That moment u try to commit suicide but u just fall on a pile of flowers Then find yourself befriending all the monsters Or dusting them all (if you're into that)
so in terms of the story behind this version of 'My R' I think its about Frisk meeting the different hearts that came before them, however unlike the original song and mv, the ones before Frisk are actually committing suicide/going to the underground because what Frisk said to each of them is the exact opposite of what life is like for them (eg, 'theres always dinner waiting on the table you know' when really their family is sickly and in pain). then eventually Frisk meets Chara and can't say anything to them because Chara had seen the worst in life and Frisk looking like a mirror image probably has too. but Chara doesn't jump and turns into flowers instead, indicating Chara's backstory of dying from the flowers, being buried in the flowers, and the connection Chara made with Frisk when Frisk fell on Chara's flowerbed. Chara's sudden appearance and dissolving into flowers could also symbolise Frisk's interaction with Chara in the actual game which is similar to Chara appearing before Frisk despite being dead and Chara's interference in the game that often guides Frisk in what they do (eg, by Chara not jumping, they are trying to guide Frisk not to jump). Frisk then jumps to commit suicide and falls into the underground where everything begins in the game. that's my theory over this animation and yes I am that bored and eventless that I wrote a whole theory on it. if you read it all, good for you and thank you for bothering.
What I can get from the song: Frisk tries to commit suicide, but then each time they try, the spirit of someone who fell before them appears. The spirits then tell them their stories, and Frisk gets angry at them. Once they sense that Frisk is unwilling to jump, at least for that day, they jump themselves, symbolizing their return to wherever they're supposed to be. After Chara comes and tries to convince Frisk to stop, the spirits see Frisk's determination and that they keep returning even when the spirits keep trying to convince them not to, so they give up and sadly watch Frisk jump.
The things frisk says "You never lost anything" "You always have someone waiting at home/loving you" The way these are said and who they are said to indicate Frisk thinks everyone else has these things, or that Frisk has these negatives. Frisk has lost something. Frisk has nobody waiting at home who loves them. This adds to the feel of the song.
I might not be the only one saying this, but this song fits perfectly for the animation and Undertale itself! Ahhh, I'm in love with it. And I'm glad I'm early to comment. Hi person reading this. :'D
Admin Maria please dont call me 'idiot' . I know the original song and just making a joke about the vid . I really dont like people call me or other people idiot "seriously" . All joke are stupid , even sans' puns . There are not meant to be seriously . So please dont call me ' idiot ' because you never meet me IRL . But anyway thanks for let me know that I am an idiot .
For some of you who didn't understand: Frisk (in this video) is trying to commit suicide by going up to Mt. Ebott and jumping down the hole. However, every single day, they see different people coming up to the mountain also committing suicide. The different people who comes up to the mountain to jump down to the hole are Frisk's inner thoughts. The people and their stories represents as the reason why Frisk should jump down the hole however, Frisk just realizes that every single stories that their inner thoughts are saying can be solved so they turn back and failed to jump down the hole. In other words, the Patience (the braided girl), Bravery (bandanna girl)'s stories is also what happened to Frisk but Patience and Bravery aren't actually there and just represents as a reason why Frisk should jump down the hole (i.e Patience's story says that she was separated by Kindness which also happened in Frisk's life, either that in Frisk's life, they lost someone who was close to them) And in the end, we see Chara who is the ultimate reason why Frisk should jump down the hole. Unfortunate for Frisk, they weren't able to find any rebuttals and able to say anything why Chara (their ultimate inner suicide thought) shouldn't jump down the hole and thus, Chara jumped down, killing himself/herself. After that, we don't see anyone stopping Frisk from jumping anymore which means they finally got the reason why they should commit suicide and they got that reason from Chara (who was Frisk's inner suicide thought). So after getting Frisk's reason to commit suicide, they take off their 'yellow cardigan' (which is Chara's yellow stripe from her clothes or whatever), she gets her braids undone (Patience's braided hair), being the small petite person they are (Bravery's short and petite form), Frisk jumps down the hole. Which means that Chara, Patience and Bravery were connected to Frisk and they weren't really there instead their real forms was Frisk. Chara Patience and Bravery are Frisk all in one. It also explains why the song's name is 'My R' which is actually 'My Reason'. Frisk's ultimate inner suicide thought (Chara) had a REASON to commit suicide and that reason is that they wanted to stop feeling pain and despair every time they go home so that's why they went to the mountain to commit suicide. In other words, when Frisk comes home every time they were stopped from killing themselves in the mountain, they feel pain and despair and desperately wanted it to stop and that's why they go to the mountain every day to have a reason to kill themselves.
FlowerCheld/FETUSCHILD fair enough, that would work, but she does say "I really thought that he might be the one, but then he told me he was done" got me thinking of more a relationship, especially from "the one," yknow? I can see it in a sibling manner though :)
So,for get this straight....Frisk is about to suicide by jumping into that hole but there is always someone before her who wants to do the same thing and she tries to stop them without success but she doesn't find anyone one day and she suicides too.Happy melody nice song but the plot makes me feel kinda sad
Mrs Blueberry Productions Asriel asked Frisk why they jumped into the Underground, and even thought that Frisk might've been trying to commit suicide like Chara did.
