@@choisansrightankle9106 Giselle can sing tho u can’t deny that. Vocally Giselle and swan&chaein r somewhat equal. To compare their vocal support Giselle G#3/A3~A4/Bb4 Swan A3~A4/Bb4 Chaein G#3/A3~A4/Bb4 They’re all pretty equal but chaein and swans consistency is better so chaein=swan>Giselle
@@pravingunvare5489 Sry but nah I mean yeah sure her vocal are definitely good she is the best vocalist in aespa but you should hear Lily's vocal her high notes are insaneee and she can support well tho so considering all this she is best vocalist in 4th gen
@@pravingunvare5489 i'm a MY but i really think Lily is the best 4th gen female vocalist we have atm. Ningning is also up there so both are vocal queens! 👑👑
Lily has the widest *support* range🤷🏽♀️ yes some may sound more open in their lower range in comparison, but she still supports the same notes, if she develops those further, she'll be miles ahead, considering how impressively relaxed and open her 5th octave is already. And stability? Did you watch the Move Your Body Kcon performance? They were running on the spot while belting🧍🏽♀️
Swan is underrated af here, she deserves to be in top 3 for me Lily and Swan with their unique voices are unmatched, and then I'd put Goeun, Sullyoon, Winter, Ningning and Chaein on third place, just together. Love all girls though
My two most favorite 4th gen girl groups (Aespa and NMIXX) and the junior of my most favorite 3rd gen girl group (Purple Kiss). 💜 Anyways, DICE is such a bop.
Can you please tell me the vocal range of all purple kiss members please? Thank you 💕 And again an accurate ranking even if I was surprised to see Giselle above Chaein and karina
Purple kiss vocal range Goeun(strongest vocalist in pk) A3-B4 Swan A3/Bb3-Bb4 Chaein (one of the best lower registers in the 4th gen) G#3/A3-A4/Bb4 Dosie Bb3/B3-G4/G#5 she’s consistent but her support is shallow
it’s a crime and plain disrespectful too giselle over chaein like u got to be joking. all the purki girls should be wayyy higher. also winter?? she should be higher as well wtf is this tier list
You lost me with Swan at 7 no way.....I love Haewon but 2 she has a beautiful voice and can hit some high notes but she's not stable enough and her voice cracks all the time. Her and Swan should be switched or have Na Goen 2 and Swan maybe 4...Top 3 lily Goen Winter also Kyujin too too low
@@billbarry2291 This is about skills, not whose voice is pretty (I mean I find Haewon's voice pretty doesn't mean she's the best vocalist in the world lol). It's a very subjective topic. It's like a visual ranking
@@LynMooSD control wise? not at all. just watch Ain't No Other Fan video about 4th main vocalists and kpop bad, decent and great belting to see what a vocal expert says about it.
@@LynMooSD swan goes for vocal style more than technique especially her vocal tone really match with her vocal style she goes the same vocal style like bae.
It’s not but compared to winter she’s lacks… her support I think is A4/Bb4 she has a few B4s but it’s not consistent. It’s gonna be hard for her to rank high if people keep ranking vocals by technique
why did you include every member of aespa and nmixx but majority of purple kiss is missing? they have a lot of talented vocalists, not just the vocal line
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc i know tone doesnt equal technique, im in music classes. im not saying they should have been higher than nmixx and aespa, but the fact that they weren't there at all. they at least could have been in the ranking. they're just missing.
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc yes, but why just fifteen? there arent that many members of purple kiss, it wouldnt be very hard to just put them at the end if thats where the creator thought they belonged.
@@Dardeevua it's not opinion on who is better. Literally based on technique on vocals. Also, only 10 people. There are so many more comments saying that Lily and Haewon are the best so keep dreaming :)
@@ValentinaFlowers Well, but I don't care about other people's opinions, it's my opinion and it's respected just like I respect others and in my opinion, Swan deserves number 1, please shut up,What a nuisance bro.
Wait.. Gisselle better than Chaein? lol I'm ok with Lily being #1 even if i like Swan and Na Goeun better than her, but Swan and Na Goeun deserve 2 and 3
Swan>Sullyoon. Sorry not sorry. Just because someone can hit high notes doesn't mean they're a better vocalist. And just because you haven't heard them sing a highnote that they are a bad vocalist. NMIXX is a performance based group so vocals are just a part of their performance while Aespa and Purple Kiss are vocals based group. As someone who loves all three groups, I'll put PK at the top of Vocals and NMIXX for dance and stage presence. PK's vocals have such good technique and control, and the harmony of their voices are heavenly. And though we haven't heard Giselle try for a high note, she has incredible control if you've heard how they record in studio. Even BoA praised her. I don't have much to say about Winter and Ning Ning as they are amazing vocalists. As for NMIXX, I'm glad they have Lily and Haewon. And Dice is such a bop that I have listening to it for weeks. But I didn't really like Sullyoon's high note cause it's strained and came off forced unlike when you listen to Lily's belt. This isn't to put down the other girls, but that's my opinion on this ranking.
