To compare India with China is an insult... China is on another level by its own , which no other country can compare with.. India is unfortunately comparerable to Zimbabwe..Philippines.... Nigeria ...
People often think that China's success in the past 40 years is simply because of the cheap labour. Then they will imagine India can do that too. That is a big fundamental mistake. China's success is much more complicated and particularly the government guidance and effective execution of clear visionary plans were very important. Not just once or twice but repetitively over a few decades.
Yes, it is all about careful planning, execution plus lot of hard works and sacrifices. Definitely not a miracle like the West or MSM like to emphasize. The funny thing is Indians believe it, so they just waited for this miracle to fall from the sky day after day, years after years......LOL
Unlike China, india never had a regular 5 year plan and sticking to it come rain or shine. Like the proverbial snake indians tend to bend and twist when the situation does not favour them or become negative. There's no preservance in the indian mindset.
Guys, I am Chinese. Let us not disrespect Indian people, many of whom are hard-working and intelligent people. Their government is what is holding them back big time. We are all humans, let us not sow division amongst each other. And also realise that the success of one (China) does not mean the failure of another (India, or US for that matter). As the Chinese always say, a win-win situation is the goal. Unlike in the west where you need to degrade/conquer/colonise another in order to succeed, which is a really foolhardy zero-sum mentality that comes from a scarcity mindset.
This dude is realistic and is focus on truth and facts, not delusional self interest, but doing his job for real. India's problem is laziness and scam culture.
In any working environment the indian mindeset is to do the minimum effort to obtain the agreed remuneration. Its all in the indian mind....sloth and laziness becomes a perpetual circle and its infectious.
I was in New Delhi for exhibition at the Exhibition Centre Pragati Madan before Covid-19. An Indian that I have met in one of the Indian exhibition booths and he told me this when we were discussing and comparing Indian and Chinese products. I was surprised what he told me. He said "The Chinese they are learning very fast from us Indian. In the next 20 years times they will sure be catching up with us" I just smiles and said of course, India is already a global superpower and China is still a developing country. He seems so happy with my replied to him. This Indian Jayant Bhandari will be hated by most of his own Indians if more Indians have watched this video discussions. Because most Indians hate to listen to such negative comments about India even if it is truth and logical. Indians love to listen to other praising them like calling India superpower, India is the greatest, India in 20 years ahead of China, lndia is world leader, etc.....
We should nevertheless admit that India is progressing steadily though at a slower pace. For example it has been able to land a rover on the south pole of the moon. India needs to be congratulated for this prowess.
@@richardlee-z9ppraising indian for the moon vehicle success is correct. But also should remind them it is a limited success with help from other who have ulterior motives. India still needed to face all the real life problems of economic development by not creating enemy, they cannot afford it.
@@richardlee-z9p Didnt you read they didnt land on the south pole as pointed out not too long ago by China top space scientist and an australian has also agreed with the chinese scientist calculations. Landing on the southern hemisphere is not landing on the south pole. The chinese scientist has written to indian space agency but have not received their reply so far.
India is at least 70 years behind China. When I was at school, I learned the Ganga River was the most polluted river in the world in the Geography class, that was 30 years ago. 30 years later, the river is still one of the most polluted in the world. That tells you something about the progress of India. One the other hand, China has changed so so so much, every time I visit China on business, it's changed beyond recognition. I believe India will eventually catch up with China in terms of national strength, but China has already moved on to another level.
but how can it sustain the growth; population of china has aged, and no competent free minded person is ready to move to china. china is never going to grant permanent residency or equal rights to migrants. during ww2, north korea was the most developed country, we all see what happened after that.
more like 17 years... India GPD/cap in 1970 - $112 China GDP/cap in 1970 - $113 ^^^ They where equal. India GPD/cap in 1980 - $267 China GDP/cap in 1980 - $195 ^^^ Then cultural revolution bring China Down. India GPD/cap in 1990 - $368 China GDP/cap in 1990 - $318 ^^^ China start catching up after Deng reforms. India GPD/cap in 2000 - $443 China GDP/cap in 2000 - $959 ^^^ China pull ahead 2x India GPD/cap in 2010 - $1458 China GDP/cap in 2010 - $5618 ^^^ China extend the gap. 4x India GPD/cap in 2020 - $1901 China GDP/cap in 2020 - $10500 ^^^ Even bigger gap. 5x
People joking the Ganga river is the periodic table of chemical elements. The place they bath, washing clothes, drink, also as a open toilet on the banks, why they don't biuld toilet instead of going moon?
Indian are not stupid...it is not that they don't know...they can't change because of the politic...and the history...and because they don't want to change ..
Although I too agree that his evaluation of India is a bit too harsh I don't think it stems from bitterness or resentment but rather from a sense of urgency amid the helplessness of the multitudes, and of frustration. I too hail from that country and looking at the country it's hard to disagree with him. While I can accuse him of his pessimistic views, India always tends to prove them right. @@kexinzhu1104
That’s true. We are an American based company with several branches over 10 countries, but the scale is not very large. We have entered the Indian market for nearly four years. Recently, we have to lose all our profits because of an inexplicable huge fine. Almost the whole project is a loss.
You earn money in India and spend every penny in India. There is no way to bring a penny back to your own country...Chinese proverb. Too many Chinese companies have been fined by the Indian government for various strange reasons like you. My American friend...🤣
That is a policy from a corruption of the highest level. They just lie and created some kind of change, or some kind of law and study and wrap all the falling companies profit like I’ll telephone company Nagesh show me Volvo they have lost the same thing.
no, it's not about bureaucracy at all. It was a fraud at the first place. Indians talk to you warmly, they promise you many things such as tax free policies, cheap land ...once you bring your money into India, your nightmare starts, they will find any excuse to take all your money...
India is a developed country, and will very soon take over the US as the world number 1 super power. The whole country (cities, towns, villages) are vastly clean, very modern and futuristic, with zero crime rate and absolutely zero pollution. There are no slumps, shit-holes, ghettos or poor uneducated hungry people in any corner of India. Each and every Indian is well educated, dead honest, equally wealthy and prosperous. Its democratic government is immensely effective, totally clean and corruption-free -- proven by the country's consistent zero unemployment for decades. Its police force holds the reputation of having the highest global standards of integrity, is very clean, corruption-free, humane, competent and professional in their jobs - they don't take bribes, they don't extort money, they don't protect scammers or organized crime, they don't rape young women or beat ordinary citizens brutally on the streets with batons or long rods like what you usually see in bollywood movies. Its judiciary system has stellar track records where judges had solved and closed all legal cases as quickly as the blink of an eye. Public utilities, public transportation, public education and notably its public toilets are all ranked first in the world. And, in case you're not aware of yet, India proudly has the world largest public toilet freely available for everyone - the Ganga River, where people can conveniently take a bath, pee and poop at the same time in one go. And you should know too that public safety in India is much better than any other countries in the world - very very safe for women to walk alone at night.
India has opportunity but holy smoke the amount of Chaos that is deeply embedded and intertwined into everything and tolerated is on a whole different level.
I'm glad Jayant is is telling the truth about India as opposed to Western Media projecting false information in the name of geopolitics. Perhaps Modi should come clean with the truth instead of playing geopolitics. India needs a genius of Lee Kuan Yew to progress. India desperately needs Jayant's consultant service.
India is a developed country, and will very soon take over the US as the world number 1 super power. The whole country (cities, towns, villages) are vastly clean, very modern and futuristic, with zero crime rate and absolutely zero pollution. There are no slumps, shit-holes, ghettos or poor uneducated hungry people in any corner of India. Each and every Indian is well educated, dead honest, equally wealthy and prosperous. Its democratic government is immensely effective, totally clean and corruption-free -- proven by the country's consistent zero unemployment for decades. Its police force holds the reputation of having the highest global standards of integrity, is very clean, corruption-free, humane, competent and professional in their jobs - they don't take bribes, they don't extort money, they don't protect scammers or organized crime, they don't rape young women or beat ordinary citizens brutally on the streets with batons or long rods like what you usually see in bollywood movies. Its judiciary system has stellar track records where judges had solved and closed all legal cases as quickly as the blink of an eye. Public utilities, public transportation, public education and notably its public toilets are all ranked first in the world. And, in case you're not aware of yet, India proudly has the world largest public toilet freely available for everyone - the Ganga River, where people can conveniently take a bath, pee and poop at the same time in one go. And you should know too that public safety in India is much better than any other countries in the world - very very safe for women to walk alone at night.
I respect him, first hand knowledge of China. He went to China and saw the truth of China progress despite all the sanctions imposed by the US and its western allies. Jayant's consultant, I salute your views and comparison between India and China. India government must learn from China and have good relationships with China and South East Asian countries.
Having been involved in setting up manufacturing plants and operations for MNC the last 30+ years in Asia, I regarded Jayant the right expert on India as he is so horribly HONEST and sincere! Mr Jayant, I Salute you after witnessed the dozens of foreign investments collapsed in India.
this fellow (rogue )is another fellow who is in the abuse india business , india influence is seen far and wide ,all across asia ,china etc , and this fellow calls us all kind of names .
@@BabaYaga826 please listen to prof mahbubani ,who is of indian orgin what he has to say about india and china ,both these countries will control about 45-50 % of world gdp . abuse dogs like this bandhari should be put in the dog house , i agree with you truth hurts , hurts whome is that question , again listen to prof mahbubani from singapore also a diplomat for 30 long years , close connections with china .
@@BabaYaga826 the truth is indian influence is far and wide across south asia ,across india , this bandari (rogue ) is nothing but a scoundrel demeaning a great country .
Jayant currently lives in San Francisco as he stated. I was just wondering why smart Indian like him wouldn't want to go back to India to help build India. Practically all indians who left the country don't want to go back home, they prefer to live in the west simply they couldn't stand the pollution, corruption and 3rd rate education system back home. All the big U.S. company CEOs are of Indian descent, i.e. Google, Microsoft and IBM just to name a few. On the contrary, most of western educated Chinese who graduated from MIT, Harvard, Stanford and Caltech return back to China to help build the country, that's another reason why India will never be the next China.
I live in the San Francisco Bay Area and have worked in Silicon Valley over 4 decades and have worked with South Asians over that period and EVERY LAST Indian/South Asian HAS ABSOLUTELY NO INTENTION OF EVER RETURNING TO INDIA/SOUTH ASIA BECAUSE THEY HAVE COMPLETELY GIVEN UP ON INDIA. At the very first opportunity of gaining full legal residency status ALL of the Indians/South Asian bring over their parents and grandparents and brothers and sisters and whoever else they CAN. The offspring of Indians/South Asian migrants that arrived in the 1980s now have their own children and the offspring and their children will never NEVER EVER return to to India/South Asia as the United States is COMPLETELY their homeland now.
Thanks to those Indians who do not love their mother land. And gaveup their passport. We can do without them. China is no democracy freedom of speech is more important than some small economic numbers in stocks. Last 5 years free food to 1.4 billion people very few will achieve.
He said he made a lot of investments in India, then eventually completely withdrew all his assets and money. I'm sure he was frustrated with the bureaucracy, absence of ease of business" lack of infrastructures, lack of competent employees, etc..
