The History of Narsil & Andúril, Blade of Kings - Artifacts of Arda

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 жов 2024
  • Andúril, reforged from Narsil, was the blade of the new king of Gondor and Arnor, Aragorn, just as Narsil had been the sword of the first king of those realms, Elendil. The history of the sword speaks to the ancientry of the kings of Men in Tolkien’s Middle-earth. Thank you all so much for watching, let me know your thoughts about Narsil and Andúril in the comments below! As always, a great thanks to the online artists whose visual works made this video possible! If you are one of the artists, please let me know and I will post your name and a link to your work in this description!
    #LordoftheRings
    #Silmarillion
    #Numenor
    #Lore
    Consider donating to our Patreon for the Westernesse Podcast and Discord Server:
    / menofthewest
    Check out our Merch:
    www.spreadshir...
    Check out our music channel:
    / @musicmotw
    Join us on Facebook at:
    / yoystan
    Join us on Twitter at:
    / yoystan
    Related articles:
    tolkiengateway....
    tolkiengateway....
    tolkiengateway....
    tolkiengateway....
    tolkiengateway....
    tolkiengateway....
    lotr.fandom.co...
    lotr.fandom.co...
    The Ring of Barahir - Artifacts of Arda:
    • The History of the Rin...
    The Rise and Downfall of Númenor - Region Spotlight:
    • The History of Númenor...
    High King Isildur - Epic Character History:
    • High King Isildur - Ep...
    Aragorn Telcontar, High King Elessar - Epic Character History
    • Aragorn Telcontar, Hig...
    Thank you for your (Valar and Elf tiers) patronage!
    Adrian De la Torre
    Peter Sheppard
    Chris Ortner
    Blair Scouten
    Samuel McBee
    Jonathan Putnam
    Mark Kralick
    Tobias Göldner
    Adam Rink
    Merten
    Ryan Ramsay
    John Hume
    Tom Bombadil
    Ridgy93
    Chip Slade
    Diego Perez
    Berni McCoy
    Daniel Orlandi
    John Crowley
    Susan Henry
    Atlas
    Maz Gibs
    Ryan Warren
    Renato Filipe
    Imiel Elenen
    Chiara Siasat
    Tyler Lund
    Hydro Knight
    Joshua W
    Ádám Kis
    Memory Troll
    Dale Starbuck
    Dan Mazzei
    April Green
    Corwin Nemeth
    Bryar Keyes
    Matthew Rivas
    Holy
    OneErlend
    Hjertholm
    Metalguy87
    Vlad Dracula
    Joshua Schofield-Raval
    The new Men of the West logo was created by Raffe - Twitter: RaffetheRandom
    The final image “Bag End” was created by Wayne Glassbrook at designly.net
    The first song used in this video:
    Procession of the King by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
    Source: incompetech.com...
    Artist: incompetech.com/
    The second and third songs were developed and produced by my associate Galafee.
    The last song used in this video is from:
    library.techsm...
    Many related and/or used art come from these artists and sources:
    Ted Nasmith:
    www.tednasmith...
    Jenny Dolfen:
    goldseven.word...
    Alan Lee:
    www.iamag.co/t...
    John Howe:
    www.john-howe....
    Hildebrant brothers:
    www.brothershil...
    DonatoArts:
    www.deviantart...
    Magali Villeneuve
    www.magali-vill...
    Wolfanita:
    www.deviantart...
    Gerwell:
    / gerwell
    Mirach Ravaia:
    www.deviantart...
    Kaprriss:
    www.deviantart...
    EKukanova:
    www.deviantart...
    steamy:
    www.deviantart...
    Laurelinartistry:
    / laurelinartistry
    SaMo-art:
    www.deviantart...
    kimberly80:
    www.deviantart...
    Anke Eissmann:
    anke.edoras-art...
    Fable Blades:
    www.deviantart...
    bozac:
    www.deviantart...
    Shockbolt:
    www.deviantart...
    Luan Felipe de Almeida:
    luandealmeida....
    Boris Lebedev:
    www.artstation...
    Danijel-Knez:
    www.deviantart...
    Leo Luján:
    www.artstation...
    annoulaki:
    www.deviantart...
    idolwild:
    www.deviantart...
    Joan Wyatt

КОМЕНТАРІ • 235

  • @MenoftheWest
    @MenoftheWest  3 роки тому +22

    Hey everyone, I am currently making a video on Elendil and noticed an error that I have made here and in other videos that I would like to amend! Elendil's father Amandil was the last lord of Andúnië in Númenor, not Elendil himself. Sorry about the mistake, thanks!

    • @caidenkalel4649
      @caidenkalel4649 3 роки тому

      you prolly dont care but if you guys are stoned like me atm you can stream pretty much all the latest movies and series on InstaFlixxer. Have been binge watching with my gf lately :)

    • @juantate5978
      @juantate5978 3 роки тому +2

      @Caiden Kalel Definitely, have been watching on InstaFlixxer for years myself :)

    • @randallbeckett2366
      @randallbeckett2366 3 роки тому +1

      @Caiden Kalel yea, I have been watching on instaflixxer for since december myself :D

  • @ricardocastillo5485
    @ricardocastillo5485 3 роки тому +57

    When they are disarmed at the door of Theoden's hall and Aragorn says no one is to touch Anduril, he says "Telchar wrought it in the deeps of time", and Gimli approves that it was made by a Dwarf, and is proud to lay his ax alongside Anduril.

