A Protestant Tours a Massive and Immaculate Gothic Church in St. Louis, Missouri

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 828

  • @johnbalao711
    @johnbalao711 Рік тому +399

    I am an atheist, and I accidentally saw this presentation, which opened my eyes to search for and know God. I can't resist anymore that hunger to learn more about God.

    • @StupidBeagleAce
      @StupidBeagleAce Рік тому +23

      Hello John. As a Christian, I encourage you to continue to seek what you are looking for. No matter what commentary or Christian teacher you may come across, you will need to make a decision on the person of Jesus of Nazereth. Read his own words and his claims. God Bless you.

    • @conallomahoney9311
      @conallomahoney9311 Рік тому +5

      God bless

    • @paru-chinbaka5214
      @paru-chinbaka5214 Рік тому +7

      Hello John, I recommend you read the books that bear your name in the Bible, listen to some Orthodox vespers, and read Mere Christianity by C. S. Lewis

    • @ryandersones
      @ryandersones Рік тому +13

      Bishop Barron says that beauty is key to drawing people closer to himself.

    • @dwinawhitson3870
      @dwinawhitson3870 Рік тому +7

      This was beautiful thank you for sharing it I am Catholic and I loved it.

  • @orangemanbad
    @orangemanbad Рік тому +18

    I became a Catholic last year. Best decision of my life. I finally feel like I know god.

  • @TaylourwtheHalo
    @TaylourwtheHalo Рік тому +99

    Let’s pray that Matt takes RCIA classes to learn about Early church history and what the Catholic Church truly believes 🙏🏿

    • @larco777
      @larco777 Рік тому +2

      Yo le recomendaria que leyera la suma apologetica de santo Tomas de aquino.

    • @sarahisatitagain
      @sarahisatitagain Рік тому +2

      Amen!

  • @user-wo7rz3yn4o
    @user-wo7rz3yn4o Рік тому +109

    This guy knows how to not let disagreements in doctrine and philosophy get in the way of things of agreement and that which can unite us Christians. Alleluia.

  • @DivineMercyFarmstead
    @DivineMercyFarmstead Рік тому +38

    Makes me tear up seeing the mural of “The Death of St. Joseph.” Beautiful! AMDG

  • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
    @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому +343

    Matt, it was such a pleasure to have you visit College Church! You did a wonderful job with this video. God bless, and I hope you and yours have a very Merry Christmas!

    • @GymGuy817JasonEuless
      @GymGuy817JasonEuless Рік тому +5

      Hello, please, you need some votive candles in the church. It looks stripped.

    • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
      @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому +14

      @@GymGuy817JasonEuless Hello and Merry Christmas! We do have votive candles; they are just not visible in the shots in this video.

    • @wsteven82
      @wsteven82 Рік тому +9

      It's so sad to not see Jesus kept in the most central altar.

    • @GymGuy817JasonEuless
      @GymGuy817JasonEuless Рік тому +1

      @@wsteven82 I agree!

    • @connorio2474
      @connorio2474 Рік тому +2

      @@wsteven82 True. We should never put Christ aside. He should always be at the center of our lives no matter if it’s convenient or not 😊

  • @MWroses
    @MWroses Рік тому +123

    Many churches still have the Tabernacle at the alter. Mine does. It's where it belongs! A separate adoration chapel is fine, but keep the Tabernacle at the front alter. A King sits at the throne.

    • @user-vj9qz3br6l
      @user-vj9qz3br6l Рік тому +16

      You are correct, it’s where it belongs-Second Vatican Council and modernist leaders caused so many issues

    • @jacobc6556
      @jacobc6556 Рік тому +35

      @@user-vj9qz3br6l To be fair to the Second Vatican Council, there was nothing in it about moving the Tabernacle. She just made that up.

    • @conservativecatholic9030
      @conservativecatholic9030 Рік тому +14

      @@jacobc6556 in fairness, she is probably repeating what she was probably taught by a modernist priest. She probably did not make that up herself.

    • @jimreilly917
      @jimreilly917 Рік тому +9

      Exactly. The janitors closet is off to the side…not the King of Kings.

    • @johnbrowne3950
      @johnbrowne3950 Рік тому

      You really believe you can keep God in a tabernacle? lol.

  • @McCainenl
    @McCainenl Рік тому +177

    "I like all four of the Gospel writers"
    "They were all good! That's why they kept them in the book"
    This lady rules

    • @goofygrandlouis6296
      @goofygrandlouis6296 Рік тому +2

      Wait.. The debate is still on about the Gospel of St-Thomas, though. right ?

    • @titob.yotokojr.9337
      @titob.yotokojr.9337 Рік тому +14

      @@goofygrandlouis6296 The debate is centuries too late if your are a Catholic because the Catholic Church has already definitively ruled in the late 3rd century that there will be no other gospel beside the four already in the bible.

    • @goofygrandlouis6296
      @goofygrandlouis6296 Рік тому +2

      @@titob.yotokojr.9337 Sure but it is still interesting to know about the other lost gospels, from an intellectual perspective 😉.

    • @goofygrandlouis6296
      @goofygrandlouis6296 Рік тому +2

      @@titob.yotokojr.9337 Also I'm a Catholic, but defintely not for the Pope.
      a) I like the figure of Mary and b) the initial Church produced the best architecture, visual art and gregorian songs ever => more "majestic" than Protestantism if you want 😉

    • @miguelpaivabezerra34
      @miguelpaivabezerra34 3 місяці тому

      ​@@goofygrandlouis6296 Those are not good reasons to be catholic... Like, The is The Eucharist, The miracles, The organization, The doctrines, The history and MANY more better reasons to be catholic

  • @Elizabeth-rh1hl
    @Elizabeth-rh1hl Рік тому +43

    I’m a St. Louis University graduate. Attended Mass at St. Francis Xavier. Beautiful church. Wonderful acoustics too.

