Attack on Bishop Mari Emmanuel

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 113

  • @OrthodoxSayings
    @OrthodoxSayings 6 місяців тому +57

    Thank God Mar Mari is ok, he only got scratches and bruises.

  • @jeromevillanueva2207
    @jeromevillanueva2207 6 місяців тому +50

    I praise his zeal in proclaiming Christ is Lord and Christ is God.
    Meanwhile, I pray for his conversion and reconcile with the Church.

  • @brotherbrovet1881
    @brotherbrovet1881 6 місяців тому +55

    When Mari Emanuel is identified by news sites as "Orthodox ". It is proper to correct them.

    • @CambyBolongo
      @CambyBolongo 6 місяців тому +10

      Why are you so eager to disassociate? A Christian was attacked in his church.

    • @bezimenkostotebrigovic5149
      @bezimenkostotebrigovic5149 6 місяців тому +17

      ​@@CambyBolongosimply he is not orthodox, that is why

    • @Burgermeister1836
      @Burgermeister1836 6 місяців тому +3

      @@CambyBolongo Truth doesn't require a motive

    • @Kostas_Dikefalaios
      @Kostas_Dikefalaios 6 місяців тому +11

      Thats what you draw out of this whole situation? A Christian bishop gets attacked for his faith in the Lord and you whine about him being labled as simply Orthodox? You may be in the true church, but you dont seem to have the Christian spirit if thats the thing that made you angry in this whole ordeal.

    • @bezimenkostotebrigovic5149
      @bezimenkostotebrigovic5149 6 місяців тому

      @Kostas_Dikefalaios he is not bishop. Maybe he is but self-proclaimed. Even being heretic, of course, feeling sorry for him. By the way, greeks are the most dangerous enemies of orthodoxy, in the last century and half, at least buahaha

  • @ICXCNIKA8
    @ICXCNIKA8 6 місяців тому +15

    Well balanced and well said! May God bless you with safe travels brother Bojan! ☦️🙏🏼🇷🇸

  • @DanicusRex-m1m
    @DanicusRex-m1m 6 місяців тому +34

    My dad, a protestant, passed away a couple of weeks ago and when i told my priest and deacon, i was comforted by their boundless compassion. My priest took me to the small church bookstore in our parish and showed me the akathist of St Varus and told me that they would both be saying private prayers for him and our family. Above all, we know that God knows each persons heart and one of my favorite things about being orthodox is knowing i can pray for the departed. For Mari Emmanuel, i have watched a few of his videos and the man's love for Christ is so apparent. Of course there are issues with some of his views, but i pray for him and that i could show the same compassion he is able to show for someone even after being so brutally attacked.

    • @st.maximusvstheuglies1309
      @st.maximusvstheuglies1309 6 місяців тому +2

      ​@Gigi-ho2qkAnd yet, loving sinners despite their sins is one of the ways our Lord taught us to judge not. We don't fight flesh and blood like Mar Mari's attacker.

    • @manikyum
      @manikyum 6 місяців тому +1

      Sorry for your loss.
      What are the issues you see with Maris views?

    • @DanicusRex-m1m
      @DanicusRex-m1m 6 місяців тому +2

      @@manikyum mainly the nestorian parts. I don't claim to be a theologian, I'm just a guy trying to work out his own salvation through fear and trembling. But along with that fear is a peace from knowing that we will all be judged by the most perfect judge who can see into our hearts. That's why I mentioned my dad earlier. By orthodox standards he was guilty of heresy. But if you knew the man personally, like I did, you'd have seen a man who pursued God and loved his neighbor as himself. So that's why my earlier post seemed to sound like I was downplaying the differences in our beliefs. Anything but that. I'm just looking at the fruits of both men's souls, and to me, I see Christ in them.

  • @stevecochran9078
    @stevecochran9078 6 місяців тому +26

    Governments that forbid self-defense for their citizens are inherently evil.