The girls that Frisk had encountered represented her in the past. Each of the girls symbolized a hard time in Frisk’s life and when she argues with them as to their reason for wanting to jump being ‘lame’ and they each ‘disappear’ this is her finding a reason to continue on living. Then when she faces her present self ( yellow cardigan ) she can’t give her a reason to continue on instead simply saying “Hey, don’t do it, please.” She loses her nerve but the next day she makes up her mind to jump and be free from all the pain she is suffering. So she does just that. ‘She takes off her yellow cardigan, watching her braids all come undone, and her petite form as short as can be is going to jump now and be free.’ (Is what I got from watching the video and paying attention to the lyrics)
Huh, I didn't think of that. While her words seemed so cruel in context, actually trying to move on from the past is the only thing you can do sometimes. Of course that isn't easy or sufficient all the time, and they jump anyway
I like the detail that despite Frisk trying to convince them otherwise, all the other kids still jump. It was kinda annoyed me in other animatics where the singer basically goes "thats stupid I have a much better reading to want to die" and the others go "you're right" and leave. In this Frisk accidentally makes it worse which I think is cool
I like your point, however, I’d like to mention (and I think most people are unaware of this) that the R stands for reflection, meaning that, as hinted in the last part, the other people going to jump, are the singer (possibly from different stages of life)
This is a really old animation but I still want to say that this is my all time favourite animation. I'm not sure why, I saw this the first time some years ago and it stuck with me, sometimes I think about it when I'm doing something else and then I have the urge to watch it again. I love the concept of this animation, is basically perfect and how it's executed is even better. This song is used and overused but this time it fits so well and it's more than you usually see around, you can interpreting this in many ways and every option it's amazing and fashinating. This is my all time favourite animation and I don't even know why
GOD FINALLY. I couldn't find a version of this song that UA-cam DIDN'T keep blocking. Thank you so much! Also, this is what introduced me to this song (and the wonderful world of human souls aus) so many years ago.
Oh wow that was amazing! I especially loved the scene where Frisk was finally about to jump and the three other humans appeared, as if all being traits of what Frisk felt.
Oh okay idk who sung it, I just thought you were trying to say a name ( probably because I know a UA-camr does a thing in a uhc where they say racchel while killing someone it a minecraft uch)
When I first saw and heard this I thought frisk was describing her personal dieing inside and the girls she mostly talked to was her describing what she looked like and when the girls were telling why they was going to do it frisk was just telling reasons why she wants to do it(no hate plz it was a thought and I had to edited it cuz I had ideas)
I just realized something. The song is probably a person's inner self trying to talk them out of suicide but on the last day her inner self couldn't stop her.
Ah, your art is so great! I also like that little animation at the beginning. It's nice to see original stuff like this, tbh. Mostly that you even gave the 6 Souls your own designs. Your bravery isn't what people usually make them like at all and this gives off such a nice vibe for the whole video, too. And.. is it weird that no matter what, I can't help but see Chara as a guy in your style..? o3o'
Makusia o w o yeah, chara though totally has that face that could be a guy or girl but kinda leans more towards guy. They just don't seem to be given any very feminine features but at the same time they don't really have masculine features either, really helps with the gender neutral thing so no one can complain "well what chara looks like doesnt fit MY headcannon!!" Same goes for frisk, but i feel they look more female than male, kinda like how chara looks more male than female though they could be either Sorry long comment have a potato emoji 🥔
I like my R song even though it's really sad and I'll be honest just by the time I got to 0:33 I was like, "OH THIS IS SUCH A COOL CONCEPT FOR THE MY R SONG." Thanks for making this I really enjoyed it!
If there was ever a time I would climb the mountain it would be sixth grade when my social isolation, depression, and apathy were at their peak. That'd be interesting to see, but personally I'm glad I never decided to disappear
SOMEBODY ELSE MADE THIS VIDEO, I am SO glad you've thought of this same song as myself. It is SO fitting to the UT children, especially the interaction with Chara. WELL DONE
God...this song is SO GOD DAMN SAD !!! But thinking this is how the storyline of undertale could a started is SO SAD AND really deep man I love this fandom
I always thought the main character in this song was Chara, and they were trying to convince the souls not to go in the mountain, but they did anyway. Then, frisk came along, and Chara thought frisk was a lot like them, and agreed to help them in the mountain, since Chara knew they possessed determination and would go anyway
I pulled down the description, and saw the undertale advertisement. I froze. Oh my gosh. It’s been 5 years. Five years, since it was made. Oh my gosh. 2015, was when it was made.
So basically...Frisk incentivated people to commit suicide by telling them "Hey, you have problems? Too bad, I'll make my life sound way worse!" "Yes, FaLl iNt0 tH3 AbBeS$¡"
Flame Raven no, in the original My R she's talking to herself each day, convincing herself to not commit suicide. Eventually she didn't convince herself.
Every new girl represents a reason to die in her own life, and every time she finds a reason to convince them (which means herself) to not take the fall. But every day, she sees a new girl which has the exact opposite situation of the reason she gave the day before, and she tries again to save that new girl with another reason to live etc... For some days, this cycle of "Pros and Cons to suicide" works in favor of her, but then one day she doesn't find anyone on the rooftop, which means that every reason she had to live does not works on her anymore, like "having a loving family" began "having a careless family" etc... So she finally takes the fall due to not having anything to live for.
Flame Raven This song is very serious and suicidal. Please do not make a joke out of it. It's very serious and I think what you said is very insensitive, especially to people thinking about committing suicide.
No, it's really not. Can we stop saying that these are the answers? For someone who has been suicidal for a long time, I can tell you that this is "not the answer for everyone who is depressed". This video is showing suicide to be the answer, and while I enjoy this so much, this is not a good answer for everyone.