  • @danielmarotta4465
    @danielmarotta4465 Рік тому +12

    My God...what a beautiful and stunning gothic church..if I ever visit USA I will try to visit and attend a service there..greetings from Sydney Australia 🇦🇺

  • @jajohnson7809
    @jajohnson7809 Рік тому +28

    This church is majestic. Thanks for bringing us there with you.

  • @robmorgan3842
    @robmorgan3842 Рік тому +5

    If you ever get the Chance please go visit and interview Fr. Joshua Caswell at St John Cantius in Chicago. That priest and the Church will blow your mind.

  • @PinkTigger33
    @PinkTigger33 Рік тому +70

    My jaw dropped. Glory to God in the highest. What gifts man has been given to bring this to life. I could just sit in there and take it all in. It's impressive even empty. I can't imagine how much more it is when it's filled with people and music singing and praising God. I love this series! Thank you so much Matt for bringing these to us. Thank you Ruth Cochran for taking the time to show and explain this.

  • @AG-fl3kl
    @AG-fl3kl Рік тому +15

    Sadly the Blessed Sacrament ought to be in the centre of this beautiful church.

  • @antoniodesousa9723
    @antoniodesousa9723 Рік тому +30

    Amazing insight into St. Joseph, love your thoughts about Jesus' earthly father.

  • @dillonpariseau7873
    @dillonpariseau7873 Рік тому +74

    If you're ever in St. Louis again, check out the Cathedral Basilica. The amount of mosaic in there is quite stunning.

    • @phickle
      @phickle Рік тому +4

      Completely agree. The inside is just gorgeous. The mosaics are beautiful.

    • @wanderingazn
      @wanderingazn Рік тому

      I third this recommendation!

    • @flyingforfunUSA
      @flyingforfunUSA Рік тому

      This.....

    • @MattWhitmanTMBH
      @MattWhitmanTMBH  Рік тому +43

      Amazing place, but I wasn't able to film there. I reached out several times, but didn't get a response - I get it, that's a huge Cathedral with huge responsibilities and I bet a lot of people contact them with outside requests like mine. I'll try again next time I'm going through St. Louis.

    • @jimferris9447
      @jimferris9447 Рік тому +13

      Try also to visit the Basilica of Saint Louis, King of France, the “Old Cathedral”. It is Saint Louis’s oldest parish. Other historic churches in the area to visit: Church of the Holy Family across the river. St. Francis De Sales, the St. Joseph Shrine, the St. Ferdinand Shrine and the Academy to the Sacred Heart Shrine.

  • @tommaxwell429
    @tommaxwell429 Рік тому +7

    OMG! I'm crying! Love this video because of the mutual respect and genuine interest in understanding. God Bless!

  • @emilybeier8919
    @emilybeier8919 Рік тому +12

    Matt, thank you for your openness, generosity of spirit, graciousness, and fraternal attitude in all these videos. Have no doubt that you are doing the Lords' work here. God bless you.

  • @danieldefonce
    @danieldefonce Рік тому +40

    Lovely! I’m from St. Louis and I engage in a number of ministries here, increasingly becoming oriented toward Catholicism. I drove by the parish a week or so ago. Hoping to visit at some point, but for now Cathedral Basilica of St. Louis will have to do 😉

    • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
      @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому +8

      We'd love to have you visit! The Cathedral is truly amazing.

    • @janedoe3648
      @janedoe3648 Рік тому

      Catholocism practices what the Bible calls doctrines of demons, forbidding marriage (of priests and monks/nuns), and contradicts the Bible in other serious ways. It's a false gospel

  • @Rorschached
    @Rorschached Рік тому +19

    With regards to moving the tabernacle from the altar, Vatican II did not mandate changes in the placement of the tabernacle. As a Catholic, I'm glad to see more and more churches returning the tabernacle to its central place of prominence behind the altar. It sends a clear message that the summit and focus of Mass is our Lord, not the priest. Additionally, adoration chapels serve the purpose of making our Lord accessible to the people for adoration, while maintaining the tabernacle's rightful place of prominence at the front of the church behind the altar.

    • @jimreilly917
      @jimreilly917 Рік тому +2

      Now, the priest needs to turn around again and face Ad Orientem during Mass. He has not turned his back on the congregation but addresses prayers directly oriented physically to Jesus in the Eucharist, in the Tabernacle. VII screwed up so much of the liturgy and sacred theology of the Church…or rather the spirit of VII which people used as excuse to chuck sacred traditions and prayer forms.

    • @margokupelian344
      @margokupelian344 2 місяці тому +1

      @@jimreilly917yes, for me having Jesus on the side and not at the back of the alter is a big NO!!! He belongs in the center of the church, His house…
      When I enter into a church the tabernacle is the first place that I look at and like to think that Jesus is in that tabernacle welcoming me with open arms…

  • @Sarah-fe1hh
    @Sarah-fe1hh Рік тому +7

    Wow Thank you for featuring this church ⛪ 🙏. God bless you Matt.

  • @KatherineWeasley
    @KatherineWeasley Рік тому +22

    The "spirit of VII" is maddening. Show me an official document from that council that states the tabernacle should be moved and communion rails be eliminated. Prayers for holy mother church!

    • @jimreilly917
      @jimreilly917 Рік тому +3

      There isn’t one.

    • @KatherineWeasley
      @KatherineWeasley Рік тому +3

      @@jimreilly917 I'm aware. That's why I put "the spirit of VII." Too many ignorant Catholics THINK that the council put certain things in motion when it did not.

    • @jimreilly917
      @jimreilly917 Рік тому

      @@KatherineWeasley I went to SLU. Had a Jesuit philosophy prof, who was in formation at the close of the Council. He remembers Jesuit priests offering Mass at SLU…The Eucharist offering? Pizza and Coca Cola. Not making this up.

