Cool video! Are you going to make more like of these science-based what ifs? It reminds me of the book Seveneves by Neal Stephenson (except, it goes differently in that story...)
Thanks for the kind words Jan! Means a lot coming from you. Yes, we might do some more in the coming months. I'll check out Seveneves, thanks for the recommendation.
Sidenote: The roche limit only applies like this if the moon is closing in on the earth IN ORBIT. If it is propelled towards the earth at a remarkable speed it would still get torn apart but only from our atmosphere. The roche limit is based on tidal forces.
And because the Roche limit is pretty near the surface of the Earth, many of the pieces would end up falling, in turn heating up the atmosphere and scar the surface, melt down the ice caps, acidify the oceans, and turn several continents into large igneous provinces for half a million years or more. Near-complete annihilation of all life would ensue.
also if this is true, im very impressed for a multiple amount of reasons: the quality of the animation. the research that went into it. and, despite what we all expected, the planet wouldnt die. sure many deaths and much destruction, nothing humans couldnt recover from. im very pleased
Thank you. Kurzgesagt videos on the same topic was a great reference for us. Our challenge was to calculate the correct apparent scale and perspective to adapt it to live action footage.
The planet wouldn't die but life certainly would. The moon wouldn't break apart and magically turn to a thin ring. It would impact with the earth and kill everything. OK but say it did magical turn into a ring, well you can expect extreme climate shifts every couple hundred years or so. That may not be a big deal initially but a lack of a moon poses another threat to life and that's ecological systems. A lot of animals depend on tides without them they would die then the animals that depended on them would die and so on. So mass die offs should be expected, if mankind somehow manages to survive that it would be at a reduced number from billions to millions or less. When the extreme climate changes start happening then expect complex life to go extinct. That's not to say life can't evolve and adapt, if does it won't be humans or likely anything you see today. It be like the reset button had been pressed sort of like how the dinosaurs went. In conclusion life would be fucked lol
@@Alex-gn9px well, the earth quakes n tsunamis are gonna do a lot of damage and there would probably be a few giant rocks falling down on Earth (although I dont think that they're gonna cause mass extinction, due to their orbit)
@@TheoCrox They should be very small. Look at the damage done by the small rock (just 10 meters in diameter) in Russia in 2013. If they were rocks of hundreds of meters or a few km, I think we would end up like the dinosaurs. However, between wars and pollution humans will become extinct sooner.
Awesome video! Lovely graphics and I was surprised when I saw the ring at the end, I thought the pieces would just crash into the earth. If I'm being honest, I rate this video 9.5/10
Scientifically it is right thing that will happen if moon comes closer : moon will be destroyed in 18000 km of earth, you worked brilliantly 💙 can't imagined this. Well done and keep this great work up ✌️🇮🇳
It’s beautiful. The taste of my megalophobia kicked in there. Just watching the moon get closer and spin faster just satisfies me. I honestly do not know why.
That would be like our Moonfall video. By observing moons of other planets scientists have enough reason to the believe that moons disintegrate when the go past their Roche limit.
I love the end that the Earth get rings like saturn, i also more like this video than part 1 because part 1 was like the bad ending and this the good ending because the rings would have the Moon's gravity and it would protect us from meteors and part 1 because the moons did not break into pieces and succesfully into Earth and more tips from part 2 that the Moon because of earths atmosphere and orbital gravitational pull the moon broke into pieces and became a ring around the Earth. bravo Incredible video:)
Great graphics there! I don't think the moon would explode dramatically like that into big chunks. Earth's gravity would most likely knead the moon crust and upper mantle like a dough until bits and pieces of semi-molten rocks tear away from the core. Btw, i read that moon's core is actually slushy in nature and is constantly sloshing around below the mantle. And that earth doesn't just revolve around the sun, it actually wobbles around the sun due to the tug of the moon. Last but not least, if you ask me which i'd prefer, a moon or a ring around the earth, i'd vote for a ring.
WOW what a coincidence! My two favourite UA-camrs are you and kurzgesart, AWESOME VIDEO!!! (Although I am wondering: there would probably be some debris close enough to the earth to land and cause chaos)
A lot of the moon debri would reach earth causing major damage. The tides would all but stop and the earth would become unstable on its slightly warped axis. Living on the earth after the demise of the moon would probably be hell. Same thing but without the debri damage once the moon drifts too far from the earth to have any effect.
