Thank you Celia for uploading with English subs! Altho' I studied French "J'aime toujours la langue", this really helps. I am one of the latest BIG fan of this film. Came across by chance. I've watched it sooo many times but never bored. Every time I see new details in their expressions, background details, the superb acting and directing, appreciate the "hidden" intense love etc. Fortunately my local library has the Vercors book with both English-French translation (donated by the French government!). I read the English version, now reading the French version. Many differences in the 2004 film from the book, but it helps me appreciate the film.
Yes,many Thanks and appreciations for the excellent work you put into this story , of us that enjoy foreign films and don’t speak and understand language other than English, your dedication is very much appreciated.💕💕
Thank you so much for posting this movie. I have seen it for the first time in Chinese, it was translated into Chinese and shown on Chinese Central Television Channel. This is a perfect film, every detail of it, from the directing, the acting, the script to the music, has been done with perfection. And for my taste it has even surpassed the novel by Vercors.
This is an impossible Love Story which requires some background explanations: During the 2nd war with Germany in 1870, France suffered 1,005,427 casualties. The first World War caused 1,927,000 casualties to France. Jeanne’s Father died in that war (as did Werner’s). No matter how much a cultured German professes his Love for France, he still is an invader and an enemy. These two did share a professional interest in classical Music but that was not enough to bridge the Abyss between them. Jeanne struggled with her feelings as she realized that this German «beast » also had feelings and was exquisitely polite. Nevertheless, Honor and Duty prevailed as she cannot consort with an Occupant of her Country, especially when the outcome of the War, in 1941, was so uncertain. As to him, deeply idealistic, he also became disillusioned after discussing the Reich’s intentions (of cultural annihilation and destruction of occupied lands) with his friends. After the assassination of the two visiting German officers, it was a logical decision for Werner to seize the bull by the horns and leave for the front in Russia. Better to die in action rather than to die a slow and unpredictable death by remaining in France. Thank you so much for uploading this very moving Love Story.
Celia, many, many thanks! I have searched for weeks to no avail. Just when I had given up, there you were, making my life so much better. Such a great story, despite the ending. So well done😍😍
Believe it or not, I have read ALL comments and replies in all the 10 videos. (Celia's uploads) Everyone is so taken by this film...Je l'adore absolutement!!! I think there is a separate Russian fan base under another upload list as well...
I did the same and also read most of the comments in other posting as well after watching it 6 times in 2 days. I wanted to know every details, different experiences and interpretations of other viewers of this marvelous movie .
Thank you for all your hard work on this. I saw Suite Francaise recently and for many reasons, I stumbled across this. Your work is thoroughly appreciated.
Thank you soooo much for posting this WONDERFUL movie and with english subs! My french is not so good so english subs help a lot. I adore this movie it is one of my favorite of all time!😍😍 I have just recently found it on YT and I watched it entire on your channel thanks to your post😊 So thank you million times!!😄😆😙😙
I watched first the movie with spanish subtitlados.second with dutch titles and finally third with englisch subtitles.and am very happy about your version.because now I could understand the french speaking. you did a great job.thanks.it is good enough to understand all.
Tinh yêu không biên giới ,phi chính trị ,nó làm tan chảy mọi trái tim ,dù xa bao lâu ,dù chưa nói một lời nó linh thiêng và chi phối cuộc đời chúng ta .và nó vô cùng đẹp dẽ cho những ai biết yêu ,trân trọng nó ,không một ai dù trong cuộc hay ngoài cuộc có thể hiểu thấu về nó ,tình yêu ngay đó ,ngay trước mắt ,mà ta vẫn không thấy ,không hiểu ,vì vậy mà nó vẫn xa vời vợi ,mong manh ,khó thấy ,khó nắm bắt ,,,,,để một ngày ,để cuộc đời khi đã nhận ra ,để hối tiếc không nguôi .
