India's AMCA Mk-1 going to a 4.5 Gen Aircraft? | हिंदी में

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 кві 2023
  • This is a video on India's AMCA Mk-1 going to a 4.5 Gen Aircraft?
    #IAF #AMCA #DRDO #HAL #defence
    AMCA Renders by: Ankur Singh & Satwik
    Website: thedefencematrix.in/
    Discord Link: / discord
    Instagram Link: / defence_matrix
    Twitter: / defencematrix1
    Music : Art of Silence - by Uniq" is under a Creative Commons license (Creative Commons - International Recognition 4.0 - CC BY 4.0)
    Intro Music : Credit Karl Casey @ White Bat Audio
    *FAIR USE*
    Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research.
    Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
    Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 487

  • @AnilArya51
    @AnilArya51 Рік тому +94

    Interview (If *HAL* was a person)
    Interviewer: What scares you the most HAL?
    *HAL* : *Deadlines!*
    Interviewer: How do you cope with that?
    *HAL* : I miss them! 😂
    Sadly it is bad for all of us : (

    • @wallflower5672
      @wallflower5672 Рік тому +2

      🥲 riyellll

    • @surajbiradar9827
      @surajbiradar9827 Рік тому +2

      😂😂😂

    • @bluesteel1
      @bluesteel1 Рік тому +3

      HAL and DRDO are racing with BSNL for the most useless companies

    • @raviprakash2129
      @raviprakash2129 Рік тому +2

      Not only HAL it includes all organizations and also government budget timely release nahi kata

    • @MINATOYELLOWFLSH2005
      @MINATOYELLOWFLSH2005 Місяць тому

      ​@@bluesteel1irony is that, BSNL was also killed by the GoI decisions. And you are hoping the same for HAL, DROD and their programs.😂

  • @osamify007
    @osamify007 Рік тому +44

    Irony is that Number of Tejas manufactured is less than number of years used to manufacture it....

  • @BB-fb2uh
    @BB-fb2uh Рік тому +82

    Next steps for IAF:
    1. Induct at least 90 more Rafale to fill in the void of multi role aircrafts.
    2.Start the work on 110KN engine which can resolve supercruise issue of AMCA.
    3. Focus on sensor fusion in Tejas MK2, AMCA MK1
    4. As of now need not worry about super manvueverability as we can overcome these by having advanced BVR and WVR missiles integrated on our platforms

    • @kachraseth5798
      @kachraseth5798 Рік тому +2

      👍

    • @saatikaybanbotra5040
      @saatikaybanbotra5040 Рік тому +2

      1 & 2 is not going to happen
      3rd one has already been in cards.

    • @RaveSharrma
      @RaveSharrma Рік тому +6

      These steps are not meant for IAF but the government of India. IAF has already made their requirements clear to the government.

    • @suryakumar3149
      @suryakumar3149 Рік тому

      😊😊😊l😊p😊😅😅😊😊😅😅😅k

    • @ciamodikabaap3980
      @ciamodikabaap3980 Рік тому +1

      Go tell them this to your air force not in comments. No one from military watching this channel, specially the top buffaloes.

  • @Maratha382
    @Maratha382 Рік тому +12

    By that time UK will have built their 6th gen tempest. And we will be stuck with our 4.5 gen AMCA 😂😂😂

    • @blazingguyop
      @blazingguyop Рік тому +4

      Keep crying anti national

    • @Maratha382
      @Maratha382 Рік тому +6

      @@blazingguyop sorry saar. 🙏
      AMCA is the best 8th generation fighter in the world.

    • @shantoshanto9550
      @shantoshanto9550 Рік тому

      ​@@Maratha382 😁😁😁✌️

    • @dark_lordvader
      @dark_lordvader Рік тому +1

      @wãr før pêæçë 🏳️ aren't you the same guy who was asking for proof of f 16 shot down
      Porkistani tumhare project azm toh zammeen me dfn bhi ho chuka hai 5 gen amca 2035 me aane toh wala hai

    • @dark_lordvader
      @dark_lordvader Рік тому +1

      @@shantoshanto9550 another goat fu*ker Abdul hasne se phle ye bata aara kya bhav hai waha project azm toh kbka khtm ho chuka hai

  • @sushantkhisty9466
    @sushantkhisty9466 Рік тому +14

    Launch ho jaye ye hi badi baat hogi.. Generation baad ki baat hain

  • @pranavsharma3361
    @pranavsharma3361 Рік тому +44

    Sir this is to Inform you that
    1 For AMCA MK 1 the engine requirement for AMCA should be 120 KN for super cruise and the can engine be maintained with stealth capability material paint.
    2 The India should sought out the engine with RR and starts working on it.
    3 The canopy should be covered with protective Ultravoilet protected glass cockpit for AMCA.
    4 The CCS should clear 15000 crore amount in next month.
    5 Now India should Acquire Rafael 4.1 generation into its combat fleet, the aircraft should be bought around 130

    • @thenovicegamer007
      @thenovicegamer007 Рік тому

      Wth is 4.1 gen?