    • @T-adams
      @T-adams 9 місяців тому

      legendary quote… i wish we didn’t forget our family history in real life

  • @vampiregirl258
    @vampiregirl258 3 роки тому +107

    I have a foam version of Anduril for larping. It was my grandfather's last Christmas gift to me and I will never part from it.

    • @Number0neSon
      @Number0neSon 3 роки тому +10

      What an awesome gift. Cherish it always.

    • @davidkenyon2193
      @davidkenyon2193 3 роки тому +6

      A gift from one king to another! 👑

    • @Jakblade
      @Jakblade 2 роки тому

      That’s really awesome

    • @silenciummortum2193
      @silenciummortum2193 Рік тому

      What a sweet memory. He sounds like a great man and is still with you…

  • @orrointhewise87
    @orrointhewise87 3 роки тому +87

    "Sauron will not have forgotten the sword of Elendil. The blade that was broken shall return to Minas Tirith"
    Love reading about the artifacts of Arda; they're like little easter eggs u find in multiple stories:)
    Just goes to show u, the gifts passed down by our forebears are valued in more ways than one

  • @nl396
    @nl396 3 роки тому +51

    I never knew Aragorn had Andúril with him that long. Now I have to read the books.

    • @DD-fj2ut
      @DD-fj2ut 3 роки тому +6

      Yes the books are a must read if you only have the movies to go by, the books cannot be beaten when compared to movie.

    • @greysnake2903
      @greysnake2903 Рік тому

      ​@DD-fj2ut Yes and no.

  • @kazorbrooks3980
    @kazorbrooks3980 3 роки тому +23

    Yes finally early, and on a topic I love too. God bless you Yostan.

  • @jenniferbaldini3527
    @jenniferbaldini3527 3 роки тому +46

    Tolkein describes Narsil thusly: "The sword of Elindil filled Orcs and Men with fear, for it shone with the light of the Sun and the Moon, and its name was Narsil". ~ 'The Fellowship of the Ring'.
    The runes on the pommel of Narsil (then Anduril) translated from Quenya, read: "Narsil is my name, a mighty sword. Telchar made me in Nogrod".
    The runes running down the fuller of Anduril are Ange'rthas Eregion (' Ancient Elvish Runes') and translate to: "I am Anduril who was Narsil, the sword of Elendil. Let the thralls of Mordor flee me". (The first word at the top of the sword closest to the crossgaurd means "Sun". The last word on the tip means "Moon". Elrond had them placed there to further magically strengthen the blade so that it could never be broken again. (I am a huge Hobbit/LOTR sword collector and am up close and personal with all of the swords, blades, daggers, and knives, envisioned/imagined and created by WETA of course.😉)
    Thanks guys, loved this vid!!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

    • @MuRevo122
      @MuRevo122 3 роки тому +4

      Do you have more cool info??

    • @jenniferbaldini3527
      @jenniferbaldini3527 3 роки тому +12

      @@MuRevo122 Aside from talking your ear off for hours about the weapons, I would be happy to share the translations on the rest of the weapons with runes, Sindar or Quenya.
      The Sword of The Lady Arwen (borrowed from her father Lord Elrond of course) was named 'Hadhafang', its Sindar inscription on the beautifully curved blade: "This blade is called Hadhafang. A noble defense against an enemy throng for a noble Lady". Interestingly, one translation of 'noble' in Sindar, is 'Arwen'. So, (only in the movie of course, because 'Hadhafang' only exists because of PJ and WETA), Arwen borrowing the sword of her father, that WAS originally made for and used by her grandmother, Idril, having a variation of her name on the blade, is just kinda interesting to me.
      The curved dagger, presented to Aragorn by Lord Celeborn in Lothlorien: "Foe of Morgoths realm".
      And last, the blade of Bilbo Baggins, then given to Frodo...Sting: "Sting is my name, I am the spiders bane".
      Thanks for the question, loved to share. 🙂

    • @Nanosuit37
      @Nanosuit37 3 роки тому +1

      Very interesting. Thank you.

    • @Sir_Baddington
      @Sir_Baddington 2 роки тому +1

      Anduril also glowed elvish light.

    • @jenniferbaldini3527
      @jenniferbaldini3527 2 роки тому

      @@Sir_Baddington From what I know of the sword from the books and its inscriptions, the sword (as Narsil) was originally forged by Telchar who was a famous Dwarven smith, in the dwarf land of Nogrod. It was not forged by elves. Although it was *reforged* by elves, it was done using the original sword, again not elven. The sword was imbued with elvish symbols and wording (by Elrond) to strengthen it so it would never break again, and it 'shone with the light of the sun and the moon', but if I remember correctly, it did not glow blue when orcs were near.

  • @theWitch-KingofAngmar
    @theWitch-KingofAngmar 3 роки тому +69

    Renewed shall be blade that was broken...
    My master Sauron the Great would have liked to see it remain broken...

    • @Avalonnerd211990
      @Avalonnerd211990 3 роки тому +5

      Yeah well im sure he has a lot of regrets like making you his mouthpiece

    • @hiswayservicesblog9288
      @hiswayservicesblog9288 3 роки тому

      That wasn't his call to make, scary dude. And I'm sure Isildur would've liked to see that your master Sauron the Terrible would've dissipated forever, body and spirit. But that didn't happen either.