My brother is really scared after watching this video if I want him to do anything I want I tell him to do it or I'll make an explosion so that it can fall down
If this happened according to this scenario, Earth would not be a fun place to live. If Earth had no moon, our planet would experience significantly different conditions, including drastically altered tides, wildly fluctuating seasons due to an unstable axial tilt, potentially much shorter days, and likely a very different evolution of life on Earth, with stronger winds and more extreme weather patterns due to the lack of the moon's stabilizing gravitational pull; essentially, our planet's climate and ecosystems would be much less stable than they are today.
That sounds cool but it's actually a really big pipeline with several hundred Specialists. I'm more of a Filmmaker who has learnt just enough of every job so I can make my own stuff :)
Cool video! Are you going to make more like of these science-based what ifs? It reminds me of the book Seveneves by Neal Stephenson (except, it goes differently in that story...)
Thanks for the kind words Jan! Means a lot coming from you. Yes, we might do some more in the coming months. I'll check out Seveneves, thanks for the recommendation.
Cool Video!
This is amazing. The music while the moon is being absolutely desecrated is PHENOMENAL. Instantly Subscribed.
I agree, I want the pipe organ music!
Comment for part 3
Me
Me
When will part three come⁉️❓️❔️❕️❗️❗️🧐🧐🧐😐😐😐😐😯😯😲😲😳😳😭😱😱😱💀☠️💀☠️💀
@@LloydSheliverock2025?
Yes
Let’s be honest, the giant ring surrounding earth looked beautiful in the day time and at night
Great job on the video! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Sidenote: The roche limit only applies like this if the moon is closing in on the earth IN ORBIT. If it is propelled towards the earth at a remarkable speed it would still get torn apart but only from our atmosphere. The roche limit is based on tidal forces.
And because the Roche limit is pretty near the surface of the Earth, many of the pieces would end up falling, in turn heating up the atmosphere and scar the surface, melt down the ice caps, acidify the oceans, and turn several continents into large igneous provinces for half a million years or more. Near-complete annihilation of all life would ensue.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
😍😍🤠😡
😊
I want to keep our moon but the ring from earths view looks overwelmingly phantastic! Well done!
Beautiful visuals man!!!!! Done a great job creating those effects.
also if this is true, im very impressed for a multiple amount of reasons:
the quality of the animation. the research that went into it. and, despite what we all expected, the planet wouldnt die. sure many deaths and much destruction, nothing humans couldnt recover from.
im very pleased
Thank you. Kurzgesagt videos on the same topic was a great reference for us. Our challenge was to calculate the correct apparent scale and perspective to adapt it to live action footage.
@@ShutterAuthority i see it went quite qualitative satisfying.
and ye..math is a d1ck..as always
Hahaha
The planet wouldn't die but life certainly would. The moon wouldn't break apart and magically turn to a thin ring. It would impact with the earth and kill everything. OK but say it did magical turn into a ring, well you can expect extreme climate shifts every couple hundred years or so. That may not be a big deal initially but a lack of a moon poses another threat to life and that's ecological systems. A lot of animals depend on tides without them they would die then the animals that depended on them would die and so on. So mass die offs should be expected, if mankind somehow manages to survive that it would be at a reduced number from billions to millions or less. When the extreme climate changes start happening then expect complex life to go extinct. That's not to say life can't evolve and adapt, if does it won't be humans or likely anything you see today. It be like the reset button had been pressed sort of like how the dinosaurs went.
In conclusion life would be fucked lol
Hey are u from India?
bro it has better vfx and comp. than a 100cr movie...🔥
Haha thanks a lot man!
even better than a 500 crore movie😅
Editor needs a pay increase fr😭
Oh I absolutely love it! Amazing seeing you put all this effort into these videos! Great job 👍
Thanks so much!!
@@ShutterAuthority so there wouldn't be an end to every living being on earth?
There's the missing part where some pieces that would be larger than what killed the dinosaurs fall to earth: same scenario in which everyone dies.
@@Alex-gn9px well, the earth quakes n tsunamis are gonna do a lot of damage and there would probably be a few giant rocks falling down on Earth (although I dont think that they're gonna cause mass extinction, due to their orbit)
@@TheoCrox They should be very small. Look at the damage done by the small rock (just 10 meters in diameter) in Russia in 2013. If they were rocks of hundreds of meters or a few km, I think we would end up like the dinosaurs. However, between wars and pollution humans will become extinct sooner.
Awesome video! Lovely graphics and I was surprised when I saw the ring at the end, I thought the pieces would just crash into the earth. If I'm being honest, I rate this video 9.5/10
Thank you for the nice comment! Some of the pieces would surely crash into the Earth causing further destruction.
