all of them are wrong and what media is saying is correct. Secondly you are blaming the current government as if the relations with china were very sweet before that. Let me remind you that we had a war with them in 1962 and it was that because of that government that India is still lagging behind in military equipments as compared to china. In your whole argument you tried to show that India is an agresser and the Chinese are very innocent, I mean you are talking about some another universe, leave behind Aksai chin ,doklham ,etc ,China doesn't even let India to declare Mazhood Azar freed through a plan hijack a worldwide terrorist in UN by using veto powers and then you say China wants south asia as India china what bull shit sir, they don't even say Indo Pacific they always profect pacific Asia , and what the hell have they been doing in Indian ocean ,they even tried to mock India in covid with dead bodies burning pictures and it were people like you who were greedy enough to make money through that pictures on social media. These are very few things I mentioned how could you even think in that way about china. They even claimed friendship before 1962. Still if you think India is an agresser what about taiwan, phillipines etc and what about chinese built a whole road and exploiting the natural resources in POK which is in Indian territory. Lastly and most importantly you said that this will lead us to a war and we will loose , I doubt if you are an Indian or you might be a congress mouthpiece I think they propaganda people do these type of things. You could have said that China is far more advanced with weapons and India is on road to development so war is not a good idea because it will come with a heavy price of lives and development or may something else but very clearly said we cannot win from China. Rediculous and baseless arguments you have put sir.
Indian economy is not in a position for a war against China. A full war require 50000 crores per day. The Tibet region is a cold desert. We can not be aggressive against China. Even if we loose 100 square kms no problem crores of Indians will suffer in war, which is important. Jayasankar is doing it . See what happened to Pakistan economy due to military while Bangladesh is growing.
This is called constructive discussion which is lacking in ur country. It’s better to learn from it and apply on your country rather than pointing fingers on others.
You have tried to make your story different and spicy. What about China transgressing sitting and going back on our territory prior to Doklam.? You are obsessed with Pak and China.
@sam123sder ok - let us just agree for arguments sake that you are correct. why would a country put such restrictions on itself for no reason ? can you give me an answer if Kashmir is an integral part of India then so is Uttar pradesh - why does Uttar pradesh not have something like article 370. now I want you to think carefully and do proper research and not just give me made up facts and then answer this after a careful thought of the reason.
You said US & China Dialogue Will put India in Difficult Condition After that Pelosi visited And after US China meet Latest German MP in Taiwan nothing happened you are predecting Some thing happening after 20 years . According to you Pak Economic crises is Bad to India & if Pak in better economy than also Bad so What happens in this Galaxy is bad for India This is Suppeerr analysis Keep it up
The problem is India has a chip on its shoulder in its relationship to China. It always wanted to be the leader and hegemon of Asia but just cannot beat China in every aspect. It has the National idea, like USA, of exceptionalism. It feels that it is the best race and country, and by divine right should be the top dog in Asia.
Critical analysis. Hattsoff Praveen ji. It's not that a hard nosed Modi of bare-it-all Jaishankar don't know the mind of Xi Jin Ping. Jaishankar is diplomatic, Modi is too strong to display his weakness of accepting ceding land to Chinese, neither his deputies are in a position to call truth.
@@tigerking2742 This man is impossible, his basic premise is 'since he said and she said', if media reports are to be believed or what his handlers are claiming, he is not a field reporter and doesn't run any organization that collects authentic information from original sources. He constantly whines about why GOI not telling this and that. Even the average joe would understand the secrecy any govt maintains while dealing with a complex geo-political situation, you don't want to play into the hands of your enemy. In an all-out war, every front is important you cover every front, every infantry line including mediabazi. This mediabazi has attained great importance in the information war. Hopefully, he shall learn the elementary guidelines of the new age war.
Praveen Sawhney’s perspective is based on: 1. China is the dominant power ad infinitum & India agrees to be subordinated to China by hyphenating China-india- with other south asian countries. 2. Sawhney’s belief that china can dominate frontier areas at their “ will”, smacks of his deep rooted disgruntled resentment as a former indian army officer. 3. Whilst the diplomats of India hv a record in promoting & justifying Chinese propagada & Chinese interpretations (just like Sawhney), Jaishanker has unambiguous clarity & whilst Modi/Doval were caught in their own ego wrap, post Ladakh/Galwan, these 2 hv done a course correction. 4. In Any future conflict with China, India’s Victory will be to”deny a Chinese Victory”. 5. Sawhney’s consistent diatribe against Gen Navarrane is distasteful especially since this General has stood his ground well against the Chinese as well our own govt without compromising India’s military options & has achieved tactical suprise in the domain of operations. 6. The Chinese occupation of 2000+ sq km of indian territory in Ladakh is the result of India’s multi Agency border management folly, As well as Doval’s meddling in military matters which is not his domain of specialisation though Modi entrusts all defence issues to his NSA which is Modi’s biggest folly (nxt only to nehru with Menon). 7. Sawhney & the Congress are of one accord. That india should tamely aquiese & surrender to Chinese interests by bartering territory to avoid a war which india cannot win. Its a warped thought process of the insane & the sulllied. ⚓️⚔️🇮🇳
Any interview with Jaishankar, you can summarise as follows:
India is an angel and will do no wrong.
india/indians are far from angels i can tell you that much lol...
@@allfd2414 the above comment was sarcasm
More than that he would have said Modi is the greatest statesman of all rtime
Indiato the westerners is an angel and China is the devil.