I ve discovered this movie like a week ago. I have watched it like 50 times already. Of course, step by step I will get tired of keep watching it but this was SUCH a surprise!!! The director is a real genius!!!Same the actors. Both of them. I would say that the male lead, apart from being handsome, has an unusual intelligent act - so subtle which makes it so credible! This is something that only a British actor, classically trained, could have managed...and yet, although I consider the brits the best actors, this role might have been a bit too much even for a brit. American actors are perhaps as bad as the Indian ones in their own way so they need not to be even thought about! However, what a pity that the art of film is now dominated by the really crappy Hollywood/ BOlywood productions while real art and really talented directors and actors are pushed away but the horrible American productions. That is why this movie is a real gem!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Time heals: ironically, Werner von Ebrennac is played by Thomas Jouannet, born in Geneva, neutral Switzerland, of a French father and a German Mother. Therefore, he is fluent in both languages. We shared the same city in the 1970s, when Thomas was between the ages of 2 and 6. Since viewing this film for the first time in late September 2021, I wished I could have baby-sat him when I was in Geneva (instead of obnoxious ex-pat American children) 😀
Dear Totoraworld, thank you thank you very much, merci beaucoup for posting this movie with the subtitles. Wow, I've must say that I have enjoyed it very much and I'm glad I came across this coincidentally :-) It was a very beautiful and good film despite being made for TV. The ending was very sad, if only the circumstances were different. Have you had a chance to see the original 1949 version though?
Hi there, I'm very glad you enjoyed the film! Yes, I saw the version of 1949 after download it, but I definitely like more this version, the actors are just wonderfully stunning! Julie Delarmé even was awarded for her perfomance in this film. Have you read the book of Vercors in which the film is based in?
I haven't read the book yet, but I want to do it someday. I don't generally like all films of determinated periods, I just came across with "Le Silence de la Mer" on Eurochannel coincidentally also and I loved it! I like very much the film "Henry Dunant, le rouge sur la croix" I even created pages for those movies on facebook. Un Village Françai of 2009? I'll search about it, but I think it's not in youtube.
Yes, people who have read the book say that the first version(1949) is more accurate with the book. I didn't read it yet, but I will, one day in a not so near future hahah
I just finished watching the 1949 version. I actually liked both of them (the 2004 verison a bit more), but the 2004 version is probably more appealing to the modern audiences because there was more focus and chemistry between the German officer and the silent niece. I have just heard of this film yesterday so it was a very nice discovery indeed. I haven't read the book yet, but the 1949 version of the movie gave a lot of details about the book itself (that it was published during the occupation
Anyone know what the piano piece the boy is playing? Also, thank you OP for doing the subtitles. I watched this a year ago w/o subtitles and although I could still follow the storyI missed all the good stuff-- finally, it was nice knowing what they were talking about esp when He goes to warm his hands by the fire and at that point she realizes she has feelings for him. Thanks!
thank you so much for posting this!! It's one of my favorite films, but it's very hard to find. Is this recorded from La 2? I lived in Madrid for a couple of years and I think I watched some foreign films on that channel there. The subtitles are also quite good, but some of them don't make as much sense in English as they do in French or Spanish. My French isn't perfect, but I understand a good deal of the film and I'm a native English speaker. Are you interested in some suggestions for improving the subtitles?
I don't know, I just added the english subtitles with WMM after translate it from the spanish subtitles. Of course I'm interested in better translations! Maybe you can add the sentences with problems here as a comment in the time where they belong, so I don't had to upload a new video and keep the URL of it, that was already many times shared probably. Thank you very much. Greetings!
I have been looking for this movie with English subtitles for years. Now, I found it, but the video itself appears to be squeezed in because this movie originally is a widescreen one with the aspect ratio of 16:9, but here it is squeezed into a 4:3 aspect ratio. The error could have happened when the DVD got converted into a video file or perhaps at the time of uploading to UA-cam, I don't know. May I ask where did you find the English subtitle file (.srt file)?
I sooooooooo love this movi and thank you for it, but please please tell me this is not the ending, I saw a comment once of a following up of his return to France after the war - do you know where it is, many would love that
I doubt if there is a following-up. It was 1942. He might die in the Eastern Front within the next 3 years. Also, he was married. If he had survived the war, he would have faced the war criminal court and his wife. There was just no space for the French love interest.