  • @michaelkaiser8694
    @michaelkaiser8694 Рік тому +11

    She’s fantastic. “I’m glad we kept them in the book.” 😂❤

  • @richardhildreth4471
    @richardhildreth4471 Рік тому +65

    Your comment on St Joseph was great. When I was a kid, I felt the same way about Mary. Asked my Protestant parents why, considering Mary's importance, we didn't honor her like Catholics do? She was willing to give birth to him and nurture him, which made her a significant contribution to th3 Christian faith, yet we only celebrated her on Mothers' Day. That with other similar issues is what attracted me to Catholicism. Anyway, thank you for your thoughtful commentary and for a great vid. Blessings.

    • @caman171
      @caman171 Рік тому +3

      as a Baptist, of course Mary as the mother of Jesus has an important place. She bascially wrote the gospel of Luke. But just like Moses, as great as he was as the lawgiver, i dont pray to her. she is a great example of humility and the love of a mother staying with her son til the very end, when everyone else abandoned him

    • @richardhildreth4471
      @richardhildreth4471 Рік тому +20

      @caman171 as a Catholic, I don't pray to her either, but tho both my parents are dead, I honor them. However, as a Christian, I believe they are alive in heaven. As I honor my parents, I honor Mary as the mother of Jesus. I can ask you to pray for me. I believe that Mary is in heaven and alive, as my parents are. Also, as his mother, I believe that she has a special relationship with him. So, as she is alive as my parents are, I can ask her to pray for me just as I can ask you to pray for me. As a Catholic, that is the extent of my relationship to Mary. I do not pray to her as I pray to God, and I would never worship her. You and I both only truly pray to and worship God. Blessings to you, brother. And, please pray for me. I can always use it. Also, I have been a Baptist. When I was in the Army, I belonged to The First Baptist Church of Heilbronn in Heilbronn, Germany.

    • @caman171
      @caman171 Рік тому +1

      @@richardhildreth4471 i will pray for you freind. as regarding mary tho, the bible clearly forbids communication with the dead as stated in Leviticus and Deuteronomy. if you are "asking" mary for something, you are praying to her, and open yourself up to demons. Jesus is our ONLY mediator and advocate with the Father (1 timothy 2:5)

    • @richardhildreth4471
      @richardhildreth4471 Рік тому +3

      @@caman171 so she's not in heaven?

    • @caman171
      @caman171 Рік тому +2

      @@richardhildreth4471 are u asking is mary in heaven? yes she is. but we cannot communicate with those in heaven, they cannot hear us. do you really believe mary can hear the millions of prayers to her from catholics all over the world? she is not God so she cannot possibly hear all those prayers anymore than you can answer a million phone calls. 1 timothy 2:5 makes it clear that Jesus is the only one who can take our prayers to the Father.

  • @JeffFister123
    @JeffFister123 Рік тому +7

    Incredible! So nice to see our Church through the eyes of another. This is our family's spiritual home… my parents were engaged there, my wife and I were married there, as well as our daughter. Now I can't wait to go to SFX on Sunday and tell my family some things I never knew!

  • @FatherJMarcelPortelli
    @FatherJMarcelPortelli Рік тому +18

    It is beautiful, but I can only imagine what it must have looked like before the 1970s, especially the sanctuary and the altar. I'm sure that it was also far more colorful. That would've all far more accurately reflected the original vision of the architects and the artists.

  • @real82it
    @real82it Рік тому +16

    Love these episodes. Makes me imagine what it will be like to worship in heaven! Can’t wait! Thx.

  • @tylerrossjcl
    @tylerrossjcl Рік тому +258

    I'm a canon lawyer and theologian. It wasn't anywhere a goal of Vatican 2 to move tabernacles aside. I'm not sure where she got that from.

    • @toddlund
      @toddlund Рік тому +58

      Sadly from the continued misunderstanding (either intentional or unintentional from the clergy) of the Second Vatican Council’s works.
      I hope to see that Churches restore the respected place of the Christ's body and blood within its walls.

    • @phickle
      @phickle Рік тому +26

      The "spirit" of Vatican 2 still lives.

    • @MWroses
      @MWroses Рік тому +49

      Yes. A King sits in a throne. He should be at the front altar. A separate adoration chapel is great, though. But tabernacle should be up front by altar.

    • @MWroses
      @MWroses Рік тому +5

      Tyler, I'm Catholic but know nothing about canon law/lawyers. Can you explain how you became a canon lawyer? Requirements? Father Frank Pavone could probably use your help, although I'm sure he probably has someone working on his case already

    • @RadTradX
      @RadTradX Рік тому

      Vatican 2 turned people away from God and they had 7 open heretics(protestants) on it which goes against all Catholic teaching since Protestants are not Christians and cannot share in eternal life according to Satie Cognitum, The Council of Florence, and The council of Trent. Vatican 2 was the work of communists

  • @GemaEnriquez
    @GemaEnriquez Рік тому +15

    BRING BACK THE STATUES AND THE COMMUNION RAIL !!!!

  • @JeffHunter-wjhunter3
    @JeffHunter-wjhunter3 Рік тому +5

    First, the tabernacles are empty once a year during the Triduum, from the end of the Holy Thursday Mass until after the Easter Vigil Mass, so it's not "rarely". Second, Sacrosanctum Concilium allowed bishop conferences to adopt sacred furnishings for their regions and customs, and the post-conciliar Eucharisticum Mysterium *recommended* that the Blessed Sacrament be reserved in a quite place of contemplation and prayer, it did not mandate that the tabernacle be removed from the main altar.

  • @lucyrestivo87
    @lucyrestivo87 Рік тому +2

    I add to Matt’s question as to if the Eucharist would not ever in the tabernacle and I thought on Good Friday the tabernacle is empty.

  • @dinofrangiamore
    @dinofrangiamore Рік тому +7

    This was really cool Matt, on many levels, architecture, history, Christianity, the stuff on Francis of Xavier, and so forth. I became a huge fan of cathedrals in junior high, visited Notre Dame in France many years later...the gothic revival movement is very intriguing...all the detail in this particular church, the windows, the sculptures, the towering ceilings and majestic archways...actually being inside that monumental work of art was no doubt an awesome experience, as your enthusiasm shows. Great job! Thank you!