Shailey Boman thank you for saying that, like srsly sure what is said could be used to save someone from depression but you cant only take the good parts of video becauses it still ends in suicide
I’m glad I knew what Yandere Sim was before I heard this song. If you don’t know what I mean, the ‘taking off my shoes’ part is a thing when someone commits suicide.
by dissapeared they dont say they walked away they killed them selves but instead of being hurt about it they were glad someone was there to hear there stories before they ended it all (i assume)
It's symbolic. In the original sound all the girls are reasons to live and in the range all of them vanish till there is no reason to live left and the main girl decides to die
Yepp, I have seen this so many times now, I know exactly whats going to happen everytime, but I have still not managed to watch the entire thing without crying, and im not sure I ever will. Thank you, I'm just mostly not able to cry, this is the only thing that has made me able to since my grandma's funeral. I cant explain how much this means to me, just, thank you, thank you so much.
Everybody who's seeing this comment I want you to know that your all special and if you can't throw away your woes give them to me i'm already carrying a lot of them And Hey i'm daniel your New friend ,hope I helped see you
I think the song was about the girl having her own iner struggles and manasfesting those problems into a person each time trys to kill herself, basicaly her brain is doing everything it can to stop her form commiting suiced. Btw great animation
This is an amazing creation!It fits Undertale perfectly!Well,before the game starts,that is.But it does explain very well why Frisk went to that mountain in the first place and that the fall WASN'T an accident at all...Anyways I LOVE the animation and I LOVE this singer and I already heard her before singing an Undertale song.It's called Stronger than you Frisk response.To people that admire Rachie as much as I do,you should check it out!:) I DEFINITELY think that the creator of Undertale should make an AU called BeforeTale explaining Frisk's past life before Undertale!
After watching this tons of times, I just realized that these are the souls after they already died and that’s why it shows Green’s grave even before Frisk ever attempted to stop him and how they already seem to know Frisk’ll fail, and how Chara disappeared into the yellow flowers. Nice going, OP :D
i should probably be more concerned about what i just watched but now im just concerned that frisk went through the whole freaking underground without shoes
Listening to the song time and time again. I believe that Frisk is trying to stop them from committing suicide, even if they want to do it, but every time they tried the wrong words came out because they don't know the whole story. Frisk may have came off angry, but they may have also been frustrated by how they could let out their pain to Frisk but in the end everyone jumped. When Frisk came across Chara, they couldn't do it anymore. And broke down. Chara did disappear, going back to the underground. When they came to commit suicide they saw themselves in the people who jumped that they failed to save.
@@_..MapleAcorn.._ my reach is far. It's not enough that I make covers and comments about Milgram, I must comment on everything I find 🤣 Real talk, I just like commenting to help boost the youtuber's engagement lol
I can’t with this. The art, the animation, the storyline. It’s all so perfect!! This is probably one of the BEST My R animations I’ve seen yet! I don’t really like Undertale, (well, *now* I don’t, I used to be obsessed with it) but this brings back a whole lot of amazing memories from this game. I LOVE this animation! Keep up the good work!
how is this the only animatic I've seen that actually takes into consideration how weirdly hypocritical this song can sound... (also this one is my favorite for this exact reason)
I'm guessing no-one really understand this so... The people who commited suicide before Frisk were actually a representation of Frisk trying to stop him/herself to commit suicide.She/He tried to look for reasons to live,but couldn't find any and...well,in the end,he/she jumped.
I remembering browsing through this channel not to long ago, and I barely saw anything, but suddenly all of these amazing animatics come out of nowhere. Why didn’t I see this before.
1:02 Frisk met Patience, Bravery, Integrity, Perseverance, and then Kindness is the second to last because Frisk never got to them. They died before Frisk met them. And Yellow is Chara she's at the end because she is like the opposite of Frisk(?) and since Frisk is the 1st one Chara would be the last one. sorry if this is incorrect I don't know too much about Undertale. Edit: okay this is probably all wrong don't pay attention to this comment 😂😂
Ok! Since most of you guys are clueless the person who made the song where she was talking to her inner self to not commit Suicide. Then The Last part was where she could not help her self and she just jumped but that hand was herself saying that once she jumped she did not really want to die.
The souls dont seem to be sad when frisk has finally made up their mind to jump, probably bc the souls know they are needed in the underground, that they'll be okay. That they are the determined angel who has seen the surface and make the underground go empty. It's their time, the prophesy foretold it. They're encouraging frisk. It's time for monsters to finally be free.
![[Undertale] GAME OVER PMV/Animation](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/h_tRTG1cWH0/mqdefault.jpg)
I've watched this so many times and only just realized that the bag stolen from bravery was not her purse but a pharmacy bag for her sick mother...
Sam is intelligence OH MY FUCKING YOU JUST MADE ME CRY MORE
FUCK NOW IVE FLOODED MY ROOM
U JUST MADE IT WORSE Q_Q
Sam is intelligence, I too
Same 😩😩😩😩😩
That moment u try to commit suicide but u just fall on a pile of flowers
Then find yourself befriending all the monsters
Or dusting them all (if you're into that)
into dusting them all in what way
Id probably commit sucide again if they are mean to me
kewly katz Unless you saw someone play pacifist, Geno is going to make no sense.
You got adopted by goats 😊
Now you are a furry
"Dusting"
"I'm hungry" Said the girl as she shed a tear. ME.