  • @shadowofchaos8932
    @shadowofchaos8932 3 роки тому +36

    A big change from the movies, Aragorn carried the blade during the books. Frodo and Sam noted his sword when Aragorn showed it broken. Important to the books, changed by Peter Jackson.

    • @Longshanks1690
      @Longshanks1690 3 роки тому +18

      Because Book Aragorn was always on the verge of singing “Oh I just can’t wait to be King!”
      It was a bigger moment in the movie precisely because it represented him accepting that mantle when his book counterpart had accepted it years ago.

    • @robertdendooven7258
      @robertdendooven7258 3 роки тому +4

      What the heck good it do to Aragorn to carry around a broken sword in the books? It never made much sense to me, unless he also carried another sword for defense at the same time. It would have made more sense to leave it in Rivendell. Though, I liked the book version of it being re-forged before the Fellowship left Rivendell.

    • @shadowofchaos8932
      @shadowofchaos8932 3 роки тому +4

      @@robertdendooven7258 he did carry two. He was the protector of the sword that he inherited.

    • @sbeaber
      @sbeaber 3 роки тому +6

      @@robertdendooven7258 he'd whip it out (lol) any chance he'd get. Like at the council of Elrond, when meeting Eomer, or at the the gate of the Golden Hall. It's kinda funny.

    • @brovold72
      @brovold72 3 роки тому +2

      @@Longshanks1690 Yeah an unnecessary, contrived "moment".

  • @Daniel0061
    @Daniel0061 3 роки тому +5

    Fun video! Thanks!
    My wife and I got to see The fellowship of the ring in IMAX 4K yesterday. Your speaking highly of the 4K the other week pushed us to do it, so thanks! It was amazing!

  • @rangerofthenorth1970
    @rangerofthenorth1970 3 роки тому +5

    I always wanted to know more about sword's history, thank you for this content, you are trully men of the west.
    Tolkien would be proud of you!

  • @IanHeins
    @IanHeins 3 місяці тому +1

    Nice work dude thanks

  • @thewayfarer8849
    @thewayfarer8849 3 роки тому +6

    I like these nice, not overlong videos by quite a wholesome channel. Thanks for the good work

    • @MenoftheWest
      @MenoftheWest  3 роки тому +2

      Thank you Wayfarer, that means a lot!

    • @thewayfarer8849
      @thewayfarer8849 3 роки тому

      @@MenoftheWest You're welcome, have a good day

    • @Mark723
      @Mark723 3 роки тому +1

      Not all who wonder are lost - well observed, Wayfarer.

  • @billmiller4972
    @billmiller4972 3 роки тому +5

    From Narsil and Anduril we see that no matter the darkness one faces nothing is beyond reforging and remaking.
    Tolkien himself would agree. Thank you. We need this positivity these dark days.

  • @Steel-101
    @Steel-101 3 роки тому +12

    This sword is in my top three! Sting, Anduril, and Orchrist(I hope I spelled that right). Thank you Mr. West 👍🏼. Also I wish you good fortune on finding a new apartment. I saw your community post.

    • @MenoftheWest
      @MenoftheWest  3 роки тому +2

      Thanks M.G., I really appreciate it, my friend! I'm actually house hunting so I can leave my apartment, so that's even more stress for me lol. But thank you again, I really appreciate it!

    • @Steel-101
      @Steel-101 3 роки тому +1

      @@MenoftheWest You’re welcome! One bit of advice. Try to avoid houses that have carpet in every room in the house. I’ve heard it’s not very healthy. Plus if you wanted to remove(replace) the carpet, it’s very expensive.

    • @dlevi67
      @dlevi67 3 роки тому +1

      It's Orcrist - no 'h' (since you made the point about spelling; it's 'orc' and 'rist', Sindarin for cleaver or sword).

    • @anthonyharris8390
      @anthonyharris8390 13 днів тому

      Ha, I have Orcrist and Anduril reproductions in my office. My Orcrist is a prop but Anduril is a real sharpened Darksword Armory version. It is epic to hold.

  • @theranger6411
    @theranger6411 3 роки тому +8

    Awesome Sword and the one sword that Sauron fears the most.

  • @apdarkness905
    @apdarkness905 3 роки тому +17

    A most fascinating look into the history of arguably the most important weapon of the War of the Ring, I wonder if the Flame of the West was ever called to combat such as was seen on Pelennor Fields on the fourteenth of March, 3019 or at the the Black Gate a mere six days later. Perhaps it will yet have a roll to play upon Dagor Dagorath, but I leave that in the hands of Ilúvatar.

  • @ravendan968
    @ravendan968 3 роки тому +1

    Not gonna lie, I was hoping that you guys could have made a shout out to the man at arms reforged episode where they made Narsil, broke it and remade it into Anduril. However I totally get if you didn't see it or weren't aware of it. I'm coming from a position that I'm an aspiring/amateur blacksmith who is also a big nerd and that particular episode is one of my favorites and most informative as well as memorable.
    Either way I love your guys channel! Watching your videos has increased my knowledge of the legendarium and as a result has enriched my viewings of the movies!