  • @herrgodfrey9563
    @herrgodfrey9563 Рік тому +6

    It makes sense why some churches and cathedrals take so long to build. The amount of painstaking detail both, with interior and exterior detail, along with funding and the preparation of materials, and the logistics of getting materials from point A to point B is incredible. Cologne Cathedral in Germany took around 600 years to complete from the 1200s to the 1800s. There's a photo of it from the late 1800s with a wooden crane on its roof that was built over 400 years before the photo was taken. They are just massive undertakings but their beauty and symbolism makes it all worth it.

  • @j.sethfrazer
    @j.sethfrazer Рік тому +16

    Me and my wife were married in the St. Louis area and this was one of the churches that we considered looking into; we even attended an evening Mass.
    Truly one of the most overwhelmingly beautiful churches I’ve ever set foot in!!!

  • @DLantz-ow1ii
    @DLantz-ow1ii Рік тому +14

    I am SO happy you went here, I am getting my Masters in Theology at Xavier University in Cincinnati, OH another Jesuit school and I love our chapel, Bellarmine Chapel, we have, as well as the Jesuit theology. It really has played an important role in my theological development. Happy Advent!

    • @angelapancella6063
      @angelapancella6063 Рік тому

      I spent many years in Norwood living just down the street from Xavier University, and know many people in Bellarmine parish. It's such a wonderful community!

  • @harambesstepbrother7579
    @harambesstepbrother7579 Рік тому +5

    Matt I wish you one day get a chance to come to Buffalo NY and take a tour of Our Lady of Victory Basilica. It’s very breath taking and feels like being in Rome/Vatican.

  • @debbiesluss9849
    @debbiesluss9849 Рік тому +3

    Thanks for doing this Matt. Reason, art, faith, creativity, community, all gifts of our God turned into such a wonderful place with people who care about God's mission. Love to hear these stories.

  • @Brodeagainstempire
    @Brodeagainstempire Рік тому +33

    This took me back to visiting The Cathedral Basilica of the Assumption in Covington, Kentucky. If you ever get the chance I HIGHLY recommend visiting. That place is the most beautiful church I have ever walked into. It had some of the best craftsmanship of every medium: woodwork, stonework, stained glass, etc. I also appreciated the piece depicting St Joseph a lot. The thought that goes into those pieces is part of why I respect the long history that comes with a faith like the catholic church

    • @PInk77W1
      @PInk77W1 Рік тому +1

      I’ve heard of it, but haven’t been

  • @amandacline8108
    @amandacline8108 Рік тому +3

    Love your vids on the different churches. While you were at St. Louis you should have stopped at the cathedral basilica of St. Louis too. Some of the most overwhelming beautiful mosaic work I’ve ever seen. Absolutely awe struck me. Worth the trip.

  • @mariahinderscheid6535
    @mariahinderscheid6535 Рік тому +1

    This is so beautiful and Majestic. Praise God,a true testament of the Catholic Faith..

  • @flyingforfunUSA
    @flyingforfunUSA Рік тому +8

    WHAT!!! Oh man i love that church! So glad you took the time to visit!

  • @jgsheehan8810
    @jgsheehan8810 Рік тому +1

    Beautiful Church. I love that in a Catholic Church there is so much symbolism behind everything in the building, Devore and fittings.

  • @bebetonguga
    @bebetonguga Рік тому +6

    Thanks for these viedos, Matt. They DO help in every sense. Blessings!!

  • @joanofarc6402
    @joanofarc6402 Рік тому +1

    I work in an old Catholic Church outside Chicago and I’m still amazed Our Lord gave us such beauty to visit Him daily.
    Excellent video. Thank you. 😇😇😇🙏🏻

  • @babyboy1971
    @babyboy1971 Рік тому +1

    This lady reminds me of Caroline Myss, also a theology expert. And she reminds me of some of my Midwest (Chicago) family. She is terrific!

  • @CalvinGomes
    @CalvinGomes Рік тому +7

    Sadly, she didn't mention much of St Francis Xavier. He was a french saint and miracle worker who converted from a hedonistic lifestyle to give his life to Jesus and become a priest. He converted so much of India and Asia to Jesus and his body is incorrupt and on display in Goa, India.

    • @jsmorenus8038
      @jsmorenus8038 3 місяці тому

      Sorry to correct you. He was born in Navarre, then an independent kingdom now part of Spain. He certainly wasn't French.

  • @paulmclaughlin710
    @paulmclaughlin710 Рік тому +16

    The first Christians that crossed the Mississippi were the Catholics lead by the Jesuits. St. Louis University is the first college across the Mississippi and also the first medical school.

  • @bessonnet
    @bessonnet Рік тому +3

    That's what i like to watch each time i enter a Church, a cloister, an abbey in France. Finding the details, the parabols represented, the stories narrated

  • @SocalNewsOne
    @SocalNewsOne Рік тому +2

    i want to thank you so much for all of the work you are doing! i am a newly confirmed Catholic that just converted last year after being married to a Catholic for over 30 years. I am on a personal journey to learn all I can about the Catholic faith and as many other faiths as possible. This church just moved to my number one spot of places to visit. Thank you again for your other videos and keep up the great work. Your openness and knowledge are compelling. On a side note, one of my favorite Catholic content producers is Father Mike Schmitz. If you get the chance to watch his videos he has got to be one of the most influential new media evangelists. God Bless!

    • @empackmanmueller1725
      @empackmanmueller1725 Рік тому +1

      Congratulations and welcome home. May I recommend Scott Hahn and his book The Lambs supper, and home sweet Rome. The st. Paul center is wonderful out of university of Steubenville. Keith Nester is also amazing convert. Godbless you and your family.