@@allfd2414 Dude where are you in Pakistan from ?
A very sound and clear thinking strategist. No hype, no nationalistic fervor. Just pure logic. I hope India will listen to Pravin. Then there will be no war between India and China.
China has been very patience with India but India treat this as a weakness by China and take advantage.
Patience has its limits.
Well informed & intelligent. Very different from other indian news channels.
Yes he is opposition party stooge no one takes him serious,he will not speak how much China occupied in 1962 war
As we people from north east india we like China, right now we can't compete to China, We have to cooperate with China is very important right now for our countries infrastructure development and modernization . Even USA can't compete with China in terms of infrastructure development right now, how can we !
I like Indian people and I have lots of Indian friends. It would be a bigger win for India and China if Indian government is willing to collaborate with China. China does not want war with any countries.
Pravin. Thank you for educating your audience on these actual facts despite the pressure you would get from those that doesn't want the truth and facts. History books would/should record and credit you.
A very important reality check of the situation on the Sino- Indian border contrary to the media reports.Situation has become much more complex and dangerous for India
india is a horribly mis-managed country, its always been the case. Then, hasn't India always been in a dangerous situation?
Jaishankar comes across as a fearless man. Hope his attitude pays off for India.
So do you believe know that india hand over 2000 square KM area to china😎?
@@zeeshansyed6290 Yes.. And it's called saksham valley.. It was ceeded to China in 1960s..u should read about it😉😉✌🏼
@@zeeshansyed6290 that happened post 1962 war
Thank you for providing a realistic situation of the India-China conflict.
Very true , Even China and Russia had dispute few decades ago and they are now the both super power best allies , India is egoistic , Ignorant , Proud but incapable and racist even among their minorities and more ever most India didn't monitor or ban their social media for provoking in internet especially RW , First Post and HT , All these provoking media will make the whole world get hated and down grade India , India choose to become a spiting cobra instead of an up coming Serpent in Asia by being close allies with the west .
As a Vietnamese, I'm hoping that both India and China must settle this (in the grand scheme of things) little border dispute difference! I'm not picking a side, but allow me to make some observations here:
1. China does not want war with India, period.
2. It's more of the India's side that is beating the drum of war, and I suspect the West is encourging this too
3. Modi is just not as honest as Xi, period
4. India mass media is propagandizing this "conflict" to drum up a war, which is never a good thing
5. the dispute terriroty, ultimately, means very little for both China and India
6. India trying to take on China and Pakistan is even worse than the US trying to take on Russia and China
7. in the eyes of the global south nations, they see India as the troublemaker right now, not China
8. China is firmly committed to Russia in an "unlimted partnership" to combat the Western hegemony, and what does Modi do? go kiss Biden. This is not good in the eyes of the global south.
9. Ultimatly, India must remember that, despite their border dispute with China, the biggest raper of India is the Anglos, not the Chinese. India must remember that siding with the Anglos will be seen by the global south as a traitor. India must remember that their energy and raw material needs, it's geography, is deeply tied with the global south, not with America or Europe.
It is mindboggling that Modi would lead India down the geopolitical path that he is leading.
I'm a Vietnamese and I support all Asian country that stand up to Western hegemony, but as soon as that Asian country conspire with the West, then I'm sorry that is where I will stop. Asia is done with colonialism, let's not turn to these colonists for help with our neighbor disputes, ok.
Mr Pavin's analyse of the China-India situaiton is RIGHT ON!!! Replace Modi with Pravin and the China-India conflict will be solved virtually overnight. Mr Pavin is a deep longterm strategic thinker, he cares for the longterm well-being of India. Modi, on the other hand, is turning out to be a Western tool much like Zelensky of Ukraine.
thanks my friends.
No one talk about bad things of India in China and no media is advocating anything against India. In India, opposite is true. I believe there are too much internal problem of India so that the politician and intellectual are handling the situation in a proved traditional way. To Godify the leader (Modi is god), to promise an eternal happy life in the future (tell ordinary people India will be the super power in the world without details), and most of all to unify people and divert their attention away from the problem they could not handle. ( in the form of a powerful enemy). This is what I believe directing the behaviors of Indian leaders. But people should take lessons from the history. China's Chairman Mao did this and failed.
🤭🤭🤭
毛主席做什么失败了？你说说？还有毛主席都叫人别神化他了。毛主席那一代几十年为中国打下经济，政治，军事，科技工业基础制度等等，把中国一个世界最穷的国家变成工业国你以为那么容易？🤔
Hard not to believe how China is encroaching on Indian territory making truly daft historical stories.
Like Chinese leader are using to divert there failure of zero covid policy economic turmoil and problem with super power usa
He is china stooge in india
This make so much more sense than the official narratives!
Gold will short fall
Yes , All these politician bastard wanted to created hatred between India and China in order to get voted again , That's why India never ban those provoking media like RW , First Post and HT . Don't forget that Russia and China dispute for many decades and now they are the 2 most powerful best allies in the world , Going against China is an enemy with Russia .
Jaishankar's entire family is settled outside India and have given up Indian citizenship. He is doing what he has to do to keep his job as minister. Smart man.
Thoda aur details me bataye please
Pakistani don't grow up, 😂😂
Forian Manister is big thing, even in India if you are government employee you can not have double citizenship, leave it for applying you need to be only Indian citizenship.
