From the information expressed to us via the MSQ it seems to me that dynamis is likely not only responsible for us being able to pull off limit breaks but indeed for us to push beyond our limits in the first place. I've mentioned this before but the entire Omega raid series was centered around Omega being frustrated that he couldn't properly quantify our power. Even with all of its advanced sensors and knowledge obtained over the millennia it was continually surprised that we defeated enemies that were far stronger than us. Furthermore, when it tried to directly see if we could instantly do the impossible it was a failure resulting in Midgardsormr having to step in to save our lives. Clearly, we have to work ourselves up to defeating these powerful foes, just like how we slowly accumulate limit gauge over time. Throughout a fight, our emotions rise and rise until they eventually allow us to transcend the limits of our aetherial existence if only briefly. Omega, by comparison, was seemingly never able to tap into this power source as it seemed utterly devoid of emotions which was likely a product of the Omicrons ridding themselves of their flesh-based existence and converting their minds into data.
Omega, and by association the Omicron in general, knew nothing about dynamis either. The Ea likewise seemed completely unaware of its existence. Either of those races theoretically would have done everything possible to learn all they could about it for their purposes otherwise.
Also worth noting, that while they are dealing with only a working theory, Nidhanna does give an example of being in combat and surpassing your physical limits as being a potential manifestation of Akasha. Despite the Endsinger's quote, Nidhannas example, and the Omega questline alluding to something else making you more powerful than they expect (which ends up being essentially because you care for others and have feelings, oh wait...) That Synodic dismisses the idea outright, and doesn't even seem to give it a thought. Quite frankly it feels the MSQ is almost going out of it's way to plant that idea without explicitly saying it.
Unfortunately that seems to not be the case. As we've seen from Elidibus he's able to use Limit Breaks with little to no effort. Meaning that Limit Breaks are fundamentally aether based since he's an unsundered, his aether would drown out any and all dynamis.
@@nerobiblios4086 But wasn't he using the hero's "summoned" beyond the rift *conviction* (which is driven by a very strong emotion) to fight evil to empower himself (which might explain the golden glow of those heros when they appear) making him a summon that was made through dynamis MORE than aether given when he separated from Zodiark he was a FRAGMENT of his former self and comprised of far less aether. On his own he SHOULDN'T be able to use dynamis but he was using emotions of countless others that overpowered the aether he's comprised of to manifest. summoning is driven through prayer via emotions (like desperation) So isn't it possible that you can create a primal out of dynamis??
Something that I missed but want to point out is that jobs like Dark Knight are visibly spending and consuming Aether to power their Spells/Abilities. If they run out of Aether, they run out of Dark Magic since the Abyss is their own personal pool of aether ignited. However, what we should be considering is how Dynamis might be aiding in helping shape their dark aether into something more potent, like an amplifier or focusing lens.
It should also be mentioned that the inner beast of warrior could be partially influenced by dynamis as well. Possibly. Also I think it more likely Ran'jit is a Reaper analogue.
You said that the shards, by technicality we should have wiped them left and right, but by that point we shouldn't be winning against Unsundered Ascians, more direct we should have straight lost to Elidibus or Emet Selch. Though I suppose there are reason to posit for those two victories...
@@SynodicScribe You can apply that argument but we did have a 1v1 fight twice over with one of the unsundered before they did their primal power up. Or how about the fight with a certain other Unsundered in the past? OH and lets not forget we've fought Ranjit multiple times with more people v. Himself so you can't just say "8v1" when like it minimizes it.
@@SynodicScribe If the fate of the source affects the reflections IE: it's destruction also causes their destruction. Would not the source getting stronger with from a rejoining also make the reflections stronger. Ambient aether flowing from the source and spread between the remaining reflections.
To break the rule (of MSQ sourcing). Something interesting: Urianger speculated that faith and prayer may have some ties to dynamis in the MSQ. There’s an Aether current side quest in Labyrinthos (Gleaner’s Wish) where a Sharlayan operator gives a lantern crystal to a Viera gleaner. He asks you to pray, giving hope and good wish to the bearer of the lantern. The researcher comments on his recent discovery of Thavnair’s theory of akasha and wonders if their custom of praying over these lanterns might be tied to it. The Ancients seem to have an atheistic society, which would make sense being such dense aetherial beings, faith is useless for them as it would have no bearing on them, since they have scarcely any dynamis to be affected by it. In the MSQ, it is faith that is used to help control one’s dynamis by providing a centered hope in (Final Days) Thavnair. My theory is that similarly to aether having different elements of two polarities. I think dynamis/akasha also has different elements (such as hope, joy, sadness), with positive and negative polarities. The WoL showed that there can be sadness, but it doesn’t destroy. It helps connect and ground a person. Then there is the sorrow and despair of the Endsinger which causes destruction. So…my speculation is that the Alliance raids will probably give some more information on the relationship between faith and dynamis. Probably indirectly, as the word dynamis is a recent (re)discovery. What does this mean? Not much, but hopefully we will find out more come future patches.
Faith is a good sample of dynamis in the scene when you limit break(tank) the first wipe skill of Endsinger after that the scion pray for WoL that is a power of dynamis too. In second astral era they begin to pray for stop the calamity that's is the beginning of magic but I think it's about dynamis because they didn't know about magic too much but they learned by not casting at all. I guess dynamis is a parallel of aether anyway. Aether is control by aether of user and knowledge to manipulate but dynamis is a power of feeling that unstable up to feeling of the user but yet powerful one . Speaking of parallel I always thinking about Ultima I didn't learned about it too much cause what is a parallel magic anyway
Dynamis (especially the fact that it interacts so weakly with the material world, and that it's stated to make up 68.3% of all energy in the universe) is a reference to dark energy in the real world.
What you said about the Dancer is also concreted by the fact that we fight a Kakodaemon, a manifestation of Foul emotions and Dynamis in both the endsinger fight and the final job quest for dancer. Seeing as dancer isn't a caster or isn't said to interact with aether (Yes I know all jobs interact with it, but in different ways and intensity mind you, focusing on how dancer would be lower aetherically active), maybe the invigoration that dancers do influences the dynamis in a positive way, purging the dark transformative emotions it can have. Of course, we would need more evidence on Dancers using Dynamis so I wouldn't be so bold as to just state it. But it is curious.
While I agree with your main point here, I would just point out that ALL Jobs in FFXIV interact with aether. Be it a Samurai or a Black Mage they are both using aether to different ends be it simply empowering their bodies or converting their energies into raw elemental power.
@@bharbarawyrstwaemasyn8741 was bout to mention bard, and honestly their effects on emotion hence dynamis, same with dancer here, can technically be seen in RL. it’s very common for certain dancing and music to cause surges of emotion. good or bad. like, imagine Bard doing “through the fire and flames” then you getting a damage buff cause you are fcking hyped. the main uses of aether for both dancer and bard are either A, weapon control (those arrows and flying discs sure as shit aint jsut skill) and B, better transmission of their dancing/singing. the dynamis comes in by the effects it has on you. like people RL literally can get stat boosts from music, be it motivation or concentration. translate that into a worl of magic i can see it having far more extensive results.
The point you make with Ran'jit makes a point that Dynamis has always been under the surface but not named. Since Shadowbringers we've encountered a number of beings that were aetherically to us as we are to Ran'jit. If we should have mopped the floor with Ran'jit because of our aetheric density, then should not Hades, Elidibus, Hermes, Venat, Erichthonius, and Hesperos done much the same to us? There's absolutely no way we should have been able to take on Ancients directly. And yet we can. Dynamis is the force that enables us to transcend limits. It's the force that Omega (who is aetherically similar to an Ancient in this context) encounters and finds themself unable to overcome or explain. People have misinterpreted the scene where we're being told about akasa as some asspull. It's not. She's telling us there's something that is confused with aether (which limit breaks and our power levels have been) and that no one knows how to directly manipulate (which doesn't imply it's never been used, when taken in context with it not being understood.) Take the pair together and you can conclude what she's really saying (narratively) is that dynamis/akasa has always been there, and that many things we thought were aether (such as the limit break) were akasa. And the story has always implied there's something inexplicable about us and people that allows them to rise to challenges and strife that they otherwise should not.
The problem I see with explaining Ran'jit kicking WoL's ass through dynamis however is that dynamis is supposed to interact with emotions and Ran'jit has never been shown to be very emotional quite the opposite in fact a calm and collected tactician and the only time where he actually gets emotional is the exact time where WoL ends up beating HIM which makes the entire argument of him using dynamis fall apart completely since if he had really been using dynamis WoL would've never been able to beat him in that fnal battle especially so inferring Ran'jit using dynamis doesn't make sense if you ask me WoL losing to Zenos and Ran'jit multiple times is just a case of good old plot armor
@@BlitzAce1995 Are we talking about the same character? The Ran'jit in the game I played was a grief stricken old man who trained the only hope against sin eaters, treated them like daughters, and watched them die again and again and again and again and again and again until finally he snapped, was given a hope of peace by Vauthry and subsequantly made ensuring the next Minfillia would never have to lose her life to her destiny again. Ran'jit is hella emotional as a character, he's just not 'stupid shonen anime emotions'. But like, ACTUAL emotions. Also, 'plot armor' doesn't mean 'Your powerfantasy character loses sometimes'. It means 'There is an ongoing plot that requires that character to remain alive in order to resolve it.' What you're describing is 'What should actually fucking happen to a protagonist now and then'
@@DracoSuave the way I see Ran'jit is that witnessing all the loss he did made him become bitter resulting in him supreesing his emotions (in which Vauthry's influence porbably also plays some role) which would get in the way of him using dynamis but that also doesn't change the fact that neither Zenos nor Ran'jit have ever been properly set up to be a threat for WoL at all I mean people TELL us that they're powerful but SE don't SHOW it to us until the scripted fights where they beat WoL if we were shown any feat of their strength before the first fight I wouldn't agrue for it being an asspull. We don't have any evidence to go by for how they measure up to Nidhogg at all if we were shown at Bealsar's Wall how Zenos beat Shinryu after Omega dissapeared or how Ran'jit easily beats some Sin-eater of a type that WoL struggled I wouldn't argue with the whole thing but as it stands the only evidence of their strengh is normal people tellung us that they're powerful which isn't exactly a good measuring stick since normal people don't exactly scale up to WoL and honestly I'm not really too fond of the idea of dynamis as a whole as it is seems too much of an ExMachina to me to explain something the writers didn't know to explain otherwise by going going "yeah that random person is totally able to beat the LITERAL GODSLAYER due to some unseen and undetectable power that is completely inexplicable otherwise" you see. My point is show don't tell if we were shown more about how dynamis works we peobably wouldn't be haing this argument in the first place but as it is we simply know too little to make really much out of it.
There is also evidence that the Bard may be using Dynamis to empower others with their songs. Especially with the quest named "The Ballad of Oblivion" in the Bard questline.
Considering that Dynamis is related to emotion, I wonder if it has a relation to the Aramitama and Nigimitama concept that was introduced in the Four Lords quest back in Stormblood? The Auspices of Stormblood was said to build up Aramitama as they grow in age and power through the passage of time, which is a violent and active aspected emotional energy that can corrupt and transform them if it is not balanced by Nigimitama, a calm and passive aspected emotional energy. This is similar to the concept of Astral and Umbral aspect of Aether. Perhaps Aramitama and Nigimitama could refer to observable effects of aspected Dynamis. Moreover, Auspices are known to transform between animal and humanoid forms much like Meteon and Terminus beasts, and much like the concept of Limit Break, transcend the natural cycle of rebirth by living beyond their normal lifespans and transcend the limitations of being originally mundane animals with mundane levels of aether. If all that I am theorizing is true, then perhaps Auspices could be considered a kind of Entelechies as well, that unlike Meteon, who is crafted, are naturally occurring.
Spirit (ari) and vessel (nigi) is indeed one of the form of Dynamis. Dynamis technically represents potential energy. A form of power that driven by emotional circumstances or imbalance constant by nature. Every religious has one, but not everyone understand what it means, which ends up no further research ever concluded and passed down. Aether by itself is a constant flow of energy. Dynamis isn’t, which makes it easier to forget or disprove by something that more easier to understand.
An astral/umbral side of Dynamis is basically expected to be explored at some point, as MSQ's been doing the same for Aether for all the while up to this point.
I want to add in terms of how the final days came to be. When in Mare Lamentorum and after beating Zodiark the watcher explains that when the final days started happening during the ancient times the location and time of where the final days started coincided with the weakening/decay (as to why this happened no one knows it could be a natural process or phase) of the celestial currents of ather around eytheris. Because this "Barrier" or layer of ather was gone there was nothing to block the dynamis from meteon from entering eytheris proper. And zodiark was summoned to basically reinforce or sustain the celestial current. And since we defeated zodiark there was nothing to maintain the celestial current thus restarting the final days. (Similar to how the earths magnetic field protects the earth from cosmic radiation)
Yeah if I remember correctly the celestial aether started to stagnated, thats why Zodiark is created of darkness, because darkness creates motion of aether the opposite of light which is stasis, so basically Zodiark just sustains the flow of celestial aether creating a protective barrier around etherys.
Dynamis is basically the real life interpretation of dark energy. Only until recently that we know it exists, but we don't know how to prove it. It just does but we are making efforts regardless. Since they introduced Omega's intentions as early as Stormblood, I don't think it was a last minute plot device slotted in. It's almost like they've been writing on "the world's mysteries" since the end of Heavensward and somehow linked dragons to it. Anyway, tinfoil hat time: What if Garleans are actually able to interact better with Dynamis?
They have been thinking about Dynamis and Meteion since HW. Look at Alexander, in the song Locus, there are lyrics that say, back to back. "Celestial Noise Detected, Delirium Unsuspecting." which is exactly what Meteion's song is.
@@archmagemc3561 it could be any number of things. Alexander, a being _purely and entirely made out of aether,_ would not be able to detect dynamis at all in the same way the ancients weren’t able to interact with it. It’s infinitely more likely that he was referring to the omicrons’ electronic communications than dynamis.
It's not MSQ related so you wouldn't have mentioned it, but there is one mention of it that struck me. Going through my lost actions with Bozja for Reaper grinding the item "Dynamis Dice" smacked me across the face. Considering the item is equally powerful an fickle, I think it needs to be noted.
My friends in the FC and I remarked on the same thing after finishing the MSQ. You're basically putting your faith in a possible good outcome. Not aether, but belief.
Throwing my own hat into the ring about Bozja, the Resistance weapons also use certain types of memories of the dying to upgrade, and in the Blade's step, raw emotions. Really shaky, but I think it could be something to consider too.
It probably can't be easy for you given all the new information we've been given on FFXIV's metaphysics, but I think you're doing a great job so far. Looking forward to more!
I hypothesize that Dynamis acts with Aether in the same way that the blue lantern rings interact with green lanterns in the DC universe. They're not particularly strong own, but when coupled with their much stronger companion, they *supercharge* it and push it past any normal limits, hence limit breaks using Dynamis according to the Endsinger. And since we've been rejoined once more than anyone else, and yet we can use Dynamis with our LBs, it may be that Dynamis multiplies the effects of Aether, but too much Aether makes it harder to interact with it. Like, more Aether means a greater barrier between the person and Dynamis, but if the person can breach that barrier, then the Dynamis has WAY more effect. I.E. if an Ancient were *unfathomably* emotional and could somehow use Dynamis, they'd be completely unstoppable
But shouldn’t that instance with the Endsinger not be used as the standard to measure this? It’s an outlier or a specific instance that would never have otherwise happened outside of Ultima Thule due to the nature of its Dynamis composition. If it were anywhere else, the outcome would have been very different.
