QnA With Baradwaj Rangan | Beast | Nelson Dilipkumar | Vijay | Pooja Hegde | Anirudh Ravichander

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 кві 2022
  • #Galattaplus #QnABaradwajRangan #BR #Beast #NelsonDilipkumar #Vijay #PoojaHegde #AnirudhRavichander #YogiBabu #RedinKingsley #BaradwajranganOnBeast #Baradwajranganreview
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    In Association with Divo :
    Website - web.divo.in/
    Instagram - / divomovies
    Facebook - / divomovies
    Twitter - / divomovies beast review
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 328

  • @saimadhusudanan
    @saimadhusudanan 2 роки тому +373

    Saddest thing about Beast movie is all the lost potential with such a wonderful one liner "RAW agent suffering from PTSD combats his inner demons and saves the day" , alas we got this half baked excuse for a screenplay

    • @kenadams6839
      @kenadams6839 2 роки тому +24

      I was literally cheering myself up when Veera was having that Dilemma abt not helping that crying kid while hiding in the mall !! But then again .. It felt like NELSON planned everything out but somehow forgot abt it !!!

    • @immortalmonkuaking679
      @immortalmonkuaking679 2 роки тому +4

      @@kenadams6839 atm scenario where he get dreams of future or some time it will happen in near future

    • @nandishsiva7480
      @nandishsiva7480 2 роки тому +2

      A grt one liner wasted af...!

    • @athul0687
      @athul0687 2 роки тому +3

      There's an amazon original series titled ' The Patriot' with same logline and same dry humour treatment.... Great watch

    • @gauthamks6180
      @gauthamks6180 2 роки тому

      American sniper came long back..if u guys r wondering

  • @midhun23kg17
    @midhun23kg17 2 роки тому +16

    I think jeevanantham in kaththi really shows vijay sir another dimension of acting rather than others use him wierdly...especially last scenes outside the court in kaththi...
    He completely did justice to his role in thirumalai and ghilli as well as pokkiri...
    Nanban showed his another side that he is a good actor...
    In kavalan except one scene he really did good job

  • @newgen1002
    @newgen1002 2 роки тому +154

    That question about trolling Nelson. There are 2 main reasons:
    1. Nelson talks a lot and raised the hype for the film in the interviews. Always noticed that when a guy talks a lot and doesn't deliver (Atlee with Bigil is an eg.) social media trolls will start. Lokesh never faced any such BIG backlash even though Master was not 100% fulfilling becuz ppl really like his no-nonsense character and appreciated him for the little attempt to make a DIFFERENT vijay movie atleast!!
    2. Vijay fans trying to save their star from trolls. So most of it was targeted on Nelson.

    • @HARIHARAN-or3cc
      @HARIHARAN-or3cc 2 роки тому +28

      Most importantly he agreed all of his mistakes in a interview,thats why people like Lokesh than Nelson

    • @stark014
      @stark014 2 роки тому +10

      He didn't talks lot bro he always said this movie for only thalapathy fans he never said this movie is masterpiece or something like that 🙂

    • @newgen1002
      @newgen1002 2 роки тому +8

      @@HARIHARAN-or3cc very true! He was very genuine in that BR interview

    • @newgen1002
      @newgen1002 2 роки тому +8

      @@stark014 no..many ppl don't understand why he was so confident in those interviews. Let me also add another thing. Fans of Vijay wanted to save their star, and that's why Nelson got many trolls too

    • @stark014
      @stark014 2 роки тому +4

      @@newgen1002 I think that's his character

  • @loubloom8370
    @loubloom8370 2 роки тому +25

    When the title credit roll in after the death of that little girl with slow bgm, I was like - damn !! It's going to be good !

  • @christoalphonsejoshy
    @christoalphonsejoshy 2 роки тому +30

    Nelson already wrote the script earlier. He said he wrote the script for Vijay in mind but he forgot to write a script for the audience which Vijay is a part of

  • @prabsworld2074
    @prabsworld2074 2 роки тому +15

    If AR murugadas directed beast movie it would have been better screen play ....

  • @sarcoma5106
    @sarcoma5106 2 роки тому +10

    So the simple ground rules that i understood are
    1. If u r writing for a big star, think about impressing the haters,reviewers.. because that's out of your comfort zone.. not just to impress fans.. this will make a good movie and fans willl be proud
    2. If you want great characters in your movie, you should have crafted and travelled with them for at least 2-3 years before introducing in your script..
    3. If you want a great scene, write a scene for 1 day and then kill the writer in your mind and review, insult,troll the scene logically for 10 days..
    Every creation starts with just one person and spreads across masses.. so the person should never loose their integrity and do justice to themself while writing 👍🏻👍🏻

  • @vc6444
    @vc6444 2 роки тому +76

    In the round table Nelson said that he only takes 3 months to write a script. My doubts about how beast would be, started when he said that. Watching beast it is clear Nelson needs to spend more time on the script or even get other writers in on his writing process.

    • @maniram9118
      @maniram9118 2 роки тому +1

      Same here

    • @nandishsiva7480
      @nandishsiva7480 2 роки тому +5

      Yeah..same..In another interview he said his main goal is to make money and further justifies tats y we all here for..! High time for him to change this intent...!