😂😂😂😂
@@GeneralInfoSystem 🤣🤣🤣 Ye fuddu bs conspiracy theories bna rha h.. Isko lagta Pakistan k politicians aur generals australia me island lete h retirement k baad to hindustan me bhi aisa hi hota hoga🤡🤡🤡
Dr. Jayshankar ki wife Japanese h.. Wo Japan me bahot time tk ambassador rhe h.. Aur sochne wali baat h.. Agar indian citizenship na ho to india me External n foreign affairs Minister bn hi nhi skte. 🤷♂️🤷♂️
Chaho to Google kr lo😉😉
@@nishantshrivastava9674 kehena kya chatey ho
@@debasismohanty1952 ye fuddu abdul bol rha h Dr jayshankar ne indian citizenship chor kr kissi aur country ku citizenship li huyi h.. Jaise pakistani pm London se operate krte h aur pakistani generals retirement k baad America aur australia settled ho jate h😜😜😜
Bajwa ka ek beta Paris me h aur ek dubai me🤭🤭
This guy can be trusted to speak the truth without nationalistic hype on either side.
China could not have a better advocate in India. Now I know who is Rahul Gandhi’s guru on national security!
Why ass on fire bjp bhakt
Why India is so adamant ? And always playing the angelic american way. We need to maintain a peaceful and healthy relationship with our neighbours with a priority to build and strengthen our nation
One of the best explanation on the border conflict of India China.
Mr. Jaishankar simply pleasing his demanding boss.
That Indian boy needs an education.
Jaishankar is no doubt a very witty man. But his too egoistic -- thinking too highly of himself, and exploiting every opportunity to boost his personal image and ego.
Part of the India-China problem is made a lot worse by India joining the QUAD, willingly becoming a lapdog of the USA. China is thus compelled to make it known to India in no uncertain terms that this opportunistic siding of the USA has to come at a price!
Or China India is a small player with outdated tech. Unless we are willing to spend on tech China will always have an upper hand. Make in India will take a long time to produce strategic weapons. Relying on Israel and America is foolish strategy.
Such an informative and educational insight! Thanks so much, Sir Pravin. As a Cambodian, I must also say that both India and China are time-tested century-old friends of Cambodia. Our most sincere desire is these two giants are in good sincere term with each others and cooperate with each other for the interest of people of both nations and the world. God bless India and God bless China, and God bless Cambodia. Amen.
Sir lord praveen shawney , next prime minister
I share your sentiment.
However it is not to be.
India has jump in bed with American lead QUAD and this complicates things.
It is common view by Indian geopolitical analysts that a mini conflict between India and China will benefit India.
What Jaishankar said is this very tactic that India is using to boost their status in the world.
could you please provide Links where this view is expressed? I have not come across any. thanks.
@@anuradharaghavan872 check out Sinderpal Singh's UA-cam videos.
What a good explanation. INDIA should relook what has been said and not just blaming others for it blunders.
Great perspective need a person like you in our strategic think tank so that a balanced approach is maintained militarily.
I thought of the same but that will never be allowed. We the citizens have to decide upon the merits of the govt's statements n those like him who can keep a clear conscience n tick off lies n miscalculations, until one day, when it will be too late.
I do not understand why India keeps behaving in a way that does little or nothing to resolve the Border Issue. Since Nehru's agreement with Zhou EngLai on the border issue, India has been consistently renagading on her promises...either by not honouring what has been agreed or distorting the agreement for domestic consumption.
Doesn't India realise that if there is this constant huge distraction, she cannot fully focus on her domestic development plans??? Besides she will be manipulated by foreign anti-China forces to create an even bigger dispute between the nations!
For example......US has persuaded India to train with US forces around the border region!!!
Now how can this be in any way beneficial towards creating an amicable relation with China??? Against such an attitude how does anybody expect China not to react!!!?
And so ...the border issue remains a thorn between them.
You are real Indian but most Indians comment against you this is problem in india . They believe on lies but not true like you
We are fired by bragging shamelessly. We are geo politically an important country, no doubt about that but we lack nobility n dont know what is modesty. Hyped up filmy status is what we're charged with, just like the our trash TV serials.
These two countries need to settle their border. The fight is ridiculous. They fight over land that has practically no inhabitants, no traffic value, no historical or emotional value, no minerals. They argue over border that is not settled because nobody was there until the armies showed up. They are wasting resources and attention of the governments. The issue is poisoning relationship between the two countries so that they cannot cooperate to solve problems of common interest.
I would like to hear someone explaining why this land is so important.
Thanks for doing an honest analysis, Dr. Sawhney. You are correct in calling Mr. Jayshankar's failure and untruthful statements. This man will leave his post in a couple of years, but the damage he has done will stay with the people of India for years to come. Therefore, there was no need for the August 5, 2019 action; Mr. Modi's shortsighted approach and Mr. Jayshankar and Mr. Doval's incompetence will cost India a couple of trillion dollars in the next three decades of misappropriating resources to support flawed policy.
Speak with money in your pocket! You Pakis have none of it
Hello, Pakistan will breakup earlier than 1 to 1 1/2 Yrs., which will save India at least 1 - 2 Trillion Dollars. China's economy is down at least 5 - 10 % & in all probability start breaking-up in 2 Yrs. & total break up in about 7 - 9 Yrs. U pakistanis are fit only for day-dreaming with empty stomach. Just one Yr.; may be even less. Keep Ur mouth SHUT & just wait & watch.