    • @royalgaming8751
      @royalgaming8751 Рік тому

      @@thenovicegamer007 it's Rafael 4.1 upgrade version

    • @Name-pq9xn
      @Name-pq9xn Рік тому

      So you are going to purchase everything ?

    • @name-tz9xn
      @name-tz9xn Рік тому

      Super cruise is a good feature but going supersonic frequently add expensive stealth coating paint job to the aircraft.... That's why F 35 fly subsonic ....,this is one of the reasons.

    • @kartiksaroha1397
      @kartiksaroha1397 Рік тому

      Hamko Super cruise bhi chaiye , hamko stealth bhi chaise ex IAF pilot😂

  • @brothergunns5055
    @brothergunns5055 Рік тому +11

    Fast forward to 2035, India will buy Tempest in large numbers, induct 10-15 AMCA aur tabh bhi MRFA chalta rahega aur squadron strength kam hoti rahegi.

    • @boejiden7093
      @boejiden7093 Рік тому +4

      Instead of buying Tempest, why not just join the development?

    • @noneB974
      @noneB974 8 місяців тому +2

      @@boejiden7093especially since UK has invited india multiple times.. they should join it

    • @boejiden7093
      @boejiden7093 8 місяців тому

      @@noneB974 i completely agree with this

  • @mayurm473
    @mayurm473 Рік тому +10

    Lao medal lao , first hai ham

  • @randmht9976
    @randmht9976 Рік тому +15

    WE SHOULD COLLABORATE WITH JAPAN FOR THE NEW GEN JET ENGINE THEY ARE MAKING , THE IHI XF9 .

    • @KPULAK
      @KPULAK Рік тому +1

      Sir, Japan is too collaborating with Britain, Spain and Italy for Tempest program. To make their 5th generation aircraft into 6th generation. Nippon are wanting an edge over PLAAF. Their main reason of collaboration is of new generation heavy thrust producing engines which will be capable of firing high intensity laser to vaporize the targets.

  • @dograkhalsa1098
    @dograkhalsa1098 Рік тому +7

    Baby steps gentlemen baby steps

  • @ankurpandey4479
    @ankurpandey4479 Рік тому +7

    One of Thakur sir point was AMCA will not have sensor fusion. This is wrong even Tejas mark 2 will have complete sensor fusion. Except Super-cruise, super-manuverability. Time line is an issue but it’s a 5th gen platform. Even if AMCA takes first flight in 2029 we will be happy because we would have flown a 5th gen plane from requirements to design to first flight in just 10 years.

  • @rishirajsinghrathore6224
    @rishirajsinghrathore6224 Рік тому +4

    Good Analysis 🎉

  • @BomberFury
    @BomberFury Рік тому +10

    First " Make" then "Brag"

  • @direwolf7491
    @direwolf7491 Рік тому +7

    This means we do need 114 Rafale F4s as airsuperiority fighters. Even AMCA Block 1 won't make the cut. AMCA will be more like F-35 for SEAD missions.

  • @SubayanSenGupta7
    @SubayanSenGupta7 Рік тому +7

    great video

  • @123Suryasis
    @123Suryasis Рік тому +13

    Although it's true that apart from F-22, the other 2 air superiority Stealth aircrafts J-20 and Su-57 lack some characteristics,. the thing is they're already here and J-20 is operational in very big numbers. So, the time in which our AMCA MK1 will fly, at least J-20 will achive the Supercruise capabilities and TVC Control even before that, if you see the pace of Chinese aviation industry. They have the luxury to do so because they understand the requirements of 5th gen fighters and started the program way early. We're already way behind for starting the program and simply can't afford to have a true 5th gen aircraft in two phase of development which would take huge time based on HALs record. I think Indian government should strongly suggest HAL to look for a foreign partner and try to come up with a proper plan to have it in a single iteration with may be a bit more time than the MK1A introduction.
    BTW, SU-57 can Supercruise at low supersonic speed using its current AL41F1 engines. Although the thrust is similar to 117S engine in Su-35, the huge lift and low drag design of Su-57 with no external payload, allows it to Supercruise.

    • @adityakalaac-5022
      @adityakalaac-5022 Рік тому

      If I am not wrong
      Russia is working in SU 75 ?

    • @123Suryasis
      @123Suryasis Рік тому +3

      @@adityakalaac-5022 Not sure. That was more of a show rather than actual project to lure funding from interested countries which failed. Now with their current financial state and hundreds of bans from west, highly unlikely that Russia has progressed much.

    • @adityakalaac-5022
      @adityakalaac-5022 Рік тому

      @@123Suryasis okay thnx for the info
      Actually I am new to these stuffs 😃

  • @arunsharma885
    @arunsharma885 Рік тому +8

    Sarkari Babus has made me loose my interest in Indigenous programms.
    Imagine what IAF and Army go through with this shameless state of affairs.