If all the big U.S. company CEOs are of Chinese descent, i.e. Google, Microsoft and IBM just to name a few, Chinese would not return to China to help build the country. Trust me, I am Chinese. Chinese return to China is because we are being targeted and marginalised by US government intentionally. Ask Trump why.
Not gdp, maybe ur talking about gdp per capita or gdp growth rate. In terms of Gdp India's gdp is 3.7 trillion usd whereas bangladesh gdp is 1.13 trillion, so it's almost 3 times larger
lndia is known as the cemetery of foreign firms. 2783 foreign companies shut India operations since 2014. These include Metro AG, Holcim, Ford, General Motors, Royal Bank of Scotland, Citibank, Harley-Davidson, Huawei, among others.
In the late 90s, one of my Japanese clients, a conglomerate, set up their R&D centre in India and spent about over USD20 million. After 3 years they moved to a country in South East Asia. The directors told me, it's a great mistake for them to set up the centre in India, the level of corruption, bureaucracy, work ethic, infrastructure, hygiene, environment etc. were unbearable 😂😂😂
*The incredible! superpower! indian! "bullet train" that Japan is giving loans for HAS TURNED INTO A UNMITIGATED MASSIVE HEADACHE FOR THE JAPANESE.* *After Japan lost the Indonesian Jakarta to Bandung High Speed project to China, Japan was heell-bent to not lose another project so Japan offered incredible! superower! india! a VERY sweetheart loan package which Japan would make a loan that would pay 80% of the 14 BILLION U.S. dollar Ahmedabad to Mumbai High Speed project AT A 0.1% INTEREST PAID OVER 50 YEARS. It was SUPPOSED to be completed and opened by 2023.* *OF COURSE NO SURPRISE, due the USUAL DEMANDS of bribes AND HUGE CHANGES DEMANDED BY POLITICIANS AND BABUS THAT HAS DEVOLVED INTO FULL BLOWN "feature creep" AND "scope creep" the cost of the high speed project has now jumped to over 22 BILLION dollars and will SUPPOSEDLY IN THEORY now be completed by 2030........AND THE incredible! superower! indians! ARE DEMANDING JAPAN EXTEND MORE LOANS TO COVER THE RISING COSTS......the Japanese media has repeatedly reported that Japanese involved in the project ARE FURIOUS......* *incredible@ superpower! india! got rid of their "Licence Raj" ONLY TO DEVOLVE INTO A FULL BLOWN KLEPTOCRACY.*
China is developing so much faster than India, basic algebra taught us, the longer the time, the farther India lags behind China, therefore India cannot be like China foreve
seems chinese ppl are buying into all the info warfare thats the CCP is subjecting them to, now that china is declining. this chap is a paid indian actor..
@tzensco4953 * : Forget India , for your good health and longevity remember China for your good mindset Always Chant China China China 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳😂🌈🎤🌈🌈🔭🥁🎶📚📢❤️🌹🇨🇳👌👍💐.
That makes no sense. Developed countries eventually stop spending as much because they don't need as much any more. That's why growth is usually greatest in developing countries.
@@bohrsmodel81659 * : China is no Genocide U.S. and EU Western Alliances nation Dacoits Gangsters . China will Never Stop Development as is natural phenomenon in Cyclic momentum Synchronous Systems incorporated with laws of motion .
Fun data: India's share of global GDP in 1947- 5 % China's share of global GDP in 1947- 4% India's share of global GDP in 2023 - 5 % China's share of global GDP in 2023 - 20%
you will make mistake if you think of india as similar to china.. india has multi-party democracy, unlike chinese single party autocracy.. india had weak congress govt for most of the prev 70 years.. but now india got a strong hindu govt.. after 1000 years of foreign and weak rule.. you can see within their 8 years rule, people all over the world are talking about india.. so you can imagine what this govt can do in 50 years.. India will surpass china in 50 years.. and not today's china, it will be china 50 years later
@@Deb_deCoderChina's current GDP is US$19.6 trillion. India’s current GDP is $3.7 trillion. India and China both have a population of 1.4 billion, but the gap in GDP is huge. Even if China stops growing now, it will take India 18 years and growing at an annual rate of 13% to catch up with China's current GDP level. In addition, China is still growing at an annual rate of 5%. China's current output value is very large, while India's current output value is very small. China has also developed from poverty and backwardness more than 30 years ago to the present. I wish India economic growth and prosperity.
@@sandipkamat5604 India should spend the money on building toilets, education rather than on its space programme. The Indian government is good at making fame projects which look good on the outside, but completely hollow on the inside. Stop comparing to China which is on god level when it comes to overall development on education, infrastructure just to name a few (I'm sure India has things that are superior to China). Get India to a place where all the overseas indians would want to come back, live and build the country. Indians are proud of the fact that a lot of the big western company CEOs are of Indian descent, at the end of the day they're merely an employee (albeit higher up on the food chain), they're supporting organizations that were built by the west, with the finances in the west and technical knowhow of the west. It brings no benefits to an ordinary Indian living in India. That'd be my heartfelt advice to all the Indians.
Just like the bullet train project that faces delays,land acquisition,corruption,other projects face same problems,highway project from Maharashtra to Goa,Karnataka,Kerala,Tamil Nadu of 1600km is still not completed in 11 years due to same problems,land corruption
My first visit to India travelling from South to North and into Pakistan in 1960. About twelve years ago I spent a day in Mumbai their most prosperous city. What I seen in the streets shocked me. Apart from some modern skyscrapers and luxurious mansions where the rich live. Majority of the streets and shop houses were dilapidated and beggars and homeless everywhere, cows and vehicles rickshaws mingled in over congested and dirty streets. reminiscent of what I saw more than sixty years ago!
The old China was of no different from today India as described by Mr. Jayant Bhandari. Most Chinese who have lived thru the old China would agree with me. So my question is why China and Chinese changed so drastically? Are these changes permanent or just a temporary phenomenon?
India would be lucky not breaking up into multiple states, let alone becoming the next China. I always find such statement like "India will catch up to China or overtaking China" amazing. If you think China is now at its peak in development or advancement, you have seen or learned nothing yet. At this rate, by the time India has reached the level of China today, they would be more than a century behind.
@@ajay262134India is going down the drain. They will reserve 80% seats for second & third rate candidates while the meritorious people will move to USA. Other countries invite talent, India pushes out talent.
@@mostupdate8802India is inherently a failed state whereas the overseas ethnic Indians are doing much better especially those Indian Singaporeans who are "over represented" owing to their diligence, intelligence & right attitude. SEA & Eastern Europe would be better option compared to a failed state called India. The comments of this Indian born are very objective.
. Not unless India can produce "4.7 million high standard STEM graduates" yearly and employees willing to work 12 hours if needed to reach it's production target deadline, , "India can never be the next China."
Wouldn't the recent experiences of Foxconn and Apple tell us the true situation in India? Though I wouldn't blame Modi, he is the chief salesman and only real sales is speeching.
@@PahatRout True. Foxconn lost huge sum of money because India STEM graduates/worker's production gives out more than 50% defective. . Both Foxconn and Apple are returning back to China. ,,, but they have a big problem Huawei's 5G Satellite phone is selling like hot-cake.
Its to hard to find someone with guts who dare to tell its as is. If India could be another China it had many years to accomplish it. India is at least a century if not more behind China and mostly in its skilled manpower sector.
If India is at least a century if not more behind China and mostly in its skilled manpower sector, today, as stated in your comment; and China is not going to stop moving forward, in a century's time, when India matched today's China, China will be two centuries ahead of India.
@@stevewang2stop consuming ccp propaganda. India is behind china sure but around 15 years. With the housing collapse and banking collapse in china the gap will be closed sooner than you think
The biggest problem in India is that people don't do things in a practical and realistic way, but just muddle along... There is no concept of efficiency in doing anything.This is a fatal flaw on the business level.
India is at least a decade behind where China was ... under Mao, back in the early 1950s. Mao's Cultural Revolution was brutal, but it swept away a lot of the old, non-progressive ways that would have hindered China's future and instituted the basic education and healthcare for human development. India lacks the concept of equality, and doesn't invest in people, so they will always be far behind.
No, India is indeed ahead of China by more than just twenty years. Now, it has even surpassed China in terms of population, rightfully claiming the title of the world's number one.
He is right. I recently visited in India and I see no difference between India today vs 20 years ago. Similarly I visited China and I was surprised to see changes in China with great transport infrastructure - bullet trains and EV vehicles, EV charging stations almost everywhere..
@@balajib1406India is still a shithole with poor sanitation, poor infrastructure, overcrowding, cows wandering on the busy streets and piles of commuters on the roof of trains. A picture of the dark ages.
@@balajib1406jealousy aint gonna get u where u wanna go. And the truth shall set u free, if u not gonna open your eyes to see, at least have an open mind to accept facts
The reason for the India euphoria is because simple-minded people focus on the fact that India's population is growing rapidly and India is a Western-style democracy. That's it. They ignore important things such as work ethic, national unity, human rights, and good governance. The Indian government has failed to unify the country because of ethnic strife. The Indian government has failed to protect and empower females and use them economically. The Indian government has failed to produce good infrastructure. The Indian government has failed to educate the masses. The Indian government is corrupt and burdened by enormous bureaucracy. In other words, a simple-minded view of India that does not take real life conditions into account is bound to yield bad investment decisions.
India is a developed country, and will very soon take over the US as the world number 1 super power. The whole country (cities, towns, villages) are vastly clean, very modern and futuristic, with zero crime rate and absolutely zero pollution. There are no slumps, shit-holes, ghettos or poor uneducated hungry people in any corner of India. Each and every Indian is well educated, dead honest, equally wealthy and prosperous. Its democratic government is immensely effective, totally clean and corruption-free -- proven by the country's consistent zero unemployment for decades. Its police force holds the reputation of having the highest global standards of integrity, is very clean, corruption-free, humane, competent and professional in their jobs - they don't take bribes, they don't extort money, they don't protect scammers or organized crime, they don't rape young women or beat ordinary citizens brutally on the streets with batons or long rods like what you usually see in bollywood movies. Its judiciary system has stellar track records where judges had solved and closed all legal cases as quickly as the blink of an eye. Public utilities, public transportation, public education and notably its public toilets are all ranked first in the world. And, in case you're not aware of yet, India proudly has the world largest public toilet freely available for everyone - the Ganga River, where people can conveniently take a bath, pee and poop at the same time in one go. And you should know too that public safety in India is much better than any other countries in the world - very very safe for women to walk alone at night.
India is a creation by the British, make up of many states and kingdoms in recent time. Only released to the world in 1947 as a freed new country. Never in history the present India ever existed. ...India will be the next Pakistan...Lol....
Before british came,this land full of many tribes and leaders,She was not a big country like China....and remember at that time the number of slaves more than their masters!How could they have a splendid civilization?
India was never a world power or an empire. It was a state assembled from many smaller states/kingdoms by British colonial rule. India only became a state in 1947 after gaining independence from Britain in 1947.
Palki prefers to talk nasty words about China and sweet words about India to her Indian audience. She cannot or is unable to bring herself to tell her Indian audience the truth from facts.
