I'm always amazed at how good Ian is - him and his band, of course. I usually see people their age really slowly (or quickly) getting old and these guys are always just the same, meaning always excellent energy and perfect quality.
That is because he is always working, always playing and composing. He has got a hell of a lot of wind for an old geezer, but you can tell that from his prattle! ;-)
Disagree, Barlow was the best drummer Tull ever had. Barlow joining the band was what allowed Tull to start playing more complex stuff. According to Ian, Clive had some trouble keeping time in odd meters and didn't feel comfortable playing them, so Barlow joining opened up more possibilities in terms of what kind of material they could write.
I can see them in the woods throwing down ale or wine 🤟🤟🤟🤟 or whatever Meade was easiest to possess from the local pub. Playing their songs, finding their ladies, and having a hell of a time. Just when they realize the ladies are magical beings that ............... well it's midnight and we will not know until a few weeks from now......... or did l just go to sleep ?
I think Doane did a great homage of Clive's 1970 Isle of Whight solo, highlighting all of Clive's best fills of that solo including the "head-bend" on the snare at the end! Very tastey! But then again, Jethro Tull has always been a class act regardless of the lineup!
I never thought I'd hear the claghorn on a live recording, let alone see it played live, let alone have Ian introduce it. Clag on! Apparently Jeffrey Hammond-Hammond invented it? Also, what a particularly good and crisp recording job for this.
Ian Anderson is so wonderfully talented. Was a big fan of his in high school and actually play one of his melodies these days though it's heavily modded. It's from Minstrel in the Gallery and is called The Whistler. Great celtic melody at it's roots. I added my own melody also for the bridge, so it's a few bars of his and then a few bars of mine.
Ian is just absolutely classic. Been a fan since they started; went to the Goose Lake rock concert just to see Tull. (Lots of other greats there, too, of course.)
Alive and Well 5/12/2020 Sheltering in Place in California....Soooo Bizarre...Listening to Good Vibes and finding new musical roads thanks to the Crazy COVID-19 restrictions
doan is one of the best drummers ever, the only usa musician played in tull, his didactic vhs is from other world, what a sound this premier and this paiste, amazing
Not entirely true Jaime. Mark Craney, who did such splendid work on the A album and tour and a very dear friend of Doane's was also American. Passed away a few years back from a long time.....congenital kidney ailment I think it was.
im not a musician, but i believe tone and timbre are the same thing. i, too, like the sound of this thing - it's low, warm, possibly baritone-ish. funny how Ian roasts it here - im sure deep down he loves it.
With all due respect to Clive Bunker, Barriemore Barlow, and for Beastie lovers like me Gerry Conway. Doane Perry is the longest serving drummer Jethro Tull has had and as shown here he is as good as they come. (Come to think of it after Ian and Martin he may even be the longest serving Tull member period.)(Checked and yes 1984 till 2011that is 27 years.)
Ian´s drum solo comment kind of rolled over everybody there in Basel. He could have supplied them with a "No drum solos? I think that deserves a boo, don´t you?!"
There has never been another band like Jethro Tull.
I agree, they are unique!
You got that right!!
You 've got to love them, don't yah ??!!? 💗😅
Nada se compara....absurdamente genial !! Uma riqueza musical.Fiz questão de apresentar para meus filhos!!!
One ,nite long ago . Walked ,in to The Fillmore E. in N.Y. To see 'Traffic' , Tull opened up and this Tune was Blaring thru like a Tsunami..
Like a fine wine. What treat. Tull RULES!
Jethro Tull!! One of my top 3 favorite bands.. Pure joy
And the other 2?
@@paultaurone5634 Currently 70's Genesis and Rush :)
@@theshiled Wow!. I was gonna guess Yes & Rush! So close!
@@paultaurone5634 very close indeed!
@@theshiled Are you a musician?
These old dudes rock! And his voice hasn't changed a bit, Ian Anderson must be immortal!
Just amazing. Beautiful sound mix and dynamic. I am so surprised to enjoy Tull as much as I did when I saw him back in the 70s. GREAT musicians !!!
I have to watch this at least once a month.
I love this song ... it is one of my early faves. There are also quite a few covers of this song online and on CD.
You're a man of impeccable taste...
@@richrol58 Thanks brother, I've dug these guys right from the get go.
