The Pinarello Dogma F is Fast but Compromised | My Real-World Review

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 127

  • @charlesblithfield6182
    @charlesblithfield6182 2 місяці тому +35

    I’m going to use something you said at the beginning of this video as my new mantra when evaluating bikes: “Normal riding, at normal speeds, on normal roads”. It’s simple and concise but says a great deal and will be a necessary reminder to me when marketing hype can cloud a decision.

    • @nellyx1x493
      @nellyx1x493 2 місяці тому +3

      Exactly, the normal rider is paying a premium for the extra stiffness that their normal power output does not require - and ending up with a worse ride quality as a result.

    • @CreativeFishDesignsCharlotte
      @CreativeFishDesignsCharlotte 2 місяці тому +1

      bless u

  • @Ridewithjst
    @Ridewithjst 2 місяці тому +20

    I ride a 2023 Dogma F, also with Princeton wheels (6560 Strada, not the 4550’s as here). I KNOW it’s one of the worst value bikes, but god damn, I love it and cherish it, which makes me ride way more, further, faster, happier.
    I’d imagine the new version is marginally better and would recommend it to anyone debating it. Stupid expensive? Yes. What’s the cost of an ear to ear smile though?

    • @ThomasIsBored
      @ThomasIsBored 2 місяці тому +1

      Also it's stuuuupid beautiful. Never had a bike fascinate me so much, this thing is simply a work of art

    • @inferno4001
      @inferno4001 Місяць тому +1

      I still ride my dogma f10. What else does one need??? 💪🏼

    • @kb240
      @kb240 Місяць тому +2

      Spot on.. In a garage full of race motorcycles, my Pina is the only thing that remains constantly spotless and excites me just by looking at it.

    • @Ridewithjst
      @Ridewithjst Місяць тому

      @@kb240 this is an excellent example of how I feel about mine, too, despite lacking the sport bikes lol.

    • @KellyB-zw8hu
      @KellyB-zw8hu Місяць тому +2

      I couldn't agree more! I currently have the Dogma F12 with the Envy Wheelset. It also makes me push harder and ride more. I lost a few nights of sleep when I first bought it, but I have no regrets.

  • @EdwardTBurke-pv3qr
    @EdwardTBurke-pv3qr 2 місяці тому +5

    This is, by far, the BEST review of the new Dogma F by anyone, out there ! Well done !!! After a 8 month wait, the three boxes from a very good source in Bergamo, Italy arrived and my friend who owns a small bike shop and I assembled my 2013/2014 Dogma F with Campagnolo Super Record wireless, Campagnolo Shamal carbon wheels, Vittoria Corsa N.EXT 700 x 28 tubeless tyres. In the Speedster Silver pearlescent silver and glossy black paint it is absolutely beautiful ! I am not Tom Pidcock descending at 100 kmph, so the aerodynamic improvements of the new 2015 Dogma F don't really matter to me. I think my "last year's" frameset actually looks better. For sizing, I am 177 cm tall and the Dogma 540 size is perfect with 2 cm of spacers under the Talon Ultra stem. I found some New Old Stock Campagnolo Record pedals to match my shoes and other bikes. Instead of the Pinarello MOST cages which are tricky to put the bottle back in, I have a pair of the SILCA (from Indianapolis USA) titanium tube cages. The tubing is what is used for the hydraulic lines on the GE turbine helicopter engines which are also manufactured in Indianapolis. Having ridden a rental Dogma F with Dura Ace Di2 in the Italian Alps, the handling of the bike is super smooth, responsive and well behaved whether you are climbing, descending or just riding on the flat. I hope to still be riding my Dogma F for the next 20 or 25 years.

  • @steveharrington1052
    @steveharrington1052 2 місяці тому +5

    My first pro level bike was a Pinarello with Campy, year was 1992. Last year I thought my last road bike should be s Pinarello but the C$17,000 price tag killed that idea. After lots of research and with Davids videos helping I bought a very sensible Roubaix SRAM AXS, could not be happier…

  • @TESTA-CC
    @TESTA-CC 2 місяці тому +14

    I'm tempted to buy a Modern carbon bike,
    But I Enjoy the simplicity of Vintage bikes.
    I have a Vitus 979 Dural & Peugeot Perthus Pro Reynolds 753r.