This doesn’t make sense. NCT is also a performance based group. Does that mean Ten, Doyoung, Taeil, Chenle etc’s vocals mean nothing? No… Taeil is one of the best 3rd gen male vocalists. Also high notes ≠ skill. Example: Nayeon hits higher notes than Jihyo, Jeongyeon and Jihyo are still better than her. Sullyoon is still better than Swan in techniques
@@cyj7n those haters always say "can High Note doesn't mean good vocals" EVEN NOBODY says NMIXX members are better just because of High Note, like they only know High Note when it comes to vocal technique
@@cyj7nyes it is one main vocalist and two aren’t ?? why would someone make someone main vocalist but yet she lower then people that aren’t that good at singing like they are good but not better then chaein ahve you even ever heard hee voice or are u just biased
@@seeunswifee Position doesn't matter? Like, Taeyeon and Jessica are main vocalists yet Taeyeon is miles ahead of her and Jessica is more on Seohyun level lol
First up Kyujin and Karina are not C- they must get consistent and fuller with B4 which they're not. Also lately sullyoon and Giselle have shown a bolder approach which has helped them improve and surpass karina and kyujin. All of these girls are D+ none is C-. If jeongyeon is not C- how can karina and kyujin become C-
Swan and chaein must be top 5 atleast..u never listen they singing live thats y..n u never see they cover psycho from redvelvet and cover eng song ,i can bet even nmixx trio cant beat trio from purplekiss,.swan , goeun and chaein is the best vocalist
@@Verowinday777Jieun is actually better than Dosie but RBW never lets her utilise all her potential bcuz she was in charge of lower singing, check some of her independent covers before she left ^^ Dosie did surprise me with the higher notes in Sweet Juice but she could definitely work a bit more on her vocals since her dance is already perfect
but isnt Sully and Kyujin around the same vocal tier? Like last I heard both are C-, except Kyujin is more trained in low tones and has chestier and fuller voice while Sullyoon is better at higher pitch
@@Linalina-nn1vx ningning is first for u bc of her tone and not vocal technique. It's pretty obvious yk nothing Abt vocal technique and ur proving just that💀
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc you can say whatever you want, but there’s a reason Ningning is more popular 😂 you can get all butt hurt as you want, but doesn’t change the fact lily is just gonna fade away as another member of a gg while Ningning is just gonna get better and better 🤡
this was before sweet juice era, they used to have very few lines and their vocals weren’t that well showcased as rbw focused more on giving them spotlight during dance breaks and stuff like that… they’re definitely deserving of a higher rank now
I will not rank all of them but my top6 1.Haewon (I prefer her tone over Lily's, and her voice is just gorgeous and very powerful but still she has a light tone, which doesn't allow her to sound as sassy as Lily for example) 2.Winter (She has one of my favourite voices in kpop, and her tone is pretty unique, that girl is just starting!-) 3.Ningning (Is a close one to Winter, but with a rather warm, soft tone) 4.Sullyoon (amazing vocals! and she shines in the softer parts, not because of weakness or whatever, her voice just fits rather soft parts) 5.Lily (she's wonderful, probably the best vocalists of this (4th) generation, but I'm not the biggest fan of her tone.. Also she sings with lots of fierceness, she sounds sassy even in calm songs and that bothers me a little if I'm honest - 6. BAE: she was at a store (with another member) and they were buying their own album, then cool (your rainbow) started playing and it was just her and that little mic and she sounded so gorgeous and stable, she doesn't need to be the main to ace with her charming vocals- Nmixx songs are not good enough for their wonderful voices, so sad.. So far the only good song and suitable for their vocals/raps was 'your rainbow' Also I know it's their opinion, but: I don't think Gigi is a better vocalist than Chaein or Rina - Gigi is the weakest vocalist in aespa and her main position is to rap! Meanwhile Rina is a main dancer, but you cannot compare her to Lisa as an example, because Rina is a better vocalist, Karina is is more like Jennie a rapper who can sing and could maybe be or is a lead-vocalist, (my world mini album proves it), and I don't mean high notes wise ~ Anyways I still respect your opinion 🦋
Vocal technique isnt based on opinions. Ok? What if Giselle is the main rapper, that doesn't take away from her supporting. Jiwoo is main rapper but she supports also Giselle isn't the weakest vocalist in Aespa anymore
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc Who said that vocal technique is based on opinions? - As the owner gave their opinion I gave mine + I truly study about music and voices so I know what I'm talking about, and with the last comeback of aespa you can definitely tell Gigi is the least vocalist ^^ doesn't mean she's bad but she's not at Karina's level Lily's tone is not the best one but she has a wonderful technique, and her voice is really impressive, I rather Haewon's tone and she's also wonderful technically-wise, Haewon is more of warm but powerful, Lily sounds strong and sassy. Winter probably has my favourite tone in aespa she's not better than Lily technically, but she's also wonderful, she sounds fierce and very stable. Ningning sounds warm, soft and calm and I also prefer her tone over Lily, but once again Lily is better technically talking- Bae also has a nice voice, her vocals still have a lot to show but she has proven many times that you don't need to be a main vocalist to shine.. And Sullyoon, that woman sounds really gorgeous, she can fit many concepts but I think softer songs make her shine the most. No worries cus I know about: textures, tones, colours, ranges, belting, heady, mixed voice, falsetto, chest voice, technique, voice types, etc.