    • @vc6444
      @vc6444 2 роки тому +1

      @@manojlds There is a reason why this space under the video is called the comments section. You comment as you watch the video. I only affirmed and added to what BR said and also added my own points that Nelson should spend more time on his scripts or bring in other writers in his writing process.

    • @vc6444
      @vc6444 2 роки тому +1

      @@rajirvin1 Anybody who spent time and money and saw the movie are reviewers too bro, no matter whoever they are. Don't belittle anyone.

    • @sivaprasa1782
      @sivaprasa1782 Рік тому

      @@rajirvin1 shut up

  • @PagalNixon
    @PagalNixon 2 роки тому +33

    I have not seen any vijay movie which is bested Thupaki so far, the comedy, the tension, the heroism was fantastic and you see the hero fallen in the hands of the villian and we feel at one point how in the hell hero is going to come out of this trap. It was one of the finely made intelligent script i have not seen in a while. There should be another movie like Thuppaki

    • @yogeshreddy6002
      @yogeshreddy6002 2 роки тому +4

      Well said. All time fav movie. A complete package.

    • @sathyananda5688
      @sathyananda5688 2 роки тому +1

      It would be much better if they removed annoying Kajal Agarwal scenes

  • @rahulrnair8540
    @rahulrnair8540 2 роки тому +113

    Really wanna see vijay in proper story , script and characterization leaving fanism away... Pushpa character speaks than Allu.. Rocky made fans than Yash... Basically wanna see him in a character... I think "Rayappan" is the nly chara he did recently...tht also ended abruptly

    • @skybebop2870
      @skybebop2870 2 роки тому +33

      JD is better characterized than pushpa and rocky but no one wants to have that conversation.

    • @rahulrnair8540
      @rahulrnair8540 2 роки тому +35

      @@skybebop2870 JD is good but second half lost tht charm.. something missing feeling i don't know...JD's first intro to Juvenile home is all time favourite entries of Vijay... Master is undoubtedly best outing of Vijay in recent years..T67 should be lokesh..a 💯 lokesh padam

    • @rahulrnair8540
      @rahulrnair8540 2 роки тому +7

      @@skybebop2870 production house issue also there... promotion,dubbing,no effort... equally we should respect the language no...in Kerala Tamil no issue... Telugu Hindi Kannada should need extra care... halamathi song and all they killed literally

    • @dilushselva5540
      @dilushselva5540 2 роки тому +19

      @@skybebop2870 I agree, JD was a complex character - the shoulder thing in pushpa was a bit random and rocky is just a mass character - not much depth there. I loved that Lokesh didn't explain why JD became an alcoholic, no melodramatic backstory. Him giving up drinking is fine - but he completely reverted to the standard Vijay we see in all his films. It was a let down. Jeevanantham in Kaththi i think is one of his more refreshing roles - a vulnerable, emotional guy that still has the qualities of a real life hero.. Standing up for what is right, not having super human strength and arrogance.

    • @imrahul86
      @imrahul86 2 роки тому +2

      @@skybebop2870
      First come out of hypocrisy atleast now. JD is just regular character bhavani character stole the show in the movie.
      Vijay on his part is picking good directors it is the director who is not managing his star power with their sensibilities.
      AR Murugadoss did that perfectly in Thupakki and Kathi.
      I am terribly disappointed with Lokesh and Nelson.
      Next one will be typical telugu masala kind of movie . I hope directors afters that bring that balance.

  • @techieeesara8453
    @techieeesara8453 2 роки тому +27

    Okay to settle all this I request you to arrange a one on one interview with nelson directly like you did with Lokesh after master. So that let us hear from him directly. Let him admit what he thought and what went wrong.

    • @techieeesara8453
      @techieeesara8453 2 роки тому +10

      @@uvanraja3356 like lokesh did ....see brother no one will cautiously commit mistake I am referring to the writting and directing only..he would have calculated something and it dint work out. But the amount of hate he is receiving is not fair...abuses and all the criticism...so its better if he opens up.

    • @rinoosashraf1373
      @rinoosashraf1373 2 роки тому +6

      Agreed. As Nelson being the captain of the ship, he is almost responsible for the movie, but that doesnt mean he needs to be trolled this badly. He directed two good movies and failures are part of this industry. I hope he accepts his mistakes just like Lokesh did

  • @shivishere93
    @shivishere93 2 роки тому +7

    The problem is all these new age directors has exceptional potential and make great 1 or 2 movies. Once they get the opportunity to handle a bigger hero, they heed to their stardom rather than playing their own strength. The ability to convince mega stars is a skill and Tamil directors don’t have that. They become one of their fan and spoil it for themselves and movie lovers.

  • @aitchari5432
    @aitchari5432 2 роки тому +4

    Beast is a cool, light-hearted movie.. among a serious movie plotted ones. It entertained. Period.

  • @TheTamilmaghan
    @TheTamilmaghan 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you, very well made segment. Loved it. Kudos for the amazing content that you keep on providing.

  • @Nothing_like_nathaniel
    @Nothing_like_nathaniel 2 роки тому +1

    This was great sir watching you answer the questions helps the audience understand so much and I’m sure more people would pool in to watch your reviews

  • @stevensong3689
    @stevensong3689 2 роки тому +17

    People need to know why 'Kaidhi' movie ran better than expected even when a big star (Vijay) movie was competiting... Because people watch movies now don't compromise for works done before, people watch for what the movie content more than the start cast...
    Beast movie was not convincing for Vijay fan who prase the movie just to see Vijay... The story of beast is great but the screenplay is not convincing to connect the story continuously till the end of the movie... Don't support Nelson for what mistakes he done in Beast... Atleast in next movie he will/have to recover just becoz he got the movie chance just by voice narration...