  • @SimonGoesSideways
    @SimonGoesSideways 2 місяці тому +6

    I'm no expert tester but your comments on the bike match my experience of riding the previous Dogma F and F12. At the more normal speeds I ride at (17 - 20mph on the flat), the bike feels uninspiriing. Not to say it's boring, but it lacks excitement unless you are going much much faster. Other bikes like the Tarmac SL8 are more involving at lower speeds

    • @PinholeQuilting
      @PinholeQuilting 2 місяці тому +1

      I have an 8 year old Tarmac, the Amira women's version. I bought it second hand from a shop in Hereford. It hada ton of upgrades on it and I could not help but buy it. When I get on it I just want to go fast. Its incredible how good it feels. It would be lovely to have a pinarello but... Its a hefty tag!

  • @kb240
    @kb240 Місяць тому +2

    I know they're pricey... but damn, Pinarello is awesome. Customers/haters questioning stiffness after the German tour article... Fine, let's make the stiffest bike ever made. Customers/haters questioning the weight? Fine, new carbon fiber that is stiff as a board is also light as air. I have an F... and if you're looking for a do it all really damn good race bike, you cant beat them.
    Instant acceleration
    Handles just like a MotoGP bike.. insanely precise.
    Climbs like a mountain goat thanks to that massive BB area/Keel
    Downsides - Cost a fortune, wandering front wheel at slower speeds (but why are you going slow on a Pina?) and parts hard to come by.

  • @SlabISR
    @SlabISR 2 місяці тому +11

    It may be quick…but to help Ineos win a TdF stage, it probably needs a motor

    • @tcrvrs
      @tcrvrs 2 місяці тому

      Underrated comment!

  • @Mrjasonjohn74
    @Mrjasonjohn74 2 місяці тому +6

    A Pinarello Dogma is like a Ducati Panigale superbike - not pretending to be some thing else but pure performance, stiff, feedback from the tarmac beneath, taste the speed and let the adrenaline rush come over you and looks sexy and fast even standing still. If you want comfort get a Dogma X or a Honda.

  • @paulwixman8151
    @paulwixman8151 2 місяці тому +1

    Very comprehensive review as per usual!! Cheers Mate, Pjw

  • @darkismkayla
    @darkismkayla 2 місяці тому

    I have one kislux bag I got in 2019, it's the LV white catogram speedy. It's counter quality and it has a nice honey patina now, so the leather is real. I think whatever makes you happy go for it. I've seen LV with plastic leather and blood red glaze...

  • @nellyx1x493
    @nellyx1x493 2 місяці тому +14

    The fact this fast aero 'race' bike comes with a compact should tell you what crowd the build is really aimed at, its the 'look at me and how amazing I look with this flash handbag' crowd.

    • @andrewhayes7055
      @andrewhayes7055 2 місяці тому +6

      Stockbrokers riding around Richmond Park on a Sunday morning

    • @charliecook6909
      @charliecook6909 2 місяці тому +6

      Definitely a rich middle aged man's bike for sure , I guess it makes you look like you know what your doing 🤣 but on the other hand ,if you can afford it why not have a tasty 14k bike

    • @Adonis-qj1nq
      @Adonis-qj1nq 2 місяці тому +2

      lol quite the opposite really. Even some pro riders use compact chainrings on the big mountain stages. Just to name one as an example, at the 2023 Giro Geraint Thomas had a compact on some of the mountain stages. Not everyone can be Tadej Pogacar. You probably live in a really flat area.

    • @nellyx1x493
      @nellyx1x493 2 місяці тому +2

      @@Adonis-qj1nq lol, the opposite. I live and ride in the mountains. Bikes like this are fast and 50/34 compact is too easy for normal riding, the pro's might slap one on for a novelty climbing stage, then go back to 54/42 or bigger for everything else. The point being, if the rider needs a compact then they probably don't need this bikes stiffness and would probably end up faster if they were on something more comfortable, as they'd be more likely to extend their training rides instead of being fatigued after 3hrs.

