Everything Wrong With The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,7 тис.

  • @nandologia_
    @nandologia_ 6 років тому +195

    9:00 Fun fact: Daniel Craig is the only actor in this movie to speak with his natural British accent. He explicitly stated in an interview he thought the whole “Swedish accent but not Swedish” was stupid and just ignored it altogether.

    • @jbvader721
      @jbvader721 Рік тому +14

      Ironic given that Craig years later would put on one of the silliest accents put to film in Knives Out. And I love it (mainly because he's clearly having more fun as Benoit Blanc than he ever did as James Bond).

  • @TGabes_Gaming
    @TGabes_Gaming 6 років тому +223

    Hi. The original title of the book was “men who hate women” in Swedish. The violence towards lisbeth is one of the most important part of the movie. She does illegal things to get him back because the government doesn’t help her and protects her attackers. That’s the point.

    • @zepar911
      @zepar911 6 місяців тому +2

      now , just having that as the title of the movie makes the movie much more sensefull

    • @lowlowseesee
      @lowlowseesee 5 місяців тому +1

      dont feed the troll that is cin sins lol

  • @lisztomaniacgirl
    @lisztomaniacgirl 4 роки тому +195

    I JUST FREAKING LOVE THE CINEMATOGRAPHY, THE MAIN ACTORS, THE SOUNDTRACK, THE WEATHER, THE AMBIENT, EVEN THE FCKN CREDITS LOL

    • @lazy.HITMAN
      @lazy.HITMAN 3 роки тому +16

      Finally someone said it. I've watched this gazillion times just to feel cozy.

    • @Schellnino1994
      @Schellnino1994 Рік тому +3

      This is how i feel as well! It has so much atmosphere that it makes up for every last sin!

    • @justsomegirlwithoutamustache
      @justsomegirlwithoutamustache Рік тому +1

      Exactly. I love the feel of this films which the original never gave me

    • @Schellnino1994
      @Schellnino1994 Рік тому

      i also love the original which also has a unique kinds of escapism!!@@justsomegirlwithoutamustache

  • @GinaMazzola
    @GinaMazzola 6 років тому +136

    This version is aesthetically breathtaking. It's a visual work of art. every set and scene is so beautifully thought through.

  • @sluggishnu
    @sluggishnu 6 років тому +586

    This movie is incredible, Jeremy cmon. And Martin wanted Mikael to continue investigating cuz HE wanted to know where Harriet was. This is explained very clearly in the torture scene.

    • @sethvanpelt5707
      @sethvanpelt5707 4 роки тому +47

      He has a problem with implicit things in movies (intentions, motives, character, subtlety, setting of tone, foreshadowing, theme, etc.) and I get that his brain is trained towards nitpicking so he’s looking at the superficial shit but he still could think about the movie more

    • @simonfrederiksen104
      @simonfrederiksen104 4 роки тому +5

      @@sethvanpelt5707 The original is better anyway

    • @johnthelesserofthethirdoft863
      @johnthelesserofthethirdoft863 4 роки тому +12

      This isn’t meant to be taken seriously. He regularly admits this in his video

    • @cpenner7086
      @cpenner7086 4 роки тому +16

      @@johnthelesserofthethirdoft863 yet his videos say other wise time and time again. also in the beginning it was actual mistakes like continuity being off and such.

    • @hewhoeatsall
      @hewhoeatsall 3 роки тому

      no

  • @GrapefruitMac
    @GrapefruitMac 6 років тому +202

    I'm glad you skip "that" part. That was rough to watch.

    • @cpurchase7237
      @cpurchase7237 4 роки тому +43

      I know what you mean. Not much fazes me, but that scene was DISTURBING

    • @chicken595
      @chicken595 4 роки тому +1

      @Kenny Wright Ikr 😂

    • @justsomegirlwithoutamustache
      @justsomegirlwithoutamustache 4 роки тому +6

      @Kenny Wright The rape scene I think

    • @earlycuyler4019
      @earlycuyler4019 4 роки тому

      Awwwwww

    • @bradsimpson8724
      @bradsimpson8724 4 роки тому +24

      Yeah, I watched this movie a couple of times, but I skipped that scene after the first watch. I'll watch a lot of dark shit with no objection, but that definitely toed the line for me.

  • @MrBallaBoy21
    @MrBallaBoy21 6 років тому +87

    The revenge scenes should remove like, 20 sins.

  • @neachtarrsainn3216
    @neachtarrsainn3216 6 років тому +56

    Really wish they had done the other 2! Rooney Mara did an excellent job portraying Lisbeth Salander!

    • @jbvader721
      @jbvader721 Рік тому +1

      Take your complaints to Sony.

  • @grandmakida6591
    @grandmakida6591 6 років тому +528

    Can I just point out that the swedish original name of this movie is "men who hate women", now you can see why the Bjurman part is relevant to the main point of the story..

    • @Heron11177
      @Heron11177 6 років тому +25

      Holy shit! Our crazy industry usually make some tacky adaptations of titles
      Ex: Saw is called Mortal Games (Jogos Mortais)
      But it's a bit rare when they stick to the original title or just translate it properly
      That movie is called Millennium: Os Homens Que Não Amavam as Mulheres
      Hue
      That's so weird

    • @Heron11177
      @Heron11177 6 років тому +15

      It is a bit different from "not love" to "hate"
      XD
      Ah, Brasil

    • @cheymilion3168
      @cheymilion3168 6 років тому +1

      @@Heron11177 the English book got the same name I think , it's been a wild.