    • @rahulgandhigandhi4242
      @rahulgandhigandhi4242 Рік тому +2

      Modi hai tu momkin hai saar.

    • @dark_lordvader
      @dark_lordvader Рік тому +1

      @@rahulgandhigandhi4242 or congress ki wajah se aaj marut aircraft successful hai haina lodu
      Harr jagah poltics gusa de bina kidi practical knowledge k

    • @surajbiradar9827
      @surajbiradar9827 Рік тому +1

      Its not just defense.
      Try getting an arms license and you will come to know our bureaucracy is just brown British raj. Liberty, individual freedom, logic and efficiency are alien concept to our babus.

    • @MN-mq3ql
      @MN-mq3ql Рік тому +3

      it's partly IAFs fault too as they change their requirements quite frequently

  • @ajayprajapti6640
    @ajayprajapti6640 Рік тому +7

    Comparing AMCA with f 22& F 35 is far fetched dream. Just having paper drawing doesn't mean anything. If it would take a decade to realize the AMCA no one ever thought about how mature J20 and F35 will be at that time.

    • @harinathan3070
      @harinathan3070 Рік тому

      J20 is another cheap Chinese plastic item..

    • @raghunandanbs2005
      @raghunandanbs2005 6 місяців тому

      @@harinathan3070 haha they aren't that good but still waaaay better than having nothing

  • @debjit00000
    @debjit00000 Рік тому +25

    20 second ka intro ko chota karo bar bar skip karna padta hai. isiye views kam aata hai

    • @DefenceMatrix
      @DefenceMatrix  Рік тому +5

      Not all videos have that, just the defence shots which are rare

    • @abbu_ka_rabbu
      @abbu_ka_rabbu Рік тому +6

      @@DefenceMatrix but i enjoy your intro in every video

    • @loretbiget784
      @loretbiget784 Рік тому +1

      @@DefenceMatrix like the intro

    • @fatmanfrommillennium7369
      @fatmanfrommillennium7369 Рік тому

      ​@@DefenceMatrix He is right , use that 20 sec clip as an outro instead .

    • @altafshaikg835
      @altafshaikg835 Рік тому

      @@DefenceMatrix j20 definitely super cruise karega ws-15 ke aur china is engine ki mass production shuru kardi hai tu kis duniya me hai raksha visheshagya 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @rohitbharti9415
    @rohitbharti9415 Рік тому +8

    114 Rafales or Gripens are must with Tejas MK1a, MK2 and AMCA development in the background.

  • @JaiRudraNath
    @JaiRudraNath Рік тому +11

    The way Technology is progressing, there will be no Airforce people required.. China, Turkey has already built Supersonic drones with 1500 kg payload with 5 hours flying capability at 100K ft .. we are way way behind .. we are chasing a wrong target ..

    • @boejiden7093
      @boejiden7093 Рік тому +3

      Even our non existent future jets will be of today’s standard when the come out 17 years from now. What a joke.

    • @dograkhalsa1098
      @dograkhalsa1098 Рік тому

      @@boejiden7093 aah a clairvoyant,its not everyday that we get to see one of you chaps.

    • @boejiden7093
      @boejiden7093 Рік тому +2

      @@dograkhalsa1098 no just truthful. If AMCA will turn out so great, tell me what sense it makes to induct a 4.5 gen fighter when the rest of the world is inducting 6th gen fighters. It’s a joke is what it is.

  • @off_grid_javelin
    @off_grid_javelin Рік тому +8

    The MAIN thing in my opinion should be minimum RCS and powerfull Avionic capabilities. Last thing I wanna see is Amca mk1 coming in 2035 BUT still without a decent enough internal bay.

  • @HomeTV9999
    @HomeTV9999 Рік тому +4

    Major concern is Istar,refullers,awcas.
    We are way behind

  • @vanithayoganand3013
    @vanithayoganand3013 Рік тому +3

    India should join Japan and UK for 5th gen aircraft

  • @SG003
    @SG003 Рік тому +1

    Good analysis

  • @maverickbeyondlimits9847
    @maverickbeyondlimits9847 Рік тому +8

    I came from future 2030, and I want to tell you
    1. MRFA price negotiation is on going
    2. Tejas mk 2 first flight delayed to 2032
    3. AMCA is still in design phase expected final CDR in next few months, government may approve funds soon
    4.IAF has issued RFI for Medium weight multi role Transport aircraft with AESA radar dome, inflight refilling capability, aircraft must perform as ISTAR and must take load of 25 tones( light tank induction to be start in late 2030)
    5. Navy received its first TEDBF last week and they planned to deploy 3 sqd near china border

    • @mayureshrasam1708
      @mayureshrasam1708 Рік тому +3

      At least Navy is working on its plan properly

    • @raghunandanbs2005
      @raghunandanbs2005 6 місяців тому +1

      Point 2 is wrong since tejas mk 2 has recieved funding so first flight isn't a problem. Orders and testing is another issue.
      Point 5 is damn true , navy isn't fking around.