Coded Artist this made me snort hella loud XDDDD
For such a sad song “I’m hungry” is the funniest line XD
Same
xD
And shane Dawson!
so in terms of the story behind this version of 'My R' I think its about Frisk meeting the different hearts that came before them, however unlike the original song and mv, the ones before Frisk are actually committing suicide/going to the underground because what Frisk said to each of them is the exact opposite of what life is like for them (eg, 'theres always dinner waiting on the table you know' when really their family is sickly and in pain). then eventually Frisk meets Chara and can't say anything to them because Chara had seen the worst in life and Frisk looking like a mirror image probably has too. but Chara doesn't jump and turns into flowers instead, indicating Chara's backstory of dying from the flowers, being buried in the flowers, and the connection Chara made with Frisk when Frisk fell on Chara's flowerbed. Chara's sudden appearance and dissolving into flowers could also symbolise Frisk's interaction with Chara in the actual game which is similar to Chara appearing before Frisk despite being dead and Chara's interference in the game that often guides Frisk in what they do (eg, by Chara not jumping, they are trying to guide Frisk not to jump). Frisk then jumps to commit suicide and falls into the underground where everything begins in the game.
that's my theory over this animation and yes I am that bored and eventless that I wrote a whole theory on it. if you read it all, good for you and thank you for bothering.
?
Proof ur a die hard fan.. Oh wait.. Anyone who makes an undertale animation is...
*claps* well done just wow gg i didnt even think of it that way just wow
That was good!
I’m glad I’m the only one who thought about that and I love your work it’s so good
Frisk: There was someone every day~
Meanwhile in the Underground
toriel be like: ItS rAInInG cHiLdReN
TRUE XD
XDDDD
XD
Two minutes later Toriel: some of them are dusting monsters I gotta put them down
Justice be like:WOMAN
Fun fact:In Japan when people kill them self by falling,they take off their shoes
Edit:Wow,I didn't expect this many likes
HOW CAN IT FUN!?
Ezra Dreemurr201x
how is that a fun fact?
yeah... its kind of a sad tradition
Ezra Dreemurr201x yeah bcuz it symbolizes going to the next world.
Ezra Dreemurr201x i know dat by yandere sim
Integrety: *smiles*
Perseverance:*smiles*
Kindness: *smiles*
Justice: *pissed*
Editing me: *Shocked pikachu face* thank you
Gl!tch Undertale I always laugh when justice shows up lol
_angery_
XD
XD what's he mad about? XD
Amanda Atyeo
Idk, but ID LIKE TO KNOW XD
What I can get from the song: Frisk tries to commit suicide, but then each time they try, the spirit of someone who fell before them appears. The spirits then tell them their stories, and Frisk gets angry at them. Once they sense that Frisk is unwilling to jump, at least for that day, they jump themselves, symbolizing their return to wherever they're supposed to be. After Chara comes and tries to convince Frisk to stop, the spirits see Frisk's determination and that they keep returning even when the spirits keep trying to convince them not to, so they give up and sadly watch Frisk jump.
Nicole Edelweiss Adella I'm p sure that the song is about a girl mentally trying to stop herself but not being able to in the end
Nicole Edelweiss Adella
That is a REALLY good theory.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Nicole Edelweiss Adella nice theory
Nice
Whiskered Wolf i like your theory and I also like how you represent frisk as they/them
THE INVISBLE ONION CUTTING NINJAS ARE BACK
AnimeLover X3 yep
Nuuu!!!
WATCH OUT! THEY GOT THEIR INVISIBLE KNIVES, INVISIBLE ONIONS, EVERYTHING!
IForgotMyName 823 mOoD
I'll get the gun
The things frisk says
"You never lost anything"
"You always have someone waiting at home/loving you"
The way these are said and who they are said to indicate Frisk thinks everyone else has these things, or that Frisk has these negatives. Frisk has lost something. Frisk has nobody waiting at home who loves them.
This adds to the feel of the song.
* S T A Y
D E T E R M I N E D
Hello child
Who here likes fortnite? WE LIKE fortnite we like fortnite
I might not be the only one saying this, but this song fits perfectly for the animation and Undertale itself! Ahhh, I'm in love with it. And I'm glad I'm early to comment. Hi person reading this. :'D
Vylan X hi I'm a day late but at least I'm here
Vylan X hi and you're right. I never thought of that
Vylan X hii
Ya you are right. There is a theory about Frisk want to suicide, so Frisk went to the mountain and fall into the hole (I guess)
I think Frisk really wanted to die
0:04 "There I see"
Frisk how teh fu can you see her your eyes are closed!!!!
No hate
Undertake logic
Don’t do it child
*FBI OPEN THE DOOR*
*The child can see with closed eyes!!* 😂😂
Don't questions undertale logic,nothing make sense,except for the fact that it's the greatest game ever!!! >:3
My friend walks in the room
"I just jave something in my eyes"
"Reallly, what is it?"
"TEARS!"
Ah yes.
Papyrus reference
Good
*Nothing, but the distant trouble trousle of bones
The second girl is me. "Im hungry!" **yeets off**
Oh shut up. She’s saying she has no food. Not just “I’m hungry!!” She can’t take it anymore.
Ismail PlayZ geez chill dude
@@Ismail-if3ff I mean it do be like that sometimes
@@Ismail-if3ff So there's like, this thing we call, "JOKES", can you please at LEAST, TRY to understand them?
kids these days ... they dont even know the different between rooftop and mountain peak.....
it just an intentional joke
Admin Maria
please dont call me 'idiot' . I know the original song and just making a joke about the vid . I really dont like people call me or other people idiot "seriously" . All joke are stupid , even sans' puns . There are not meant to be seriously .
