Here`s Mine: S01 - Nightmare S02 - In My Time Of Dying S03 - Mystery Spot S04 - The Monster At The End Of This Book S05 - Swan Song S06 - Appointment In Samarra S07 - Party On, Garth S08 - As Time Goes By S09 - Dog Dean Afternoon S10 - Fan Fiction S11 - Baby S12 - Regarding Dean S13 - Scooby-Natural S14 - Lebanon/Moriah S15 - Drag Me Away From You
Season 1 Favorite: The Benders Best: Faith Season 2 Favorite: Born Under a Bad Sign Best: All Hell Breaks Loose Part 2 Season 3 Favorite: Jus In Bello Best: No Rest for the Wicked Season 4 Favorite: On the Head of a Pin Best: Lazarus Rising Season 5 Favorite: Hammer of the Gods Best: Swan Song Season 6 Favorite/ Best: The French Mistake Season 7 Favorite/Best: Death’s Door Season 8 Favorite: Goodbye Stranger Best: Sacrifice Season 9 ( Has my favorite title card) Favorite: First Born Best: Do You Believe In Miracles? Season 10 Favorite /Best: Fan Fiction Season 11 ( Favorite Season) Favorite: Hell’s Angel Best: Baby Season 12 Favorite: Stuck in the Middle (With You) Best: Regarding Dean Season 13 Best: ScoobyNatural Season 14: Favorite: Mint Condition Best: Lebanon Season 15 I don’t have a clue what’s the best episode or my favorite in this season.
"Dont Call Me Shurley" for me really hits it out of the park over "Baby" in season 11 because the Winchesters actually get to meet God and then Deans Amulet comes into play too and answers questions for us for that season!! That wins hands down as my fav of the season!!!
I know It's been a couple of years so Here's mine Season 1 Faith it brings a lot to the forefront and how Sam & Dean would find away help each Other Season 2 Playthings Dollies are cute but it's creepy that your own grand aunt is haunting you through them Season 3 Malleus Malecarum A fun Episode which brings us a major plot point and it introduces Witches Season 4 It's The Great Pumpkin Sam Winchester This episode alone is major we get his demon blood & Dean's Hell (Bonus we get a PLL Star before she was one) Season 5 Two Minutes Till Midnight it reintroduces Death to us (Since we get the principle in Faith) Here we get to see him (The Horseman) Season 6 Clap your Hands If You Believe Fairies (FINALLY) we get an episode where we see both Fairies & Sam's seductiveness' here Season 7 Out With The Old A very similar plot episode (Bad Day At Black Rock) plus it gives us the height of the Leviathan's Plans (Like my Season 4 fave it also has a PLL Gust Star Teacher's mother) Season 8 As Time Goes By I'd say one of it's finest plus we get to see The Winchester Side of the family and more mystery as well Season 9 Dog Dean Afternoon Leslie Jordan aside we get the infamous Dean vs Pigeon Scene (Classic) along with some good Acting from Ackles Season 10 Paint It Black a Case with somewhat good intentions on the monster's side plus we get to hear some major plots from Olivette (Seen her before?? Nurse, Heart) Season 11 Just My Imagination We get to see a side of Sam that we didn't get to see plus Gabriel's actor directs the Episode Season 12 Ladies Drink Free Glad get to see Claire again plus some cute boys (Sam & Dean aside) and we get to see a cure for Werewolves in this Episode Season 13 Scobbynatural I Agree with you on why this crossover was good and the last good Crossover since Disney's "That So Suite Life Of Hannah Montana" Season 14 Lebanon I also Agree with you plus we see some alternate versions of Cass & Zechariah Season 15 Gimme Shelter a very rare Episode where we have more than a human villain plus Matt Cohen Directs it and we get to see another lose end here (What Happens to the villain after the Crossroad demon gets her?)
My favorite season 1 episode was "Hell House." That was the one that introduced the enthusiastic but clueless Ghostfacers, and it's actually the first time the Winchesters encountered a monster they could not actually kill!
Correction: In season 8, it was *Sam* alone - not Sam and Dean - who had to go through the trials to close the gates of Hell. And it wasn't because of that trial that the angels fell. It was because of Metatron. For me, the best episode of season 7 - as sad as it is - is "Death's Door," because of the exploration of Bobby's past. Don't get me wrong. I hate the fact that Bobby dies. But given the fact that he's one of my favorite characters, I'm glad I learned some things about his past. As far as season 4 is concerned, I think of "The Rapture," as the best episode. My pick for season 9 is "I'm No Angel."
