Episode #8. Work Sharp Professional and Elite side by side comparison +serrations tackled

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 49

  • @CuttingBoardRx
    @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +4

    Please watch (or rewatch) my other videos about these sharpening systems. I get awesome results, but that came with much blood and tears…

    • @heavyweightsound
      @heavyweightsound Місяць тому +2

      I can attest to that. After applying your fixes to the pro model I'm achieving much better edges

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому

      That’s awesome to know!

    • @MrCaissed
      @MrCaissed Місяць тому +2

      @@CuttingBoardRx I traded some knives and donated some for @theknifedr’s auction for 2 separate but necessary causes. I received 3 knives 2 Case knives and I keep cutting myself. Probably shouldn’t sip whiskey while sharpening blades. 😂

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +1

      Careful with them Cases! Every time you cut yourself, you gonna have to resharpen the knife! Their edge retention is great for slicing air, water, even occasional sandwich as long as it’s just Wonderbread and mayonnaise and you don’t press too hard. 🤣
      Sorry, hope you don’t take my humor the wrong way. On a serious note, steels like 8CR or lower, 420, 440, 12C27… don’t really require a diamond plate sharpener. And neither one of these WSPA’s will handle blades less than 3/4” wide very well.

    • @heavyweightsound
      @heavyweightsound Місяць тому +1

      ​@@CuttingBoardRx 😂 🤣 🤣 🤣 you're funny! I used to have a huge collection of case knives but they were just for show. Every one of them came with a huge Burr on one side I put them away for 20 years and ended up selling them this year for double and sometimes triple what I paid for them. Great investment!

  • @Cary-s1w
    @Cary-s1w Місяць тому

    Awesome! That knife has cut through tons of zipties, rope, wood, MRE bags, even some mud hut doors. Thanks for taking it on!

  • @achimgeist5185
    @achimgeist5185 Місяць тому +1

    I use diamond round and triangular files of various sizes and grits to sharpen serrated edges. Then a few strokes on the smooth side over a fine ceramic whetstone and leather with diamond compound.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому

      Great tips! Thanks for sharing and subscribing!

  • @TheBeater2382
    @TheBeater2382 Місяць тому

    I enjoy your take on anything knives. Little advice if I may. Being a viewer I like to watch high quality videos with GOOD LIGHTING. If you can shine some brighter light your video quality will increase and watching your videos will be much more enjoyable. Your content is much different and different which I like

  • @matthewmarek1467
    @matthewmarek1467 Місяць тому +1

    A thorough and informative overview. I've always wanted to try one of these, now I know I should just save up for the good one.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +1

      I’m going to try a Chinese system that looks a lot like TS Prof. Season 2 on my Sharpener show

  • @davidcoats1037
    @davidcoats1037 Місяць тому +1

    I’ve been using the Lansky system for years, long before WorkSharp existed. Simpler and much cheaper but same results. I did spring for a set of their Diamond stones. Much better.
    Thanks for the video! 😃👍🏼

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +2

      @@davidcoats1037 Sir, it is NOT actually much cheaper at $48. I had that system and it didn’t work out for me because it is just too primitive to achieve a mirror polish single-plain edge on anything harder than 57HRC. Also, if you drop the stone on a hard surface, it will detach from the plastic carrier and likely crack.
      If anyone is reading this thinking that buying Lansky red plastic box system for 50 or even 40 bucks is going to save them money, I predict they will end up spending almost as much on diamond stones like this Gentleman. That’s not taking into account the ruined blades that will pave your way to that decision.
      Sorry, didn’t mean to poo-poo your comment but if you never tried any other system, how would you know?

    • @Knivess0
      @Knivess0 Місяць тому +1

      I started on a Lansky and thought it was great..until I got serious. The fact that the rods can bend is a serious problem, as well as the lack of true angle finding within the set up of the system. Not only that, but I've seen and heard that most Lansky stones are not glued or affixed to their plastic molding straight, which will cause an uneven edge. Please, please save up for a Worksharp at least, or a KME.

    • @davidcoats1037
      @davidcoats1037 Місяць тому +1

      @@CuttingBoardRx lol I thought the same thing right after I sent it. I mean, I haven’t tried the WorkSharp so how would I know. Also I bought the Diamond stones much later so I didn’t take that into account on price so you are right again. The WorkSharp probably is a better and ultimately cheaper system. Feel free to delete my original comment. I don’t want anybody to get a bum deal.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +2

      @davidcoats1037 Thanks for both of your comments! I think it’s a good discussion to have in a public forum.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому

      @Knivess0 I had the same experience with the Lansky. Thanks for commenting!

  • @tombrown4683
    @tombrown4683 Місяць тому +1

    Im going to buy one of those fixed angle systems before too long. I'm just curious as I have been freehand sharpening for many years. Noticed the discussions about the Lansky. I bought one back in the last century. I gave up using the guided part of the system & just used the stone attachments freehand. That worked for me but of course no "super steels" to deal with back then.
    Thanks for the Benchmade cap. It was misdelivered to my neighbor but he brought it to me on a Sunday night before I started a job requiring 12 hour days 7 days a week. Finished that one so please forgive the delay. On the bright side, I should be able to afford one of ghose Benchmades now. Probably go second hand anyway, lol.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +1

      @@tombrown4683 Great to hear from you, Sir!