  • @rupesh9569
    @rupesh9569 2 роки тому +9

    Very well reviewed and explained the faults and mistakes of the movie "Beast" in detail. 👍 If Director Nelson takes these feedback constructively, he can definitely make a better movie the next time. All the best Nelson for your next movie 👍

  • @eelavanjanarthanan8117
    @eelavanjanarthanan8117 2 роки тому +2

    I love this mans videos. Very straightforward and educational in a cinematic perspective

  • @bhuvanashiva9032
    @bhuvanashiva9032 2 роки тому +9

    BR's apparel is getting more and more gangstery after joining galatta.. Maybe In a couple of months, rangan vaathiyar is gonna start wearing heavy gold chains and sporting fancy canes...Eagerly waiting for the drug lord baddie getup!

  • @saimadhusudanan
    @saimadhusudanan 2 роки тому +67

    Of course big stars like Vijay are to blame for so many reasons, but the other half of blame should definitely fall on Nelson too. This film had the laziest writing in a vijay movie in a long long time. At the end of the day Nelson wanted to make a quick buck and good for him.
    Also movies like Beast and Valimai make Atlee look the GOAT of commercial cinema

    • @gopinathm.p1924
      @gopinathm.p1924 2 роки тому +18

      After watching beast and valimai, my respect for Atlee, ar murugadoss increased massively. It's not easy to do a big star commercial movie at all 😂😂

    • @christoalphonsejoshy
      @christoalphonsejoshy 2 роки тому +10

      Yes. Also, the respect for Shankar is increased. Looks like Atlee learnt from the best (shankar). Atlee never experimented with vijay except for Rayappan and he did a job in exploiting Vijay's stardom until the breaking point called Bigil.

    • @christoalphonsejoshy
      @christoalphonsejoshy 2 роки тому +6

      @@gopinathm.p1924 ARM wasted Rajini in Darbar, though. I mean Darbar was outright bad and makes Sarkar a better film.

    • @gopinathm.p1924
      @gopinathm.p1924 2 роки тому +2

      @@christoalphonsejoshy ya Darbar was the lowest point of ar murugadoss. Apart from that, i would say his movies with big stars were atleast decent. Nothing was bad as beast

    • @counterpoint9260
      @counterpoint9260 2 роки тому +1

      blame the audiences who help these films make 200cr...

  • @anug14
    @anug14 2 роки тому +9

    4:58 valimai also had lot of effort in their stunts, i believe for unbelievable stunts to work is audience actually wants it to happen so bad then it will work. Sometimes people would usually want their favorite actors doing such stuff but general audience go by emotions.

  • @ritesh2769
    @ritesh2769 2 роки тому +8

    Don't care much about negative comments here, you will definitely get a bunch of them from the huge fan base, so chill

  • @cherubic6223
    @cherubic6223 2 роки тому +8

    Hey you should do a post release interview with Nelson like the one with Lokesh

    • @visual_audiosymphony
      @visual_audiosymphony 2 роки тому +1

      Not after this much degrading. Maybe Film Companion will do one

  • @TSSproductionz
    @TSSproductionz 2 роки тому +25

    Actors salaries are an issue even in Hollywood.
    Although it makes sense that if they were to reduce the salaries then the movies would benefit, but also I think these big stars have really worked hard to be in the position that they’re in. No one in regular life would even be judged this much for how much money they’re getting paid. The struggles of being a celebrity I guess.

    • @kathirvel5278
      @kathirvel5278 2 роки тому +3

      But the thing there is that, a Robert Downey Jr will not take the same remuneration for The Avengers and The Judge. The salary is proportional to the budget of the film there. Here, whatever the film is, the salary is just exponentially growing from the previous film.

    • @rishijagtap2968
      @rishijagtap2968 2 роки тому +3

      But the market of Hollywood is huge. They have multiple contries under their belt. China is one of their biggest territory. Vijay and Ajith don't have market outside a few territories. Beast and Valimai were huge failures in the Hindi market and other states too...

    • @devilsadvocate5391
      @devilsadvocate5391 2 роки тому

      @@rishijagtap2968 Exactly. The hero of the movie was not allu arjun nor the director was rajamouli. These two have fans all over india even though they are from south where most of the movies don't reach audience in the north. Hindi audience are a huge market.

    • @TSSproductionz
      @TSSproductionz 2 роки тому

      @@kathirvel5278 I think the fair thing to do is for them to cut a percentage from the movie afterwards. But believe me, if it’s a hit (trust me whether it’s bad or good Vijay and Ajith movies are always making bank) they’ll end up making much more then they would if they were paid upfront. A lot of producers wouldn’t like that deal with a huge star. Trust me there’s more to it. These producers just want them to take less money upfront with no percentage cuts from the total. Beast being an average movie has nothing to do with the amount of money Vijay gets, it all comes down to the script being weak. In fact everyone’s raving about the stunt work, the mall set, the music, etc…….. people are just trying to fit everything into their narrative for their own benefit.