That palki chick is just amouth pie for the indian media. I watched some of her shows, very biased and full of propaganda stuff. She isnt interested in true journalism, she just wanna say what indians wanna hear. I really said some nasty stuff on her shows because spreading lies like she did is disgusting!
With riots in Manipur, separatists in Kashmir, Naxalite insurgency, Khalistani resentment, wrestler's protest, massive unemployment, rising farmers suicides, falling groundwater levels, communal tensions,religion politics,north-south india sentiments,uttar pradesh crime rate,poverty,bihar overpopulated,income gap,woman safety,global warming,infrastructure problems,train safety. #107 in Hunger index #161 in Freedom Press index #126 in Happy index #139 in GDP per capita #132 in HDI index #148 in Women, Peace And Security Index 10% earn
You guys are so informed about confident that India 🇮🇳 is going no where Good to have that atitude untill china claims your land in their new map All their economy size is good and all because everyone is a slave of the rich duck But nobody cares about poor good people , coz they don't have money to through at your face China could do that I am not yet sold I am with my country China got loads of problems , they just don't have people like you saying shits about themselves
The two nations couldn't be more different. The Chinese are inspired by the way their leadership, combined with their cooperation, have lifted nearly a billion of them from abject poverty to prosperity within a generation. India is hamstrung by its millenia-long CASTE SYSTEM.
Oh you old , yeah I agree we have caste system. And I thank the the father of all disputes in the world today and also India's caste Practice and government corruption after independence To one and only god's own country sun never sets Our dearest BRITAIN 🇬🇧
@@cecaloather8701not really, Jayant has an axe to grind due to his personal problems in his family back in India. It's like Gordon Chang's view on China
@@blackmamba9950 What does this have to do with Bhandari? I am talking about companies like Foxconn and Wistron crawling back to China after their horrible encounters investing in India. It was even more true during the worst of Covid when companies crawled back to China anyway.
@@cecaloather8701 I mean, how is investing in China any good. The rules are too opaque, you can't pull the money out when you need. Your leader is megalomanic involved in fights with everyone else, so the western investors are rightfully apprehensive about their capital. You have a very high unemployment rate among youth now, add to that the real estate imploding where all the Chinese middle class have invested their money. So, the national consumption will go down, I clearly know why you guys are cribbing as China has understood that their theory of "internal consumption" to maintain the economy would never work, you need exports to survive, so any country eating up that would be opposed by the Chinese. Why are your millionaires off shoring the money?? The first base of infrastructure will always be difficult and fraught with problems, India is going through that now. Once we get past that, it will be much better. Lot of Chinese cried about the phone assembly in India as well 5 years back, now look at the output of that, this even includes Chinese phone manufacturers. You can't expect to manufacture a 150 nm chip from the beginning, it's a slow process and we will get there b
@@cecaloather8701 I added Bhandari's history as he projects too much. He believes that everyone is corrupt because his own sister cheated him out of his ancestral property. So he feels cheated by the system which is a rightful feeling on his part. I sympathize with his situation but the problem is Bhandari offering sweeping statements without living in India for the last 10 years. Again, what's his credentials? He got a MBA long back and worked as some middle level manager, if he's willing to publicly post his investment record,I'll take him seriously. He's apparently a "mining" consultant and talks about investing in "gold", he's such a boomer in his takes and hardly understands supply chain, operations or technology
I worked for a US multinational Corp. We have a subsidiary in Mumbai (the New York of India). We have spent the last 12 years trying to wind up that subsidiary. A simple winding up petition. It’s not adversarial, no unpaid creditors or adverse claims. Just a simple winding up petition. It has been 12 years - and no sign of resolution. The Indian bureaucracy is shocking, utterly lazy and corrupt.
Don't you know China still have restrictions on who can buy property in most major cities? People from other cities are not allowed. Also new propertie prices are foced by government to sell at about 60% of nearby 2nd hand properties，buyers take lottery to be qualified, at a rate of 3-5%.
@@vocvoc9895 Yeah, okay. So? China controls the movement of the population. That's why there is no slums in China. Go to any other developing Asian countries, you will find slums mostly inhabitted by people from out of town and their descendants.When the land owner want to use the land, then they have spend a lot of money to compensate these illegal settlers. The government cannot do anything because the politicians rely on the votes of these illegal settlers.
India is going down the drain. They will reserve 80% seats for second & third rate candidates while the meritorious people will move to USA. Other countries invite talent, India pushes out talent.
That could be true... But so does China give special privileges to tgeir ethnic minorities. If u don't want the ethnic minorities in india, give them their freedom ie the NE part of India.
WOW, Finally I can see an honest and brave person dare to stand the truth. Almost all Indians even foreign Indians had been denying their problems, always say Indians and India never wrong and forever no1. They even praised new Indian politicians who rised up and condemned the locals by needing Indian help. I salute this guy! He is honest and maybe a trustworthy person.
@@knottytoob Everyone has their own problems. But local in India always refused to face their facts and dodge the important reality. Foreign Indians has many types. Most still stubborn like their India relatives. The biggest problem is Indians slow at changing minds.
Indian Billionaire builds a $1 billion apt condo for his family next to a slum neighbor tells you all you need to know about India and its priority.....Its not for its own people well being that is for sure.
@@rayhuang6155 我是中国人。对不起我左看右看，真的不觉得文革在中国人民的历史整体上是一件好事。My own take is that, after the gigantic and murderous upheaval of the Cultural Revolution, the Chinese people were finally completely exhausted - sick and tired of the endless political campaigns, civil strife, bloodshed and torture. And they had been cold and hungry and frigtened for more than 10 years, now they just craved food on the table and safety in their homes, nothing else. For that, they were ready to work hard - VERY hard if needed - and work smart. Then in comes a visionary leader like Deng Xiao Ping and, BANG, the thing takes off. 至于文革有益地打破了传统习惯这个看法，我不敢苟同。
I lived in India for a few years, i remember drinking from a plastic straw which collapsed under the pressure of the liquid, it was only a straw in looks, Envelopes and stamps don't have enough adhesive but have the shiny look....Peoples word means nothing, how anything gets done is a miracle. Don't get me started on the bureaucracy....
She comes across as so upperty & condescending,(I’ve noticed others female presenters are doing the same, perhaps following instructions from Networks anti China bosses?) India needs to eat a slice of humble pie & stop trying to trash China to feel better, when your own yard is full of Trash, try to stop throwing it over the fence & just CLEAN up your own 💩 .. 🤨
then how does india have so many foreign investors and india bcame the 3rd largest economy ? looks like chinese ppl are becoming desperately stupid the way wuhan virus was handled in china by yearlong lockdowns. will be nice to see you guys in 10 yrs.
China is now 100 steps ahead of India although India is also moving forward. But in 5 years time when India has moved 50 steps forward, China will has already made another 80 steps more forward. That's meant in 5 years time China will be 130 steps ahead of India. Because China is not going just to stand still or fall asleep.
@@Deb_deCoder china already have most of it's Legos pieces in place, while India is trying to bulit piece by piece 🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩 get it???🤣🤪🤣
@@minhloi4536 no one is comparing current china with current india.. china is far ahead.. but everyone is rooting for india for the next 30 years.. india will be the world's largest economy by that time
@@Deb_deCoder bro you don't have a crystal ball, and you're not an expert. But i do hope Asia will rised in power. Just sick of the united States dictating the whole World.
Tim cook said it several times. China wasn't about cheap labour. Their effectiveness and efficiency is what made manufacturers think twice to move out.
PM Modi took office in 2014, just 2 years after President Xi. And except for the Ambanis and Adanis(nobody ever heard of him before 2014) the living standard of the people still remains the same if not worst. In fact the country has seen more divisions and crisis than ever before. Modi masters the art of delivering long speeches while Xi brought 600 million Chinese out of poverty.
Despite having similar population number at 1.4b India only have 672m workforce vs 931m for China. 48% Indian worked to support the others 52% unproductive population vs 66% Chinese worked to support the others 34% unproductive population. *India:* Population 1.4b Male 700m = 73% labor force participation rate Female 700m = 23% labor force participation rate (On par with Somalia, Pakistan, Palestine) Total workforce = 511+ 161 = 672m Literacy Rate = 69% *Educated workforce = 463m* Grain production = 330 million tons *China:* Population 1.4b Male 700m = 72 % labor force participation rate Female 700m = 61% labor force participation rate (On par with Canada, Netherlands, Israel) Total workforce = 504 + 427 = 931m Literacy Rate = 95% *Educated workforce = 844m* Grain production = 686 million tons
No one deny India has potential, it has always been like that. But anyone who think India can replace China in the next few years, they must be dreaming. It took China about thirty to forty years to get to where it is now, and that is with the legendary China speed too. India is notoriously slow and full of red tapes, they even have the term for it, the Hindu growth rate. Those factories and infrastructures can't be built overnight.
I am humbled and shocked by so many Indian comments in this section! I see the potential of this nation: self-awareness is the first step to growth and development.
PM of India are just a puppet of the India corporate Elites few %, Corrupted Politicians getting hand outs to look the other way, in all aspects of human rights of women & children, antiquated beliefs & religions... Indian millionaires owning factories, hiring children for pennies, but thinks nothing of having luxury houses & lavish million on weddings of sons & daughters... no wonder Democracy is thriving in India..🤨
As a Chinese I would like to say: more than 50 years ago, we are in a level of development with India, there are many patriots gave up generous treatment to return to the country to build, "two bombs and one star" of the 23 meritorious, 21 elite are overseas Chinese, which shows the development of society needs patriots, the need for national identity, if some of our motherland is not doing well enough, do not forget their own roots and national dignity, if you forget your own people you will not be respected by Western society, just a tool, we should not blindly denigrate their own country and ethnicity, as a Chinese I hope that the Indians, the whole world can live a better, more dignified!
Indians are doing very good in US. Also in China, my Indian business friends are doing very good. We have Lots of cute Chinese girlfriends too 😊 India as a country is shit. But we Indians as people are capable of doing good in any environment, just like the overseas Chinese did. I have lots of business in Shenzhen and Shanghai and really like modern China 🇨🇳 My fav leader in the world is Deng X.
Yes, like he said it..."for many many reasons"...I agree. But to deliver my opinion to lay person clearly, let me put it this way. China is already like a skyscraper. To build one, you can't have plenty of JUST cement or gravel. You must have others too like water, iron bars, sand, energy in electrical equipments and humans, etc. India's manager who's trying to build this skyscraper, though that size is all about it. India population can match that of China, and others to him is just by reflecting on the patriotic memoir of India's past civilization. Whimsical mentality...I call it. Land size, natural resources and population doesn't guarantee that you can easily strive smooth sailing. Being leader, you are first to instill the right of everything into your people, your culture and your vision. People - poverty, low level of education and skill training, not harmoniously living in diversity, adopt the right culture and sincerity in attracting foreign cooperation with neighbors or others...that is what the leadership should rectify first for startup. And this is simply the reason that perpetuated into branching out of reasons that makes it difficult to elaborate/summarize why India can't come even close to what China achieved. Even some FarEast or Southeast Asian nations that had and could challenge India could never come close to challenge China although some might had or have real good leadership but failed to mold the people into the right mode of culture in living, working, thinking and behaving...Not even the American are safe now with the might of China, their only challenge by their leadership now is through falsifying the real existence of China as evil. You can stop evil but you can't stop the force of goodness like China...of now. But nevertheless if this force of goodness turns bad as happened to others before, it is stoppable....just like huge empires in history. You simply have to embrace learning more about China and not growing anxiety towards China. Chinese in just China...mark that...not outside of China. This is very enlightening for those having an open unbiased minds.