  • @mel87123
    @mel87123 Місяць тому +1

    Great instructional video!

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому

      @@mel87123 Thank you! It was a logical continuation of the other videos about these sharpeners that are in the mentioned playlist.

  • @MrCaissed
    @MrCaissed Місяць тому +1

    Hi CB I was going to buy one of those most likely the the less expensive. I use 95% of the time a backpack workshop except the strop. Thank you for this great information!

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +2

      @@MrCaissed Have fun with that! I have hacks for both of them in the playlist, do check them out once you get yours.

    • @MrCaissed
      @MrCaissed Місяць тому +1

      @@CuttingBoardRx oh great thank you 🙏 I bought my first knife from Remette. The RT -BEE but it’s the budget version with G-10 scales and 14c 28n steel. I changed the bevels to 15 degrees and it cuts tissue leaving sharp lines. Hanging it, not on a Cutting Board. It’s the new knife with a titanium tooth pick. I haven’t purchased from them before and they kept changing the delivery date and didn’t tell me. Not a good start. When I called to cancel and send it back it arrived the next day. Hmm 🤔 right.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +1

      @MrCaissed Remette is a brand that’s different from the rest of Chinese manufacturers.
      All their knives have a hit and a miss but I hope they succeed because it can’t be all WE and Kizer…

    • @MrCaissed
      @MrCaissed Місяць тому

      @@CuttingBoardRx I agree. Slap we on a knife and add $200 more than civivi. Of coarse better steel but they offer that same steel through civivi not so much with sencut. Well made but soft steel.

  • @BenCampbell-777
    @BenCampbell-777 Місяць тому

    Not much love for that small-blade table with the PPA :-) I've used mine successfully but I agree it is a pain and easy to screw up. I recently read that some people have used the Tormek small knife jig with Wicked Edge clamps, I wonder if it would work with the WS PPA. It's a bit expensive, but if it works, it looks like it would allow really low angles on really small knives.

  • @butchcassidy3373
    @butchcassidy3373 Місяць тому +1

    I use chain saw files to sharpen serrations and free hand the bevels.
    Getting tougher as i get older because of failing eye sight. Lol

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому

      @@butchcassidy3373 LOL. Let me guess, we are not taking some super steel knives here? More like Coast, Buck, Ka-Bar or Gerber?

    • @butchcassidy3373
      @butchcassidy3373 Місяць тому

      @@CuttingBoardRx no I do it with elmax too but it takes a while and I've got some diamond rods to do those with.

  • @kush662
    @kush662 Місяць тому +1

    Love this channel, 1st as always!

  • @kush662
    @kush662 Місяць тому

    What are your recommendations for attaining a mirror edge for a 8 inch kitchen knife? Mirror edge is more esthetically pleasing than practical and so is my cooking lol.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому

      I would start with no rougher than 400 grit and work my way through 600, 800 and honing plates before stropping with black and green compound. Alternatively, since kitchen knives are usually made of softer steel, you could use sand paper stretched over a leather strop to form a convex edge.

    • @balloonn2662
      @balloonn2662 Місяць тому

      @@CuttingBoardRxIf I buy the hapstone rs/ppa universal stone holder and buy the 4inch ceramic Worksharp stones just for lapping would that work and be worth the extra price I do have the money for it was just wondering if it’s worth it. Over the 6inch ceramic stone that cost 3x the price each considering they would just be used for ao lapping

  • @MikeyD8716
    @MikeyD8716 Місяць тому

    I feel like it’s just easier to freehand sharpen on Diamond plates.

  • @heavyweightsound
    @heavyweightsound Місяць тому +2

    Too bad worksharp ignores you. They need you on their payroll.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому +1

      I’ll take a pay cut but only after I retire 👍

  • @enwin1912
    @enwin1912 Місяць тому +1

    You can’t beat a Worksharp for polished consistency on the secondary bevel. Otherwise it’s stones on Scandi and beaters. Kudos to the wizards who can do it all on stones.

    • @CuttingBoardRx
      @CuttingBoardRx  Місяць тому

      @@enwin1912 I can now beat a Work Sharp Pro! Because I applied the famous CBRx hacks (see Episode #1 in the playlist!) LOL

    • @enwin1912
      @enwin1912 Місяць тому

      Ah yes, there’s another 7 episodes on conveniently stacked up. And after checking out Ep1 it seems like the ‘Pro’ actually means Prototype. Cool to point out the flaws, but wild to see u sort them out like that. Great stuff as per usual💯

  • @samuraiS30v
    @samuraiS30v Місяць тому

    I can sharpen those serrations

    • @Knivess0
      @Knivess0 Місяць тому

      Okay? So can I?

    • @samuraiS30v
      @samuraiS30v Місяць тому

      @@Knivess0 I am offering to sharpen them. Don’t be such a turd.

  • @Szyszka-df6xh
    @Szyszka-df6xh Місяць тому

    As always great video! Thanks a lot!