  • @maheshshah7570
    @maheshshah7570 Рік тому

    Good information video

  • @Be_shant_
    @Be_shant_ Рік тому +1

    Intro Is Lit🔥

  • @bambang303378
    @bambang303378 Рік тому +1

    I love the logic!
    We can not get original TEJAS to work, so lets jump ahead and make the 4,5 generation fighter of TEJAS!

  • @patilrahulr11
    @patilrahulr11 Рік тому +3

    Why AMCA not using F110 engine with higher thrust..as far as turkey using it

  • @parthsna
    @parthsna Рік тому +1

    I think super manoeuvrability is a needless expense, good decision to keep it out. For supercruise too, the applications are too far in between since most of a2a combat happens at subsonic speeds. Supercruise takes less fuel than afterburners but still a lot more fuel than subsonic flight. Focus on sensor fusion, stealth and kinematic performance thats enough.

  • @lightningsword8568
    @lightningsword8568 Рік тому +2

    indian people say that amca projects runs slow compare to turkish tfx.because it will have 6th gen features.now it lacks 5th gen features.wah kay natak hai

  • @userx946
    @userx946 Рік тому +2

    SU-35 being a heavyweight aircraft can super cruise and is super manuverable. The reason being that it has a powerful engine. We also need stronger engines.

  • @sigma-sigma1
    @sigma-sigma1 Рік тому +16

    There is an urgent need for induction of 5th generation fighters by iaf by outright purchase either in the form of f-35 or su-57 or maybe in near future su-75. So that let indigenous amca project , can proceed at its own speed of induction in whenever or whatever form be it be 4.5, 5.00, 5.5 or 5.75 generation form .

    • @prakhargupta1405
      @prakhargupta1405 Рік тому +3

      What's the urgent need , both of your enemies doesn't posses a 5th generation fighter J-20 can be easily out performed by Rafale's so we should induct more Rafale's in V4 configuration because they are reliable and battle tested platform with less maintenance cost .

    • @deeptoxd816
      @deeptoxd816 Рік тому +7

      @@prakhargupta1405 Stealth is an important factor

    • @goofygoofy6098
      @goofygoofy6098 Рік тому +8

      ​@@prakhargupta1405 when you are sandwiched between two hostile enemies, you need to be a step ahead of your enemies.

    • @sigma-sigma1
      @sigma-sigma1 Рік тому +9

      @@prakhargupta1405 rafale is built ground up and designed as an 4th generation
      Aircraft no matter whatever upgradation in technology it will have it's limitations of 4th generation aircraft.
      J-20 has been built as an ground up as an 5th generation aircraft,and has been inducted in quite a good numbers, AS OF NOW j-20 may not be as advanced as f-22 Or f-35 aircrafts or may be lagging behind as compared to f-22 or f-35, BUT THERE IS NO REASON TO BELIEVE CHINA CANNOT OR WILL NOT BE ABLE TO IMPROVE THIER TECHNOLOGY IN THE FUTURE.

    • @sigma-sigma1
      @sigma-sigma1 Рік тому +5

      @@goofygoofy6098 yes spot on

  • @SentinelAerospaceOfficial
    @SentinelAerospaceOfficial Рік тому +2

    AMCA will be 5th gen as it meets the criteria for it.
    1) Stealth
    2) Supercruise
    3) Advanced Avionics
    4) High Manueverability

  • @ramdharisinghdinkar1069
    @ramdharisinghdinkar1069 Рік тому +20

    90 rafale f4 and 36 f35, ye abhi best decision hoga

    • @ManjuDevi-ir5rr
      @ManjuDevi-ir5rr Рік тому +3

      It's approx 30 billion dollar.. Half our defnce budget

    • @ramdharisinghdinkar1069
      @ramdharisinghdinkar1069 Рік тому +2

      @@ManjuDevi-ir5rr but it is very much needed

    • @ManjuDevi-ir5rr
      @ManjuDevi-ir5rr Рік тому

      @@ramdharisinghdinkar1069 yes

    • @debasismohanty1952
      @debasismohanty1952 Рік тому

      ​@@ramdharisinghdinkar1069 no needed at all because pakistan economy totally destroyed and china never going to attack IND because china and IND trade 130 billon dollars per year and usa now strategic partner of india china knows if war happens usa will Fully support IND and no country can beat usa military in a conventional warfares

    • @ramdharisinghdinkar1069
      @ramdharisinghdinkar1069 Рік тому +2

      Petrol ka price 1 rupay badha denge to cover ho jayega

  • @soumyajitsingha9614
    @soumyajitsingha9614 Рік тому +2

    Maybe we should upgrade GE F414 INS6 engine to EPE standards which would be enough to produce 117kn

  • @vishaldeka5298
    @vishaldeka5298 Рік тому +19

    Building an aircraft like the F22 Raptor is not possible for India right now. Besides, the Raptors are extremely expensive to operate and maintain. This is the reason why US invested in the F35. We have to be realistic with our expectations since India has got neither the experience like USA nor money like China.