@@Hseofcdrs2217 Glad to know that! I heard they were planning to make a second part but they decided not to do it because they deemed it inappropriate for the public. In the second part he sustains a permanent injury to his leg and is dispatched. He goes back to Germany and becomes a well known composer known for his "Le silence de la mer " music. Jeanne lives alone with the boy and her grandfather has died. She joins the resistance occupying the place of her friend. Every friday/Saturday she sells potatoes, fruits and other things from her house. If you notice in the movie she spoke to her grandfather about classes of agriculture and joining the resistance. Werner could not forget her and after the war he goes back to her village in civilian clothes and nobody recognizes him. He wanders around her house and finds she has never married like him. He begins playing the piano and Jeanne, surprised,looks at him with a smile and says "bonjour ". She tells him that after he left she joined the resistance,but didn't like watching all those people die. He is surprised but doesn't judge her. They get married and have two sons. And they live happily. When the captain is 75 years old he dies of a heart attack. I will try to find the link.
I need some help here! I absolutely love this movie partly because of the piano playing and I don't know the name of the song the German general plays! I'm learning how to play the piano and the song that he plays is my ultimate goal so if anyone knows the name of the song please let me know!
Abril Gutierrez go to Spotify and type in the title of the movie and it gives you the play list. But I don't think the piece this boy is trying to play is on there. Do you know?
@GezaShad Well, is not a .srt file really, I just downloaded the version of the movie in 10 parts without subtitles from UA-cam, then wrote the english subs with Windows Movie Maker and then uploaded it again. Yes, the original was widescreen but maybe it changed with the conversion from .flv to .avi, but I'm not really sure because this is not my speciality, this are the first subtitles I make, the easiest way I know is with WMM.
Mandaram uma mensagem pra mim, falando q vc Thomas é um inimigo!!!! Mas eu não acredito!!!!! Mesmo q seija, mas é na série. Eu gosto de bc Thomas, q Deus te abençoe para todo sempre!!!!
Have you read the book though? Are you generally interested in films depicting the Second World War period? I came across this French TV series called "Un village français." Would really love to watch it too, but I haven't been able to find it with English subtitles at all.
A French Village is a wonderful series about human reactions in time of great duress. You don’t know who is worse, the German occupiers or the friends and neighbors of the village? Keeps you wanting to know how it all ends. Good to binge watch!
In case anyone needs more of Jeanne and Werner, I'm completely run away with writing about them. I'm OfRooksandOrchids on AO3. I have a few things posted featuring our favorite couple and many more in the works.
Morgan Mills I have read your stories about Jeanne and Warner and I’m so appreciative of your efforts. I highly recommend your writings on Archive of Our Own website. Keep up your good work!
I checked out your work on SOTS at Archive of Our Own about a year ago. It's very good. However, I revisited the site again this week and your work is not there anymore. Have you taken your stories down or is there a glitch in the system?
There is a version of this movie which appears to be an original video, not clips. It is much clearer which gives more detail to the actors and actions. It is dubbed in Russian but if you can get passed that, it is a pleasure to watch. Look for it on UA-cam with Russian titles. Hope this helps.
@@sharyncarr4279 I have read all the comments you left for this movie. In some way they strongly resonate with my own perception and understanding of the major idea of the film and that's why I would like to recommend you to read a novel by a famous Russian writer Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn called "Cancer Ward" where the one also discovers a touching story of love and relationship between two really deep people. The English translation is great(my mother tongue is Russian), one of the best translations of Russian classical novels, I guess. There is some similarity in spirit between this film and the above mentionned novel. Hoping you will enjoy it))
Thank you for your suggestion. I read The Gulag Archipelago a long time ago in graduate school and found it thought provoking. I ordered Cancer Ward and I’m looking forward to reading it. Thanks again.
Why didn't they leave France? There is no dignity and honor left for those who stay in an occupied countries, look at the disgusting triumph of Werner's two friends, I cheered and applauded when they were blown to pieces!