India is a state assembled from many smaller states/kingdoms by British colonial rule. India only became a state in 1947 after gaining independence from Britain in 1947.
@@bobsmith3983 On the contrary....India was a region with numerous Kingdoms albeit its diversity of existence were all harmoniously living next to each other in solidarity, commercially trading with the Chinese from the Far East and Arabs & Persians from the middle east. They could co-exist until the European started to explore the world in effort to circumvent the Ottomans monopoly in trade. The Ottomans never invaded or colonised Asia...but the imperial west did... especially the Brits, strategizing their divide and conquer formula, they installed animosities throughout Asia, not just India...their reputation of being the no 1 colonizers with the most land invaded is by no co-incident but by that golden rule. And with European plot of 3G, they although rival each other (Spanish, Dutch, French,etc) in establishing their East Indies companies divided Asia & Africa and also the Americas between themselves. That's how these animosities grew over the centuries, installing borders never existed before and "patriotism" to ensure the rest of the world is jungle that European could continue to be in control. It's a secret precision scheme stemmed from the crusade...to be exact, the Knights of the Templer. So, again...I say, the British didn't assembled India. It created India out of the region's divide and conquer. The word India was never there in the first place. Just like the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, etc. It's easy to understand the history they thought us in schools but it is not so for those of resilient minds, because living facts don't lie to them and they're quick to be triggered where some narratives goes against what is clear to them. British and the west didn't build or assemble and time by time the truth is coming boldly out especially in these times of advent communication.
He is telling the truth and he traveled the world and doing consultations work because of this he knew exactly what is happening to India compared to China. The truth is, the success of China in IT, 5G, Ai, jet engine and high speed rail just to name a few because they have so many scientists that work so hard to compete to the world especially U.S.
Brutally honest but true. Infrastructure in India is what defines a third world country. For context, the govt owned telecom BSNL is still relying on 3G network that too with a 2G speed most of the time. The govt from top to bottom is viciously corrupted.
To the Chinese, they dont mind that India like other Western world thinks China is still poor and weak. China's rise is good for China and Chinese to enjoy and prosper who cares if what others think of China as long as they don't make troubles for China and Chinese.
Countries that lead the world in 44 critical technology* sectors: 1. China = 37 2. USA = 7 3. UK = 0 4. Germany = 0 5. Japan = 0 *In fields like defence, space, robotics, energy, the environment, biotechnology, artificial intelligence (AI), advanced materials and key quantum technology areas Source: Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI) **India leads the world in the field of cow husbandry, which is neither a technology nor critical
The dishonesty in India and intricate attrition in the work culture is actually a result of deep sitting distrust amongst the people. Cast is a main issue in my opinion.
China helped India established their first Rail University in 2014. India sent their rail way employees to training in China last 10 years. CRRC invested and cooperated with India companies manufacturing the trains. There are lot India metros and infrastructure projects are built by China made equipments, designed and technology. The heralded of both countries are the border dispute which planted by Britain colonists master in 1914. Now both countries suffered from the colonists heritage. Both countries kept peace thousand years until British colonial officers McMahon and Johnson drawn a illegal border lines between China and India in 1914. McMahon line and Johnson line are illegal based on international law.
Another factor ignored by the west is the Chinese government's focus on eradicating corruption. It is not just a punch line as there is strong enforcement for those guilty of corruption. That is something unfortunately very difficult for India to eradicate.
Harsh but truthful. I have work with Indian for so long, 15 years ago they have a good work ethic but now days they seems dont care any more, bad work ethic, bad attitude, bad planning, bad result, bullying, and over selling their own capabilities (note: i am Indonesian)
bukan makin baik malah tambah parah kah? bbrp thn lalu teman saya pernah order packaging utk produk kopinya awalnya bagus utk samplenya tapi begitu sdh deal eh beda jauh dari samplenya mana nggak bisa tukar krn beragam alasan
Chinese people are humble, hardworking and far-sighted. It is easier for them to see the essence of anything and take the right measures. Many Westerners look at projects that can be measured by numbers and compare those numbers with India and conclude that India is the next China, but have no idea why China has always been able to get the right response in the last 40 years or whether India can do it.
Merely 2 years ago, lndian economy shrank by a negative -8.6%, one of the worst performing economies in the world. lndian economy is highly fragile and unpredictable
Now, As per IMF and World Bank, India is the fastest growing major economy in the world. In 2022, GDP growth rate of India was 9.1% while growth rate of China was only 2.9%.
The people/culture are totally different; Chinese have a shared group identity for common prosperity based on hard work (no class system); India has a class system which puts a built-in limitation on how far you can go if you're born in the wrong class!
To compare India with China is an insult... China is on another level by its own , which no other country can compare with.. India is unfortunately comparerable to Zimbabwe..Philippines.... Nigeria ...
People often think that China's success in the past 40 years is simply because of the cheap labour. Then they will imagine India can do that too. That is a big fundamental mistake. China's success is much more complicated and particularly the government guidance and effective execution of clear visionary plans were very important. Not just once or twice but repetitively over a few decades.
China's power comes from Chinese character
Yes, it is all about careful planning, execution plus lot of hard works and sacrifices. Definitely not a miracle like the West or MSM like to emphasize. The funny thing is Indians believe it, so they just waited for this miracle to fall from the sky day after day, years after years......LOL
Unlike China, india never had a regular 5 year plan and sticking to it come rain or shine.
Like the proverbial snake indians tend to bend and twist when the situation does not favour them or become negative.
There's no preservance in the indian mindset.
Plus the average IQ of the Chinese people is >104 which makes for a highly intelligent and skilled work force. The average Indian IQ is 76.
Guys, I am Chinese. Let us not disrespect Indian people, many of whom are hard-working and intelligent people. Their government is what is holding them back big time. We are all humans, let us not sow division amongst each other. And also realise that the success of one (China) does not mean the failure of another (India, or US for that matter). As the Chinese always say, a win-win situation is the goal. Unlike in the west where you need to degrade/conquer/colonise another in order to succeed, which is a really foolhardy zero-sum mentality that comes from a scarcity mindset.
This dude is realistic and is focus on truth and facts, not delusional self interest, but doing his job for real. India's problem is laziness and scam culture.
In any working environment the indian mindeset is to do the minimum effort to obtain the agreed remuneration. Its all in the indian mind....sloth and laziness becomes a perpetual circle and its infectious.
Indeed the scam culture, esp. call centres, shamelessly rakes in 30 billion USD from the anglosphere without the govnmt's intervention or crack-down.
I was in New Delhi for exhibition at the Exhibition Centre Pragati Madan before Covid-19. An Indian that I have met in one of the Indian exhibition booths and he told me this when we were discussing and comparing Indian and Chinese products. I was surprised what he told me. He said "The Chinese they are learning very fast from us Indian. In the next 20 years times they will sure be catching up with us" I just smiles and said of course, India is already a global superpower and China is still a developing country. He seems so happy with my replied to him.
This Indian Jayant Bhandari will be hated by most of his own Indians if more Indians have watched this video discussions. Because most Indians hate to listen to such negative comments about India even if it is truth and logical. Indians love to listen to other praising them like calling India superpower, India is the greatest, India in 20 years ahead of China, lndia is world leader, etc.....
Indians prefer to listen to sweet words instead of listening to the truth from facts.
We should nevertheless admit that India is progressing steadily though at a slower pace. For example it has been able to land a rover on the south pole of the moon. India needs to be congratulated for this prowess.
@@richardlee-z9ppraising indian for the moon vehicle success is correct. But also should remind them it is a limited success with help from other who have ulterior motives. India still needed to face all the real life problems of economic development by not creating enemy, they cannot afford it.
@@richardlee-z9p Didnt you read they didnt land on the south pole as pointed out not too long ago by China top space scientist and an australian has also agreed with the chinese scientist calculations. Landing on the southern hemisphere is not landing on the south pole. The chinese scientist has written to indian space agency but have not received their reply so far.
He is not alone. I do meet Indians with similar viewpoint like him.
India is at least 70 years behind China. When I was at school, I learned the Ganga River was the most polluted river in the world in the Geography class, that was 30 years ago. 30 years later, the river is still one of the most polluted in the world. That tells you something about the progress of India. One the other hand, China has changed so so so much, every time I visit China on business, it's changed beyond recognition. I believe India will eventually catch up with China in terms of national strength, but China has already moved on to another level.
but how can it sustain the growth; population of china has aged, and no competent free minded person is ready to move to china. china is never going to grant permanent residency or equal rights to migrants. during ww2, north korea was the most developed country, we all see what happened after that.
more like 17 years...
India GPD/cap in 1970 - $112
China GDP/cap in 1970 - $113
^^^ They where equal.
India GPD/cap in 1980 - $267
China GDP/cap in 1980 - $195
^^^ Then cultural revolution bring China Down.
India GPD/cap in 1990 - $368
China GDP/cap in 1990 - $318
^^^ China start catching up after Deng reforms.
India GPD/cap in 2000 - $443
China GDP/cap in 2000 - $959
^^^ China pull ahead 2x
India GPD/cap in 2010 - $1458
China GDP/cap in 2010 - $5618
^^^ China extend the gap. 4x
India GPD/cap in 2020 - $1901
China GDP/cap in 2020 - $10500
^^^ Even bigger gap. 5x
@@johnsmith-cw3wo ok mr astrologer. hope you get your 10 yuan as promised.
People joking the Ganga river is the periodic table of chemical elements. The place they bath, washing clothes, drink, also as a open toilet on the banks, why they don't biuld toilet instead of going moon?
your statement is correct if China is standstill not moving a step forward in the next 70 years.
Finally an Indian who can see India accurately. Modi should consult him.
作为一个中国人，我认为他对印度的评价有点太刻薄了，我猜他一定是在印度经历了很大的投资失败......
Indian are not stupid...it is not that they don't know...they can't change because of the politic...and the history...and because they don't want to change ..
@@kexinzhu1104hmm yup
Although I too agree that his evaluation of India is a bit too harsh I don't think it stems from bitterness or resentment but rather from a sense of urgency amid the helplessness of the multitudes, and of frustration. I too hail from that country and looking at the country it's hard to disagree with him. While I can accuse him of his pessimistic views, India always tends to prove them right. @@kexinzhu1104
@@kexinzhu1104 as a Indian I'll say he's being brutality honest
That’s true. We are an American based company with several branches over 10 countries, but the scale is not very large. We have entered the Indian market for nearly four years. Recently, we have to lose all our profits because of an inexplicable huge fine. Almost the whole project is a loss.