    • @sorayaimperial
      @sorayaimperial 6 років тому +4

      @@Heron11177 Em Portugal é Os homens que odeiam as mulheres. Which is totally pointless. I mean "men who hate women" is "homens que odeiam mulheres" as in general women, not some particular women. I hate translations.
      Then again, Inglorious Bastards is called Sacanas sem Lei. And Die Hard é Assalto ao Arranha Céus. And "Millenium 2: The Girl who played with fire" suddenly turns into, tcharam, "A rapariga que sonhava com uma lata de gasolina e um fósforo"... F'ING WHAT?!
      Then again, The Godfather came out in Brasil as O Poderoso Chefão so.... xD

    • @Heron11177
      @Heron11177 6 років тому

      ​@@sorayaimperial They even tossed a minor spoiler for the movie "A Dog's Purpose"

  • @SupremeLeaderKimJong-un
    @SupremeLeaderKimJong-un 6 років тому +1421

    Please do Everything Wrong with The Interview. I know for a fact my death in it is wrong since I'm immortal

    • @paranidherc
      @paranidherc 6 років тому +32

      But...there is nothing wrong with The Interview

    • @erikgardner4777
      @erikgardner4777 6 років тому +74

      @@paranidherc except his death because as he just said he's immortal

    • @jimb.7523
      @jimb.7523 6 років тому +8

      Hard for Jeremy to do a EWW for a comedy.

    • @summertyme5748
      @summertyme5748 6 років тому

      Hahahaha.

    • @tintinismybelgian
      @tintinismybelgian 6 років тому +1

      There needed to be a scene in it where the protagonists liberated a prison camp.

  • @PoojsVarietyHour
    @PoojsVarietyHour 6 років тому +783

    The MAIN thing wrong was Fincher wasn't allowed the complete the trilogy and Rooney/Craig weren't invited back!

    • @1cjoseph11
      @1cjoseph11 6 років тому +5

      Pooj Reviews Why did that happen?

    • @PoojsVarietyHour
      @PoojsVarietyHour 6 років тому +85

      @@1cjoseph11 Because Sony decided to release the movie on boxing day - which is movie death date so it didn't perform as well as they may have liked. Therefore, instead of continuing with the other 2 books in the series to complete the trilogy, they decided to reboot with new cast with the 4th book which was written by a different author all together. Sad times - the movie was a critical success and having read the first book, this movie was a very faithful adaptation.

    • @xRebeccaWolf
      @xRebeccaWolf 6 років тому +18

      @@PoojsVarietyHour You need to read up. The 4th movie wasnt written by a different author. The original author had the script for the 4th book but died before publishing it, thus it was published by a dear friend of his. There are 3 movies for the 3 books already out that are phenomenal and made by swedish film industry. I recomend them, unlike this american garbage.

    • @PoojsVarietyHour
      @PoojsVarietyHour 6 років тому +51

      @@xRebeccaWolf Firstly - you're wrong. It was by a different author given PERMISSION by Larson's estate - you can read it on the wiki for one here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Girl_in_the_Spider's_Web
      Secondly, I never said that there weren't movies for the others books nor that they are garbage. Fincher is a brilliant director, so while you may hate American movies, degrading all american film makers due to their nationality is a pretty sucky thing to do.

    • @xRebeccaWolf
      @xRebeccaWolf 6 років тому +7

      @@PoojsVarietyHour Firstly, I never said you claimed the swedish movies were garbage, so please do not lie.
      Secondly, Fincher is a good director, but this movie was awful, that is my opinion.
      Thirdly, I NEVER degraded all american film makers, I said that the movie was american garbage, that is in no way me saying that all american movies are garbage. So please, dont lie :)

  • @jarlhenrik
    @jarlhenrik 6 років тому +183

    16:32 This is one of the bigger sub-plots of the books that the movies never really explain well. Erika and Greger are in an open marriage, where Mikael and Greger at least respect eachother if not being openly friendly. Erika loves them both differently. Greger is her husband, but due to *reasons* they spend much time apart, while MIkael and Erika work together and live fairly close to eachother. Thus they frquently hook up for some sex, giving Erika release when Greger isn't around, while Mikael who can't handle a steady relationship gets his sex-itch scratched. It's a deal that works fine for all 3. Michael and Gregor never talk outside of the occasional "how do you do", so whoever Mikael fucks beyond his wife isn't his concern.

    • @delfin7461
      @delfin7461 6 років тому +18

      @@beachboy1840 NO, it's just that Swedes aren't that uptight about sex and relationships. Norwegians tend to be the same way. As long as there's trust and it's mostly a "don't ask, don't tell" kind of thing, it can work. That's what's presented here.

    • @levischorpioen
      @levischorpioen 6 років тому +5

      @@delfin7461 That's just most Europeans, to be perfectly honest. Especial Northern Europeans. We simply don't give a fuck.

    • @delfin7461
      @delfin7461 6 років тому +8

      @@levischorpioen Fair enough! I lived in the Czech Republic for 10 years and have been all over Europe and have tons of Northern European friends so, yeah, you are right. Americans have tons of sexual hang ups, it's one of the reasons we have so many sex crimes. It's too bad the guy doing this video doesn't realize that it's just not a big deal. :-) - I live in Vietnam now and I think there might be some very strange ideas about sex, I know the sex ed isn't very good here. I do know that people are VERY embarrassed by talking about sex and even kids in their late teens/early twenties giggle and "ew" at any sort of sex in films.

    • @beachboy1840
      @beachboy1840 6 років тому +24

      delfin7461 Call it what you want, not “caring” or “don’t ask don’t tell” are just other ways to say the relationship didn’t have any worth to begin with. Swingers have the highest rate of failure out of any couples including homosexual relationships which are over 70% more likely to split than a heterosexual relationship. Being s swinger is being open about cheating, no matter if you agree on it or not before your relationship begins.

    • @Yabbaxoraz
      @Yabbaxoraz 6 років тому +33

      @@delfin7461 "not being uptight about sex and relationships" is not the same thing as being ok with your wife being fucked by another man, that's just misunderstanding the point of a marriage

  • @boopiedoopiee1017
    @boopiedoopiee1017 6 років тому +367

    Coraline please do Coraline

    • @guido7677
      @guido7677 6 років тому +1

      I would love to see that!

    • @B_Squar3d
      @B_Squar3d 6 років тому +4

      I think they did....it just got taken down. Don’t quote me on that but I could’ve sworn I saw it

    • @goreman7160
      @goreman7160 6 років тому

      Like the fact it's rated pg I believe and uh.... Glitter.... I watched this when I was 8

    • @deadpopstar
      @deadpopstar 6 років тому +2

      Yes I'd love to see them do Coraline!! And I thought Coraline was PG-13 for "disturbing imagery" & "semi-adult themes"..could be/prob. am wrong there; just thought that. Prob. thought so because the great novel by the outstanding Neil Gaiman would be rated PG-13 if books were rated.

