So good by Lucas to have Padme say, "There's good in him" while baby Luke is there in Obi-Wan's arms. Such a great moment. The only thoughts and feelings Luke carries on from his mother are that there is still good in Vader. Perfect storytelling by Lucas.
Yes! That would’ve shaken me as Obi-Wan, hearing the exact words that Luke’s mother had spoken all those years ago. I like to think that Luke unknowingly does this again when he tells Vader “Come with me,” on Endor, since Padme said those exact words to Anakin when pleading for him to leave everything and go with her. Vader responds to Luke by saying Obi-Wan once thought as he did, but I wonder if this was partly an attempt to block out the memory of that moment when Padme had asked the same thing of him. It’s also interesting that when Luke states that Vader will be forced to kill him, Vader’s response is far more hesitant, as if remembering Padme’s fate. When Luke persists in appealing to the good in his father, Anakin’s spirit seemingly breaks through for a moment and admits his own despair, that it is too late to turn back. In his mind, he cannot go with Luke even if he wanted to, he can see no way out. Yet in admitting this, we all catch a glimpse of what Luke and Padme believed: “There is still good in him.”
_Emotion, yet peace._ _Ignorance, yet knowledge._ _Passion, yet serenity._ _Chaos, yet harmony._ _Death, yet the Force_ _Remember this._ _Although he may be leaving,_ _The force will be with us,_ _Always._
*_"Amazing. Every word of what you just said was wrong. The Rebellion is reborn today. The war is just beginning. And I will not be the last Jedi."_* *_- Luke Skywalker_*
I almost cried in the theaters when Luke saw the two suns and you had the same force theme playing, it was like a kick to the gut, and brought out much more emotion than Han’s death
That line has nothing to do with The Last Jedi. The line is about how Luke rushes of to face Vader, because he thinks hes ready because he isn't afraid, when really, like Yoda says in Return of the Jedi, Luke wasn't ready, and that's why he wasn't prepared when Vader revealed the truth to him in Cloud City. I tried my best to explain it.
Crying my eyes out as I'm writing this. Luke is a character that we all grew up with, that we identify with. To see his life put beautifully together in this video you've made, has been very emotional for me.
Lemuel Rosario Luke is my all-time favorite character and my childhood hero. His hope against all hope that there was still good in Vader... I mean how could you make a better character than an orphan boy who finds out his father is the most evil man in the galaxy, yet is convinced he can save him from himself. Just an absolutely incredible story.
Lemuel Rosario he killed millions of people with families. Obi wan made false situations to persuade Luke into killing millions. He killed hdhajpa jwkamns Seoul o one me dbutbt
you really get to see luke grow up from a child to a warrior, even facing the darkside, losing himself in it, then overcoming it. what a great character
Robb Stark Running like a coward to let his entire group of friends and the last surviving members of his family be murderd is not exactly a great end to a character who was previously set up to not be like that.
An absolute masterpiece. Luke always has be and always will be my favorite character and you captured his story and essence in a beautiful way. I didn't think I could be any more excited to see Luke again in The Last Jedi... but now I am. Well done.
Your comments are always much appreciated man. Thank you so much, I'm glad you're more excited now. I sure as hell was when I finished the video. May the Force be with you my friend : )
As a stupidly die hard fan of Luke, I think he had a great story progression in TLJ and a compelling arc. The end when he stared out at Ak-tu's sky, with twin suns like that of Tatooine, the binary Sunset theme that started him on his journey accompanying him at his end, was especially beautiful.
What we saw in the Mandalorian was Grandmaster Luke skywalker, what we saw in the TLJ was Jake skywalker(I didn't say it, It was Mark Hamill himself who called Jake skywalker)
@@saravanankannan7009 yep, they so need to write it off as a clone from a failed experiment using old clone wars tech or something similar....the real Luke can be off in hiding training Grogu.
This was moving beyond words. Having seen The Last Jedi, my heart is broken. This was a wonderful piece that really encapsulates the true heart of the character and why he has meant so much to so many for so long.
You need to watch greatest teacher failure is. It explains why Luke did what he did. Or star wars was never meant for you. And just move on with your life. Take up knitting or something.
@origamiChef So the son of anakin skywalker has no potential of dark side whatsoever? And when he attacked him in episode 6 he taped into that same dark side...hmm yeah your right though it ruined his character.
@@stephanies6740 So Star wars was never meant for me because I don't like what a company and a director who has no ties to the original is pulling out of nothing and pretending it's deep or meaningful when all that is really going on is they're tearing down the original heroes to try to make there very boring ones look better? It's not complicated inf act it's an idiot plot and it's not deep and it never had to make everyone from the originals complete useless failures. Saying Star Wars was never meant for some one because they don't like the whats happening l know is elitist and disgusting
"Pass on what you have learned." Yoda- Return if the Jedi That line now has a whole new meaning because of the last Jedi. Luke (and us, the audience) thought that it simply meant to teach a new generation the ways of the Jedi. So he did.... But it failed. He as a person changed because of the weight of the responsibility that was put on his shoulders. He was so overwhelmed by this, that he became as paranoid as the Jedi in the prequels. No matter how pure hearted someone is, that would easily alter them as a person. So, he ended up making the same mistake that the Jedi have always made. He was so afraid of the dark side returning, that he unintentionally created the dark side itself. So when he realized this was not only his mistake, but the mistake of the Jedi as a whole, he wrongfully thought that it would be best if the Jedi simply ceased to exist. And disappeared to die alone, as the last Jedi. This is the same destructive mentality that is driving Kylo Ren further and further from reality. They're both so caught up in the old ways dying, that they can't see the mistakes that they're making in the present. ("Always looking off into the horizon. Never focusing on where he was. What he was doing.") So when Yoda confronts Luke for the final time in TLJ, he reinforces what he had told him before, and also clarifies what it meant. He tells him that he's still too caught up in what will happen, that he can't see what's right in front of him. (In front of your nose.) And that he still must do what he instructed him to do all those years ago. To pass on what he has learned. Both the ways of the Jedi.... and their mistakes. Or else this endless cycle of conflict will continue for eternity. "Pass on what you have learned." This one line is now probably the most important line in the star wars saga. It links all three trilogies together, and gives each one a purpose, and a reason to exist. (Even phantom menace) People say that the sequel trilogy has no reason to exist, but I have to disagree. If it was simply the original trilogy and the sequel trilogy, and the prequels never existed, then they would be right. But in reality, if you include the prequel trilogy, Return if the Jedi is not a satisfying ending. Sure, it may resolve the core plot of the conflict between a father and his son, and the rise and fall of an evil empire, but thematically, it doesn't solve the third major piece of the story which the prequels created: That the Jedi are flawed, and are a major reason why the dark side always returns. If you watch the movies chronologically (which is what George Lucas intended) the first trilogy (the prequels) introduces all of these themes, which are not resolved, and then the second act (the original trilogy) doesn't even touch on them. If that were the ending, then nothing would be resolved. The audience is just left thinking that Luke will pass on the ways of the Jedi, and the constant cycle of good versus evil will continue. But the sequel trilogy is now finally addressing that. I recommend any star wars fan to watch the entire saga chronologically from episode 1 to episode 8 (then 9 when it's released) sure it cheapens the Vader reveal, and a few other things, but overall it gives a better sense of what the full picture really is. I admit that The Last Jedi is a very flawed movie, but I don't think that means that it's bad. On its own, I consider it pretty good to average, but alongside the entire rest of the series, I strongly believe that this is a great movie. But that's just my stance on it. You don't have to agree. If you've somehow managed to find this and read through all of it, then thank you and I hope that I made a decent point.