    • @empackmanmueller1725
      @empackmanmueller1725 Рік тому +1

      Also as a new Catholic I would recommend Shrine of Immaculate conception in DC. It's the largest Catholic church in the Western Hemisphere. It's on the campus of Catholic University, right around the corner from Pope John Paul II center.

  • @nicholasshaler7442
    @nicholasshaler7442 Рік тому +54

    Matt discovering Catholic inside baseball at 22:20 or so was mildly entertaining. That is a point of contention, and there is nothing which requires the Tabernacle not to be at the center of the church where it always had been.

    • @myleshagar9722
      @myleshagar9722 Рік тому +19

      With the tabernacle gone from the centre, the majestic reredos made to house it is meaningless and redundant. At least they did not grind it up for pavement.

    • @nicholasshaler7442
      @nicholasshaler7442 Рік тому +7

      @@myleshagar9722
      Agreed entirely.

    • @jacobc6556
      @jacobc6556 Рік тому +10

      You knew with a Jesuit church there were bound to be a few overinterpretations of Vatican 2 popping up! ;-)

    • @nicholasshaler7442
      @nicholasshaler7442 Рік тому +1

      @@jacobc6556
      Of course.

    • @daenithriuszanathos9306
      @daenithriuszanathos9306 Рік тому +3

      Could you please explain what you meant by "discovering Catholic inside baseball"? I feel like this is a figure of speech that's flying over my head.

  • @CaptGiboo
    @CaptGiboo Рік тому +6

    This is great! I went to SLU, so it was wonderful to see you tour this beautiful church that I’ve been to so many times! During the school year, try and attend the 10 pm Sunday Mass (if they have it still). It’s the student Mass. It will lift your heart and soul. I miss that Mass. As for the criticism on here about the tabernacle, etc…I definitely lean towards traditional views, but I can’t criticize these people. The Jesuits were good to me, and the education I received at SLU most certainly kept me on the right path. I probably would have lapsed as a Catholic had I not attended such wonderful theology courses there. God bless you, the College Church and SLU!

    • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
      @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому +1

      God bless you too! Yes, the student Masses are amazing. Currently they are held every Sunday the university is in session, at 4:30 and 8 pm.

    • @tedpuckett8066
      @tedpuckett8066 Рік тому

      Horrible theology n 73; de Chardin.

  • @ptalteredcrafts7228
    @ptalteredcrafts7228 Рік тому +1

    We live about 85 miles west of STL. It’s breathtaking. If you want to visit another beautiful Catholic Church, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal in Perryville, MO is open for guided tours & photos. It’s just beautiful. God bless!

  • @antaine1916
    @antaine1916 Рік тому +2

    Hearing all these Vatican II references has me wanting to reiterate my comment on another of your videos, that you visit a Latin Mass parish from the FSSP (Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter) or ICKSP (Institute of Christ the King Sovereign Priest). They are both priestly organizations dedicated to offering the old Latin Mass, and they undergo training at special seminaries for that. Those two groups are in full communion with the Holy See (and not in a "canonically irregular" way, like some Latin Mass groups are), so it would be a really good peek into the traditionalist Catholic community in the most "mainstream" way possible.

  • @WillMartin86
    @WillMartin86 Рік тому +17

    Matt, the most didactic high altar I've ever seen was in the Notre Dame Basilica in Montreal. I've been to Rome and Paris but that high altar was the most incredible I've ever seen, and highlights the foreshadowing of the Eucharist sacrifice through many of the events in the Old Testament. I'm happy to send pictures and captions to you if you're interested in seeing them. (Of course pictures don't do them justice!)

    • @TheMickey1892
      @TheMickey1892 Рік тому +4

      I’ve been to Montreal‘s Notre Dame basilica, too, and I have to agree with you. Words fall short.

  • @stephenbastasch7893
    @stephenbastasch7893 Рік тому +6

    Thanks for another lovely, informative show. I had not known that it has become customary to move the tabernacle from the central altar or reserve location to a place more "withing the community". I was raised in the pre-Vatican II Church and the Hosts were kept over the altar in the center of the nave, with some in reserve in a less ornate tabernacle off to the side of the altar. I was cheered to hear that some pastors are still allowed to keep the tabernacle in the center of the sanctuary, like we did it in "the old days".

    • @coolerking04
      @coolerking04 Рік тому +3

      In fact she was wrong in this point, most churches have the tabernacle in the center. In places where it was moved aside, younger priests are typically restoring tradition. Jesuit churches tend to be glaring exceptions

    • @stephenbastasch7893
      @stephenbastasch7893 Рік тому

      @@coolerking04 Okay - thanks for the hopeful update/clarification on this!

  • @patrickdean4853
    @patrickdean4853 Рік тому +18

    Beautiful Church and thoughtful dialogue. A few items of note: Vatican 2 did not direct the removal of the tabernacle from the alter- ideologues did that. Secondly, we kept hearing about the “renovation” to the church… and this is what happened when those same ideologues had enough influence to direct the redesign of archeological masterpieces that required no redesign whatsoever. Many, many gorgeous Churches were gutted and redesigned with atrocious results (see the Cathedral of Milwaukee). It is no coincidence that the popular devotion to the Blessed Sacrament has suffered since the widespread practice of removing the tabernacle from its proper place on the High Alter to a side chapel or, even worse, some spot they just picked off to the side. In closing, explain to me, that if you believed that the Eucharist was the Literal “body, blood, soul and divinity “, why would you remove the tabernacle-which is the space reserved specifically for containing the Blessed Sacrament- away from the visual center of the church. That’s exactly why the area directly behind the alter is so beautifully crafted. It expressly draws the eye to the most important place in the church.

    • @sadie4538
      @sadie4538 Рік тому +2

      Agree with you 100%!