    • @coralineparmentierworldpianist
      @coralineparmentierworldpianist 6 років тому

      I'm already made XD

  • @Ackalan
    @Ackalan 6 років тому +330

    I just want to point Sweden has the same population percentage of fluent english speaking citizens as Canada, it's taught from fourth grade to the end of high school, there are no dubbed series or films on TV, most kids play games in english and most parents start teaching their kids english in kindergarden.
    There's not a single reason why all these people wouldn't be able to hold interviews in english.
    Why this would be preferable is another question entirely, but not the one asked.
    Edit: Also, great pun about "fjordshadowing", but the correct term would be "fjärdshadowing" since a fjord is a bay surrounded by steep cliffs, while a fjärd is a bay with very low rocks and cliffs in and around it and the photo is obviously from a fjärd.
    Am I being petty?

    • @Xenobat
      @Xenobat 6 років тому +41

      I genuinely found your comment interesting and educational. Not what I usually find in comment sections! *Removes sin*

    • @Klm49
      @Klm49 6 років тому +5

      This comment just made my day!

    • @TheodoreAzlain
      @TheodoreAzlain 6 років тому +1

      From what I remember, we are taught english in second grade (when we are 8 years old) and games, shows and movies do get dubbed but those are usually directed toward children.

    • @TaylorPhase
      @TaylorPhase 6 років тому

      i mean pewdiepie is swedish and he speaks english

    • @GreenBaldrick
      @GreenBaldrick 5 років тому +6

      Swedes being able to speak English doesn't explain them speaking English instead of Swedish in Sweden while speaking with another Swedes. In this movie this happens only in order to make the movie an English-lanuage one and not for some logical reason which actually makes sense.

  • @lcult2001
    @lcult2001 6 років тому +435

    The Dragon with the Girl Tattoo

  • @trollmanable
    @trollmanable 5 років тому +198

    My biggest problem with this film was the ending. I felt the girl was put through enough shit, and deserved a happier outcome with a guy that she genuinely liked.

    • @sinutnaprezidenta5457
      @sinutnaprezidenta5457 3 роки тому +14

      I thought the movie should've had a little different ,,killing Martin and saving Mikael" scene and Mikael and Lisbeth being together to be the ending. The part after this when Lisbeth stoles all of Wilmstromes(whatever his name is) money and gets him killed someway off-screen was a little unnesecary.

    • @creativecacti9686
      @creativecacti9686 3 роки тому +14

      I agree 😔I was devistated at the ending my hopes were so high for them 😭

    • @justsomegirlwithoutamustache
      @justsomegirlwithoutamustache 3 роки тому +30

      He's already in a cheating relatioship so I'm not surprised he didn't wanna stay with her. The ending was sad but she deserved better than him

    • @AxTechs
      @AxTechs 3 роки тому +16

      That's not a problem with the film at all, the fact that your pissed off shows that it's a great plot point and that it invests you in the characters

    • @creativecacti9686
      @creativecacti9686 3 роки тому +3

      @@AxTechs That is very true I agree 100 percent.

  • @air03man
    @air03man 6 років тому +566

    Brought to you by "the girl in the spider's web" in theaters this Friday

    • @jarlhenrik
      @jarlhenrik 6 років тому +5

      wait really? this shitty remake made enough bank to justify remaking the newest book? Or is the new one handled by different people and companies?

    • @AWorldofKayos
      @AWorldofKayos 6 років тому +3

      The second

    • @amanibob1416
      @amanibob1416 6 років тому +10

      What happened to the girl with the Golden Compass? Oh... Wait... My mistake!

    • @cadillacdeville5828
      @cadillacdeville5828 6 років тому

      Why thank-you sir

    • @MrGabeanator
      @MrGabeanator 6 років тому

      steve blum yep

  • @Nova-sama420
    @Nova-sama420 6 років тому +477

    Main sin : Movie does not contain an actual Dragon.

    • @JimmyMon666
      @JimmyMon666 6 років тому +14

      you forget there's the word tattoo at the end. I'm not sure if they actually show the dragon tattoo since I haven't seen this movie.

    • @fen4613
      @fen4613 6 років тому +3

      Jimmy M you forget the context joke.

    • @michaelc1632
      @michaelc1632 6 років тому +1

      The original was WAY better in my opinion.

    • @Zach-Fetters
      @Zach-Fetters 5 років тому

      @@fen4613 that's not how you do a context joke.

    • @victorix30
      @victorix30 4 роки тому +1

      Jimmy M they do couple of times when Lisbeth is naked. Especially in a sex scene

  • @JanOnDemand
    @JanOnDemand 6 років тому +338

    Yes, in smaller Swedish communities, local phone numbers are 5 digits long. *ding*

    • @606danco
      @606danco 6 років тому +1

      JanOnDemand where i live its six

    • @NilsForsman
      @NilsForsman 6 років тому +7

      In Sweden, hardline area codes are 2-4 numbers and the local part varies from 5-8
      These are the patterns numbers follow ( - ):
      08-xxx xxx xx
      08-xxx xx xx
      08-xx xx xx
      0yy-xxx xx xx
      0yy-xx xx xx
      0yy-xxx xx
      0yyy-xx xx xx
      0yyy-xxx xx
      So in some areas there exists local part numbers that is 5 digits.
      Since Hedestad is a fictional place so it is a bit hard to say if it would've made sense in that location.

    • @TheReZisTLust
      @TheReZisTLust 6 років тому +2

      Who's number is 55555

    • @ashthomas5827
      @ashthomas5827 6 років тому +2

      @@NilsForsman i live in Australia... ive always wanted to go to sweden... well the parts that havent been ruined by Somalians etc. Is Umea still nice?

    • @Cerebrosum
      @Cerebrosum 6 років тому +22

      @@ashthomas5827 "Ruined" is a very strong word. Especially when used by someone so far away. News have a tendency to distort the further away one is, because the mundane doesn't sell.
      Of course no matter how "bad" or "good" one would say that the immigration issue is it's not really something that'd affect a tourist. So come on by if you want to, enjoy the sights and have fun.