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc Yes, cus I wanted to add more things, but just added, didn't remove anything my opinion is still the same. Now you can read my previous comment and give nice arguments
I only know their belting notes Goeun Bb3?-B5 (strongest vocalist in pk) Swan lows??-A4/Bb4 Chaein A3-A4/Bb4(one of the best lower registers in the 4th gen) Dosie Bb3/B3-G4/G#4
@@ValentinaFlowersi mean personally i think she is very shallow and doesn't really engage much with her diaphragm while singing, thats why i usually put her in low weak to average
Source : Sootzubæ
The changes in the rankings are the latest updates. You can't expect the order to stay the same forever.
@@riyachandak7770 jk will win every category my guess??
Giselle>sullyoon with her clean approach and consistent support tell sootzubae stop being bias on nmixx she did this in the very beginning challenge
@@navisoori5391 ??
@@itz_lavena in what?
@@zippy_zunairah they wanted aa comparison vid nd i said jk will win
felt bad for the purple kiss members because i believe they deserved a higher ranking
WHY IS CHAEIN AND SWAN SO LOW????? they are literally the most powerfull vocals ever
This is a dumb video tbh, even Jieun is pretty low for someone from such a vocally powerful group
compare to the ones ranked above them definitely not
@@mariahlol2488 they could sing live for a change then, no?
@@episode40 and i didnt say they couldnt sing live smh
Chaein and Swan is not powerful vocals but stylistic vocals
NMIXX is so lucky to have HaeLy
Jyp literally hit a Jackpot
Lily trained for like 7-8 years so of course she’s gonna be great. And I think Lily help haewon with her vocal Bc their both amazing
Jackpot 🤩🤩
To have all of NMIXX infact.
More like JYP is so lucky to have NMIXX
I don’t want to be rude or anything, but Giselle better than chaein!? And she is vocally better than swan….I’m so confused.
This is just their opinion, not facts. I also think Jieun is low
@@episode40 yeah all of them are amazing 🤩 but I was a little confused..
@@episode40 this is facts just bc ur fav wasnt ranked higher doesnt mean this is their opinion
@@mariahlol2488 it isn't facts tho. this person knows nothing about singing and there's no way giselle is higher than chaein period
@@episode40 lol ur faves arent the best just accept that
3 strongest vocal line in 4th gen ❤️
swan and chaein can't be so low i'm sorry
They r- Giselle and swan r equal but I would put chaein above both
@@dino.nuggies2382in my opinion i would put swan higher because i love her smooth voice and it kinda gives soul
@@mruknown8797 if the ranking was based on vocal color and tone then swan obliterates everyone. Swan>>>>>>>>>
@@dino.nuggies2382ur actually joking right. like actually. u think giselle can sing like that? are u nuts
@@choisansrightankle9106 Giselle can sing tho u can’t deny that. Vocally Giselle and swan&chaein r somewhat equal. To compare their vocal support
Giselle G#3/A3~A4/Bb4
Swan A3~A4/Bb4
Chaein G#3/A3~A4/Bb4
They’re all pretty equal but chaein and swans consistency is better so chaein=swan>Giselle
Im here for swan 🤍 my fav 4th gen vocal from gg
Same 😊, her vocals are heaven to my ears.
I prefer Swan voice the most
I'm not Purple kiss fan and don't know the members but Swan, and she is number 1 for me or maybe 2 after Lily
«For me» it's not about technique
Lily the 4th gen vocal queen 🪐!