@@chandrashekaragupta8628 Hahahahaha, wait, I guess Pakistanis will take half of India in the Indian Ocean with them if they drown. Stop living with delusions.
@@amitabhshrivastava3121 Go visit "Dharvi Slum" and spend some money on those unfortunate Indians, instead of boasting.
@@zaffazad4040 Whole of Pakistan and the muslim mohallas of India are like Dharavi - the Islamic way of life. Kashmir is Modi's harem.
India has a border with Tibet not China . China has illegally occupied Tibet who is socio culturally ,political a different entity who are religious and who wanted to remain Independent.
India had also taken over Sikkim , right ?
Boss what is your logic here -
You are saying China, because they formed a large army ( which is incapable to a large extent no matter how much a hype they want to showcase ) has the right to bring in their army to borders and break any agreement at will and that’s why Jaishankar is wrong in stating China broke the agreement .. ? Great logic
I agree, he has absurd conspiracy theory
There’s no right or wrong.. just consequences
This old B*td Pravin is a part-time paid artist of PLA AND SCAMGRESS .😇😇😇
The very fact that the Chinese created the western command means they had started amassing soldiers against India. This dude brushes that off as just the PLA's restructuring. Like I said before this dude is full of hatred for India for a failed Army career. I see dudes who failed miserably in India all over the world, who become venomously anti Indian.
@@bsobro - then why have rules based order, UN, or courts, justice.. throw away all that .. let’s take all island nations, invade whosoever we like to.. nuke any country we like to ..
Good of Prof Pravin to exposing the lying Jaishankar who thought his smooth talk can fool anyone but not the professor.
The only Indian defence analyst with a massive Pakistani and Chinese fan following 😁
Pravin probably is an ISI agent.
@@AzamSheikh We don't do that in India, unlike in some countries where everyone with a different opinion is a Raaaw agent 😁. He is just a disgruntled old man, with a failing Magazine business and skewed and pessimistic world view of his own.
Yes he is a Paki/Chinese agent
Hahaha
He is fit only for pakistan & china; which will be very good for India too.
Time to resolve all issues and make our countries rich so people get good life . India Pakistan and China should come together. Modi cannot do this because of Rss.
Message from Pakistan
PM modi dont have any need to such kind of silly things .Do you people produce lot of crude oil like saudi arabia so that you would be able to supply india ?do you people produce so much rare earth minarel like china so that you would be able to support indias electronic industry?Do you people produce lot of semi conducter like taiwan so that you would be able to support the information technology industry of india?do you people produce lot of edible oil like ukrain so that you would be able to supply india for house hold use ?Do you people have advanced space tech like usa so that you would be able to support our space mission ?do you people advance wepons like france and russia so that you people would be able to support indian armed forcess with your wepons ?just give one reason for which pm modi will come together with pakistan?He is the prime minister of 130 crore people of india .Have 200 other countries to manage .Managing the whole globe is not a small thing.if tomorrow rahul gandhi became pm then still the things will be remain unchanged.Friendship always happend among equals.In 1947 both the countries were liberated together .Today african countries are requesting to our pm to forgive their loans worth of 12 billion dollars .on the pakistani pm is very happy after reciving the promise for 9 billion dollars flood relief from international community.Today 1 indian currency is equal to 3 pakistani rupees .if we will say that to the normal pakistanis fighting for wheat that look if you will join to india then not only the value of your properties will enhance to 300 percent overnight but also every your single rupee you have will turned into three rupees then at least half of pakistan living out side the punjab would beready to join india .It seems crazy but thats how west have suceeded to convince the germans from east germany to merge with west germany.china is also weponising their currency against the taiwan to turn the public opinion of taiwan in favour of chineese communist party by
Pakistan has nothing to do with it.
It is a failed state with radicalized Islamist society. It is gonna be next Syria of Asia.
If we would want economic framework with China.. It would include Bangladesh instead.
We do not want to come together with jihadis we prefer hinduism
First of all get rid from your property dealers(Pakistan Army)
Mind ur own country😂
We indians are Happy with what we got
How do you know that the Chinese are occupying 2000 sq km of new Indian territory since 2020 ? Ex Army chief General Naravane clarified that the PLA has been moved back to the LAC at all 7 points.
Sir, ye banda jhoot pe jooth bole Jaa rha he. Ye banda pehle army me hi tha but iski kaali kartooto ki vjh se iska court Marshall hua hai.. aur ab ye ek jehadi ladki ke saath milke ye saare kaam krta hai. Like journalism Krna, secularism promotion Krna aur dusri countries ka agenda chlana
@@mohitpatel4578 देश में जयचंदों की कमी नहीं है। टिप्पणी अनुभाग देखें: मुसलमानों और वामपंथियों की टिप्पणियों से भरा हुआ।
@Mohit Patel this alzimer patient can talk anything,previously, he may be PLA AGENT and scamgress follower.
@@arindamghatak Thank you, aap dekhna, isko Maine 7 questions puche he..kisika bhi answer nai dega😆
The big statement i am going to make is this..
Aside from LAC..
What HOSTILITIES has India reacted to China in compared with what Hostilities China has reacted to India?
Did India join an organisation called Quad to deal with China?
Did China joined any organisation to deal with India?
Did India keep poking into Taiwan issue?
How often did China poke into Kashmir issue?
Did India block Chinese apps , Hiawei etc?
Did China block anything from India?