    • @Ridewithjst
      @Ridewithjst 2 місяці тому

      @@nellyx1x493I have a 2023 Dogma with 52/36 and 11/34 in the back. I’ve put 1,200 watts through the bike at 80kg and the stiffness is extremely appreciated, even at far lower power outputs. You really notice it during fast group rides that border on low end crit races where you have to lay down big efforts to stay in the wheel, for example.

  • @NemanjaPantelic
    @NemanjaPantelic 2 місяці тому +5

    Finally, I really like the appearance of the Dogma, especially in this color. So, I suppose in the car world, a Dogma F would be a Koenigsegg, right? Or is it more like the Ferrari at 13:19? 😁

  • @deanf2259
    @deanf2259 2 місяці тому

    Hi Dave, 28mm tryes tubeless an a low pressure of 50psi. I run 32mm on my bikes, with tubes and at 40psi. No issues and no hassle of tubeless. 32mm tyres for road riding is the new standard. I'm a complete convert. Stopped riding my older race bike with rim brakes and only max tyre size of 27mm.

    • @ronetele13
      @ronetele13 2 місяці тому

      How much does your bike & rider weigh?

  • @fabianmolyneux2308
    @fabianmolyneux2308 2 місяці тому +2

    Great review Dave really value your impressions. I'm not a racer and prefer more of a "do it all" type of bike. I've are Tarmac SL8 and it ticks that box for me. It's a pity the Pinarello is not on trend by better accommodating wider tyres.
    Again, thanks for your review.
    As an aside, when you initially reviewed the Madone you indicated you were reserving your final impressions bending getting in on your home turf for a ride. Any indication when that might be on the cards?

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 місяці тому

      Thanks Fabian. There is a Madone SL heading my way soon but don't have an eta on that just yet, fingers crossed it's soon

  • @Nucz523
    @Nucz523 2 місяці тому +2

    I have reserved one of this in our local bike shop in luxter red, how is the stiffness? I know its a few hundred grams heavier than the tarmac but I heard this is stiffer so it likely to have better power transfer than sl8

    • @ellwitz9838
      @ellwitz9838 2 місяці тому

      Does it really matter if you feel beat up after 100 km?
      Unless you are killing it at the local Cat 1 races you are better off saving the weight and walking away from long rides while still comfortable

  • @theovannieuwenhuizen5756
    @theovannieuwenhuizen5756 2 місяці тому +1

    Thanks for your honest review.
    Will you be testing the Merida Reactie soon? Would be very interesting to get your opinion. Specifically for recreational riding.
    Excellent camera work by the way.

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 місяці тому

      Thanks. No plans on the Reacto yet but let me see what I can do

  • @saxon1376
    @saxon1376 2 місяці тому +4

    That looks soooooo much fun ,
    What with the Italian heritage I’d defo love to take it out for a spin

    • @saphireg8094
      @saphireg8094 2 місяці тому +1

      I’m going to get one anyways, rip it on a bike that transfers all the power

    • @larryt.atcycleitalia5786
      @larryt.atcycleitalia5786 2 місяці тому

      What with the Italian heritage - when was the last one of these things actually Made-in-Italy?

  • @daxmotis27
    @daxmotis27 2 місяці тому +14

    Rather have the c68 or tarmac if I’m spending that kind of money

    • @peterfreeman3317
      @peterfreeman3317 2 місяці тому +3

      I’d rather have a Time Scylon. And I have 3 Pinarello’s…too much for a bike made in the Far East. Build it in Italy and I’d pay the premium.

  • @SFSomega
    @SFSomega 2 місяці тому +7

    My heart say I need one, my wallet says fuck you!

  • @69michas
    @69michas 2 місяці тому +1

    For me, it's clearly a bike for people in midlife crisis, apart from the pros.
    But what would interest me: do you know in what ratio the drivetrains are ordered? SRAM, Shimano or Campagnolo?