  • @AdamG1983
    @AdamG1983 6 років тому +102

    Daniel Craig specifically gained weight so he wouldn't be looking like a secret agent. Great research, guys.
    *DING*

    • @comfortouch
      @comfortouch 4 роки тому +13

      I gain more weight when I'm bloated on my period. Maybe he should have identified as a girl for the role.

    • @deodorant2191
      @deodorant2191 4 роки тому +4

      @@comfortouch the single best comment on this entire video hands down.

  • @TravisHouze
    @TravisHouze 6 років тому +449

    He brought back the infamous first sin: “This movie exists.”

    • @adolfodelao9335
      @adolfodelao9335 6 років тому +36

      Travis Houze what about the scene does not contain a lap dance?

    • @amanibob1416
      @amanibob1416 6 років тому +2

      At least they didn't SPARKLES!!!

    • @JusticeforLiberty
      @JusticeforLiberty 6 років тому +2

      6,000,000,000 sins because this movie exists

    • @need-to-know-
      @need-to-know- 6 років тому +3

      Well we already had this movie, so yes.

    • @DevinLind
      @DevinLind 6 років тому

      And rightly so.

  • @rofln00b
    @rofln00b 6 років тому +13

    11:44 clearly you've never experienced life in the rural parts of the Nordic countries. People leave car keys in the car with doors unlocked. Barns and shit never have locks. Houses are often left unlocked, and if the front door is locked when everyone leaves, back door might still be open. That's just the way it is.

  • @sinutnaprezidenta5457
    @sinutnaprezidenta5457 3 роки тому +65

    David Fincher just likes to extend his movies. Sometimes putting unnesecary information or extending the plot too much. But who cares he makes absolute masterpieces. One of the best directors regardless.

    • @philocleandes9302
      @philocleandes9302 Рік тому

      He seems to have a fetish for well-dressed rich people in expensive houses and offices.

  • @catwmn2345
    @catwmn2345 6 років тому +242

    "fjordshadowing" would have been a fun joke if this was Norway, but it's not, so.... SIN!

    • @Teekalin
      @Teekalin 6 років тому +13

      We have fjords in Sweden too so...

    • @kylpyvene
      @kylpyvene 6 років тому +1

      @@Teekalin is the english word for it fjord?

    • @catwmn2345
      @catwmn2345 6 років тому +6

      @@Teekalin But do we really call them fjords (fjordar)? I would say we don't. We call them "vikar" as in inlets, bays or bights maybe.

    • @Teekalin
      @Teekalin 6 років тому +2

      @@catwmn2345 Not sure actually. I've always heard them called Fjords (fjordar) but it could be that we just use the Norwegian name.
      I am quite positive that Vikar is a different thing though.

    • @Teekalin
      @Teekalin 6 років тому +3

      @@catwmn2345 This is from the Wikipedia page.
      "I Västsverige betecknar "fjord" ibland ett identifierbart öppet vattenområde som Dana fjord, Hakefjorden eller Rivöfjorden. I östra Sverige används ordet fjärd på ett liknande sätt, men kan där också beteckna vilken vik eller vilket öppet vattenområde som helst i en skärgård. Ordet kan i Norge och angränsande delar av Sverige även beteckna en långsmal insjö, som i Tyrifjorden och Glafsfjorden.
      "Etymologiskt sett är orden fjord och fjärd identiska; skillnaden är från början bara olika uttal av samma ord i olika dialekter. Det första ordet används längs Sveriges västkust (som var norsk/dansk före 1658), och i Norge och Danmark. Det senare ordet används i östra Sverige men kan där också vara av betydelsen havsvik.
      "Gränsen mellan de olika dialektområdena går genom Blekinge - i östra Blekinge kallas vikarna fjärdar och i västra fjordar."

  • @dinsism
    @dinsism 6 років тому +135

    I absolutely love this film, it’s long as fuck, but the beauty of Sweden and the atmosphere easily makes up for it

    • @Crimson_Thief007
      @Crimson_Thief007 6 років тому +5

      Just go to Sweden then, instead of punishing yourself with this movie.

  • @djvoldemort1
    @djvoldemort1 6 років тому +23

    In its own right, without comparing it to the original, It's a damn masterpiece.

  • @megfilms9437
    @megfilms9437 6 років тому +32

    I love both adaptations of this book, and some of these sins can be explained by the book. I am a massive Rooney Mara fan tho so this film is my bias. I just wish Fincher could have finished the trilogy with Mara and Craig!

    • @billmartins5545
      @billmartins5545 2 роки тому +4

      I would literally pay £200 for a movie ticket for the second and third movies each, had they been made in the us remake.

  • @dogesmith7942
    @dogesmith7942 6 років тому +76

    Plague was a fat, lazy but brilliant hacker in the book tho lol

    • @comfortouch
      @comfortouch 4 роки тому +4

      Yeah, that shouldn't be a sin, 'cause every hacker I know IS a fat lazy dude, often with a 13y/o maturity level, and opts to play video games and smoke weed in his 'off' time.. which happens to be a lot of hackers since I do live in silicone valley.

  • @NopeJustPatrick
    @NopeJustPatrick 6 років тому +80

    I'm still pissed that they never finished the trilogy, this adaption showed a lot of promise.

    • @IreneWY
      @IreneWY 4 роки тому +1

      the whole book series is not finished either...

    • @NopeJustPatrick
      @NopeJustPatrick 4 роки тому +1

      @@IreneWY Also true.

    • @arx754
      @arx754 4 роки тому +6

      Huh? The author, Greg Larsson, delivered the manuscripts for THREE books before he died in 2004. "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo", "The Girl Who Played with Fire", and "The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest". I've read all three, so I don't get your statement that the trilogy was never finished. ?

    • @arx754
      @arx754 4 роки тому +2

      @@IreneWY : Larsson, the author of the 3 books out, died in 2004.