For season 4 I totally agreed on your pick being phenomenal, its the episode I show people when I want them to watch the show. But I always really loved The Rapture. Misha’s performance brings me to tears every time as Jimmy Novak. I just. Ugh. Love it. But Season 4 is so good, they’re all the best lol
Im a feature length film Director ( not to toot the ol’ horn, but) Here’s what I would do to fix all this… Take things back to the basics and work with the strengths of the show. I would make a feature length film that took place after the events of Season 5 as an epilogue. Seasons 1-5 have a specific tone that defined the show. It was scary, it was dark , it was heartwarming and it had STEAKS. There would be no “ End of the world or grand scale scenario”… You can’t outdo the final steaks of season 5, so you tell a personal story. The movie would address a 20 year time gap of Dean living his life with his new family and legitimately being happy, but is repressing his inner darkness regarding Sam’s fate in Hell, meanwhile Sam being trapped in the spirit realm on earth with other nasty ghosts. He was pulled from Hell due to his heroic sacrifice. Both Sam and Dean can’t move on until they accept their Fates. Somehow I want to make this happen one day.
Season 7 is definitely underrated, and one of my favorites. Nice to see someone else that thinks 7 gets a lot of undue hate.
I'm glad you picked Scarecrow for season 1 because that one always stood out to me
Here`s Mine:
S01 - Nightmare
S02 - In My Time Of Dying
S03 - Mystery Spot
S04 - The Monster At The End Of This Book
S05 - Swan Song
S06 - Appointment In Samarra
S07 - Party On, Garth
S08 - As Time Goes By
S09 - Dog Dean Afternoon
S10 - Fan Fiction
S11 - Baby
S12 - Regarding Dean
S13 - Scooby-Natural
S14 - Lebanon/Moriah
S15 - Drag Me Away From You
Season 1
Favorite: The Benders
Best: Faith
Season 2
Favorite: Born Under a Bad Sign
Best: All Hell Breaks Loose Part 2
Season 3
Favorite: Jus In Bello
Best: No Rest for the Wicked
Season 4
Favorite: On the Head of a Pin
Best: Lazarus Rising
Season 5
Favorite: Hammer of the Gods
Best: Swan Song
Season 6
Favorite/ Best: The French Mistake
Season 7
Favorite/Best: Death’s Door
Season 8
Favorite: Goodbye Stranger
Best: Sacrifice
Season 9 ( Has my favorite title card)
Favorite: First Born
Best: Do You Believe In Miracles?
Season 10
Favorite /Best: Fan Fiction
Season 11 ( Favorite Season)
Favorite: Hell’s Angel
Best: Baby
Season 12
Favorite: Stuck in the Middle (With You)
Best: Regarding Dean
Season 13
Best: ScoobyNatural
Season 14:
Favorite: Mint Condition
Best: Lebanon
Season 15
I don’t have a clue what’s the best episode or my favorite in this season.
"Dont Call Me Shurley" for me really hits it out of the park over "Baby" in season 11 because the Winchesters actually get to meet God and then Deans Amulet comes into play too and answers questions for us for that season!! That wins hands down as my fav of the season!!!