What a fantastic analysis my friend. I'm so glad that there's at least a few people that try to think in this light even when knowing how flawed The Last Jedi was. This perspective gives Luke and Ben at least some good depth that may have been easy to miss within the other unnecessary subplots in the movie. As Master Yoda said, "The greatest teacher, failure is." May the Force be with you.
Heroes Fan Productions dang. I didn't think anyone would see this. Thanks man. Love your videos. Can't wait till episode 9 comes out so you have Rey's full story to work with 😉.
I think TLJ was way better than most people realized. I keep hearing charges that it broke the Star Wars lore but I think it was perfectly fitting the grand theme; Hope. Hope was lost when Luke went into hiding, ashamed that for a split second, the murder of his own student that was also the son of his best friend was a tempting idea. Not letting oneself be consumed by fear and anger (aka "the path that leads to the dark side") is everydays work, not a decision you make once and for all.
The Jedi told Luke to kill his father, that there was no other way. Luke proved them wrong, proved the Jedi ways were flawed, and returned his father to the light side despite the Jedi telling him it was impossible. That’s why Luke is *the* master Jedi, not only did he master the ways of the force but he evolved the Jedi for the better- and redeemed one of the most evil beings in the galaxy.
Daddy Skee I remember Obi Wan saying he must face his father, nothing about killing him. Luke killed darth Vader, yet he didn’t kill anakin, who was is true father.
Percival Graves still luke but years later. Abandons whole galaxy for dark side to take dominance and also Kill his best friend and also leave his sister for dead
CALISVN 111 when Luke says he can’t kill his father, Obi Wan says that the empire has already won. If you have brain cells above room temp, it should be easy to decipher that Obi Wan wants him to kill Vader. Admit it, they are flawed
the part that got me was the similarities between when luke and padme were on the floor, giving the perspective of what Anakin was looking at; he failed his wife but he wasn't going to fail his son. I really like that little cut cuz it shows the ring theory from George Lucas. keep up the awesome man !! I'm excited to see what's in store for the future!!!
Exactly. I know it wasn't possible to use flashbacks when the original films came out, but seeing them now brings a real sense of the feelings of the characters.
*_"Amazing. Every word of what you just said was wrong. The Rebellion is reborn today. The war is just beginning. And I will not be the last Jedi."_* *_- Luke Skywalker_*
I can't thank you all enough for enjoying and sharing this tribute. Doing this is my absolute passion and to be recognized by MARK FREAKING HAMILL was just spectacular!!! And it's all because of you, the Star Wars fans. We truly are one of the BEST fandoms/communities out there, and I'm so happy to be a part of it!! May the Force be with you all! Subscribe if you want to stick with me and see what I do next!!
This was amazing from start to finish. But 7:00 onwards was just a whole nother level. You really brought out the conflict within both Luke and Vader, and all the scenes just flowed so well into one another. Really good job yet again mate!
“It’s time for the Jedi to end.” RIP to the grandmaster Jedi legend to the one and only, Luke Skywalker. Thank you for bringing 40 years of Star Wars to life Mark Hamill. May the force be with you, always! 👍❤️😓⭐️
DAMN. I actually cried watching this. The music, the editing, the scenery, it was all PERFECTLY put together. I absolutely love Star Wars. It's my childhood. Since i was 6 years old. And i watched the original trilogy on VHS in my room. Now, i'm 12 years old, and i love it even more because of what it has brought us since Star Wars:Rebels and The force awakens. This, is probably, the BEST, fan made tribute i have ever seen for any franchise. Well done. One more thing, if i could, i would definitely push the golden button.
3 minutes in, i had goosebumps. 5 minutes in, i was tearing up. this is the best star wars video i've ever seen, and i've watched hundreds and hundreds of these.
This was beautiful; as moving as watching all of these great moments for the first time. Given the horrible film that I had to witness last week, It was a nice surprise to see a truly great piece of film making. Bravo to you and Bravo, Mark Hamill.
A great and touching video that strikes the true Star Wars fan right in the heart, and a piece of film I'm sure Mark Hamil himself would perceive so greatly.
"You've failed your highness. I am a jedi, like my father before me." The greatest story ever told is the Skywalker family's. Say what you will about the sequel luke, but he will always be a symbol of hope. We saw this with MANDO szn 2 finale. Luke Skywalker has changed so many lives and nothing will ever take away that..
Train yourself to let go of everything you fear to lose. Awesome video, really brought through the conflicts in Luke and once again Anakin. A great, refreshing narrative of Skywalkers' tragic epic, dude!
That is fracking beautiful. I have always identified with Luke Skywalker since seeing Star Wars' national release in '77 at Tower Mall in Portsmouth, Virginia. So many people hate on Luke, calling him a whiner. Allow me to bring your awareness to something; All of the major characters are whiners. Han, Leia, Chewy, 3PO, even R2. Even when Luke did whine, I always saw it as totally relatable and/or justifiable given his upbringing. But in Return of the Jedi, Luke didn't whine once when all the others still did.
to you three commenters...I felt Luke learnt nothing in his 30 years between SW6 and 7. I might be blind by the Dark Side, but Luke could have ended in a far more powerful and meaningful way.
canmani2 And it's comments like this that show how crazy "some" of you are. There is no way on earth Luke would ever be worse than Jar Jar, so clearly you're just butthurt that you didn't get your OP Luke that kills 2,000 guys.
Amazing video, I’ve watched it a ton of times now. You can see all of the emotion throughout Luke’s journey and at the end when Rey hands him back his and his fathers lightsaber, it’s sad to know after seeing last Jedi that he literally throws it over his shoulder and walks off.
I think the movie would have been 20x better if he simply looked at the lightsaber, shed a tear and dropped it, then carried on the film normally, it would have made alot more sense
"One day soon... young Skywalker will wake up and realize he can no longer go back to his pitiful friends. He will look at himself and see his true face. The face of power. The face of the dark side."
Anakin Skywalker was my favorite character of the prequels. Even though I knew he was to become Darth Vader it wasn't until he actually turned in Episode III that it really hit me. Not to sound corny but it truly broke my heart when he turned. That said the editing of images between Anakin and Darth Vader are true genius. Every time the word "father" is uttered we see cutaways from Anakin to Vader it is making me very emotional. Well done.
I love how you included the deleted scene between Luke and Biggs at the beginning. I’d seen the scene before but never thought much of how it shows Luke’s desire to help others.