    • @saphireg8094
      @saphireg8094 2 місяці тому

      I love the design and weight, waiting on my “my way” spec

  • @HeyWattsUpCycling
    @HeyWattsUpCycling 2 місяці тому +2

    I like the color on it, dont like the forward seatpost thats out of alignment with the seat tube (like on my F5 thats on the same alignment plane). I wonder if it bb/crank:rear stays is more stiff and accelerates better. My F5 (also 6.8kg) is the same frame as the outgoing dogma and its super complaint BUT it just doesnt have that instantaneous snap acceleration even with my crazy light custom wheels... id rather it be rigid and buzzy but accelerate than comfy and sluggish.

    • @WoolyChewbakker
      @WoolyChewbakker 2 місяці тому +1

      Totally agree. It’s a Dogma, not a Domane 😊

  • @harrywalker4922
    @harrywalker4922 2 місяці тому +7

    I always enjoy your videos. Illinois, U.S.

  • @LiquidRengar
    @LiquidRengar 2 місяці тому +1

    Hi David, Will there be a day where you'll test a SEKA Exceed Aero bike? Or maybe the new Seka Spear?

  • @yo5666_
    @yo5666_ 2 місяці тому

    I'd go with sworks sl8. But I really like some myway colors that dogma F has.

  • @deweylim
    @deweylim 2 місяці тому

    Hi David, which bike would you recommend that is fast and comfortable?

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 місяці тому +1

      For max comfort and speed an endurance bike like Enve Fray or Giant Defy is the obvious choice, or the Sika I just reviewed

  • @zhuyufan1186
    @zhuyufan1186 2 місяці тому +21

    My eyes says yes you need it but wallet says no.

    • @mr.z2618
      @mr.z2618 2 місяці тому

      Common is ugly like hell, check this bottom bracket area?!! Paint job is dull, where is Italian soul!! There are plenty of nicer bikes, cheaper and better then this. Canyon, Factor, Giant they all much better looking bikes. I would not take this bike for free…

    • @5891jonathan
      @5891jonathan 2 місяці тому

      I will take a Wiliers over this.

    • @zhuyufan1186
      @zhuyufan1186 2 місяці тому

      @@mr.z2618 On second though, this thing does not look as good (to me) or unique as the model it succeed. It is awkward looking, in the middle of becoming another mainstream aero bike but not there yet.

    • @zhuyufan1186
      @zhuyufan1186 2 місяці тому

      @@5891jonathan The Astana team bike looks gorgeous...

    • @christoph3805
      @christoph3805 2 місяці тому

      I would take it for free😉😅

  • @sootymilly15
    @sootymilly15 2 місяці тому

    Any chance you can review the Merida Reacto range, they seem excellent value but would love to have your opinion.

  • @bigredactionsportsstuff1245
    @bigredactionsportsstuff1245 2 місяці тому +3

    Hot take as a lifelong rider and mechanic: No bike over 8k is worth the hype.

  • @Andy_ATB
    @Andy_ATB 2 місяці тому +2

    The perfect example of why most race bikes are flawed for everyday use on normal crap roads......Like buying a road legal race car for everyday use; too low, too stiff, no sound proofing, etc

  • @georgefouskitakis6697
    @georgefouskitakis6697 2 місяці тому +1

    How does it compare - in terms of stiffness only - with the Cervelo S5 ?

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 місяці тому +1

      I sadly haven't ridden the latest S5. Yet...

  • @ClayterSiebert
    @ClayterSiebert Місяць тому

    kislux You are so well-informed about luxury accessories and bags. You've obviously done your due diligence and the comparison to the US is very informative...because of course, I live in New York. thank you very much.

  • @HeySers
    @HeySers 2 місяці тому

    So more important question cause nobody has 15.000€ für sich a bike:
    New Canyon aeroad cf slx with ultegra and arc 1400 wheels or
    Van rysel rcr pro with ultrgra and swissside wheels?

  • @Earage1117
    @Earage1117 2 місяці тому

    In previous vedio the short trail of large size gives the twitchy handling, how about this time?

  • @seanmccuen6970
    @seanmccuen6970 2 місяці тому +3

    prettiest bikes in the pro peloton.

  • @stefanomancini6569
    @stefanomancini6569 2 місяці тому +3

    What a bike! Beautiful!

  • @adnanmajeed6916
    @adnanmajeed6916 2 місяці тому +1

    To the road bikers out there, what the hell is it with the twiglet arms? Do your muscles melt away when you road cycle? Can’t be healthy.