  • @manuela1986
    @manuela1986 3 роки тому +4

    I often think about how cool it would be to walk through a museum with all this Middle Earth artifacts 😁♥️

  • @J-ui2jr
    @J-ui2jr 3 роки тому +2

    Can't wait for your video on Aragorn and Arwen

  • @IronDragon-2143
    @IronDragon-2143 3 роки тому +142

    The Sword that shames Excalibur

    • @TheVictorLoyiso
      @TheVictorLoyiso 3 роки тому +14

      Indeed this blade makes Excalibur look like a Big Mac without the meat or buns.

    • @IronDragon-2143
      @IronDragon-2143 3 роки тому +9

      @@TheVictorLoyiso It makes Excalibur look like a BLT without Bacon, Lettuce or Tomato.

    • @occamsox5331
      @occamsox5331 3 роки тому +16

      Please. Excalibur is the inspiration.

    • @IronDragon-2143
      @IronDragon-2143 3 роки тому +6

      @@occamsox5331 please. Narsil and later Anduril was the sword of kings for many generations even after it was broken and reforged for Aragorn. Excalibur was used once before being tossed back to the Lady of the Lake after Arthur died and was never seen or used again.

    • @treynienhuser2616
      @treynienhuser2616 3 роки тому +1

      I am regretful to admit that this is true.

  • @thesandmancurtballirg4371
    @thesandmancurtballirg4371 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you for making this vid. Tolkien's universe is so history rich with Arda's lore that, I think, we get new stories by looking at it from different perspectives...inc. the weapons, gems and trees.

  • @Avalonnerd211990
    @Avalonnerd211990 3 роки тому +4

    Thank you for making this one i love this sword!

  • @sethmiller2534
    @sethmiller2534 3 роки тому +11

    When you see a man as he is, you see his eyes, you see his hair, his face, his smile or grin, but when I imagine seeing you, I see nothing but a golden ethereal being, so beautiful and bold. I see a strong and glorious man, the Man of the West. You are more precious than the Arkenstone, and shine bright always

    • @MenoftheWest
      @MenoftheWest  3 роки тому +2

      LOL thanks Seth

    • @lordheklsmosh9490
      @lordheklsmosh9490 3 роки тому

      @@MenoftheWest last time I checked you haven't even done a face reveal.😁

  • @magnoliamadam3113
    @magnoliamadam3113 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you for the video! I also love the artwork which compliments your explanations to the stories.

  • @scages101
    @scages101 3 роки тому +10

    One of the coolest weapons in LOTR

  • @vojticvojtic2631
    @vojticvojtic2631 3 роки тому

    Hi, I just want to thank you for your amazing work. The lord of the rings made me who I am today and your videos are so good! I always look forward for your new content. Dissapearing into the lore of Middle-earth even just for few minutes helps me to overcome these dark days, which are the worst times I have ever been through (even without covid). I dont know if you will read this, but it doesnt matter, I just want to write it down and hopefuly it will give back a bit of happines you give to all of us through your great, great videos. Dont you ever stop creating, you are the best.
    Many thanks from Prague!

  • @mrllama4172
    @mrllama4172 3 роки тому +1

    Great video! Didn't know sword history could be soo interesting!

  • @johnpatricktan5545
    @johnpatricktan5545 3 роки тому +1

    Great video Yostan!!

  • @nomorok15
    @nomorok15 3 роки тому +10

    The fact that a lesser divine being feared that sword tells you everything you need to know

  • @marionbaggins
    @marionbaggins 3 роки тому +6

    I think we all know why, you love Anduril...It's because it's Aragorn's (your Favorite Character) Sword!!!
    This Video very early Mellon, and I haven't had 1st Breakfast yet!!!
    Thanks for telling us on the famousist Sword (or 4 way tie for first) in Arda, Until Aragorn and Arwen Love Story...Marion Baggins Out!!!

    • @MenoftheWest
      @MenoftheWest  3 роки тому +1

      You've got that right Marion! Yeah this one is pretty early haha, getting ready for the Superbowl!

    • @marionbaggins
      @marionbaggins 3 роки тому +1

      @@MenoftheWest Makes Sense!!!

  • @gordonmills2748
    @gordonmills2748 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for using the Brothers Hildebrandt artwork in the video. Long before Peter Jackson, they made the Tolkien tale come to life through their art.

    • @Mark723
      @Mark723 3 роки тому

      Great observation! Whenever I think of any LOTR artwork, I immediately envision a Hildebrandt piece...

  • @bradmarthafocker4285
    @bradmarthafocker4285 3 роки тому +1

    Outstanding work, as always.

  • @debbie4503
    @debbie4503 3 роки тому

    @Men Of The West I don't think I told you, but I love your channel!

  • @azipoor3468
    @azipoor3468 3 роки тому +5

    Awesome as always.btw if you are Tolkien fan and your first language is French or you are learning French you can check" Mémoires de la terre du milieu" and "Mestre Thibaut" UA-cam channels(I'm sure you will like them too ).

    • @leahea4906
      @leahea4906 3 роки тому

      Thank you very much.I really needed a channel about lotr or silmarillion in French.l like them and I'll subscribe to them as well.
      Merci beaucoup mon ami(e).

  • @javiervalverde628
    @javiervalverde628 3 роки тому +1

    Epic tattoo Yoystan! I love it!

    • @richardevans6183
      @richardevans6183 3 роки тому

      I agree: the tattoo is epic! I love it, Yoystan! Thank you for showing it.
      No greater sword than this with its glorious heritage and destiny. The grand account of how it broke and the how the elves reforged it for greater purposes yet to come. You have a grand destiny, too, Yoystan! (And thank you for these awesome videos!)