THIS is the ideal tribute to Luke!! Every single tribute to him on here is just some poorly edited clips with some pop or metal song. This is perfection!!!
This is so beautiful, it literally brings a tear to my eye, Luke Skywalker is such an underdog, never giving up hope, always hopeful, always a Jedi, may the force be with us ❤️
That sensation of your hairs standing up when watching and hearing those Star Wars scene and voices come to past..it is Heaven..all ties together as the Dynasty of the Skywalker families..remember my Apprentices you are a Skywalker ...
Thank you so much for this! Luke Skywalker is my favourite character in movie history, and this was just incredibly well done, and absolutely moving. Again, truly, thank you!!
Loved the video! It was so well done and unlike most people it has seemingly enhanced by already deep appreciation for Luke’s character and conclusion in TLJ. I hope you find the time to create another video that includes the Last Jedi because now we have seen the end of Luke’s journey. Once again loved the video great work! One aspect about Luke I want to go into is his decision to not face Kylo in person. If you recall in ANH Obi-Wan says the line “you can’t win, but there are always alternatives to fighting”. Yoda also offers the lesson that “a Jedi uses the force for knowledge and defense, never attack”. What’s important is that Luke never learned this lesson and it is one of the things Yoda and Obi repeatedly call him out on. It is his greatest flaw. Consistently throughout the OT, Luke always gives into his first instinct to fight and use his power offensively. Luke brings his weapons into the Dagobah cave and strikes down Vader, he goes to face Vader on Bespin and ignites his saber first, he tries to strike down the Emperor out of fear and hate, he unleashed a furious barrage of offensive strikes when battling Vader until he almost killed him, and he almost struck down Ben Solo in fear of what he would become. This instinct has benefitted Luke at times, but it also symbolized his most vulnerable and weakest moments in his life. It was the source of his constant battle with the temptation toward the dark side. He never utilized the lesson of passiveness taught to him and always gave into his impulsiveness. Luke’s decision to not go and battle Kylo Ren is the moment when Luke learns from his mistakes and uses the teachings Obi and Yoda taught him long ago. By not fighting, Luke is finally able to overcome his fear of the dark side. By not fighting, he achieves a sense of self-purpose and peace he had never felt. By not fighting, he discovers the value that the true ways of the Jedi could have on his soul. Though Luke might have pretended to be a master following ROTJ, he still had much to learn and obstacles to overcome. Now that he had conquered his greatest fear and learned his final lesson from Obi and Yoda, he had no more to learn and no more obstacles in his way. So he fades into the force just like his mentors before him. Joining them not as a student, but as a fellow master. Finally, Luke has become a master of the Jedi.
RIP to the greatest Jedi to ever live. Luke reminds me of me. Curious about the world, wanting to do more. Luke was one of the best. He started with Binary Sunset. And he ended with Binary Sunset. R.I.P man
"Elegant weapon... for a more civilized age." *cuts off someone's arm, leaving blood all over* *CIVILIZED* *shoots someone with a blaster leaving a small wound cauterized by the heat allowing a much cleaner death* *UNCIVILIZED*
@@arcanedreamer1640 I know, but he’s alluding to the Mos Eisley scene when Obi Wan slices that guys arm off and there’s more than enough blood and nothing is cauterized. It’s obviously before Lucas refined how lightsaber wounds would actually occur, with the idea of flesh encountering concentrated intense heat.
I don't care what anyone else might say, but this was an excellent companion to The Chosen One you did, and people don't realize just how close Luke came to going over to the dark side.... I've had many arguments over it with friends who thought Luke was bullet proof and immune to the dark side.
That would destroy his character by doing one of many things that go against the Jedi it makes sense for Vader coz he is sith it would've made even worse fan service than Yoda vs Dooku in the prequels
@@grey3247 The Jedi were never a bunch of pacifists. Obi-wan hacks off a guy's arm in the first movie. There's be nothing out of character about Luke defeating a bunch of first order soldiers. Especially since, you know, they could have always had him do it without killing them. If they really wanted to make him adopt a no-kill policy. Which was never a policy of the original Jedi order, just to be clear.
Luke Skywalker Me too. I barely handled Han's death, then Carrie Fisher's. I don't think I'd make it through if Luke dies. However, if they mention that he died off screen, or by old age, I'm fine with. I just don't want to have to watch it.
Joseph Cambell's Hero's Journey in Luke right here. Thanks for this vid and incredible work on it! I teach about the Hero's Journey at the university by way of Luke Skywalker (who I also included as an illustrative example in my work on veteran transition and paths to wellbeing). I will use this video in future lectures if you don't mind, HFP(?)! Looking forward to seeing more of Luke's journey in the years to come.
By all means man, go ahead and use this for your lectures. Make sure to credit me of course. I hope others can be inspired by Luke's journey as well in this video.
Can I ask why you feel his heroic journey is as impressive as you say? I am curious and enjoy writing characters immensely. I also like to hear differing opinions to my own.
mate i dont belive how do you come with all of this plans it's just amazing and your fans love it i think you have to make pages in facebook and instagram and more to be famous
This is beyond amazing. Honestly, your work is never anything less than spectacular. Absolutely beautiful edit and you are very gifted at what you do. Never stop making these phenomenal videos!!
I love the dichotomy near the end when he’s fighting Vader, the voices of the Emperor and Yoda, giving Luke opposite teachings about the Force. The conflict within him, just like his father had. “Remember, a Jedi’s strength flows from the Force.” Always gave me goosebumps that Yoda strains to tell Luke such a simple fact as he’s about to pass on. The Sith rely on their passion and emotions, the Jedi’s strength flows from the Force itself.
And let me just say, your attention to detail and pacing skills are unrivaled. You have a unique sense of were to put clips, sound, and dialogue in order to make something impactful, and there are some scenes that really made me smile and say "dang that was cool" like when Vader clenched his fist and then it smoothly transitioned to Luke doing the same thing, and stuff like that. Really well done mate!
Thank you my friend for this well thought-out critique. I enjoy doing this so much and it's wonderful to receive some recognition. Completely respect if you like the Chosen One more. That's what this channel is for anyway, to eventually have a wide-selection of tributes to watch and enjoy. Thanks again, and May the Force be With you.
the chosen one is even the coollest character so... good work at all you really deserve more suscribers... i also dont get evrything maybe because i'm german^^
Marvelous tribute! I'm so sad. Seeing this after the Last Jedi... it hurts si much. Never, ever, Luke would have try to kill Ben... Also I would have loved some flashbacks in Luke's mind about the good times with his nephew in Last Jedi. Seeing Ben laugh with him, playing together, having Luke taking his nephew in his arm with Han and Leia when little.... So much could have make people cry and feel with him the sorrow of Luke. Instead we have space cows. .. Continue your beautiful work !
I’ve been watching these movies since I was 8 and Luke was always my favorite character in the whole saga and seeing like Han Solo and leia die was really hard but seeing Luke die was the hardest because he was my childhood hero and now the sky walker series is over and I just wanted to see the old Luke again..
