Tories mock Kate Forbes for 'not breaking the law' by balancing Scottish budget

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
  • In a debate by Scotland’s Finance Secretary Shona Robison, about the forth coming UK and Scottish budget, Murdo Fraser and Kate Forbes clashed over a series of questions.
    Ms Forbes egged Mr Murdo on to tell her how many times the Scottish Government had balanced its budget over the last 17 years.
    Mr Murdo replied that The Deputy First Minister was trying to get him to congratulate the Scottish Government for not breaking the law.
    www.theScottish...
    / thescottishsun
    / scottishsun
    #scotland #snp #kateForbes #politics

КОМЕНТАРІ • 77

  • @vtechead1
    @vtechead1 3 дні тому +15

    I’m sure she will sleep soundly, knowing that those living in homes with flammable cladding, are not going to get their homes made safe, now that the money the UK Gov gave the SNP to do the work has gone awol. (£97 million )

    • @ianscott3180
      @ianscott3180 3 дні тому +3

      You mean the lucky ones that have homes.

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      @@vtechead1 I wouldn't trust the tories or Labour kick them l out

    • @vtechead1
      @vtechead1 День тому

      @@barbaraurquhart2276 but you trust the SNP with 22 and counting polic enquires into them and their finances.
      House raided, Sturgeon and hubby arrested, then Murrell charged with embezzlement.
      Billions missing that was sent up by the UK Gov to help Scotland during covid, cannot be accounted for.
      £100 million given to the SNP to replace flammable cladding on Scots homes, gone elsewhere, putting lives at risk of all those living in unsafe buildings.
      £33 million ringfenced for Agriculture, missing, and nobody can or will not say where it went.
      Matheson hapoy to steal £11 grand from Scots taxpayers to pay his ipad bill- till he was caught.
      NHS A&E waiting times getting WORSE, waiting times for operations getting worse, and the Health Minister claims there is no crises !
      I could go on but if you trust the SNP, I can only laugh.
      They’re not down to 9 seats for nothing.

    • @vtechead1
      @vtechead1 День тому

      @@barbaraurquhart2276but you trust a party that takes £100 million from the UK Gov that was supposed to go towards replacing flammable cladding, leaving Scots with unsafe homes if a fire breaks out. You trust a party that took £33 million ringfenced for agriculture, and cannot/ will not say where it went. You trust a party that the leaders house was raided, she and hubby arrested, and him charged with embezzlement. You trust a party that backed Matheson after he was going to rob Scots taxpayers of £11,000 after racking up an ipad bill on holiday - till he was found out.
      Billions missing from covid money given by the UK Gov.
      Yeah, the party you can trust 😂😂😂

  • @keithduff8158
    @keithduff8158 3 дні тому +17

    Where's the missing £100 million for cladding 😅

  • @philstabler
    @philstabler 2 дні тому +2

    Hmm 2008 crash was coursed by a Scottish banker boss.

  • @lionelmcmillan7984
    @lionelmcmillan7984 3 дні тому +16

    Its time the SNP cancelled the Internation Development Fund and The Climate Justice fund to Malawi, Rwandan and Zambia which costs us Scottish taxpayers over £30m a year.
    The leaders of these 3 countries probley have health Swiss bank accounts at our expenses.

    • @johncarney9049
      @johncarney9049 7 годин тому

      I agree IF you have evidence to back up your claim. Until then it is nothing more than speculation and the problem with the world now a days is that everything has become speculation and not enough fact. Why are you adding to the mess?

  • @GRUMPY0254
    @GRUMPY0254 3 дні тому +23

    Congratulations SNP, you are helping the Cumbrian economy enormously with your policies. Businesses are crossing the border and setting up because of your stupid policies. 👏👏

    • @graemeross1998
      @graemeross1998 3 дні тому +2

      😂😂😂 really

    • @GRUMPY0254
      @GRUMPY0254 3 дні тому +4

      @@graemeross1998 .Yes really. 👍👍👍

    • @lionelmcmillan7984
      @lionelmcmillan7984 3 дні тому +5

      Why hasn't any of MSP put forward a motion of no confidence in this corrupted SNP adminstration at Hollyrood,are they all scared Refrom will get a foot hold in Scotland.