  • @thedunadan8021
    @thedunadan8021 3 роки тому +1

    Your tattoo is PERFECT. Love it!

  • @bellisperennissturdivant
    @bellisperennissturdivant 3 роки тому +2

    rly love yr videos wish they had subtitles !!!!

  • @BioHunter1990
    @BioHunter1990 3 роки тому +3

    Good timing!

  • @knightonart8886
    @knightonart8886 3 роки тому +26

    Put aside the ranger. . . become who you were born to be

    • @mikegagne3263
      @mikegagne3263 3 роки тому

      Movie quote.

    • @adrianciobanu5856
      @adrianciobanu5856 3 роки тому

      Move dont have logic ithen tolkien king of umbar being discendent of castamir ho have purest numenorean blood have raight to bi king of Gondor so umbar gondor wars are civil wars for the throne

    • @hiswayservicesblog9288
      @hiswayservicesblog9288 3 роки тому

      "Remember who you are."

  • @Sh0ckmaster
    @Sh0ckmaster 3 роки тому +1

    The art from 3:11 to 4:03 is tiptop stuff. New wallpapers for my PC I think :)

  • @funnyhappyharry746
    @funnyhappyharry746 3 роки тому

    So this is going to be a tad odd, but- that being said if you read this, there is a Minecraft server out there called Ardacraft. It’s a none profit project aiming to rebuild middle earth at 1/3rd scale I believe? It’s book and lore accurate, not based on the movies. Currently they have gotten as far as Rohan- but I think it would be a great server to check out for visual content for your videos. If you want to get in contact with the owner of the project I do know him. I am currently not apart of this project, I used to be. But I think you’d very much enjoy it. It’s one of the largest Minecraft projects ever undertaken. It is pure respect to Tolkien and his dream for middle earth.

  • @melkhiordarkfell4354
    @melkhiordarkfell4354 2 місяці тому

    My headcanon is since Curufins knife was also made by Telcar, Narsil was actually Curufins sword, taken from him by Beren, when he took Angrist. Beren taking it on his quest and it being kept in Doriath after Berens death. Also nicely links Beren and Luthien to Aragorn and Arwen.

  • @Sam-kn2mm
    @Sam-kn2mm 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you making this VIDEO!!!!!!!!!!

  • @GarretGarlinger
    @GarretGarlinger 3 роки тому

    Awesome Video! As always!

  • @DucktorZom
    @DucktorZom 3 роки тому

    I wonder what the eight people who disliked this video were watching... this is probably the best video on UA-cam about a sword!

  • @georgemercer402
    @georgemercer402 Рік тому

    Guthwine, Anduril and Glamdring combining forces with (I wish) Durin's axe was an awesome time for the free peoples of Middle-Earth; I love seeing that happen whenever I watch the movies.

  • @brianmessemer2973
    @brianmessemer2973 3 роки тому +2

    10:25 "The sword shall be made whole, and the bicep made swole." 💪😎

    • @Mark723
      @Mark723 3 роки тому

      I know, right - that's some gun has our Yoystan has!

  • @Arthog627
    @Arthog627 3 роки тому +1

    Another great video. Ever consider doing an audio book of THE LOTR series? Haha

    • @Mark723
      @Mark723 3 роки тому

      Truth queried as jest. I know many hours of research go into each video; nonetheless, even with all the amazing facts and quotes, wonderful artwork and excellent editing, it’s your observational comments at the end of each tale which show your greatest talent. That, and again, your captivating diction, which I liken to Sir Peter Ustinov, making listening to each and every video a pure delight. Would these well-written and well-crafted videos be as brilliant if read by a mere mortal? Methinks not.

  • @josephgraney1928
    @josephgraney1928 3 роки тому +2

    I think it needs to be discussed that Beren, during his time as a bandit, wounded Sauron himself in the hand, as is told in the Silmarillion. I would think it quite likely that the blade used was Narsil; objects in Tolkien's writings have animus towards the enemies against whom they were forged (the barrow-blades being another example) and Sauron would have had all the more reason to fear the blade which had twice injured his hands.

  • @aethewulf4787
    @aethewulf4787 3 роки тому +1

    Hello would you ever consider doing video about eastern/southern lands? cheers!

  • @SekuACDC
    @SekuACDC 3 роки тому

    Great video, as always! Yesterday I rewatched The Fellowship of the Ring and a question came to my mind: during the escape from Moria Gandalf tells Aragorn that "swords are no more use here", but considering the properties and the history of Andúril, do you think that Aragorn would have been able to injure Durin's Bane?

  • @mangaxrisk669
    @mangaxrisk669 2 роки тому

    I would love some more videos about the metaphysical/Jungian representation of items and analysis of characters in lord of the rings.
    To me Narsil in Aragorns journey represents reclaiming ones generational trauma in order to embody the archetype of the king, but I would like to hear others interpretations more familiar with Tolkien's work.
    Also why the sun and the moon representation for example? Often in cultures these represent union of masculine and feminine in creating wholeness.
    Just some ideas. Cheers

  • @AdventuringJD
    @AdventuringJD 3 роки тому +1

    My memory is fuzzy... Did Aragorn do amything in/for the lands of Armor after the war of the ring? If he does, that would be an awesome video I would love to see! Good luck house hunting!