I'm not involved in any business in India, but I've often heard of the bureaucracy of India enough to make business operations there difficult.
You earn money in India and spend every penny in India. There is no way to bring a penny back to your own country...Chinese proverb. Too many Chinese companies have been fined by the Indian government for various strange reasons like you. My American friend...🤣
That is a policy from a corruption of the highest level. They just lie and created some kind of change, or some kind of law and study and wrap all the falling companies profit like I’ll telephone company Nagesh show me Volvo they have lost the same thing.
no, it's not about bureaucracy at all.
It was a fraud at the first place.
Indians talk to you warmly, they promise you many things such as tax free policies, cheap land ...once you bring your money into India, your nightmare starts, they will find any excuse to take all your money...
Because you did not bribe Indian officials🤣🤣🤣🤣
Finally, an Indian who thinks for himself and sees reality. Hats off to you for your independence…..
India is a developed country, and will very soon take over the US as the world number 1 super power. The whole country (cities, towns, villages) are vastly clean, very modern and futuristic, with zero crime rate and absolutely zero pollution. There are no slumps, shit-holes, ghettos or poor uneducated hungry people in any corner of India. Each and every Indian is well educated, dead honest, equally wealthy and prosperous. Its democratic government is immensely effective, totally clean and corruption-free -- proven by the country's consistent zero unemployment for decades. Its police force holds the reputation of having the highest global standards of integrity, is very clean, corruption-free, humane, competent and professional in their jobs - they don't take bribes, they don't extort money, they don't protect scammers or organized crime, they don't rape young women or beat ordinary citizens brutally on the streets with batons or long rods like what you usually see in bollywood movies. Its judiciary system has stellar track records where judges had solved and closed all legal cases as quickly as the blink of an eye. Public utilities, public transportation, public education and notably its public toilets are all ranked first in the world. And, in case you're not aware of yet, India proudly has the world largest public toilet freely available for everyone - the Ganga River, where people can conveniently take a bath, pee and poop at the same time in one go. And you should know too that public safety in India is much better than any other countries in the world - very very safe for women to walk alone at night.
this stooge is a paid actor sitting in south east asia on CCP yuan not an indian.
India has opportunity but holy smoke the amount of Chaos that is deeply embedded and intertwined into everything and tolerated is on a whole different level.
he is anti hindu propagandist.
He is extremely a RADICALIZED Indian hater 😅
I'm glad Jayant is is telling the truth about India as opposed to Western Media projecting false information in the name of geopolitics. Perhaps Modi should come clean with the truth instead of playing geopolitics. India needs a genius of Lee Kuan Yew to progress. India desperately needs Jayant's consultant service.
India is a developed country, and will very soon take over the US as the world number 1 super power. The whole country (cities, towns, villages) are vastly clean, very modern and futuristic, with zero crime rate and absolutely zero pollution. There are no slumps, shit-holes, ghettos or poor uneducated hungry people in any corner of India. Each and every Indian is well educated, dead honest, equally wealthy and prosperous. Its democratic government is immensely effective, totally clean and corruption-free -- proven by the country's consistent zero unemployment for decades. Its police force holds the reputation of having the highest global standards of integrity, is very clean, corruption-free, humane, competent and professional in their jobs - they don't take bribes, they don't extort money, they don't protect scammers or organized crime, they don't rape young women or beat ordinary citizens brutally on the streets with batons or long rods like what you usually see in bollywood movies. Its judiciary system has stellar track records where judges had solved and closed all legal cases as quickly as the blink of an eye. Public utilities, public transportation, public education and notably its public toilets are all ranked first in the world. And, in case you're not aware of yet, India proudly has the world largest public toilet freely available for everyone - the Ganga River, where people can conveniently take a bath, pee and poop at the same time in one go. And you should know too that public safety in India is much better than any other countries in the world - very very safe for women to walk alone at night.
I respect him, first hand knowledge of China. He went to China and saw the truth of China progress despite all the sanctions imposed by the US and its western allies.
Jayant's consultant, I salute your views and comparison between India and China. India government must learn from China and have good relationships with China and South East Asian countries.
I am surprised why Modi lets him live!
@@zhoubaidinh403 because India don't kill who speaks against them like tiananmen square massacre 😂
Modi is good enough. Dont blame him. His foreign strategy indeed shows the geopolitical power of india.
Having been involved in setting up manufacturing plants and operations for MNC the last 30+ years in Asia, I regarded Jayant the right expert on India as he is so horribly HONEST and sincere! Mr Jayant, I Salute you after witnessed the dozens of foreign investments collapsed in India.
I love this guy, who tells the truth bravely.
Imagine if this guy were Chinese.... :)) The comment section would be full...
this fellow (rogue )is another fellow who is in the abuse india business ,
india influence is seen far and wide ,all across asia ,china etc ,
and this fellow calls us all kind of names .
Truth hurts?
@@BabaYaga826 please listen to prof mahbubani ,who is of indian orgin
what he has to say about india and china ,both these countries
will control about 45-50 % of world gdp . abuse dogs like this bandhari
should be put in the dog house , i agree with you truth hurts , hurts
whome is that question , again listen to prof mahbubani from singapore
also a diplomat for 30 long years , close connections with china .
@@BabaYaga826 the truth is indian influence is far and wide across
south asia ,across india , this bandari (rogue ) is nothing but a
scoundrel demeaning a great country .
Jayant currently lives in San Francisco as he stated. I was just wondering why smart Indian like him wouldn't want to go back to India to help build India. Practically all indians who left the country don't want to go back home, they prefer to live in the west simply they couldn't stand the pollution, corruption and 3rd rate education system back home. All the big U.S. company CEOs are of Indian descent, i.e. Google, Microsoft and IBM just to name a few. On the contrary, most of western educated Chinese who graduated from MIT, Harvard, Stanford and Caltech return back to China to help build the country, that's another reason why India will never be the next China.
101% CORRECT!
I live in the San Francisco Bay Area and have worked in Silicon Valley over 4 decades and have worked with South Asians over that period and EVERY LAST Indian/South Asian HAS ABSOLUTELY NO INTENTION OF EVER RETURNING TO INDIA/SOUTH ASIA BECAUSE THEY HAVE COMPLETELY GIVEN UP ON INDIA.
At the very first opportunity of gaining full legal residency status ALL of the Indians/South Asian bring over their parents and grandparents and brothers and sisters and whoever else they CAN.
The offspring of Indians/South Asian migrants that arrived in the 1980s now have their own children and the offspring and their children will never NEVER EVER return to to India/South Asia as the United States is COMPLETELY their homeland now.
Thanks to those Indians who do not love their mother land. And gaveup their passport. We can do without them. China is no democracy freedom of speech is more important than some small economic numbers in stocks. Last 5 years free food to 1.4 billion people very few will achieve.
He said he made a lot of investments in India, then eventually completely withdrew all his assets and money. I'm sure he was frustrated with the bureaucracy, absence of ease of business" lack of infrastructures, lack of competent employees, etc..
If all the big U.S. company CEOs are of Chinese descent, i.e. Google, Microsoft and IBM just to name a few, Chinese would not return to China to help build the country. Trust me, I am Chinese. Chinese return to China is because we are being targeted and marginalised by US government intentionally. Ask Trump why.
After years of "growth", lndia's per capita GDP now falls behind Bangladesh. The only growth in lndia is population
Not gdp, maybe ur talking about gdp per capita or gdp growth rate. In terms of Gdp India's gdp is 3.7 trillion usd whereas bangladesh gdp is 1.13 trillion, so it's almost 3 times larger
No. India's GDP per capita is more than Bangladesh.
lndia is known as the cemetery of foreign firms.
2783 foreign companies shut India operations since 2014.
These include Metro AG, Holcim, Ford, General Motors, Royal Bank of Scotland, Citibank, Harley-Davidson, Huawei, among others.
Yah be cuz when I saw their business it’s just to expensive their product they sell to Indians so no sale u lose
In the late 90s, one of my Japanese clients, a conglomerate, set up their R&D centre in India and spent about over USD20 million. After 3 years they moved to a country in South East Asia. The directors told me, it's a great mistake for them to set up the centre in India, the level of corruption, bureaucracy, work ethic, infrastructure, hygiene, environment etc. were unbearable 😂😂😂
They should have done their homework independently.
*The incredible! superpower! indian! "bullet train" that Japan is giving loans for HAS TURNED INTO A UNMITIGATED MASSIVE HEADACHE FOR THE JAPANESE.*
*After Japan lost the Indonesian Jakarta to Bandung High Speed project to China, Japan was heell-bent to not lose another project so Japan offered incredible! superower! india! a VERY sweetheart loan package which Japan would make a loan that would pay 80% of the 14 BILLION U.S. dollar Ahmedabad to Mumbai High Speed project AT A 0.1% INTEREST PAID OVER 50 YEARS. It was SUPPOSED to be completed and opened by 2023.*
*OF COURSE NO SURPRISE, due the USUAL DEMANDS of bribes AND HUGE CHANGES DEMANDED BY POLITICIANS AND BABUS THAT HAS DEVOLVED INTO FULL BLOWN "feature creep" AND "scope creep" the cost of the high speed project has now jumped to over 22 BILLION dollars and will SUPPOSEDLY IN THEORY now be completed by 2030........AND THE incredible! superower! indians! ARE DEMANDING JAPAN EXTEND MORE LOANS TO COVER THE RISING COSTS......the Japanese media has repeatedly reported that Japanese involved in the project ARE FURIOUS......*
*incredible@ superpower! india! got rid of their "Licence Raj" ONLY TO DEVOLVE INTO A FULL BLOWN KLEPTOCRACY.*
don't spread lies on behalf on ccp
they wrongly thought the cheap labour would made up for the other issues.
90s india is very diff..we have had a new govt with better vision and better resolve since 2014 and its quite stable.
China is developing so much faster than India, basic algebra taught us, the longer the time, the farther India lags behind China, therefore India cannot be like China foreve
seems chinese ppl are buying into all the info warfare thats the CCP is subjecting them to, now that china is declining. this chap is a paid indian actor..
@tzensco4953 * : Forget India , for your good health and longevity remember China for your good mindset Always Chant China China China 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳😂🌈🎤🌈🌈🔭🥁🎶📚📢❤️🌹🇨🇳👌👍💐.
That makes no sense. Developed countries eventually stop spending as much because they don't need as much any more. That's why growth is usually greatest in developing countries.
@@bohrsmodel81659 * : China is no Genocide U.S. and EU Western Alliances nation Dacoits Gangsters . China will Never Stop Development as is natural phenomenon in Cyclic momentum Synchronous Systems incorporated with laws of motion .
China & India are both developing countries, there is nothing to do with developed countries, thank you! @@bohrsmodel81659
Fun data:
India's share of global GDP in 1947- 5 %
China's share of global GDP in 1947- 4%
India's share of global GDP in 2023 - 5 %
China's share of global GDP in 2023 - 20%
In the past India was part of British Empire,that's why her GDP could be so high.....