When Jethro Tull formed in December 1967, I was just 12 - Ian Anderson will be 66 in August 2013. Simply amazing this Musician.
maravilloso; parece imposible que haya tanta sensibilidad en estos músicos. Jethro Tull por siempre.
bravo bravo bRaVo BrAvO! BRAVO BRAVO!
One of my absolute favorite Tull songs, love the energy and simplicity of this tune.
I'm always amazed at how good Ian is - him and his band, of course. I usually see people their age really slowly (or quickly) getting old and these guys are always just the same, meaning always excellent energy and perfect quality.
That is because he is always working, always playing and composing. He has got a hell of a lot of wind for an old geezer, but you can tell that from his prattle! ;-)
Ian is great and a natural showman alright. And wow is this rendition of Dharma for One good.
sttgaegoaktd
😛😛😛😛😛😛😛
Erudite and witty. Some very special music, here!
They still have it!
Best Tull drummer alongside Barlow. Check his contributions.
clive was different
Fou tu reste toujours fou je t aime beaucoup car fou plus que toi
Best Jethro Tull Drummer ever was Clive Bunker. Barriemore was good,this guy is good. Clive was Great!
Disagree, Barlow was the best drummer Tull ever had. Barlow joining the band was what allowed Tull to start playing more complex stuff. According to Ian, Clive had some trouble keeping time in odd meters and didn't feel comfortable playing them, so Barlow joining opened up more possibilities in terms of what kind of material they could write.
@@AK99581 Agree 100%! Barlow was a monster! According to John Bonham, the best Rock Drummer England ever produced!
Love Clive, but Barry was the best, one of the greatest ever I have heard live.
Saw Barrie with Tull in ‘78, one of the best performances I’ve seen by a drummer. The guy is simply brilliant.
They both were extremely talented and underrated. Maybe the most underrated ones in rock history... What a shame!
Best live show I've ever seen...8 times...
Excellent live rendition. Very tight musicianship. Martin is smokin' on that guitar part after the drum solo.
I can see them in the woods throwing down ale or wine 🤟🤟🤟🤟 or whatever Meade was easiest to possess from the local pub. Playing their songs, finding their ladies, and having a hell of a time. Just when they realize the ladies are magical beings that ............... well it's midnight and we will not know until a few weeks from now......... or did l just go to sleep ?
Tull as 'mad' as ever... Tull fan since 1969
Sunrise flute reminds me of Osibisa.
I think Doane did a great homage of Clive's 1970 Isle of Whight solo, highlighting all of Clive's best fills of that solo including the "head-bend" on the snare at the end! Very tastey! But then again, Jethro Tull has always been a class act regardless of the lineup!
I never thought I'd hear the claghorn on a live recording, let alone see it played live, let alone have Ian introduce it. Clag on! Apparently Jeffrey Hammond-Hammond invented it? Also, what a particularly good and crisp recording job for this.
These drummers must be the happiest people in the world........
Ian Anderson is so wonderfully talented. Was a big fan of his in high school and actually play one of his melodies these days though it's heavily modded. It's from Minstrel in the Gallery and is called The Whistler. Great celtic melody at it's roots. I added my own melody also for the bridge, so it's a few bars of his and then a few bars of mine.
Great SONG!
Whistler is on Songs fom the Wood album.
Cada canción que escucho me parece la mejor. Jethro Tull es sencillamente acojonante. La voz de Ian es irrepetible.
Unique sound, unique band, unique rock. The Jethro Tull sound stands out amongst them all. Simply brilliant!
I love this song ... and its many versions.
Toujours super
Waahh!!! Mamma mia!!!!!!!!!! Perfect! If qualcuno ask me what is the perfection i rispondo to see this!
Who said you are to old for one leg, rock on old timers.
Sorry maybe I'm just living in the past.
this is definetely a great song and of course this perfomance was absolutely brilliant
Ian is just absolutely classic. Been a fan since they started; went to the Goose Lake rock concert just to see Tull. (Lots of other greats there, too, of course.)
Tull playing live NEVER let you down!
Alive and Well 5/12/2020 Sheltering in Place in California....Soooo Bizarre...Listening to Good Vibes and finding new musical roads thanks to the Crazy COVID-19 restrictions
Mi banda favorita de siempre. Espectacular
Ian I am one of 5 on this planet that only took me 40 years thanks a lot for my instruments of torture
just so good!
i swear myself i'm gonna learn to play my new flute like you master yours Ian!
doan is one of the best drummers ever, the only usa musician played in tull, his didactic vhs is from other world, what a sound this premier and this paiste, amazing
Not entirely true Jaime. Mark Craney, who did such splendid work on the A album and tour and a very dear friend of Doane's was also American. Passed away a few years back from a long time.....congenital kidney ailment I think it was.