  • @DarioMagno
    @DarioMagno 6 місяців тому +10

    As a person saved by jesus from the satanic heresy of Islam, and as a new Christian (since few years already) I'm so blessed by the teachings and the holiness of Mar Mari Emmanuel. I'm not Assyrian and not even Orthodox. I'm in the Catholic church now, but wherever is holiness in a church of Jesus Christ, the Son of God, I believe in that church. May God bless us all! 💜✝️☦️💜

  • @copticconcept
    @copticconcept 6 місяців тому +8

    As an Oriental Orthodox Christian, I share many of the same points. Mari Emmanuel seems like a great man, and his zeal is recognizable, and we are praying for his recovery. However, we must be sure recognize what He believes about God, which is heretical and not Orthodox.
    Our clergy have been very strict to call him out in the past, because of his garb that resembles the Syrian Orthodox Monastic garb, which the Coptic Orthodox Church adopted in wear.
    He also has an Icon of St. Pope Kyrillos the Sixth on his altar, but he has the icon because of the miracles and appearances of this saint to many Assyrians in the peak of ISIS's persecution.
    So unfortunately, many, especially boomer generation Oriental Orthodox mistakenly have thought he was Coptic or Syriac, which is not the case at all. That is why we have to be careful in educating people about theology.

  • @maxe.miller6301
    @maxe.miller6301 6 місяців тому +22

    I pray this event does not solidify his or his followers belief that Christ is behind them in their heresy

    • @Fredo-n1d
      @Fredo-n1d 6 місяців тому +5

      You might want to address that huge chunk of wood in your own eye first before spending your precious worry on others.

    • @Tornadospeed10
      @Tornadospeed10 6 місяців тому +10

      @@Fredo-n1dit’s always important to point out massive heresy

  • @vibjbaha
    @vibjbaha 6 місяців тому +10

    Your name is Bojan. My name is Bijan 😀

  • @thedreadtyger
    @thedreadtyger 6 місяців тому +19

    The Assyrian Church is not Oriental Orthodox. We are miaphysite. They are (kind of to definitely) Nestorian, depending on the person. Many wonderful things can be said of them.
    You may have the same opinion of us. That's not my business.
    And Bojan, may God grant you a safe trip and a good Confession.

    • @josephfox9221
      @josephfox9221 6 місяців тому +2

      I think he was talking more about the fact that Bishop Mari uses a Coptic Headgear and not Traditional Assyrian clothing. which was a contributing factor of him exiting the Assyrian church of the east. the whole Mari relationship to Assyrian church is complicated.

    • @BozheTsaryaKhrani
      @BozheTsaryaKhrani 6 місяців тому

      he said church of the east he was correct he never called them oriental

  • @yossarian7617
    @yossarian7617 6 місяців тому +3

    I don't think it was a switchblade as they're illegal in a lot of places therefore very hard to get. It was probably a folding blade and when the guy struck Mari the blade folded back on the handle thus cutting his own fingers.

  • @marycayburkindine1003
    @marycayburkindine1003 6 місяців тому

    Thank you for telling this bad incident kindly and honesty. I had not heard abt this on US news, not that that surprises me. I had heard abt this bishop and his Church, thank you the information. I will pray for all in evolved and hope Orthodoxy will gain positive from this bad thing, unfortunately at near Pascha

  • @berniegran5391
    @berniegran5391 6 місяців тому +5

    the blade was open people freeze the frame to show the blade, the blade probably closed after the first stab..... God literally saved him

  • @shovelleator4738
    @shovelleator4738 6 місяців тому +3

    Not sure if this is entirely on point but I watched the videos of interviews with the young widows of Egyptians who were martyred in orange overalls on the beach. One seared into my consciousness
    Holding a baby on her hip and another child at her feet stated
    “ I am not worthy to be his widow, the widow of a martyr “ ( my memory of it).
    I wept because I know how bankrupt my faith is compared to hers. I wept because I too have children and now grandchildren and those little ones have no father. I wept because she showed me up as a shallow man and I want to be like her.
    I’m EO and she’s a Copt. I believe there is only one true church and heresy is evil . I didn’t even go there TBH. Orthodoxy is both and not either or. We can appreciate this clerics zeal and what good he speaks and also recognise heresy without having to be pharisaical and full of ourselves( especially during lent!). Let us all humble ourselves and ask God to make us believers like Mar Mari who forgive and love their enemies AND who hold to the TRUTH

  • @diannalaubenberg7532
    @diannalaubenberg7532 6 місяців тому +4

    My information is that he is not Nestorian.

  • @iamdigory
    @iamdigory 6 місяців тому +6

    I read that Mar Mari had reconciled with the church of the east.

    • @traceyedson9652
      @traceyedson9652 6 місяців тому +1

      I believe he’s in a schismatic group of old calendarist Assyrians called the Ancient Church of the East.