India's share of global GDP is around 3% only @@peterg0
Scammers are 90% indians.😂😂😂
you will make mistake if you think of india as similar to china.. india has multi-party democracy, unlike chinese single party autocracy.. india had weak congress govt for most of the prev 70 years.. but now india got a strong hindu govt.. after 1000 years of foreign and weak rule.. you can see within their 8 years rule, people all over the world are talking about india.. so you can imagine what this govt can do in 50 years.. India will surpass china in 50 years.. and not today's china, it will be china 50 years later
@@Deb_deCoderChina's current GDP is US$19.6 trillion. India’s current GDP is $3.7 trillion. India and China both have a population of 1.4 billion, but the gap in GDP is huge. Even if China stops growing now, it will take India 18 years and growing at an annual rate of 13% to catch up with China's current GDP level. In addition, China is still growing at an annual rate of 5%. China's current output value is very large, while India's current output value is very small. China has also developed from poverty and backwardness more than 30 years ago to the present. I wish India economic growth and prosperity.
This chap is brilliant. How come I haven’t heard of him before. I went to India once for 2 weeks and I am not going back. Uninvestable.
Did you goto sell drugs ?
No one in India is waiting for your visit.There are many who want to invest in India.
@@sandipkamat5604 India govt should invest in building more sanitary facilities, so that people wouldn't have to pee and defecate publicly.
@@ButchCassidyAndSundanceKid Yes you are right. It is a problem and does no good for India's image.
@@sandipkamat5604 India should spend the money on building toilets, education rather than on its space programme. The Indian government is good at making fame projects which look good on the outside, but completely hollow on the inside. Stop comparing to China which is on god level when it comes to overall development on education, infrastructure just to name a few (I'm sure India has things that are superior to China). Get India to a place where all the overseas indians would want to come back, live and build the country. Indians are proud of the fact that a lot of the big western company CEOs are of Indian descent, at the end of the day they're merely an employee (albeit higher up on the food chain), they're supporting organizations that were built by the west, with the finances in the west and technical knowhow of the west. It brings no benefits to an ordinary Indian living in India. That'd be my heartfelt advice to all the Indians.
Finally a honest and rational Indian
India can only be the next India , not China, Not USA, not Japan, etc....
Indian can at least be the greatest braggart of the world: Great boast, small roast.
Or may be it become ...... honestly I could not find any worse!
nope, India next will be Bharat🤧
@@xiaoyuvax at best😜
Yes keep low
Just like the bullet train project that faces delays,land acquisition,corruption,other projects face same problems,highway project from Maharashtra to Goa,Karnataka,Kerala,Tamil Nadu of 1600km is still not completed in 11 years due to same problems,land corruption
My first visit to India travelling from South to North and into Pakistan in 1960.
About twelve years ago I spent a day in Mumbai their most prosperous city. What I seen in the streets shocked me. Apart from some modern skyscrapers and luxurious mansions where the rich live. Majority of the streets and shop houses were dilapidated and beggars and homeless everywhere, cows and vehicles rickshaws mingled in over congested and dirty streets. reminiscent of what I saw more than sixty years ago!
India cannot even build enough toilet as a human basic right for his people as the link provide here {what a shame} #opendefecation
Spot on. That is the real India.
The old China was of no different from today India as described by Mr. Jayant Bhandari. Most Chinese who have lived thru the old China would agree with me. So my question is why China and Chinese changed so drastically? Are these changes permanent or just a temporary phenomenon?
@@orangutan4696 You are Orangutan, cannot understand the Chinese change for the better is long term?
India would be lucky not breaking up into multiple states, let alone becoming the next China.
I always find such statement like "India will catch up to China or overtaking China" amazing. If you think China is now at its peak in development or advancement, you have seen or learned nothing yet. At this rate, by the time India has reached the level of China today, they would be more than a century behind.
*No British East Asia Company = No incredible! superpower! india!*
Keep telling yourself that 😂😂
b,b,but China's AI core technology lags behind that of US and the west as a result of lack of AI talents and heavy Government regulations
@@ajay262134India is going down the drain. They will reserve 80% seats for second & third rate candidates while the meritorious people will move to USA. Other countries invite talent, India pushes out talent.
@@mostupdate8802India is inherently a failed state whereas the overseas ethnic Indians are doing much better especially those Indian Singaporeans who are "over represented" owing to their diligence, intelligence & right attitude. SEA & Eastern Europe would be better option compared to a failed state called India. The comments of this Indian born are very objective.
. Not unless India can produce "4.7 million high standard STEM graduates" yearly and employees willing to work 12 hours if needed to reach it's production target deadline,
, "India can never be the next China."
Over 10.000.000
Wouldn't the recent experiences of Foxconn and Apple tell us the true situation in India? Though I wouldn't blame Modi, he is the chief salesman and only real sales is speeching.
@@PahatRout True. Foxconn lost huge sum of money because India STEM graduates/worker's production gives out more than 50% defective.
. Both Foxconn and Apple are returning back to China.
,,, but they have a big problem Huawei's 5G Satellite phone is selling like hot-cake.
Ask Foxconn....withdrawing from India and many more....closing down
@@limabc2009 lol foxconn doubled their initial investment in india.. you guys are in denial man 😅
Thanks for giving us the Truth, the whole Truth and nothing but the Truth... Truth you cannot get from India or Western media.
China's success is being it's leadership's policies and the citizens's intelligent, skills workholic that makes the country move forward.
Please remove leadership's policies.BTW I am a Chinese.
Yes very ture. Leadership's policies are the most important factors .BTW I am a Chinese.
Yes, the wisdom of the Chinese leadership is really beyond the imagination of us ordinary people.
Singapore prime minister LKY: India is the country of the future, where the future NEVER arrives.... Hahaha lol lol lol
Its to hard to find someone with guts who dare to tell its as is. If India could be another China it had many years to accomplish it. India is at least a century if not more behind China and mostly in its skilled manpower sector.
If India is at least a century if not more behind China and mostly in its skilled manpower sector, today,
as stated in your comment; and China is not going to stop moving forward, in a century's time, when
India matched today's China, China will be two centuries ahead of India.
@@stevewang2stop consuming ccp propaganda. India is behind china sure but around 15 years. With the housing collapse and banking collapse in china the gap will be closed sooner than you think
The biggest problem in India is that people don't do things in a practical and realistic way, but just muddle along... There is no concept of efficiency in doing anything.This is a fatal flaw on the business level.
India is at least a decade behind where China was ... under Mao, back in the early 1950s. Mao's Cultural Revolution was brutal, but it swept away a lot of the old, non-progressive ways that would have hindered China's future and instituted the basic education and healthcare for human development. India lacks the concept of equality, and doesn't invest in people, so they will always be far behind.
No, India is indeed ahead of China by more than just twenty years.
Now, it has even surpassed China in terms of population, rightfully claiming the title of the world's number one.
He is right. I recently visited in India and I see no difference between India today vs 20 years ago. Similarly I visited China and I was surprised to see changes in China with great transport infrastructure - bullet trains and EV vehicles, EV charging stations almost everywhere..
Better see an ophthalmologist 😅
@@balajib1406India is still a shithole with poor sanitation, poor infrastructure, overcrowding, cows wandering on the busy streets and piles of commuters on the roof of trains. A picture of the dark ages.
@@balajib1406jealousy aint gonna get u where u wanna go. And the truth shall set u free, if u not gonna open your eyes to see, at least have an open mind to accept facts
@@balajib1406 --- you need to remove your rose tinted glasses.
@@KayyHong I am from India I know what is going on here! As for China, it's 50 years ahead of us, we can never catch up!
India may not be the next China. But America could be the next India. 😂😂😂
😁😁😁😁😁😁America could be the next India
It's getting there.
Hahaha
What a sad truth.😢😂😅
@@Walawala459 Canada already there.
The reason for the India euphoria is because simple-minded people focus on the fact that India's population is growing rapidly and India is a Western-style democracy. That's it. They ignore important things such as work ethic, national unity, human rights, and good governance. The Indian government has failed to unify the country because of ethnic strife. The Indian government has failed to protect and empower females and use them economically. The Indian government has failed to produce good infrastructure. The Indian government has failed to educate the masses. The Indian government is corrupt and burdened by enormous bureaucracy.
In other words, a simple-minded view of India that does not take real life conditions into account is bound to yield bad investment decisions.
Most important thing that these savages have not consumed is logic.
India is a developed country, and will very soon take over the US as the world number 1 super power. The whole country (cities, towns, villages) are vastly clean, very modern and futuristic, with zero crime rate and absolutely zero pollution. There are no slumps, shit-holes, ghettos or poor uneducated hungry people in any corner of India. Each and every Indian is well educated, dead honest, equally wealthy and prosperous. Its democratic government is immensely effective, totally clean and corruption-free -- proven by the country's consistent zero unemployment for decades. Its police force holds the reputation of having the highest global standards of integrity, is very clean, corruption-free, humane, competent and professional in their jobs - they don't take bribes, they don't extort money, they don't protect scammers or organized crime, they don't rape young women or beat ordinary citizens brutally on the streets with batons or long rods like what you usually see in bollywood movies. Its judiciary system has stellar track records where judges had solved and closed all legal cases as quickly as the blink of an eye. Public utilities, public transportation, public education and notably its public toilets are all ranked first in the world. And, in case you're not aware of yet, India proudly has the world largest public toilet freely available for everyone - the Ganga River, where people can conveniently take a bath, pee and poop at the same time in one go. And you should know too that public safety in India is much better than any other countries in the world - very very safe for women to walk alone at night.
And it's not that the Indian people are not capable. They're very capable when placed in a different environment, like UK, USA, Canada, Australia.
@@nulnoh219 Doesn't matter.
India cannot even build enough toilet as a human basic right for his people as the link provide here {what a shame} #opendefecation
INDIA IS THE COUNTRY OF THE FUTURE WHERE THE FUTURE NEVER SHOWED UP
Many parts of India didn't belong to this country before her master British's arrival......
India is a creation by the British, make up of many states and kingdoms in recent time. Only released to the world in 1947 as a freed new country. Never in history the present India ever existed.
...India will be the next Pakistan...Lol....
India has never been the world power in the last few thousands years
Before british came,this land full of many tribes and leaders,She was not a big country like China....and remember at that time the number of slaves more than their masters!How could they have a splendid civilization?
Only the world best bragger.
Still there was no hand pump.
India was never a world power or an empire. It was a state assembled from many smaller states/kingdoms by British colonial rule. India only became a state in 1947 after gaining independence from Britain in 1947.
You are right. Th elarge population does not mean much in India. It has never been a super power. It didn't have Civilization, even now.@@bobsmith3983
Kudos to an Indian talking honestly about China. Yoo-hoo, Palki, please take note.
Palki prefers to talk nasty words about China and sweet words about India to her Indian audience.
She cannot or is unable to bring herself to tell her Indian audience the truth from facts.
Palki is the one showing reality of china to the world which ccp hides behind big empty buildings 😂
@@stevewang2Palki....former WION's bitchy witchy...
Palki reflects a typical India view on China, a sour grapes mentality.
That palki chick is just amouth pie for the indian media. I watched some of her shows, very biased and full of propaganda stuff. She isnt interested in true journalism, she just wanna say what indians wanna hear. I really said some nasty stuff on her shows because spreading lies like she did is disgusting!