ANSWER THAT TRUTHFULLY...then anyone will know why the LAC cannot be resolved..
Who is the real Hostile one?
How does it feel my dear Pakistanis to hear only the one person who you can listen to without any pain?
Not any worse then being called "piss drinkers" by the whole world and China kicking your ass! We like watching this from the sidelines. The tea is ready by the way! Your agony is our joy!
This is your problem, Dear, don't drag us against the gentleman
No we love to hear gayshankar too😂
we love to hear Godi media too
It is remarkable. Wish we all could be like that as our fathers used to live in combined India
This is how you showcase political diatribe as military analysis.
Sir, you must be very strongly PRO-CHINA ! Say, how many times India should continue Negotiation? DO you really believe that it is Chine who does not show any interest in Northern boarder?
Keep up the good work.
So much for the hate of Narender Modi......the Indian Army is wrong......the FM Jaishanker is wrong.......the people of India are wrong and specifically don't have the MOJO to stand up against China. This guy even made a pariah of China and Shi Jing Ping (the bear)......lol. Don't know what the presenters background is.......but seems he is on the payrolls of Chinese PLA and specifically for senior people like these today India is at such a disadvantage with loosing territory in 1962 and maybe even later on. I would invite the presenter to tag along with me and let's visit some Chinese villages together to know the ground truth on both sides of the border or so called Line Of Control ( And Sir your security is on me and my village friends). With my upbringing all across the NE region of India......who more can know what and how the Chinese think and act. Chinese are into active defence and fight in enemy territory.......my foot.....these PLA troops doesn't have the stomach to see blood.....let alone fight in Himalayan heights. China can only fire missiles and shells from a distance or from the air.......but to conquer territory u need boots on the ground. And Sir.....what do you think......leave aside the India army......you think the people of the NE India will sit quite and seek peace with the Chinese. Are you aware our Naga Brothers keep the enemies skull as trophy with them.....and you think China will send troops to face US.......pfff.
Today the whole country and related lack of development/s are largely because of poor/self inflicting wounds policy followed by Jawaharlal Nehru/Congress/Mahatma Gandhi/etc and people like you during the last 70 odd years. Had Netaji been at the helm of affairs we would have seen a different India with our head held high always.
Pls at this age all these bigotemy doesn't suit you even if it means for you to stay relevant. Jai Hind.
While I found the observations interesting, a word of advice. At some point (12min 40sec) you mention an observation shared with you by an army commander. I respectfully suggest that observations made in private and in confidence should not be attributed by name to anyone. The other party should remain anonymous, unless their consent was obtained to name them.
When it is a matter of our country, I am sure he is justified. Besides, he be well aware of such etiquettes n in the process avoid ambiguity.
Welcome back sir....👏👏
The old idiot was at your home previously 🤣🤣🤣
China doesn't want war, China and India should stand UNITED together for a peaceful and prosperous world.
What about pakistan?
we indians are the decendents of the maurian emperor samrat asoka .we belive in vijaya through dharmik means but not without compromising the capabilities needed for yuddha vijay
@@coconutpunch123 in that case Pakistan will be stand by with the Western powers as a pakistani I can confirm that because West needs Pakistan to neutralize any riseup in asia for their own interests
of course China does not want war especially now India has Agni V that could reach Beijing in 5 minutes
@@coconutpunch123 Britain partitioned India. Subjects must obey their masters. Therefore, India is allowed only to fight China, never mind Pakistan.
Dalai Lama belongs to India, and so does Tibet. India must go to war with China and take back Tibet. Because British left Tibet to India, when a master left something with its subject, the subject must fight to death to keep it.
Where did you get the information that Chinese were already there illegally. This is a wrong premise. He seems to be doing to highlight Chinese to be superior to Indian defence strengths.
Very fair & detailed analysis of the full situation.
Considering a particular country your arch enemy is worst possible mistake you could possibly make in geopolitics
Indian pride goes first.
Yo, Indians r not my enemy. Greetings from Chinese! My fav food is chicken tikka, varuval, briyani, cheese naan yum!
You are overseas Chinese. Haha. I like Indian food as well.
But their inept politicians are
China May be big country with world’s largest Army .And richest country.Does it makes country strong militarily The strength of it military is proved in-terms of winning a war .not it’s numbers .Perhaps Chinese Army is one of the weakest armies .Their Will to fight is questionable .Indian Army is battle hardened force .Allied power would not have won 2nd WW but for Indian Army..You seem to be a Congress spokes person to run down our foreign policy and Army..Please remember this not Nehru era ,when military and foreign policy blunder resulted in losing 1962 war
Well done and a great analysis . Regards from Pakistan
why you pakistanis are feeling so much happy. He is saying about the over estimated chineese capabilities .Not about pakistani capabilities .It seems that you people have actually started to thinking yourself as chineese ,not pakistani.some times you people claimed mohammad bin kasim as the first pakistani.some times imran khan claimed the ertugal as the show on your ancestors ,some times you people claimed the remins from sikh empire as the ancient pakistan. some times you people claime jinnah as the baba e quam,it seems that you people have lot of confusion about the origins of your gather ,grand father ,great grand father and other ancestors.probably your mothers have not told you people who was the father of your race .not knowing about the father of the children is a normal thing for prostitutes
Hahaha metoo# from pakistan! We should be the last ones to comment! Given the kanjar Army we ended up creating
I just don't understand why Modi and other defense experts are WASTING their time and resources to study china and its moves, if they only ask Mr. Pravin Shawney about the next move of Chinese I am sure they will save so much on military resources.