NO NINGNING IS BEST
@@pravingunvare5489 Not really, NingNing is only better at lower registers
@@pravingunvare5489 Sry but nah I mean yeah sure her vocal are definitely good she is the best vocalist in aespa but you should hear Lily's vocal her high notes are insaneee and she can support well tho so considering all this she is best vocalist in 4th gen
@@pravingunvare5489 i'm a MY but i really think Lily is the best 4th gen female vocalist we have atm. Ningning is also up there so both are vocal queens!
👑👑
@@bearyoung
1. LILY IS B-, B
2. HAEWON IS B-
3. NING 2 C+, B-
Best vocal doesn't mean best ni high note only.. must be best both in low n high registers and stable voice also
there is no name High Register, but Upper Register lol
"stable" how can we know one can be stable if some of them lipsync most of the time?
swan and chaein are amazing in both😭
Lily has the widest *support* range🤷🏽♀️ yes some may sound more open in their lower range in comparison, but she still supports the same notes, if she develops those further, she'll be miles ahead, considering how impressively relaxed and open her 5th octave is already.
And stability? Did you watch the Move Your Body Kcon performance? They were running on the spot while belting🧍🏽♀️
which is why the purple kiss girls are always ranked so low. they have better lower registers than the others on the list
okay no. cannot agree this time. swan and chaein deserved WAY higher pls
this is literally outdated like read the pinned comment-
Jieun, Swan and Bae deserves to be higher
chaein too.
Swan is underrated af here, she deserves to be in top 3
for me Lily and Swan with their unique voices are unmatched, and then I'd put Goeun, Sullyoon, Winter, Ningning and Chaein on third place, just together. Love all girls though
Vocal tone =/= vocal technique. Swan shouldn't be top 3 she isn't even the best in her group. Swan is W-A
Yk nothing abt vocal technique
You need to know about thei vocal range and vocal support that why the ranking is not as you expect 😂
Purple kiss is 1 in vocal (:
The fact that everyone on the ranking can support.
ok woah but Giselle 🤩
Maybe give her a high note now
Swan goeun and chaein at that low 😢they're best
Lily!!!
Slay gurl ✨️😩
Jieun at 15? Lmao your kidding bcs swan and chaein that low...
r u dumb enough to not read the pinned comment?
Are you calling Jieun a bad vocalist?
My two most favorite 4th gen girl groups (Aespa and NMIXX) and the junior of my most favorite 3rd gen girl group (Purple Kiss). 💜
Anyways, DICE is such a bop.
Purple kiss is 4th gen
@@NoHairNoHumanity Yea I know that, but MAMAMOO, a 3rd gen group, is their seniors.
Did Swan win Immortal Song too
Como pones a swan 8
Omgggg yes every member of aespa in top 10 let's go!!! Btw I thought jieun couldn't support?
Yeah I don't think she supports.
@@hopeflakez no jieun and dosie both support, and I guess dosie is in weak tier like low weak , so purple kiss has 5/7 support
@@hopeflakez jieun can support but it’s not consistent
Why wouldn't she? She's a great vocalist lol
@@justanoerfan1572 Ireh can’t support ?
Whole aespa is in top 10🔥
Our girls slayed always 💯
Where dosie and ireh?
this was only for main and lead vocalists
Can you please tell me the vocal range of all purple kiss members please? Thank you 💕
And again an accurate ranking even if I was surprised to see Giselle above Chaein and karina
I surprised to see her above chaein the most…. And didn’t Elle support a E5 head voice or was it falsetto
Purple kiss vocal range
Goeun(strongest vocalist in pk)
A3-B4
Swan
A3/Bb3-Bb4
Chaein (one of the best lower registers in the 4th gen)
G#3/A3-A4/Bb4
Dosie
Bb3/B3-G4/G#5 she’s consistent but her support is shallow
@@dino.nuggies2382 Thank you
@@elfy2006 I’m still look for the rest
@@elfy2006 cause ik jieun and ireh can support some notes
Umm...Dosie, Ireh and Yuki don't exist or what? -_-
This ranking is so incorrect,it can be your opinion sure,but factually its wrong.
Your opinion may differ, but factually the video is right
@@hopeflakez no it isn't.
@@hopeflakez the top 5 are the rest isnt.
@@hyunjinie_lixie_chanie4514 Why?