Damn, damn, DAMN!!! That was an amazing compilation video! I got chills and tears! Thanks for taking the time to make such a great reminder of just how awesome SW once was!!!
I ABSOLUTELY ❤️ your work! The music...the masterful way you weave ALL the stories together...it pulls at my heartstrings! Lucasfilm should hire you...SERIOUSLY!👏👍😎
I am so excited that you used Biggs and Luke's conversations from the deleted scenes. You even used other deleted scenes from the original trilogy. It's so cool!!
I cried like a baby. Every cell of my inner child. In dark times, when I doubt it is still alive, Star Wars gives me the undisputable answer. The callbacks, the shots of old Obiwan before young, of young Anakin when Luke redeems Vader, the perfect link between all these wonderful creations, showing how he is the center of it all, and the perfect ending offered by TFA, with Yoda prompting him to pass on what he has learned. Of course, about the very last sentence, there's no way you could have known. Thank you for literally transcending what was already a work of definition and inspiration for part of humanity. Thank you George, thank you Mark, for changing my life.
Here's the link to the newest Ahsoka tribute! - ua-cam.com/video/961qYQGoj4I/v-deo.html
Congrats on Mark Hamill retweeting this man. You're getting really good press
he washed now period on Vilkings now?? what a joke
Mark Hamill is badass...in any context...true Jedi spirit, period
Awww shucks you guuuys .!
Love me some Mark Hamill. He gets us Star Wars fans, but most importantly he gets the real character of Luke Skywalker, and Not the Disney BS!
@Akira Toriyama say sike right now
The Force will be with you Luke. Always.
I love u even tho u not the real Obi Wan
Hello there
The high ground will be with you sir.
Master.
I see you comment on like every tribute video lol
"See you around, kid."
Fucccccc I cry even more but Luke will always be with us 😭😭
So he did pass something on! Han's phrases!
Luke really was the last jedi do u guys think rey is more of a grey jedi
@@dariusnelson8187 At the end probably.
masterpiece
Without Luke, Anakin would never have shown his true self again
Incorrect, vader would find out about leia
luke is the true hero of the saga. always has been, always will be
@@jacobniepoetter8180 but it would make her stay on the dark side of the force. And she would probably kill him.
@@James-xw8li ikr without Luke the galaxy wouldn’t of been saved
To end all of your dreams. If not for Anakin then Luke would never have been borned. Anakin would never be his true self without himself. Checkmate.
So good by Lucas to have Padme say, "There's good in him" while baby Luke is there in Obi-Wan's arms. Such a great moment. The only thoughts and feelings Luke carries on from his mother are that there is still good in Vader. Perfect storytelling by Lucas.
Yes! That would’ve shaken me as Obi-Wan, hearing the exact words that Luke’s mother had spoken all those years ago.
I like to think that Luke unknowingly does this again when he tells Vader “Come with me,” on Endor, since Padme said those exact words to Anakin when pleading for him to leave everything and go with her. Vader responds to Luke by saying Obi-Wan once thought as he did, but I wonder if this was partly an attempt to block out the memory of that moment when Padme had asked the same thing of him.
It’s also interesting that when Luke states that Vader will be forced to kill him, Vader’s response is far more hesitant, as if remembering Padme’s fate. When Luke persists in appealing to the good in his father, Anakin’s spirit seemingly breaks through for a moment and admits his own despair, that it is too late to turn back. In his mind, he cannot go with Luke even if he wanted to, he can see no way out. Yet in admitting this, we all catch a glimpse of what Luke and Padme believed: “There is still good in him.”
He massacred children yet there’s still good in him???
_Emotion, yet peace._
_Ignorance, yet knowledge._
_Passion, yet serenity._
_Chaos, yet harmony._
_Death, yet the Force_
_Remember this._
_Although he may be leaving,_
_The force will be with us,_
_Always._
Max Gareth I see you know much more than the Jedi and sith, but the teachings founded in Ashla and the philosophy of the *the Grey* 😉
Good, now tell me the tree pillars one. And you will achieve you Jedi Battlemaster rank.
Till he isn't
*_"Amazing. Every word of what you just said was wrong. The Rebellion is reborn today. The war is just beginning. And I will not be the last Jedi."_*
*_- Luke Skywalker_*
The last one that tried pedophilia
*“See you around kid.”*
@@Adriano70911 u r random crap
We are the spark that will light the fire that will burn the first order down!
I almost cried in the theaters when Luke saw the two suns and you had the same force theme playing, it was like a kick to the gut, and brought out much more emotion than Han’s death
You are a binary sun. We are a binary sun with our sun. You have a sun in your belly/solar plexus. Let your light shine.
I cried at that moment
It's even more sad after watching Rey look at the same two suns at the end of The Rise of Skywalker!
@@markipliernumber1stan Ah, but have you noticed that Rey is watching the suns rising, not setting? Btw I cried on all those occasions.
Fanfiction.
Luke-"Im not afraid"
Yoda- "You will be".
That line has a whole new meaning after the last jedi.
Yeah man, Yoda makes me feel the world is much bigger than I think I know
That line has nothing to do with The Last Jedi.
The line is about how Luke rushes of to face Vader, because he thinks hes ready because he isn't afraid, when really, like Yoda says in Return of the Jedi, Luke wasn't ready, and that's why he wasn't prepared when Vader revealed the truth to him in Cloud City.
I tried my best to explain it.
Crying my eyes out as I'm writing this. Luke is a character that we all grew up with, that we identify with. To see his life put beautifully together in this video you've made, has been very emotional for me.
Lemuel Rosario Luke is my all-time favorite character and my childhood hero. His hope against all hope that there was still good in Vader... I mean how could you make a better character than an orphan boy who finds out his father is the most evil man in the galaxy, yet is convinced he can save him from himself.
Just an absolutely incredible story.
Lemuel Rosario he killed millions of people with families. Obi wan made false situations to persuade Luke into killing millions. He killed hdhajpa jwkamns Seoul o one me dbutbt
@@salim5394 Wtf are you talking about? Luke never killed millions...
@@cathyskywalker77 he did by trying to kill Kylo though sooooo
@@cathyskywalker77 but no idea what that dudes talkIng about
you really get to see luke grow up from a child to a warrior, even facing the darkside, losing himself in it, then overcoming it. what a great character
Robb Stark
Running like a coward to let his entire group of friends and the last surviving members of his family be murderd is not exactly a great end to a character who was previously set up to not be like that.
An absolute masterpiece. Luke always has be and always will be my favorite character and you captured his story and essence in a beautiful way. I didn't think I could be any more excited to see Luke again in The Last Jedi... but now I am. Well done.
Your comments are always much appreciated man. Thank you so much, I'm glad you're more excited now. I sure as hell was when I finished the video. May the Force be with you my friend : )
Thor Skywalker well right now we know mr mouse fucked Luke Skywalker
I bet you are so disappointed now having seen the disgrace that is The Last Jedi!
As a stupidly die hard fan of Luke, I think he had a great story progression in TLJ and a compelling arc. The end when he stared out at Ak-tu's sky, with twin suns like that of Tatooine, the binary Sunset theme that started him on his journey accompanying him at his end, was especially beautiful.