Shocked and relieved as an Indian there is yet another Indian who sees things the way they are
With riots in Manipur, separatists in Kashmir, Naxalite insurgency, Khalistani resentment, wrestler's protest, massive unemployment, rising farmers suicides, falling groundwater levels, communal tensions,religion politics,north-south india sentiments,uttar pradesh crime rate,poverty,bihar overpopulated,income gap,woman safety,global warming,infrastructure problems,train safety.
#107 in Hunger index
#161 in Freedom Press index
#126 in Happy index
#139 in GDP per capita
#132 in HDI index
#148 in Women, Peace And Security Index
10% earn
I feel bad for the farmers in India.
abdul chup reh, jyaada ucchal mat
You guys are so informed about confident that India 🇮🇳 is going no where
Good to have that atitude untill china claims your land in their new map
All their economy size is good and all because everyone is a slave of the rich duck
But nobody cares about poor good people , coz they don't have money to through at your face
China could do that
I am not yet sold
I am with my country
China got loads of problems , they just don't have people like you saying shits about themselves
@@stayfree870wumaos arent free
The two nations couldn't be more different. The Chinese are inspired by the way their leadership, combined with their cooperation, have lifted nearly a billion of them from abject poverty to prosperity within a generation. India is hamstrung by its millenia-long CASTE SYSTEM.
Oh you old , yeah I agree we have caste system.
And I thank the the father of all disputes in the world today and also India's caste Practice and government corruption after independence
To one and only god's own country sun never sets
Our dearest BRITAIN 🇬🇧
Thanks for bringing Jayat to the channel. The issues involved in moving manufacturing from China to India is oversimplified in the media.
My understanding is, they suffered so much losses in India, they crawl back to China anyway.
@@cecaloather8701not really, Jayant has an axe to grind due to his personal problems in his family back in India. It's like Gordon Chang's view on China
@@blackmamba9950 What does this have to do with Bhandari? I am talking about companies like Foxconn and Wistron crawling back to China after their horrible encounters investing in India.
It was even more true during the worst of Covid when companies crawled back to China anyway.
@@cecaloather8701 I mean, how is investing in China any good. The rules are too opaque, you can't pull the money out when you need. Your leader is megalomanic involved in fights with everyone else, so the western investors are rightfully apprehensive about their capital. You have a very high unemployment rate among youth now, add to that the real estate imploding where all the Chinese middle class have invested their money. So, the national consumption will go down, I clearly know why you guys are cribbing as China has understood that their theory of "internal consumption" to maintain the economy would never work, you need exports to survive, so any country eating up that would be opposed by the Chinese.
Why are your millionaires off shoring the money?? The first base of infrastructure will always be difficult and fraught with problems, India is going through that now. Once we get past that, it will be much better. Lot of Chinese cried about the phone assembly in India as well 5 years back, now look at the output of that, this even includes Chinese phone manufacturers. You can't expect to manufacture a 150 nm chip from the beginning, it's a slow process and we will get there b
@@cecaloather8701 I added Bhandari's history as he projects too much. He believes that everyone is corrupt because his own sister cheated him out of his ancestral property. So he feels cheated by the system which is a rightful feeling on his part. I sympathize with his situation but the problem is Bhandari offering sweeping statements without living in India for the last 10 years. Again, what's his credentials? He got a MBA long back and worked as some middle level manager, if he's willing to publicly post his investment record,I'll take him seriously. He's apparently a "mining" consultant and talks about investing in "gold", he's such a boomer in his takes and hardly understands supply chain, operations or technology
I worked for a US multinational Corp. We have a subsidiary in Mumbai (the New York of India). We have spent the last 12 years trying to wind up that subsidiary. A simple winding up petition. It’s not adversarial, no unpaid creditors or adverse claims. Just a simple winding up petition. It has been 12 years - and no sign of resolution. The Indian bureaucracy is shocking, utterly lazy and corrupt.
The efficiency is point!!! The procrastination of Indians is unimaginable...
India is the next somalia
I agree with Mr. Jayant that the Chinese government should let the property market correct itself. Short-term pain is much better than a long one.
When property market controlled by some capitalists or USA,you can't let it correct itself......
资本家犯的错不应该由底层人民买单 我们不是资本主义
chinese govt refused to bail out the evergrande crook and ordered him to use his own money to mitigate the problem
Don't you know China still have restrictions on who can buy property in most major cities? People from other cities are not allowed. Also new propertie prices are foced by government to sell at about 60% of nearby 2nd hand properties，buyers take lottery to be qualified, at a rate of 3-5%.
@@vocvoc9895 Yeah, okay. So?
China controls the movement of the population. That's why there is no slums in China. Go to any other developing Asian countries, you will find slums mostly inhabitted by people from out of town and their descendants.When the land owner want to use the land, then they have spend a lot of money to compensate these illegal settlers. The government cannot do anything because the politicians rely on the votes of these illegal settlers.
India is going down the drain. They will reserve 80% seats for second & third rate candidates while the meritorious people will move to USA. Other countries invite talent, India pushes out talent.
That could be true... But so does China give special privileges to tgeir ethnic minorities. If u don't want the ethnic minorities in india, give them their freedom ie the NE part of India.
WOW, Finally I can see an honest and brave person dare to stand the truth. Almost all Indians even foreign Indians had been denying their problems, always say Indians and India never wrong and forever no1. They even praised new Indian politicians who rised up and condemned the locals by needing Indian help.
I salute this guy! He is honest and maybe a trustworthy person.
India number one !
Could you expand on 'even foreign Indians had been denying their problems...'? Thank you and kind regards.
@@knottytoob Everyone has their own problems. But local in India always refused to face their facts and dodge the important reality. Foreign Indians has many types. Most still stubborn like their India relatives. The biggest problem is Indians slow at changing minds.
Indian Billionaire builds a $1 billion apt condo for his family next to a slum neighbor tells you all you need to know about India and its
priority.....Its not for its own people well being that is for sure.
It's 2 billion dollars not 1.
The more I see India, the more I realize why China initiated the Cultural Revolution.
你是中国人还是外国人?如果你能注意到“文化大革命”的意义，证明你是一个很智慧的人。正是文化大革命打破了中国传统的门阀习惯和意识，真正让中国成为平民社会而有今天的发展基础。印度的确需要一次文化大革命。😮
@@rayhuang6155 我是中国人。对不起我左看右看，真的不觉得文革在中国人民的历史整体上是一件好事。My own take is that, after the gigantic and murderous upheaval of the Cultural Revolution, the Chinese people were finally completely exhausted - sick and tired of the endless political campaigns, civil strife, bloodshed and torture. And they had been cold and hungry and frigtened for more than 10 years, now they just craved food on the table and safety in their homes, nothing else. For that, they were ready to work hard - VERY hard if needed - and work smart. Then in comes a visionary leader like Deng Xiao Ping and, BANG, the thing takes off. 至于文革有益地打破了传统习惯这个看法，我不敢苟同。
I totally agree with you.
@@rayhuang6155 我是華僑, 可是因為在紐約長大, 常跟老中交往.
@@hc1897
He is almost the best person I ever heard. Most of the US & Western economic speaker are mostly Fortune Teller.
I agree fully with Mr Bhandari on Indian situations.
This video is very realistic. The trend on UA-cam about hyping India and bashing China is ridiculous
I could not imagine any country who will never have a potential future than India, it is really a hopeless case and a hopeless place!
change the political system firstly and education next !
@@hyphoneto Its culture is hopeless, corrupt, superstitious, mob mentality, hygiene free!
I lived in India for a few years, i remember drinking from a plastic straw which collapsed under the pressure of the liquid, it was only a straw in looks, Envelopes and stamps don't have enough adhesive but have the shiny look....Peoples word means nothing, how anything gets done is a miracle. Don't get me started on the bureaucracy....
🤯
I'm sure Wion definitely won't invite him
Wion is created tpbslander China.
Hahaha no point to mention wion
Miss Palki's blood will boil if she watches this video
She comes across as so upperty & condescending,(I’ve noticed others female presenters are doing the same, perhaps following instructions from Networks anti China bosses?)
India needs to eat a slice of humble pie & stop trying to trash China to feel better, when your own yard is full of Trash, try to stop throwing it over the fence & just CLEAN up your own 💩 .. 🤨
@@seebauong9593 Host of firstpost?
@@areyouokay365 yep
The graveyard for investors.
No contract is ever fulfilled.
Rules laws are changed or even backdated to suit them.
then how does india have so many foreign investors and india bcame the 3rd largest economy ? looks like chinese ppl are becoming desperately stupid the way wuhan virus was handled in china by yearlong lockdowns. will be nice to see you guys in 10 yrs.
Shithole? Wow, this guy is brutally honest...tells it like it is. Respect.
China is now 100 steps ahead of India although India is also moving forward. But in 5 years time when India has moved 50 steps forward, China will has already made another 80 steps more forward. That's meant in 5 years time China will be 130 steps ahead of India. Because China is not going just to stand still or fall asleep.
you are telling this bs even after seeing the economic tragedy currently happening in china 😅
@@Deb_deCoder china already have most of it's Legos pieces in place, while India is trying to bulit piece by piece 🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩🧩 get it???🤣🤪🤣
@@minhloi4536 no one is comparing current china with current india.. china is far ahead.. but everyone is rooting for india for the next 30 years.. india will be the world's largest economy by that time
@@Deb_deCoder bro you don't have a crystal ball, and you're not an expert.
But i do hope Asia will rised in power.
Just sick of the united States dictating the whole World.
@@Deb_deCoder Nonsense.
As a Chinese, I accept rational opinions from both side, pros or cons.
this is not a rational opinion. just crappy drivel from a highly biased person. looks like we just saw an indian gordon chang.
Facts are not opinions..data is science.
Don't worry, some pro-American Chinese insist that there is something called democracy that can ensure that India develops better than China.
In dream land 🤣
You mean Gordon Chang?😂
I guess they have the right to believe in whatever pipedream they choose.
You mean bananas 😂
If China is really a democratic country then they should prove it. Y'all need VPN to even access simple platforms like UA-cam 😂😂😂
Tim cook said it several times. China wasn't about cheap labour. Their effectiveness and efficiency is what made manufacturers think twice to move out.
PM Modi took office in 2014, just 2 years after President Xi. And except for the Ambanis and Adanis(nobody ever heard of him before 2014) the living standard of the people still remains the same if not worst. In fact the country has seen more divisions and crisis than ever before. Modi masters the art of delivering long speeches while Xi brought 600 million Chinese out of poverty.
Modi can't do anything. Indians are the problem
Xi brought 800 million Chinese out of poverty
From : Singapore 🇸🇬
@@RAJPUT_SonOfKing
Indians are the problem. Modi is the greater problem.
From : Singapore 🇸🇬
Xiaomi knows Indian government very well😂
In the end ,the difference is between the Chinese DNA and Indian DNA according to Jayant .
Truth is hard to swallow. Takes courage to voice it.
Jayant is brave enough to speak out. I think it is not popular and politically right in India.