Your question is difficult to answer unless you know the history of WWII. Werner knew he could not leave the German Wehrmacht, the long standing traditional German Army, not the SS, or he would be tried for desertion and executed if caught. His family would also have been shamed and persecuted for his actions. There was no place for Werner and Jeanne to go. They possibly could have fled to Switzerland or Spain but travel was dangerous and heavily patrolled by the Germans. Werner knew his only way out of fighting for an evil regime was to volunteer for the Russian front where death by a Russian bullet or a Russian snow bank would most likely be his fate. It was the only honorable option he had. If he survived, he would have been held in a Russian prison camp and forced into years of slave labor. Most of those prisoners died in captivity. For this reason thousands of German army troops surrendered to the Americans or the British where they were processed and sent home. I hope this helps to answer your question.
This movie is more about love 💕 than war ✳️beautiful story 💓
This is the best movie..
my favorite movie..
Thank you so much👍👌
💕🤗👍👍👍✌️💗oglodam codziennie beautiful movie💕
What a wonderfull movie
A pure love!
I love this film so much
Thank you Celia for uploading with English subs! Altho' I studied French "J'aime toujours la langue", this really helps. I am one of the latest BIG fan of this film. Came across by chance. I've watched it sooo many times but never bored. Every time I see new details in their expressions, background details, the superb acting and directing, appreciate the "hidden" intense love etc. Fortunately my local library has the Vercors book with both English-French translation (donated by the French government!). I read the English version, now reading the French version. Many differences in the 2004 film from the book, but it helps me appreciate the film.
Yes,many Thanks and appreciations for the excellent work you put into this story , of us that enjoy foreign films and don’t speak and understand language other than English, your dedication is very much appreciated.💕💕
Thank you so much for posting this movie. I have seen it for the first time in Chinese, it was translated into Chinese and shown on Chinese Central Television Channel.
This is a perfect film, every detail of it, from the directing, the acting, the script to the music, has been done with perfection. And for my taste it has even surpassed the novel by Vercors.
This is an impossible Love Story which requires some background explanations: During the 2nd war with Germany in 1870, France suffered 1,005,427 casualties. The first World War caused 1,927,000 casualties to France. Jeanne’s Father died in that war (as did Werner’s). No matter how much a cultured German professes his Love for France, he still is an invader and an enemy. These two did share a professional interest in classical Music but that was not enough to bridge the Abyss between them. Jeanne struggled with her feelings as she realized that this German «beast » also had feelings and was exquisitely polite. Nevertheless, Honor and Duty prevailed as she cannot consort with an Occupant of her Country, especially when the outcome of the War, in 1941, was so uncertain. As to him, deeply idealistic, he also became disillusioned after discussing the Reich’s intentions (of cultural annihilation and destruction of occupied lands) with his friends. After the assassination of the two visiting German officers, it was a logical decision for Werner to seize the bull by the horns and leave for the front in Russia. Better to die in action rather than to die a slow and unpredictable death by remaining in France. Thank you so much for uploading this very moving Love Story.
Thank you for posting the english subtitle!!! This is a great movie! i can't believe so little people know about it. thank you again (=
this is a beautiful film.
Celia, many, many thanks! I have searched for weeks to no avail. Just when I had given up, there you were, making my life so much better. Such a great story, despite the ending. So well done😍😍
Bellissimo grazie mille beautiful thank you very much
Believe it or not, I have read ALL comments and replies in all the 10 videos. (Celia's uploads) Everyone is so taken by this film...Je l'adore absolutement!!! I think there is a separate Russian fan base under another upload list as well...
I did the same and also read most of the comments in other posting as well after watching it 6 times in 2 days. I wanted to know every details, different experiences and interpretations of other viewers of this marvelous movie .
Thank you for all your hard work on this. I saw Suite Francaise recently and for many reasons, I stumbled across this. Your work is thoroughly appreciated.
Drama Lover me too!
Как он красив.Жуанне очень красив.
@SugarAddictOriginal I know! Besides it's a beautiful movie, one of my favorites! Thanks for your comment, I'm glad you like it! Greetings
Thank you soooo much for posting this WONDERFUL movie and with english subs! My french is not so good so english subs help a lot. I adore this movie it is one of my favorite of all time!😍😍 I have just recently found it on YT and I watched it entire on your channel thanks to your post😊 So thank you million times!!😄😆😙😙
Bianca Beluga 7
I love this film‼️😍🇭🇹
I watched first the movie with spanish subtitlados.second with dutch titles and finally third with englisch subtitles.and am very happy about your version.because now I could understand the french speaking.
you did a great job.thanks.it is good enough to understand all.
where is the link for the full movie?