    • @ritabecnel5422
      @ritabecnel5422 Рік тому +1

      you are correct!! When our parish built a new church several years ago, they rightly put the tabernacle in the central area where everyone can see it (it was in a side chapel in the previous church). That happened partly because so many people told our pastor that we wanted our church to look like a Catholic church. The tabernacle holds the Body of our Lord, and should be in the most prominent place possible!

    • @richardbenjamin5958
      @richardbenjamin5958 3 місяці тому

      Altar...learn to spell.

    • @patrickdean4853
      @patrickdean4853 3 місяці тому

      @@richardbenjamin5958 if that’s the best you have got, I’m sorry your life is that boring

  • @kerimurphy4240
    @kerimurphy4240 Рік тому +11

    I'm fascinated by the craftsmanship and history. Unfortunately there's only less than 100 or so of gothic churches from the 1800s in the United States.

  • @marcelinolorenzo9218
    @marcelinolorenzo9218 Рік тому +1

    Wow... It's beautiful✨

  • @titob.yotokojr.9337
    @titob.yotokojr.9337 Рік тому +3

    The previous bishop of my place had the Tabernacle of the cathedral moved to a side chapel so people could continue to worship before it without disturbing what's going on at the main altar.
    But the present bishop moved it back to the main altar after the construction of the Eucharistic Adoration Chapel where people can worship regardless of what's going on inside the cathedral.

  • @donnariggs1567
    @donnariggs1567 Рік тому +4

    Thank you for this tour. Beautiful! I live south of ST Louis for 25 years now. I have gone past this church and never imagined how amazing it is on the inside. Such craftsmanship!!!

    • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
      @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому

      Thank you for the kind words! You are always welcome to stop in--we keep the doors open Monday through Friday until early afternoon, and we have weekend Masses at 5:15 on Saturdays and 8 and 10:30 on Sundays.

    • @donnariggs1567
      @donnariggs1567 Рік тому +1

      @@StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch How kind, thank you! It would make a lovely day trip and then hit the Hill for some local food, also.
      Merry Christmas God Bless!

    • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
      @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому

      @@donnariggs1567 Sounds like a very fun day trip! Merry Christmas to you too!

    • @donnariggs1567
      @donnariggs1567 Рік тому +2

      @@StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch I'm going to bring it up to the girl friends for a spring thing. I think St Louis has so much to offer. Cheers!

  • @rebeccavalicoff1581
    @rebeccavalicoff1581 Рік тому +2

    And just down the street we also have the Cathedral! We in St. Louis MO are blessed with many beautiful churches!

  • @maillemacanaugh1841
    @maillemacanaugh1841 Рік тому +1

    Finishing the basement first so that the people could worship: puts a new spin on the underground church 😊

  • @apostolicapologetics4829
    @apostolicapologetics4829 Рік тому +1

    Beautiful! The way a Catholic Church should look.

  • @jowr2000
    @jowr2000 Рік тому +13

    The Church is stunning. The aftermath of Vatican II has been a disaster. In the name of "accessibility" and "inclusivity", not only have cherished traditions fallen by the wayside, but even some moral doctrines have been called into question. The Church is not supposed to change to accommodate secular culture, but should stand firm for absolute truth.

    • @jimreilly917
      @jimreilly917 Рік тому

      But…but…what is a woman?🙄🥴🤡

    • @jowr2000
      @jowr2000 Рік тому

      @@jimreilly917 😂😂

  • @gphodgins1
    @gphodgins1 Рік тому +1

    Thank you Matt. God bless you my brother. Your videos' are a blessing. Pax Christi.

  • @Dddezzz
    @Dddezzz Рік тому +17

    It would be cool if you interviewed Fr. Donald Calloway. He wrote a book about St. Joseph. I think you would enjoy having a conversation with him. Plus, he has an epic conversion story

    • @sadie4538
      @sadie4538 Рік тому

      Yes his conversion story is awesome!

  • @beautifullycreatable
    @beautifullycreatable 19 днів тому

    Thank you Matt for this wonderful video ❤. The bright, St Augustine, if I am not mistaken, converted to Catholicism because of the kindness and gentleness of St Ambrose, who simply lived and served his parishioners. I think that evangelization takes root in the heart of simple service. It is implanted by the seed of service out of love. I see the grandeur of the history of that Church, not just in the services it provides in its community, but to the many influences of the priests they formed, the children they educated and the families they helped in their basic needs. We cannot see how far and wide where and what influences these people have been formed and helped, only God sees the totality of all their contributions, but for sure it is beyond what we know. Christ in His greatness did the basic ways of services as what he can do in his limitations as human, but His influence in our Church now is immeasurable. That is why God loves simple ways and people brcause He could make them grand and beyond expectations ❤. 1 or 2 dedicated priests that that Church could form from one of the families they helped would already be a great success of that Church.

  • @angelapancella6063
    @angelapancella6063 Рік тому +5

    Something I love about College Church is the way it helps me keep in mind the mystery of the Incarnation. The wood altar with an ornate high altar in view behind it reminds me how Jesus humbled Himself all the way to a scandalous death, a self-emptying that becomes present at every Mass. And our tabernacle is likewise both unassuming and attended to by adoring angels. It calls to mind John 1:14--"the Word became flesh and dwelt among us"--"tabernacled" with us.

  • @CroweDharmaReloaded
    @CroweDharmaReloaded Рік тому +9

    I'm a Catholic in the Netherlands. Very rarely the tabernacle is NOT in the middle (in my experience). In my church the Eucharist is only moved to a side altar/tabernacle on White/Holy Thursday untill Easter Vigil.

    • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
      @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому

      @@PTHazel I can tell you more about our ID and birth certificate program. When folks who are going through a tough time--out of homelessness, or some other hardship--lose their documentation, it costs around $25 to get replacements. Lack of ID makes it a challenge to get a job, housing, etc. So we decided that, just as many churches will run a food pantry or other concrete ways to help neighbors in need, we would commit to helping people who need assistance getting replacement IDs.

