Echoes Live: Gdansk 2006 [Pink Floyd Reaction] One of These Days: PULSE 5.1 Surround - David Gilmour
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 чер 2024
- This reaction is our first time watching these Pink Floyd songs performed live. The 2006 live version of Echoes from Gdańsk, Poland, is the last time David Gilmour or Richard Wright ever performed this epic song. We also give a first-time reaction to One of These Days Live from Earls Court (PULSE 1994). Nick Mason joins for this one.
This is our first time seeing and listening to these performances. We are re-experiencing classic rock music, an album at a time, with fresh perspectives and active ears, so that Dev can learn and appreciate this music more, and so that Mike can relive his childhood.
00:00 - Introduction
01:36 - One of These Days
09:09 - Echoes
35:47 - Wrap-Up
🔔 Don't forget to subscribe to our channel!
/ musicforbusypeople
💲 Exclusive videos and more on Patreon - / musicforbusypeople
💲 PayPal tips - paypal.me/powerforbusypeople
Donations of $5 or more will receive recognition in our next video.
🎵 Reaction to One of These Days studio version - • Meddle: One of These D...
🎵 Reaction to Echoes studio version - • First time hearing Ech...
🎵 Reaction to Echoes Live at Pompeii - • Pink Floyd Live at Pom...
✅ Instagram - / gaming4busypeople
✅ Discord - / discord
This video contains clips of live performances:
🎸 One of These Days by Pink Floyd (PULSE 1994) - • Pink Floyd - One Of Th...
🎸 Echoes by David Gilmour (Gdańsk 2006) - • David Gilmour - Echoes...
#musicreaction #pinkfloyd #echoes #OneOfTheseDays #reaction #songreaction #firsttimereaction #firsttimehearing #firsttimelistening #firsttimewatching
© 2024 by Music for Busy People. All rights reserved.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
![Dark Side of the Moon: Side 1 [Pink Floyd Reaction] Breathe, On the Run, Time, Great Gig in the Sky](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GjHwUDQvVVM/mqdefault.jpg)
![Dark Side of the Moon: Side 1 [Pink Floyd Reaction] Breathe, On the Run, Time, Great Gig in the Sky](/img/tr.png)
![Echoes Live at Pompeii [Pink Floyd Reaction] 2016 mix - First time watching - SEE DESC FOR ORIG. MIX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7L0Ry5nlq8I/mqdefault.jpg)
![Shine On You Crazy Diamond [Pink Floyd Reaction] Parts 1-5, First time hearing Wish You Were Here](/img/n.gif)
Thank you to the following community members who subscribed after this video was published. We wish we could thank you all.
_t vo, TheSecretTreaties, Richard P., Robert C., Wayne M., chris b, Bill M., Eddie Criglington, irishlizzi3, debjorgo, Martin M., Matt W., Paul S., kratino, Ontariosound, littlepapa 10463, Theodore McS, David S., Ignacio C., rutgar64, Michael W., rudedogmat, lkras08, Ivan E. Iconic Guitar Repairs, George E, Nooce Luap_
You can almost hear Dave and Richard saying goodbye to each other in those last lovely final notes.
Masterpiece.
Never thought of it that way. Listened to it and kinda cried. 😢
How to say goodbye to a friend among friends. Beautiful.
This song (Echoes) is a musical gem! And this version from Gdansk is probably the best! Every time I hear the last vocal part, I want to cry - considering the lyrics and the fact that Rick was really seriously ill at that time, and yet he gave an absolutely great performance. No wonder after all that David will never play this song again.
The blonde bass player is Guy Pratt, he was Richard Wright's son in law, he has played on a lot of big star's tracks.
As a BIG P.F. fan the end of Echoes seem like Dave and Rick saying goodbye to each other. Roger said once that the first part was about humanity lack of empathy towards each other and the second part was about a rebirth when there was empathy towards each other. Lighting director Mark Brinkman said he had a challenge so all 100,000 people could she what was going on. Dave less is more and he said that this was song was the favorite to perform cause of Rick.
this version is just a masterpiece...and for pink floyd s fan very emotional when we see the final duet
*MUSIC 50 YEARS OLD* better than today.