It very much seems like dynamis is very much like gravity in quality, it's a weak force that exists everywhere that can be defied by simply raising your hand but also creates black holes. Meanwhile aether is a strong force like the nuclear force
This is my new favorite channel. Also, my favorite part about the discussion of Akasa / Dynamis is when Nidhana states that, in legend and myth, it was 'torn from the heavens'. From my point of view, it sort of implies that the song 'Torn From The Heavens' is almost an anthem to the power of Dynamis. The heroic, rising notes retroactively symbolizing the rising of Dynamis in the Warrior of Light, cresting and seething with their desire defend Etheirys, as well as the instrument of shattering their limits. Hell, to call it 'The Limit Break Song' wouldn't really be wrong, from that point of view.
Glad to see I wasn’t the only one who noticed that correlation! Especially since it normally plays when we are transcending our limits. I’m inclined to think this is deliberate (how could it not be) but only time will tell! Right now we know next to nothing about Dynamis and can’t say much with any certainty. I look forward to what the future will bring!
At this point in time, would the Elpis flowers be our only effective or consistent tool for interacting with dynamis for research purposes? Unlike us, it’s classified as an entelechy.
@@SynodicScribe I just rewatched the cutscene where she says this, and Hermas says just because we are thin of aether, it doesn't make us an entelechy but that we can be affected by akasha and be able to transcend our limitations. This being that we aren't so reliant on aether as we thought, but a combination of the two since the sundering.
@@iGREENification Late reply, but even still, we cannot research the energy in question ourselves. So the flower itself is still something usable for research purposes.
There are a couple of in-game mechanics that can be explained a bit further if you take the existence of Dynamis, or even in-game occurances. First is our ability to "Push the limit", our buff where the Warrior of Light is taking things past the normal capabilities of physics. This only happens in very important, emotionally laden fights. Our will, our need to succeed harnesses Dynamis to give us an extra boost. As you said, we are powerhouses of Aether of ourselves. The Echo buff may be a second. While we're taught that the Echo is a thing that we've unlocked from being sundered Ancients ourselves, the buff we get might be traceable back to Dynamis. The 'vision' we get from the battle gone wrong only serves to emotionally charge us into needing to try harder. It is important to note that the Echo itself is not Dynamis. We've been told that this is an ability the people of Ancient Etheirys could call on. I feel that everyone who actually HAS the Echo is a sundered soul of an Ancient. While others who live around us may be sundered but might have been part of that new life that flourished in the time after Zodiark saved the world. The shade of Hythlodaeus says as much in Amaurot; One third gave their lives to summon Him, about half of the survivors again to restore the elements and purify the lands so that New Life might be born. And of that new life they would sactrifice to get their own back. That stands to conclude that a lot of new beings with souls were alive at the time that Hydaelyn sundered the place. Despite the big emotional scene showing it happening on the Final Day. I believe that to just be narrative compression of events. Our Limit Break has been confirmed to BE Dynamis manipulation by Meteion herself. In fact it makes sense considering that everyone in the party cheers you on when you use it, suggesting there is more of a "WE CAN DO THIS!" feeling behind it than outright Aether manipulation. The fact that it charges slowly but steadily but gets quick boosts when someone survives a deadly attack or a healer cures a ton of health on someone who went sub 10% would also suggest an emotional origin. (listen for a tiny little swoosh sound whenever someone does that and note that the lb bar grew quite a bit ) And the last thing I can recall at this point are the NPCs who can go toe-to-toe with the Warrior of Light and sometimes even warrant us to use our breaking the limits... Almost all of them are fighting us for a belief they hold personally very VERY dear. You mentioned Ran'Jit; He fights us in name of the faith he has placed in Vauthry, but ALSO the desperate desire to not let yet another Minfillia die a needless death. Believe it or not, he DOES care about her. And since he's willing to die for that belief, he is able to harness more than simply Aether to his side. And almost everyone else who suddenly appear as powerful as the person who has killed pretty much the entire Pantheon of gods of everyone around them are almost always fighting us from a similar position of deep and emotional conviction.
Your statement of the other shards being more "attuned" than the Source's denizens...It is highly speculative that the "main energy source" on how the Empty at the First would be reclaimed would be Dynamis. given how emotionally charged the events of the Eden arc was (love between two ancients, reconciliation of said ancients and moving on, forging new relationships as well), the sudden growth of plant life, nature slowly reclaiming Eden, as the entwined tree surrounding it after finishing the story arc, it would seem Dynamis is pushing the aetheric balance a bit strongly to project effects such as those, just like on your last statement of augmenting both energies to produce a much greater effect.
I'm tempted to call Dynamis an asspull, but the Endwalker msq goes to great lengths in establishing it as an esoteric and obscure subject with (until now) very little practical application in-universe. It may very well be that it was only now first mentioned because there was never occasion to mention it before.
It also helps that there are previous events in the story that make a lot of sense in the context of dynamis existing, i.e. Omega's whole test was basically trying to figure out how it worked without knowing what it is
It's an asspull, just like how meteion has the power to destroy worlds when she's just supposed to be a record keeping 'AI' bird. There's several unquestioned things and asspulls in the story. All seems to go downhill when reviewing the past.
@@TKUltra971 If you put a gun to my head and asked me to explain it I'd say that, as entelechies, the Meteion collective was both empowered and warped by a massive amount of negative dynamis over the course of literal eons. Whether or not that's a convincing explanation is a matter of opinion I suppose.
@@TRECTADACTYL interesting theory. I just don't get why out of the blue a ai 'robot' automatically has the power to end words. negative or not. And that makes even less sense that Hermes would create her and never expect or predict this to be an outcome. Also i don't buy every world visited was a grave yard or 10 minutes past the dooms day clock in armageddon.
Spoiler Perhaps I'm misremembering this but wasn't Zodiarc strengthening the celestial currents. This would hold back the song of the end by drowning it out with more dense aether. Please tell me if I'm missing something here.
He's making the celestial currents move faster, via the polarity of darkness to be astral. Fast-moving celestial currents means no points were there are weak currents, thus no way for Meteion to enact the final days through dynamis.
The biggest thing I got out of it is that we have always been using Dynamis whenever we push beyond our limits. So for example when we get the Echo buff after dying in a dungeon or trial. That buff was always associated to the power of the Echo from the name, but it could possibly be us pushing further by tapping into Dynamis
You're also forgetting there was another tease that I took to mean Limit Break was Akasha, later being Dynamis of course. In the same conversation we hear about Akasha for the first time, to give an example Nidhana says "As a veteran of the battlefield, surely you've experienced moments of desperation or exaltation when you transcended the usual limits of your capabilities? That is a manifestation of Akasha." which calls out Limit Break being Dynamis before even hitting level 84 or knowing anything really set in stone about Dynamis. I actually noticed this and in my head was just going "oh so this is Limit Break got it." It wasn't that mind-blowing of a revelation for me as this was the end of the current story. I expected answers like this.
This right here. Is why I'm not uploading the Limit Break video. Even with all the sources and data I have, these kind of comments will flood the video and cause further confusion. lmao
Dynamis is extremely similar to The Warp from Warhammer 40k. The Warp being, in super simple terms, a dimension or veil on top of our own, filled with a raw energy that reacts to emotion and can be channeled by skilled individuals to wield what you would call magic or supernatural powers. But it can also corrupt living beings too. Or living beings can corrupt "it" in certain cases thru their strong emotions, giving birth to abominations in the Warp. Look into it, I bet that's where they took some inspiration from.
Spoilers and random thoughts from me. Thanks for the video! Back in FF6, Limit Breaks weren't actually a thing and instead characters had the possibility of performing a unique desperation attack if they were left at low HP. The way I see Limit Breaks is that they are used when we are at our most desperate (in terms of Healer and Tank LBs) or most exhilarated (in terms of DPS LBs). Emotions do run high in combat situations. "I have to win because everyone is counting on me!", "I can't give up yet! What will happen to the world if I fail?" These thoughts and desperate feelings probably shaped our will into the wall that protected us from The Endsinger's attack. The Endsigner is surprised because she did not know we could manipulate Dynamis to block her oblivion wave attack even in such a crude fashion. Heck, I doubt we even knew that ourselves and just considered the LB as something that our Warriors of Light could inherently do. Additionally, the Scions praying for our victory granted us a bonus shield that blocked her second wave when we ourselves were spent. This gives credence to my personal theory on why Thordan was so terrified at the end of our battle against him in Heavensward. He couldn't see Dynamis, but he saw us stand up again and again after he threw everything he had against us and yet we still came after him and took everything he threw at us on the chin. The way Dynamis is structured in game reminds me of one of the bigger mysteries in physics. Why is Gravity, one of the four fundamental forces, so weak in comparison to Electromagnetism? Gravity has infinite range, exists everywhere as a consequence of distortions of space-time. Similarly to Aether, much of our real world technology is based around electricity. Imagine what a society that has access to gravity-based technology could do instead and it is an interesting parallel to dynamis. There is a short story by Harry Turtledove "The Road Not Taken" where such an alien society which has gravity-based tech but otherwise has weaponry from the Age of Sail attempts to conquer modern day Earth and pretty much immediately loses; however, they unlock this branch of technology for humanity. The aliens realize this and say "What have we done?!" Turtledove has written many other alternative history works of a similar nature and it goes to show that just because one species has access to one technology branch does not inherently make it immediately superior to all others. Similarly tying this random aside back to FF14, even if one of the shards has direct access to Dynamis, does not immediately make it more powerful than our Aether wielding Warriors of Light, it might level the playing field or it may not depending on how it is used; although IMO, Ranj'it was just a really amazing technical fighter and not in anyway wielding Dynamis against us.
About Ranjit, a part of me has a feeling that when rejoinings happen they affect the shards too as the source is just that, the source. I don’t think the remaining shards have 1/14th of their aether, but they aren’t quite 7x rejoined either. Especially since they can use magic and the source couldn’t until the 1st rejoining. Can’t explain what’s going, but I don’t think it’s simple maths. So mebe Ranjit is just a bit stronger than others on the first and has a bit more aether than usual making him a little closer to the WoL? I dunno. All this new info is making my head spin😆
@@etowesho It is a possibility. However, since the Rejoinings were always of Ascian design, I doubt that they would ever rejoin a shard to another shard. Their goal was always to rejoin all the shards to the Source. Also, aether is really only one part of the equation. It doesn't account for 100% of ones combat prowess in the physical space as much as it does for one's ability to exert aetheric energy. Ranj'it, despite his age, was definitely a technical fighter. He studied us before he took us and all the other Scions present down simultaneously. He even said he "had our measure!" That speaks tremendously to his personal skill in combat arts. Also, I don't want to think that we are innately superior to people on the other shards. We merely have more aether than they do having been through rejoinings, that doesn't necessarily mean that they cannot defeat us in combat and we would be dismissively discounting their own training and abilities that they bring to the table. I would say that Ryne, despite being a native on the First is an equal in combat skill to any of the rogues in the rogue's guild on the Source, possibly superior since she was trained by Thancred and the other Scions.
Could Frey and Myste be dynamis shaped creations of aether? I understand that Frey at least is a sort of necessary construct for the souls crystal but Myste was completely an accident caused by our emotions.
Those guys are essentially familiars as I see it. Just our creation magics leaking through, but I guess Dynamis has some effect on it. I mean, our strongest abilities utilize Dynamis (LBs) so that stuff is extremely potent.
Since Zodiark isn't around anymore to shield the Source and the remaining reflections from overabundance of dynamis I can see alot of job classes that relied on emotion to start suddenly getting ridiculous power boosts, such as Dark Knight, Bard and Dancer. And possibly new job classes popping up with dynamis mainly being used.
I don’t know if this has been mentioned before but there is a bit of a fan/ hinted theory about dynamis that I think warrants further insight on however this does contain some spoilers to the storm blood raids so spoilers for those who haven’t played it yet: During one of the msq cutscenes one of the dialogue options I noticed (and the one I picked) was a comment on how our characters are able to break their limits from time to time to perform amazing feats that defy explaination. Though emet dismisses it as desperation, it is theorized that instead this is due to the character unknowingly using dynamis energy to temporarily break their limits. The support for this theory comes from both interactions with the endsinger who believes that you used dynamis to survive her first apocalypse attack (the tank limit break required during that part of the fight) and omega, who is trying to understand how a being like the wol and others beat impossible odds. From what has been said omega was trying to understand how your emotional state was what was triggering extreme feats of strength. This according to game theories state that what omega was trying to measure and couldn’t understand was in fact dynamis. I believe that the Theory that the limit break ability is from the wol using dynamis does warrant some further investigation. Hopefully this theory turns out to be fun to investigate as well since it seems like dynamis as a whole is fun to theory craft on
Oooh. Nice video. Makes me want to think of Dynamis Dice lost action in the Resistance quest series. While it mentions placing faith to Nymeia and roll for the best case scenario (e.g. Healer LB3 or some buffs), we still get bad rolls sometimes (uncleansable Doom, etc.). Potentially dynamis in action as all sorts of emotions are there in the Southern Front and Zadnor - both optimistic and otherwise, which may influence the "rolls", with the Gambler Essence like a flagon of "let me feel good vibes" to mitigate the negative emotions already in the area and skew the rolls into more positive ones? Just some thoughts though which may or may not be useful in the search for literature on dynamis. Also, it's coincidentally called the Dynamis Dice, meaning it was a battle action that was used previously (its usage frequency could only be theorised) before it was Lost.
Very pleased this sticks with the source text. Lately I keep coming across folks who can’t tell their head canon apart from what the text supports. Your approach is the best one.
Ghostbusters 2 has a parallel way of understanding how emotions influence physical objects. Slime in the Ghostbusters universe undergoes a pH change while under the influence of different emotions. Hostile and depressive emotions causes the pH of the slime to become more caustic as hydroxide (-OH) in the substance increases. The visible colors of the negatively charged slime becomes dark pink to black. Coming into physical contact with negatively charged slime causes people become more hostile and coming into contact with black slime was said to be corrosive to the soul. Nurturing and more hopeful emotions causes the pH of the slime becomes more acidic as the main body of the substance retains more Hydrogen (H+). The color of the more positively charged slime becomes light pink/white to green. Being covered in positively charged slime was observed to cause general euphoria.
The thing about limit break having it's history as dynamis, it is not the first time a FF game has tried to have an explanation for the existence of limit breaks. FF9 is an example of dynamis like Trance.
I really enjoy your videos and this is another good one! A couple of things that I think you missed: Meteion also mentions that the star is saturated with aether, there was also a greater amount compared to dynamis. We also know that dynamis started to effect area of the star where the celestial aether started to weaken which seems to happen naturally, my guess would be that Meteion's song couldn't penetrate that layer or aether so Zodiark reinforce the aether to prevent the song from reaching the star. Now I have a question! Correct me if I'm wrong, but souls are made of pure aether, so is it possible to have a soul made from pure dynamis? If so it would need to form in a place where there is no aether, and that would be the thirteenth shard since all the aether there got destroyed. Just some food for thought.
As far as we know. No. Souls as we understand them are only composed of aether because Dynamis isn't dense/strong enough to carry what we could be consider the essence of a spirit. Think of it this way, Aether is Proactive(Creating things), while Dynamis is only Reactive(reacting to stimuli).
You know the Cry from the Earth that preludes the Final Days? The start of the theme of the Nael fight in coils has this brutally haunting wail which fits perfectly. But why would it play there? It's in Dalamuds ruins which was exposed to Dynamis for a really long time when it was in space since the Aether currents only protect Moon and Planet right? Spinfoil or possible? It was designed to harvest solar aether? Maybe it picked up Meteions lyrics by chance. (Would also explain the morse code in CT which spells Meteions phrase since it got picked up by dalamud, transmitted to CT and translated into readable data) but that is actual spinfoil
Oh wow, holy moly I must sincerely thank you for your warning about Shadowbringers spoilers as my brain must have been half asleep to miss the hint in the title and since I’m at the start of Stormblood I’m trying to avoid spoilers. See, “Dynamis” is also something from FF11 and I assumed you’d taken a jaunt into Vana’diel so I figured a trip down memory road might be cool. I played that game years ago, quitting a few months after Abyssea launched. Honestly I don’t remember much about the lore videos exactly, but the Dynamis I knew was maps of the starter cities and Jeuno but filled with insanely tough versions of the beast tribes that fought the civilisations in the real world. They generally required full 18 person teams under a very skilled leader to beat. The goal was to reach a point on the map and click on the ground. Mobs also dropped the second set of artifact armour for each job. I seriously don’t remember if the Vana’diel version of Dynamis was a dream realm or an alternative reality where the beast tribes won. Might have to look it up. In any case the Dynamis of FF14 is absolutely not for me just set, so I paused at about 30 seconds in and now I must take my leave.