@@cyj7n because its known that karina and Giselle are both D/D+ and kyujin and sullyoon are C/C+ and karina and Giselle are ranked higher then them
Giselle better than chaein? 🤔
Swan 7° and Sullyoon 6°??? WTF???? SWAN 7°?????? purple kiss vocal's best
I do not accept swan being 7th wtf
For me swan is the best❤❤
They all slayy In vocals
it’s a crime and plain disrespectful too giselle over chaein like u got to be joking. all the purki girls should be wayyy higher. also winter?? she should be higher as well wtf is this tier list
Perfect gg ever = Nmixx
So what are purplekiss vocal line supported ranges? I feel like you should include that within these videos so ppl understand the rankings
Goeun is C, Chaein D+ and Swan I think she is an high D+
Lily haewon and ningning never leave their stop when it comes to 4gen vocal ranking
You lost me with Swan at 7 no way.....I love Haewon but 2 she has a beautiful voice and can hit some high notes but she's not stable enough and her voice cracks all the time. Her and Swan should be switched or have Na Goen 2 and Swan maybe 4...Top 3 lily Goen Winter also Kyujin too too low
Cracking doesn't really mean anything
And you can't really compare Swan to Haewon who has such a fuller, more powerful voice
@@cyj7n Swan's voice is one of those unique original and rare voices that come once a generation. So yes she's a top 3
@@billbarry2291 This is about skills, not whose voice is pretty (I mean I find Haewon's voice pretty doesn't mean she's the best vocalist in the world lol). It's a very subjective topic. It's like a visual ranking
Karina is best than giselle
congrats for 6k ✨
Tyy 💗
Love Haewon ❤️❤️❤️
God swan deserve the 1st place, and chen under 5 whats wrong with the list
Definitely not, the biased is crazy
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIcI agree but she should at least be in top 4 and chaein too. this person the made the video is def biased
@@seeunswifee mm no
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc mmmmm yes ur way to biased
@@seeunswifee mm no, there's no way she can be top 4 when there's way better vocalists here, ur the actual one being biased here not me
where are ireh, yuki, and dosie from purple kiss
i think this was only for main and lead vocalists
only top 15, dosie would be 16th, ireh 17th, and yuki 18th
Lol even experts have said Swan is arguably the best vocalist in 4th gen but ok 👍
Swan is nowhere near Lily when it comes to vocals, Lily is the best vocalist in 4th gen.
@@mixxpolelily needs to find her own sound
@@mixxpole hey I’m not an expert but I do agree with them, Lilly is good but Swan is a lot better especially control wise
@@LynMooSD control wise? not at all. just watch Ain't No Other Fan video about 4th main vocalists and kpop bad, decent and great belting to see what a vocal expert says about it.
@@LynMooSD swan goes for vocal style more than technique especially her vocal tone really match with her vocal style she goes the same vocal style like bae.
Swan is too low, her vocals are not far from Goeun
It’s not but compared to winter she’s lacks… her support I think is A4/Bb4 she has a few B4s but it’s not consistent. It’s gonna be hard for her to rank high if people keep ranking vocals by technique
Dosie > Jieun imo
That's an unpopular one
Lily is queen vocal
why did you include every member of aespa and nmixx but majority of purple kiss is missing? they have a lot of talented vocalists, not just the vocal line
Bc half of them can't support. Vocal tone =/= vocal technique
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc i know tone doesnt equal technique, im in music classes. im not saying they should have been higher than nmixx and aespa, but the fact that they weren't there at all. they at least could have been in the ranking. they're just missing.
@@lillie8916 it's says top 15, u shouldn't expect all of them to be included there
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc yes, but why just fifteen? there arent that many members of purple kiss, it wouldnt be very hard to just put them at the end if thats where the creator thought they belonged.
@@lillie8916 maybe bc she doesn't want the vid to be long
Now Chaein>=Swan
nahhh swan number one
Bae 14???????????? Karina 10????????? Giselle 8??????????? This ranking was a mess. And where are Ireh Dosie and Yuki???????
its only top 15. dosie would be 16th, ireh 17th, and yuki 18th
it was only for main and lead vocalists that’s why they are missing
Kyujin is c- karina is d+ and soolyeoon is d+ too ?
man but bae at 14th 💀😭
Karina>>>Giselle en vocal
No
No
Yeah
Of all the ones that appear in the video, number 1 has to be swan.
no swan is Number 3
@@ValentinaFlowers Well in my opinion no and I think those 10 people who liked the comment think the same.
@@Dardeevua it's not opinion on who is better. Literally based on technique on vocals. Also, only 10 people. There are so many more comments saying that Lily and Haewon are the best so keep dreaming :)
@@ValentinaFlowers Well, but I don't care about other people's opinions, it's my opinion and it's respected just like I respect others and in my opinion, Swan deserves number 1, please shut up,What a nuisance bro.