I am looking for Spanish or portuguese,because I am from Brasil
Tinh yêu không biên giới ,phi chính trị ,nó làm tan chảy mọi trái tim ,dù xa bao lâu ,dù chưa nói một lời nó linh thiêng và chi phối cuộc đời chúng ta .và nó vô cùng đẹp dẽ cho những ai biết yêu ,trân trọng nó ,không một ai dù trong cuộc hay ngoài cuộc có thể hiểu thấu về nó ,tình yêu ngay đó ,ngay trước mắt ,mà ta vẫn không thấy ,không hiểu ,vì vậy mà nó vẫn xa vời vợi ,mong manh ,khó thấy ,khó nắm bắt ,,,,,để một ngày ,để cuộc đời khi đã nhận ra ,để hối tiếc không nguôi .
I ve discovered this movie like a week ago. I have watched it like 50 times already. Of course, step by step I will get tired of keep watching it but this was SUCH a surprise!!! The director is a real genius!!!Same the actors. Both of them. I would say that the male lead, apart from being handsome, has an unusual intelligent act - so subtle which makes it so credible! This is something that only a British actor, classically trained, could have managed...and yet, although I consider the brits the best actors, this role might have been a bit too much even for a brit. American actors are perhaps as bad as the Indian ones in their own way so they need not to be even thought about! However, what a pity that the art of film is now dominated by the really crappy Hollywood/ BOlywood productions while real art and really talented directors and actors are pushed away but the horrible American productions. That is why this movie is a real gem!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Time heals: ironically, Werner von Ebrennac is played by Thomas Jouannet, born in Geneva, neutral Switzerland, of a French father and a German Mother. Therefore, he is fluent in both languages. We shared the same city in the 1970s, when Thomas was between the ages of 2 and 6. Since viewing this film for the first time in late September 2021, I wished I could have baby-sat him when I was in Geneva (instead of obnoxious ex-pat American children) 😀
Thomas Jouannet ❤
@calabasasbrokeryourpartner1541 Thomas Jouannet really excellent handsome actor
Thank You so much for these❤
Thank you for uploading this 😍
thnx 4 uploading this nice movie.
thank you for the upload, I'm a huge fan of the original!!!
You're welcome! But what original? The black and white version?
Thank you!!!!
Thank you so much!
Dear Totoraworld, thank you thank you very much, merci beaucoup for posting this movie with the subtitles. Wow, I've must say that I have enjoyed it very much and I'm glad I came across this coincidentally :-) It was a very beautiful and good film despite being made for TV. The ending was very sad, if only the circumstances were different. Have you had a chance to see the original 1949 version though?
Боже этот офицер сводит меня с ума .....
Hi there, I'm very glad you enjoyed the film! Yes, I saw the version of 1949 after download it, but I definitely like more this version, the actors are just wonderfully stunning! Julie Delarmé even was awarded for her perfomance in this film. Have you read the book of Vercors in which the film is based in?
I'm looking for the book in English or Italian but no e-book till now
Is it this really the only place where it is possible to watch the full movie?
I haven't read the book yet, but I want to do it someday. I don't generally like all films of determinated periods, I just came across with "Le Silence de la Mer" on Eurochannel coincidentally also and I loved it! I like very much the film "Henry Dunant, le rouge sur la croix" I even created pages for those movies on facebook.
Un Village Françai of 2009? I'll search about it, but I think it's not in youtube.
graciasssss
Yes, people who have read the book say that the first version(1949) is more accurate with the book. I didn't read it yet, but I will, one day in a not so near future hahah
You're welcome! Yes, I love this film too, but I haven't read the novel yet, still in my to do list.
I just finished watching the 1949 version. I actually liked both of them (the 2004 verison a bit more), but the 2004 version is probably more appealing to the modern audiences because there was more focus and chemistry between the German officer and the silent niece. I have just heard of this film yesterday so it was a very nice discovery indeed. I haven't read the book yet, but the 1949 version of the movie gave a lot of details about the book itself (that it was published during the occupation
Very austere tho.