    • @NopeJustPatrick
      @NopeJustPatrick 4 роки тому +3

      @@arx754 This is a video about the movie, which is likely not receiving any sequels. I've read the books, I know they're complete.

  • @G-Unit1111
    @G-Unit1111 6 років тому +148

    Also... "Stellan Skarsgard plays the obligatory actual Swedish guy in a Swedish role in an American film", cliche. **DING**
    Also also - "Daniel Craig gets tortured by the bad guy" cliche. **DING**
    Also also also - "Creepy guy with too many security cameras in his house really is hiding something horrible in his basement" cliche. **DING**

    • @68404
      @68404 6 років тому

      Don't forget the multistory car park shot. Why is the concrete wet? Like, total cover...

    • @G-Unit1111
      @G-Unit1111 6 років тому

      True! **DING** @@68404

    • @kisun7123
      @kisun7123 5 років тому +1

      Cliche because he plays BOND?

    • @AndreyAndreyevich
      @AndreyAndreyevich 5 років тому

      Martin isn't a creepy guy with lots of security cameras, at least none was shown in the movie

  • @Dan-xt7sv
    @Dan-xt7sv 6 років тому +35

    5:04 "I guess proud infidelity is a THING in Sweden?"
    buddy you have no idea.

    • @tylerrebik7700
      @tylerrebik7700 3 роки тому +2

      I was married to a Swedish woman and lived there.
      That's some truth.

  • @twentywordsorlessYT
    @twentywordsorlessYT 6 років тому +8

    3:54-56 As a Master's student, this is an INCREDIBLY accurate description of my life right now.

  • @metalhead8659
    @metalhead8659 3 роки тому +6

    9:52. It makes sense, that Martin wants Mikael to keep on with his research, in the end, it is revealed, that Martin didn't kill her, but was always wondering all these years, what happened to her. In the interrogation of Mikael, when Mikael accuses Martin to be her murderer, he firstly hopefully but aggressively wants to hear, what happened to her, he thought, Mikael found her and only starts to consider him useless, when he realizes, that Mikael only tracked down the truth about Martin and his father...

  • @vladimirhorowitz
    @vladimirhorowitz 11 місяців тому +1

    This movie's an all-timer. I disagree with most of these scenes, although I'll concede that the golf club whack at the end was indeed a little rote and the "we're not so different, you and I" cliche wasn't needed. But the "Satisfying my urges requires more towels" line more than makes up for it. Just a masterpiece of a film.

  • @randymootooveran5784
    @randymootooveran5784 6 років тому +146

    Personally I like this version more. David Fincher is always awesome.

    • @AnimaniacZero
      @AnimaniacZero 6 років тому +14

      The Fincher/Reznor-Ross one-two combo is always pleasing.

    • @emmanuelwil-jeff
      @emmanuelwil-jeff 6 років тому +9

      For what it was I liked it the actress who played Lisbeth was great woulda liked to see a sequel with her and Daniel Craig was good

    • @OrangeGraffiti
      @OrangeGraffiti 6 років тому +5

      I watched the Swedish one first, and love it. The story flows much better in that. But I also loved this version, the cinematography is beautiful and I love the actors... though as mentioned here, the story can be muddled and hard to understand in the US version.... so I always suggest newcomers to watch the Swedish one first.

    • @Yunghamz
      @Yunghamz 6 років тому +1

      Agreed. It's tough to like the swedish version if you've read the book. The script was dissapointing. Martin and henrik were casted better in fincher's version. Martin is supposed to be a likeable character at first but comes across as a cunt from the get go in the swedish version when he refers to mikeal as 'kalle'. Makes the reveal in the end underwhelming.

    • @kisun7123
      @kisun7123 5 років тому

      I totally agree

  • @piiiiko
    @piiiiko 6 років тому +12

    0:42, you can remove that sin, cuz all TV's have shit audio unless you go to a "luxurious" cafe (Yes I'm from Sweden)

  • @MegaSoulHero
    @MegaSoulHero 6 років тому +128

    Do Everything Wrong With Incredibles 2

    • @PoojsVarietyHour
      @PoojsVarietyHour 6 років тому +4

      How when that is a perfect movie...
      ...remake of Incredibles 1

    • @GradietPanda12345
      @GradietPanda12345 6 років тому

      Pooj Reviews it’s not a remake idiot

    • @PoojsVarietyHour
      @PoojsVarietyHour 6 років тому +4

      @@GradietPanda12345 it was a joke bro lol chill

    • @michealward7992
      @michealward7992 6 років тому +1

      r/wooosh

    • @Theauu
      @Theauu 6 років тому +9

      @@PalataoBola0 Stop advertising your fucking garbage channel.

  • @MasanMarsan
    @MasanMarsan 8 місяців тому +1

    11:45 There is a culture of not locking doors and cars in some parts of sweden. Especially the north. My family never lock the house during the day. They explained to me as a child that people for example might need to go inside during a snow storm to survive, could get away in case of a bear or moose attack (yes, you should be afraid of moose), could hide and call the cops if someone was trying to hurt them or call an ambulance if someone got hurt. 👍

  • @chatchaat
    @chatchaat 5 років тому +8

    I'm only two minutes into this but this version of GWTDT is fucking great. Part of what makes it great is the multiple story/plot lines it takes, all of which are done extremely well.

  • @BatmanHQYT
    @BatmanHQYT 6 місяців тому +1

    Honestly, the density of the intertwined storylines is what makes this movie so unique and compelling for me. Fincher does an astounding job keeping it all feeling coherent without any drag to the pace. I know this channel isn't meant to be taken too seriously but Jeremy made such a fuss about the number of subplots and yet they're all explored quite well.

  • @shadesofgray5476
    @shadesofgray5476 6 років тому +6

    I think the reason Martin seemed supportive of Blomkvist's investigation is because he actually wanted to know what happened to Harriet. That is why he got mad when B still accused him of killing her. He probably suspected Harriet escaped.

  • @drjohnson98
    @drjohnson98 3 роки тому +1

    Biggest thing wrong with it is that it was unnecessary. The Swedish original was great and actually Swedish.