    • @debasismohanty1952
      @debasismohanty1952 Рік тому +7

      We need to focus more on health and education

    • @prakhargupta1405
      @prakhargupta1405 Рік тому +6

      Ye sab ye log nahi samjhte inko bas sare best weapons chahiye 😂

    • @rahulgandhigandhi4242
      @rahulgandhigandhi4242 Рік тому +3

      Reality of India 😫

    • @debasismohanty1952
      @debasismohanty1952 Рік тому

      @@prakhargupta1405 best weapons rakh ke kya faida da use hi nae karna hey

    • @xipingpongs
      @xipingpongs Рік тому +2

      ​@@rahulgandhigandhi4242 at least we are far better than pappu era 😵😏

  • @erwinrommel9137
    @erwinrommel9137 Рік тому +7

    YF 23 jaisa design ka Amca hota toh better stealth aur manuverability better hota

  • @mayurm473
    @mayurm473 Рік тому +7

    F 35 pehle order kr do , fir aram se baith ke AMCA banate rho 2050 tak

  • @alimughalfoodsecrets3351
    @alimughalfoodsecrets3351 Рік тому

    Amazing facts

  • @gauravdey4163
    @gauravdey4163 Рік тому

    Hal and ADA scientist said in an Interview long back that AMCA mk1 Will be able to supercruise with Minimal payload. With maximum payload it cant. So just like Gripen E AMCA Mk1 can Supercruise but only with limited Payload.

  • @rohitbharti9415
    @rohitbharti9415 Рік тому

    I always believed that there should always be a double pronged approach regarding Foreign inductions and indigenous developments.
    There should always be a gradual process of reducing dependence on Foreign products.

  • @kausalsharma8585
    @kausalsharma8585 Рік тому +2

    Roj in log ka plan chage hota hai meko tho koi news me bharosha nai hai jab ban jayega tab dekhenge

  • @name-tz9xn
    @name-tz9xn Рік тому +1

    Does super cruise depend upon altitude????

  • @RomitDholakia5
    @RomitDholakia5 Рік тому +4

    Again my prediction is coming out to be true. I earlier said that India is trying to build 5th gen but AMCA will only be a 4th gen fighter jet. America poured 10s of billions only after then it was able to develop 5th gen fighters. It took China decades to develop proper stealth and jet engines after stealing blueprints from here and there. It will take India atleast 60 years to develop its own indigenous 5th gen jet due to politics and kunjoosi panti in pouring money in r&d.

    • @RomitDholakia5
      @RomitDholakia5 Рік тому

      @@aritramal5036 tu bata de itna bhi kaun sa bada difference hai 4 aur 4.5 k beech. Aur kuch aisa difference batana jo ki 4th gen fighter ko upgrade kar k nahi mil sakta.

  • @chandrachurniyogi8394
    @chandrachurniyogi8394 Рік тому

    AMCA has to be inducted into the Indian Air Force by 2030 in realistic terms . . . the project has to be expedited inspite of the challenges being faced by HAL & GTRE . . . not to mention the Tejas Mk2B light multi role interdictor strike fighter which has been delayed . . . the SUKHOI Su-57A (Block II) stealth multi role all weather strike fighter incorporates super-maneuverable characteristics of such measure, that makes it even better than the F-22E Raptor (Block 50+) stealth multi role fighter in more ways than one . . .

  • @ayushgarg423
    @ayushgarg423 Рік тому

    This will the major set back for nation , we already are behind in 5 gen and this news India have to wait till mk2 for 5gen describing the condition that IAF will have 5gen after 2035-40. So do we have to consider F-35 , Su-75 now.

  • @kachraseth5798
    @kachraseth5798 Рік тому +2

    Bhai kabhi twitter pe chal rahe topics se kuch alag video banado

  • @HarshGupta-my5pk
    @HarshGupta-my5pk Рік тому +4

    We need 2d or 3d tvc nozzles that can suppresss ir to some extent

    • @samratashoka4538
      @samratashoka4538 Рік тому +2

      Russia is developing 5th gen izdeliye 30 engines with 3d thrust vectoring nozzles.
      But nobody knows when it will be completed.

    • @fatmanfrommillennium7369
      @fatmanfrommillennium7369 Рік тому +1

      ​@@samratashoka4538 Recently they were seen being tested on an su 57

    • @samratashoka4538
      @samratashoka4538 Рік тому +3

      @@fatmanfrommillennium7369 Yeah! They are in the testing phase but they haven't developed completely yet.