So please dont call me ' idiot ' because you never meet me IRL .
But anyway thanks for let me know that I am an idiot .
Lol ikr frisk needs to work on her architectural vocabulary
Admin Maria jeez ur an idiot
Admin Maria ...
*JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE JOKE* ❤️
HA
I'M SO NOT IN TEARS. FUXKIN ONIONS QAQ
Gone I'm just sweating from my eyes
Gone
Onion-san!
Moon Side ONIONSAN GET OUT
ONION NINJAS. SHIIIIIIIITTTTTT.
I'M NOT CRYING, I JUST HAVE SOMETHING IN MY EYE
and whats that
TEARS :'(
Chara & frisk are so cute'-'
คนไร้ตัวตน ใช่ๆ
คนไร้ตัวตน unlike me ;-;
Annoying kid :D เด็กเกรียน เจอคนไทยเชย'-'
คนไร้ตัวตน
Especially when they fall in and commit suicide
คนไร้ตัวตน aww yea so cute '-'
For some of you who didn't understand:
Frisk (in this video) is trying to commit suicide by going up to Mt. Ebott and jumping down the hole. However, every single day, they see different people coming up to the mountain also committing suicide. The different people who comes up to the mountain to jump down to the hole are Frisk's inner thoughts. The people and their stories represents as the reason why Frisk should jump down the hole however, Frisk just realizes that every single stories that their inner thoughts are saying can be solved so they turn back and failed to jump down the hole. In other words, the Patience (the braided girl), Bravery (bandanna girl)'s stories is also what happened to Frisk but Patience and Bravery aren't actually there and just represents as a reason why Frisk should jump down the hole (i.e Patience's story says that she was separated by Kindness which also happened in Frisk's life, either that in Frisk's life, they lost someone who was close to them)
And in the end, we see Chara who is the ultimate reason why Frisk should jump down the hole. Unfortunate for Frisk, they weren't able to find any rebuttals and able to say anything why Chara (their ultimate inner suicide thought) shouldn't jump down the hole and thus, Chara jumped down, killing himself/herself. After that, we don't see anyone stopping Frisk from jumping anymore which means they finally got the reason why they should commit suicide and they got that reason from Chara (who was Frisk's inner suicide thought). So after getting Frisk's reason to commit suicide, they take off their 'yellow cardigan' (which is Chara's yellow stripe from her clothes or whatever), she gets her braids undone (Patience's braided hair), being the small petite person they are (Bravery's short and petite form), Frisk jumps down the hole. Which means that Chara, Patience and Bravery were connected to Frisk and they weren't really there instead their real forms was Frisk. Chara Patience and Bravery are Frisk all in one.
It also explains why the song's name is 'My R' which is actually 'My Reason'. Frisk's ultimate inner suicide thought (Chara) had a REASON to commit suicide and that reason is that they wanted to stop feeling pain and despair every time they go home so that's why they went to the mountain to commit suicide. In other words, when Frisk comes home every time they were stopped from killing themselves in the mountain, they feel pain and despair and desperately wanted it to stop and that's why they go to the mountain every day to have a reason to kill themselves.
Wooh lotta words
Good theorie
“My R” either means “My reason” oRoooOr “my Reflection” chara and frisk basically look the same just different colors and personalities
You put a lotta effort in explaining there.
You deserve a sub.
I just realized that undertale is like Alice in wonderland...just sharing tho
True there is also a more better imitation frisk in underland. Lol
True-
...no wonder it felt so familiar-
I thought something felt familiar too.
So does that make Flowey the Cheshire Cat or the white rabbit or is that Sans?
Wait cyan soul was with green soul??? ME SHIPS LIKE THE FED EX
Gwen Stacy Wow that is a fast ship! Thanks for the package Fed Ex!
I like to think they were siblings
Jeez. It's just made for match with song
FlowerCheld/FETUSCHILD fair enough, that would work, but she does say "I really thought that he might be the one, but then he told me he was done" got me thinking of more a relationship, especially from "the one," yknow? I can see it in a sibling manner though :)
Feyza Nur I know but a ship has been proposed and I'm rolling with it 😂
So,for get this straight....Frisk is about to suicide by jumping into that hole but there is always someone before her who wants to do the same thing and she tries to stop them without success but she doesn't find anyone one day and she suicides too.Happy melody nice song but the plot makes me feel kinda sad
Frisk Dreemurr I actually dont know,what did he say?
Mrs Blueberry Productions Asriel asked Frisk why they jumped into the Underground, and even thought that Frisk might've been trying to commit suicide like Chara did.
Shadow Lynx trust me I did,but I didn't like it,Chinese get on my nerves XD
+Mrs Blueberry Productions **Inhales** It's Japanese my friend.
Pokelo h *exhales* Who cares?!
I'm crying again... I watched this when it first came out... It was my sister's favorite video so we watched it together all the time
Wow. This is just fantastic, nice job, Starbeam.
The girls that Frisk had encountered represented her in the past. Each of the girls symbolized a hard time in Frisk’s life and when she argues with them as to their reason for wanting to jump being ‘lame’ and they each ‘disappear’ this is her finding a reason to continue on living. Then when she faces her present self ( yellow cardigan ) she can’t give her a reason to continue on instead simply saying “Hey, don’t do it, please.” She loses her nerve but the next day she makes up her mind to jump and be free from all the pain she is suffering. So she does just that.