Just curious, what was the .5 you deducted for? Lol
@@chaz.o well if I had to say, it would be for the graphics looking a tiny bit fake. But thats all lol
True! Really good video i should use the thing to make my video better!
I rate is video 1,000/1,0000000
Earth: Can I copy your assignment?
Saturn: Yes, but change a little bit.
😅
Your vfx better than adipurush🙏🏼
Absolutely Amazing! Excellent job!
Thank you very much!
Just Mind Blowing 😯. Nxt lvl bro iam seriously scarred a lot😓. Expecting more like this🤗
Render cycle or evee bro?
Some shots were eevee, some cycles.
Can. part. 3?
dude this is insane looks really real 🤩❤❤👍
Video came after 3 months
But what a comeback ❤️❤️❤️
Your moonfall video and this video both are amazing 😍😍😍
Thank you! We've been working on a few other videos which is why the delay. There's going to be more frequent videos in 2023 :)
@@ShutterAuthority sounds great 😃😃
ohh that's so cool seeing earth with rings like saturn amazing video
Yeah! It would be beautiful for sure
Not so beautiful when fragments would fall into earth daily, causing a mass extinction anyways
Scientifically it is right thing that will happen if moon comes closer : moon will be destroyed in 18000 km of earth, you worked brilliantly 💙 can't imagined this. Well done and keep this great work up ✌️🇮🇳
It’s beautiful. The taste of my megalophobia kicked in there. Just watching the moon get closer and spin faster just satisfies me. I honestly do not know why.
Awesome work! What would we do without sea tides though?
I love your videos! So fascinating.
Thank you so much!
In which country and city😮
I'm pretty sure the moon would maintain its orb shape, then crash into the Earth, destroying all life. Really cool video though. Great work!
That would be like our Moonfall video. By observing moons of other planets scientists have enough reason to the believe that moons disintegrate when the go past their Roche limit.
@@ShutterAuthority I can't believe I missed your other moon video. Congats on reaching 20 million views on it! That's really cool!
I love the end that the Earth get rings like saturn, i also more like this video than part 1 because part 1 was like the bad ending and this the good ending because the rings would have the Moon's gravity and it would protect us from meteors and part 1 because the moons did not break into pieces and succesfully into Earth and more tips from part 2 that the Moon because of earths atmosphere and orbital gravitational pull the moon broke into pieces and became a ring around the Earth. bravo Incredible video:)
Great graphics there! I don't think the moon would explode dramatically like that into big chunks. Earth's gravity would most likely knead the moon crust and upper mantle like a dough until bits and pieces of semi-molten rocks tear away from the core. Btw, i read that moon's core is actually slushy in nature and is constantly sloshing around below the mantle. And that earth doesn't just revolve around the sun, it actually wobbles around the sun due to the tug of the moon. Last but not least, if you ask me which i'd prefer, a moon or a ring around the earth, i'd vote for a ring.
Без Луны Земля потеряла бы стабильное вращение и климат стал бы непредсказуемым и невыносимым для ныне живущих на планете форм жизни!
You are awesome dude ❤️
Love from Sri Lanka 🇱🇰
props to the camera man for being able to capture this masterpiece 😀😀😀
Best video, my favourite video, I love you this video, my favourite video.
Who missed earth
Me
WHAT THE HELL
Me
Me
Me 😢
The best video in my life❤ Amazing video!
WOW what a coincidence! My two favourite UA-camrs are you and kurzgesart, AWESOME VIDEO!!! (Although I am wondering: there would probably be some debris close enough to the earth to land and cause chaos)
Thank you so much!! Some debris would definitely hit the earth
This was very cool, thank you.
That's crazy but awesome editing
I love the music! And it’s so real! The graphics are amazing! I love earth’s rings in the end! I rate it 100/10
2:05 i thought this video is moon hitting the earth why moon break correct me if I'm wrong
WOW! It reminds me of a star wars movie. I love it!
So much hard work for this I really really appreciate you man❤️👍 keep it up
Thank you so much 😀
I cannot hear moon explode sound
A lot of the moon debri would reach earth causing major damage. The tides would all but stop and the earth would become unstable on its slightly warped axis. Living on the earth after the demise of the moon would probably be hell. Same thing but without the debri damage once the moon drifts too far from the earth to have any effect.
[i edited the comment so new reader dont have any context]
😆
😂 lol
True
Who would do that😑
My brother is really scared after watching this video if I want him to do anything I want I tell him to do it or I'll make an explosion so that it can fall down
This Is one of the best realistic films I have ever watched thank you for the film happy new year!