ça me sauve la vie je doit lire le bouquin pour dans 3 jours :)
Anyone know what the piano piece the boy is playing?
Also, thank you OP for doing the subtitles. I watched this a year ago w/o subtitles and although I could still follow the storyI missed all the good stuff-- finally, it was nice knowing what they were talking about esp when He goes to warm his hands by the fire and at that point she realizes she has feelings for him. Thanks!
thank you so much for posting this!! It's one of my favorite films, but it's very hard to find. Is this recorded from La 2? I lived in Madrid for a couple of years and I think I watched some foreign films on that channel there.
The subtitles are also quite good, but some of them don't make as much sense in English as they do in French or Spanish. My French isn't perfect, but I understand a good deal of the film and I'm a native English speaker. Are you interested in some suggestions for improving the subtitles?
I don't know, I just added the english subtitles with WMM after translate it from the spanish subtitles. Of course I'm interested in better translations! Maybe you can add the sentences with problems here as a comment in the time where they belong, so I don't had to upload a new video and keep the URL of it, that was already many times shared probably. Thank you very much. Greetings!
The subtitles are terrible, but at least they exist.
I have been looking for this movie with English subtitles for years. Now, I found it, but the video itself appears to be squeezed in because this movie originally is a widescreen one with the aspect ratio of 16:9, but here it is squeezed into a 4:3 aspect ratio. The error could have happened when the DVD got converted into a video file or perhaps at the time of uploading to UA-cam, I don't know. May I ask where did you find the English subtitle file (.srt file)?
How to find whole movie? One time I found, but now I can not find. I would like to watch and save whole movie.
Anybody know where I can buy the DVD for this film?
Only in www.amazon.fr i guess.
That where I got my copy few weeks ago. I can play it on my Mac computer without any problems
"可憐無定河邊骨，
猶是深閨夢裏人。"
他終於知道:她也愛他。
I sooooooooo love this movi and thank you for it, but please please tell me this is not the ending, I saw a comment once of a following up of his return to France after the war - do you know where it is, many would love that
I doubt if there is a following-up. It was 1942. He might die in the Eastern Front within the next 3 years. Also, he was married. If he had survived the war, he would have faced the war criminal court and his wife. There was just no space for the French love interest.
The book and the move have been a huge success in terms that audience yearn for more.
@@hanaforsuccess315 No he was not married. He had already broken off the engagement long before he joined the war. I have read the Vercors book.
@@Hseofcdrs2217 Glad to know that! I heard they were planning to make a second part but they decided not to do it because they deemed it inappropriate for the public. In the second part he sustains a permanent injury to his leg and is dispatched. He goes back to Germany and becomes a well known composer known for his "Le silence de la mer " music. Jeanne lives alone with the boy and her grandfather has died. She joins the resistance occupying the place of her friend. Every friday/Saturday she sells potatoes, fruits and other things from her house. If you notice in the movie she spoke to her grandfather about classes of agriculture and joining the resistance. Werner could not forget her and after the war he goes back to her village in civilian clothes and nobody recognizes him. He wanders around her house and finds she has never married like him. He begins playing the piano and Jeanne, surprised,looks at him with a smile and says "bonjour ". She tells him that after he left she joined the resistance,but didn't like watching all those people die. He is surprised but doesn't judge her. They get married and have two sons. And they live happily. When the captain is 75 years old he dies of a heart attack. I will try to find the link.
@@silentsea2956 thank you so much
Where can I buy this DVD, region 2 also with english or dutch subtitels ?
I need some help here! I absolutely love this movie partly because of the piano playing and I don't know the name of the song the German general plays! I'm learning how to play the piano and the song that he plays is my ultimate goal so if anyone knows the name of the song please let me know!
Abril Gutierrez go to Spotify and type in the title of the movie and it gives you the play list. But I don't think the piece this boy is trying to play is on there. Do you know?
Prélude No. 1 in C Major - Johann Sebastian Bach.
My favorite music composition. I play it every time.