We have some lead vocalist have more good vocal in a main vocalist
Wait..
Gisselle better than Chaein? lol
I'm ok with Lily being #1 even if i like Swan and Na Goeun better than her, but Swan and Na Goeun deserve 2 and 3
Q descaro este rank, how come purple kiss rank so far ?
Purple Kiss deserve #1 spot
@@episode40 not when there's nmixx and aespa
They're not that far?
why is chaein and swan so slow she they are both main vocalist
Swan>Sullyoon. Sorry not sorry. Just because someone can hit high notes doesn't mean they're a better vocalist. And just because you haven't heard them sing a highnote that they are a bad vocalist.
NMIXX is a performance based group so vocals are just a part of their performance while Aespa and Purple Kiss are vocals based group. As someone who loves all three groups, I'll put PK at the top of Vocals and NMIXX for dance and stage presence. PK's vocals have such good technique and control, and the harmony of their voices are heavenly. And though we haven't heard Giselle try for a high note, she has incredible control if you've heard how they record in studio. Even BoA praised her. I don't have much to say about Winter and Ning Ning as they are amazing vocalists. As for NMIXX, I'm glad they have Lily and Haewon. And Dice is such a bop that I have listening to it for weeks. But I didn't really like Sullyoon's high note cause it's strained and came off forced unlike when you listen to Lily's belt.
This isn't to put down the other girls, but that's my opinion on this ranking.
it’s almost like she can improve which she did. Swan is also stylistic anyway so.
This doesn’t make sense. NCT is also a performance based group. Does that mean Ten, Doyoung, Taeil, Chenle etc’s vocals mean nothing? No… Taeil is one of the best 3rd gen male vocalists. Also high notes ≠ skill. Example: Nayeon hits higher notes than Jihyo, Jeongyeon and Jihyo are still better than her. Sullyoon is still better than Swan in techniques
lol ur so biased its obvious u dont know anything abt nmixx calling them only a dance and performance group
I'd say NMIXX is definitely a vocal-based group
Also, no one said Sullyoon is better just because she can hit high notes 💀
@@cyj7n those haters always say "can High Note doesn't mean good vocals" EVEN NOBODY says NMIXX members are better just because of High Note, like they only know High Note when it comes to vocal technique
What's that purple kiss song?
in jieun fancam - pretty psycho
in chaein fancam - pretty psycho
in swan fancam - memem
in goeun fancam - nerdy
@@myeonluv thank you
No hate but I prefer Swan's voice over Lilly and Ningning
Ok and? Doesn't mean she's better than them
TOP10
01° Lily (B)
02° Haewon (B-)
03° Ning Ning (B-)
04° Goeun (C+)
05° Winter (C)
06° Swan (C-)
07° Kyujin (D+/C-)
08° Chaein (D+)
09° Karina (D+)
10° Sullyoon (D+)
Proud of you girls 💘
ÆSPA queens of 4th gen 👑
What are all of their supported ranges?
How tf is Giselle better than Karina and Chaein.. this ranking is crap
Because she has a cleaner approach to singing. It's not even that big of a difference, no big deal
@@cyj7nyes it is one main vocalist and two aren’t ?? why would someone make someone main vocalist but yet she lower then people that aren’t that good at singing like they are good but not better then chaein ahve you even ever heard hee voice or are u just biased
@@seeunswifee Position doesn't matter? Like, Taeyeon and Jessica are main vocalists yet Taeyeon is miles ahead of her and Jessica is more on Seohyun level lol
Karina over Giselle So wrong...
Karina is literally Below Giselle, are you stupid or something?
It's about improvement
@@user-dy1cz4tf4f Not even bro
@@rohanbera1160 But even if she improved Karina would still be above her..
@@trulytuna3765 Giselle is better than Karina NOW. You get it? NOW.
When did giselle improve over karina(not saying its wrong, just wondering)
Clean approach and consistent support giselle, karina can be throaty sometimes
@@navisoori5391 i see, thanks for explaining
Yo Giselle is better then Karina??
And people have the audacity to say shes talentless
Where’s Ireh:(
It's the top 15
Karina D+/C-
Kyujin D+/C-
Sullyoon D+
Giselle D/D+
So Karina and kyujin should be higher
First up Kyujin and Karina are not C- they must get consistent and fuller with B4 which they're not. Also lately sullyoon and Giselle have shown a bolder approach which has helped them improve and surpass karina and kyujin. All of these girls are D+ none is C-. If jeongyeon is not C- how can karina and kyujin become C-
Nope
Giselle D+/C- same as karina and sullyoon too
This is so random💀
How? Is it bcuz of Purple Kiss?