2:17 orochimaru tone never expected ❤❤
😂😂😂😂😂😂.Oh this Tune Ororchiimaru
I watched the video many times, it's very mysterious, and it's a good theory, like my Tyrannosaurus reviving~
We survived!
We would all die.
Yeah we would but it just made the Earth look like 🪐
Amazing Graphics mate! Really well done.
Love the kurzgesagt easter egg :D (Just thought, didn't they do this already? ^^ )
Haha Glad you caught it :)
Wow what a coincidence!! My favorite two youtubers you and kurzgesart (Awesome video)!!!
Aw thanks!! I
1:35 looks like solar eclipse or a black hole
I like your what if scenario.. well done ✅
Amazing Video
Wonderful
It Was Real .... I Was Living In It....😊...Good keep doing..
Just as like 'Don't Look Up'. Keep it up.
I loved that movie!!
Great! This vid will definetively come in handy ❤
@0:46 I like how this event was next on the feed of the unfortunate UA-cam watcher 😂
😂😂
You Put A Lot Of Effort in This Video❤
2:11 is that orochimaru
Amazing video !! I reaaly wish a Blender tutorial about how to make such volcano !! Stunning !!
It's actually a real photo of a volcano that I've projected onto a simple mesh I modeled and used shape keys to animate the lava.
@Shutter Authority so u made Planet Earth more like planet Saturn Now
Right video.
If this happened according to this scenario, Earth would not be a fun place to live. If Earth had no moon, our planet would experience significantly different conditions, including drastically altered tides, wildly fluctuating seasons due to an unstable axial tilt, potentially much shorter days, and likely a very different evolution of life on Earth, with stronger winds and more extreme weather patterns due to the lack of the moon's stabilizing gravitational pull; essentially, our planet's climate and ecosystems would be much less stable than they are today.
Wow, this is not a short clip, this is a 3 minute video let me grab my popcorn.🍿
2:40 Saturn Cloud Tops Be Like:
So cool
I didn't know there a part 2
The Earth and Asteroid this ring the time 2:54
Wow i really love disastrous videos keep making more
Second!
Brilliant video of of a super natural imagination. Please make another of What if the Mars...
3:00 Earth Rings? bro That Saturn Rings Lol That Earth Rings
The Earth now have Rings but in Real life no
Oh Telescope To Saturn Rings
WOW!!! Wenn das nicht hammergeil ist........Perfekt!!!!!! 😍😍😨😨
1:06 microwave
i dont understand this context a year later
OH
Man, this is wilddddd. Stocking up supplies and a helmet ASAP.
Yes! A few years in a bunker should surely improve your chances of survival 😉
This is not necessarily gr
Bro I am really happy and so proud of you cuz you gave credit to kurzgesagt
Of course! We love kurzgesagt and their video was an inspiration for us.
Is the moon falling into the earth and caused tsunami,high tides,earthquake,volcanoes ,solar eclipse, and roche limit?
I just wanna say
Cool video it's so realistic!
It's so real! This has to be a movie! (love the video)
Boss: "You're still coming to work right??"
Great stuff and the rings was unexpected.
I like so much this video can you do more. And Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year🌕🌎🎄☃️🏆
Thank you!! Wish you the same :)
This was such a great video!
Glad you like it!
Well that ended differently than I expected 👏
Will earth rotate on its axis after the formation of that ring?
What a great video you made a video more better than me i cant do that but i want to do that too show me the toturial great job
marvel should take you as their vfx editor
That sounds cool but it's actually a really big pipeline with several hundred Specialists. I'm more of a Filmmaker who has learnt just enough of every job so I can make my own stuff :)
@@ShutterAuthority 🖤✨ God bless u. there is another joy in the things which are made by own self. I also support your thought.
Great job. Love the story.
That ring around the earth is the most glorious thing I've seen today
dude.... what is it with your freaking animation skills???? :O
Lifehack: be a cameraman then you’ll never die
I sort of anticipated the ring formation by the end, but jeeebuz that gravitational pull in the beginning was scary
AMAZING VIDEO!!! new subcriber
Welcome to my channel!!
Big fan of your work
Good job buddy. It's become looks like a Saturn's ring .
Your videos are so awesome. The siren head ones are some of my favorite videos on this whole platform. Thank you thank you :) !
To your own think is this real?
Great video. I was surprised to see the ring at the end.
a very fine job, it's immediately clear that the person tried a lot of respect for him
Very nice enjoyed watching.
Underrated channel and vid
Firstly it gets so chaotic but if you survive all that. You get to see the beautiful rings
excellent f/x and apparently scientifically likely, including the surprise ending.
Part 2? I knew Earf would survive!