    • @jesusacuna309
      @jesusacuna309 6 місяців тому +5

      ​@@traceyedson9652he WAS in communion with the Ancient Church of the East

    • @oscarbelmare_22
      @oscarbelmare_22 6 місяців тому +2

      @@traceyedson9652Yeah he left the Ancient Church of the East, a schismatic of an already schismatic denomination from the Assyrian Church of the East

  • @andje_______
    @andje_______ 5 місяців тому

    Tbh i really like your content. I'm from Bosnia, had some awakening literally around Christianity... I almost went into islam... Then protestantism and adventism... I was baptised in ortodox church as a baby, but now I'm going back on track with ortodoxy... I'm wondering if i should do to do like a life confession or what should i do? I was never on a proper, confession nor religion my whole life.. and I'm scared to do it literally. What's your advice?

  • @makimas-favorite-son
    @makimas-favorite-son 6 місяців тому +4

    Im sorta near new york. do you want to visit the church im an inquiry at? 😂

  • @TheSkullThatTalks
    @TheSkullThatTalks 6 місяців тому +2

    He is Nestorian.But not like you think.He said he defends Nestorius in a sense that he wasn't properly judged.He says that Nestorius was falsely charged of heresy,and that he didn't preach all those things.As I understand,that was the reason he went his own way with his church.He's a Nestorius apologist.

    • @TheSkullThatTalks
      @TheSkullThatTalks 6 місяців тому +2

      Also it would be cool if you researched him more and make a larger more detailed video on him. He is getting bigger and bigger on internet.And btw,he also very often praises Eastern Orthodox church.Russian the most.He also speaks as he is a part of Eastern Orthodox church.

  • @nuns8126
    @nuns8126 6 місяців тому

    I watched Bishop Mar Mari Emmanuel's mass/divine liturgy. He does acknowledge a Patriarch during mass.

  • @iona3669
    @iona3669 6 місяців тому

    Good video, commentary, and review!

  • @e-knjige8209
    @e-knjige8209 6 місяців тому +3

    Bojan when you travel to NY you can meet another chrsitain youtuber he is called reefemed zoomer, he is presbyterian sadly, he likes to debate everyone and everything tho...

  • @DoggoAnon
    @DoggoAnon 6 місяців тому +24

    The consequences of☪ancer.

    • @nuns8126
      @nuns8126 6 місяців тому

      He belongs to a "branch" of the Nestorian, Assyrian Church of the East. He was raised in Syria. So he is of Assyrian Church.
      Please visit his website.
      Good Shepherd Church in Wakely, Australia.

  • @patcandelora8496
    @patcandelora8496 6 місяців тому +2

    First and foremost he is a fellow human being. The theological aspects can be debated afterwards. Seems obvious to me!🤷🏻

  • @DinaraDivision
    @DinaraDivision 6 місяців тому +6

    Naj glavnije je da je Pop zdrav i nije zadobijo velke telesne povrede.
    Druga stvar je da smo mi Pravoslavci izašli na ulice , pokazali cjelom svjetu da smo spremni braniti naŠu Slavnu Vjeru prije ičeg . ☦️

  • @al4381
    @al4381 6 місяців тому

    I believe he was readmitted into the ACoE during the pandemic years, when their church got their current Patriarch. I think the relation was healed and he is back in...

  • @ausguy5052
    @ausguy5052 6 місяців тому +6

    Bojane, coming to Christ via a heretical path is NOT coming to Christ.

    • @traceyedson9652
      @traceyedson9652 6 місяців тому +2

      Not necessarily so. A “heretic” is a teacher who has been corrected by his synod or a council and does not correct himself. The Holy Spirit can and does find myriad ways in this world to bring people to Christ. He’s done so with you. He’s done so with me. Otherwise, He is not “everywhere present filling all things.” And that would be a heretical, God-limiting, devil-glorifying notion.

    • @ausguy5052
      @ausguy5052 6 місяців тому +2

      @@traceyedson9652 “A "heretic" is a teacher who has been corrected by his synod or a council and does not correct himself.” Mari Emmanuel and his schismatic church uses the term “christotokos”, this has been corrected 1600 years ago, Council of Ephesus 431, “If anyone does not confess that Christ is God in truth, and therefore that the holy virgin is the mother of God, the Theotokos, for she bore in a fleshly way the Word of God become flesh, let him be anathema.” Yet although corrected this so called bishop continues to use the false term.

    • @violetrose415
      @violetrose415 6 місяців тому +1

      To tell you the truth, the light of Christ shining in anyway on anyone is a plus in my opinion. We need more people to know God is there for them so they can find healing in God. You don't know how many people feel lost without the love of God so even a little bit of light is better than total darkness.