    • @billstewart7457
      @billstewart7457 3 дні тому +2

      Vote Reform

    • @RonBryson-i2k
      @RonBryson-i2k 3 дні тому +2

      Correct and I will be crossing the border next month to the Lake District but will buy my Xmas drink whilst down there.

  • @jamesalexander4926
    @jamesalexander4926 3 дні тому +4

    Staunch Rangers man is Murdo

    • @eleanorcrawford9978
      @eleanorcrawford9978 3 дні тому +4

      What has that got to do with the state Scotland football won’t save Scotland and its problems. Some people shouldn’t vote.

    • @jamesalexander4926
      @jamesalexander4926 3 дні тому +2

      @@eleanorcrawford9978 It was Rangers fans that stopped independence.

    • @Rosie-uk4jh
      @Rosie-uk4jh 3 дні тому

      Yes and Frightened pensioners,

    • @julianshepherd2038
      @julianshepherd2038 3 дні тому

      ​@@eleanorcrawford9978you don't know much about the Conservative and Unionist Party or Scotland

  • @mikee66
    @mikee66 3 дні тому +13

    Embarrassing SNP

    • @JohnedwardScullion
      @JohnedwardScullion 3 дні тому

      Realy????😮😮

    • @grww4056
      @grww4056 3 дні тому +2

      @@JohnedwardScullion corrupt SNP.

    • @lorrainekerr8749
      @lorrainekerr8749 3 дні тому +1

      House jocks are embarrassing.

    • @grww4056
      @grww4056 3 дні тому +2

      @@JohnedwardScullion oh dear….😂

    • @gazzthered5659
      @gazzthered5659 3 дні тому +1

      ​@@JohnedwardScullion tell me that you're not brainwashed without telling me you're not brainwashed 😂😂😂

  • @matteeeiscool6912
    @matteeeiscool6912 3 дні тому +12

    Kate Forbes , what a disaster , is this the best Scotland can find !!!

    • @desgilroy1357
      @desgilroy1357 3 дні тому

      Naw, that's Swinney apparently.

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      Better than the tories or Labour the pensioners will be booing Labour anyway thei will be a lot of pensioners won't make it through the winter because ot Labour and they don't give a hoot all they do is slate the tories and blame them we all know the tories made a mess but why pick on the pensioners and the poor instead of the rich

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      ​@@desgilroy1357but I will say one thing the snpvwoul have won their seats back that they lost if they had not copied keir starmer and Rachel theives over the winter fuel payments that was awful

  • @peterscraig1673
    @peterscraig1673 3 дні тому +2

    Does the UK financeSCOTLAND WITH BORROWED MONIES

    • @tallywacker43
      @tallywacker43 7 годин тому

      no scotland pay in taxes and get a small portion back.

  • @JohnedwardScullion
    @JohnedwardScullion 3 дні тому +5

    You just seen a scottish torry minister say scotland wad faild by his party he is 100 percent correct and we a have always been faild by both the tory party and the dreadfull labour party 😮😮😮

    • @thetruthisoutthere2076
      @thetruthisoutthere2076 3 дні тому +1

      The grammar in your statement is terrible.

    • @eleanorcrawford9978
      @eleanorcrawford9978 3 дні тому +3

      Not as bad as the failings of the SNP.

    • @JohnedwardScullion
      @JohnedwardScullion 3 дні тому +1

      @@thetruthisoutthere2076 we cant all be perfect every time and our independence is in the post just check out salvo libaration and weep ha ha

    • @thetruthisoutthere2076
      @thetruthisoutthere2076 3 дні тому +1

      @@JohnedwardScullion grammar again. There should be an apostrophe in the word “can’t” . Also it is liberation, not libaration. Apart from that it is a good thing that you can dream or fantasise re independence, something that will never happen.