  • @pandeyharshit
    @pandeyharshit Рік тому +3

    6 th se 5th se 4.5 aayega tb 3.5 generation ka hoga bs

  • @beingethicalwithlogics3113
    @beingethicalwithlogics3113 Рік тому +1

    Jai Hind 🇮🇳

  • @I_Am_Victor
    @I_Am_Victor Рік тому +4

    It's okay, India is not going into war but the soonest New Gen fighters are in fleet the better. ☝️😎

  • @gauravanand2897
    @gauravanand2897 Рік тому +1

    Situational Awareness 😁😎

  • @RanaKhan-nu5jk
    @RanaKhan-nu5jk Рік тому

    Hahhha lagy raho mona bhai

  • @GoldenArrow297
    @GoldenArrow297 10 місяців тому +1

    Procrastination, delay and failure to meet deadlines is a hallmark of our defence manufacturers. Its sad non of the consequtive governments have paid attention to this serious issue.
    Jai Hind

    • @GDSHSG666
      @GDSHSG666 7 місяців тому

      If it can be solved, it is an issue. If it cannot be solved, we call it an inherent feature.

    • @GoldenArrow297
      @GoldenArrow297 6 місяців тому

      @@GDSHSG666 Offcourse it can be solved with strict governnence. Even great countries like Singapore went through hell until they found a great leader like Lee Kuan Yew.

    • @GDSHSG666
      @GDSHSG666 6 місяців тому

      @@GoldenArrow297 Although Singapore is in Southeast Asia, it is predominantly a Chinese-majority nation. It can essentially be understood as an exclave of East Asia located in the south. It possesses the typical characteristics of an East Asian country, with a society that is highly efficient and well-organized. On the other hand, India's social structure relies heavily on a minority of elites, so comparing the two doesn't make much sense.

  • @praveenbairagi616
    @praveenbairagi616 Рік тому +2

    Sir AMCA me f22 raptor ke engine kyu use nahi krlete❤

  • @prateeksharma6706
    @prateeksharma6706 4 місяці тому

    We should send a private public venture to join European 6th gen fighter program and use that experience to build our own AMCA too

  • @voltgaming2213
    @voltgaming2213 Рік тому

    India is doing good in software engineering domain but India needs to seriously work on hard industries like jet engines and high power car engines to develop the industry with aerospace and materials science advancement and India needs to do it fast

  • @prashanthb6521
    @prashanthb6521 Рік тому +2

    New AL-41 engine can solve this problem !
    Su-35 can super cruise above Mach 1 and is highly maneuverable. Those engines are a bit efficient too compared to Al-31. We should use this engine in our AMCA till we develop our own thigh thrust engines.

    • @123Suryasis
      @123Suryasis Рік тому +1

      Your point is valid but there is a huge problem at least in AMCA design. Let me explain here. If you see all the current operational or semi-operational 5th Gen main air superiority fighters, they are all pretty big. F-22 is bigger than F-15 or Su-30 series, Su-57 is even bigger than that and J-20 is the biggest, almost equal to a Deep strike Fighter-Bomber F-111. The reason behind that is they need to carry reasonable amount of weapons and fuel internally to maintain their stealth charecteristic and the designers have utilize that big size to optimize the design for higher body lift and bigger engines. J-20 was developed around a big AL-31 series engine to make sure when the higher thrust version of their engines are available, they can fit it which they are now doing. AMCA, unlike any of these proven 5th Gen design philosophy, being deveoped as a medium weight fighter like current 4.5th gen Rafale or Eurofighter and that design choice is limiting to actually use bigger engine to it. I personally think that it is a wrong decision because not only it won't allow to accommodate powerful engines but it also will restrict its weapon carrying and internal fuel carrying capacity to perform deep strike and SEAD missions inside enemy territory, a main usage of 5th Gen aircrafts.

  • @relaxingtherapy8045
    @relaxingtherapy8045 Рік тому +3

    AMCA First Flight will be on 2030😂

  • @sanchittandon9196
    @sanchittandon9196 Рік тому +2

    matlab HAL aur 25 saal lega ek 5th gen jet bana ne mei

  • @sanatanihindu3089
    @sanatanihindu3089 Рік тому +6

    In logo se koi umid nhi hai ye kuch na bna payenge

    • @debasismohanty1952
      @debasismohanty1952 Рік тому

      Bina western countries ke help ke fighter jet bana na next to impossible hey

    • @MRBasu-rg9nw
      @MRBasu-rg9nw Рік тому +2

      E log paise deke Scientist Bane isliye 😂

    • @sanatanihindu3089
      @sanatanihindu3089 11 місяців тому

      @@debasismohanty1952 achcha toh turkey or South Korea kese bna Raha hai sidhe bolo na hamare log kaamchor or muftkhor hai