  • @FT__Bicycling_____-sc7yv
    @FT__Bicycling_____-sc7yv 2 місяці тому +4

    I guess it's their brand identity to make the frameset curvy ... but.. it's so ugly I would have thought they would have evolved to something that looks better by now

  • @abhimawa1
    @abhimawa1 2 місяці тому +5

    Very expensive & eye catching. Perfect for cafe ride. 0 stage win on tdf24, though 🤔 → the maillot jaune is won by a rider riding 220ish-watt bike (not “aero” enough)

    • @christophertan3195
      @christophertan3195 2 місяці тому +3

      I guess aero testing and weight is nothing vs a TDF result 😂

    • @tommyfreckmann6857
      @tommyfreckmann6857 2 місяці тому +1

      You understand windtunnel results with only mannequin legs are nothing similar to real-world wind conditions, and actual rider pushing big numbers...

    • @christophertan3195
      @christophertan3195 2 місяці тому +1

      @@tommyfreckmann6857 Yeah but they use this test on all bikes

  • @alexfotopoulos779
    @alexfotopoulos779 2 місяці тому

    Can you review C68 all road.

  • @markrae7664
    @markrae7664 2 місяці тому

    Great video.

  • @ronetele13
    @ronetele13 2 місяці тому

    50psi in 28mm tires?? How much do you weigh?

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 місяці тому +1

      About 65kg on a good day

  • @alexwipe
    @alexwipe Місяць тому

    Out of interest where are you in the Cotswolds?

  • @DDai-qd8uk
    @DDai-qd8uk 2 місяці тому

    So how doe it climb?

  • @CreativeFishDesignsCharlotte
    @CreativeFishDesignsCharlotte 2 місяці тому +2

    i would get a MOTORCYCLE first or 3

  • @inferno4001
    @inferno4001 Місяць тому

    Anyone owning a dogma is riding fast!!! (ok, in their own mind that is....). That said, the bike demands you to go faster, even if you don't want too. More speed, more fun!!

  • @hudsoneful
    @hudsoneful 2 місяці тому

    The last good dogma was the f12 - i mean it was also the last won to win a GT also

  • @samgiamarelos4524
    @samgiamarelos4524 2 місяці тому +7

    That bottom bracket area is proper ugly,

    • @reinholdachleitner2069
      @reinholdachleitner2069 2 місяці тому +4

      Pinarello Road bikes styling are proper ugly period.🚴‍♂️✌🏻

    • @mr.z2618
      @mr.z2618 2 місяці тому

      Agree , this is ugliest bike ever. Is like Italians push „anatomic” shapes to next level and create frankenstein.

    • @seanmccuen6970
      @seanmccuen6970 2 місяці тому +2

      @@reinholdachleitner2069 get thicker glasses.

    • @SeeYouUpTheRoad
      @SeeYouUpTheRoad 2 місяці тому

      @@reinholdachleitner2069 They definitely are ugly bikes for that or any amount of money!

  • @KeithCollyer
    @KeithCollyer 2 місяці тому

    For me, the answer is an unequivocal no. I'm not a snake-hipped mid-twenties speed freak.

  • @davidnicholson6680
    @davidnicholson6680 2 місяці тому +7

    $15K dedicated aero race bike with a compact crank 😂😂

    • @reinholdachleitner2069
      @reinholdachleitner2069 2 місяці тому +1

      Well spotted 😅,you can buy 3 excellent carbon race bake for the price of this Dogma.

    • @JD7GD7
      @JD7GD7 Місяць тому

      What’s wrong with compact?

  • @EdwardTBurke-pv3qr
    @EdwardTBurke-pv3qr 2 місяці тому

    I’m an old fart and I loose track of what decade it is. I meant 2023, not 2013 !!

  • @richiejames928
    @richiejames928 2 місяці тому +2

    The bottom bracket on these is actually pathetic. 😂😂😂 yeah just keep throwing carbon at it until it’s stiff enough fellas 😂

  • @christopher4100
    @christopher4100 2 місяці тому

    I would like to sell my GT RTS 2 that is all original and in showroom condition. I also have the original brochure, the original owners manual and the original rock shock manual that came with the bike when I brought it in 1996 can you please tell me what a bike like this would be worth I would like to sell it.