  • @Ajax-0137
    @Ajax-0137 5 років тому +36

    Remember when CinemaSins focused mostly on LEGITIMATE mistakes? Pepperidge farm remembers

    • @AndreyAndreyevich
      @AndreyAndreyevich 5 років тому +1

      this is the only episode I've seen and have no intention to watch any other. hope it was really decent at some point)

    • @JLHunter61
      @JLHunter61 5 років тому +1

      To what are you referring? CinemaSins? The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo franchise? Movies? Because, if it is this CinemaSins episode to which you are referring, then I feel bad for you.
      I agree that this episode is lacking, and some of their "reviews" are certainly lacking, especially some of the newer ones, but many of their reviews are incredibly hilarious. You should view a couple more before giving up on them.

    • @Zach-Fetters
      @Zach-Fetters 5 років тому +1

      No you don't because it's been the same since God created heaven and earth. It was heaven, earth, cinimasins dogs and so on.

  • @scythehound
    @scythehound 6 років тому +53

    "Everything wrong with Matilda", that old ass kids movie that is worth being sinned 😂

    • @Klm49
      @Klm49 6 років тому +3

      Oh agreed times a thousand!! Recently watched it again and lord have mercy there are a lot of seriously neglectful parents living in that town if Trunchbull can torture those kids and not one parent discovers the truth!!!! As a parent now myself I feel horrified. But it is still one of my fav movies from childhood.

    • @vantamcfly4618
      @vantamcfly4618 3 роки тому

      @@Klm49 thats the whole point of the movie luv

  • @PorgWitch
    @PorgWitch 6 років тому +9

    Everytime you do a book adaptation I usually hear you point out something in the film that was explained in the book. I'm super happy to hear you making comparisons because although not everyone reads the book before seeing the movie and films should stand on their own, I find making comparisons of translation very important!

  • @TR230de
    @TR230de 6 років тому +47

    I loved the Swedish one I feel like the actress who played Lisbeth was phenomenal

  • @SkefnarmPictures
    @SkefnarmPictures 6 років тому +118

    Movie takes place in Sweden; hammers this in by having one of the first shots be of the letter Å *ding*

    • @karcavida3250
      @karcavida3250 6 років тому +1

      That letter doesn't exist in Swedish?

    • @SkefnarmPictures
      @SkefnarmPictures 6 років тому +3

      It *only* exists in Swedish, I think. It's just a little on-the-näsa, if you catch my drift.

    • @diamondsofsix
      @diamondsofsix 6 років тому +2

      @@SkefnarmPictures And norwegian, danish and icelandic?

  • @Steve__________
    @Steve__________ 6 років тому +5

    9:53 Because he wants to know where his sister is. You can see how excited he is in the scene where he's torturing Mikael when he thinks Mikael might've found out what happened to her.

  • @peterfrank3365
    @peterfrank3365 6 років тому +92

    Fincher's remake would've been the superior version if he had his trilogy.

  • @samueltheprideofafrikarobi9319
    @samueltheprideofafrikarobi9319 6 років тому +14

    This movie gets A LOT of unnecessary hate from movie circles. I thought it was rather good. And it seemed to have more...octane than the original film. Which was an utter bore. Not to mention that IT'S 30 MINUTES LONGER THAN THE REMAKE. (A point I'm sure that CinemaSins simply "forgot" to mention while he was ragging this version's run time.)
    I tend to view it in the same way that I view Let Me In...which people also hated. These are two movies that are better than their original properties in a lot of ways. They both have higher production values, better direction (which is, admittedly subjective), better pacing, better acting and better cinematography. You could even argue that the scripting was superior without altering what made these properties what they were. Many people seem fixated on the fact that "they're not the originals" instead of looking at the quality of the properties themselves. Just because something wasn't first doesn't mean that it's not as good if not better than what proceeded it.
    What's really baking my noodle though is that critical response to this film was so negative that it effectively killed the rest of this version of the trilogy..........yet it was still apparently good enough that we're getting another film with this exact same art direction in this same universe from a later tattoo trilogy. I'm confused. What am I missing? Did the world hate the American version or not? Because for all of that, we could have just finished the story that was originally being told.

    • @AndreyAndreyevich
      @AndreyAndreyevich 5 років тому

      this isn't a remake, it's a screen adaptation of the book tho)

  • @fnaffan5867
    @fnaffan5867 6 років тому +55

    Can You Do Scream 4 Next To Complete The Scream Franchise?

    • @Pikashades
      @Pikashades 6 років тому +7

      We're probably getting that by next year's Halloween.

    • @WilliamButtlicker
      @WilliamButtlicker 3 роки тому

      He hasn't done Scream 3 either I think

  • @snarkmark
    @snarkmark 2 роки тому +1

    8:18 I used to have the phone number 30566, so the answer is yes (or no depending on the question), the teachings of the movie is correct.

  • @andrewjohnson6716
    @andrewjohnson6716 5 років тому +8

    You'd actually be amazed at how much of day to day life goes on in English in modern Stockholm. Everyone speaks it, so it has become the lingua franca of the international community in Europe and Scandinavia.

  • @henrikandersson6757
    @henrikandersson6757 2 роки тому +11

    Being a Swede myself, I would say that (back in the day) it was very common that phone numbers only included five digits. It would (of course) depend on the area (code) and what part of the country you lived in. Living in Stockholm for example wouldn't quite cut it of course...
    For example: Hedeby and by extension Hedestad are fictional places, in the countryside as in regard to our real world. But it would be situated (and was actually in part filmed!!) very close to where I live in real life... The point being: living in the same area code meant that anyone within that area code only needed to dial five (5) digits to reach anyone in the same area code district. So no, Cinemasins... it's not bullsh*t at all! **PLING** 😛😛😛
    As far as I know, this system actually still exists today, though there are (naturally) fewer and fewer clients that use "land-based" telephone numbers around today.

  • @DinosaurVlogs
    @DinosaurVlogs 6 років тому +42

    I love the books and this made me want to read them all over again, it's a shame I can't find the Swedish movies now :/

    • @LuLu-Sil
      @LuLu-Sil 3 роки тому

      Have you tried Netflix recently?