Lol - Perry sounds like a beginner compared to Barriemore Barlow.
J'ai vu Jethro Tull in Festhalle Bern Bursing out and thé drumm solo is great Barlow was Good. And Martin Barre, John Evan excellent. Great mémoires.
Impresionante versión!!!
I quite like the tone and timbre of the claghorn
im not a musician, but i believe tone and timbre are the same thing.
i, too, like the sound of this thing - it's low, warm, possibly baritone-ish.
funny how Ian roasts it here - im sure deep down he loves it.
A musicalidade desses caras me emociona, do caralho Jethro Tull!
Grand monsieur adorable pour toujours
With all due respect to Clive Bunker, Barriemore Barlow, and for Beastie lovers like me Gerry Conway. Doane Perry is the longest serving drummer Jethro Tull has had and as shown here he is as good as they come. (Come to think of it after Ian and Martin he may even be the longest serving Tull member period.)(Checked and yes 1984 till 2011that is 27 years.)
He's got an electric pickup on that flute! Nice! Those are fun!
Anche il flauto traverso è Rock!!!!!!
Tu reste toujours adorable super
J aime beaucoup
Reste toujours super adorable grand monsieur de l histoire du musique oui bouquou toujours adorable super yan
I do Enjoy listening to Doanne & Clive though , they both compliment the band in there own way and both have fantastic sounding Kits
Happy birthday IAN..
Great tune, love this.
Amoooooo
after 40 years....
brilliant performance
When I first heard this I immediately went out and bought Stand Up brilliant.
Clive bunker the best of the bunch
Just behind Barriemore Barlow!
@@TD06071951 In all honesty, safely behind Barriemore Barlow.
Martin Barre is tonal Master .Nice player..Ian should have never let him go
EXCELLENT ~~~~ MUST SEE!!!!!
wow, still an incredible showman.
dharma for everybody
Magistral, indeleble.
Actually, Clive Bunker's original drum sole on Tull's solo Lp is one of my favorites.
LEGEND FOREVER
Extraordinary
Excellent!
stupendo!
Это просто фантастика !!!
El mejor tema de la banda
Refer to The St Cleve Chronicle page 7, Weekend Radio, Radio Three (8.0),
History of the Claghorn
no way!! :O
Weltklasse ✌️
loved the flute player in breaking bad
And all this time I thought the cleghorn was some lost medieval instrument or something.( In a way it is "medieval" in Ian's hands.)
Any good karma for Dharma For One in 2024?
spettacolari!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Maestro YETRO TULL 😍🌈💯
🎧🎼🎼🎼🎼⚓🎯📖⏳🌪️😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘♥️♥️♥️
Ian´s drum solo comment kind of rolled over everybody there in Basel. He could have supplied them with a "No drum solos? I think that deserves a boo, don´t you?!"
his little finger is not crooked anymore !
Questa musiea è senza tempo!
amazing
Man, he talks like four times faster than he did in the 70s. He must be drinking a lot of coffee or something.
He had to make up for quitting smoking...
Excelente
Q BELLO!,,Y QUE BATERISTA GENIAL!
Did any of your Tull freaks ever notice how huge Martin Barre's hands are? Take a look, he is just all over the fretboard - 5:17
bravoo!
awesome...
Imagine a band today writing a song for their drummer,wouldn’t happen.
Lol! OK.
Foo Fighters? Technically a drummer who now writes songs for himself!
Ian Williamson God hates us dumbos,looks after the smart people.
That was a longer solo than the original Clive Bunker version.
Clive made up for it at the Carnegie Hall concert--in spades...!!😊
Very good
SKVELÝ bubeník aj celá banda!!!
Anderson Forever💖
brillante!!!!!
Best Drummer wowwwwwwwwwww
muy bueno!
Super adorable yan inderson
En Chile se conoció como jeltrul
Brilliant
That can duplicate you. God bless your pointy little head always the best Ian. Peter j hare
2:37 - Doan Perry's drum solo ... or break ... or whatever Ian wants to call it, and the longer real drum solo at 3:08 .
Your thhunder and your fluite thats great