@@user-dy1cz4tf4f i think yes
Exactly
How is it random…. Their comparing the top 3 known groups with the best vocals lines
lily number one! its true ❤
Im sorry but this list is not good lmao. I feel like its biased.
Karina ain't 10th
Swan and chaein must be top 5 atleast..u never listen they singing live thats y..n u never see they cover psycho from redvelvet and cover eng song ,i can bet even nmixx trio cant beat trio from purplekiss,.swan , goeun and chaein is the best vocalist
Sorry but kyujin vocals better than Karina and Giselle
2022.10 updated
Kyujin D+ (close to C-)
Giselle D+
Please tell me how Kyujin is C-. Give logical reasons lol
@@dumbdumb1853 watch Dice by nmixx
@@chamikaroshani6318 What's new in there
Karina is D+/C-
@@hwjinlix Karina is not C- she's D+ tho. She's nowhere near consistent on B4 so how is she C-
Imo chaein is a better vocalist than swan considering that she as a wider range by a little bit
for me:
1.Lily (B+)
2.Haewon (B)
3.NingNing (C+)
4.Goeun (C)
5.Winter (C)
6.Kyujin (C-)
7.Swan (D+/C-)
8.Chaein/Sullyoon (D+)
9.Karina/Jinni(💔)/Jiwoo/Giselle (D+)
10.Bae (D)
11.Jieun (E/F+)
Dosie is better than jieun she is E+
@@Verowinday777Jieun is actually better than Dosie but RBW never lets her utilise all her potential bcuz she was in charge of lower singing, check some of her independent covers before she left ^^ Dosie did surprise me with the higher notes in Sweet Juice but she could definitely work a bit more on her vocals since her dance is already perfect
This is wrong
Jieun doesn't deserve to be so low 💜💜
true but she never got many lines unfortunately to show her vocal potential in purki songs, she showed her vocal capacity in covers better
Kyujin is higher than Karina i believe.
Now, yes I think. But this ranking is """old"""
but isnt Sully and Kyujin around the same vocal tier? Like last I heard both are C-, except Kyujin is more trained in low tones and has chestier and fuller voice while Sullyoon is better at higher pitch
my ranking
1.swan、lily
2.goeun
3.ningning
4.heawon
5.winter
Delusional. Vocal technique isn't based on opinions, so u ranking them based on ur opinion is useless bc no professional vocal coach will listen to u
Ehhhh lilys voice is way too shrill and breathy for me. Purple kiss vocals rate higher for me, but Ningning is def first and winter second.
She's shrill and breathy for u bc u don't like her tone whereas vocal technique isn't based on tone kid
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc so? Doesn’t change the fact it doesn’t sound good kid
@@Linalina-nn1vx for u it doesn't.
@@Linalina-nn1vx ningning is first for u bc of her tone and not vocal technique. It's pretty obvious yk nothing Abt vocal technique and ur proving just that💀
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc you can say whatever you want, but there’s a reason Ningning is more popular 😂 you can get all butt hurt as you want, but doesn’t change the fact lily is just gonna fade away as another member of a gg while Ningning is just gonna get better and better 🤡
Tbh
Karina>Giselle>Kyujin>Sullyoon:)
@Loona the world Literally like every peeps thinking that just bc she did a high note so she became better 🤦bro she is still D+
no….
@@san-ps3fyyes, bc Karina is high D+/C-, Kyujin and Giselle is high D+(but Giselle is little bit better) and Sullyoon is only D+.
@@rimkim21 and your rebuttal is only "support range" lmao, do you even understand technique vocals other than that? like he said?
😂🎲🎲
haewon💞
where's dosie and ireh???
this was before sweet juice era, they used to have very few lines and their vocals weren’t that well showcased as rbw focused more on giving them spotlight during dance breaks and stuff like that… they’re definitely deserving of a higher rank now
only top 15 in the video
como poner a swan hasta ese número...