    • @robertolopez1904
      @robertolopez1904 3 роки тому +3

      Torrent.

    • @LolitaDavidovich934
      @LolitaDavidovich934 3 роки тому

      You can rent them on UA-cam , but I do not know if they are subtitled.

    • @aleksandrac9335
      @aleksandrac9335 Рік тому

      I have all on dvd:)

    • @Daemon1995_
      @Daemon1995_ Рік тому

      @@LuLu-Silno longer on Netflix aside from finder and the shitty reboot

  • @ChakatStripedfur
    @ChakatStripedfur 6 років тому +1

    The Swedish Chef reference at the end just made this 100% funnier for me.

  • @justsomegirlwithoutamustache
    @justsomegirlwithoutamustache Рік тому +3

    The original may have been fine, but the remake is remarkable and one of my favourite films.

  • @sinutnaprezidenta5457
    @sinutnaprezidenta5457 3 роки тому +2

    3:01 Exactly. After finishing the movie that was the only thing that didn't sit wright with me.
    I completely excluded the option that it might be Harriet who is sending the pictures beacause yeah why would she even do that. She is trying to disspear.
    But there might be another thing. Maybe Harriet wanted Henrick to know that she is alive so that's why she was sending the pictures but obviosly as the film showed Henrick most certainly wasn't thinking of that option.

  • @citrusforce
    @citrusforce 6 років тому +10

    "If I met this guy I'dve immediately been on my Skarsgard." I'm dying!! That was too good.
    The Dj Khaled one was also great!

    • @need-to-know-
      @need-to-know- 6 років тому

      I didn't get the DJ Khalid reference. Care to clue a brother in?

    • @Schwedeballz
      @Schwedeballz 6 років тому

      Same

    • @TheCstar07
      @TheCstar07 6 років тому +1

      @@need-to-know- dj Khaled went on the breakfast club and said he'd never do cunnalingus but he expects a woman to give him head because he's a man and deserves it.

    • @need-to-know-
      @need-to-know- 6 років тому +1

      @@TheCstar07 thanks.

  • @JasonScotchmer
    @JasonScotchmer 9 місяців тому

    Here are all the audio outtake clips at the end:
    1 (16:48): Snowpiercer (English dub; CJ Entertainment, 2014)
    2 (16:55): So I Married an Axe Murderer (TriStar Pictures, 1993)
    3 (17:05): Kiss Kiss Bang Bang (Warner Bros., 2005)
    4 (17:10): Fight Club (20th Century Studios, 1999)
    5 (17:13): The Princess Bride (20th Century Studios, 1987)
    6 (17:15): Good Will Hunting (Miramax, 1997)
    7 (17:27): Old School (DreamWorks Pictures, 2003)
    8 (17:29): Happy Gilmore (Universal Pictures, 1996)

  • @sinutnaprezidenta5457
    @sinutnaprezidenta5457 3 роки тому +3

    13:18 that scene is made for us! So we can get a clear view of what is going on and of course so Lisbeth can have time to come and save him...but i wouldn't count that as a sin cuz this information of Martin's is needed

  • @nnnosebleed
    @nnnosebleed 2 роки тому +3

    This movie's just one of those movies man. One of those movies that's beautiful to look at, but still has enough story to remain interesting and engaging.

  • @TeatroGrotesco
    @TeatroGrotesco 5 років тому +4

    I think that sin for the magazine business was only to show Robin Wright walking away in slomo.
    And I thank you.

  • @mirigoodman8143
    @mirigoodman8143 6 років тому +1

    @CinemaSins Please do the Princess Bride. You always do audio outtakes from it and I love it every time you do. I want to see how you could tear it apart. I LOVE IT

  • @michellegomes2030
    @michellegomes2030 2 роки тому +7

    There’s nothing wrong with this masterpiece

  • @abdaniel487
    @abdaniel487 6 років тому +1

    Holy Jesus that Swedish Chef punishment was hilarious.

  • @bodasactra
    @bodasactra 5 років тому +13

    This film is one of the finest examples of a director who actually understands the finer methods of the art.

  • @theghostoferictheactor9808
    @theghostoferictheactor9808 2 роки тому +2

    Fincher is the master of opening credits

  • @MDARapBattleTurnier
    @MDARapBattleTurnier 6 років тому +18

    FINALLY! THANKS

  • @kleetus92
    @kleetus92 6 років тому +1

    Ok, I almost spit out my coffee on the Swedish Chef... LOL

  • @JakeDisselt
    @JakeDisselt 6 років тому +7

    I've never understood how Harriet vanished and her body was never found and how she was the only one who gave him a flower every year on his birthday and no one else knew about this and after Harriet vanishes, Henrik continues to receive flowers every year to the same date and for some reason, Henrik just simply assumes that she was murdered and her killer is toying with him, rather than she simply ran away and has been continuously sending him flowers as an acknowledgement that she is alright.
    *Also, when Mikael first meets Lisbeth Daniel clearly calls her 'Elizabeth'.

    • @pianolararen4957
      @pianolararen4957 6 років тому +1

      John D'Isselt but after Never hearing anything from her its not weird that he thinks she is dead.
      The funny thing is that i am swedish so i have seen the swedish ones millons of times and they are so much better😅

    • @JakeDisselt
      @JakeDisselt 6 років тому

      @@pianolararen4957 I like Fincher's better personally.
      I guess it makes sense that Henrik thinks that but how come no one else does? There's a couple scenes in the film where 1). Mikael asks 'she didn't just run away?'
      2). Joely Richardson (I forgot her fake name but I know she turns out to be Harriet) says she felt really bad for Harriet and she would have gotten away a long time ago
      I feel like my first assumption would have been that Harriet ran away

    • @lusciousloxx6112
      @lusciousloxx6112 6 років тому +3

      @@JakeDisselt Did you read the books? The way the island was situated, there was only one way out (the bridge). Since no body turned up, since Harriet was too young to drive, since Harriet had no known motive at the time to run away, but there was plenty of motive to dispose of her, and since she had no known family or place to run away to outside of the island, her being a runaway was ruled out. Everyone who knew of the case had no knowledge of the abuse at the hands of her father and brother.