I like luke but Starkiller has to my favorite cause I grew up playing as him in the force awakens, good times
The force will be with you, always
Obi wan Kenobi l
Hello there Kenobi
Hello there
Obi wan Kenobi heh heh heh
May the force be with you master kenobi
Luke’s story is and will forever be, legendary.
Yes Luke's story is always going to be legendary for us :)
Who's Here After He Returns In The New Mando Episode? I Cried I Was So Emotional...
That was the Luke Rian tried to kill...
What we saw in the Mandalorian was Grandmaster Luke skywalker, what we saw in the TLJ was Jake skywalker(I didn't say it, It was Mark Hamill himself who called Jake skywalker)
@@saravanankannan7009 yep, they so need to write it off as a clone from a failed experiment using old clone wars tech or something similar....the real Luke can be off in hiding training Grogu.
Me too😥💖
@@oopopp Mando luke literally had no character depth
This was moving beyond words. Having seen The Last Jedi, my heart is broken. This was a wonderful piece that really encapsulates the true heart of the character and why he has meant so much to so many for so long.
You need to watch greatest teacher failure is. It explains why Luke did what he did.
Or star wars was never meant for you. And just move on with your life. Take up knitting or something.
@origamiChef So the son of anakin skywalker has no potential of dark side whatsoever? And when he attacked him in episode 6 he taped into that same dark side...hmm yeah your right though it ruined his character.
@@stephanies6740 So Star wars was never meant for me because I don't like what a company and a director who has no ties to the original is pulling out of nothing and pretending it's deep or meaningful when all that is really going on is they're tearing down the original heroes to try to make there very boring ones look better? It's not complicated inf act it's an idiot plot and it's not deep and it never had to make everyone from the originals complete useless failures.
Saying Star Wars was never meant for some one because they don't like the whats happening l know is elitist and disgusting
@@choose3373 Discounting everything he learned and everything he was is what ruined the character.
@@jayshade5730 get over it. Tlj is canon and nothing will change. Wow you are such a baby.
"Pass on what you have learned." Yoda- Return if the Jedi
That line now has a whole new meaning because of the last Jedi.
Luke (and us, the audience) thought that it simply meant to teach a new generation the ways of the Jedi. So he did....
But it failed.
He as a person changed because of the weight of the responsibility that was put on his shoulders. He was so overwhelmed by this, that he became as paranoid as the Jedi in the prequels. No matter how pure hearted someone is, that would easily alter them as a person.
So, he ended up making the same mistake that the Jedi have always made. He was so afraid of the dark side returning, that he unintentionally created the dark side itself.
So when he realized this was not only his mistake, but the mistake of the Jedi as a whole, he wrongfully thought that it would be best if the Jedi simply ceased to exist. And disappeared to die alone, as the last Jedi. This is the same destructive mentality that is driving Kylo Ren further and further from reality. They're both so caught up in the old ways dying, that they can't see the mistakes that they're making in the present. ("Always looking off into the horizon. Never focusing on where he was. What he was doing.")
So when Yoda confronts Luke for the final time in TLJ, he reinforces what he had told him before, and also clarifies what it meant. He tells him that he's still too caught up in what will happen, that he can't see what's right in front of him. (In front of your nose.) And that he still must do what he instructed him to do all those years ago. To pass on what he has learned. Both the ways of the Jedi.... and their mistakes. Or else this endless cycle of conflict will continue for eternity.
"Pass on what you have learned." This one line is now probably the most important line in the star wars saga. It links all three trilogies together, and gives each one a purpose, and a reason to exist. (Even phantom menace)
People say that the sequel trilogy has no reason to exist, but I have to disagree. If it was simply the original trilogy and the sequel trilogy, and the prequels never existed, then they would be right. But in reality, if you include the prequel trilogy, Return if the Jedi is not a satisfying ending. Sure, it may resolve the core plot of the conflict between a father and his son, and the rise and fall of an evil empire, but thematically, it doesn't solve the third major piece of the story which the prequels created:
That the Jedi are flawed, and are a major reason why the dark side always returns. If you watch the movies chronologically (which is what George Lucas intended) the first trilogy (the prequels) introduces all of these themes, which are not resolved, and then the second act (the original trilogy) doesn't even touch on them. If that were the ending, then nothing would be resolved. The audience is just left thinking that Luke will pass on the ways of the Jedi, and the constant cycle of good versus evil will continue. But the sequel trilogy is now finally addressing that.
I recommend any star wars fan to watch the entire saga chronologically from episode 1 to episode 8 (then 9 when it's released) sure it cheapens the Vader reveal, and a few other things, but overall it gives a better sense of what the full picture really is.
I admit that The Last Jedi is a very flawed movie, but I don't think that means that it's bad. On its own, I consider it pretty good to average, but alongside the entire rest of the series, I strongly believe that this is a great movie. But that's just my stance on it. You don't have to agree.
If you've somehow managed to find this and read through all of it, then thank you and I hope that I made a decent point.
What a fantastic analysis my friend. I'm so glad that there's at least a few people that try to think in this light even when knowing how flawed The Last Jedi was. This perspective gives Luke and Ben at least some good depth that may have been easy to miss within the other unnecessary subplots in the movie. As Master Yoda said, "The greatest teacher, failure is." May the Force be with you.
Heroes Fan Productions dang. I didn't think anyone would see this. Thanks man. Love your videos. Can't wait till episode 9 comes out so you have Rey's full story to work with 😉.
Brad Neece you're comment just help me realize why Luke said the Jedi must end in the last Jedi.
Runt S.L. Awesome! Glad I could help, man. I was surprised how much tlj relies on the rest of the movies. You gotta know the full story to get it.
I think TLJ was way better than most people realized. I keep hearing charges that it broke the Star Wars lore but I think it was perfectly fitting the grand theme; Hope.
Hope was lost when Luke went into hiding, ashamed that for a split second, the murder of his own student that was also the son of his best friend was a tempting idea.
Not letting oneself be consumed by fear and anger (aka "the path that leads to the dark side") is everydays work, not a decision you make once and for all.
3:36 Luke wasn't there to save his Aunt & Uncle and still feels guilty, so he rushed to help Han & Leia. I had never made that connection before.
Like this father Anakin. Couldn't save his mother so he wanted to save Padme.
And considering it was most likely Fett that killed them, not STs. Then Luke ‘killing’ Fett in ROTJ is pulpable.
You can be the hardest dude in the room and this will still hit you in your soul.
The Jedi told Luke to kill his father, that there was no other way. Luke proved them wrong, proved the Jedi ways were flawed, and returned his father to the light side despite the Jedi telling him it was impossible. That’s why Luke is *the* master Jedi, not only did he master the ways of the force but he evolved the Jedi for the better- and redeemed one of the most evil beings in the galaxy.
Daddy Skee I remember Obi Wan saying he must face his father, nothing about killing him. Luke killed darth Vader, yet he didn’t kill anakin, who was is true father.