    • @TSSproductionz
      @TSSproductionz 2 роки тому

      @@devilsadvocate5391 you really think Allu Arjun has a bigger audience in Hindi than Vijay? Why cuz of butaboma and Pushpa?

  • @kathirvel5278
    @kathirvel5278 2 роки тому +51

    I completely agree with BR with all the answers except 19:09 because I strongly feel an actor should be wise enough only to choose his script and after that, it should be left to the director entirely. If an actor wants to involve, it could solely be in the discussion phase and definitely not after the movie has gone to the floors. The director needs to have the command and capability on the sets and the actors are meant to just do what they are asked to (they can improvise here and there, that's fine). Only when a director has this command, he can make a film with the kind of vision they began with. It's the director who is seeing the monitor, sitting with the editor, sitting with the music director, so he'd know to remodel a scene or bring a different perspective on the edit table or whatever, leading to creating whatever they have envisaged.

    • @ursyedis
      @ursyedis 2 роки тому +10

      I think what he meant is someone like Vijay sethupathi, madhavan. For example in super deluxe even though TK is dictatorial kinda director VJS still went and said on how his felt character should behave which even TK agreed. It's not about ego it's about how they can collaborate and bring a better movie.

    • @kathirvel5278
      @kathirvel5278 2 роки тому +1

      @@ursyedis even what I mentioned has nothing to do with ego. It's simply because if there is any interference with opinions on the sets, it'll cloud the judgement of the director. I also recall the Vikram Vedha example like Vjs proposed the climax approach and his entry shot. Those worked out, well and good. But my point is, we've also heard so many many cases where actors have interfered or someone else interfered with the script and it going haywire. Even in the past, or even Hollywood, if you take the greatest actors, they would have done best in the given scene only and not gotten intellectually involved in the scene itself. It's the director's job and conception

  • @user-hq8wm8giyujcg
    @user-hq8wm8giyujcg 2 роки тому +11

    only if producers, otts and audience focus on highly talented Indian writers and directors whether established, under rated, new comers, and give them absolute freedom and let them make whatever they want, and however they want only then the quantity of unique, highly localized, quality content with wide variety will increase

  • @caddyvas1
    @caddyvas1 2 роки тому +2

    Baddy bro.. Excellent answer for the question 13:35. I had that in my mind too.

  • @rakesha9176
    @rakesha9176 2 роки тому +5

    People complaining about doctor part is too cringe in Beast whereas No one is complaining about Rocky calling the heroine as "Entertainment". This is way more cringey

    • @adeptgamezone8457
      @adeptgamezone8457 2 роки тому +2

      When a person got too much hatred everyone will criticise everything kgf is too bad but majority thinks that is great 😆😆

    • @tamizhvendhanm111
      @tamizhvendhanm111 2 роки тому

      Not entertainment..company nu soluvaru

  • @tvsriram77
    @tvsriram77 2 роки тому +3

    Won't they even run this with a few folks before going to production. It felt like a fit movie for Mirchi Siva and the spoof.

  • @visual_audiosymphony
    @visual_audiosymphony 2 роки тому +4

    Kollywood is a actor centric industry

    • @visual_audiosymphony
      @visual_audiosymphony 2 роки тому

      @@what5791 I am not into Telugu as I watched the obvious Telugu movie, Bahubali(that too in Tamil haha). But my statement is unlike Hollywood or the recently transformed Bollywood (which might need a argument) which are director centric industry. All the people here expect the actors to take the good decisions but complain the director for the miss (I am talking like from Vettaikaran).

    • @jayceekarp
      @jayceekarp 2 роки тому

      @@what5791 there are people like nani, vjd in telugu also

  • @anandprakash4330
    @anandprakash4330 2 роки тому +7

    When the same star interferes in the script writing and asks to make changes that he assumes people might like, these guy will go berserk. Here he is complaining that vijay didnt interefere and argue with the director instead of having complete faith on him. Double standards .

  • @m.avinash8862
    @m.avinash8862 2 роки тому +11

    1:20 Murugadoss wrote Thuppakki for Akshay initially, as he was busy with his commitments.... He did with Vijay and again made Holiday

    • @christoalphonsejoshy
      @christoalphonsejoshy 2 роки тому +5

      @@ABHlSHEK I heard it was narrated to suriya. Anyway, akshay's acting made holiday a cheap action film and we saw mahesh babu under muragdoss' direction in spyder. 😂🤣😆😁

    • @kenadams6839
      @kenadams6839 2 роки тому +13

      And guess what Vijay did it better than both of them !!

  • @saikrish177
    @saikrish177 2 роки тому +3

    7:02 thanks for answering BR. Yes that logic loophole(out of many!) of having 50 in one place like a student before maths teacher 😂 yeah such a sloppy writing!

    • @ayazazhar325
      @ayazazhar325 2 роки тому +3

      Also tone bro. Doctor Had Comedy that worked but still the child trafficking never seemed like a joke. Not sure how Nelson did it but he made it seem dark and serious even when having the comedy portions. i think most of that is because of shivakarthik and vinay's character writing and arch was pretty good. the tone was nicely balanced thru out. In Beast, everythings a joke, looks like a joke. There is no seriousness in this supposedly action movie dealing with terrorism after that opening sequence.