  • @louis1904
    @louis1904 2 місяці тому

    Simply the best bike.

  • @MenealGosso
    @MenealGosso Місяць тому

    Combining elegance and luxury kislux

  • @the_luki
    @the_luki 2 місяці тому +4

    Avoid every bike over 6k

  • @paulwoodward8265
    @paulwoodward8265 2 місяці тому +2

    It looks awful climbing out of the saddle

  • @_cpdchua
    @_cpdchua 2 місяці тому

    The head tube is one thing, but the arcing top tube is another. Pinarello lost their amazing designs. It looks too wonky. If we're talking italian bikes with that price range, I'd rather buy the C68.

  • @niklaskristensson2231
    @niklaskristensson2231 2 місяці тому +1

    A ripper! Too stiff & expensive, though.

  • @AwwadSincero
    @AwwadSincero 2 місяці тому

    All dat kislux bags sssssoooooooo gorgeous

  • @bradsanders6954
    @bradsanders6954 2 місяці тому +2

    Sooooo fast. Its a funny thing, a really strong rider can come out and smoke the pack on a 900.00 bike.
    And a wannabe can come out on this Dogma and cant keep up at all. The rider, is whats fast.
    I see 70 year olds who love to spend money riding around on 9 or 10K bikes...................nothing wrong with it. Its a statement bike. Statement being "I have money"
    Marketing makes it all go round.

    • @slowcyclist4324
      @slowcyclist4324 2 місяці тому +4

      Well, let’s be real lol. Having money to throw is way better than being a fast cyclist on a shoestring budget lol.
      Why smoke ppl on the tarmac when you could slap them with a bank account 😂😂

    • @christophertan3195
      @christophertan3195 2 місяці тому

      hahaha stupid comparison

    • @abhimawa1
      @abhimawa1 2 місяці тому

      @@slowcyclist4324 most people I know riding these bikes live from paycheck to paycheck. Those with private bankers usually ride non-fancy bikes (and we have guards for personal reasons). No slapping biz or snobbery, especially on minuscule matters like bicycle.

    • @yukiko_5051
      @yukiko_5051 2 місяці тому

      ​@@abhimawa1Tell that to most old roadies in my city. They're stupidly rich. The only young guys that ride expensive bike are athletes with their sponsored bikes 😂

    • @slowcyclist4324
      @slowcyclist4324 2 місяці тому

      The demographic and choices made by the folks where I live are very different.
      That said, I don’t disagree with some of the things said. Even now I’m starting to think that moving forward, a good ole custom titanium metal frame would be a better choice for my forever bike over constantly changing carbon frames.

  • @rob5521
    @rob5521 2 місяці тому +3

    Always found this brands bikes to be ugly . Bling …….

  • @ekm3820
    @ekm3820 2 місяці тому +5

    Bike looks ugly

  • @garybrown5769
    @garybrown5769 2 місяці тому +1

    Chimney stack ruins a bike, just run a higher stem for the videos , looks are all that matters here
    Also stop grouping your self with us normal folk, you’re an entitled you tuber , be proud of that

  • @boots8683
    @boots8683 2 місяці тому +3

    Made in china with western branding.

  • @reinholdachleitner2069
    @reinholdachleitner2069 2 місяці тому

    This bike does not appeal,you can buy Superior bikes X-Road team elite Di2 105 for $2400 albeit heavier but I'm sure it rides the similar,absolute ridiculous price for this Dogma.Not for me thanks.💯👌🏻✌🏻🚴‍♂️

  • @bobbyenglish7803
    @bobbyenglish7803 2 місяці тому +2

    My wallet is glad I have no interest in buying one of these. To my eyes they are really ugly.

  • @carefulsum
    @carefulsum 2 місяці тому +3

    That's one UGLY bike....

  • @EllyasFelex
    @EllyasFelex 2 місяці тому

    HEY kislux !! I have been watching you for years and im so proud of where you have made it! I love you so much! Also thanks for making my day