    • @eleanorcrawford9978
      @eleanorcrawford9978 3 дні тому

      @@thetruthisoutthere2076 oh shut up

  • @peterscraig1673
    @peterscraig1673 3 дні тому +4

    HOW DID THE CONSERVATIVES GET INTO SO MUCH DEBT

    • @eleanorcrawford9978
      @eleanorcrawford9978 3 дні тому +2

      They never it’s all lies by the Labour. It’s an excuse to raise taxes. Blaming the heating allowance that our grandparents relieve not the invasion of migrants KP living in luxury in hotels that’s draining the economy.

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому +1

      @@peterscraig1673 the tories made such a mess and labour are no better

  • @julianshepherd2038
    @julianshepherd2038 3 дні тому +4

    Every Scottish Government spends within its money
    No Westminster Government spends within its money

    • @topnotchpiperdad
      @topnotchpiperdad 3 дні тому +3

      Pity they have waisted billions over the years, and financed terror.

    • @christopherfranklin972
      @christopherfranklin972 3 дні тому +5

      Care to explain the whereabouts of the 'ring fenced' £97 million for cladding and £33 million for agriculture?

    • @desgilroy1357
      @desgilroy1357 3 дні тому +1

      🦄🤡💩

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      ​@@christopherfranklin972care to explain why keir starmer and Rachel theives is picking on the pensioners and the poor disgusting and it is going to get worse in October time to boot out keir starmer and Rachel theives

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      Care to explain why labour are picking on the pensioners and the poor and it is goingvto get worse in the October budget labour used to be for the country and the people but no more keir starmer is more tory than Labour time he got booted out I hope at the Scottish elections both the tories and labour get kicked out of Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @RonBryson-i2k
    @RonBryson-i2k 3 дні тому +11

    Well done Murdo at last someone saying it how it is and exposing that shower of no hopers.

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      Why should she break the law if she had broke the law the tories would have slated her even worse I hope the tories and labour don't win a single seat at the next election I hope keir starmer and Rachel theives and the tories that mad an awful mess of the country for fourteen years get booted out of Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      I wouldn't vote for any tory or Labour

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      What would murdo frazer want kste forbes to break the law if she had the tories would have had a field day about that better being truthful

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      I meant to say kate forbes

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 День тому

      And leave this answer on

  • @catherine999
    @catherine999 3 дні тому +4

    Has everyone got a cold? No wonder they’re all ill in that place

  • @rossrennie182
    @rossrennie182 3 дні тому +3

    Release the Sausages

  • @sunrayisdown1690
    @sunrayisdown1690 2 дні тому +2

    More sunshite

  • @redacted629
    @redacted629 7 годин тому +1

    @8:14 The goal must never be to get more money to spend but rather to address the key responsibilities in a cost effective manner.

  • @patricktracey7424
    @patricktracey7424 19 годин тому +1

    if we are the fastest growing economy why are we paying sky high taxes, losing essential services, pensioners about to die in droves during winter.

  • @DavidLockett-x4b
    @DavidLockett-x4b 2 дні тому +1

    “The best laid schemes o' mice an' men / Gang aft a-gley.”

  • @scary19682
    @scary19682 3 дні тому +4

    Well said Bro Fraser 🇬🇧

  • @johncarney9049
    @johncarney9049 7 годин тому

    If mocking is all the Tories have - then they have nothing at all. Typical childish politics from the kids in the room. That is all the tories have to offer and all they ever had,.

  • @gardengnome2409
    @gardengnome2409 23 години тому +1

    Kate Forbes is comedy gold. She makes Diane Abbot look like a rocket scientist. Islanders 🤣🤣🤣