    • @sanatanihindu3089
      @sanatanihindu3089 11 місяців тому

      @@MRBasu-rg9nw pese deke nhi arakshan se scientist bne h

  • @jaskirat816
    @jaskirat816 Рік тому +1

    Bhai I would like to disagree...ge-414 engine ka ek variant gripen me use ho Raha hai...aur wo supercruise karne ke kabil hai...aur to aur,jo variant India ne tyaar karwaya hai,wo 414-ge- ins-6 variant hai,jo general electric ne confirm Kiya hai k 414 engine ka sabse jyada thrust produce karne wala variant hai...ab exact specifications is variant kii to reveal nahi kii gayi hai because of secrecy offcourse...but I think ye variant Jo amca me lagega,wo definately supercruise karne ke kabil hoga...

  • @VijayKumar-mw9js
    @VijayKumar-mw9js 2 місяці тому

    Article was published months ago amca is still in design phase how can some one just say its not a 5th gen aircraft when we are years away from prototype production.

  • @rakeshkryadav5888
    @rakeshkryadav5888 8 місяців тому

    su57 is capable of super-cruize and now it is getting new engine with flat nozzle.
    F35 is also capable of super-cruize and US is thinking of retiring its F22 because of its high maintenance cost.

  • @pahadi-mankhi1992
    @pahadi-mankhi1992 Рік тому +4

    मुझे तो लगता है जब तक amca और तेजस mk2 का जब तक प्रोटोटाइप ना आ जाए तब तक इन पर वीडियो ना। बनाए क्यों की ये इस डिकेट में तो आने रहा मुझे नही लगता और ना ही इंजन का कुछ होने वाला है क्यों की हमारी सरकार को इनके बारे में घंटा कुछ पता नही है

  • @mintdel333
    @mintdel333 Рік тому +2

    Let finish project prototype will confirm don't give Gyan and wait till the prototype come out.

  • @subratsahu9033
    @subratsahu9033 Рік тому +2

    Came across this article a while back and was waiting for your video. At the end of the day we will have to accept the fact that we got independence not so long ago and there are limitations to how much we can evolve within this short span on our own.
    However one thing that was not mentioned in the video is, how HAL and DRDO initially give nod to every demand and then only they realise the feasibility of the project. Maybe the lack of competition is fueling this behaviour.
    Also the projected AMCA capabilities may not be lacking to those of F35 or J20 etc. in present, but we have to accept the fact that their fleet capabilities will grow too by that time. How will India match up to them at that time? Alongside AMCA there should be another new project with a long term vision.

    • @Vajrapani108
      @Vajrapani108 Рік тому +3

      In 20 years it would be a 100 years of independence. In the 40s in terms of industrialisation we were ahead of almost all asian nations save for Japan. The Koreans were in comparison living in mudhuts, had to indure the brutal Japanese who would have made even taimurlane blush. We on the other hand had railway, we had the biggest cities in Asia, we were in the perfect diplomatic position being opposite to communist china meaning both USSR and USA were our potential allies. And you know what we did? We de-industrialised East India and became socialists. We are to blame, not the British in the least. Bengal famine was bad but not bad enough to stall the growth of a nation for half a century. In reality we have only been independent for 30 years, and I'll agree we have made good progress. But whe should have made that in the 70s

  • @kunalsinha2355
    @kunalsinha2355 Рік тому

    Jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @humanbeing5837
    @humanbeing5837 Рік тому +1

    Time Machine banao koi bhai, 2050 main check karna hai ki amca ud raha hai ya nahi 😂

  • @tigeri2336
    @tigeri2336 Рік тому

    Why they are missing most important aspect and that is situational awareness....

  • @TheVyomesh1234
    @TheVyomesh1234 8 місяців тому

    F414 ka latest version 110 kn ka thrust produce karta hai

  • @ushnishdas4596
    @ushnishdas4596 Рік тому +1

    Let it come first

  • @asifahmed3521
    @asifahmed3521 Рік тому +5

    Humlog fund release me hi matha laga rahe ha abhi tak

  • @vanithayoganand3013
    @vanithayoganand3013 Рік тому +1

    Why then media claims as 6th gen

  • @abhinavsharma5274
    @abhinavsharma5274 Рік тому +2

    They are making ground to join Brits Tempest program.

  • @pranavsharma3361
    @pranavsharma3361 Рік тому

    For Indian Navy 56 Rafael Marine 4.1 Aircraft should be bought for Indian navy

  • @pv.sketchandcraft7059
    @pv.sketchandcraft7059 Рік тому

    Now the IAF should be busy a F35 fighter
    Jet

  • @HH-yj3jc
    @HH-yj3jc Рік тому +1

    Super cruise and supermaneuverability are not necessary for 5th gen fighters. I don't understand who wrote that article. He is stuck in the 80's.🤦 Aircraft categorization ki maan Behan aik kar di hai writer nay.