As someone more or less working in research IRL I do enjoy a lot of what you do on your channel! Now in regards to Limit Breaks, my understanding of what the Endsinger said is that Dynamis helps to give form to the aether used in the LBs. Like some kind of spark to launch the whole process. I think it's a super interesting concept but I wish it was hinted at earlier (maybe in Shadowbringers or Stormblood?). It feels a bit weird because it's not bad but it does lack a strong connection with the world of XIV. That being said I think the writers could use that and maybe have some parts of the patches/raids/trials/etc... dedicated to show research or attempts of explaining Dynamis and linking it to past events. I'll hold my opinion on it until then or until we get another Encyclopedia
Hmm, I guess Hermes was the only one who made research about it. The reason is bcus theres very little amount of dynamis in Etheirys. But in the great expanse outside Etheirys, dynamis is more dominant than aether.
I suppose it was sort of hinted at in the Omega raids. Omega really tried to recreate the power we demonstrated during extreme stress, was really baffled by it, even went so far as to try to emulate us in the final fight, but failed, since it's a machine and just can't use Dynamis.
i dunno if this helps but in the bozja content you have acces to the dynamis dice which when used gives different buffs/debuffs and it can even do a healer LB3
When they summoned zodiark I’m not sure what laws rewritten but venat said by his summoning the world was shrouded in Aether keeping the effects of dynamis to a minimum influence so that could explain why dynamis was even less prominent so we could more easily manipulate it as easily as we should of.
Whilst I recognise that this might be only my head cannon, I keep reading peoples comments about dynamis and it seems to be believed by people that dynamis IS emotion, rather than being an ENERGY that can be MANIPULATED or AFFECTED by emotion. In my mind the Elpis flower itself even proves that. A flower, as we understand them doesn't have emotion, but the emotions of others around the flower are affecting the charge of the dynamis either within or around the flower thus changing its colour. I also want to suggest something else. I believe that limit breaks are neither exclusively aether based or exclusively dynamis based. I believe the intent of the lore was to suggest that in using or accessing the energy that is dynamis we are augmenting or pushing past the mortal limitations of our natural powers in time of desperation to result in something I would compare with a sort of adrenaline rush. I have nothing to prove that particular point but I feel like it lets both the aether and the dynamis components not directly contradict each other. Moreover the game seems to imply that though aether is more potent than dynamis sufficient quantities of dynamis can overpower aether too, otherwise Hermes would have had no need to create an entelechy in the first place in order to traverse the great expanse he had to 'look to an alternative source of energy by necessity' if i remember his quote correctly. At this point in time we don't actually know what the power ratio between a unit of aether and a unit of dynamis actually is. aether could be 20% stronger of 1000% stronger, we simply don't have that information at the moment
You're actually correct. People's head cannon on dynamis is kinda running wild at the moment. It's untested, not researched, and undefined at the moment. We'll have to see how or IF they choose to play with dynamis anymore in the future.
A note, I had just remembered that when we had rejoinings explained to us in ShB, they mentioned that MOST of the aether flows back into the shard, not all of it. I believe they said the rest flows back into the other shards as well, but maintenance is happening right now and even I don't have the patience to comb through youtube or the cutscenes. TL;DR, Ran'jit and the denizens of the other shards aren't 1/14th the strength of an ancient.
@10:00 In summation of your point at this particular moment in the video, if I'm understanding you correctly, you are saying "Dynamis has not been recorded nor discovered in Aetherys's known history, thus has either played no role in the outcome of historical events, or if it was present, at least not to any significant extent." I'm wondering if this may be too bold of an assumption to make. For all we know, many heroes, conquerors, and other such sorts of figures might have wielded Dynamis unknowingly throughout known history. The reason this would not be noted by historical records can be reasonably explained by its absence, but not *only* by its absence. Another, equally viable explanation, was that our inability to detect or measure Dynamis would lead to such effects being conflated with those brought about by an mysterious/subconscious application of Aether, or by "willpower" or "determination" of the individual, or perhaps "a Miracle of the Twelve/the Kami/Some Other God." Perhaps throughout history events have occured in which Dynamis changed the course of history, but was not recognized for having done so due to its much more subtle nature as a magical force. I'm not saying that it *did* play such a role, either. I'm just saying that, from my point of view, we can't *say* that it didn't or that it did at this time. On the other hand, I view this part of the video as asserting that you feel it definitively did not (based on our current information.)
Im thinking maybe we get a dynamis zone like in FF11, where we go to grind for the new relic weapon. That big area north east in radz-at--han seem to important to be "empty" and must be a hub for something.great video like always btw:)
2 questions. 1.-How does the "sundering" work in relation to the rest of the universe? say, if someone from the first and the source went to the moon would they be able to meet there? Or does each world have their own moon? Or are there actually 14 different universes? IIRC, they don't explain if that is on a timeline/universal level. 2.-Speaking of timelines, what happens with the whole Meteion deal in the "Black Rose" timeline? Sure they say the WoL died there, but it's odd since the current present we live in relies on two separate time travel instances, the exharch going back in time to a different shard and then the WoL going to Elpis. If the WoL said everything that happened to Venat, does that mean that she had to make sure the black rose events happened and then just take a gamble and hope that G'raha would succeed and play his part? If anything the Hydaelin from that timeline will not know if her plan succeeded, I wonder if in the future we will go there in some way and try to fix it or something.
Everyone talking about how Dynamis works, meanwhile I’m gonna be the one to point out that Synodic censored himself in the cutscene from the Dancer quests, mans really doesn’t wanna be seen without that cloak and mask. XD
Such a fantastic point of insight you provided. Imagine if something else caused rejoinings. The stronger we became aetherically, the stronger the shards could be via dynamis against us
There is something I'd like to point out. Are there _any_ indication, MSQ or otherwise, that the different shards are of equal power when it comes to aether? looking at the EW MSQ and at Emet-Selch's statements regarding the reflections, it always seemed like the Warrior of Light and the Scions are said to have small amounts of it compared to the "bountiful" of the ancients, despite everyone at that point being half of 14, and even more in the case of the WoL. If that's true, it suggests that there's at least one reflection with a LOT of aether in their inhabitants, which would in-turn also suggest that this reflection wouldn't be able to manipulate dynamis, and that there would be other shards where people are almost like Garleans and instead manipulate Dynamis. Some might even have/use neither and do something else instead.
My little theory is that dynamis is able to read our feeling telling aether what to do. It would be like computer code telling a program what it needs done, and you input in what you want it to do. So my theory just puts dynamis as like an interpreter. now I still can't figure out why when it goes out of control that it has the influence to change people into monsters. maybe it's just telling the aether to completely rewrite the physical form of an induvial by sacrificing the soul. Still working on that one lol.
Its possible that the prayers and supplications that give rise to primals are based on dynamis too. With dynamis giving aether shape and form based on the will of the worshippers. Great video, thanks.
Warning for spoilers: The whole idea of Limit Breaks being aether refined by dynamis might hold even more water as we see in Seat of Sacrifice - Elidibus, an unsundered being using immense amounts of aether that even we cannot hope to wield, calls upon assistance from souls of other worlds, either the Source or its reflections. If the theory that LB = dynamis-augmented aether is correct, Elidibus shouldn’t be able to Limit Break at all; yet not only could he, he was capable of attaining a level of Limit Break thought to be completely impossible. It should also be noted that while not cited by name, dynamis may very well have been established as early as Stormblood, as Omega was trying to figure out why its calculations kept being thrown off by us, and the only thing it could peg was that emotional energy that allowed us to surpass our limits in times of extreme duress - which could have very well been it trying to explain dynamis without having a word for it. This seems to hold, given the behavior of various other Omicrons we meet during and after Endwalker.
Elidibus did probably gain a bunch of dynamis by being the ascians final hero and last hope and he also channeled a lot of dynamis from the faith and belief of the warriors of light that he then became.
iirc, he is like a Garlean at this point in time. he has inherent aether, but cannot manipulate it. which also raises the question, are Garleans also able to manipulate dynamis effectively?
@@rachelkelley5930 it might be because I believe Thancred has had the most job changes as any of the sions. From a 1.0 sword job to ninja then Gunbreaker.
This is where I start sharing and comparing notes: So far, the six elements has two "status": umbral and astral, making them "twelve". If you add the "light" and "darkness" (which I consider wrong, but we'll get there), you have the magic number: fourteen. In one of your, ahem, studies, you tell us that living beings are composed of body, soul and mind. Three, that might why not have their oposites, such as the elements, and then again two "status", umbral and astral, and we're both dying and being "reformed", "recycled". When dead, one's aether is turning into something else. Add this to a draconic timelessness perspective, and one, from this, can conclude (and that might need a lot of suspension of disbelief, but bear with me, the more you think the more it makes sense): 1- All things are tridimentional. 2- All things have an opposite. 3- All things have a state of vibration (movement) and stasis. And, last but not least: as it is below so it is above. All I suggest is as you try to overlap the many different "circles" that we find throughout the star's history. "What does all this blabering has to do with Dynamis", one would rightfully ask. I **SUGGEST** that Dynamis isn't the MATTER(body) nor the SOUL(aether), but the MIND. The silent administrator that decide what deserves our attention or not, the both EMOTIONAL(astral) or RATIONAL(umbral) judge that moves all things, so inherently attached to them that one could leave them unoticed. Where we keep looking for something to interact with, we should observe thing's *direction*, and call it Dynamis. As you stablished yourself, thicker the aether, the least it's influenced by Dynamis -- the slower it moves.
Want to share one idea, that WoL some other had joined shards who present the power of echo, evloved new abilities to interact beyond the barrier of time/language, which is meteon sense familar to herself. That might be the true effect after hydeline divided the world and ascens try merge them. Both are catastrophic, but therefore bring our chance to be dynamic being. Also in first shard on 5.3, they are evoked the echo, but there is no prove they evoled same sense power. It seems to be the pattern of the aether as in 5.x storyline where xenos experimented.
I believe strongly the twelve are entelechy. Hermes states "Dynamis is an energy put in motion by feelings. Feelings for which there must first exist a source. A source to which the victims must be attuned-one that harbors the selfsame negative emotions. Elsewise it could not be the agent of such extreme change." The twelve origin stories are so heavily tied to emotions and relationships which act as the fuel for their powers. Powers that did not seem to line up with the limits and uses Aether if you were to take the tales literally, but with Dynamis seem much more plausible. Nymeia creating a lake by crying for example, so ridiculous even in the 14 universe it seems like a folktale. They embody concepts like love, wisdom and Fury rather then just definitive elements. Their use of Dynamis or being entelechy would explain why we cannot see them even though they did/do exist. Meteion would have escaped completely on Elpis had we ( a being capable of interacting with dynamis) not been there showing just how invisible entelechy can be. The fact the newest raid tier will be based on the twelve, and Emet with full memories directly commented on us not knowing what they "Truly are" ties in so well with them being entelechy. A presence that has been in the game since 1.0 and referenced constantly but never directly interacted with. That is, until now with full knowledge of the concept of Dynamis to properly locate them.
Thought on the future, as Dynamis becomes more concrete it will be interesting to see if we get new Job abilities in 7.0 based around it as it becomes a bigger part of the world with Zodiark gone.
I just wanted to say..I come across this love your channel..I just finished Shadowbringers and Eden so I will watch this later! Much love and respect to our fav scribe/scholar! And! With the class series would you consider making one on reaper maybe, I find the lore of it so enticing! Especially after playing through Shadowbringers!
If the star was sundered into 14 parts making the aether 1/14th its power at the time of sundering. Then when the Ascians forced a shard to rejoin the source it would be 2/13th and again 3/12th. Gaining what 25% of our aetheric power back? (Am bad at the maths) this does not account for the voidsent shard if that has any kind of aetherics left even. On top of this I wonder why the sundering did not sunder dynamis also? So many questions still...
About the limit break, it triggers when you get to low HP in ff6 and ff8. I remember reading somewhere that it could be seen as an action by desperate emotion to overcome tough situations. In ff7, the limit gauge build up when you got hit which in turn can be seen as you get angrier. In ff9, trance state is also linked to emotion I think. Which that I think linking limitbreaks to dynamis is not so far fetched. It has been awhile since I play those game so I might be mistaken but it just my thought.
I know this video is now over a year old; but, I offer one small postulation. As Yoshi P has said that he plans continued development for FFXIV: what if Dynamis is a way for additional abilities to be added, changed, or offer a gateway to one of the shards? For example: players when they start a basic class lack a job/soul stone until later in the story, at which new abilities are given, some abilities change in power, and the learning of the job truly begins. I could stand to reason that there could be something that takes place where the job/soul stone is infused with the ability to control Dynamis: resulting in abilities the WoL already has to be something more, something different, or to be able to gain a completely new ability altogether. Just a thought....
The real life blend of science and magic in endwalker was fascinating. Just like how ripples(waves) in a lake can't made/seen without water (a medium). Before Einsteins time, alchmist/scientists knew that light was also a wave (but not yet also a particle of energy). So they believed light must also have some form of medium to travel through. Just like how fish can't see the water they swim in, we also must be in a medium we can't see the theory was called Luminiferous Aether. It was believed this aether medium zone was started or expanded by the big bang and all Matter that we can interact with exists in this medium. Everything outside of it that we still don't know much about and can't interact with is dark matter/dark energy. Energy/heat is nothing but particles bouncing around in a condescend zone. There is a theory that dark energy is responsible for causing the expansion of the universe which meteion claims do be doing as endsinger. She wants to do this to speed up the heat death of the universe, because the true universe is nothing but a cold void. Aether is the medium/ bubble that protects us from the cold void and keeps the energy/life-force in a condescend zone. Let's say a star acts as a gravity well/reserve for aether thus over time creating a dense area of aether. so people are reincarnated on their star in the form of matter/condescend aether. But it's even stated that if a star is destroyed they can be reincarnated in another star, because of the Aether medium. Since there is a 2:1 ratio Meteion power over dynamis can washout/ erase a person's Aether when it gets too sparse. like dirt and water. Thus ending their reincarnation cycle in the life force
MSQ said the dynamis attacks came thru where the celestial aether was thin or missing. Zodiark was summoned to cause the celestial aether to be even across the entire star.
After watching this video, the entire 60-70 Job quests for White Mage came flooding into mind having played through it recently. I won't spoil anything but.....
I am very interested in the limit break video, I would also LOVE to see a break down of the blessing of light and how it differs from the echo. There seems to have been a bit of retconing in shadowbringers that should be cleared up.
@@SynodicScribe I mean I kinda understand. In my head cannon I assume that anyone who awakens to the echo and is able to hear hydaelyn automatically is bestowed the basic blessing of light (aka the travelers ward) by her, making them immune to tempering and other aetheric corruption at minimum.. Using a the full shield and other more powerful abilities requires getting 1 or more crystals of light.
I feel like the fact that things associated w/ dynamis (e.g., the blasphemies) have a similar color scheme to the void and voidsent has to be significant somehow. Granted, that might be more the Song of Oblivion than dynamis itself, but it's something that struck me.
Considering how source of power is described in final fantasy universe for Dark Knights, do you think they actually might be utilising dynamis? Not enough data to confirm it, but it kinda fits.