At no point did the Jedi tell Luke to kill Vader 😂
Still Luke but years later: Try to kill his own nephew
Percival Graves still luke but years later. Abandons whole galaxy for dark side to take dominance and also Kill his best friend and also leave his sister for dead
CALISVN 111 when Luke says he can’t kill his father, Obi Wan says that the empire has already won. If you have brain cells above room temp, it should be easy to decipher that Obi Wan wants him to kill Vader. Admit it, they are flawed
the part that got me was the similarities between when luke and padme were on the floor, giving the perspective of what Anakin was looking at; he failed his wife but he wasn't going to fail his son. I really like that little cut cuz it shows the ring theory from George Lucas. keep up the awesome man !! I'm excited to see what's in store for the future!!!
Exactly. I know it wasn't possible to use flashbacks when the original films came out, but seeing them now brings a real sense of the feelings of the characters.
I saw that too. Man, it gives me goosebumps. Loved it.
Seeing that now is awesome that it brings everything into context as to why he hesitated. Those flashbacks, awesome touch.
at what part I missed it
"i want to learn the ways of the force and become a jedi like my father."
"It's time for the jedi, to end."
tom campbell that is something father trying to do long time ago is kill all the Jedi and luke want to end Jedi life.
The greatest Jedi masters wanted him to kill his father and lied right to his face.
*_"Amazing. Every word of what you just said was wrong. The Rebellion is reborn today. The war is just beginning. And I will not be the last Jedi."_*
*_- Luke Skywalker_*
Obi wan never told you, what happen to your father.
I can't thank you all enough for enjoying and sharing this tribute. Doing this is my absolute passion and to be recognized by MARK FREAKING HAMILL was just spectacular!!! And it's all because of you, the Star Wars fans. We truly are one of the BEST fandoms/communities out there, and I'm so happy to be a part of it!! May the Force be with you all! Subscribe if you want to stick with me and see what I do next!!
Told you he would give you a shout out!
Came here to comment that as soon as I saw the tweet. That is unbelievably crazy, so congratulations dude, you must be so proud!
Now that's a video to truly be proud of!! Liked and subbed. Great work!! "The Force is strong with this one!"
This video deserves the attention of the great Mark Hamil fantastic work!
Heroes Fan Productions wait so where did he recognize you I want to see it
Luke Skywalker greatest Jedi that will ever exist.
Sean Last anakin
Na obi wan and then luke
I am more anakin...luke is anakin without the heartbreak
all y’all dumbasses just forgetting about yoda?
Easy. Obviously Luke
"I am a jedi like my father before me"
Luke Skywalker
Farewell Master Skywalker and may the force be with you always.
Wow, this hits harder after watching The Last Jedi 😪
You need to watch greatest teacher failure is.
I have a feeling Luke is going to come back bigger than ever in "Rise of the SkyWalkers"
Rise of Skywalker is about Ben. In the end he will die for his redemption
@@Dewitt-b8n oh please don't I Ben is my fav.
Professor Smoothiess Ben sucks he is a horrible recreation.
This was amazing from start to finish. But 7:00 onwards was just a whole nother level. You really brought out the conflict within both Luke and Vader, and all the scenes just flowed so well into one another.
Really good job yet again mate!
Thanks man! Glad you enjoyed it! : )
I agree, you put it together very well so that we could see the struggles of both Luke & Darth Vader/Anakin Skywalker
Wow can't believe REX is here.
REX r
REX hey what up
Star Wars changed my life
Luke is so much more than a character to me
“It’s time for the Jedi to end.” RIP to the grandmaster Jedi legend to the one and only, Luke Skywalker. Thank you for bringing 40 years of Star Wars to life Mark Hamill. May the force be with you, always! 👍❤️😓⭐️
DAMN. I actually cried watching this. The music, the editing, the scenery, it was all PERFECTLY put together. I absolutely love Star Wars. It's my childhood. Since i was 6 years old. And i watched the original trilogy on VHS in my room. Now, i'm 12 years old, and i love it even more because of what it has brought us since Star Wars:Rebels and The force awakens. This, is probably, the BEST, fan made tribute i have ever seen for any franchise. Well done. One more thing, if i could, i would definitely push the golden button.
3 minutes in, i had goosebumps. 5 minutes in, i was tearing up. this is the best star wars video i've ever seen, and i've watched hundreds and hundreds of these.
Rest in peace Son of Chosen One Luke Skywalker.....
Manuel Amaya
To some, including me, Luke is the true chosen one
JG32 But he didn't kill emperor so... No...
Manuel Amaya
True, but if Luke never existed, well...
The galaxy’s fucked
JG32 that is true...
Without Luke then Vader would never kill Emperor
@@JG31392 Yeah that's what i was always confused about.
The part where the emperor goes “You, like your father are now mine” and it fades into anakin was amazing
JC Inc. while I don’t disagree with you, I was shook when it transferred from Luke to Vader and they both said “sister” that was THE greatest part.
This was beautiful; as moving as watching all of these great moments for the first time. Given the horrible film that I had to witness last week, It was a nice surprise to see a truly great piece of film making. Bravo to you and Bravo, Mark Hamill.
A really good tribute to Luke it managed to capture most the growth he went through in the movies. Also I liked the deleted dialog with Biggs.
A great and touching video that strikes the true Star Wars fan right in the heart, and a piece of film I'm sure Mark Hamil himself would perceive so greatly.
I can't believe you don't have 1 million subs yet! All of your work is so great, it's only a matter of time.
Thank you soo much my friend, I'm so glad you enjoyed it :)
Heroes Fan Productions the chosen one perfect
Man luke is just so awesome he truly is the greatest Jedi
"You've failed your highness. I am a jedi, like my father before me." The greatest story ever told is the Skywalker family's. Say what you will about the sequel luke, but he will always be a symbol of hope. We saw this with MANDO szn 2 finale. Luke Skywalker has changed so many lives and nothing will ever take away that..
Train yourself to let go of everything you fear to lose.
Awesome video, really brought through the conflicts in Luke and once again Anakin.
A great, refreshing narrative of Skywalkers' tragic epic, dude!
I loved this it's a great capture of Luke life, I got the feels whenever Luke started screaming Han an Leia's name
That is fracking beautiful. I have always identified with Luke Skywalker since seeing Star Wars' national release in '77 at Tower Mall in Portsmouth, Virginia.
So many people hate on Luke, calling him a whiner. Allow me to bring your awareness to something; All of the major characters are whiners. Han, Leia, Chewy, 3PO, even R2. Even when Luke did whine, I always saw it as totally relatable and/or justifiable given his upbringing. But in Return of the Jedi, Luke didn't whine once when all the others still did.
This video shows more respect to the Luke character and his life than the entire Disney fanfiction of SW trilogy. Love it to the end.
Bingo Bango. The last jedi was a great ending for luke, don't be blind
to you three commenters...I felt Luke learnt nothing in his 30 years between SW6 and 7. I might be blind by the Dark Side, but Luke could have ended in a far more powerful and meaningful way.