  • @hughgedney3393
    @hughgedney3393 3 роки тому

    A very extremely great video as always Men of the West.

  • @wrathandflame3987
    @wrathandflame3987 3 роки тому +1

    My theory is that Narsil was a specially forged sword for Maedhros after his rescue from Angband. We know that the knife Angrist was forged by the same person and Maedhros's brother Curufin carried it until Beren took it from him so perhaps the two weapons were crafted together after being commissioned by the Fëanorians who had ties with the Dwarves. Maedhros now had only one hand so he needed a lighter weapon to fight with but still big enough to fit his extreme hight. We know that Anduril was a big sword even for a tall man like Aragorn but light enough for him to carry with two hands so I guess it makes sense. So regarding the means by which the sword passed on to the line of Elendil I believe it all goes back to the time when Maedhros and Maglor took in Elrond and Elros after capturing them during the third kinslaying. The two of them I have to believe were trained by Maedhros in combat and perhaps Elros showed great promise in that regard so after the War of Wrath Maedhros gifted him the sword to carry in battle and keep safe. After that Elros passed it down to his descendants in Numenor and eventually to Aragorn who we know is related to him:)
    P.S. We know that Maedhros suffered at the hands of Sauron in Angband so it would be a fitting late revenge for his sword to be the one to cut Sauron's finger
    P.S.2 The name fits perfectly aswell. Narsil "Red and White Flame". What if red symbolised Fëanor's spirit of fire who Maedhros inherited and white the light of the Silmarils (I don't know just dropping random ideas)

  • @MrBLomBOa
    @MrBLomBOa 3 роки тому +2

    Can you do a Video about „what if Gandalf realized Bilbo had the One Ring before it was passed to Frodo“?

  • @RobertOrtiz1015
    @RobertOrtiz1015 3 роки тому

    Kinda like the movies twist on the matter of the sword! Brought a dramatic effect ! I still remember my reactionWhen he was given in the movie

  • @johnwoyurka5373
    @johnwoyurka5373 3 роки тому +1

    Tom Bombadil is one of your patrons, that's awesome. Lol where's Goldberry?

  • @christosvoskresye
    @christosvoskresye 3 роки тому

    @9:17 Hence the song "Sauron of the Nine Fingers and the Ring of Doom."

  • @jodiepalmer2404
    @jodiepalmer2404 3 роки тому +2

    I would like to think that Andruil was actually Meadhros Feanorian Sword which he gave to Elros as a gift when Elrond and Elros was given to Gil Galad. Telchar (Dwarven Smith) made the sword for Meadhros because I think Meadhros and his brothers helped kept Morgorth and his army at bay from the Dwarven Kingdoms.

    • @aurelian2668
      @aurelian2668 3 роки тому

      Actually Elros's blade comes from thingol himself which was passed down by his parents. The name in english or common is kings wrath? Im not sure though i am sure it was thingols blade which Elros half-elven wields.

  • @davidhenneberg2661
    @davidhenneberg2661 3 роки тому +3

    Hello from Chicago suburbs

  • @taywaz123
    @taywaz123 3 роки тому +2

    Definitely my favorite sword. I would only bow to a king with this sword

  • @BlairScouten
    @BlairScouten 3 роки тому +1

    This excellent video is best viewed on a giant 65” TV with Glamdring & Anduril hanging on the wall on either side! 😎
    Great work as always Yoystan! 👍🏼

  • @me7094
    @me7094 3 роки тому

    Ok I’m not the best of UA-cam and don’t know how to msg you. But you seem like one of the more versed people’s of the lotr universe I am an off the grid leather worker and blacksmith I always want to do a lotr build and rangers of the north is my first pick but I can’t find any information on the gear and kit they would carry including clothing I can find pics from the movies but the pics are not clear of Aragorn and was wondering if you had pics or sources I could find what they would generally have in tow on their journeys. Much thanks if you read this and find it appropriate to be posted on here.hail and well met

  • @Michaelkayslay
    @Michaelkayslay 3 роки тому +1

    Aragorn walking around without a shealth for his sword? That is dangerous!

  • @TheDeadlyKnight
    @TheDeadlyKnight 3 роки тому

    I have theory about how it was that such a well-bred heirloom weapon like Narsil broke in the fateful final combat of Last Alliance. The explanation is actually simple in all likelihood. Once Gil-galad and Elendil managed to pierce Sauron however many times they managed to in order to mortally wound his physical form, the two legendary weapons - Aiglos and Narsil were doomed. It seemed to be one of the features of the binding magic Sauron imbued in his rings of power; dissolution of weapons that strike Ring- wearers; perhaps a type of ruin-spell such as durin’s bane used or the one that was on the gate-ram Grond. There are several examples of such in instances involving the Nazgul when weapons were wielded at them.

  • @shanenolan8252
    @shanenolan8252 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks early release

  • @jazeroth322
    @jazeroth322 3 роки тому

    Seen this sword in games workshop hq in Nottingham. It is a really impressive sword.

  • @manbearpig5907
    @manbearpig5907 2 роки тому +1

    An elegant weapon,
    from a more civilized time.

  • @HeartlessRandomguy
    @HeartlessRandomguy 2 роки тому

    Cop: May I see your license sir? Aragorn: How about a broken sword?

