Are YouTube Podcasts kind of dumb?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
- I asked UA-cam questions directly about UA-cam Podcasts, and I got some answers to share with you. If you're a podcaster, these are exciting, weird and confusing times. Let's discuss.
Listen to my podcasts here:
🎤 The Smart Passive Income Podcast: www.smartpassi...
🎤 AskPat (these are real life business coaching calls): www.smartpassi...
Also, have you thought about starting your own podcast? Check out the #1 podcasting tutorial on UA-cam here:
• How to Start a Podcast...
The podcasting equipment I use: www.kit.co/patf...
My video and live streaming equipment: patflynn.com/l...
Also, follow me at these places below and say hi!
Personal site: www.patflynn.com
Instagram: / patflynn
Twitter: / patflynn
If you'd like to send me any snail mail, send it here:
10531 4S Commons Dr.
Suite 524
San Diego, CA 92127
They weren't always called "podcasts" but gained the moniker because Apple made listening to them easier on an iPod (at the time they needed podcasts). They were also called "Netcasts," "Webcasts"," or "Internet Radio" (some older shows still have "radio" in their titles like "Gamertag Radio."
I like Rob Walch's definition, he said *in part* that a podcast is an audio program with an RSS feed.
Here's another question, for YOU (and, for UA-cam, by extension). Once the integration is complete, will every time someone LISTENS to a video from a Podcast playlist in UA-cam Music, will it count as a VIEW? 🤔 And if so, will that WATCH TIME count towards qualifying for the YT Partner Program? 🤷♀🤷♂
We need this answer!!!!
And is every episode treated the same as a regular video for monetization once you are in YTPP as per regular videos
@@OUTHERETRYNASURVIVE don't we though?? But even UA-cam might not quite know yet 😅
As an audio only listener, I hate that you have to have YT open on mobile and when the phone turns off, the podcast stops. So, I don't consume podcasts on YT.
It will be VERY interesting to see how YT implements RSS feeds. YT's analytics are top notch so I'm not sure how companies such as Podbean, Blubrry, Libsyn, etc. are going to compete.
I experimented with this feature and put an audio podcast on with a still image. I was horrified to see it show up in my main feed. And then surprised to see it do better than other videos. I am best known as a podcaster so that may have affected the outcome. But audiences may not have the difficulty we think. So, there’s one data point.
Was dumb😂...After this video...Have curated special podcasts🎉fights, Love,crow Tales and Enjoy watching..up next funny .Thank you 🌹🌹
Great questions, Pat. I was actually just thinking about the possibility of setting video game let's plays as a podcast to test out. They share many similarities with podcasts - longform, episodic in nature, etc. - and with UA-cam pushing this feature, it had me wondering if they may actually get more of a push by being labeled as a podcast. Also, that line of "same audience, same channel - different audience, different channel" is oh so hard to nail down as a creator!
Podcasters have been posting their audio on UA-cam as a video with just a stationary image showing on the screen for years. UA-cam didn't call these broadcasts podcasts but that's what they were. These "videos" are how I got introduced to listening to podcasts back in 2016. It's also how I found some of the podcasts I listen to today. UA-cam's new podcast service will help podcasters by giving them one more place to be found. I don't think podcasters should put a lot of effort into making their content into a video production. A podcast's unique value is that it can be listened to while doing something else. Last point, I don't foresee many podcast listeners making UA-cam their primary source of content. Most will keep listening on platforms like iTunes, Stitcher and Overcast. Podcasters should not publish exclusively on UA-cam but should treat it as a way to reach new listeners who will listen and subscribe on other platforms.
Well, here I am, watching a UA-cam video about whether UA-cam podcasts are dumb... So who's the real genius here? 😂 Great insights into the platform debate!
Tbh, youtube implementing podcasts seems to be a great thing for many creators, as it gives creators their own space to be discovered more easily
Agreed. I think it could go one step further and add discord or zoom style integration for interviews or participation during a stream or private session so you could record the podcast as well.
Yeah but then there's YT's policies, and sometimes vague and broad striking and demonetizing practices, especially towards creators who don't agree with the same political/social ideas as the monkeys behind the screen at YT HQ.
My only question, can it play with the screen off? I'm only about half way through the video though
It's dumb UA-cam is not a place for podcast. People on UA-cam are not long form listeners unless it's trash.