    • @sadie4538
      @sadie4538 Рік тому +3

      Totally agree. It’s the Holy of Holies. Why would anyone consider moving the Eucharist off to a side altar? SMH.

    • @363catman
      @363catman Рік тому

      @NPR Sucks! If you get in the details of the why the changes were made regarding the tabernacle move the term you will see is something along the lines of a chapel of repose basically this was something that existed in large cathedrals & basilica Look at Saint Peter's itself there was never a tabernacle on the main altar under Bernini's baldachin. They were essentially a Mini church or mini chapel unto themselves within the building and while there was probably some well intended good thinking in practicality most churches were not laid out (size & space) to where this was conducive to the idea

  • @cameronaustin7734
    @cameronaustin7734 Рік тому +5

    I went to SLU and college church is very pretty and well taken care of, but if you are in St. Louis don't leave without visiting St. Francis de Sales oratory while you are there! It is one of the most remarkable and magnificent gothic churches in the country with an even more beautiful building than college church. It is also run by the Institute of Christ the King and is reknowned throughout the whole country for having one of the most beautiful traditional liturgies anywhere.

  • @embelslishments
    @embelslishments Рік тому +52

    It's a fair mistake, but St Paul's Cathedral in London isn't gothic, it's late English baroque. However it did replace a medieval gothic building! Westminster Abbey, a few miles west of St Pauls, is gothic (although parts are Norman romanesque & parts have some baroque touches, it's been changing gradually for over a thousand years so architectural categories naturally get super vague)

    • @dalecaldwell
      @dalecaldwell Рік тому +5

      One of the hidden tricks of St. Paul's is that it actually has flying buttresses because Wren had no better way of dealing with the weight, but they are hidden by an exterior wall.

    • @justin_messer
      @justin_messer Рік тому +2

      I thought St. Paul’s was Byzantine Revival. It seemed like everyone in the west (Catholic and Protestant) in the late19th century wanted to build their generations Hagia Sophia.

    • @the.orthodox.photographer2272
      @the.orthodox.photographer2272 Рік тому +3

      @@justin_messer There may be some Byzantine influenced but by and large, it's English Baroque, NeoClassical. However, Westminster Cathedral (NOT Abbey) is indeed Byzantine.

  • @thepianoman6958
    @thepianoman6958 Рік тому +4

    Definitely should check out St. Francis de Sales Oratory there in St. Louis! It's run by a traditional institute.

  • @TestifyApologetics
    @TestifyApologetics Рік тому +2

    I'm from St Louis. And I'm the 314th like which is the StL area code so boom serendipity

  • @peterjones7984
    @peterjones7984 Рік тому +4

    If you visit this beautiful church, you should also visit the St. Louis Cathedral Basilica, it's right down the street and is another Old World style Cathedral that is absolutely stunning.

  • @PaulsWanderings
    @PaulsWanderings Рік тому

    I am so glad she explained about the placement of the Tabernacle on the side. My understanding was that must be in the center. The church in which I grew up and the church I go to now have the Tabernacle in the center behind the altar.

  • @ryandersones
    @ryandersones Рік тому +1

    Nicely done Matt. I love your videos and how respectful you are. I pray for you to become Catholic but I'm glad you are taking your time and investigating everything. It reminds me of my own journey! God Bless!

  • @lesmen4
    @lesmen4 Рік тому +5

    I want more like this. Be where you are.

  • @lizf506
    @lizf506 Рік тому +5

    God bless you, Matt. I will pray for you. Sadly, so many of those changes were terrible and shouldn't have happened. They were done "in the spirit of Vatican II." Now, happily a lot of churches are moving to put such lovely traditions back (Communion rails, the Tabernacle in the Center and so on) and to restore the things in the church that fit with the old rite of of the mass. (The Traditional Latin Mass.) It's a lovely church and it's fun to see it. p.s. I think St. Joseph was young, not old.

  • @jeffabernathy8305
    @jeffabernathy8305 Рік тому +5

    The true beauty of this church is during Sunday evenings during the school year. While Ruth spoke well of the Parish that worships there during the day, the other community that worships there during the school year is college students. And that church is very full with 18-25 year olds every Sunday. The beauty of the youth of the Church combined with the beauty of the church is quite the sight to see.

    • @josephh.7109
      @josephh.7109 Рік тому

      I couldn’t agree more, I loved those Sunday night services. Everyone was there because that was where they wanted to be. That was the first time many actually chose to go on their own. My roommate was even baptized in that font.

    • @tedpuckett8066
      @tedpuckett8066 Рік тому

      They're too lazy to get up early.

  • @dodg1988
    @dodg1988 Рік тому +7

    Well Ruth seems like one of the kindest people on the planet

  • @brendaboykin3281
    @brendaboykin3281 Рік тому

    Thank you,Matt and beautiful guide🌹🌹🌹🌹

  • @thomasklug1294
    @thomasklug1294 Рік тому +3

    Appreciate the tour of this masterpiece. As a cradle Catholic, and revert to the faith one of the things I've enjoyed myself is going to the many beautiful churches built in the earlier centuries. It always brings a sense of holiness being in one of those buildings dedicated to God our Lord Jesus Christ. Everything about them has been thought out, as you've noted, and they are so much more uplifting then all the new concrete monstrosities built since vatican II. Those buildings took generations to build for all the generations to come after them like the eternal Himself!

  • @sopad4629
    @sopad4629 Рік тому +1

    I grew up catholic and I still within me revere the holiness of this place. Jesus being present in the Tabernacle with His Body and Blood in the Holy Eucharist. I prefer silence, prayer and listening to God speaking to me in this place. If I hear God speak to me, I’ll be crying with emotions of peace and joy.