One point of correction. We know what Zodiark did to Ethierys once summoned and the change he made to what aether did. He changed the world from one where the celestial aether (the outermost aetheric part of the atmosphere) followed currents and changed density in places according to various laws, to one where the celestial aether was constantly dense around the entire planet, with no drop in density at all. This was because the ancients discovered that areas of low celestial aetheric density were the places the Final Days would turn apocolyptic. And once the Song started attacking, changing, and eventually corroding spots of weak aether, they'd stay that way. Hydaelyn's capturing of Zodiark was done to keep him doing that. Once Zodiark is gone, the world's aetheric rules went right back to their natural state, and to that we see the one result: Celestial Aether reverts back to a variant state.
While we sure can explain everything with Aether I also want to note that emotions can lead to even greater feats. A berserker comes to mind and sure one might say that it's just someone who gave up on restraining themselves in a fit of rage but one can argue that because of these pure emotions these powers are enhanced. And while it may sound silly, I myself can also say that I'm far more productive when I'm in a good mood which can also be attributed to dynamis due to the emotional nature.
So I have a bit of a dissenting theory as to how aether and dynamis function and interact. To draw some parallels to how energy works in real life physics energy itself is a bit of an abstract concept: we have usable forms of energy that are easier to manipulate and observe such as heat, electricity, and motion. These different forms of energy can with some work be intercompatible and changed into one another but at the end of the day it's still energy. I believe that Aether and dynamis share a similar relationship: they are two aspects of one concept, and the use of one elicits reactions from the other. That is to say it is not necessarily that more aetherically dense beings like the ancients had complete inability to affect dynamis ( If that were the case Hermes would never have been able to create Meiteon), But more likely that they just hadn't made the logical leap to consider the two as coming from a fundamental pool of nebulous " energy ". The main reason I look at it this way is because of the final fight with Zenos. I think our constant pushing of the limit in that fight is meant to represent a conversion of dynamis into usable Aether, But I don't think it's a necessarily because we understood dynamis better. The one solid fact we know about dynamis is that it is strongly affected by emotion, And that fight is an emotionally charged moment not just from a storytelling perspective but to the characters involved. To me it seems likely that emotions agitate the flow of dynamis, and cause it to sort of burn releasing energy into a more usable form. And to circle back to the ancients, I think the reason they lacked ability to manipulate dynamis at a wider scale, is because their culture has a very prominent focus on crushing individuality and suppressing emotion. They are a very ascetic culture based on what we've seen, and I think this is the real determining factor into why their knowledge and use of dynamis is so limited.
My biggest theory in regards of Dynamis is that Auracite is the perfect balance of Aether and Dynamis intermingled. The strong desires and emotions it takes in along with the aether mingling and mixing until the very fabric of reality begins to fray as ambition reshapes the flesh. Whether Ultima was aware of Dynamis when creating the auracite in 14's version of Ivalice is up for debate, though I'm personally leaning toward the idea that it was more of an accidental byproduct rather than a feature. To use the example of concrete and abstract energy you make here, I kind of visualize Dynamis in similar terms of soundwaves. A powerful enough blast of sound has the power to knock someone off their feet, or even jostle internal organs while leaving the rest of the body unaffected, but in its natural state is something we experience all the time and we don't consciously notice it. But with the right tools and, time, and energy can be amplified fairly easily to deafening degrees. By the same token, should a tool or amplifier not be properly adjusted, those waves can become amplified ad infinitum in a feedback loop, until ears start bleeding.
So I'm delirious with sick right now, so maybe this isn't as funny as it is in my head, but as I listen to your narration, I keep mentally swapping the word dynamis with "traffic lights." The video is thoroughly amusing that way. 🤓
To be fair the introduction of traffic lights in FFXIV have really shaken things up. But now we've gotta considered how traffic lights might affect the world moving forward.
Yeah, it did. But how? The method behind such an act could have meant a variety of things for the world. But we don't know the exact nature of Zodiark's powers, and now we never will.
@@SynodicScribe They used the concept of darkness which stands for progress and advancement. That way the aether flowed faster hence enhancing it. It was explained in Shadowbringers how Light is a force of Stasis and Darkness for advancement
LOVE your videos. Thank you so much. I was hoping for a clarification. You mentioned we were 8 rejoined. Would it not be 9? Being born on source -1, 7 collapses - 8, Ardbert - 9. Am I mistaken or not understanding? Thank you so much for everything.
I can feel that Limits are Dynamus in action XD which also explains why its only lb3s that are different. Maybe its the dynamis within the job crystals? This is assuming that it, as emotion, can be stored in the same manor as the memories and techniques.
A few thoughts: 1) Humanity is capable of interacting with dynamis, they just didn't know how. Some people have guessed that a limit break is an example of this. This is supported by the phase change in the final day trial where your friends create a shield for you. 2) Nero knew something. In the Crystal Tower raid, he was searching for an unknown power source. At the end of the raid series, the final cutscene has him standing on a cliff edge near the crystal tower. He says something about going off to start a new life and throws his scanner into the ravine. As the camera pans away, morse code can be heard echoing up from the canyon. The morse code, when translated, says "It's all wrong". Sound familiar? He detected Meteion and the power source he was looking for was Dynamis. This is in the cutscene still and can be seen in the journal in the inn. They had that planned almost a decade ago. 3)Other possibilities for Dynamis in action would be the bard and monk who use inner ability rather than specific aether applications but that's just a theory. 4) Shortly before the "Final Days" dungeon, Emet-Selch and Hythlodaeus were able to use creation magic to create a field of flowers that produced enough dynamis to sustain the environment in Ultima Thule without the souls of the Scions, allowing them to be re-formed. Thus Dynamis could, to some degree, be interacted with by Aether dense beings using magic.
"Aye always good ta see yer lectures, this is very new to meh as well, 'owever I 'eard it being called Akasa by Thavnir Alchemists, only vague whispers though ... nothing conclusive, yet." -Amov
I like the idea that Dynamis is able to sort of complement and augment Aether, but the idea that Dynamis is able to make up the power gap in sundered and partially rejoined beings is something I never considered, and REALLY like.
The way Emit Selch explained the shards, I figured each shard gained a new 1/14th when a shard rejoined with the source. So the first is 7/14th like the source.
The 1st is still 1/14th. Only the Source gained aether/power from the rejoinings. The shards will ever remain the 1/14th fragments they were meant to be.
I should point out though that even if the WoL is 8 times rejoined due to Ardbert, it is heavily implied that the finishing blow dealt to Hades using the light that was contained in the WoL also consumed Ardbert's power. So yes, for a short time between the beginning and end of the fight with Hades, the WoL was 8 times rejoined but afterwards likely returned as only 7 times rejoined. That's further confirmed later when Elidibus walks around in Ardbert's body : the MSQ implies that Ardbert is no more so it becomes glaringly obvious that Elidibus-as-Ardbert is a fake. Either that or that explains why limit breaks are becoming less and less impressive as the overall output of damage makes it use as an emergency raise or mechanic block more important than a damage dealing move : with a 8th rejoining, the potential to deal damage with an LB is less than the constant, raw damage dealt over a period of time by the party... but an emergency party raise is always viable as is being able to soak a party wipe mechanic.
My theory on dynamis, is that it is the exact same thing as the “press of death” from fire force. If you’ve ever watched fire force you’ll know that in the last training arc with benimaru he teaches shinra and Arthur how to exceed their limits and access their hysterical strength and get an adrenaline boost that allows them to keep going in a fight. Benimaru explains that the press of death is more emotional/mental than physical, because you have to genuinely that believe you will die in a fight in order activate it, but once you active it, you break your limits and are able to do things with your powers you could never normally do. I think this is what dynamis is because of the final fight against zenos, both you and zenos surpass your limits in the final fight pushing each other to the brink of death you both come back fully healed and charged with more powerful than before, they say that this is because of the dynamis in your souls burning with passion for the fight, that is pushed you into overdrive, you both tap into your hysterical strength, desperate to defeat the other as the fight goes on, and you both are able to keep going again and again until both you you die. That’s why at the end of the fight neither of you can move, and are on the brink of death, dynamis, or in other words adrenaline caused tou both to used up everything you guys had and left you nothing except what little ability you had to blink.
what about the blasphemies,meteion, and the constructs made by the scions sacrifices? were they not all made of mostly dynamis? meteion in particular was made almost entirely of dynamis,and her attacks were dyanmis based too
Ok there's a few issues there. First off, Meteion is a horrible example of how Dynamis would work on our star since she was engineered differently than how all life naturally occurs on our world. Secondly, Ultima Thule is an aether deprived zone. So again, we can't use that location as an example of how Dynamis would operate on our aether based star. Lastly, the Blasphemies were a direct result of an entity forcing an overwhelming amount of Dynamis onto someone. Therefore, the Blasphemies as we know them could never occur naturally.
While I generally agree with your position on the DK and Warrior jobs in general, I'd like to point out that surprisingly weak effects can have dramatically disproportionate impacts in complex systems, so even if it's effects where EXTREMELY limited if those effects where of the right nature they could still play a critical and/or catalytic role yet still go unnoticed until one knew to look. Just think about how IRL it's often only when our old models don't quite work do we start looking for new options, and are all to willing to overlook small discrepancies so long as it's "good enough". So my hypothesis is that while on the concrete level the jobs work as we've always assumed, certain jobs, especially those that use emotions/instincts, may use dynimus to get that last little something something to work, much like how lighting is diven by atmospheric conditions, yet stray stellar particles can often serve to set of the cascade that is the bolt itself
Just watched the video, on Limit Breaks: I may have mis-interpreted this, but I thought that the Ancients could not really interact with Dynamis nor be impacted by it due to their Aetherical content. Its why Hermes needed to make the Metions in the first place, they could interact while he couldn't. It's the stated reason the End of Days impacted creation magics rather than the Ancients themselves. This also is why, to me, the flowers in Elpis never really bloomed, because its clear the ancients had emotions, just judging by how Emet/Venat/Hythlodaeus interacted, but they never had any impact on the flowers. Which brings me to this: Elidibus uses a Limit Break. You could argue its not a true Limit Break and he is just mimicking what heroes do, but he does use one. And he's an Ancient who can not be impacted by Dynamis. How is he able to use a Limit Break if Limit Breaks come from the emotion of Dynamis? Dynamis can not impact him, so he should not get any power himself. He could theoretically be using Dynamis to create a limit break, but if the Elpis flowers theory I have is true, then he shouldn't be able to manipulate/interact with Dynamis either. So, how is Elidibus able to Limit Break when he can't use Dynamis?
I for the life of me cannot find it, but there is a fan fest lore panel some where in which some one asked Koji directly about Limit Breaks. This is around Stormblood or Shadowbringers... but, Koji very coyly responded to the question before backtracking his response realizing he'd already said too much. I'm sure on the official Forums, Anonymoose somewhere has a record of this... anyway... Koji said limit breaks weren't powered by Aether but another force called Dymamis that was tied to emotional energy. At that point he refused to say much more because it would be spoilers. I can't remember if it was at a PAX panel or an official Fan Fest one... but somewhere if you can find it... there's a record... but I've had trouble nailing it down. All I can do is limit the search window for anyone wanting to hunt to sometime between 2014 and 2018.
One theory I had on dynamis and how it interacts is that unlike aether it is a more vague and "spiritual" energy. Ather is solid (metaphorically speaking) it has elemental manifestations, poles, and can be weaved into direct spells. It is controlled via techniques and mind. While dynamis is tied to emotions, it is more passive, and unseen. Less methadological per say and less potent. That might be why it wasn't as out there and worked on as aether. Anyone can look at a warrior pushing his hardest and say: "Oh they barely pulled through." Realistically not many would go out of their way and be like: "Oh odd they shouldn't be able to do that so there must be a second force!" If that makes sense. Way I see dynamis and aether based classes is, dynamis boosts your overall skills. Or as the game puts it, it helps you go beyond your limits. While it's effects aren't as pronounced as that of the aether, it is there behind the curtains, assisting you during your hour of need, feeding not upon your pool of magic, but of your emotions, urging you to stride ever forward through and beyond your limits.
I would consider how you dont have limit break at the start of your fight and only get it after you've done a lot of fighting and have expended your aether. Aether leaves, Dynamis takes its place. Limit Break becomes avaliable? I dunno. I might be smoking
Like I said, Limit Breaks were explained long before Endwalker and I have the data to prove it. But I'm not releasing it for the exact reason you just proved. lol
Hmm.. if Meteion is associated with despair, do voidsent associate with greed, and sineaters with apathy? Each of these corrupt the body and soul, leaving nothing but an incarnation of despair/greed/apathy and stray memories.
this REALLY makes me wonder if one of the surviving shards has actually discovered dynamis early on and has become extremely fluent in it since they are the most susceptible to it to the point that some people on there might even think of aether as useless. that would be so fucking interesting
Here's my wild hypothesis regarding Dynamis and LB's. So, I believe that when someone executes a limit break they're effectively using almost every last drop of their aether, to a degree it's actually dangerous. This is where I think Dynamis come into play, filling in the void left by our (temporarily) detached aether in a manner not unlike what's seen in terminus beasts. This doesn't explain how one who's performed a LB has enough aether to keep fighting after it's finished, but as I said earlier this is very much wild conjecture.
My take on it is that since Dynamis affects aether, a LB is basically the WoL's strength of will drawing upon the surrounding aether and having it augment their own powers without necessarily making the WoL have that aether flow through them / having the WoL command that aether through normal means
Since dk and war abilities are at least partially rooted in emotion, then it's possible that there's a subconscious mixing of the two. Also Bard songs. And well if it's subconscious, would they notice?
Something I’d been thinking about… I like the theory that limit break is dynamis but… didn’t Elidibus use multiple limit breaks himself in the fight against the WoL? Wouldn’t that throw off the whole theory given unsundered people like Elidibus wouldn’t be able to manipulate Dynamis? Also. I’d love to see a video on the sundering itself. It always confused me. Did Vanaut split all of existence into 14. Or just planet into 14. Are the Shards pocket dimensions or do they have their own universe outside the planet that mirrors the source?
From the information expressed to us via the MSQ it seems to me that dynamis is likely not only responsible for us being able to pull off limit breaks but indeed for us to push beyond our limits in the first place. I've mentioned this before but the entire Omega raid series was centered around Omega being frustrated that he couldn't properly quantify our power. Even with all of its advanced sensors and knowledge obtained over the millennia it was continually surprised that we defeated enemies that were far stronger than us. Furthermore, when it tried to directly see if we could instantly do the impossible it was a failure resulting in Midgardsormr having to step in to save our lives. Clearly, we have to work ourselves up to defeating these powerful foes, just like how we slowly accumulate limit gauge over time. Throughout a fight, our emotions rise and rise until they eventually allow us to transcend the limits of our aetherial existence if only briefly. Omega, by comparison, was seemingly never able to tap into this power source as it seemed utterly devoid of emotions which was likely a product of the Omicrons ridding themselves of their flesh-based existence and converting their minds into data.
Omega, and by association the Omicron in general, knew nothing about dynamis either. The Ea likewise seemed completely unaware of its existence. Either of those races theoretically would have done everything possible to learn all they could about it for their purposes otherwise.
Also worth noting, that while they are dealing with only a working theory, Nidhanna does give an example of being in combat and surpassing your physical limits as being a potential manifestation of Akasha.
Despite the Endsinger's quote, Nidhannas example, and the Omega questline alluding to something else making you more powerful than they expect (which ends up being essentially because you care for others and have feelings, oh wait...) That Synodic dismisses the idea outright, and doesn't even seem to give it a thought. Quite frankly it feels the MSQ is almost going out of it's way to plant that idea without explicitly saying it.
Unfortunately that seems to not be the case. As we've seen from Elidibus he's able to use Limit Breaks with little to no effort. Meaning that Limit Breaks are fundamentally aether based since he's an unsundered, his aether would drown out any and all dynamis.
But was it really his own power he was using, or that of all the spectral heroes he was summoning to empower himself?
@@nerobiblios4086 But wasn't he using the hero's "summoned" beyond the rift *conviction* (which is driven by a very strong emotion) to fight evil to empower himself (which might explain the golden glow of those heros when they appear) making him a summon that was made through dynamis MORE than aether given when he separated from Zodiark he was a FRAGMENT of his former self and comprised of far less aether.