  • @mssuresh741
    @mssuresh741 2 роки тому

    Sir you are just suuuuuuupppppprrrrreeebbbb 👍👍👍👍👍 true to the fact 🙏🙏

  • @jd6431
    @jd6431 2 роки тому +2

    BR na summava🔥🔥

  • @ishuk4590
    @ishuk4590 2 роки тому +2

    I also agree with Arun Pandian sir who in recent interview talked about actor remuneration
    We just need to empower our writers and dialogue writers than paying 80% of the budget for a star salary

    • @adeptgamezone8457
      @adeptgamezone8457 2 роки тому

      It all depends on the business that star can do regardless of how good the movies are so vijay got a big fan base which includes children's and people who see movie Occasionally with their family regardless of the negative reviews he will be generating revenue for his movies if his movies are subjected to loss no one will do this big investment on him there are many people who doesn't care or know about what a good cinema is they will go to the theaters and watch beast only because of poi it got vijay and they enjoy it I think arun pandian and producer's like him are not expecting to produce good concent if they do so they would have done something good right all they want is to have more profit how can they achieve it if they can able to do movies with actors like vijay ajith rajini whom they just can't simply afford if they can get them for less salary and make a movie with less money they will get lots of profit from that that's the only reason they were speaking like that why can't they fund good directors like ram and many more if they really want content only few consider that and arun pandian is not one of them from his records of the movies he did so far

  • @ritesh2769
    @ritesh2769 2 роки тому +6

    Very good show baddy, keep this Q&A format for every movie, it's fun to watch 😀

  • @TheAathi6
    @TheAathi6 2 роки тому

    At last this segment is here!

  • @rohitsiva63
    @rohitsiva63 2 роки тому +3

    Well, u said the actor should question the director regarding the way things are shaping up, yes of course they can
    But then the directors will come saying that actors not giving the creative freedom to work with...

  • @gujonidahoud4281
    @gujonidahoud4281 2 роки тому +7

    I have so many ideas. Really make Vijay fail in his 1st attempt to catch the terrorist. Cause the child's death. Gets booted of the army for being mentally distorted and lose all the benefits of a soldier. Get a therapist who works to program Vijay again. Gets him the job in a security company. Make Shine Tom Chako the actual baddie and he causes Vijay plans to fail in the mall until we reach resolution. Now this ain't enough but somebody like me can come up with this, why can't Nelson...

  • @working8860
    @working8860 2 роки тому +8

    The beast's primary downfall was so-called " Vijay - Ajith " devoted followers who fought and degraded one other's films. 90% of the movie's life span was decided on the first day of the review, in which beast and valimai were both mocked by each other's followers, while Pushpa and rrr was celebrated with joy in other states. Stop criticising actors in movies.

  • @user-hq8wm8giyujcg
    @user-hq8wm8giyujcg 2 роки тому +6

    13:45 i think in generations after us this attitude of audience will be gone, and we should keep rejecting bad movies and demand unique, localized indian movies and give most respect to directors and writers

  • @dpods
    @dpods 2 роки тому

    Do more Q and A

  • @manas.manas.1
    @manas.manas.1 Рік тому +2

    Imagine if someone like ar murugadoss or lokesh kanagaraj directed this film
    The story demanded serious thriller like screenplay but Nelson had other plans

  • @KishoreKumar-is3qn
    @KishoreKumar-is3qn 2 роки тому +23

    Really lost my shit when Rocky called Reena for 'entertainment'. Not sure, why no one is talking about this

    • @ramakrishnamayya2678
      @ramakrishnamayya2678 2 роки тому +6

      Every review mentioned about the worst romantic line in the movie

    • @KishoreKumar-is3qn
      @KishoreKumar-is3qn 2 роки тому +5

      Sorry didn't know if they mentioned about the entertainment part, Not sure if kgf deserves periyamma illa periyappa. this is not even close to kgf1 and doesn't do justice.

    • @adeptgamezone8457
      @adeptgamezone8457 2 роки тому +1

      @@KishoreKumar-is3qn so true kgf and rrr are worst movies which cannot even considered as an typical good commercial movie both of them are I'll logical and stupid but everyone praises that kgf 2 even contradicts kgf 1s story

    • @pavanpadmanabhan1911
      @pavanpadmanabhan1911 2 роки тому

      I didn't like Reena character in KGF 2 . Except that everything else was good

  • @suriagerrard3396
    @suriagerrard3396 2 роки тому +13

    I don't think beast was that bad of a movie. Yes, it's not the best movie out there but it's not the worse also. I really liked the slow burn aspect of the movie because it is a heist/hijack genre. I just feel that they should have tapered down the action sequences and made them more realistic. Also, Tamil movies should stop this one-man army crap. That's just my opinion and I'm allowed to have one. Thank you!

  • @lalithavijjapu7413
    @lalithavijjapu7413 2 роки тому +2

    Pls make a top 10 maniratnam films

  • @nakeeransumathi1079
    @nakeeransumathi1079 2 роки тому +6

    Not surprised KK & Doctor terribly overated too. Just a blow up of big names & Anirudh saves these films by his music! Again my opinion pls feel free to have a different take. Master was so good, as such the quality of the director shows.

    • @Daily_1percent
      @Daily_1percent 2 роки тому +1

      Even doctor has illogical scenes but comedy really work out so people forget

    • @rakesha9176
      @rakesha9176 2 роки тому +1

      People forget illogical scenes when the film is entertaining. Same with RRR and KGF have illogical scenes but the way people perceived it is different and entertaining, so people tend to forgot it.