@GezaShad Well, is not a .srt file really, I just downloaded the version of the movie in 10 parts without subtitles from UA-cam, then wrote the english subs with Windows Movie Maker and then uploaded it again. Yes, the original was widescreen but maybe it changed with the conversion from .flv to .avi, but I'm not really sure because this is not my speciality, this are the first subtitles I make, the easiest way I know is with WMM.
Crediti ma am asteptat de a lungul episoadelor sa se imtample ce a, dar nimic...asa cum a inceput asa s a si terminat...
Traducciones al castellano por favor!!
Anyone know the piano song that boy plays at the start ?
洛攸 i think iit is musette bvh anh.126 by Bach
@@sylwialesniak4335 Yes ! It's the song! It catches my heart! Thank you very much!
洛攸 you’re welcome 😊 I discovered it in the game Piano Tiles
Mandaram uma mensagem pra mim, falando q vc Thomas é um inimigo!!!! Mas eu não acredito!!!!! Mesmo q seija, mas é na série. Eu gosto de bc Thomas, q Deus te abençoe para todo sempre!!!!
Have you read the book though? Are you generally interested in films depicting the Second World War period? I came across this French TV series called "Un village français." Would really love to watch it too, but I haven't been able to find it with English subtitles at all.
A French Village is a wonderful series about human reactions in time of great duress. You don’t know who is worse, the German occupiers or the friends and neighbors of the village? Keeps you wanting to know how it all ends. Good to binge watch!
Можно по - русски?
Недавно смотрела на ютубе - есть
I loveeee u
In case anyone needs more of Jeanne and Werner, I'm completely run away with writing about them. I'm OfRooksandOrchids on AO3. I have a few things posted featuring our favorite couple and many more in the works.
Morgan Mills
I have read your stories about Jeanne and Warner and I’m so appreciative of your efforts. I highly recommend your writings on Archive of Our Own website. Keep up your good work!
I checked out your work on SOTS at Archive of Our Own about a year ago. It's very good. However, I revisited the site again this week and your work is not there anymore. Have you taken your stories down or is there a glitch in the system?
I read all your postings, they were very good why did you remove them?
Anyone know where I can watch this in better quality?
There is a version of this movie which appears to be an original video, not clips. It is much clearer which gives more detail to the actors and actions. It is dubbed in Russian but if you can get passed that, it is a pleasure to watch. Look for it on UA-cam with Russian titles. Hope this helps.
@@sharyncarr4279
I have read all the comments you left for this movie. In some way they strongly resonate with my own perception and understanding of the major idea of the film and that's why I would like to recommend you to read a novel by a famous Russian writer Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn called "Cancer Ward" where the one also discovers a touching story of love and relationship between two really deep people. The English translation is great(my mother tongue is Russian), one of the best translations of Russian classical novels, I guess. There is some similarity in spirit between this film and the above mentionned novel. Hoping you will enjoy it))
Thank you for your suggestion. I read The Gulag Archipelago a long time ago in graduate school and found it thought provoking. I ordered Cancer Ward and I’m looking forward to reading it. Thanks again.
7:50
This is the mine
I prefer the black and white version,the original.
Why didn't they leave France? There is no dignity and honor left for those who stay in an occupied countries, look at the disgusting triumph of Werner's two friends, I cheered and applauded when they were blown to pieces!
Your question is difficult to answer unless you know the history of WWII. Werner knew he could not leave the German Wehrmacht, the long standing traditional German Army, not the SS, or he would be tried for desertion and executed if caught. His family would also have been shamed and persecuted for his actions. There was no place for Werner and Jeanne to go. They possibly could have fled to Switzerland or Spain but travel was dangerous and heavily patrolled by the Germans. Werner knew his only way out of fighting for an evil regime was to volunteer for the Russian front where death by a Russian bullet or a Russian snow bank would most likely be his fate. It was the only honorable option he had. If he survived, he would have been held in a Russian prison camp and forced into years of slave labor. Most of those prisoners died in captivity. For this reason thousands of German army troops surrendered to the Americans or the British where they were processed and sent home. I hope this helps to answer your question.
Or Grandpa could have said if the Script writer dare to allow him: "War is not going to last forever. Peace will return. Hang tight, stay alive."