On his own he SHOULDN'T be able to use dynamis but he was using emotions of countless others that overpowered the aether he's comprised of to manifest.
summoning is driven through prayer via emotions (like desperation)
So isn't it possible that you can create a primal out of dynamis??
Something that I missed but want to point out is that jobs like Dark Knight are visibly spending and consuming Aether to power their Spells/Abilities. If they run out of Aether, they run out of Dark Magic since the Abyss is their own personal pool of aether ignited. However, what we should be considering is how Dynamis might be aiding in helping shape their dark aether into something more potent, like an amplifier or focusing lens.
It should also be mentioned that the inner beast of warrior could be partially influenced by dynamis as well. Possibly. Also I think it more likely Ran'jit is a Reaper analogue.
You said that the shards, by technicality we should have wiped them left and right, but by that point we shouldn't be winning against Unsundered Ascians, more direct we should have straight lost to Elidibus or Emet Selch. Though I suppose there are reason to posit for those two victories...
@@keinchi So you're trying to equate a 1v1 stand off between Ranji and the WoL vs an 8v1 victory against an unsundered? lol
@@SynodicScribe You can apply that argument but we did have a 1v1 fight twice over with one of the unsundered before they did their primal power up. Or how about the fight with a certain other Unsundered in the past? OH and lets not forget we've fought Ranjit multiple times with more people v. Himself so you can't just say "8v1" when like it minimizes it.
@@SynodicScribe If the fate of the source affects the reflections IE: it's destruction also causes their destruction. Would not the source getting stronger with from a rejoining also make the reflections stronger. Ambient aether flowing from the source and spread between the remaining reflections.
To break the rule (of MSQ sourcing).
Something interesting: Urianger speculated that faith and prayer may have some ties to dynamis in the MSQ.
There’s an Aether current side quest in Labyrinthos (Gleaner’s Wish) where a Sharlayan operator gives a lantern crystal to a Viera gleaner. He asks you to pray, giving hope and good wish to the bearer of the lantern.
The researcher comments on his recent discovery of Thavnair’s theory of akasha and wonders if their custom of praying over these lanterns might be tied to it. The Ancients seem to have an atheistic society, which would make sense being such dense aetherial beings, faith is useless for them as it would have no bearing on them, since they have scarcely any dynamis to be affected by it.
In the MSQ, it is faith that is used to help control one’s dynamis by providing a centered hope in (Final Days) Thavnair. My theory is that similarly to aether having different elements of two polarities. I think dynamis/akasha also has different elements (such as hope, joy, sadness), with positive and negative polarities. The WoL showed that there can be sadness, but it doesn’t destroy. It helps connect and ground a person. Then there is the sorrow and despair of the Endsinger which causes destruction.
So…my speculation is that the Alliance raids will probably give some more information on the relationship between faith and dynamis. Probably indirectly, as the word dynamis is a recent (re)discovery.
What does this mean? Not much, but hopefully we will find out more come future patches.
Omega Raids foreshadow's dynamis' existence if we wanna go outside of msq stuff
Faith is a good sample of dynamis in the scene when you limit break(tank) the first wipe skill of Endsinger after that the scion pray for WoL that is a power of dynamis too.
In second astral era they begin to pray for stop the calamity that's is the beginning of magic but I think it's about dynamis because they didn't know about magic too much but they learned by not casting at all.
I guess dynamis is a parallel of aether anyway. Aether is control by aether of user and knowledge to manipulate but dynamis is a power of feeling that unstable up to feeling of the user but yet powerful one . Speaking of parallel I always thinking about Ultima I didn't learned about it too much cause what is a parallel magic anyway
Dynamis (especially the fact that it interacts so weakly with the material world, and that it's stated to make up 68.3% of all energy in the universe) is a reference to dark energy in the real world.
What you said about the Dancer is also concreted by the fact that we fight a Kakodaemon, a manifestation of Foul emotions and Dynamis in both the endsinger fight and the final job quest for dancer. Seeing as dancer isn't a caster or isn't said to interact with aether (Yes I know all jobs interact with it, but in different ways and intensity mind you, focusing on how dancer would be lower aetherically active), maybe the invigoration that dancers do influences the dynamis in a positive way, purging the dark transformative emotions it can have. Of course, we would need more evidence on Dancers using Dynamis so I wouldn't be so bold as to just state it. But it is curious.
While I agree with your main point here, I would just point out that ALL Jobs in FFXIV interact with aether. Be it a Samurai or a Black Mage they are both using aether to different ends be it simply empowering their bodies or converting their energies into raw elemental power.
Kakodaemon? Doomslayer class confirmed?
Hm, there is also one in the raid... that must mean something then
Makes me question how bards might use dynamis through songs to influence their allies but to what extent? Seems really cool to think about
@@bharbarawyrstwaemasyn8741 was bout to mention bard, and honestly their effects on emotion hence dynamis, same with dancer here, can technically be seen in RL.
it’s very common for certain dancing and music to cause surges of emotion. good or bad. like, imagine Bard doing “through the fire and flames” then you getting a damage buff cause you are fcking hyped.
the main uses of aether for both dancer and bard are either A, weapon control (those arrows and flying discs sure as shit aint jsut skill) and B, better transmission of their dancing/singing. the dynamis comes in by the effects it has on you.
like people RL literally can get stat boosts from music, be it motivation or concentration. translate that into a worl of magic i can see it having far more extensive results.
The point you make with Ran'jit makes a point that Dynamis has always been under the surface but not named.
Since Shadowbringers we've encountered a number of beings that were aetherically to us as we are to Ran'jit. If we should have mopped the floor with Ran'jit because of our aetheric density, then should not Hades, Elidibus, Hermes, Venat, Erichthonius, and Hesperos done much the same to us? There's absolutely no way we should have been able to take on Ancients directly.
And yet we can.
Dynamis is the force that enables us to transcend limits. It's the force that Omega (who is aetherically similar to an Ancient in this context) encounters and finds themself unable to overcome or explain.
People have misinterpreted the scene where we're being told about akasa as some asspull. It's not. She's telling us there's something that is confused with aether (which limit breaks and our power levels have been) and that no one knows how to directly manipulate (which doesn't imply it's never been used, when taken in context with it not being understood.) Take the pair together and you can conclude what she's really saying (narratively) is that dynamis/akasa has always been there, and that many things we thought were aether (such as the limit break) were akasa. And the story has always implied there's something inexplicable about us and people that allows them to rise to challenges and strife that they otherwise should not.
Based. I want Omega back.
@@eW91dHViZSBpcyBjZW5zb3JzaGlw i still believe omega is alive inside mini omega that accompanies alpha the chocobo
The problem I see with explaining Ran'jit kicking WoL's ass through dynamis however is that dynamis is supposed to interact with emotions and Ran'jit has never been shown to be very emotional quite the opposite in fact a calm and collected tactician and the only time where he actually gets emotional is the exact time where WoL ends up beating HIM which makes the entire argument of him using dynamis fall apart completely since if he had really been using dynamis WoL would've never been able to beat him in that fnal battle especially so inferring Ran'jit using dynamis doesn't make sense if you ask me WoL losing to Zenos and Ran'jit multiple times is just a case of good old plot armor
@@BlitzAce1995 Are we talking about the same character?
The Ran'jit in the game I played was a grief stricken old man who trained the only hope against sin eaters, treated them like daughters, and watched them die again and again and again and again and again and again until finally he snapped, was given a hope of peace by Vauthry and subsequantly made ensuring the next Minfillia would never have to lose her life to her destiny again.
Ran'jit is hella emotional as a character, he's just not 'stupid shonen anime emotions'. But like, ACTUAL emotions.
Also, 'plot armor' doesn't mean 'Your powerfantasy character loses sometimes'. It means 'There is an ongoing plot that requires that character to remain alive in order to resolve it.' What you're describing is 'What should actually fucking happen to a protagonist now and then'
@@DracoSuave the way I see Ran'jit is that witnessing all the loss he did made him become bitter resulting in him supreesing his emotions (in which Vauthry's influence porbably also plays some role) which would get in the way of him using dynamis but that also doesn't change the fact that neither Zenos nor Ran'jit have ever been properly set up to be a threat for WoL at all I mean people TELL us that they're powerful but SE don't SHOW it to us until the scripted fights where they beat WoL if we were shown any feat of their strength before the first fight I wouldn't agrue for it being an asspull. We don't have any evidence to go by for how they measure up to Nidhogg at all if we were shown at Bealsar's Wall how Zenos beat Shinryu after Omega dissapeared or how Ran'jit easily beats some Sin-eater of a type that WoL struggled I wouldn't argue with the whole thing but as it stands the only evidence of their strengh is normal people tellung us that they're powerful which isn't exactly a good measuring stick since normal people don't exactly scale up to WoL and honestly I'm not really too fond of the idea of dynamis as a whole as it is seems too much of an ExMachina to me to explain something the writers didn't know to explain otherwise by going going "yeah that random person is totally able to beat the LITERAL GODSLAYER due to some unseen and undetectable power that is completely inexplicable otherwise" you see. My point is show don't tell if we were shown more about how dynamis works we peobably wouldn't be haing this argument in the first place but as it is we simply know too little to make really much out of it.
There is also evidence that the Bard may be using Dynamis to empower others with their songs. Especially with the quest named "The Ballad of Oblivion" in the Bard questline.
Tank LB3 is even hinted at to be dynamis
@@NikkoTanGoogle All LBs are Dynamis.
When I hear Dynamis I'm given PTSD of FF11. That was one of our raids. Lore wise I think it was the realm of dreams.
Considering that Dynamis is related to emotion, I wonder if it has a relation to the Aramitama and Nigimitama concept that was introduced in the Four Lords quest back in Stormblood? The Auspices of Stormblood was said to build up Aramitama as they grow in age and power through the passage of time, which is a violent and active aspected emotional energy that can corrupt and transform them if it is not balanced by Nigimitama, a calm and passive aspected emotional energy. This is similar to the concept of Astral and Umbral aspect of Aether. Perhaps Aramitama and Nigimitama could refer to observable effects of aspected Dynamis.
Moreover, Auspices are known to transform between animal and humanoid forms much like Meteon and Terminus beasts, and much like the concept of Limit Break, transcend the natural cycle of rebirth by living beyond their normal lifespans and transcend the limitations of being originally mundane animals with mundane levels of aether.
If all that I am theorizing is true, then perhaps Auspices could be considered a kind of Entelechies as well, that unlike Meteon, who is crafted, are naturally occurring.
Could be! I like this theory alot!
Spirit (ari) and vessel (nigi) is indeed one of the form of Dynamis. Dynamis technically represents potential energy. A form of power that driven by emotional circumstances or imbalance constant by nature.
Every religious has one, but not everyone understand what it means, which ends up no further research ever concluded and passed down. Aether by itself is a constant flow of energy. Dynamis isn’t, which makes it easier to forget or disprove by something that more easier to understand.
An astral/umbral side of Dynamis is basically expected to be explored at some point, as MSQ's been doing the same for Aether for all the while up to this point.
There was also that thing with the zenos fight where we get a buff saying the high concentration of dynamis in the area was giving us strength
I want to add in terms of how the final days came to be. When in Mare Lamentorum and after beating Zodiark the watcher explains that when the final days started happening during the ancient times the location and time of where the final days started coincided with the weakening/decay (as to why this happened no one knows it could be a natural process or phase) of the celestial currents of ather around eytheris. Because this "Barrier" or layer of ather was gone there was nothing to block the dynamis from meteon from entering eytheris proper. And zodiark was summoned to basically reinforce or sustain the celestial current. And since we defeated zodiark there was nothing to maintain the celestial current thus restarting the final days. (Similar to how the earths magnetic field protects the earth from cosmic radiation)
So I did remember that right. They did explain how Zodiark was preventing the final days.
Yeah if I remember correctly the celestial aether started to stagnated, thats why Zodiark is created of darkness, because darkness creates motion of aether the opposite of light which is stasis, so basically Zodiark just sustains the flow of celestial aether creating a protective barrier around etherys.
Dynamis is basically the real life interpretation of dark energy. Only until recently that we know it exists, but we don't know how to prove it. It just does but we are making efforts regardless.
Since they introduced Omega's intentions as early as Stormblood, I don't think it was a last minute plot device slotted in. It's almost like they've been writing on "the world's mysteries" since the end of Heavensward and somehow linked dragons to it.
Anyway, tinfoil hat time: What if Garleans are actually able to interact better with Dynamis?
Ishikawa did write Omega.
They have been thinking about Dynamis and Meteion since HW. Look at Alexander, in the song Locus, there are lyrics that say, back to back.
"Celestial Noise Detected, Delirium Unsuspecting." which is exactly what Meteion's song is.
@@archmagemc3561 it could be any number of things. Alexander, a being _purely and entirely made out of aether,_ would not be able to detect dynamis at all in the same way the ancients weren’t able to interact with it.
It’s infinitely more likely that he was referring to the omicrons’ electronic communications than dynamis.
Garleans tapping into dynamis easier would explain how they can live in the inhospitable climate of the north without any aether.
@@throwmeaname they have aether, they just can’t tap into it in the same way we can. So no magic, instead they are physically stronger.
It's not MSQ related so you wouldn't have mentioned it, but there is one mention of it that struck me. Going through my lost actions with Bozja for Reaper grinding the item "Dynamis Dice" smacked me across the face. Considering the item is equally powerful an fickle, I think it needs to be noted.
My friends in the FC and I remarked on the same thing after finishing the MSQ. You're basically putting your faith in a possible good outcome. Not aether, but belief.
Throwing my own hat into the ring about Bozja, the Resistance weapons also use certain types of memories of the dying to upgrade, and in the Blade's step, raw emotions.
Really shaky, but I think it could be something to consider too.
@@chaos_blue1089Memories are aether
It probably can't be easy for you given all the new information we've been given on FFXIV's metaphysics, but I think you're doing a great job so far. Looking forward to more!
I hypothesize that Dynamis acts with Aether in the same way that the blue lantern rings interact with green lanterns in the DC universe. They're not particularly strong own, but when coupled with their much stronger companion, they *supercharge* it and push it past any normal limits, hence limit breaks using Dynamis according to the Endsinger. And since we've been rejoined once more than anyone else, and yet we can use Dynamis with our LBs, it may be that Dynamis multiplies the effects of Aether, but too much Aether makes it harder to interact with it. Like, more Aether means a greater barrier between the person and Dynamis, but if the person can breach that barrier, then the Dynamis has WAY more effect. I.E. if an Ancient were *unfathomably* emotional and could somehow use Dynamis, they'd be completely unstoppable
But shouldn’t that instance with the Endsinger not be used as the standard to measure this? It’s an outlier or a specific instance that would never have otherwise happened outside of Ultima Thule due to the nature of its Dynamis composition. If it were anywhere else, the outcome would have been very different.
It very much seems like dynamis is very much like gravity in quality, it's a weak force that exists everywhere that can be defied by simply raising your hand but also creates black holes. Meanwhile aether is a strong force like the nuclear force
This is my new favorite channel.
Also, my favorite part about the discussion of Akasa / Dynamis is when Nidhana states that, in legend and myth, it was 'torn from the heavens'. From my point of view, it sort of implies that the song 'Torn From The Heavens' is almost an anthem to the power of Dynamis. The heroic, rising notes retroactively symbolizing the rising of Dynamis in the Warrior of Light, cresting and seething with their desire defend Etheirys, as well as the instrument of shattering their limits.
Hell, to call it 'The Limit Break Song' wouldn't really be wrong, from that point of view.
Glad to see I wasn’t the only one who noticed that correlation! Especially since it normally plays when we are transcending our limits.
I’m inclined to think this is deliberate (how could it not be) but only time will tell! Right now we know next to nothing about Dynamis and can’t say much with any certainty. I look forward to what the future will bring!