‘She takes off her yellow cardigan, watching her braids all come undone, and her petite form as short as can be is going to jump now and be free.’
(Is what I got from watching the video and paying attention to the lyrics)
Huh, I didn't think of that. While her words seemed so cruel in context, actually trying to move on from the past is the only thing you can do sometimes. Of course that isn't easy or sufficient all the time, and they jump anyway
Wait, Rachie you said? So this was sung by the same person who sing STY frisk's response?
K' Ce exactly
Key Woah
Woah didnt notice
Key
WAIT?! REALLY?! Wow! Those two songs are like, some of my favorites.
I knew this sounded oddly familiar... Dammit sh has the best frisk voice ever
First soul was patience?
Or kidness ??? 0:35 - 0:38 - 0:56 ????????????
yes bt 0:36 ???????!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
It was just to match the song's appearance description (The first person would be Chara, but they don't have braids, so it was changed to patience)
Candy Rin no The first soul was Chara DUH. .-. They just put up Patience first because of the song!
Anamaria Tuta XD kidness
I like the detail that despite Frisk trying to convince them otherwise, all the other kids still jump. It was kinda annoyed me in other animatics where the singer basically goes "thats stupid I have a much better reading to want to die" and the others go "you're right" and leave. In this Frisk accidentally makes it worse which I think is cool
I like your point, however, I’d like to mention (and I think most people are unaware of this) that the R stands for reflection, meaning that, as hinted in the last part, the other people going to jump, are the singer (possibly from different stages of life)
This is a really old animation but I still want to say that this is my all time favourite animation.
I'm not sure why, I saw this the first time some years ago and it stuck with me, sometimes I think about it when I'm doing something else and then I have the urge to watch it again.
I love the concept of this animation, is basically perfect and how it's executed is even better.
This song is used and overused but this time it fits so well and it's more than you usually see around, you can interpreting this in many ways and every option it's amazing and fashinating.
This is my all time favourite animation and I don't even know why
GOD FINALLY. I couldn't find a version of this song that UA-cam DIDN'T keep blocking. Thank you so much! Also, this is what introduced me to this song (and the wonderful world of human souls aus) so many years ago.
Oh wow that was amazing! I especially loved the scene where Frisk was finally about to jump and the three other humans appeared, as if all being traits of what Frisk felt.
RAAAAAAAAAACCCCCCCHHHHHHHHHHHHHIIIIIIIIIIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Princess Cookie45 Nope. Rachie is the person singing the song in the video
No just search it,Rachie is the one who sing it.
Oh okay idk who sung it, I just thought you were trying to say a name ( probably because I know a UA-camr does a thing in a uhc where they say racchel while killing someone it a minecraft uch)
Well the question is
*DOES RACHEL DO A COVER?*
When I first saw and heard this I thought frisk was describing her personal dieing inside and the girls she mostly talked to was her describing what she looked like and when the girls were telling why they was going to do it frisk was just telling reasons why she wants to do it(no hate plz it was a thought and I had to edited it cuz I had ideas)
Baby Ghost yeah I think your right
Ask The Human Souls Undertale like I said it's my opinion
Ask The Human Souls Undertale, Frisk is gender ambiguous not genderless. You can call them whatever since it's just an opinion on what they are.
Baby Ghost this song wasn't made by the creator of the art. Though, that was the original plan for the original song.
Actually, in the original song of My R, it is actually talking about it. Some people are theorizing about it.
I just realized something. The song is probably a person's inner self trying to talk them out of suicide but on the last day her inner self couldn't stop her.
It was undertale that brought me to this song.. And up until now i still listen to it
Ah, your art is so great! I also like that little animation at the beginning. It's nice to see original stuff like this, tbh. Mostly that you even gave the 6 Souls your own designs. Your bravery isn't what people usually make them like at all and this gives off such a nice vibe for the whole video, too.
And.. is it weird that no matter what, I can't help but see Chara as a guy in your style..? o3o'
Makusia o w o yeah, chara though totally has that face that could be a guy or girl but kinda leans more towards guy. They just don't seem to be given any very feminine features but at the same time they don't really have masculine features either, really helps with the gender neutral thing so no one can complain "well what chara looks like doesnt fit MY headcannon!!" Same goes for frisk, but i feel they look more female than male, kinda like how chara looks more male than female though they could be either
Sorry long comment have a potato emoji 🥔
Guess we see it the same way then x'D
Makusia o w o \(^_^)/
I like my R song even though it's really sad and I'll be honest just by the time I got to 0:33 I was like, "OH THIS IS SUCH A COOL CONCEPT FOR THE MY R SONG." Thanks for making this I really enjoyed it!
It was kinda cruel that Bravery just fell down the mountain and left her sick mother in the house alone tho..
I think the reason she jumped was because her mom died from being sick
This is so true.. It's like you save everyone but no-one saves you
player:this how undertale was born
fatal error sans:seriously where you even get this
i want to cry T-T
anime-game-lover Then cry! let those tears come out of your eyeballs!
Same
I did cry
QwQ
If there was ever a time I would climb the mountain it would be sixth grade when my social isolation, depression, and apathy were at their peak. That'd be interesting to see, but personally I'm glad I never decided to disappear
Didn't Frisk trip into the hole? Or did they really want to commit suicide????
Edit: Thanks guys!!!! 😄😄
Who knows. Maybe they went up there to do it and tripped anyway? It's up to interpretation really.