Despite having similar population number at 1.4b India only have 672m workforce vs 931m for China. 48% Indian worked to support the others 52% unproductive population vs 66% Chinese worked to support the others 34% unproductive population.
*India:*
Population 1.4b
Male 700m = 73% labor force participation rate
Female 700m = 23% labor force participation rate (On par with Somalia, Pakistan, Palestine)
Total workforce = 511+ 161 = 672m
Literacy Rate = 69%
*Educated workforce = 463m*
Grain production = 330 million tons
*China:*
Population 1.4b
Male 700m = 72 % labor force participation rate
Female 700m = 61% labor force participation rate (On par with Canada, Netherlands, Israel)
Total workforce = 504 + 427 = 931m
Literacy Rate = 95%
*Educated workforce = 844m*
Grain production = 686 million tons
Even if China remains stationary, India will not be able to catch up in 100 years
Oh cmon 😂
Lmao cope. Insecurities against India is insane among the Chinese.
@@AshishBagade-hv4elhe's right though
No one deny India has potential, it has always been like that. But anyone who think India can replace China in the next few years, they must be dreaming. It took China about thirty to forty years to get to where it is now, and that is with the legendary China speed too. India is notoriously slow and full of red tapes, they even have the term for it, the Hindu growth rate. Those factories and infrastructures can't be built overnight.
I am humbled and shocked by so many Indian comments in this section! I see the potential of this nation: self-awareness is the first step to growth and development.
India finally surpass China, in population.
This is something that India can be really proud of...
LMAO
@@michaelzm76we are ur fathers wumao
@@John_wick604 No, you have surpassed these. You are the King of Earth, the Lord of the universe！🤣
@@michaelzm76 wumao 😎 🥚 🚽🍺 some wizz soaked eggs ?
He should be the next PM of India. Great mind.
PM of India are just a puppet of the India corporate Elites few %, Corrupted Politicians getting hand outs to look the other way, in all aspects of human rights of women & children, antiquated beliefs & religions...
Indian millionaires owning factories, hiring children for pennies, but thinks nothing of having luxury houses & lavish million on weddings of sons & daughters... no wonder Democracy is thriving in India..🤨
he wouldn't want to be the PM even if you give him a trillion dollars 🤣🤣
Who will commit suicide😂😂
Why India?Make him President of the US or PM of UK.
As a Chinese I would like to say: more than 50 years ago, we are in a level of development with India, there are many patriots gave up generous treatment to return to the country to build, "two bombs and one star" of the 23 meritorious, 21 elite are overseas Chinese, which shows the development of society needs patriots, the need for national identity, if some of our motherland is not doing well enough, do not forget their own roots and national dignity, if you forget your own people you will not be respected by Western society, just a tool, we should not blindly denigrate their own country and ethnicity, as a Chinese I hope that the Indians, the whole world can live a better, more dignified!
Indians are doing very good in US. Also in China, my Indian business friends are doing very good. We have Lots of cute Chinese girlfriends too 😊 India as a country is shit. But we Indians as people are capable of doing good in any environment, just like the overseas Chinese did. I have lots of business in Shenzhen and Shanghai and really like modern China 🇨🇳 My fav leader in the world is Deng X.
Yes, like he said it..."for many many reasons"...I agree. But to deliver my opinion to lay person clearly, let me put it this way.
China is already like a skyscraper. To build one, you can't have plenty of JUST cement or gravel. You must have others too like water, iron bars, sand, energy in electrical equipments and humans, etc. India's manager who's trying to build this skyscraper, though that size is all about it. India population can match that of China, and others to him is just by reflecting on the patriotic memoir of India's past civilization. Whimsical mentality...I call it. Land size, natural resources and population doesn't guarantee that you can easily strive smooth sailing. Being leader, you are first to instill the right of everything into your people, your culture and your vision. People - poverty, low level of education and skill training, not harmoniously living in diversity, adopt the right culture and sincerity in attracting foreign cooperation with neighbors or others...that is what the leadership should rectify first for startup. And this is simply the reason that perpetuated into branching out of reasons that makes it difficult to elaborate/summarize why India can't come even close to what China achieved. Even some FarEast or Southeast Asian nations that had and could challenge India could never come close to challenge China although some might had or have real good leadership but failed to mold the people into the right mode of culture in living, working, thinking and behaving...Not even the American are safe now with the might of China, their only challenge by their leadership now is through falsifying the real existence of China as evil. You can stop evil but you can't stop the force of goodness like China...of now. But nevertheless if this force of goodness turns bad as happened to others before, it is stoppable....just like huge empires in history. You simply have to embrace learning more about China and not growing anxiety towards China. Chinese in just China...mark that...not outside of China.
This is very enlightening for those having an open unbiased minds.
The West is worried that China will treat them like the West treated the rest of the world.
India is a state assembled from many smaller states/kingdoms by British colonial rule. India only became a state in 1947 after gaining independence from Britain in 1947.
@@bobsmith3983 On the contrary....India was a region with numerous Kingdoms albeit its diversity of existence were all harmoniously living next to each other in solidarity, commercially trading with the Chinese from the Far East and Arabs & Persians from the middle east. They could co-exist until the European started to explore the world in effort to circumvent the Ottomans monopoly in trade. The Ottomans never invaded or colonised Asia...but the imperial west did... especially the Brits, strategizing their divide and conquer formula, they installed animosities throughout Asia, not just India...their reputation of being the no 1 colonizers with the most land invaded is by no co-incident but by that golden rule. And with European plot of 3G, they although rival each other (Spanish, Dutch, French,etc) in establishing their East Indies companies divided Asia & Africa and also the Americas between themselves. That's how these animosities grew over the centuries, installing borders never existed before and "patriotism" to ensure the rest of the world is jungle that European could continue to be in control. It's a secret precision scheme stemmed from the crusade...to be exact, the Knights of the Templer. So, again...I say, the British didn't assembled India. It created India out of the region's divide and conquer. The word India was never there in the first place. Just like the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, etc. It's easy to understand the history they thought us in schools but it is not so for those of resilient minds, because living facts don't lie to them and they're quick to be triggered where some narratives goes against what is clear to them. British and the west didn't build or assemble and time by time the truth is coming boldly out especially in these times of advent communication.
I am a Chinese, I want India doing well too as we can make money if they prosper. I hope that they can find out a way to develop consistently
Isn't UA-cam banned in China ?
@@mohba01So many chinese living outside china. They can access UA-cam
@@mohba01 VPN
I find that the Chinese are very positive and wish others well. It is one reason why China should lead the World.
He is telling the truth and he traveled the world and doing consultations work because of this he knew exactly what is happening to India compared to China. The truth is, the success of China in IT, 5G, Ai, jet engine and high speed rail just to name a few because they have so many scientists that work so hard to compete to the world especially U.S.
Brutally honest but true. Infrastructure in India is what defines a third world country. For context, the govt owned telecom BSNL is still relying on 3G network that too with a 2G speed most of the time. The govt from top to bottom is viciously corrupted.
Great video with Jayant as always telling the truth 👍🏻👍👍🏼
Indian enjoy their freedom and democracy, they don't need work, just enjoy
I don't understand how you can be productive and meet demand when your still in a very tribal environment. I just don't get it.
To the Chinese, they dont mind that India like other Western world thinks China is still poor and weak. China's rise is good for China and Chinese to enjoy and prosper who cares if what others think of China as long as they don't make troubles for China and Chinese.
Countries that lead the world in 44 critical technology* sectors:
1. China = 37
2. USA = 7
3. UK = 0
4. Germany = 0
5. Japan = 0
*In fields like defence, space, robotics, energy, the environment, biotechnology, artificial intelligence (AI), advanced materials and key quantum technology areas
Source: Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI)
**India leads the world in the field of cow husbandry, which is neither a technology nor critical
1967 wumao eyes
Wrong….India is almost 2 or 3 in almost all these 44 aspects
😢😢😢😢😂😂😂@@AshishBagade-hv4el
That's so sad about India's future for their people.
He really made his point
That is some blunt honesty right there.
The dishonesty in India and intricate attrition in the work culture is actually a result of deep sitting distrust amongst the people. Cast is a main issue in my opinion.
Yes, India is not the next China! India is the next US !!! Make Bharat great again !!!
China helped India established their first Rail University in 2014.
India sent their rail way employees to training in China last 10 years.
CRRC invested and cooperated with India companies manufacturing the trains.
There are lot India metros and infrastructure projects are built by China made equipments, designed and technology.
The heralded of both countries are the border dispute which planted by Britain colonists master in 1914. Now both countries suffered from the colonists heritage.
Both countries kept peace thousand years until British colonial officers McMahon and Johnson drawn a illegal border lines between China and India in 1914.
McMahon line and Johnson line are illegal based on international law.
indians triggered lol love it
Another factor ignored by the west is the Chinese government's focus on eradicating corruption. It is not just a punch line as there is strong enforcement for those guilty of corruption. That is something unfortunately very difficult for India to eradicate.
very honest and insightful
Harsh but truthful. I have work with Indian for so long, 15 years ago they have a good work ethic but now days they seems dont care any more, bad work ethic, bad attitude, bad planning, bad result, bullying, and over selling their own capabilities (note: i am Indonesian)
bukan makin baik malah tambah parah kah?
bbrp thn lalu teman saya pernah order packaging utk produk kopinya
awalnya bagus utk samplenya
tapi begitu sdh deal eh beda jauh dari samplenya
mana nggak bisa tukar krn beragam alasan
AMAZING interview where so much truth is said. Well Done Jayant.
Chinese people are humble, hardworking and far-sighted. It is easier for them to see the essence of anything and take the right measures. Many Westerners look at projects that can be measured by numbers and compare those numbers with India and conclude that India is the next China, but have no idea why China has always been able to get the right response in the last 40 years or whether India can do it.
India can never be the next China! Comparing India to China is already an insult to the latter !
😂😂😂
@@yongdeng1813chenk we are with ur women in Singapore Indian ur daddy
I’m an Indian and completely agree about Views on Indian economy ❤
Merely 2 years ago, lndian economy shrank by a negative -8.6%, one of the worst performing economies in the world.
lndian economy is highly fragile and unpredictable
Definitely
Now, As per IMF and World Bank, India is the fastest growing major economy in the world. In 2022, GDP growth rate of India was 9.1% while growth rate of China was only 2.9%.
Please help India's ambition to become the next superpower, so that the US will shift its attention to India.
I am imagining the face of Jai Shankar hearing this wise Indian businessman 😊
Jai Shankar would have a stroke.
Jai Shankar's three children are settled in the USA.
@@anewlife5846 lol
There is a reason why so much of India's top talent ends up outside of India. I hope one day India does regain its historical position in the world.
He's 75% right and 25% wrong. Things have changed a lot here.
He is not 75% right. He exaggerated a lot of things.
@Pain-zd5uo actually now he's 99% right.
The people/culture are totally different; Chinese have a shared group identity for common prosperity based on hard work (no class system); India has a class system which puts a built-in limitation on how far you can go if you're born in the wrong class!
不要低估印度，这个国家在这么多问题困扰之下，仍然发展出来了自己的核武器和登月项目，都是在无法获得外来支援的情况下做到的。