DejaVoodooDoll Considering how the books represented Luke, you are very wrong.
How is he blind when Disney has made Luke the weakest main character in the entire SW universe? Even Jar Jar is a stronger character than him now.
canmani2 And it's comments like this that show how crazy "some" of you are. There is no way on earth Luke would ever be worse than Jar Jar, so clearly you're just butthurt that you didn't get your OP Luke that kills 2,000 guys.
Amazing video, I’ve watched it a ton of times now. You can see all of the emotion throughout Luke’s journey and at the end when Rey hands him back his and his fathers lightsaber, it’s sad to know after seeing last Jedi that he literally throws it over his shoulder and walks off.
I think the movie would have been 20x better if he simply looked at the lightsaber, shed a tear and dropped it, then carried on the film normally, it would have made alot more sense
Mike Urci Wrong
Mike Urci yes, tlj really ruined this whole video for me.
"One day soon... young Skywalker will wake up and realize he can no longer go back to his pitiful friends. He will look at himself and see his true face. The face of power. The face of the dark side."
Anakin Skywalker was my favorite character of the prequels. Even though I knew he was to become Darth Vader it wasn't until he actually turned in Episode III that it really hit me. Not to sound corny but it truly broke my heart when he turned. That said the editing of images between Anakin and Darth Vader are true genius. Every time the word "father" is uttered we see cutaways from Anakin to Vader it is making me very emotional. Well done.
Star Wars is the best movies ever
@@theemperor1379 And it's "was"
@@firetopman nope.
@@theemperor1379 yes
@@caesarvalorvmsheevpalpatin8755 yes what?
The force is strong in you
"Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter." That line brings tears to my eyes.
I love how you included the deleted scene between Luke and Biggs at the beginning. I’d seen the scene before but never thought much of how it shows Luke’s desire to help others.
This is great now. Especially considering the events of The Last Jedi.
It was for told I would be here hero fans productions, your work pleases me...
Thank you my lord, I made sure your beloved son received a proper representation.
nice job
Heroes Fan Productions very few have earned this gift from Darth Vader... but you clearly deserve it...
+1 sub
I won't take this for granted, my lord, Thank you. I'm eternally grateful : )
Darth Vader so you couldn't just whip out your lightsaber and killbyour master instead of dying
THIS is the ideal tribute to Luke!! Every single tribute to him on here is just some poorly edited clips with some pop or metal song. This is perfection!!!
This is so beautiful, it literally brings a tear to my eye, Luke Skywalker is such an underdog, never giving up hope, always hopeful, always a Jedi, may the force be with us ❤️
That sensation of your hairs standing up when watching and hearing those Star Wars scene and voices come to past..it is Heaven..all ties together as the Dynasty of the Skywalker families..remember my Apprentices you are a Skywalker ...
Thank you so much for this! Luke Skywalker is my favourite character in movie history, and this was just incredibly well done, and absolutely moving. Again, truly, thank you!!
Amazing tribute to a very complex character. Well done.
That was a BEAUTIFUL tribute, thank you SOO much!!
"Never... I will never turn to the dark side... you failed your highness... I'm a jedi, like my father before me..."
Loved the video! It was so well done and unlike most people it has seemingly enhanced by already deep appreciation for Luke’s character and conclusion in TLJ. I hope you find the time to create another video that includes the Last Jedi because now we have seen the end of Luke’s journey. Once again loved the video great work!
One aspect about Luke I want to go into is his decision to not face Kylo in person. If you recall in ANH Obi-Wan says the line “you can’t win, but there are always alternatives to fighting”. Yoda also offers the lesson that “a Jedi uses the force for knowledge and defense, never attack”. What’s important is that Luke never learned this lesson and it is one of the things Yoda and Obi repeatedly call him out on. It is his greatest flaw. Consistently throughout the OT, Luke always gives into his first instinct to fight and use his power offensively. Luke brings his weapons into the Dagobah cave and strikes down Vader, he goes to face Vader on Bespin and ignites his saber first, he tries to strike down the Emperor out of fear and hate, he unleashed a furious barrage of offensive strikes when battling Vader until he almost killed him, and he almost struck down Ben Solo in fear of what he would become. This instinct has benefitted Luke at times, but it also symbolized his most vulnerable and weakest moments in his life. It was the source of his constant battle with the temptation toward the dark side. He never utilized the lesson of passiveness taught to him and always gave into his impulsiveness. Luke’s decision to not go and battle Kylo Ren is the moment when Luke learns from his mistakes and uses the teachings Obi and Yoda taught him long ago. By not fighting, Luke is finally able to overcome his fear of the dark side. By not fighting, he achieves a sense of self-purpose and peace he had never felt. By not fighting, he discovers the value that the true ways of the Jedi could have on his soul. Though Luke might have pretended to be a master following ROTJ, he still had much to learn and obstacles to overcome. Now that he had conquered his greatest fear and learned his final lesson from Obi and Yoda, he had no more to learn and no more obstacles in his way. So he fades into the force just like his mentors before him. Joining them not as a student, but as a fellow master. Finally, Luke has become a master of the Jedi.
I'm almost 42 years old. Amazing, I got goosebumps watching the Last Jedi. I get the same seeing Obi Wan give Luke the lightsaber.
Good stuff man, keep up the good work.
RecruitGamer O
this was absolutely beautiful! thank you from the bottom of my heart!
RIP to the greatest Jedi to ever live. Luke reminds me of me. Curious about the world, wanting to do more. Luke was one of the best. He started with Binary Sunset. And he ended with Binary Sunset. R.I.P man
We all have a bit of Luke Skywalker inside of us.
"Elegant weapon... for a more civilized age."
*cuts off someone's arm, leaving blood all over*
*CIVILIZED*
*shoots someone with a blaster leaving a small wound cauterized by the heat allowing a much cleaner death*
*UNCIVILIZED*
I still agree with obi-won
A laser sword would take much more skill to wield while a blaster anyone can pick up and use
Lightsabers actually don't leave any blood, because the heat closes the wound instantly.
@@arcanedreamer1640 I know, but he’s alluding to the Mos Eisley scene when Obi Wan slices that guys arm off and there’s more than enough blood and nothing is cauterized.
It’s obviously before Lucas refined how lightsaber wounds would actually occur, with the idea of flesh encountering concentrated intense heat.
I don't care what anyone else might say, but this was an excellent companion to The Chosen One you did, and people don't realize just how close Luke came to going over to the dark side.... I've had many arguments over it with friends who thought Luke was bullet proof and immune to the dark side.
Epic, to say the least. Please, do keep up the good work.
This brought tears to my eyes. Luke means so much to me ❤️
i don't know why but in this videos Anakins story ALWAYS makes me cry :(
he was the best
Just in time, too! Thank the Force for 40 years of Star Wars!
Luke needs to have a Vader moment like in Rogue One, except with the First Order and Knights of Ren, and just absolutely eviscerate them.
ShadowPatriotX unfortunately that didn't happen...