  • @florepetrus5153
    @florepetrus5153 Рік тому +4

    Hey Matt! If you ever make it back to St. Louis and want to visit another breathtaking gothic church please come to St. Francis de Sales Oratory. You may be interested in their preservation of the traditional Latin rite and the monastic priest of the institute of Christ the King that call this beautiful oratory their home

  • @kristen1398
    @kristen1398 Рік тому +5

    If you're ever in NYC come check out the Church of St Francis Xavier in Manhattan! It's huge and beautiful on the inside but easy to miss if you're just walking down the street and its been part of NYC for 175 years.

    • @kristen1398
      @kristen1398 Рік тому +3

      @@marym.338 The parish's mission statement says "The Church of St. Francis Xavier, a Roman Catholic parish in the Jesuit tradition, strives to be a prophetic, welcoming community, and an inclusive witness to the presence of Christ Jesus in our midst. Mindful of our utter reliance on God, and need for God’s grace, we rejoice together in our celebration of the sacraments and proclamation of the Gospel. As a people of hope, we commit ourselves through prayerful and creative discernment to respond to God in our time by: being a respectful community where seekers and their questions are welcomed, where injustice is challenged, where the poor, the alienated and the marginalized find a home, and where people are refreshed, reconciled and renewed." If those Gospel values can be easily divided into one political ideology, we're in a sad place as a church

  • @charlesmcdermott6139
    @charlesmcdermott6139 Рік тому +3

    This was very impressive! Thank you for respecting and understanding us Catholics and how we worship the same Lord Jesus Christ. May I suggest that you visit the Cathedral Basilica of the Sacred Heart in Newark, NJ. It is considered the best example of French Gothic architecture in the Western Hemisphere, and is even larger than St. Patrick’s in New York which is just across the Hudson! Thanks for this series.

  • @juanpaolovilladolid9550
    @juanpaolovilladolid9550 Рік тому

    I enjoyed this a whole lot, god be with you, my brother.

  • @samuraisaxon6800
    @samuraisaxon6800 Рік тому +8

    Such a stunning chapel! I just applied to this university

    • @jimreilly917
      @jimreilly917 Рік тому

      Good luck! Merry Christmas. SLU Alum PL, AS, 91.

  • @UnOrthodox_Christian
    @UnOrthodox_Christian Рік тому +1

    Thanks for this video!

  • @JonathanAllen0379
    @JonathanAllen0379 Рік тому +4

    11:45 - I hope there *is* a Vatican III, as long as it is convened by a conservative traditionalist Pope.

  • @alBngnnuyn8070
    @alBngnnuyn8070 Рік тому +10

    I really want to visit and see the interior of church in person, one day.

    • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
      @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому +3

      Please do! We have daily Masses Monday through Friday, and the church is open for quiet prayer during the week until mid-afternoon. We have weekend Masses on Saturdays at 5:15 and Sundays 8 am and 10:30 am.

    • @alBngnnuyn8070
      @alBngnnuyn8070 Рік тому +2

      @@StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Thank 😊 you so much for the information.

    • @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch
      @StFrancisXavierCollegeChurch Рік тому +1

      @@alBngnnuyn8070 You are welcome! God bless you!

  • @samuelunderwood5286
    @samuelunderwood5286 Рік тому +3

    Matt, if you're in the Lou, you gotta visit the Cathedral Basilica of St. Louis, the Old Cathedral, and St. Francis de Sales.

  • @Daydreamerx4
    @Daydreamerx4 Рік тому

    This was amazing so glad I found your channel ❤ Thank you for sharing

  • @RuachNation82
    @RuachNation82 Рік тому +5

    Stunning church. Wow!

  • @robertotapia8086
    @robertotapia8086 Рік тому +3

    @Matt Whitman Matt as a Catholic abroad on an island I thank you so much for these and other videos that you've made with so much respect and in a reverent way to our Temples ⛪ and our Catholic beliefs I respect you for it. GOD BLESS your family and you , Robert from Puerto Rico 🇵🇷

  • @9502937
    @9502937 Рік тому +2

    Interesting coincidence of you posting this today: the conversation about Joseph starting at about 18:00 is very apropos in light of today's gospel reading in the Catholic church, Matthew 1:18-24

  • @sjmnic
    @sjmnic Рік тому +8

    While I know the topic of the Virgin Mary can be difficult for some to understand, it helps me to concentrate on two aspects. First, Mary for me is the perfect Christian as she accepted everything God asked of her. Secondly, in the same way as with friends on Facebook or in a prayer circle, I ask her to prayer for me and my intentions to the Holy Trinity.

    • @peterfox7663
      @peterfox7663 Рік тому

      Do you ask your dead friends, too?

    • @LB_die_Kaapie
      @LB_die_Kaapie Рік тому

      @Peter Fox We pray to recognised Saints.Not just any person.

    • @peterfox7663
      @peterfox7663 Рік тому

      @@LB_die_Kaapie So, dead people.

    • @jamespowell_km_kchs
      @jamespowell_km_kchs Рік тому +3

      @@peterfox7663 they are more alive than you and I are. To be in the presence of the Almighty….

    • @peterfox7663
      @peterfox7663 Рік тому

      @@jamespowell_km_kchs They are in the same state as anyone that has passed and is saved

  • @MelaniesManicures
    @MelaniesManicures Рік тому +1

    Beautiful church!
    Regarding Mary…A suggestion is to look at the wedding at Canna where Jesus wasn’t ready to show himself to the world but he listened to His mother and turned water into wine. So there is an example of a time Jesus granted the request of His mother.

  • @rachelmiles2211
    @rachelmiles2211 Рік тому +2

    Thank you so much for this video. It is such a testament to the glory of the Creator when we see what incredible beauty mere man can create. If you really want your mind blown, take a look at all the symbolism of the Traditional Latin Mass liturgy - from the vesting prayers of the priest to the meaning of the steps up to the altar to the tiniest gestures of the priest throughout the Mass…

  • @crystalrock18
    @crystalrock18 Рік тому +1

    I live in Warren County Missouri I need to go by and check that place out. The basilica in Saint Louis is absolutely phenomenal I highly recommend anyone here here in the STL area to go see that.