Cryogenic Kitty *CHARA* tripped, no one knows about Frisk though.
Cryogenic Kitty that was chara
Cryogenic Kitty no one knows
why else would you climb a mountain no one returns from
Cryogenic Kitty it was chara that triped. We dont know what Frisk did
I love how instead of jumping off the roof it’s jumping into the underground, really brings out the story and the meaning
I think that Chara would be a better fit for this (of course the people they talk to will be part of themselves)
Anyways, I love this
Capri Draws same
Chara already died goddamit
@@Toetouchers I’m pretty sure that’s why they said Chara would be a better fit. Cause they actually died underground unlike frisk
SOMEBODY ELSE MADE THIS VIDEO, I am SO glad you've thought of this same song as myself. It is SO fitting to the UT children, especially the interaction with Chara. WELL DONE
I love the song buddy, chump, pal, ok ill stop but i do love it
*PATIENCE,BRAVERY, INTEGRITY,PERSEVERANCE,KINDNESS,JUSTICE,FRISK,CHARA*
**S T A Y**
**D E T E R M I N E D**
*FEAR*
*HATE*
God...this song is SO GOD DAMN SAD !!! But thinking this is how the storyline of undertale could a started is SO SAD AND really deep man I love this fandom
Gods........this is literaly the best Undertale animation ever
This is beautiful. The song and animation fits together so well. Well done Starbeam!
I always thought the main character in this song was Chara, and they were trying to convince the souls not to go in the mountain, but they did anyway. Then, frisk came along, and Chara thought frisk was a lot like them, and agreed to help them in the mountain, since Chara knew they possessed determination and would go anyway
You have no idea how hard it was for me to find this
I pulled down the description, and saw the undertale advertisement. I froze. Oh my gosh. It’s been 5 years. Five years, since it was made. Oh my gosh. 2015, was when it was made.
"I coulnd't care less either way"
DETERMINATION LOSTED
So basically...Frisk incentivated people to commit suicide by telling them "Hey, you have problems? Too bad, I'll make my life sound way worse!" "Yes, FaLl iNt0 tH3 AbBeS$¡"
Flame Raven no, in the original My R she's talking to herself each day, convincing herself to not commit suicide. Eventually she didn't convince herself.
Every new girl represents a reason to die in her own life, and every time she finds a reason to convince them (which means herself) to not take the fall.
But every day, she sees a new girl which has the exact opposite situation of the reason she gave the day before, and she tries again to save that new girl with another reason to live etc...
For some days, this cycle of "Pros and Cons to suicide" works in favor of her, but then one day she doesn't find anyone on the rooftop, which means that every reason she had to live does not works on her anymore, like "having a loving family" began "having a careless family" etc...
So she finally takes the fall due to not having anything to live for.
this song in a nutshell
Flame Raven This song is very serious and suicidal. Please do not make a joke out of it. It's very serious and I think what you said is very insensitive, especially to people thinking about committing suicide.
EmberTheVixen a.k.a Ember Lol like none of us already thought about that
This is a perfect song for people who r depressed because it shows the answer for every problem they have
okay! Im going to mt ebott
Me too!
What it showed like suicide is the answer
No, it's really not. Can we stop saying that these are the answers? For someone who has been suicidal for a long time, I can tell you that this is "not the answer for everyone who is depressed". This video is showing suicide to be the answer, and while I enjoy this so much, this is not a good answer for everyone.
Shailey Boman thank you for saying that, like srsly sure what is said could be used to save someone from depression but you cant only take the good parts of video becauses it still ends in suicide
Its been 7 years?
Oh wow, i miss this
I’m glad I knew what Yandere Sim was before I heard this song.
If you don’t know what I mean, the ‘taking off my shoes’ part is a thing when someone commits suicide.
Oh yeah......i forgot
Micah Roland,
*MIDORI GRUIN(?)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Who is here, thinking that you had finally found the Undertale version of 'My R'.
And happy that you came here.
Chara No!! no...
.... *you tell This person that you ship Charisk then you Jump off cliff*...
The song said frisk stop them from killing themselves yet we all see them do it... LOGIC!!!!!
Jeannie Garcia Look up the original too. Falling was both walking away for some and suicide for the singer in the song.
by dissapeared they dont say they walked away they killed them selves but instead of being hurt about it they were glad someone was there to hear there stories before they ended it all (i assume)
It's symbolic. In the original sound all the girls are reasons to live and in the range all of them vanish till there is no reason to live left and the main girl decides to die
God damn it this song is so sad! But you did a really nice job on the animation!! ♥
Who would have thought the undertale animation would be the one that made me cry
Yepp, I have seen this so many times now, I know exactly whats going to happen everytime, but I have still not managed to watch the entire thing without crying, and im not sure I ever will.
Thank you, I'm just mostly not able to cry, this is the only thing that has made me able to since my grandma's funeral.
I cant explain how much this means to me, just, thank you, thank you so much.
Everybody who's seeing this comment I want you to know that your all special and if you can't throw away your woes give them to me i'm already carrying a lot of them
And Hey i'm daniel your New friend ,hope I helped see you
Dynamic Daisy I'm the soul of kindness
Dynamic Daisy do you now if I'm your friend?