This guys has so much inside information about Chinese. GURU on china. 😂😂😂
What are you saying ? That we should accept Ladakh as a disputed territory? You seem to be talking like a Chinese Ambassador.
Good Morning General Pravain
Excellent explanation. If possible- kindly if you can explain with the maps and names of place etc. would give the best understanding. thanks
He aint no GENERAL !!
He is just a Major who was court Marshalled and sacked from Indian Army on disciplinary grounds...Get your facts alright
@@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd WIld Rose seems to have a Wild imagination.....giving all those rapid promotions !!
@@blackswan6963 He has more intelligent and analytic skills than all Indian generals combined who had been invited by PLA touring military compounds and setups in China in the past years.
MR lam.....Generals when visiting MILITARY AREAS abroad are supposed to absorb things, presented to them...and what they can discern otherwise !! Nobody makes the mistake of showing their analytical skills....bad manners, and bad diplomacy ! You seem to have a shortage of Generals with such skills......you are welcome to borrow PRAVIN FOR THE SAME...on second thought may like to keep him with you permanently....what are friends for !!
KUDOS SAWHNEY SIR.....
HAPPY 😊 AS FIRST VIEWER
Couple of questions:
1. How do you know what the Chinese side was/were thinking?
2. How is violation LAC agreement any different from crossing over LAC and occupying area.
3. India also says there should be peaceful relations with China and Pakistan. How is it any different from when Chinese leaders are saying that.
4. Why is Chinese non-acceptance of Cartographic modifications so sacrosanct when the borders themselves are not agreed upon.
However I do agree that the Chinese bogey card is overplayed and that its military strategy and equipment is far superior, notwithstanding opinion of experts/analysts.
It is clear, the old idiot is a spy, how he can say 2000sqkm occupied?? Did he whent to border to measure the land??
YOU CAN FIGHT WITH KNOW ENEMY.
While you have few questions, lemme share one observation and ask a question to you. On 20th August 2020, in Russia there was a press conference where Jaishankhar was present. It was supposed to be a joint press conference, but only China's points were shared in the press conference. Neither did Jaishankhar protest or say anything and was silent. In fact, they have shared bits of that on the MEA website but there is no official press release of the entire thing, why so ???
I hope you answer it, that actually made China's stand much more stronger. And this is before the Chinese-Russian friendship thing happened, that statement was over a month later, September 2020 onwards.
China's goodwill makes Indians believe that they can be unscrupulous. Senior Indian officials know China's strength, so they retreat after every provocation, and China also preserves India's face.
Because India can do no wrong according to Indian Media, lol what a joke of a country
Nice in depth analysis, and a good critic, request you to give suggestions for all the challenges and decisions of the army, it's easy to be critical,
Mr.Pravin Sawhney are you doing the video at the behest of Chineese ? You always talk in favour of China !! You always talk about India getting defeated in case of War. Yes economically speaking, War is not welcome. I never heard you saying Chineese violet LAC given differing perceptions. First you answer when Chineese are vacating occupied 2000 sq.kilometer ???? Yes you are right about Indian Military ' s
exclusive focus on Pakistan neglecting north-eastern Chineese Border. Govt. since 1971 missed opportunity to widen chicken neck substantially in consultation with Bangladesh & that was possible.This strategy like that of POK after surrender of Pak Army when India could have leveraged POK as J&K is inseparable part of India. I admit our people lack foresight
and long term strategic plan. According to you Xi deserve Noble Peace Prize.
He talks about the Eastern problem where India occupies an area that China claims.
There is also a Western problem where China occupies an area that India claims.
It seems nobody knows the whole story.
But what sawhney will never quote about is AK Anthony statement in parliament about the pathetic state of infrastructure in the indo china border prior to 2014 so the present government is having a fire 🔥 fighting exercise trying to do its best to overcome the existing weakness 🤔
I salute you,Pravin for telling the unpleasant truth for Indians.
Uh, my brother dont waste your time, dont you feel he does nothing but gathers Pakistani audience? he is the only person you can listen to without pain in your ears
Acc. to this man whatever Indian does, whatever action the India govt. or military takes is wrong and is eventually going to cost India
Just listening to pleasant things which susuitour taste not gonna help. reality is India is rapidly growing economy, Global player which world recognizes and Pakistan is just 📉
@@rishabhchaudhary3918 There is only one way to findout...a War between India vs Pak+ China ...without any external help to either side. Ready?? 😂😂🤣
There is another reality is that 18.000 Indian people have applied for asylum seeker just in one year 2022 . It is a huge figure for a smallest country like Austria , what about another 27 European states ? I guess there must be a number of people trying to get asylum on behalf of that India is not a safer country
Hello, they are all pakistanis posing as Indians.
Thank you so much to Dr Pravin Sawhney ji
You call him Dr Pravin?? Ask him for his matriculation certificate first
@@amitabhshrivastava3121 🤣🤣🤣
BJP leaders have elevated themselves or by media. Nation needs to be aware of ground reality
Great analysis. It would be great if you could use maps when you describing the geogrpahical details and landscape.
What is your achievements. Every tom Dick and Harry thinks that he knows foreign policy
Praveen keep it up
The kashmiei pheran is really beautiful nd looking owsm on you ❣️
a very intelligent analysis . keep going .