Fantastic song, fantastic performance, fantastic reaction.
I noticed Dev had said they "borrowed" from Phantom on this one. It was actually the other way around, Echoes came out years before ALW wrote the music for Phantom.
Rick was singing with throat cancer of which he died of he still sounded great at the ending you can hear the goodbyes between David and Rick more emotion than usual
Mi spiace contraddirti amico ma nel 2006 Richard Wright non era malato o ancora non ne era a conoscenza e il cancro che lo portò alla morte due anni dopo non era alla gola ma ai polmoni.
Great reaction. Thanks for checking this version too!! Can never have too much Echoes!
You nailed it - it IS a conversation between Dave & Rick - both musically & vocally, which is why David said he'll not perform it again since Rick's passing - and I respect that.
This is such a wonderful & powerful version - the sound mixing is top notch, ESPECIALLY on a surround system! Cheers.
The guitarist on the far left is Phil Manzanera, a close friend of David's who used to play in Roxy Music with Brian Ferry.
Thanks for sharing your experience and emotional reaction to this. We are so fortunate to have great musicians making great music like this that touch us all in unique ways, and differently at different times based on our state of mind, memory, emotional state and circumstance. I appreciate how music enriches our life experience. Thank you!
Awesome. This album, Meddle needed to be made for the group to move forward for the next 4 albums.
Also, I was at this 1994 concert in GB.3 of 4 concerts. And 12 concerts in the United States in 1994 Even the one in Houston @ Rice Stadium that was shorten due lightning and a deluge of water. It seemed god did this on purpose. The lightning was perfectly timed with the songs. And the big fat rain drops falling through the lasers beams. Due to the power going on and off several times. and everything drenched, they didn’t have an opportunity to play Comfortably Numb that night. Finally, I was able to see the concert in its entirety about 10 days after the Houston concert in San Diego, Ca. And I was in G’dansk 2006. I was so happy to finally hear my song, Echoes, being played. And was happy to see/hear this song one last time before Richard’s passing.
David Gilmour and Richard Wroght’s voices were made for one another
Love the Dr Who theme quote! Pulse and Gdańsk best concerts ever and this ECHOES is the best IMHO - I was at the birth of ECHOES so this holds a special place in my heart. You also have PHIL MANZANERA on second guitar - ex Roxy Music. David has his Hendrix guitar strap. Essentially you have later Pink FLOYD here minus Nick but apart from David and Rick you have Guy Pratt on bass who took over from Roger and is also on bass throughout PULSE. As regards the Phantom riff Roger’s comment was that he was aware but couldn’t ‘be arsed’ to sue Lloyd Webber. The end of ECHOES is moving and epic. A fitting send off for Rick who was such a huge part of the FLOYD sound not only with brilliant keyboards and soundscapes to harmonies and the odd lead vocal
Pink Floyd are the Undisputed Gods of Live performance. They are the Supreme Masters of blending the visual with the musical. They create a visceral experience for the audience. David Gilmour is a living guitar God. He can do more with one note than most guitarists can do with an entire fret board.
Wonderful reaction, guys. You are one of the few reactors who has gone through all three iterations of Echoes, with a great video sound quality for all of them. Kudos to you both for that. For me, the Gdansk performance is the best of the three, with the audio version a close second. Their Pompeii version was fine, but they were still so young then, still learning their craft. And the sound system back then couldn't compete with the technology available at Gdansk. Still, their youthful vigor really shines through in Pompeii, and I'm so glad it was captured on film, providing an important historical record of a band that was about to explode on the world scene.
When Pink Floyd opened with this at JFK Stadium in 1987, it brought a tear to my eye. I couldn't believe I was able to see 3 of the 4 guys responsible for this masterpiece. When I saw the Animals tour in 77, they played no old stuff. Just all of Animals and then all of Wish You Were Here and Money for the encore. The Philly 87 soundboard version is here on UA-cam.