At this point in time, would the Elpis flowers be our only effective or consistent tool for interacting with dynamis for research purposes? Unlike us, it’s classified as an entelechy.
If I recall, in Elpis, Meteion refers to us as being just like her, an Entelechy
@@iGREENification we're not an entelechy. she's a child and didn't know any better. lol
@@SynodicScribe I just rewatched the cutscene where she says this, and Hermas says just because we are thin of aether, it doesn't make us an entelechy but that we can be affected by akasha and be able to transcend our limitations. This being that we aren't so reliant on aether as we thought, but a combination of the two since the sundering.
@@iGREENification Late reply, but even still, we cannot research the energy in question ourselves. So the flower itself is still something usable for research purposes.
There are a couple of in-game mechanics that can be explained a bit further if you take the existence of Dynamis, or even in-game occurances.
First is our ability to "Push the limit", our buff where the Warrior of Light is taking things past the normal capabilities of physics. This only happens in very important, emotionally laden fights. Our will, our need to succeed harnesses Dynamis to give us an extra boost. As you said, we are powerhouses of Aether of ourselves.
The Echo buff may be a second. While we're taught that the Echo is a thing that we've unlocked from being sundered Ancients ourselves, the buff we get might be traceable back to Dynamis. The 'vision' we get from the battle gone wrong only serves to emotionally charge us into needing to try harder.
It is important to note that the Echo itself is not Dynamis. We've been told that this is an ability the people of Ancient Etheirys could call on. I feel that everyone who actually HAS the Echo is a sundered soul of an Ancient. While others who live around us may be sundered but might have been part of that new life that flourished in the time after Zodiark saved the world. The shade of Hythlodaeus says as much in Amaurot; One third gave their lives to summon Him, about half of the survivors again to restore the elements and purify the lands so that New Life might be born. And of that new life they would sactrifice to get their own back. That stands to conclude that a lot of new beings with souls were alive at the time that Hydaelyn sundered the place. Despite the big emotional scene showing it happening on the Final Day. I believe that to just be narrative compression of events.
Our Limit Break has been confirmed to BE Dynamis manipulation by Meteion herself. In fact it makes sense considering that everyone in the party cheers you on when you use it, suggesting there is more of a "WE CAN DO THIS!" feeling behind it than outright Aether manipulation. The fact that it charges slowly but steadily but gets quick boosts when someone survives a deadly attack or a healer cures a ton of health on someone who went sub 10% would also suggest an emotional origin. (listen for a tiny little swoosh sound whenever someone does that and note that the lb bar grew quite a bit )
And the last thing I can recall at this point are the NPCs who can go toe-to-toe with the Warrior of Light and sometimes even warrant us to use our breaking the limits... Almost all of them are fighting us for a belief they hold personally very VERY dear. You mentioned Ran'Jit; He fights us in name of the faith he has placed in Vauthry, but ALSO the desperate desire to not let yet another Minfillia die a needless death. Believe it or not, he DOES care about her. And since he's willing to die for that belief, he is able to harness more than simply Aether to his side. And almost everyone else who suddenly appear as powerful as the person who has killed pretty much the entire Pantheon of gods of everyone around them are almost always fighting us from a similar position of deep and emotional conviction.
Your statement of the other shards being more "attuned" than the Source's denizens...It is highly speculative that the "main energy source" on how the Empty at the First would be reclaimed would be Dynamis. given how emotionally charged the events of the Eden arc was (love between two ancients, reconciliation of said ancients and moving on, forging new relationships as well), the sudden growth of plant life, nature slowly reclaiming Eden, as the entwined tree surrounding it after finishing the story arc, it would seem Dynamis is pushing the aetheric balance a bit strongly to project effects such as those, just like on your last statement of augmenting both energies to produce a much greater effect.
I'm tempted to call Dynamis an asspull, but the Endwalker msq goes to great lengths in establishing it as an esoteric and obscure subject with (until now) very little practical application in-universe. It may very well be that it was only now first mentioned because there was never occasion to mention it before.
It also helps that there are previous events in the story that make a lot of sense in the context of dynamis existing, i.e. Omega's whole test was basically trying to figure out how it worked without knowing what it is
@@dumbsterdives Also probably explains how faith/belief is a tangible phenomenon capable of physically affecting the world.
It's an asspull, just like how meteion has the power to destroy worlds when she's just supposed to be a record keeping 'AI' bird. There's several unquestioned things and asspulls in the story. All seems to go downhill when reviewing the past.
@@TKUltra971 If you put a gun to my head and asked me to explain it I'd say that, as entelechies, the Meteion collective was both empowered and warped by a massive amount of negative dynamis over the course of literal eons. Whether or not that's a convincing explanation is a matter of opinion I suppose.
@@TRECTADACTYL interesting theory. I just don't get why out of the blue a ai 'robot' automatically has the power to end words. negative or not. And that makes even less sense that Hermes would create her and never expect or predict this to be an outcome. Also i don't buy every world visited was a grave yard or 10 minutes past the dooms day clock in armageddon.
Spoiler
Perhaps I'm misremembering this but wasn't Zodiarc strengthening the celestial currents. This would hold back the song of the end by drowning it out with more dense aether. Please tell me if I'm missing something here.
He's making the celestial currents move faster, via the polarity of darkness to be astral. Fast-moving celestial currents means no points were there are weak currents, thus no way for Meteion to enact the final days through dynamis.
The biggest thing I got out of it is that we have always been using Dynamis whenever we push beyond our limits. So for example when we get the Echo buff after dying in a dungeon or trial. That buff was always associated to the power of the Echo from the name, but it could possibly be us pushing further by tapping into Dynamis
You're also forgetting there was another tease that I took to mean Limit Break was Akasha, later being Dynamis of course. In the same conversation we hear about Akasha for the first time, to give an example Nidhana says "As a veteran of the battlefield, surely you've experienced moments of desperation or exaltation when you transcended the usual limits of your capabilities? That is a manifestation of Akasha." which calls out Limit Break being Dynamis before even hitting level 84 or knowing anything really set in stone about Dynamis. I actually noticed this and in my head was just going "oh so this is Limit Break got it." It wasn't that mind-blowing of a revelation for me as this was the end of the current story. I expected answers like this.
This right here. Is why I'm not uploading the Limit Break video. Even with all the sources and data I have, these kind of comments will flood the video and cause further confusion. lmao
@@SynodicScribe I completely understand that hahaha
10:34 "Let's ask ourselves wha--HOW dynamis affects us?"
Dynamis is extremely similar to The Warp from Warhammer 40k. The Warp being, in super simple terms, a dimension or veil on top of our own, filled with a raw energy that reacts to emotion and can be channeled by skilled individuals to wield what you would call magic or supernatural powers. But it can also corrupt living beings too. Or living beings can corrupt "it" in certain cases thru their strong emotions, giving birth to abominations in the Warp. Look into it, I bet that's where they took some inspiration from.
Does that mean we get to play Paradox-Billiards-Vostroyan-Roulette-Fourth-Dimensional-Hypercube-Chess-Strip Poker?
@@SynodicScribe I hope so!
@@SynodicScribe I love that you know about that TTS reference
@@lukasperuzovic1429 oh I'm a huge fan of Bruva Alfabusa's work. haha
@@SynodicScribe Have you checked out his latest video? It really…. Describes and appreciate the finer details in table making. :D
Great break down and explanation.
Now I want a dancer job video hahaha
I’ve been waiting for this one. Another great video!
Also, the potential connection with the kriegstanz and totenkranz occured to me too. I'd be very disappointed if this wasn't addressed at some point.
In Bard final job quest in heavensward lvl60, the boss called Iigeia sings the quest name "The Ballad of Oblivion". ;)
Spoilers and random thoughts from me. Thanks for the video!
Back in FF6, Limit Breaks weren't actually a thing and instead characters had the possibility of performing a unique desperation attack if they were left at low HP. The way I see Limit Breaks is that they are used when we are at our most desperate (in terms of Healer and Tank LBs) or most exhilarated (in terms of DPS LBs).
Emotions do run high in combat situations. "I have to win because everyone is counting on me!", "I can't give up yet! What will happen to the world if I fail?" These thoughts and desperate feelings probably shaped our will into the wall that protected us from The Endsinger's attack. The Endsigner is surprised because she did not know we could manipulate Dynamis to block her oblivion wave attack even in such a crude fashion. Heck, I doubt we even knew that ourselves and just considered the LB as something that our Warriors of Light could inherently do. Additionally, the Scions praying for our victory granted us a bonus shield that blocked her second wave when we ourselves were spent. This gives credence to my personal theory on why Thordan was so terrified at the end of our battle against him in Heavensward. He couldn't see Dynamis, but he saw us stand up again and again after he threw everything he had against us and yet we still came after him and took everything he threw at us on the chin.
The way Dynamis is structured in game reminds me of one of the bigger mysteries in physics. Why is Gravity, one of the four fundamental forces, so weak in comparison to Electromagnetism? Gravity has infinite range, exists everywhere as a consequence of distortions of space-time. Similarly to Aether, much of our real world technology is based around electricity. Imagine what a society that has access to gravity-based technology could do instead and it is an interesting parallel to dynamis.
There is a short story by Harry Turtledove "The Road Not Taken" where such an alien society which has gravity-based tech but otherwise has weaponry from the Age of Sail attempts to conquer modern day Earth and pretty much immediately loses; however, they unlock this branch of technology for humanity. The aliens realize this and say "What have we done?!" Turtledove has written many other alternative history works of a similar nature and it goes to show that just because one species has access to one technology branch does not inherently make it immediately superior to all others. Similarly tying this random aside back to FF14, even if one of the shards has direct access to Dynamis, does not immediately make it more powerful than our Aether wielding Warriors of Light, it might level the playing field or it may not depending on how it is used; although IMO, Ranj'it was just a really amazing technical fighter and not in anyway wielding Dynamis against us.
About Ranjit, a part of me has a feeling that when rejoinings happen they affect the shards too as the source is just that, the source. I don’t think the remaining shards have 1/14th of their aether, but they aren’t quite 7x rejoined either. Especially since they can use magic and the source couldn’t until the 1st rejoining. Can’t explain what’s going, but I don’t think it’s simple maths. So mebe Ranjit is just a bit stronger than others on the first and has a bit more aether than usual making him a little closer to the WoL? I dunno. All this new info is making my head spin😆
@@etowesho It is a possibility. However, since the Rejoinings were always of Ascian design, I doubt that they would ever rejoin a shard to another shard. Their goal was always to rejoin all the shards to the Source. Also, aether is really only one part of the equation. It doesn't account for 100% of ones combat prowess in the physical space as much as it does for one's ability to exert aetheric energy. Ranj'it, despite his age, was definitely a technical fighter. He studied us before he took us and all the other Scions present down simultaneously. He even said he "had our measure!" That speaks tremendously to his personal skill in combat arts.
Also, I don't want to think that we are innately superior to people on the other shards. We merely have more aether than they do having been through rejoinings, that doesn't necessarily mean that they cannot defeat us in combat and we would be dismissively discounting their own training and abilities that they bring to the table. I would say that Ryne, despite being a native on the First is an equal in combat skill to any of the rogues in the rogue's guild on the Source, possibly superior since she was trained by Thancred and the other Scions.
Could Frey and Myste be dynamis shaped creations of aether? I understand that Frey at least is a sort of necessary construct for the souls crystal but Myste was completely an accident caused by our emotions.
Those guys are essentially familiars as I see it. Just our creation magics leaking through, but I guess Dynamis has some effect on it. I mean, our strongest abilities utilize Dynamis (LBs) so that stuff is extremely potent.
@@Ranziel1 So basically akin to Meteion herself, an aether shell (for lack of a better comparision) sustained and empowered by Dynamis?
Since Zodiark isn't around anymore to shield the Source and the remaining reflections from overabundance of dynamis I can see alot of job classes that relied on emotion to start suddenly getting ridiculous power boosts, such as Dark Knight, Bard and Dancer. And possibly new job classes popping up with dynamis mainly being used.
Your videos are just like Ethys's earlier lore videos...and this is a good thing. Keep up the good works.
I don’t know if this has been mentioned before but there is a bit of a fan/ hinted theory about dynamis that I think warrants further insight on however this does contain some spoilers to the storm blood raids so spoilers for those who haven’t played it yet:
During one of the msq cutscenes one of the dialogue options I noticed (and the one I picked) was a comment on how our characters are able to break their limits from time to time to perform amazing feats that defy explaination. Though emet dismisses it as desperation, it is theorized that instead this is due to the character unknowingly using dynamis energy to temporarily break their limits. The support for this theory comes from both interactions with the endsinger who believes that you used dynamis to survive her first apocalypse attack (the tank limit break required during that part of the fight) and omega, who is trying to understand how a being like the wol and others beat impossible odds. From what has been said omega was trying to understand how your emotional state was what was triggering extreme feats of strength. This according to game theories state that what omega was trying to measure and couldn’t understand was in fact dynamis. I believe that the Theory that the limit break ability is from the wol using dynamis does warrant some further investigation. Hopefully this theory turns out to be fun to investigate as well since it seems like dynamis as a whole is fun to theory craft on
Oooh. Nice video. Makes me want to think of Dynamis Dice lost action in the Resistance quest series. While it mentions placing faith to Nymeia and roll for the best case scenario (e.g. Healer LB3 or some buffs), we still get bad rolls sometimes (uncleansable Doom, etc.).
Potentially dynamis in action as all sorts of emotions are there in the Southern Front and Zadnor - both optimistic and otherwise, which may influence the "rolls", with the Gambler Essence like a flagon of "let me feel good vibes" to mitigate the negative emotions already in the area and skew the rolls into more positive ones?
Just some thoughts though which may or may not be useful in the search for literature on dynamis. Also, it's coincidentally called the Dynamis Dice, meaning it was a battle action that was used previously (its usage frequency could only be theorised) before it was Lost.
Very pleased this sticks with the source text. Lately I keep coming across folks who can’t tell their head canon apart from what the text supports. Your approach is the best one.
Ghostbusters 2 has a parallel way of understanding how emotions influence physical objects.
Slime in the Ghostbusters universe undergoes a pH change while under the influence of different emotions.
Hostile and depressive emotions causes the pH of the slime to become more caustic as hydroxide (-OH) in the substance increases. The visible colors of the negatively charged slime becomes dark pink to black.
Coming into physical contact with negatively charged slime causes people become more hostile and coming into contact with black slime was said to be corrosive to the soul.
Nurturing and more hopeful emotions causes the pH of the slime becomes more acidic as the main body of the substance retains more Hydrogen (H+). The color of the more positively charged slime becomes light pink/white to green.
Being covered in positively charged slime was observed to cause general euphoria.
The thing about limit break having it's history as dynamis, it is not the first time a FF game has tried to have an explanation for the existence of limit breaks. FF9 is an example of dynamis like Trance.
I really enjoy your videos and this is another good one!
A couple of things that I think you missed: Meteion also mentions that the star is saturated with aether, there was also a greater amount compared to dynamis. We also know that dynamis started to effect area of the star where the celestial aether started to weaken which seems to happen naturally, my guess would be that Meteion's song couldn't penetrate that layer or aether so Zodiark reinforce the aether to prevent the song from reaching the star.
Now I have a question! Correct me if I'm wrong, but souls are made of pure aether, so is it possible to have a soul made from pure dynamis? If so it would need to form in a place where there is no aether, and that would be the thirteenth shard since all the aether there got destroyed. Just some food for thought.
As far as we know. No. Souls as we understand them are only composed of aether because Dynamis isn't dense/strong enough to carry what we could be consider the essence of a spirit. Think of it this way, Aether is Proactive(Creating things), while Dynamis is only Reactive(reacting to stimuli).
You know the Cry from the Earth that preludes the Final Days? The start of the theme of the Nael fight in coils has this brutally haunting wail which fits perfectly.