Pravin, you are too obsessed with the Prime Minister's "image". Even Rahul Gandhi has a few arguments other than that. :)
Can you mark out the latitudes and longitudes of the 2000 kms of Indian territory occupied by China
One should NOT forget salami slicing tactics. It is naive not to take it seriously. Do not forget regular encouragement given to Pakistan to create tensions within India. Wonder how these experts forget that Chinese Communist Party is driven by a take two steps forward one step back. Leave aside these agreements that are treated with convinience rather than honour. The question is WHY do you want to build such military build up unless it has ugly plan. It is ok for China to build up in questionable areas while when India does it it is foul!! Get real and balanced and look at geopolitics. Pakistan has been used as a proxy for a long time as it gets paid to do so.
I agree with pravin sir on Jaishankar telling the world, china tried to change border status quo in 2020 when in reality chinese already grabbed some 2000 sq km indian and still sitting on it.
I don’t understand why indian forces left doklam plateau when the chinese troops are still there.
Jaishankar should tell the truth on situation on chinese border instead of covering up for his boss Modi.
Abbye mister bean, funny fellow is that old idiot measure the land saying 2000sqkm, at the old age he lost the brain don't be so happy .
Bean will be knocked down soon. 🤣🤣🤣
Well! If he tells the truth then Mr Modi is no Demi god and BJP might loose face … enough to be kicked out of power in 2024 … so no , he can’t tell the truth!
Where the fuck is the proof of this land occupation
Such a thing without war means a complete collapse of the indian line so again where is the proof of that collapse??
@@Pop23ygcxdrtyhbnniyeesd where is the proof indians still holding to pre April 2020 LAC line in ladakh? Are indians still in control of finger 4 till finger 8 areas in pango lake ? Can indians patrol pt 14,15,16 & 17 areas in depsang?
I always wonder how much is he paid by chinese
He's a beautiful man. I enjoyed his interview with Pakistan.
Man of peace.
Of course we Pakistanis enjoyed his interview! Just like we are enjoying the chittar parade of our army! 😂😂
Take him to pakistan.
@@chandrashekaragupta8628 no wheat, no gas, no electricity, no job and no money- don’t think he will like that
Abbye Nasser mujrey walla, buddha beautiful dheak ra? Yaa toe hijra??🤣🤣🤣
He's talking your language, saying things you want to hear. Why wouldn't he look beautiful to you?
Lying Jaishankhar exposed!
No! What does Pravin know about foreign policy??
@@amitabhshrivastava3121 --- he knows more than you want to admit!
Absolutely baseless things you are mentioning sir, first of all your whole argument is based on media facts which you said in the starting and surprisingly you are believing those reports over what our Foreign minister, Military chief defence chief are saying . So according to you all of them are wrong and what media is saying is correct. Secondly you are blaming the current government as if the relations with china were very sweet before that. Let me remind you that we had a war with them in 1962 and it was that because of that government that India is still lagging behind in military equipments as compared to china. In your whole argument you tried to show that India is an agresser and the Chinese are very innocent, I mean you are talking about some another universe, leave behind Aksai chin ,doklham ,etc ,China doesn't even let India to declare Mazhood Azar freed through a plan hijack a worldwide terrorist in UN by using veto powers and then you say China wants south asia as India china what bull shit sir, they don't even say Indo Pacific they always profect pacific Asia , and what the hell have they been doing in Indian ocean ,they even tried to mock India in covid with dead bodies burning pictures and it were people like you who were greedy enough to make money through that pictures on social media. These are very few things I mentioned how could you even think in that way about china. They even claimed friendship before 1962. Still if you think India is an agresser what about taiwan, phillipines etc and what about chinese built a whole road and exploiting the natural resources in POK which is in Indian territory. Lastly and most importantly you said that this will lead us to a war and we will loose , I doubt if you are an Indian or you might be a congress mouthpiece I think they propaganda people do these type of things. You could have said that China is far more advanced with weapons and India is on road to development so war is not a good idea because it will come with a heavy price of lives and development or may something else but very clearly said we cannot win from China. Rediculous and baseless arguments you have put sir.
I would like to invite you In Pakistan in a May 2023?? Please let me know
This proposal not acceptable to indians but good relations between china should be maintaned.
Whenever you criticise means Modi govt doing things 100% right, massive massive majority beleives that
Indian economy is not in a position for a war against China. A full war require 50000 crores per day. The Tibet region is a cold desert. We can not be aggressive against China. Even if we loose 100 square kms no problem crores of Indians will suffer in war, which is important. Jayasankar is doing it . See what happened to Pakistan economy due to military while Bangladesh is growing.
Informative video.
Why modi govt implying isreali model in Jammu kashmir house demolish 20 lakh peoples
Jai Shankar's son is also on the Chinese payroll in Washington DC. Working for a Chinese think tank Quid Pro Quo
Really?? 😮😮
I paid your mother and why aren't you my mouthpiece...what utter nonsense
You are amazing if I would in owner I would make prime minister Military Advisor
So called Surgical Strike hahaha
I love this sentence sir
Point to be noted. At 3.03 jaishankar said border areas. He do not have spine to say LAC now bcz china says boarder areas.
Hanji let's do talk on Pakistan border issue going on with Afghanistan? Should we ?
bhai india pe baad me ayen ge pehle hum apne masle tou hall kar len. Apne mulk k pakoray lage paray hen!
@@bharatkapoor4062
Sure bharat. Pathan hote hi hain bakland. Kapoor bhi India me wahin se aaye the na.