How cool that you would comment "looks like an accountant" referring to Nick Mason. David Gilmour comes on stage dressed as if he's there to fix a leaky faucet, then transforms in front of you as the best guitar soloist in existence. PF don't care to distinguish themselves with anything but the performance for the audience. IMO, the "Division Bell" tour (which was released a year later as "P.U.L.S.E." is the most incredible live show ever.
A couple of FYIs: the pig controversy began when Roger Waters got a temporary injunction to halt the use of "Alfie" (the inflatable used on the cover of the "Animals" album) by Gilmour. David countered by having a set of testicles added. The ultimate FU to Roger was changing to Boars (far more aggressive). Bassist Guy Pratt (who is a far better player than Waters could ever hope to be) is Richard Wright's son-in-law.
Also, "One Of These Days" was the closing number for the first set. They would end the second set with "Run Like Hell".
Thanks for the great pairing here - keep 'em coming.
"Look like accountants" lol. Brilliant.
David said he’s not playing that song again without Rick. As far as I know he never has since.
I always feel really sad at the end, it seems like David is sat by Richards bed holding his hand as he passes away 💔
No, Phantom of the Opera "borrowed" the descending line from Echoes. Andrew Lloyd Webber's score was written in the mid 1980's, while Echoes came out in 1971. Having said that, many parts of the melodic sections of Echoes borrow from previously-written tunes within the rock pantheon.
Dev I am so sorry. Grief last a lifetime. But clearly you are learning from it. I hope one day you can listen and release. I have a song that does me the same way, so I completely get it. Thank you for that honesty. Thank y’all for the wonderful reactions to PF and everyone else. You do such a wonderful job. Keep it up!
I saw this live in 94, Raleigh NC at Carter Finley Stadium... one of the greatest nights of my life lol .. check out "run like hell" from the same Pulse concert! they unleash everything on it!
And that friend's is how the Pro's do it. Match that.
Your sharing about your friend was very touching and brought a lump to my throat.
1971, my big brother got me that album for my 11th birthday, 1974, he took me to see them for my 14th, the Dark Side of the Moon tour, the Liverpool Empire theatre UK, my hometown 😊 they did Echoes as the encore..I got a synth for my 15th birthday and spent about a year teaching myself all things Floyd 😊 👍 my older siblings used to go and watch the local bands in clubs around Liverpool in the 60s, one club, the Cavern was a favourite though, they used to watch the Beatles there 😊 and my mum used to go to the bingo with Mrs Starkey.. aka Ringos mum 😂 I miss those days big time..
The end between Dave and Rick pure soul and magic
I was fortunate to see One of These Days played at the Three Rivers Stadium production of the Pulse tour. I was with my brothers down on the field for the first half of the show, which of course concluded with OTD. You don't see it in the official film you watched, but at the conclusion, the pigs fall straight down from the towers. My youngest brother had connections with the Steelers, so we watched the second half of the show from the Steelers private box. Oddly enough, Dan Rooney didn't come to see the show that evening.
I first heard parts from "One Of These Days" in the very early seventies as backdrop of a German documentary about volcanoes. First album I got from Pink Floyd was "Dark Side Of The Moon" in March 1974. It wasn't until 1975, after I got "Wish You Were Here" that I acquired "Meddle" and discovered "Echoes". Damn, that was a trip. The live version here at Gdansk is the most magnificent version I have ever heard. Got the Album with the DVDs and enjoyed both sound and vision quite often. I have 221 discs of Pink Floyd (don't know how many albums they represent. I rip everything to PC with a folder for each disc, so double or tripple albums are seen as two or three discs. Most of the lot are soundboard bootlegs). Thanks for the sharing of the music and your thoughts. Warm greetings and salutations from Belgium.
I think you are the first people to react to this version .
Phantom borrowed it from Pink Floyd. Yes this is the best version (for me). The climax later in the song is epic.
Hi, when I play One of these days I use a Boss Bass effect unit BE30, so I can do the repeats and put on the synth while playing. For Echoes my modded strat via 2 digital effect pedals and a boss Effects unit for the stereo out and rotatory speaker simulation.