    • @JakeDisselt
      @JakeDisselt 6 років тому +1

      @@lusciousloxx6112 no I didn't know that. Maybe I'm applying too much of my own knowledge of local cases around me towards this. Maybe if I read the book Larsson will spell it out better than how the movie set it up.

  • @nobodyfromnowwhere7510
    @nobodyfromnowwhere7510 6 років тому +1

    I love how they completely buckle to youtube and refuse to show anything that might get the video demonized. It's the exact kind of shit they used to would have called a movie out for.

  • @fabio-01
    @fabio-01 6 років тому +13

    Can you do “The Wolf Of Wall Street“ please

  • @jonathanbethards3689
    @jonathanbethards3689 6 років тому

    4:49 THAT is how you write a pun. It may be lazy comedy, but that was a great one.

  • @AngelsOfTheSea13
    @AngelsOfTheSea13 6 років тому +17

    Wait.. this isnt a re-upload?

  • @robjef622
    @robjef622 6 років тому +5

    Everything Wrong With The Thing (1982). I think it's perfect for these winter months.

    • @cplpetergriffin1583
      @cplpetergriffin1583 6 років тому

      Every time there's a blizzard I think of that fucking head spider

  • @Beetrice
    @Beetrice 6 років тому +4

    I love the books more than the movies. They hold a special place in my heart.

  • @TyReeL7
    @TyReeL7 6 років тому +4

    Please do Tucker and Dale vs Evil. It’s one of my favorite movies and I’d love to see y’all critique of it

  • @dailycarolina.
    @dailycarolina. 6 років тому +5

    The book is AMAZING. Definitely a must read !

  • @WildeFyre69
    @WildeFyre69 6 років тому

    Yes, that *is* Solitaire. There are many, many, many versions of Solitaire... like hundreds. Good video!

  • @MetalTraveler
    @MetalTraveler 6 років тому +37

    Next do the original trilogy :3
    1:40 it's like some of these plots spanned through 3 movies.

  • @yeetalita
    @yeetalita 6 років тому +2

    "Wait, another murder mystery plot INSIDE a murder mystery plot? That's like, 16 murder mystery plots!"
    *I see what you did there*

  • @julieporter7805
    @julieporter7805 6 років тому +3

    I kept cracking up at the Swedish Chef at the end.
    I do agree in the book the Wennestrom subplot ran far too long.

  • @khariscorner
    @khariscorner 6 років тому +1

    You guys love that "What happens when the engine stops we all freeze and die" voice clip, oh but not more than your "tommy how's your peeping"

  • @LadyGhoost
    @LadyGhoost 6 років тому +7

    I remember seeing this, after I have seen the Swedish versions (obviously since I am from Sweden), and I never felt the thrill, creepiness or the mystery as I did in the Swedish version, it was like all of it disappeared. The Swedish version makes the murders interesting, just as the end is more logical. And I felt like Lizbeth was such a more interesting character, just as Mikael. Here he just feels like Bond trying a new job... I don't know, just wished they did more with this movie if they wanted to do another version, especially since they have good actors and all.

  • @chickendrawsdogs3343
    @chickendrawsdogs3343 6 років тому +2

    With that opening, Daniel Craig and the color grating, I REALLY thought I was going to a Bond film.

  • @AndreyAndreyevich
    @AndreyAndreyevich 5 років тому +11

    before watching: nothing really
    after watching: 12:08 that photo was the carpenter's wife's, nobody probably investigated it.

  • @clooperman3745
    @clooperman3745 3 роки тому +2

    We watched the whole film and enjoyed every minute.

  • @epickagraczka4841
    @epickagraczka4841 6 років тому +15

    I've been waiting for this to come out

    • @lulua6203
      @lulua6203 6 років тому +2

      Just like me lol

  • @AndreyAndreyevich
    @AndreyAndreyevich 5 років тому +1

    the main sin is that Sony never made the two next movies but this one is so great that it stands out on its own

  • @oliviamoose9641
    @oliviamoose9641 6 років тому +3

    I liked this movie and wanted more from them and all the things you've sinned I agree with, but the acting and ost and cinematography was amazing and I wanted more.

  • @mmclaurin8035
    @mmclaurin8035 6 років тому +1

    This movie exists because it is ridiculously superior to the original. Fincher is a God, and waaaaaay more talented to whoever directed the first one.

  • @delfin7461
    @delfin7461 6 років тому +5

    the books are incredible. the Swedish films are amazing but VERY face paced and leave out a lot of the small details from the books. I really liked the American version and would love to have seen the other two films. In some ways I like the American version better because it sticks to the book, and seeing the whole side story of Lisbeth going to Zurich(?) and doing all the money stuff is just another thread in the amazingly complex web that is woven in this book and over the course of all three of them. Personally, I recommend all of the films. Crazy good acting and some wild story lines.

  • @psifla99
    @psifla99 6 років тому +2

    The sad (or funny?) thing about CinemaSins is that a good deal of the “sins” aren’t even the movie’s fault.

  • @niceboy171
    @niceboy171 6 років тому +3

    The ending of this movie was heartbreaking, and I wanted to see a sequel to find a resolution. Now we will never get it.

    • @arx754
      @arx754 4 роки тому

      Read the books. Three of them. This is the first one.

    • @niceboy171
      @niceboy171 4 роки тому

      @@arx754 Very true haha

  • @lold6130
    @lold6130 2 роки тому +2

    I love The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

  • @barackobama6231
    @barackobama6231 6 років тому +13

    Lmao the title makes it sound like they are jusy making fun of some girl with a dragon tattoo

    • @madselmvig1457
      @madselmvig1457 6 років тому

      True, the original title "Men that hates Women" is far superior.

  • @MBlacklaw
    @MBlacklaw 6 років тому

    "fjordshadowing" absolutely f-cking priceless...

  • @Reaps
    @Reaps 6 років тому +15

    Only Sin this movie deserves is leaving me without the sequels.. Anywhoo.. Do Evil Dead 2! Do It!

  • @sorenthefilmbrony
    @sorenthefilmbrony 6 років тому +2

    0:59 "The books don't matter," remember?