@@Wasim_Raza hahahahaha so now targeting communities let's not talk it's not worth it
This is called constructive discussion which is lacking in ur country. It’s better to learn from it and apply on your country rather than pointing fingers on others.
You have tried to make your story different and spicy. What about China transgressing sitting and going back on our territory prior to Doklam.? You are obsessed with Pak and China.
Good dispassionate analysis.
What does Pravin know about foreign policy??
Why do you try to tell tge people the truth, you would do much better teaching people mandrin in 3 easy steps.
removal of article 370 means change of status quo.
India changed the status quo by removing article 370
@sam123sder ok - let us just agree for arguments sake that you are correct.
why would a country put such restrictions on itself for no reason ?
can you give me an answer
if Kashmir is an integral part of India then so is Uttar pradesh - why does Uttar pradesh not have something like article 370.
now I want you to think carefully and do proper research and not just give me made up facts and then answer this after a careful thought of the reason.
It was TEMPORARY and its India's internal matter. I dont know why the terrorists are commenting here.
Pakistan changed the status quo by sending militias into Kashmir in 1947 in the first place. This lead to LOC. why do people forget this?
@john: J&K is part of our country and no outsider has locus standi.
Your videos are really excellent to watch.
You said US & China Dialogue Will put India in Difficult Condition After that Pelosi visited And after US China meet Latest German MP in Taiwan nothing happened you are predecting Some thing happening after 20 years . According to you Pak Economic crises is Bad to India & if Pak in better economy than also Bad so What happens in this Galaxy is bad for India This is Suppeerr analysis Keep it up
The problem is India has a chip on its shoulder in its relationship to China. It always wanted to be the leader and hegemon of Asia but just cannot beat China in every aspect. It has the National idea, like USA, of exceptionalism. It feels that it is the best race and country, and by divine right should be the top dog in Asia.
He speaks the truth
Thanks for your certificate otherwise nobody else would have believed now we have two truthful people here you and mr Sawhney😆
is there anything right for you with the indian government or the Indian army...you seem to be quite a pessimistic gentleman ...
Critical analysis. Hattsoff Praveen ji. It's not that a hard nosed Modi of bare-it-all Jaishankar don't know the mind of Xi Jin Ping. Jaishankar is diplomatic, Modi is too strong to display his weakness of accepting ceding land to Chinese, neither his deputies are in a position to call truth.
Beggers are not chociers, keep begging till the last day comes 🤤🤤🤤
Media reports have more credentials than ministers words, wow and this man is analyst.
This Crook are in Chinese payroll 👍👍👍
@@tigerking2742 This man is impossible, his basic premise is 'since he said and she said', if media reports are to be believed or what his handlers are claiming, he is not a field reporter and doesn't run any organization that collects authentic information from original sources. He constantly whines about why GOI not telling this and that. Even the average joe would understand the secrecy any govt maintains while dealing with a complex geo-political situation, you don't want to play into the hands of your enemy. In an all-out war, every front is important you cover every front, every infantry line including mediabazi. This mediabazi has attained great importance in the information war. Hopefully, he shall learn the elementary guidelines of the new age war.
@@umeshshahane you just watch his old program where he talk with a pakistani Anchor then you understand how much he hate BJP and Modi 👍👍👍
@@tigerking2742 he pretends to be an analyst but even by his mediocre standard doesn't stay discrete, he spouts his political bias with every sentence
@@umeshshahane hmmm actually UA-cam sab tarah ke logon ko platform deta hai I never upset this type of person 👍👍
politicians LIE!
Praveen Sawhney’s perspective is based on:
1. China is the dominant power ad infinitum & India agrees to be subordinated to China by hyphenating China-india- with other south asian countries.
2. Sawhney’s belief that china can dominate frontier areas at their “ will”, smacks of his deep rooted disgruntled resentment as a former indian army officer.
3. Whilst the diplomats of India hv a record in promoting & justifying Chinese propagada & Chinese interpretations (just like Sawhney),
Jaishanker has unambiguous clarity
& whilst Modi/Doval were caught in their own ego wrap, post Ladakh/Galwan, these 2 hv done a course correction.
4. In Any future conflict with China,
India’s Victory will be to”deny a Chinese Victory”.
5. Sawhney’s consistent diatribe against Gen Navarrane is distasteful especially since this General has stood his ground well against the Chinese as well our own govt without compromising India’s military options & has achieved tactical suprise in the domain of operations.
6. The Chinese occupation of 2000+ sq km of indian territory in Ladakh is the result of India’s multi
Agency border management folly,
As well as Doval’s meddling in military matters which is not his domain of specialisation though Modi entrusts all defence issues to his NSA which is Modi’s biggest folly (nxt only to nehru with Menon).
7. Sawhney & the Congress are of one accord. That india should tamely aquiese & surrender to Chinese interests by bartering territory to avoid a war which india cannot win. Its a warped thought process of the insane & the sulllied.
⚓️⚔️🇮🇳
How come the comment box is filled with chinese and pakistani comments
Sir we want peace with India but rss do not want peace .
🤡🤡🤡 who told u india wants peace or any sort of relation with Pakistan??
BJP is doing what 1 billion of indians have elected them for.
India doesn't want to have anything to do with pakistan.
Says people who regularly send terrorists from Pakistan to india
First try becoming human not terrorists
U have problem with each of ur neighbour 😂