Two giants of the sycadelic progressive rock world can't imagine what was going through their minds when they played this incredible creation together for the last time it brings a lump to my throat and heightens my emotions everytime I listen to it more so this particular concert I'm so glad you two lovers of great rock music finally took the time to experience this amazing version of echoes great reaction respect to you both
I was at this performance, sat about 12 rows down from the stage on the right-side directly below that pig, I promise you it's pretty scary when you suddenly look up and see a giant pig with bright eyes flying out of the wall directly at you!
Echoes has MANY moments that give me what I used to call "headgasm" but which I learned just the other week has a real name: musical frission.
The voices at the very end always gives me a 2001 vibe and with the song being about evolution it makes some sense.
the ONLY song in the floyds history that NICK MASON sings the lyrics "one of these days, im going to cut you into little pieces"
superbe concert j'aurais aimer les voir en concert live , respect ,love and peace 🤩👍👍🗼☮
Thoroughly enjoyed that with the headphones on.
The trippy effect at the start of Echoes Part 2 was discovered by accident when someone plugged a wah wah pedal in reverse
i like the way they slide in the original Dr Who music .The Doctor Who theme music is a piece of music written by Australian composer Ron Grainer and realised by Delia Derbyshire at the BBC Radiophonic Workshop. Created in 1963, it was one of the first electronic music signature tunes for television.
In the Peter Capaldi story 'Caretaker', he whistles the 'we don't need no education' lyric from the Wall.
@@mark-nm4tc Nice one cheers.
Great reaction, my first time finding you guys. Can feel and understand your emotions.
Exquisite. Absolute Masterpiece. Yes, as said by others, you can feel David and Richard talking to each other through their instruments. Incredible and a sad feeling too.
My first listen to Pink Floyd was, ‘Echoes’, as a 15 year old in 1971, just after Meddle had been released.
It’s pretty much my favourite piece of Floyd music, but only just, as there’s so many Masterpieces.
Especially, ‘Dark Side Of The Moon’, ‘Wish You Were Here’ and ‘The Wall’. All incredible Concept Albums. So many more great Albums as well as those, but they’re my own personal favourites.
Also, you’ll no doubt be familiar with ‘Comfortably Numb’, from ‘The Wall’. For me the Live versions are best, as they have the long extended Solo’s, to close the track. I know the version from the Live Pulse Show in 1994, is brilliant and well loved, including by me, but If I may, could I highly recommend you try this version too. My own personal favourite performance of ‘Comfortably Numb’.
I was lucky enough to see the ‘One Night Only’ Cinema showing of David Gilmour’s return to the Pompeii Amphitheater, in 2016, with his Band. (Pink Floyd’s previous visit being in 1971, when they were filmed playing ‘Echoes’, in the Centre of the Amphitheater, with no audience), which I know you’ve seen.
And this version of ‘Comfortably Numb’, from that 2016 Show, is sensational. This time to an audience.
And what a light Show this has too. All in the stunning setting of this Roman Amphitheater.
David Gilmour at his stunning best, aged 70. Genius.
Incredible. Just my own feelings. Hope you can manage to watch this video, you won’t regret it.
ua-cam.com/video/eHKG7EMxWW8/v-deo.html
🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
I’ve seen “The Australian Pink Floyd” tribute band several times - they are as close to the real thing as you can get they are amazing. When they play “One of These Days” they have an inflatable kangaroo on stage
😅
@gavinblenkinsop6250 FYI, we sent you a direct message in Patreon regarding a special request you may have
@@MusicforBusyPeople I didn’t see the notification. I’ve sent you a reply :)
@@gavinblenkinsop6250 FYI, Wishbone Ash reaction is on Patreon
A snippet of the Doctor Who theme at 4:09 there
8:40
They used pigs (as they did it in the late 80s concerts already) on One Of These Days, because they didn't find a way to bring any song from "Animals" album to perform it in those shows, so they found another composition from the 70s to match there somehow... )
Great reaction, guys! A lot of comments already about Echoes, but I do love the live performance of One of These Days! For another version of that check out OOTD from Roger Waters Us & Them tour!
The black Fender Stratocaster Gilmour is playing here recently sold at auction for $3.9 million.