    • @traceyedson9652
      @traceyedson9652 6 місяців тому +1

      @@violetrose415 this seems obvious, but some people turn the Truth of Christ & His Church into a sect. Christ the Way, and His Church is One. But it is not a sect.

    • @ausguy5052
      @ausguy5052 6 місяців тому

      @@violetrose415 My point is, be very wary of people shining that light and altering the rules to serve their own purposes. Many cults in the past have used your argument, with disastrous results.

  • @billybenson3834
    @billybenson3834 6 місяців тому

    We all need to pray for his speedy recovery and for him to return to the fold of Orthodoxy. He is out of communion and his statement of faith is outside of the historical faith of the saints. Check the Calcedon council if you need any evidence.

    • @copticconcept
      @copticconcept 6 місяців тому

      The fathers of Ephesus condemn two natures after the union.

  • @fmayer1507
    @fmayer1507 6 місяців тому +2

    How about our Orthodox prelates that went along with the closings of churches when liquor stores were kept open? How about our Prelates that lick the boots of our depraved political leadership worldwide? Our Lord Jesus Christ and the way of practice on Mount Athos and in monasteries that operate like Mount Athos is what is truly ORTHODOX, NOT the churches that over identify with their governments. Jesus, Our Savior stated unambiguously that He wanted us all to be one. That is God's true desire. We need to pray for all Christians to follow the Orthoxdox way of correct belief that is collegial and NOT based in any way on the godless game of thrones we see throughout the "Christian" world. Humility and true love of God and neighbor will triumph over doctrine any day. Jesus proclaimed this in Matthew Chapter 25 very clearly an unambiguously.

  • @elias8141
    @elias8141 5 місяців тому

    Not to judge him but I think that he uses this incident to promote his church and I don’t blame him if I had what I thought is the truth. I would promote it in any way shape or form. This is the normal act of love and it chose how good he is but being good is not the same as being right. What he teaches is a heresy and people need to be informed about this

  • @MrPeterFranc
    @MrPeterFranc 6 місяців тому

    Is it ok for orthodox to call heretical leaders bishops?

  • @ckingufwgleej3362
    @ckingufwgleej3362 6 місяців тому +11

    he's not a bishop

    • @traceyedson9652
      @traceyedson9652 6 місяців тому +6

      @Gigi-ho2qkit must be nice to have divine knowledge & judgment.

    • @nikkilengyel
      @nikkilengyel 6 місяців тому

      Gigi, you're a coward. It isn't noble or virtuous to anonymously sit in judgment of someone who puts their life on the line to lead people away from a murderous cult. Playing keyboard warrior isn't helping anyone.

    • @RevengeOfIjapa
      @RevengeOfIjapa 6 місяців тому

      And so?

  • @azulceleste2646
    @azulceleste2646 6 місяців тому +6

    Sorry to say it bluntly but I'm so fed up with religion and all the different interpretations. People should not attack or kill other people, regardless of their belief. Period!

    • @Harith-le5iq
      @Harith-le5iq 6 місяців тому +11

      You’re oversimplifying, islam says to kill who insult Mohammad what does that have to do with other religions

    • @traceyedson9652
      @traceyedson9652 6 місяців тому

      @@Harith-le5iqor atheists.

  • @nisahmed9121
    @nisahmed9121 6 місяців тому +3

    ⁠ Muslims love Jesus and honor his mother Mary. Their story and all other prophets Adam, Abraham, Issac, Jacob, Moses are mentioned in the Quran. Muslims believe in the Virgin birth and second coming of Jesus. They don't believe he was killed but protected by God and ascended to him!
    Saladin made it Muslims duty to protect Jerusalem Christians & their Churches. He entrusted two Muslim families to be custodians of the keys of the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem and other churches .For over 850 years the Husseini & Nuseibbehs families were tasked to open and close doors of the churches! Till now they carry the same old historical keys!

    • @ophanimangel3143
      @ophanimangel3143 6 місяців тому +1

      Lies upon lies. Hadiths and Quran say otherwise. You don’t even call God the Father yet claim you love the Son Jesus?

  • @beataens1
    @beataens1 6 місяців тому

    Assyria == Asshur

  • @areyoutheregoditsmedave
    @areyoutheregoditsmedave 6 місяців тому +1

    did anne frank even exist? 🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @ioansmarket
    @ioansmarket 6 місяців тому +26

    The attacker cut his own fingers because the knife malfunctioned while opening it that's why the Bishop survived.