Dynamic Daisy my name in English means what's wrong(Que pasa)
Dynamic Daisy that's the correct answer you win a spiritual hug by me
Dynamic Daisy why must you give me hope for life knowing that I'll die, you're too perfect for this world,
Please take my illness
I think the song was about the girl having her own iner struggles and manasfesting those problems into a person each time trys to kill herself, basicaly her brain is doing everything it can to stop her form commiting suiced. Btw great animation
Love this song and especially love this animation. Seriously your fallen human designs are probably one of my favorites. :)
I saw someone make a vid where undertale reacted to this and I felt like I had to come here to like it once it was done.
Oh my god this was such a pivot point to my interests like 3 years ago when I got into anime stuff having been an undertale fan
This is an amazing creation!It fits Undertale perfectly!Well,before the game starts,that is.But it does explain very well why Frisk went to that mountain in the first place and that the fall WASN'T an accident at all...Anyways I LOVE the animation and I LOVE this singer and I already heard her before singing an Undertale song.It's called Stronger than you Frisk response.To people that admire Rachie as much as I do,you should check it out!:) I DEFINITELY think that the creator of Undertale should make an AU called BeforeTale explaining Frisk's past life before Undertale!
I'm so glad I found this song again
After watching this tons of times, I just realized that these are the souls after they already died and that’s why it shows Green’s grave even before Frisk ever attempted to stop him and how they already seem to know Frisk’ll fail, and how Chara disappeared into the yellow flowers. Nice going, OP :D
Wow, you made an already sad song, somehow even sadder. This was extremely well done. Good job.
i should probably be more concerned about what i just watched but now im just concerned that frisk went through the whole freaking underground without shoes
A'm I the only one who read the desc?
Edit: wow, I didn't exapt to get likes xD
Edit again :^): woww, 220
Sparkle Fox, no I did
Sparkle Fox i did
Sparkle Fox I did
Sparkle Fox I read descriptions.
•Sparkle Føx• I did like someone with common sense
Returning after 4years
same
Listening to the song time and time again. I believe that Frisk is trying to stop them from committing suicide, even if they want to do it, but every time they tried the wrong words came out because they don't know the whole story. Frisk may have came off angry, but they may have also been frustrated by how they could let out their pain to Frisk but in the end everyone jumped. When Frisk came across Chara, they couldn't do it anymore. And broke down. Chara did disappear, going back to the underground. When they came to commit suicide they saw themselves in the people who jumped that they failed to save.
You did a lovely job on this animatic. Every time I hear this song I start crying and seeing it in animatic form just really amplified the feelings.
IM CRYING-
but i love this :D
Happy beat
Sad meaning to the lyrics
Nice art and nice music beautiful 😊
Finally heard this in the year of our lord 2024
Dude I see you on almost every milgram eng cover WHY ARE YOU HERE TOO
@@_..MapleAcorn.._ my reach is far. It's not enough that I make covers and comments about Milgram, I must comment on everything I find 🤣
Real talk, I just like commenting to help boost the youtuber's engagement lol
I can’t with this.
The art, the animation, the storyline. It’s all so perfect!!
This is probably one of the BEST My R animations I’ve seen yet! I don’t really like Undertale, (well, *now* I don’t, I used to be obsessed with it) but this brings back a whole lot of amazing memories from this game. I LOVE this animation! Keep up the good work!
how is this the only animatic I've seen that actually takes into consideration how weirdly hypocritical this song can sound...
(also this one is my favorite for this exact reason)
I'm guessing no-one really understand this so...
The people who commited suicide before Frisk were actually a representation of Frisk trying to stop him/herself to commit suicide.She/He tried to look for reasons to live,but couldn't find any and...well,in the end,he/she jumped.
47 people cried so hard they hit the dislike button
383 people*
Now 407
Poor short girl/bravery(I think), she's hungry...
I really love this.
Its perfect.
I remembering browsing through this channel not to long ago, and I barely saw anything, but suddenly all of these amazing animatics come out of nowhere. Why didn’t I see this before.
I’ve been looking for this video EVERYWHERE
I finally found it!
Yellow Soul's like "Chill, I'm going to go find the 5 other people"
Clover never came back. Woooo...
Please...can we not bring uty into EVERYTHING?
1:02 Frisk met Patience, Bravery, Integrity, Perseverance, and then Kindness is the second to last because Frisk never got to them. They died before Frisk met them. And Yellow is Chara she's at the end because she is like the opposite of Frisk(?) and since Frisk is the 1st one Chara would be the last one. sorry if this is incorrect I don't know too much about Undertale.
Edit: okay this is probably all wrong don't pay attention to this comment 😂😂
When the song goes "Hey, don't do it please" for the second time, I always tear up.
Agreed
Ok! Since most of you guys are clueless the person who made the song where she was talking to her inner self to not commit Suicide. Then The Last part was where she could not help her self and she just jumped but that hand was herself saying that once she jumped she did not really want to die.
Despite myself, I go and scream
"Hey dont do it and please"
great work I was wondering why there wasn't an Undertale version and this turned out great
Anyone in 2019 or 2020 still watching this??..
Or still loves undertale??
I refuse to let undertale go...
I am determined to not let it go
I'm am!
And Undertale will always persevere!
💜
ME TOO :D I HAVE THE GAME
The souls dont seem to be sad when frisk has finally made up their mind to jump, probably bc the souls know they are needed in the underground, that they'll be okay. That they are the determined angel who has seen the surface and make the underground go empty. It's their time, the prophesy foretold it. They're encouraging frisk. It's time for monsters to finally be free.
AOMG I`VE WAITED FOR THIS SO LONG!!! IT`A PERFECT!!!
You did an amazing job with this
in all honesty this is the first video I watch that's not for the song yet includes one