Ahhh we have been debating taking our podcast episodes off our channel and creating a new channel and focus on just YT viewers for our current channel. Now what do we do?? 😂😂😂
Thanks for the vid. Lets assume I record video podcasts. I use the audio for my regular podcasts, what happens if a use a distribution platform (for spotify and others), and now want to add the video podcast to youtube, will that be considered a podcast or a regular video on my channel? How would search be effected? I doubt listeners would prefer a video podcast, and I'm not sure how many listen to podcasts on youtube, as opposed to watching the podcast.
Wooooow.. interesting. A few months ago Google announced they would stop presenting the podcast carousel in search results. Some people wondered why they were dropping the podcast crawling experiment they've been doing for the last couple years. I guess this answers the question. 🤔
They're like "now you can take videos, and put them in to a playlist!" ......isn't that just a playlist? I really don't get the concept of a podcast video. It would make sense if YT made an audio only version of your selected video, and there's your podcast, and people could find it wherever they get podcasts, or in a UA-cam podcast player. Otherwise I don't get it.
I am really confused whether podcast contains video or audio which is better to be published ?
Thank You
Does this mean this would be a good time to launch a podcast? Like will it be pushed more by UA-cam?
Some great questions raised here and I am interested in following these developments and how UA-cam is going to change the podcasting landscape. Thanks for this.
I've been using Anchor (or I guess it's now called Spotify for Podcasters) and it's been working great as an audio podcast host and RSS feed. I feel like UA-cam would have to offer me quite a few comprehensive features to get me to use UA-cam as my RSS/host
I have a small YT channel and was moving away from YT to create podcast content full-time... Some of my YT viewers were sad that I was leaving as they ONLY watch YT and wouldn't even consider listening to a podcast .
They are now happy that they can listen to my podcasts on YT and don't care that there is only one static image for the whole podcast episodes.
I tried creating a visual story to follow the podcast stories and it took MANY MANY hours to do and not worth the effort as the views show.
Great questions... I was also thinking "what's the point" of this new category.... glad you were just as perplexed! lol
Thanks for asking these questions Pat and being open that the answers aren't 100% clear (like most things in this world). We're going to try using our Video Marketing Podcast as video but a video highlight reel of what's more extended on audio. This info was helpful for me. Thanks! - Dane 🙋🏻♂
Hello. If you have a podcast, I think we should be excited! Definitely us small channels.
Great probing questions Pat. I think it's still early 'daze' and the audience analytics will decide. I'm in Favor of anything that will help spread the word and build my audience. The big thing is the amount of time it takes to publish a podcast is much less than for a video.
I keep thinking Podcast means a digital broadcast. Anything is a podcast. Is the evolution of radio and tv.
Ok, here's what I'd love to see you cover: what to do if you have an existing podcast elsewhere and want to move to UA-cam.
For one, should you? And secondly, how?
"Same audience, same channel. Different audience, different channel." Good stuff Pat!
RSS integration is major
So the answer seems to be that, yes, they are kind of dumb. But! They might not be so dumb in the future. And it might be smart(!) to start taking advantage of this feature now.
Affiliate marketing video🎉Facebook group and ads video
I do not have option to podcast when going live or uploading unless I make a podcast playlist from my videos that have already been made.
Ive always wondered about this. What constitutes a podcast? Now everyone has a podcast.
very very interesting .... curious to where tthings will go
Very interesting...I was just thinking about starting a podcast then I saw that you can do a podcast on youtube then I said wait....isn't that the same ting???? the way you explained it I think I got it. Thank you.
any news on the RSS feed topic? Can I now publish my UA-cam Podcast on other Podcast directories?
I enabled stream to UA-cam on Libsyn then realized all it was doing was duplicating essentially the same content so I removed it. I record a main interview which we release on the channel to help promote the podcast, but it’s not the entire podcast, only the main interview, which makes more sense to me than duplicating things. Podcasting is hard.
This is a headache more than a blessing it seems at the moment. I wish they'd differentiate podcast playlists from regular channel videos so it doesn't hurt engagement/watch time analytics.
It does. You can select an upload to go to a regular playlist as well as the podcast and then you will see separate analytics for the podcast side. I’ve been using it almost a month and content is getting views on both.
@@cool2no your podcast isn't also on your main video feed?
@@KevinNordstrom yes and no…the podcast site UA-cam started is like another shelf for content and you have to set it up in studio from computer then it’s basically a playlist with a special designation off to the right of “podcast” when you upload content for it from then on you can select it to be listed there as well as other playlists on your channel. If it’s in the podcast designated playlist it will have additional analytics showing you how it’s performing on that side of UA-cam. Just think of it as a category that if you don’t put content in, it won’t go in that category.