2001 space Odyssey and this song is amazing.
The reason ehy he is using a repeater is it was originally record with Waters and Gilmour playing dual, or double tracked basses
the bass player is Guy Pratt, he is married with the daugther of Rick Right
Pretty sure that is Phil Manzanera from Roxy Music on the other guitar. I may be wrong on this one, but Manzanera does play with both Gilmour's solo band and David Gilmour plays on a Bryan Ferry solo record also. I love that my 2 favorite bands are in cahoots, particularly these two of such exceptional original and creative force. So fitting!
You are correct.
Echoes was made before phantom of the opera so it was Andrew Lloyd Webber who borrowed from pink floyd
THe other musicians are Phil Manzanera, Roxy Music guitarist and Steve Di Stanislao - drums, recently with Crosby and Nash.
SORRY, ITS nick mason ON DRUMS, NOT STEVE,,,this is pink floyd not a dave gilmour concert
@@tammyphxaz I was obviously talking about the Gdansk performance.
Check the Pompeii version 👍
We did. Choose your preference...
ua-cam.com/video/h-sS2wiBsDU/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/7L0Ry5nlq8I/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/I8ZKdwFQop8/v-deo.html
For me the whole "Delicate Sound Of Thunder" concert is even better in some ways than "Pulse". I know that it's more 80s thing and less classic PF, but come on - they really rock there (and deliver some really great saxophone solos also)!... )
I remember watching that concert on TV. It was the first time I ever saw/heard anybody from Pink Floyd play live, and I was riveted.
Actually, IMO they played the best version of Echoes a few weeks prior to Gdansk, in the Royal Albert Hall (the 'Remember That NIght' version). They play it a bit tighter, the 'whaling section' sounds a bit better, and the climax looks (even) more spectacular.
Echoes came out in 1971
Phantom of the opera came out in 1986
so Webber borrowed stole it from PINK FLOYD
This came before phantom of the opera
Name that tune in 1 note.
This live version from 1987 is a more intense version if you like.
ua-cam.com/video/218_-Lze8N0/v-deo.html
Watch David Gilmour Rattle That Rock World Tour
Hi, I just came across your enjoyable reaction. Regarding the wild boars rather than piggies: the region is very big on boar roasts, I've been there a few times and if on official business, cultural exchange or similar, they tend to organise a huge boar roast for guests. I suppose the wild boars are synonymous with the city and region so it could well an acknowledgement of the fact. Just a guess!
No. They had the boar for this song in Philly as well. Roger retained legal rights to use the pigs, so David went with boars.
Cazzo c'entra sto commento ?
@65alef Si riferiscono al fatto che David Gilmour ha mostrato cinghiali invece di maiali perché Roger Waters manteneva i diritti legali sul maiale originale di "Animals".
This isn't from the Gdansk performance. Nick Mason is playing the drums here and in Gdansk it was Steve DiStanislao.
_One of These Days_ is from PULSE 1994. Only _Echoes_ is from Gdańsk.
Gotcha,work getting to me lol.Great vid.@@MusicforBusyPeople
❤🧡💛💚💙💜🤎🖤💔
The "Pigs" are Wild Boar because Dave was in a fight with Roger over using the Pig from Animals..... so these Wild Board are complete with over sized testicles!..... I have no idea what message was being sent! 😂😂😂
Do you have anything good to say about them?
Nope, should have went for the original studio version or the Live At Pompeii version.
Already did. Links in the Description.
Dude, please do a little research...RIP Richard Wright
Il canto del cigno di Richard .
Emozionante .
Don't cry😢I, really, like your reactions....We all have songs like that, which reminds us of good, or bad memories😢Honesty yes😂I would like to see what you wrote, during the song, please😂Peace from France ✌️ PS: why is Nick Mason reacting to his own music?🤔😅😅🤭🤭✌️Sorry, it's a joke, but you look like to Nick Mason, so much (with short hair)😂....More, seriously, please, my, lady....No, Nick,😂 please, ask to your wife to show us what she wrote, during those songs😢Please....You're both great....✌️