I will not rank all of them but my top6
1.Haewon (I prefer her tone over Lily's, and her voice is just gorgeous and very powerful but still she has a light tone, which doesn't allow her to sound as sassy as Lily for example)
2.Winter (She has one of my favourite voices in kpop, and her tone is pretty unique, that girl is just starting!-)
3.Ningning (Is a close one to Winter, but with a rather warm, soft tone)
4.Sullyoon (amazing vocals! and she shines in the softer parts, not because of weakness or whatever, her voice just fits rather soft parts)
5.Lily (she's wonderful, probably the best vocalists of this (4th) generation, but I'm not the biggest fan of her tone.. Also she sings with lots of fierceness, she sounds sassy even in calm songs and that bothers me a little if I'm honest -
6. BAE: she was at a store (with another member) and they were buying their own album, then cool (your rainbow) started playing and it was just her and that little mic and she sounded so gorgeous and stable, she doesn't need to be the main to ace with her charming vocals- Nmixx songs are not good enough for their wonderful voices, so sad.. So far the only good song and suitable for their vocals/raps was 'your rainbow'
Also I know it's their opinion, but: I don't think Gigi is a better vocalist than Chaein or Rina - Gigi is the weakest vocalist in aespa and her main position is to rap! Meanwhile Rina is a main dancer, but you cannot compare her to Lisa as an example, because Rina is a better vocalist, Karina is is more like Jennie a rapper who can sing and could maybe be or is a lead-vocalist, (my world mini album proves it), and I don't mean high notes wise ~ Anyways I still respect your opinion 🦋
Vocal technique isnt based on opinions. Ok? What if Giselle is the main rapper, that doesn't take away from her supporting. Jiwoo is main rapper but she supports also Giselle isn't the weakest vocalist in Aespa anymore
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc Who said that vocal technique is based on opinions? - As the owner gave their opinion I gave mine + I truly study about music and voices so I know what I'm talking about, and with the last comeback of aespa you can definitely tell Gigi is the least vocalist ^^ doesn't mean she's bad but she's not at Karina's level
Lily's tone is not the best one but she has a wonderful technique, and her voice is really impressive, I rather Haewon's tone and she's also wonderful technically-wise, Haewon is more of warm but powerful, Lily sounds strong and sassy. Winter probably has my favourite tone in aespa she's not better than Lily technically, but she's also wonderful, she sounds fierce and very stable. Ningning sounds warm, soft and calm and I also prefer her tone over Lily, but once again Lily is better technically talking- Bae also has a nice voice, her vocals still have a lot to show but she has proven many times that you don't need to be a main vocalist to shine.. And Sullyoon, that woman sounds really gorgeous, she can fit many concepts but I think softer songs make her shine the most. No worries cus I know about: textures, tones, colours, ranges, belting, heady, mixed voice, falsetto, chest voice, technique, voice types, etc.
@@L14U9N9 this was outdated tho...
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc Yes, cus I wanted to add more things, but just added, didn't remove anything my opinion is still the same. Now you can read my previous comment and give nice arguments
LMFAOx100000000000 This rankig is a joke
Let me guess, there is no reason at all why you disagree, you just do
Giselle > Chaein / Sully > Swan (even knowing how difficult it is to maintain the high note of 'DICE'?) ??? So biased
Ning ning can easily be higher then haewon
No. They’re far apart.
Winter is no 1 for me
On Boi you trying to be bias
@@cassandraadea5536 its "for me". And im not even an Aespa fan
LOL
@@mariahlol2488 lol
@@nouraaz27 LOL
Lets be real here Giselle cant sing.
Ma'm... tf
Lol
She can lmao
ig jieun, bae, jiwoo, jinni, kyujin, karina, and chaein cant skng either then 🤷♀️
Wait what?
It has nothing to do with the video, but does anyone know the support and vocal range of the purple Kiss members? i really need it.
I only know their belting notes
Goeun Bb3?-B5 (strongest vocalist in pk)
Swan lows??-A4/Bb4
Chaein A3-A4/Bb4(one of the best lower registers in the 4th gen)
Dosie Bb3/B3-G4/G#4
@@dino.nuggies2382 Why do you not know for Ireh, Yuki and Jieun?
@@episode40 I know yuki can’t support
I got dosies supported range from a friend… and I think jieun can support.
Ireh idk about her
@@dino.nuggies2382 Thanks.
Giselle would prob be 14
no-
@@ValentinaFlowersi mean personally i think she is very shallow and doesn't really engage much with her diaphragm while singing, thats why i usually put her in low weak to average
For Me:
1.Lily
2.Ningning
3.Haewon
4.Swan
5.Goeun
6.Winter
7.Sullyoon
8.Chaein
9.Karina
10.Giselle
11.Kyujin
12.Bae
13.Dosie
14.Jiwoo
15.Ireh
16.Yuki
Vocal
Haewon B- >Ningning C+
@@user-ch8fm3zf4w yeah I know that but my ranking is not all about technique.It’s just my opinion
@@meviaally no way you vocal is renga
Why would u erase Jieun 💀💀
@@episode40She erase Jinni too. I think it's because they are no longer in their group 😢