  • @unkagug1169
    @unkagug1169 6 місяців тому +18

    Despite his Nestorianism, he says a lot of good things. We don't immediately condemn Protestants or Catholics for saying good things, we find good things we agree on. This is the foundation of evangelism, find our common ground and move from there. To tell them "you're a bunch of heathens, you'll go to hell unless you listen to me" is proselytizing which converts few and creates animosity with everyone else.

    • @armen4ok280
      @armen4ok280 6 місяців тому +4

      Well said!

    • @ausguy5052
      @ausguy5052 6 місяців тому +1

      If thats the case, then we should just do away with all the Ecumenical Councils rules as set out by our church fathers, I mean whats the point, as long as heretics "say a lot of good things" as you wrote, thats the main thing. It doesn't work that way my friend, a person stealing from the rich to give to the poor isn't a good person, they're still a THIEF and breaking the law. We cant pick and chose whats right or wrong, it either is or isnt, and calling it a grey area only means one is not will to make a stand and pick the truth.

  • @cerebrummaximus3762
    @cerebrummaximus3762 6 місяців тому +4

    Nice video! Praise Mar Mari's loyalty to Christ, but pray for his health and reconciliation of his heresies to reconciliation with Orthodoxy.
    Bojan, may you do a video or some mention on the late Patriarch Neophyte of the Bulgarian Orthodox Church? He was ill for a while, and passed away a month or so ago (Memory Eternal). Even the main TV channel switched the logo to black in his memory for a few weeks.
    Just as about we thought he'd rest in peace, his grave had been vandalised in the night, more than once, with the cross by his grave pushed off, and the frames of his grave kicked broken. All the people have is CCTV footage. This has happened on multiple occasions.
    Similar to Mar Mari's situation, what would you say is to be done in this situation? When I heard it on the news, it saddened, even angered, me how anybody could not just decide, but even think of doing this, but thankfully the other church leaders and carers have managed to keep a mature attitude, recommended we waste not our anger on the grave vandals, but rather pray.
    May God bless you Bojan, and much love 🇧🇬☦✝️❤

  • @jonathon5135
    @jonathon5135 6 місяців тому +1

    Good reaction to the event. I have been a catechumen for more than a year and Mar Mari's videos were instrumental in my re-focusing on my path earlier this year. Despite his heresy, he's a man who loves Christ our God. I pray for a safe journey to NYC. It's a shame you are traveling there during Lent, because there's lots of great food with lots of meat and cheese. 🤤
    Glory to Jesus Christ

  • @mement0_m0ri
    @mement0_m0ri 6 місяців тому

    My thoughts exactly.

  • @igorlopes7589
    @igorlopes7589 6 місяців тому

    Sources say the attacker screamed Abdul's snackbar before stabbing the Bishop

  • @FromWarWithLove
    @FromWarWithLove 6 місяців тому +2

    Mar Mari is not a heretic. He might not say the term ‘Theotokos’ when referring to Mary, but affirms its reality. Christ is God. Mary is his mother.

  • @kgsniper4850
    @kgsniper4850 6 місяців тому

    I completely agree ❤

  • @gillianc6514
    @gillianc6514 6 місяців тому +2

    Correction, the bishop a critic of Z**nism (which does not have its roots in Judaism), and against radical Islam (which does not have its roots in Islam). He is an outspoken supporter of Palestine. He is much loved by Palestinians of all faiths for speaking out. This may explain where the attack originated.

  • @waltershumer4211
    @waltershumer4211 6 місяців тому +9

    The cowardice and pacifism of modern Christianity will be its Doom

    • @BaikalTii
      @BaikalTii 6 місяців тому

      meekness and humility will be the salvation of the true Christian.

    • @CocotheNut
      @CocotheNut 6 місяців тому +5

      ehhh Christianity's been through worse I think we'll be ok

    • @luciancornelius
      @luciancornelius 6 місяців тому +1

      Christians should be pacifist as the Martyrs and Saints of the old die without hurting another humans. The 12 Apostles are influential yet they did not promote vengeance and revenge towards oppressors. Remember the Beatitudes and the Law of Moses

    • @rylanwalker442
      @rylanwalker442 6 місяців тому

      That is not Christs teaching

    • @waltershumer4211
      @waltershumer4211 6 місяців тому

      @@rylanwalker442 not his teaching? You ever notice what Protestant churchs a teach about LGBT? I'm not sure his teaching has anything to do with it