But why would it play there? It's in Dalamuds ruins which was exposed to Dynamis for a really long time when it was in space since the Aether currents only protect Moon and Planet right? Spinfoil or possible?
It was designed to harvest solar aether? Maybe it picked up Meteions lyrics by chance.
(Would also explain the morse code in CT which spells Meteions phrase since it got picked up by dalamud, transmitted to CT and translated into readable data) but that is actual spinfoil
Oh I'd LOVE to see that Limit Break video 👀
Oh wow, holy moly I must sincerely thank you for your warning about Shadowbringers spoilers as my brain must have been half asleep to miss the hint in the title and since I’m at the start of Stormblood I’m trying to avoid spoilers.
See, “Dynamis” is also something from FF11 and I assumed you’d taken a jaunt into Vana’diel so I figured a trip down memory road might be cool.
I played that game years ago, quitting a few months after Abyssea launched. Honestly I don’t remember much about the lore videos exactly, but the Dynamis I knew was maps of the starter cities and Jeuno but filled with insanely tough versions of the beast tribes that fought the civilisations in the real world. They generally required full 18 person teams under a very skilled leader to beat. The goal was to reach a point on the map and click on the ground. Mobs also dropped the second set of artifact armour for each job.
I seriously don’t remember if the Vana’diel version of Dynamis was a dream realm or an alternative reality where the beast tribes won. Might have to look it up.
In any case the Dynamis of FF14 is absolutely not for me just set, so I paused at about 30 seconds in and now I must take my leave.
As someone more or less working in research IRL I do enjoy a lot of what you do on your channel!
Now in regards to Limit Breaks, my understanding of what the Endsinger said is that Dynamis helps to give form to the aether used in the LBs.
Like some kind of spark to launch the whole process.
I think it's a super interesting concept but I wish it was hinted at earlier (maybe in Shadowbringers or Stormblood?). It feels a bit weird because it's not bad but it does lack a strong connection with the world of XIV.
That being said I think the writers could use that and maybe have some parts of the patches/raids/trials/etc... dedicated to show research or attempts of explaining Dynamis and linking it to past events.
I'll hold my opinion on it until then or until we get another Encyclopedia
Hmm, I guess Hermes was the only one who made research about it. The reason is bcus theres very little amount of dynamis in Etheirys. But in the great expanse outside Etheirys, dynamis is more dominant than aether.
I suppose it was sort of hinted at in the Omega raids. Omega really tried to recreate the power we demonstrated during extreme stress, was really baffled by it, even went so far as to try to emulate us in the final fight, but failed, since it's a machine and just can't use Dynamis.
i dunno if this helps but in the bozja content you have acces to the dynamis dice which when used gives different buffs/debuffs and it can even do a healer LB3
When they summoned zodiark I’m not sure what laws rewritten but venat said by his summoning the world was shrouded in Aether keeping the effects of dynamis to a minimum influence so that could explain why dynamis was even less prominent so we could more easily manipulate it as easily as we should of.
Whilst I recognise that this might be only my head cannon, I keep reading peoples comments about dynamis and it seems to be believed by people that dynamis IS emotion, rather than being an ENERGY that can be MANIPULATED or AFFECTED by emotion. In my mind the Elpis flower itself even proves that. A flower, as we understand them doesn't have emotion, but the emotions of others around the flower are affecting the charge of the dynamis either within or around the flower thus changing its colour. I also want to suggest something else. I believe that limit breaks are neither exclusively aether based or exclusively dynamis based. I believe the intent of the lore was to suggest that in using or accessing the energy that is dynamis we are augmenting or pushing past the mortal limitations of our natural powers in time of desperation to result in something I would compare with a sort of adrenaline rush. I have nothing to prove that particular point but I feel like it lets both the aether and the dynamis components not directly contradict each other. Moreover the game seems to imply that though aether is more potent than dynamis sufficient quantities of dynamis can overpower aether too, otherwise Hermes would have had no need to create an entelechy in the first place in order to traverse the great expanse he had to 'look to an alternative source of energy by necessity' if i remember his quote correctly. At this point in time we don't actually know what the power ratio between a unit of aether and a unit of dynamis actually is. aether could be 20% stronger of 1000% stronger, we simply don't have that information at the moment
You're actually correct. People's head cannon on dynamis is kinda running wild at the moment. It's untested, not researched, and undefined at the moment. We'll have to see how or IF they choose to play with dynamis anymore in the future.
A note, I had just remembered that when we had rejoinings explained to us in ShB, they mentioned that MOST of the aether flows back into the shard, not all of it. I believe they said the rest flows back into the other shards as well, but maintenance is happening right now and even I don't have the patience to comb through youtube or the cutscenes.
TL;DR, Ran'jit and the denizens of the other shards aren't 1/14th the strength of an ancient.
@10:00 In summation of your point at this particular moment in the video, if I'm understanding you correctly, you are saying "Dynamis has not been recorded nor discovered in Aetherys's known history, thus has either played no role in the outcome of historical events, or if it was present, at least not to any significant extent." I'm wondering if this may be too bold of an assumption to make. For all we know, many heroes, conquerors, and other such sorts of figures might have wielded Dynamis unknowingly throughout known history. The reason this would not be noted by historical records can be reasonably explained by its absence, but not *only* by its absence. Another, equally viable explanation, was that our inability to detect or measure Dynamis would lead to such effects being conflated with those brought about by an mysterious/subconscious application of Aether, or by "willpower" or "determination" of the individual, or perhaps "a Miracle of the Twelve/the Kami/Some Other God."
Perhaps throughout history events have occured in which Dynamis changed the course of history, but was not recognized for having done so due to its much more subtle nature as a magical force. I'm not saying that it *did* play such a role, either. I'm just saying that, from my point of view, we can't *say* that it didn't or that it did at this time. On the other hand, I view this part of the video as asserting that you feel it definitively did not (based on our current information.)
Im thinking maybe we get a dynamis zone like in FF11, where we go to grind for the new relic weapon. That big area north east in radz-at--han seem to important to be "empty" and must be a hub for something.great video like always btw:)
2 questions.
1.-How does the "sundering" work in relation to the rest of the universe? say, if someone from the first and the source went to the moon would they be able to meet there? Or does each world have their own moon? Or are there actually 14 different universes? IIRC, they don't explain if that is on a timeline/universal level.
2.-Speaking of timelines, what happens with the whole Meteion deal in the "Black Rose" timeline? Sure they say the WoL died there, but it's odd since the current present we live in relies on two separate time travel instances, the exharch going back in time to a different shard and then the WoL going to Elpis. If the WoL said everything that happened to Venat, does that mean that she had to make sure the black rose events happened and then just take a gamble and hope that G'raha would succeed and play his part? If anything the Hydaelin from that timeline will not know if her plan succeeded, I wonder if in the future we will go there in some way and try to fix it or something.
Everyone talking about how Dynamis works, meanwhile I’m gonna be the one to point out that Synodic censored himself in the cutscene from the Dancer quests, mans really doesn’t wanna be seen without that cloak and mask. XD
I wanna keep the mystery alive as long as I can. hehe
Such a fantastic point of insight you provided. Imagine if something else caused rejoinings. The stronger we became aetherically, the stronger the shards could be via dynamis against us
There is something I'd like to point out.
Are there _any_ indication, MSQ or otherwise, that the different shards are of equal power when it comes to aether? looking at the EW MSQ and at Emet-Selch's statements regarding the reflections, it always seemed like the Warrior of Light and the Scions are said to have small amounts of it compared to the "bountiful" of the ancients, despite everyone at that point being half of 14, and even more in the case of the WoL.
If that's true, it suggests that there's at least one reflection with a LOT of aether in their inhabitants, which would in-turn also suggest that this reflection wouldn't be able to manipulate dynamis, and that there would be other shards where people are almost like Garleans and instead manipulate Dynamis. Some might even have/use neither and do something else instead.
My little theory is that dynamis is able to read our feeling telling aether what to do. It would be like computer code telling a program what it needs done, and you input in what you want it to do. So my theory just puts dynamis as like an interpreter. now I still can't figure out why when it goes out of control that it has the influence to change people into monsters. maybe it's just telling the aether to completely rewrite the physical form of an induvial by sacrificing the soul. Still working on that one lol.
Its possible that the prayers and supplications that give rise to primals are based on dynamis too. With dynamis giving aether shape and form based on the will of the worshippers. Great video, thanks.
Warning for spoilers:
The whole idea of Limit Breaks being aether refined by dynamis might hold even more water as we see in Seat of Sacrifice - Elidibus, an unsundered being using immense amounts of aether that even we cannot hope to wield, calls upon assistance from souls of other worlds, either the Source or its reflections. If the theory that LB = dynamis-augmented aether is correct, Elidibus shouldn’t be able to Limit Break at all; yet not only could he, he was capable of attaining a level of Limit Break thought to be completely impossible.
It should also be noted that while not cited by name, dynamis may very well have been established as early as Stormblood, as Omega was trying to figure out why its calculations kept being thrown off by us, and the only thing it could peg was that emotional energy that allowed us to surpass our limits in times of extreme duress - which could have very well been it trying to explain dynamis without having a word for it. This seems to hold, given the behavior of various other Omicrons we meet during and after Endwalker.
Elidibus did probably gain a bunch of dynamis by being the ascians final hero and last hope and he also channeled a lot of dynamis from the faith and belief of the warriors of light that he then became.
I'm curious to see if they'll explore how dynamis affects Thancred and whether he can manipulate it better than those who can still manipulate aether
Behold a new dynamis tank and Thancred job changes again
iirc, he is like a Garlean at this point in time. he has inherent aether, but cannot manipulate it. which also raises the question, are Garleans also able to manipulate dynamis effectively?
@@pirateman4877 why does this make me giggle?
@@rachelkelley5930 it might be because I believe Thancred has had the most job changes as any of the sions. From a 1.0 sword job to ninja then Gunbreaker.
@@pirateman4877 actually I think it was the way you phrased it that was so funny. Also Thancred wasn’t a ninja, he was a very skilled rouge.
This is where I start sharing and comparing notes:
So far, the six elements has two "status": umbral and astral, making them "twelve". If you add the "light" and "darkness" (which I consider wrong, but we'll get there), you have the magic number: fourteen. In one of your, ahem, studies, you tell us that living beings are composed of body, soul and mind. Three, that might why not have their oposites, such as the elements, and then again two "status", umbral and astral, and we're both dying and being "reformed", "recycled". When dead, one's aether is turning into something else.
Add this to a draconic timelessness perspective, and one, from this, can conclude (and that might need a lot of suspension of disbelief, but bear with me, the more you think the more it makes sense):
1- All things are tridimentional.
2- All things have an opposite.
3- All things have a state of vibration (movement) and stasis.
And, last but not least: as it is below so it is above.
All I suggest is as you try to overlap the many different "circles" that we find throughout the star's history.
"What does all this blabering has to do with Dynamis", one would rightfully ask.
I **SUGGEST** that Dynamis isn't the MATTER(body) nor the SOUL(aether), but the MIND. The silent administrator that decide what deserves our attention or not, the both EMOTIONAL(astral) or RATIONAL(umbral) judge that moves all things, so inherently attached to them that one could leave them unoticed. Where we keep looking for something to interact with, we should observe thing's *direction*, and call it Dynamis.
As you stablished yourself, thicker the aether, the least it's influenced by Dynamis -- the slower it moves.
(I even have a chart for Dynamis, such as the elemental one.)
Want to share one idea, that WoL some other had joined shards who present the power of echo, evloved new abilities to interact beyond the barrier of time/language, which is meteon sense familar to herself. That might be the true effect after hydeline divided the world and ascens try merge them. Both are catastrophic, but therefore bring our chance to be dynamic being. Also in first shard on 5.3, they are evoked the echo, but there is no prove they evoled same sense power. It seems to be the pattern of the aether as in 5.x storyline where xenos experimented.
I believe strongly the twelve are entelechy. Hermes states "Dynamis is an energy put in motion by feelings. Feelings for which there must first exist a source. A source to which the victims must be attuned-one that harbors the selfsame negative emotions. Elsewise it could not be the agent of such extreme change."
The twelve origin stories are so heavily tied to emotions and relationships which act as the fuel for their powers. Powers that did not seem to line up with the limits and uses Aether if you were to take the tales literally, but with Dynamis seem much more plausible. Nymeia creating a lake by crying for example, so ridiculous even in the 14 universe it seems like a folktale. They embody concepts like love, wisdom and Fury rather then just definitive elements. Their use of Dynamis or being entelechy would explain why we cannot see them even though they did/do exist. Meteion would have escaped completely on Elpis had we ( a being capable of interacting with dynamis) not been there showing just how invisible entelechy can be.
The fact the newest raid tier will be based on the twelve, and Emet with full memories directly commented on us not knowing what they "Truly are" ties in so well with them being entelechy. A presence that has been in the game since 1.0 and referenced constantly but never directly interacted with. That is, until now with full knowledge of the concept of Dynamis to properly locate them.
What was that cut at 12:18?!
Thought on the future, as Dynamis becomes more concrete it will be interesting to see if we get new Job abilities in 7.0 based around it as it becomes a bigger part of the world with Zodiark gone.
I just wanted to say..I come across this love your channel..I just finished Shadowbringers and Eden so I will watch this later! Much love and respect to our fav scribe/scholar! And! With the class series would you consider making one on reaper maybe, I find the lore of it so enticing! Especially after playing through Shadowbringers!
If the star was sundered into 14 parts making the aether 1/14th its power at the time of sundering. Then when the Ascians forced a shard to rejoin the source it would be 2/13th and again 3/12th. Gaining what 25% of our aetheric power back? (Am bad at the maths) this does not account for the voidsent shard if that has any kind of aetherics left even. On top of this I wonder why the sundering did not sunder dynamis also? So many questions still...
About the limit break, it triggers when you get to low HP in ff6 and ff8. I remember reading somewhere that it could be seen as an action by desperate emotion to overcome tough situations. In ff7, the limit gauge build up when you got hit which in turn can be seen as you get angrier. In ff9, trance state is also linked to emotion I think. Which that I think linking limitbreaks to dynamis is not so far fetched.
It has been awhile since I play those game so I might be mistaken but it just my thought.
I know this video is now over a year old; but, I offer one small postulation. As Yoshi P has said that he plans continued development for FFXIV: what if Dynamis is a way for additional abilities to be added, changed, or offer a gateway to one of the shards? For example: players when they start a basic class lack a job/soul stone until later in the story, at which new abilities are given, some abilities change in power, and the learning of the job truly begins. I could stand to reason that there could be something that takes place where the job/soul stone is infused with the ability to control Dynamis: resulting in abilities the WoL already has to be something more, something different, or to be able to gain a completely new ability altogether. Just a thought....
The real life blend of science and magic in endwalker was fascinating.
Just like how ripples(waves) in a lake can't made/seen without water (a medium).
Before Einsteins time, alchmist/scientists knew that light was also a wave (but not yet also a particle of energy). So they believed light must also have some form of medium to travel through.
Just like how fish can't see the water they swim in, we also must be in a medium we can't see the theory was called Luminiferous Aether.
It was believed this aether medium zone was started or expanded by the big bang and all Matter that we can interact with exists in this medium. Everything outside of it that we still don't know much about and can't interact with is dark matter/dark energy. Energy/heat is nothing but particles bouncing around in a condescend zone.
There is a theory that dark energy is responsible for causing the expansion of the universe which meteion claims do be doing as endsinger. She wants to do this to speed up the heat death of the universe, because the true universe is nothing but a cold void. Aether is the medium/ bubble that protects us from the cold void and keeps the energy/life-force in a condescend zone. Let's say a star acts as a gravity well/reserve for aether thus over time creating a dense area of aether. so people are reincarnated on their star in the form of matter/condescend aether. But it's even stated that if a star is destroyed they can be reincarnated in another star, because of the Aether medium.