  • @ranjithss6423
    @ranjithss6423 2 роки тому +1

    I really like the way you explained everything, but I am not sure the big stars will change their way of doing movies. Like all the recent movies of tamil super stars are not done well eg. Annathe, Valimai and Beast. If these stars think differently they can make a lot of changes in Indian movies. Because they have a good fan base. Let them see this video and understand what the audience is looking for....

  • @Asha-br9dp
    @Asha-br9dp 2 роки тому +1

    19:54 💯💯💯

  • @antoneczarajanayagam357
    @antoneczarajanayagam357 2 роки тому +1

    If I was director Nelson I would have made Beast a xmas action comedy movie. Possibly add some xmas nostalgia, some side artists that audience might root for besides the hero. Instead of Vijay giving the hijackers hard time I would probably make the villains give Vijay hard time whole 1st half. Since Vijay suffers from PTSD, I would probably make Vijay realize the seriousness and becoming brave during interval. In 2nd half he battles against hijackers, untill climax and just as a finale touch when the hostages get freed one of the small girls, who was a hostage grabs two pink ballons and runs towards freedom. the end

  • @srisaru1912
    @srisaru1912 2 роки тому +6

    You and few people might say this movie is average but this move have a big scope for the second part, if Nelson could form a team of experienced and young writers with fresh mind, he can bring out an excellent 2nd part.... Everyone would like to see Vijay in that stylish look handling guns awsomely....

  • @aniruddhabetta2950
    @aniruddhabetta2950 2 роки тому +2

    this is not a bad movie but Vijay shouldn't be there, my conclusion.

  • @bhuvanashiva9032
    @bhuvanashiva9032 2 роки тому +5

    Not kidding, BR is gonna be a fashion icon in a while! Honestly, boss is just de aging!

  • @vox-populi-vox-dei-
    @vox-populi-vox-dei- 2 роки тому +1

    I already warned Nelson not to work with stars but actors. ஆனால் ஆசை யாரை விட்டது!!!!

  • @DannyDexx
    @DannyDexx 2 роки тому

    Kudos to Anil ravipudi
    He delivered good output in six months with MB

  • @srinivasansundarum6326
    @srinivasansundarum6326 2 роки тому

    Hi BG. Have you left film companion South and going on your own? Viewers could use an update please

  • @akileshnagarajan
    @akileshnagarajan 2 роки тому +1

    Can you guys revert to a slower format rather than fast cuts for these QnA's. They're supposed to feel like a discussion, not a rapid fire

  • @prasannaraju8977
    @prasannaraju8977 2 роки тому

    Looks like Br jus borrowed shirts from Cameron tucker (modern family)!😄

  • @rishuoffice2247
    @rishuoffice2247 2 роки тому +3

    Beast much better than KGF. KGF is overhyped and overrated. KGF is wat balayya and Vijaykanth made in 90s snd 2000s

  • @vikru8081
    @vikru8081 2 роки тому

    Do a QnA on KGF

  • @bunny8759
    @bunny8759 2 роки тому

    Br sir please do an ask br session for rrr. Telugu people are waiting for it.

  • @ChalakudyTales
    @ChalakudyTales 2 роки тому

    Kumaraswaram was "Peda Rap" in Beast. The message goes out to Neyveli Lignite Mines Employee Ravi Ganesan, his brother Kumar, his two sisters one who is Bharati and his elder brother. Go figure: Mumbaikars in Neyveli for past 20 years.

  • @durgadarshan7583
    @durgadarshan7583 2 роки тому +1

    Get the deep focus for nelson on beast

  • @FubbleretIn
    @FubbleretIn 8 місяців тому

    BADDY do a QnA for Leo and get Loki for a post movie interview every very soon!!

  • @Adi-tt6qb
    @Adi-tt6qb 2 роки тому

    Do an RRR Q and A also

  • @deepikas3123
    @deepikas3123 2 роки тому

    pupil before math teacher! :D

  • @SuperstarRajinikanthFan
    @SuperstarRajinikanthFan 2 роки тому +2

    People need to understand that the biggest commercial films will never be perfect. There will logical loop holes. Look at MCU films. They are made for everyone to enjoy the films. The issue is recent Big hero films from Tamil Cinema was that we saw no improvement. No intention to change the status quo. You can easily forgive over the top masala elements in RRR and KGF2 because you clearly see the effort and vision of the director.

    • @SuperstarRajinikanthFan
      @SuperstarRajinikanthFan 2 роки тому +1

      Based on what BR said, I hope Nelson will be given enough time to write a great script for Thalaivar 169

    • @maxl2062
      @maxl2062 2 роки тому +1

      Even in Beast, audience could excused the logic of it was fully engaging and entertaining. But it’s was dragging in so many parts.

    • @KumarB819
      @KumarB819 2 роки тому

      Not the effort ( How you are showing those scenes and the underlying emotions makes the logic less scenes will hit u differently than some random logic less scenes)

    • @SuperstarRajinikanthFan
      @SuperstarRajinikanthFan 2 роки тому +1

      @@KumarB819 The underlying emotion as you call it, is based on the writer's vision. Overall I need to get the feel that the team tried to give us somehow an entertaining or even new experience. Let's be honest. Not all movies are ground breaking. But as long as they are entertaining, we will watch it even for timepass.