  • @futuresonex
    @futuresonex 2 роки тому +1

    One of the things in the books that I thought was pretty ridiculous was when Aragorn was carrying the sword while it was still the 'Shards of Narsil'. It always seemed rather stupid to me that a ranger would carry a broken sword into the wild where he may and in fact did have to face combat. That's one thing that the movies did better, in my opinion. They gave Aragorn, or Strider as he was known at that time, a different, unbroken, and useful sword to carry until the Shards of Narsil were reforged into Anduril...and then they went and changed how, when, and where it was given back to him. There was no need for that change.
    On a side note, the method of reforging the sword that was shown in the movie would not work...at all...not even a little. If they reforged the sword like that it would break the very first time he used it! To reforge a broken sword using the same steel as the original it would first have to be broken into much smaller pieces. The small pieces would be stacked and forge-welded into a solid billet which could then be drawn out into a blade in much the same way that pattern-welded 'Damascus' steel blades are still made today.
    BTW, does it seem strange to anyone else that technology in Middle Earth didn't advance at all in thousands of years? I mean Frodo, Bilbo, Thorin, & Gandalf are all using swords that are well over 5,000 years old, and they're not only still useful, but they're as good or better than anything else that could be made in Middle Earth at the end of the Third Age!

  • @rick9977015
    @rick9977015 3 роки тому

    Wen they released the Lord of the Rings on blu-ray there was a limited edition package that included Anduril as a letter opener. Still have mine in the box.

  • @mikecobalt7005
    @mikecobalt7005 Рік тому

    Great Video

  • @danielhall6578
    @danielhall6578 3 роки тому

    This man should talk to the head mod of divide and conquer, and partner up for some lore video

  • @gideonhorwitz9434
    @gideonhorwitz9434 3 роки тому +1

    I have a topic for a new video. At the end of the wars with Angmar why did Gondor leave their sister kingdom and kinsmen to ruin and division . Why didn’t The house of Anárion (Gondor) and their armies stay in Eriador for a period instead to reunite and rebuild Arnor to ensure stability in the north and a ally in the wars to come or at least grant their kinsmen of the House of Elendil sanctuary in Gondor rather than leaving them in exile as impoverished rangers in the wild.

  • @huanhoundofthevailinor2374
    @huanhoundofthevailinor2374 3 роки тому +1

    Love the swords of Arda I always wanted húr sword

  • @friccle_
    @friccle_ Рік тому

    I like thinking the broken shape of Narsil also sorta inspired the idea of Acharn from SoW, but the roles are reversed, being a sons sword broken and taken by the father

  • @pittland44
    @pittland44 3 роки тому

    I have heard a couple of theories about how the sword came to Numenor. The first is that Telchar (or the Lord of Nogrod) gave the sword to the Feanorians (specifically Maedhros or Maglor as payment for rescuing him when he was cornered by orcs) and they passed the sword on to Elros when he was young, as a gift and for penance. The other theory I have heard is the sword passed from the Telchar and the dwarves of Nogrod to Finrod, when the dwarves of the Ered Luin helped him carve Nargothrond, and because of their great friendship with him the sword was passed on as a gift. It's possible then that the sword passed from Finrod to Beren when Beren came to Nargothrond seeking help, and as Beren had no weapons Finrod would have armed him and thus the sword passed to Beren and then on to men.

  • @stevedenis8292
    @stevedenis8292 3 роки тому +3

    Narsil has suffered a catastrophic failure please surrender you blade and leave the forge. It will not keel but it will cut. Before you Elvin smiths is the broken blade of Narsil you must forge it back into a new blade the parameters are the following It must be between 4 and 5 feet in length a full tang and pommel with elvish script on its blade and finally it should glow blue when orcs are near. Your 3 ages begin now. p.s. nice ink

    • @ashleyaltice540
      @ashleyaltice540 3 роки тому +1

      I'm waiting for Forged in Fire to do that very episode. They've already done Game of Thrones. Here's fingers crossed.

  • @willemvanstaden3292
    @willemvanstaden3292 3 роки тому

    Man, I wish I could get my hands on an actual battle-ready and sharpened/tempered Glamdring and Anduril... But in South Africa, there are very few talented smiths, and the price of these swords would be astonishing...

  • @ChiaraSiasat
    @ChiaraSiasat 3 роки тому +1

    The one thing that bothers me about the movie version is the fact that Aragorn is given “Anduril” by Elrond before leaving for the Paths of the Dead and not like it was written in the book for the fact that he had the sword just before the Fellowship left for Mordor.

  • @DD-fj2ut
    @DD-fj2ut 3 роки тому

    In the movie they basically ignor Anduril, though once reforged it is a magic sword, blue flames rippled up the blade, and it could go through orcs like butter. But the movie gives no input on this sword and it’s important role in Aragorn being a master swordsman.

  • @garmisra7841
    @garmisra7841 3 роки тому

    In all of the Hildebrandt illustrations Aragorn looks like he should be in Foghat or something...that stache!!!

  • @elenapascucci1997
    @elenapascucci1997 3 роки тому

    I was wondering if you could make a video about what’s the meaning of the hand sign Legolas and Thranduil make at the end of the Hobbit battle of the five armies

  • @championsgaming1
    @championsgaming1 2 роки тому

    Im going to be getting anduril as part of a tattoo design soon.

  • @Jessica-dx7ki
    @Jessica-dx7ki 3 роки тому +1

    The one dislike is Sauron, who is bitter that you made a video about the demise of his finger.