Since there is a 2:1 ratio Meteion power over dynamis can washout/ erase a person's Aether when it gets too sparse. like dirt and water. Thus ending their reincarnation cycle in the life force
MSQ said the dynamis attacks came thru where the celestial aether was thin or missing. Zodiark was summoned to cause the celestial aether to be even across the entire star.
Few people take into account the WoL is the strongest aether bases life form on the planet after Shadowbringers.
It's a detail people seem to gloss over frequently.
After watching this video, the entire 60-70 Job quests for White Mage came flooding into mind having played through it recently. I won't spoil anything but.....
I am very interested in the limit break video, I would also LOVE to see a break down of the blessing of light and how it differs from the echo. There seems to have been a bit of retconing in shadowbringers that should be cleared up.
After the way they handled the Blessing of Light in Endwalker I'm scared of tackling it. lol
@@SynodicScribe I mean I kinda understand. In my head cannon I assume that anyone who awakens to the echo and is able to hear hydaelyn automatically is bestowed the basic blessing of light (aka the travelers ward) by her, making them immune to tempering and other aetheric corruption at minimum.. Using a the full shield and other more powerful abilities requires getting 1 or more crystals of light.
I feel like the fact that things associated w/ dynamis (e.g., the blasphemies) have a similar color scheme to the void and voidsent has to be significant somehow. Granted, that might be more the Song of Oblivion than dynamis itself, but it's something that struck me.
Considering how source of power is described in final fantasy universe for Dark Knights, do you think they actually might be utilising dynamis? Not enough data to confirm it, but it kinda fits.
One point of correction. We know what Zodiark did to Ethierys once summoned and the change he made to what aether did. He changed the world from one where the celestial aether (the outermost aetheric part of the atmosphere) followed currents and changed density in places according to various laws, to one where the celestial aether was constantly dense around the entire planet, with no drop in density at all.
This was because the ancients discovered that areas of low celestial aetheric density were the places the Final Days would turn apocolyptic. And once the Song started attacking, changing, and eventually corroding spots of weak aether, they'd stay that way.
Hydaelyn's capturing of Zodiark was done to keep him doing that. Once Zodiark is gone, the world's aetheric rules went right back to their natural state, and to that we see the one result: Celestial Aether reverts back to a variant state.
While we sure can explain everything with Aether I also want to note that emotions can lead to even greater feats. A berserker comes to mind and sure one might say that it's just someone who gave up on restraining themselves in a fit of rage but one can argue that because of these pure emotions these powers are enhanced.
And while it may sound silly, I myself can also say that I'm far more productive when I'm in a good mood which can also be attributed to dynamis due to the emotional nature.
So I have a bit of a dissenting theory as to how aether and dynamis function and interact. To draw some parallels to how energy works in real life physics energy itself is a bit of an abstract concept: we have usable forms of energy that are easier to manipulate and observe such as heat, electricity, and motion. These different forms of energy can with some work be intercompatible and changed into one another but at the end of the day it's still energy. I believe that Aether and dynamis share a similar relationship: they are two aspects of one concept, and the use of one elicits reactions from the other.
That is to say it is not necessarily that more aetherically dense beings like the ancients had complete inability to affect dynamis ( If that were the case Hermes would never have been able to create Meiteon), But more likely that they just hadn't made the logical leap to consider the two as coming from a fundamental pool of nebulous " energy ".
The main reason I look at it this way is because of the final fight with Zenos. I think our constant pushing of the limit in that fight is meant to represent a conversion of dynamis into usable Aether, But I don't think it's a necessarily because we understood dynamis better. The one solid fact we know about dynamis is that it is strongly affected by emotion, And that fight is an emotionally charged moment not just from a storytelling perspective but to the characters involved. To me it seems likely that emotions agitate the flow of dynamis, and cause it to sort of burn releasing energy into a more usable form.
And to circle back to the ancients, I think the reason they lacked ability to manipulate dynamis at a wider scale, is because their culture has a very prominent focus on crushing individuality and suppressing emotion. They are a very ascetic culture based on what we've seen, and I think this is the real determining factor into why their knowledge and use of dynamis is so limited.
My biggest theory in regards of Dynamis is that Auracite is the perfect balance of Aether and Dynamis intermingled. The strong desires and emotions it takes in along with the aether mingling and mixing until the very fabric of reality begins to fray as ambition reshapes the flesh. Whether Ultima was aware of Dynamis when creating the auracite in 14's version of Ivalice is up for debate, though I'm personally leaning toward the idea that it was more of an accidental byproduct rather than a feature.
To use the example of concrete and abstract energy you make here, I kind of visualize Dynamis in similar terms of soundwaves. A powerful enough blast of sound has the power to knock someone off their feet, or even jostle internal organs while leaving the rest of the body unaffected, but in its natural state is something we experience all the time and we don't consciously notice it. But with the right tools and, time, and energy can be amplified fairly easily to deafening degrees. By the same token, should a tool or amplifier not be properly adjusted, those waves can become amplified ad infinitum in a feedback loop, until ears start bleeding.
So I'm delirious with sick right now, so maybe this isn't as funny as it is in my head, but as I listen to your narration, I keep mentally swapping the word dynamis with "traffic lights." The video is thoroughly amusing that way. 🤓
To be fair the introduction of traffic lights in FFXIV have really shaken things up. But now we've gotta considered how traffic lights might affect the world moving forward.
Didn't the MSA explicitly say what zodiark did was strenghten the astral aether currents?
Yeah, it did. But how? The method behind such an act could have meant a variety of things for the world. But we don't know the exact nature of Zodiark's powers, and now we never will.
@@SynodicScribe They used the concept of darkness which stands for progress and advancement. That way the aether flowed faster hence enhancing it. It was explained in Shadowbringers how Light is a force of Stasis and Darkness for advancement
LOVE your videos. Thank you so much. I was hoping for a clarification. You mentioned we were 8 rejoined. Would it not be 9? Being born on source -1, 7 collapses - 8, Ardbert - 9. Am I mistaken or not understanding? Thank you so much for everything.
I can feel that Limits are Dynamus in action XD which also explains why its only lb3s that are different. Maybe its the dynamis within the job crystals? This is assuming that it, as emotion, can be stored in the same manor as the memories and techniques.
A few thoughts:
1) Humanity is capable of interacting with dynamis, they just didn't know how. Some people have guessed that a limit break is an example of this. This is supported by the phase change in the final day trial where your friends create a shield for you.
2) Nero knew something. In the Crystal Tower raid, he was searching for an unknown power source. At the end of the raid series, the final cutscene has him standing on a cliff edge near the crystal tower. He says something about going off to start a new life and throws his scanner into the ravine. As the camera pans away, morse code can be heard echoing up from the canyon. The morse code, when translated, says "It's all wrong". Sound familiar? He detected Meteion and the power source he was looking for was Dynamis. This is in the cutscene still and can be seen in the journal in the inn. They had that planned almost a decade ago.
3)Other possibilities for Dynamis in action would be the bard and monk who use inner ability rather than specific aether applications but that's just a theory.
4) Shortly before the "Final Days" dungeon, Emet-Selch and Hythlodaeus were able to use creation magic to create a field of flowers that produced enough dynamis to sustain the environment in Ultima Thule without the souls of the Scions, allowing them to be re-formed. Thus Dynamis could, to some degree, be interacted with by Aether dense beings using magic.
"Aye always good ta see yer lectures, this is very new to meh as well, 'owever I 'eard it being called Akasa by Thavnir Alchemists, only vague whispers though ... nothing conclusive, yet."
-Amov
I like the idea that Dynamis is able to sort of complement and augment Aether, but the idea that Dynamis is able to make up the power gap in sundered and partially rejoined beings is something I never considered, and REALLY like.
The way Emit Selch explained the shards, I figured each shard gained a new 1/14th when a shard rejoined with the source. So the first is 7/14th like the source.
The 1st is still 1/14th. Only the Source gained aether/power from the rejoinings. The shards will ever remain the 1/14th fragments they were meant to be.
I should point out though that even if the WoL is 8 times rejoined due to Ardbert, it is heavily implied that the finishing blow dealt to Hades using the light that was contained in the WoL also consumed Ardbert's power. So yes, for a short time between the beginning and end of the fight with Hades, the WoL was 8 times rejoined but afterwards likely returned as only 7 times rejoined. That's further confirmed later when Elidibus walks around in Ardbert's body : the MSQ implies that Ardbert is no more so it becomes glaringly obvious that Elidibus-as-Ardbert is a fake.
Either that or that explains why limit breaks are becoming less and less impressive as the overall output of damage makes it use as an emergency raise or mechanic block more important than a damage dealing move : with a 8th rejoining, the potential to deal damage with an LB is less than the constant, raw damage dealt over a period of time by the party... but an emergency party raise is always viable as is being able to soak a party wipe mechanic.
My theory on dynamis, is that it is the exact same thing as the “press of death” from fire force. If you’ve ever watched fire force you’ll know that in the last training arc with benimaru he teaches shinra and Arthur how to exceed their limits and access their hysterical strength and get an adrenaline boost that allows them to keep going in a fight. Benimaru explains that the press of death is more emotional/mental than physical, because you have to genuinely that believe you will die in a fight in order activate it, but once you active it, you break your limits and are able to do things with your powers you could never normally do. I think this is what dynamis is because of the final fight against zenos, both you and zenos surpass your limits in the final fight pushing each other to the brink of death you both come back fully healed and charged with more powerful than before, they say that this is because of the dynamis in your souls burning with passion for the fight, that is pushed you into overdrive, you both tap into your hysterical strength, desperate to defeat the other as the fight goes on, and you both are able to keep going again and again until both you you die. That’s why at the end of the fight neither of you can move, and are on the brink of death, dynamis, or in other words adrenaline caused tou both to used up everything you guys had and left you nothing except what little ability you had to blink.
what about the blasphemies,meteion, and the constructs made by the scions sacrifices? were they not all made of mostly dynamis? meteion in particular was made almost entirely of dynamis,and her attacks were dyanmis based too
Ok there's a few issues there. First off, Meteion is a horrible example of how Dynamis would work on our star since she was engineered differently than how all life naturally occurs on our world. Secondly, Ultima Thule is an aether deprived zone. So again, we can't use that location as an example of how Dynamis would operate on our aether based star. Lastly, the Blasphemies were a direct result of an entity forcing an overwhelming amount of Dynamis onto someone. Therefore, the Blasphemies as we know them could never occur naturally.
While I generally agree with your position on the DK and Warrior jobs in general, I'd like to point out that surprisingly weak effects can have dramatically disproportionate impacts in complex systems, so even if it's effects where EXTREMELY limited if those effects where of the right nature they could still play a critical and/or catalytic role yet still go unnoticed until one knew to look. Just think about how IRL it's often only when our old models don't quite work do we start looking for new options, and are all to willing to overlook small discrepancies so long as it's "good enough". So my hypothesis is that while on the concrete level the jobs work as we've always assumed, certain jobs, especially those that use emotions/instincts, may use dynimus to get that last little something something to work, much like how lighting is diven by atmospheric conditions, yet stray stellar particles can often serve to set of the cascade that is the bolt itself
Just watched the video, on Limit Breaks:
I may have mis-interpreted this, but I thought that the Ancients could not really interact with Dynamis nor be impacted by it due to their Aetherical content. Its why Hermes needed to make the Metions in the first place, they could interact while he couldn't. It's the stated reason the End of Days impacted creation magics rather than the Ancients themselves. This also is why, to me, the flowers in Elpis never really bloomed, because its clear the ancients had emotions, just judging by how Emet/Venat/Hythlodaeus interacted, but they never had any impact on the flowers.
Which brings me to this: Elidibus uses a Limit Break. You could argue its not a true Limit Break and he is just mimicking what heroes do, but he does use one. And he's an Ancient who can not be impacted by Dynamis. How is he able to use a Limit Break if Limit Breaks come from the emotion of Dynamis? Dynamis can not impact him, so he should not get any power himself. He could theoretically be using Dynamis to create a limit break, but if the Elpis flowers theory I have is true, then he shouldn't be able to manipulate/interact with Dynamis either. So, how is Elidibus able to Limit Break when he can't use Dynamis?
I for the life of me cannot find it, but there is a fan fest lore panel some where in which some one asked Koji directly about Limit Breaks. This is around Stormblood or Shadowbringers... but, Koji very coyly responded to the question before backtracking his response realizing he'd already said too much. I'm sure on the official Forums, Anonymoose somewhere has a record of this... anyway... Koji said limit breaks weren't powered by Aether but another force called Dymamis that was tied to emotional energy. At that point he refused to say much more because it would be spoilers. I can't remember if it was at a PAX panel or an official Fan Fest one... but somewhere if you can find it... there's a record... but I've had trouble nailing it down. All I can do is limit the search window for anyone wanting to hunt to sometime between 2014 and 2018.
One theory I had on dynamis and how it interacts is that unlike aether it is a more vague and "spiritual" energy. Ather is solid (metaphorically speaking) it has elemental manifestations, poles, and can be weaved into direct spells. It is controlled via techniques and mind. While dynamis is tied to emotions, it is more passive, and unseen. Less methadological per say and less potent. That might be why it wasn't as out there and worked on as aether.
Anyone can look at a warrior pushing his hardest and say: "Oh they barely pulled through." Realistically not many would go out of their way and be like: "Oh odd they shouldn't be able to do that so there must be a second force!" If that makes sense.
Way I see dynamis and aether based classes is, dynamis boosts your overall skills. Or as the game puts it, it helps you go beyond your limits. While it's effects aren't as pronounced as that of the aether, it is there behind the curtains, assisting you during your hour of need, feeding not upon your pool of magic, but of your emotions, urging you to stride ever forward through and beyond your limits.
I would consider how you dont have limit break at the start of your fight and only get it after you've done a lot of fighting and have expended your aether.
Aether leaves, Dynamis takes its place. Limit Break becomes avaliable?
I dunno. I might be smoking
Like I said, Limit Breaks were explained long before Endwalker and I have the data to prove it. But I'm not releasing it for the exact reason you just proved. lol
The only 2 Ancients that is known to use dynamis are Hermes via Metion and Elidibus via Limit Break 1, 2, 3, and 4 during the Seat of Sacrifice fight.
Hmm.. if Meteion is associated with despair, do voidsent associate with greed, and sineaters with apathy? Each of these corrupt the body and soul, leaving nothing but an incarnation of despair/greed/apathy and stray memories.
this REALLY makes me wonder if one of the surviving shards has actually discovered dynamis early on and has become extremely fluent in it since they are the most susceptible to it to the point that some people on there might even think of aether as useless. that would be so fucking interesting
Here's my wild hypothesis regarding Dynamis and LB's. So, I believe that when someone executes a limit break they're effectively using almost every last drop of their aether, to a degree it's actually dangerous. This is where I think Dynamis come into play, filling in the void left by our (temporarily) detached aether in a manner not unlike what's seen in terminus beasts. This doesn't explain how one who's performed a LB has enough aether to keep fighting after it's finished, but as I said earlier this is very much wild conjecture.
My take on it is that since Dynamis affects aether, a LB is basically the WoL's strength of will drawing upon the surrounding aether and having it augment their own powers without necessarily making the WoL have that aether flow through them / having the WoL command that aether through normal means
Before Dynamis was even a thing Limit Breaking was a highly concentrated aetherial ability.
Since dk and war abilities are at least partially rooted in emotion, then it's possible that there's a subconscious mixing of the two. Also Bard songs. And well if it's subconscious, would they notice?
Something I’d been thinking about… I like the theory that limit break is dynamis but… didn’t Elidibus use multiple limit breaks himself in the fight against the WoL? Wouldn’t that throw off the whole theory given unsundered people like Elidibus wouldn’t be able to manipulate Dynamis?
Also. I’d love to see a video on the sundering itself. It always confused me. Did Vanaut split all of existence into 14. Or just planet into 14. Are the Shards pocket dimensions or do they have their own universe outside the planet that mirrors the source?
well at that point elidibus was a primal powered by thoughts and prayers of hope
Great video.