    • @SuperstarRajinikanthFan
      @SuperstarRajinikanthFan 2 роки тому

      @@what5791 why shouldn't he get the time? After Beast turning our to be a disaster everyone from Sun Pictures and Thalaivar circle looking closely at his work. They won't rush anything.

  • @dildilip18
    @dildilip18 2 роки тому +1

    All these trolling is because of fan rivalry, they are just waiting for the other person to go down and when it happens they make sure that they dug them deep

  • @christoalphonsejoshy
    @christoalphonsejoshy 2 роки тому +1

    It is unusual for Vijay to say ok for a script when he just heard its first half since he is a person who wants a full bound script. May be he could relate with this character since satyamoorthy is one of his favourite characters and we can the shades of the character in this film as well.

    • @counterpoint9260
      @counterpoint9260 2 роки тому

      @@rajirvin1 i would blame the idiot fans who run to theaters to watch films like these..

    • @priyaroselin5632
      @priyaroselin5632 2 роки тому +1

      @@rajirvin1 oh really !!!!! Then in the same interview when nelson asked him about the movie's outcome vijay said " who knows only if movie releases we will know " ......and also vijay said that he gives his geniune effort but some movies get clicked and some get missed ......and also vijay didn't whole heartedly praise nelson by saying nelson is clear minded guy only after nelson stresses him by asking sir plz tell something good about me I am the director of this movie vijay says your clear minded ......it seems like vijay showing curtisy towards nelson .......oh come on even if you know that Nelson's outcome is not satisfactory being in the interview face to face vijay cannot tell him that you are worst nelson .....I mean which big hero is gonna say like that .....

    • @adeptgamezone8457
      @adeptgamezone8457 2 роки тому +2

      @@rajirvin1 when there is mad hate you would see strong support from the people who love the person you hate stupidly

    • @priyaroselin5632
      @priyaroselin5632 2 роки тому +2

      @@adeptgamezone8457 so true

  • @HariKrishnan-pe3ft
    @HariKrishnan-pe3ft 2 роки тому +3

    But Nelson said that " he wrote the script for Vijay".

  • @aravindkumar6631
    @aravindkumar6631 2 роки тому

    Pls do a qanda for RRR br

  • @christoalphonsejoshy
    @christoalphonsejoshy 2 роки тому +4

    I am still wondering why Ajith joins with a corporate production company like Lyca for his 62th film since he has been acting in films produced by solo producers for years now. May be he started to think out of his narrow mind. Also, ajith just hears the one liner for his films, which I think is why most of his film are outright bad.

    • @pradheeps5719
      @pradheeps5719 2 роки тому

      no solo producers can give salary as Ajith expects in Tamil industry now

    • @adeptgamezone8457
      @adeptgamezone8457 2 роки тому

      @@pradheeps5719 even the one who gave got suffered 😆

  • @user-hq8wm8giyujcg
    @user-hq8wm8giyujcg 2 роки тому

    the king of storytelling writing countries are America (and west in general) in there books, movies, show, animation, comics, video games and Japan in there animation, comics and video games, why india's writing game is so weak, hopefully our quantity of quality unique localized movies and other storytelling medium will increase

  • @nash0076
    @nash0076 2 роки тому +1

    Dude. Valimai is fairly a good movie.

  • @anug14
    @anug14 2 роки тому +2

    18:16 lead character cannot be this unique kind of guy, with no emotions. It was amusing in doctor. If they repeat it won't work imo.

  • @sriramvenkateshakadebutjou8074
    @sriramvenkateshakadebutjou8074 2 роки тому +1

    And you haven't answered my last question yet baddy🤪

  • @vox-populi-vox-dei-
    @vox-populi-vox-dei- 2 роки тому +1

    Vijay shall only work with filmmakers who have done a minimum of three hits...

  • @dhonimahi7786
    @dhonimahi7786 2 роки тому

    neenge ena vena solunge naange
    TH❤L❤P❤THY VIJ❤Y അണ്ണൻ UYIR ഇഷ്ടം apdi solitu poyikite... IrupeN
    BE❤ST🥳

  • @shaktivellsunder3491
    @shaktivellsunder3491 2 роки тому +1

    Jai bhin reference 😂😂😂

  • @coolsand
    @coolsand 2 роки тому

    What are some examples of recent Tamil movies which were great cinematically but were not successful

  • @satyakam1979
    @satyakam1979 2 роки тому

    Watch Nishkarsha movie which has a similar genre.. it has no songs.

  • @sstf8113
    @sstf8113 2 роки тому +3

    Dai galatta, atleast oru AC podra nam pan indian reviewer ku

  • @ssuresh9320
    @ssuresh9320 2 роки тому

    @20.12 sir but ethum change sonnale... directors ah work panna vida maatranga nu solranga...Vera enna panrathu actors??!!!

  • @southpaw1122
    @southpaw1122 2 роки тому

    When is KGF QnA releasing???