The more answers I get, the more confused I am. Is it primarily for video podcasts? If it goes to the UA-cam Music app, it'd just be playing the audio, right? So if I have an audio podcast, it'd make sense to create a graphic for the video track, upload it as a podcast, and then get it onto UA-cam music where it's only the audio. Right?
Great video Pat. I'm glad you are asking the questions. As you have a larger audience definitely UA-cam will be more inclined to answer quicker. :) Your information is great as always. Thank you for keeping us all informed. GREAT THUMBNAIL too. :)
Just show us how to get say an existing
Playlist that we want to get to you tube podcast. Including making sure we get the square thumbnail uploaded
I can't seem to get studio to let me change the thumbnail to square for the podcast listing
Pat just casually answered all my questions
😁
I'm being blocked from posting pod cast
Honestly I'm behind this. UA-cam is the main SM network I use by a ton and it'd be nice to do more things in one place.
They don't make sense to me. If they were also audio playable when people use podcasting apps such as Google podcasts or Spotify podcast, then it would be a real podcast. Otherwise it's just video blogs. It should be RSS feed as well. I should also have audio versions. It should also have an algorithm to check if a video is designed like a podcast with an introduction and conclusion and a commentary because podcasts are usually involve people talking.
I interview creators and entrepreneurs who are using video to grow their business. The interviews are on this channel and I have clips that I've turned into UA-cam Shorts :) (I also still have and use my ipod) :)
And? Does UA-cam support RSS now, instead of a podcast host?
It’s definitely a bit confusing right now. I’m hoping for clarity as this rolls out. Currently 27 interviews selected for the podcast playlist and a logo made. Time will tell!
it’s a playlist category they added. To access it, go to UA-cam studio from a computer and tap “create” in the upper right. You’ll see “new podcast” as an option there. When you have content for a podcast and you select that it will ask for a couple pieces of information and then it’s a playlist in your available playlists when you upload from then on. The rest of the features they’re rolling out like creating an audio version and being shown on the main podcast page are if you’re getting tons of views and interaction. Hope this helps
Hi today Pat ! I think audio podcast youtube channel will not work only video podcast?
@patflynn do you recommend starting a new channel based on more search volume and lots of competition or less search volume and less competition?
Are those audio only RSS links out yet?
I think this is smart move from Google / UA-cam to run more ads and get more revenue.
Great thoughts and insight, thanks!
Ive been pretty confused by this idea but think it's going to be a great asset in the future. The one thing that seems strange is, why wouldnt you put the podcast as a long form video and benefit from the homepage rather than locking it away on the podcast tab?
Yeah, still very confusing. Love your videos by the way - super HIGH production, and extremely valuable. Thank you for commenting over here!
And it did happen. Rss feed😂😂
Definitely taking advantage of this new feature in the coming months! One of my main questions is how the podcast episodes would show up in your public video library?
Likely similar to how shorts have their own category link on the video tab.
I’ve been doing it and it’s essentially a playlist with a designation of podcast off to the right. You can upload content and select a regular playlist as well as the podcast. The first time you do this you would set up the podcast with a description and static thumbnail. After that anything you upload can also be checked to store in that list as well. As he’s saying here, eventually the episode going to audio on to UA-cam music as well as your rss feed to go out to platforms like Apple Podcasts will be available too.
I’m super happy about this integration. I have been flip-flopping on different content strategy ideas for a long time and this actually incorporates everything I wanted to do. A longform podcast on top of a UA-cam channel that can easily feed into each other.
Thanks for covering this and I’m looking forward to anything else about UA-cam podcasts :)
Hello, Mr. Pat "Podcast" Flynn! These are valid questions. Additionally, how will they be monetized? When I am listening to a podcast I don't want interruptions from ads. I listen often when I need to be "hands-free" and I hate trying to listen to a video (I often do) and getting stuck in the ad loop because I'm driving. UGH. What do you think?
Good questions and answers
Great video, Pat! I'm wondering if I mark a current video as a podcast if its views will stop counting toward my watch hours. And will it stop being shown on my channel page (unless people click the podcast tab?)
Very helpful video, I'm posting my first podcast today and had a lot of questions, this touched on many of them! Appreciate it!
UA-cam ruined podcast.
One of my first questions:
But can I listen to UA-cam Podcasts on my phone with the screen locked?🤔
Also, thanks for this video.
I'm sensing some level of scrutiny that seems of artifice, which is unusual for your videos. "Podcasts" have taken on a certain format because of talk radio/public radio and I don't see the addition of a UA-cam category necessarily changing that. And the question of whether or not the podcast fits your audience is something that is covered by what most people say on the topic of channel topic, and now confirmed by UA-cam - that if your topic relates to your channel's audience, then keep it there.