Like many other things in TLJ😫😫😫
ShadowPatriotX :(
That would destroy his character by doing one of many things that go against the Jedi it makes sense for Vader coz he is sith it would've made even worse fan service than Yoda vs Dooku in the prequels
@@grey3247 The Jedi were never a bunch of pacifists. Obi-wan hacks off a guy's arm in the first movie. There's be nothing out of character about Luke defeating a bunch of first order soldiers. Especially since, you know, they could have always had him do it without killing them. If they really wanted to make him adopt a no-kill policy. Which was never a policy of the original Jedi order, just to be clear.
@@BingBong67489 he wasnt a jedi anymore att
If Luke dies in episode 8, he better go out fighting.
Not Spiderman If he dies in 8, I'm leaving the theater.
Not Spiderman If he dies i'm done with Star Wars
Luke Skywalker Me too. I barely handled Han's death, then Carrie Fisher's. I don't think I'd make it through if Luke dies. However, if they mention that he died off screen, or by old age, I'm fine with. I just don't want to have to watch it.
Sophie Juravle fuck no if he dies for natural causes off screen I will pissed the fuck off
I'd rather him die at peace the way obi-wan did than in a blaze of glory.
Luke Skywalker IS Star Wars. This is a great tribute.
The truth is Luke Skywalker is a Legend of The Galaxy.
Joseph Cambell's Hero's Journey in Luke right here. Thanks for this vid and incredible work on it! I teach about the Hero's Journey at the university by way of Luke Skywalker (who I also included as an illustrative example in my work on veteran transition and paths to wellbeing).
I will use this video in future lectures if you don't mind, HFP(?)! Looking forward to seeing more of Luke's journey in the years to come.
By all means man, go ahead and use this for your lectures. Make sure to credit me of course. I hope others can be inspired by Luke's journey as well in this video.
Thank you! I absolutely will cite you and have already shared your video with others. Great work!
Can I ask why you feel his heroic journey is as impressive as you say? I am curious and enjoy writing characters immensely. I also like to hear differing opinions to my own.
mate i dont belive how do you come with all of this plans it's just amazing and your fans love it i think you have to make pages in facebook and instagram and more to be famous
Thank you my friend. I just might even consider that :)
waiting :)
This is beyond amazing. Honestly, your work is never anything less than spectacular. Absolutely beautiful edit and you are very gifted at what you do.
Never stop making these phenomenal videos!!
Thank you for this amazing comment my friend. Don't worry, the vids will keep coming :) May the Force be With You
You're very welcome, and I'm glad to hear it! May the Force be With You too! :)
I love the dichotomy near the end when he’s fighting Vader, the voices of the Emperor and Yoda, giving Luke opposite teachings about the Force. The conflict within him, just like his father had.
“Remember, a Jedi’s strength flows from the Force.” Always gave me goosebumps that Yoda strains to tell Luke such a simple fact as he’s about to pass on. The Sith rely on their passion and emotions, the Jedi’s strength flows from the Force itself.
"No one's ever really gone" - Luke Skywalker
Sovereign “Meesa back!”
You are not saren
Amazing! Chosen one was better, but this one is right up there with it. Probably just because this one didn't have quite as good a song
And let me just say, your attention to detail and pacing skills are unrivaled. You have a unique sense of were to put clips, sound, and dialogue in order to make something impactful, and there are some scenes that really made me smile and say "dang that was cool" like when Vader clenched his fist and then it smoothly transitioned to Luke doing the same thing, and stuff like that. Really well done mate!
Thank you my friend for this well thought-out critique. I enjoy doing this so much and it's wonderful to receive some recognition. Completely respect if you like the Chosen One more. That's what this channel is for anyway, to eventually have a wide-selection of tributes to watch and enjoy. Thanks again, and May the Force be With you.
Heroes Fan Productions may the force be with you too!
the chosen one is even the coollest character so... good work at all you really deserve more suscribers... i also dont get evrything maybe because i'm german^^
Chosen one made me fucking cry
My all time favorite star wars character
moved me to tears...always be my childhood hero..always will be the jedi.
It's amazing to see people here in the comments who understood the last jedi
Enzo Saraiva I understood it... enough to know it was a self-contradicting mess of a film that tried too hard to be edgy and artsy
That was one of the best tribute videos I've seen yet. That touched Luke's character on SO many levels. Man, keep them coming.
Marvelous tribute! I'm so sad. Seeing this after the Last Jedi... it hurts si much.
Never, ever, Luke would have try to kill Ben...
Also I would have loved some flashbacks in Luke's mind about the good times with his nephew in Last Jedi. Seeing Ben laugh with him, playing together, having Luke taking his nephew in his arm with Han and Leia when little.... So much could have make people cry and feel with him the sorrow of Luke. Instead we have space cows. ..
Continue your beautiful work !
Yannick Joyal He would tried, and he did
Luke used the darkside to defeat Vader and stopped himself just before the final blow. Not that hard to believe it could happen again
Amazing thank you!
I’ve been watching these movies since I was 8 and Luke was always my favorite character in the whole saga and seeing like Han Solo and leia die was really hard but seeing Luke die was the hardest because he was my childhood hero and now the sky walker series is over and I just wanted to see the old Luke again..
The edit at 7:30 - 7:38 with Luke and Padme on the floor is just beautiful.
Damn, damn, DAMN!!! That was an amazing compilation video! I got chills and tears! Thanks for taking the time to make such a great reminder of just how awesome SW once was!!!
I absolutely miss Luke. I really miss the REAL Luke.
Real Luke?
@@ApexGorilla1 from the original trilogy (and legends). Because the man that is in sequel trilogy is Jake Skywalker
Last night’s Mandalorian made me want to see this again, I was so happy. I felt like 6 year old me discovering Star Wars for the first time again.
"I want to learn the ways of the force and become a jedi like my father."
*cue chills-inducing music
Luke is my favorite Star Wars character from the originals! I love this video so much! Great job! And congrats on the Mark Hamil re-tweet!
Crazy how you can feel such emotion for a fictional character. George’s Star Wars will always be the best!
Trust in the force...
And in time,
*A New Hope Will Emerge*
I ABSOLUTELY ❤️ your work! The music...the masterful way you weave ALL the stories together...it pulls at my heartstrings! Lucasfilm should hire you...SERIOUSLY!👏👍😎
You can say all you want about rey "Skywalker" being the last Jedi. but all the real SW fans will never believe it.
I am so excited that you used Biggs and Luke's conversations from the deleted scenes.
You even used other deleted scenes from the original trilogy. It's so cool!!
I cried like a baby. Every cell of my inner child.
In dark times, when I doubt it is still alive, Star Wars gives me the undisputable answer.
The callbacks, the shots of old Obiwan before young, of young Anakin when Luke redeems Vader, the perfect link between all these wonderful creations, showing how he is the center of it all, and the perfect ending offered by TFA, with Yoda prompting him to pass on what he has learned.
Of course, about the very last sentence, there's no way you could have known.
Thank you for literally transcending what was already a work of definition and inspiration for part of humanity.
Thank you George, thank you Mark, for changing my life.