  • @ResidentNotEvil5
    @ResidentNotEvil5 2 роки тому

    Baradwaj Rangan even working huge stars 4months isnt enough for beast another thing KGF1, 2 took 8 years with 200 writers but if even 6months time to write script and post production it will be hit another thing actors should bring down salary by 30%

  • @vijanrama
    @vijanrama 2 роки тому +1

    Only Nelson can tell us what he really wanted to make and whether what was released was the movie he wanted to make. Making the Pakistan terrorist a midget or short is like a caricature to the point of making a spoof film. Was Nelson trying to make a movie in the style of Deadpool or Zombieland or a spoof like Hot Shots. Anyone noticed that Nelson did the Nuke The Fridge scene from Indiana Jones 4. Why was the villain wearing a Breaking Bad character mask? The core of the movie is Die Hard in a Shopping Mall and that’s where the movie falters the most because the screenplay was not engaging. I enjoyed the movie for Vijay, Arabic Kuthu (the prelude scene to the song itself was superb), Pooja, VTV Ganesh and the Jolly song - at least they make you sit until the end. Smart Nelsa. Better luck next time Nelson - hope you bounce back with a better reviewed movie. Myself will watch the movie 1 more time before it’s removed from theatres.

  • @visual_audiosymphony
    @visual_audiosymphony 2 роки тому +4

    First Question: How I can ask you a 5 mark question for the next upcoming films? Tweet tagging you and the movie?

    • @saimadhusudanan
      @saimadhusudanan 2 роки тому

      Twitter, he usually has a thread few days before the actual video shooting

  • @avatt4691
    @avatt4691 2 роки тому +6

    Considering the genre of hostage drama, hindi movie 'Sanak' by Vidyut Jamwal was far far better than Beast
    Hospital equipments based action scenes were well choreographed, unlike dump skating action scene in Beast

  • @yujiitadori8704
    @yujiitadori8704 2 роки тому

    Nelson said he wrote the script already keeping Vijay in mind before he tell Vijay the story

  • @jgjcreations7393
    @jgjcreations7393 2 роки тому +3

    Sir, you should do an interview with Nelson and ask him to break down his process of arriving at such a silly and loose screenplay ......

  • @thedood5665
    @thedood5665 2 роки тому +4

    Ppl keep saying & posting mems regards why didn't see logic in other languages movie like RRR KGF & keep basing tamil movies for illogical scenes
    FIRST OF ALL movies doesn't need to have any logics it's fictional world from a director/writers vision THE KEY FACTOR IS HOW THEY MAKE IT LOOK LIKE BELIEVABLE if they didn't hook the audience into their world they distract from the movies they started scrolling the phones look for logic loop holes like how vijay shirt got that blood why it's look like ➕ symbol how Pooja costume🤣 changes in the 2nd half whereas in KGF our thinking brain is muted by the WORLD BUILDING gripping screenplay we were hooked from the start to the end without even thinking that why herione didn't go his father funeral 😂

    • @adeptgamezone8457
      @adeptgamezone8457 2 роки тому

      It's not at all the screenplay which make you guys not think of the logic it is the psychological effect that you have on that movie due to the over appreciation and word of mouth your mind failed to have it's own opinion that's it I can't see why a good screen play allow villains to not kill the hero whey they get a chance and vice versa even meeting pm like his neighbor and do murder inside the assembly by only meeting pm itself he would get so much exposure rather than killing someone inside the assembly while there is a meeting in front of pm if Rocky get this kind of exposure it self enough that he is remembered in the history like the killing of rajeev Gandhi for example and how can a town he built on kgf got completely destroyed and there wouldn't be no remains of it even nuke will left something so by seeing the leftovers or knowing that someone bombed that place badly everyone would know about kgf and Rocky but according to the story of kgf 1 know one knows it only a reporter knows it I can keeping on going like this so many things in that movie so it's not the movie it's your mentality which made kgf 2 looks good to you when you belive on something you will feel like it so as everyone one few found kgf 2 is so stupid 😂

  • @karthikrajagopalan5130
    @karthikrajagopalan5130 2 роки тому +1

    Beast failure will change the course of upcoming tamil movies, also big stars will start to rethink. Eppovum Puyalaku pin oru amaidhi irrukum

  • @drshikshajangde4611
    @drshikshajangde4611 2 роки тому

    Even in Arabic kuthu song , during female voice Vijay was in screen

  • @ashkarnizam7019
    @ashkarnizam7019 2 роки тому

    ok.1st of all people here are already saying vijay influenced the script and ruined beast a film where vj had no vj elements not even a stylish intro...now after watching beast its evidently clear vj had no influence on director but don't u think vj or ajith questioning especially a young director would add pressure and change the movie very drastically

  • @vij8426
    @vij8426 2 роки тому +1

    Vijay can act very well and the last movie which proved that was kaththi .. the problem was that the movie released almost 10 years ago.. so no consistency and no attempt to make such kind of movies again

  • @midhun23kg17
    @midhun23kg17 2 роки тому

    I think everyone tries to sell vijay sir fans support

  • @lexluther6917
    @lexluther6917 2 роки тому

    I think thuppaki 2 script was modified to make beast....coz of director walking out

  • @thenameischaithu
    @thenameischaithu 2 роки тому +2

    You need to do a Post release interview of KGF 2 with Prasanth Neel. Spoiler filled interviews are always cool, so we can see what was directors intention and what was communicated.

  • @james30321
    @james30321 2 роки тому

    Mr. BR not only nowadays always people forget the good hapnd always ready to point the bad .. humans are always ungrateful