    • @kieranh2005
      @kieranh2005 3 роки тому +1

      Looks like a few of the ringwraiths have chipped in too. Not the mouth of Sauron though. He would have left a salty comment.

    • @Jessica-dx7ki
      @Jessica-dx7ki 3 роки тому

      @@kieranh2005 hahaha omg yes

  • @NovaaGrind
    @NovaaGrind 3 роки тому +1

    Make a what if video about isuldur destroying the ring and what becomes of middle earth there after. A new war of men, elves and dwarves???

    • @Mark723
      @Mark723 3 роки тому

      Excellent! Such a what-if need not be a thin book indeed...

  • @Nelotepes108
    @Nelotepes108 3 роки тому +1

    Narsil shall forever be one of the most powerful of all swords in history

  • @chefitaly7339
    @chefitaly7339 3 роки тому +4

    Hell yeah

  • @Longshanks1690
    @Longshanks1690 3 роки тому +9

    Can you imagine if they had went to try and reforge it and they found some pieces missing if they had gotten knocked behind a rock or something? 😂
    Honestly kudos to Sauron for breaking it in a manner that there were only a few fractured pieces and none of those tiny annoying ones like when something glass breaks so it can’t be put back together lol.

    • @IvorMektin1701
      @IvorMektin1701 3 роки тому

      @@Thomas.Wright
      Here's a link attempt:
      ua-cam.com/video/TEktwaAsv_Y/v-deo.html

    • @brovold72
      @brovold72 3 роки тому

      @@Thomas.Wright But what if the "you" in question are Noldor?

    • @IvorMektin1701
      @IvorMektin1701 3 роки тому

      @@Thomas.Wright
      UA-cam is a capricious foe!

    • @brovold72
      @brovold72 3 роки тому

      @@Thomas.Wright Yes but does that apply to a Dwarvish blade of Beleriand? Or an Elvish blade of Gondolin? How did Galadriel and her maidens weave the cloaks? Same dif.

    • @brovold72
      @brovold72 3 роки тому

      @@Thomas.Wright Though it is interesting, on its own. Does not tell us much about what the Elvish smiths did in Rivendell, however.

  • @barrylucas8679
    @barrylucas8679 3 роки тому

    I like to imagine strider drawing the broken sword and out dueling thieves and orks with it alone.

  • @davesmith4839
    @davesmith4839 3 роки тому +1

    So Trolls are Melkor/Morgoth’s perversion of the Ents created by Eru? The Dragons were Morgoth’s perversion of the great eagles, Orcs obviously are supposed to represent Elves that Morgoth perverted with evil thoughts, and without the ability to ever feel any true good feeling, like happiness, and love for friends and family. So what were the fell beasts then? Just like regular eagles, instead of the Great Eagles of Manwe? Can someone shed some light on this for me?

  • @adrian_veidt
    @adrian_veidt 3 роки тому +1

    the sword was also my fave weapon in the legendarium.
    Till I found out Tulkas' fists lmao

  • @hudsonball4702
    @hudsonball4702 3 роки тому +4

    Early today. not that i'm complaining :)

  • @massivedynamic2339
    @massivedynamic2339 3 роки тому +2

    Nice

  • @stimpsonjcat67
    @stimpsonjcat67 3 роки тому +1

    I must admit taking some issue with the images typically associated with the re-forging of Narsil. As a blacksmith/bladesmith...it simply wouldn't have been does as 99% of the imagery depicts it. The shards and the remaining blade would have been separated from any hilt and guard appurtenances and the larger pieces would have been heated and folded back into a size where the smaller pieces could then be forge-welded back into the overall billet. Then worked back into a blade form.
    I am willing to accept that Elven smiths would have been capable of shielding spells to prevent scale, so we can allow for no loss of material in the shaping...so no donor material needed adding. But no smith worth working such a thing would accept a simple scarf joint of all those pieces...even if it could be done.
    It was a shame to see it in the film. Hollywood seems bent on depicting this process incorrectly...this...the poured swords of Conan and GoT...it never ends.
    Forge welding metal is indeed magical. But not like hollywood shows it. It's harder, like anything important.

    • @stimpsonjcat67
      @stimpsonjcat67 3 роки тому

      @@Thomas.Wright That was a bit drmatic for my tastes, but yeah, they did it right.

  • @Longshanks1690
    @Longshanks1690 3 роки тому +8

    Isildur: 🤚 > 🗡
    Sauron: 🥾
    Isildur: 👁 👁
    👄

  • @ragnarcrockettsson4058
    @ragnarcrockettsson4058 3 роки тому +4

    Hi Yoystan! How is the house hunting going?

    • @MenoftheWest
      @MenoftheWest  3 роки тому +3

      Good Ragnar, thanks for asking! Hoping to hear back about one particular house soon, so here's to the hope!

    • @ragnarcrockettsson4058
      @ragnarcrockettsson4058 3 роки тому +1

      @@MenoftheWest Great! Glad to hear it

  • @paulwagner688
    @paulwagner688 3 роки тому +1

    Aranruth was in truth the sword of the King of Numenor. However, Narsil must have been a high sword in Elwe's treasury. The King in Numenor also had Tuor's Axe in his treasury. So I suppose that when Simarien married Elatan, her father gave Valandil, first Lord of Andunie, both Narsil and the Ring as token of the kinship between Armenelos and Andunie.