A big reason why I don't dip into the podcasting waters is because it's more work. Setting up new accounts, payments and everything associated with podcasting is something I don't want to add. UA-cam Podcasts sounds like it makes it easy - and you don't have to pay money to host the content on a different platform. Add RSS feed and AdSense and it just makes sense!
420K subscriber's 😊
Interesting.
All great questions Pat! I set up my interview playlist and changed name to channel name and set to Podcasts. UA-cam's instructional video said to not include the word "podcast" in the title, but now I am wondering if I should to distinguish it?
I started a separate channel for my podcast because I was advised by youtube experts out there that you don't want these hour long videos mucking up your video list.
My question is, if I set up a playlist as a podcast does UA-cam take those videos, remove it from my main video feed, and add it to a podcast tab on my channel (like shorts do)? Or do they still sit in my "Videos" section and get in the way of my other videos?
If they do it like they do with shorts then I'd consider moving my podcast (which is fairly new, only 5 episodes) back to my own channel because it's the same target audience.
I believe they stay on your main video feed along with it separately within its own playlist. Unless you can remove it from the main video shelf separately
Happy Easter! 🌞👍
We tested with 3 uploads. I wish they would allow you to remove it from notification alert.
RSS Feed is Huge!
My head hurts 🤕
Thank you for this, Pat. I suppose everything depends on what UA-cam envisions for this. If they envision this being a platform for podcast listeners who have no interest in seeing images as they consume content, then sticking one visual on an old podcast and uploading it if still relevant should do the trick. But is this how I should view it? What about newbie's just starting out on the platform for the sake of having a podcast that is searchable. Is there anything in your opinion that we should be thinking about?
I have in Swedish podcast on my youtube that only have one pic on it.... Don it for a will now... It works good
This was extremely interesting and I’m excited to see your further findings on this topic 👍🏻
Hey Pat, I just watched your video and I must say that it was really informative and well-made. I loved your videos. I was wondering if I could help you edit your videos and also make highly engaging shorts for you?
I like to listen to podcasts while lying down on my couch with eyes closed. It would be great of UA-cam had the ability to turn off the screen while listening like other top podcast apps
Whatever happens we can be sure it will be eventually ruined by an algorithm
i am wanting to start a podcast and wish to use Garageband. However, getting the settings correct and reducing or eliminating all of the unwanted white noise is driving me crazy!! Pat, do you know how to do this? I have looked through your previous podcasts on Garageband and find that you and many others overlook getting the settings right to make it sound anywhere near as professional as you sound!
Thanks for your thoughts on question 4, Pat. This is something we've been trying to determine the best path forward on.
Can you help me figure out why I got demonetized?
The same audience answer makes a lot of sense! Works that way with all platforms and content you put out. The rest I’m still trying to understand 🤪 All great questions, Pat! Looking forward to more on this!
Great questions, and like you, I don't look at UA-cam videos for more than a few seconds unless something is said that creates the need to look at it.
While it would appear to be a positioning move to bring broader content to YT Music, I agree with you 💯 around quality assurance being needed! Thanks for sharing Pat, looking forward to hearing what else you find out!
This was extremely interesting and I’m excited to see your further findings on this topic!Thanks for sharing!
Am I correct, that you can still upload your video to YT as video not as podcast? Do you think there will be an ad in between like to regular YT video? How much do they pay for the monetization of YT Podcast?
The creator can choose to monetize it like a regular video and will likely pay just like a regular video, as opposed to shorts which have a separate frestment
Thank you for sharing
Good episode
Thanks
Could those answers be the product of chatgpt? 🤔
No because ChatGPT doesn’t have data that up to date and has yet to integrate web
@@patflynn thanks for taking the time to read and address my assumption. Have a lovely week 😊
I think a stronger title by removing kind of would perform better. Currently the title is super wishy washy
Hello from Gatlinburg TN Smoky Mountains Park...I've made 50$ from the 3 weeks I've signed up ...wait, what???? I go live here in Gatlinburg abs after I end it, I add it to my *podcast*.. I still have no clue how or why ..but thank you 🏞️🐻🌄
I still have an IPod that works and I use!!! So glad you are covering this as I didn't understand why they have a Podcast option, but it's super cool the episodes get more distribution and will continue to grow. What happens if you duplicate some of your content exactly from one channel to another - I thought that goes against UA-cam's terms and conditions, but I know that some of my videos would likely do very well duplicated on another channel for a specific segment of my audience, that could grow into a bigger segment of it's own, but it still very relevant to my main audience?