I know It's been a couple of years so Here's mine
Season 1 Faith it brings a lot to the forefront and how Sam & Dean would find away help each Other
Season 2 Playthings Dollies are cute but it's creepy that your own grand aunt is haunting you through them
Season 3 Malleus Malecarum A fun Episode which brings us a major plot point and it introduces Witches
Season 4 It's The Great Pumpkin Sam Winchester This episode alone is major we get his demon blood & Dean's Hell (Bonus we get a PLL Star before she was one)
Season 5 Two Minutes Till Midnight it reintroduces Death to us (Since we get the principle in Faith) Here we get to see him (The Horseman)
Season 6 Clap your Hands If You Believe Fairies (FINALLY) we get an episode where we see both Fairies & Sam's seductiveness' here
Season 7 Out With The Old A very similar plot episode (Bad Day At Black Rock) plus it gives us the height of the Leviathan's Plans (Like my Season 4 fave it also has a PLL Gust Star Teacher's mother)
Season 8 As Time Goes By I'd say one of it's finest plus we get to see The Winchester Side of the family and more mystery as well
Season 9 Dog Dean Afternoon Leslie Jordan aside we get the infamous Dean vs Pigeon Scene (Classic) along with some good Acting from Ackles
Season 10 Paint It Black a Case with somewhat good intentions on the monster's side plus we get to hear some major plots from Olivette (Seen her before?? Nurse, Heart)
Season 11 Just My Imagination We get to see a side of Sam that we didn't get to see plus Gabriel's actor directs the Episode
Season 12 Ladies Drink Free Glad get to see Claire again plus some cute boys (Sam & Dean aside) and we get to see a cure for Werewolves in this Episode
Season 13 Scobbynatural I Agree with you on why this crossover was good and the last good Crossover since Disney's "That So Suite Life Of Hannah Montana"
Season 14 Lebanon I also Agree with you plus we see some alternate versions of Cass & Zechariah
Season 15 Gimme Shelter a very rare Episode where we have more than a human villain plus Matt Cohen Directs it and we get to see another lose end here (What Happens to the villain after the Crossroad demon gets her?)
My favorite season 1 episode was "Hell House." That was the one that introduced the enthusiastic but clueless Ghostfacers, and it's actually the first time the Winchesters encountered a monster they could not actually kill!
Correction: In season 8, it was *Sam* alone - not Sam and Dean - who had to go through the trials to close the gates of Hell. And it wasn't because of that trial that the angels fell. It was because of Metatron.
For me, the best episode of season 7 - as sad as it is - is "Death's Door," because of the exploration of Bobby's past. Don't get me wrong. I hate the fact that Bobby dies. But given the fact that he's one of my favorite characters, I'm glad I learned some things about his past.
As far as season 4 is concerned, I think of "The Rapture," as the best episode.
My pick for season 9 is "I'm No Angel."
I don't agree with your feelings on Season 10, but I do really like this list. Happened to come back to the fandom after everything exploded 😂
I am also not really a big fan of season 11 but Baby is such an incredible episode.
For season 4 I totally agreed on your pick being phenomenal, its the episode I show people when I want them to watch the show. But I always really loved The Rapture. Misha’s performance brings me to tears every time as Jimmy Novak. I just. Ugh. Love it. But Season 4 is so good, they’re all the best lol
Faith is definitely the best in Season 1 in my opinion.
I liked the phantom traveler
@@praesidium4278 Decent episode. Love it on first watch.
I feel like I'm the only person who preffers the monster of the week episodes
This show came out when I was born...now it’s 15 years later and I can’t believe it
Imagine if Eric Kripke had done 15 seasons of Supernatural. It would have been the greatest TV show of all time
Excellent picks! Not perhaps always the ones I would have chosen, but then again there are so many good episodes to pick between :-)
Ok. But you picked almost only scenes about Dean, you talk only about Dean. It's like Sam wasn't part of the show.
I would Pick Swan Song for S5 and Dont call me shurley for S11
I agree w/ your S7 & S8 choice.
Faith is one of the best episode.. feels so real.
Loved that one as well. A lot of the ones from the early seasons are top tier classic episodes
@@AlexMadden yes.. the crazy part is that I stopped watching the season after 11.
Maybe I might watch again/ not sure.
The best episode of all was the season 5 finale.
Could you also do the worst episodes?
It would probably be all season 10 episodes since I hate most of that season
@@AlexMadden. Season 1’s worse would be Bugs
Im a feature length film Director ( not to toot the ol’ horn, but) Here’s what I would do to fix all this… Take things back to the basics and work with the strengths of the show.
I would make a feature length film that took place after the events of Season 5 as an epilogue. Seasons 1-5 have a specific tone that defined the show. It was scary, it was dark , it was heartwarming and it had STEAKS.
There would be no “ End of the world or grand scale scenario”… You can’t outdo the final steaks of season 5, so you tell a personal story.
The movie would address a 20 year time gap of Dean living his life with his new family and legitimately being happy, but is repressing his inner darkness regarding Sam’s fate in Hell, meanwhile Sam being trapped in the spirit realm on earth with other nasty ghosts. He was pulled from Hell due to his heroic sacrifice. Both Sam and Dean can’t move on until they accept their Fates.
Somehow I want to make this happen one day.