  • @kaustubhtiwariex0486
    @kaustubhtiwariex0486 Рік тому

    Amca mk1 ke initial order q itne kam h???

  • @himanshupandeyofficials8928
    @himanshupandeyofficials8928 5 місяців тому

    India🇮🇳 should join the Britain's🇬🇧 TEMPEST fighter jet program which is a 6th gen fighter jet

  • @soumiksamanta1376
    @soumiksamanta1376 Рік тому

    So is it right to call F35 and su57 5th generation fighters? Or is it right to call them 4.5 gen. Fighter?

  • @Slicer400
    @Slicer400 Рік тому +2

    First flight 2050. I’m sorry but I got 0 fking hope with Hal.

  • @theheretic6739
    @theheretic6739 Рік тому +1

    AMCA Mk1 , can have both super cruise and super maneuver ability if HAL aims for faster service inductions.
    If M88 engine in twin configuration can provide Super Cruise ability to the shape and weight category of Rafale , why won't the GEF414 with similar specifications be able to do the same on the better designed AMCA Mk1 ? AMCA mk1 is definitely more aerodynamic than F/A18 Super Hornet which uses GEF414 in twin configuration but cannot Supercruise .
    Thrust vectoring nozzles had been in development at DRDO ever since 2015 , according to some reports, specifically for the AMCA , if the Mk1 misses it then , its no one's fault but HAL's. With the indigenous TVCs however , supermaneuverability will not be a problem for the AMCA Mk1.
    Eurasian times , the publication, publishes article with Russian and Chinese bias - hence undermining and criticising Indian indigenous development is expected - be it valid or be it exaggerated. Its opinion has not affected the Indian procurement so far.
    F35 and J20 both are underperforming 5th Gen fighter jets and can be equated with a Rafale F3R one to one. But F35 emerges ahead if put in USAF's network linked warfare. Both Rafale and J20 lack that support. IAF do not have enough Rafales to be as effective as USAF F35s.
    What concern me most is the AMCA engine , a 110kn dry thrust engine in twin set up as per IAF demand would have put it in F22's territory ......but GEF414 with its 98kn dry thrust may not power up all the devices alongwith performance on the AMCA.What's worse is that, I hear the indigenous engine which was to be atleast 105Kn dry and 130kn category onnafterburner has been respecced lower for the first version to just around 100kn with afterburner .I suspect non cooperation from international partners in the engine project to co develop a better engine on which India will have authority.
    My opinion of a way around this, ditch foreign co developers , buy the GE F414 TOT which GE is willing to offer if it gets US senate nod and then retune the mechanism for a new engine with 110kn dry thrust , fully indigenous.
    GE F414, which is sold to India, has a dry thrust of 98Kn and 116kn with afterburner - I am sure GTRE has enough experience by now to upgrade that stable core to 110kn dry and 140kn with afterburner . All it needs , is the full TOT on the GE F414.
    The Indian government should start lobbying the US senate for getting GE its approval and ditch efforts to woo Safran and Rolls Royce anymore.

  • @jigneshchouhan8795
    @jigneshchouhan8795 Рік тому

    निश्चित रूप स HAL समय पर डिलीवरी के मामले में एक बड़ी कमी रही है, उस समय 4.5 जीन फाइटर होने का क्या मतलब है, नए फाइटर्स 6 पीढ़ी के प्लेटफॉर्म पर होंगे।.

  • @raghunandan6413
    @raghunandan6413 Рік тому

    Your wrong about distributed apracher system with sensors fusions with network

  • @jaytrivedi7489
    @jaytrivedi7489 Рік тому +4

    We need a 5th gen fighter asap. By 2035 I am pretty sure the world will be using 6th gen. So I think the ideal way is to buy some f35 like 50-70. And speed up the Tejas mk2 rollout. To match the threat from China.
    Too bad even after this much talent in the country we are still lagging behind.

    • @mattdoespushups2350
      @mattdoespushups2350 Рік тому +1

      I agree with you 100% on this i have verified this by watching american defence channels many types of channel. They all said most of the in- development 6th gen fighters have 2034-2040 induction timeline with earliest being 2 6th gen fighters from u.s and later are italy spain 6th gen fighter constrotium. Even china have full fledged 6th gen fighter plan which probably will be launched earlier than u.s even if technical parameters are not met fully .just to show an era of new technology king .

    • @abhilashyadav2274
      @abhilashyadav2274 Рік тому +2

      India bought 36 rafale after starting mmrca on 2004 . 50-70 f 35 on urgent basis seems like a distant dream at best.

  • @sushantmhatre8794
    @sushantmhatre8794 Рік тому +1

    What about internal weapons Bay ?

    • @kachraseth5798
      @kachraseth5798 Рік тому +1

      Bhai aero india me model nahi dekha kya wapones bay ka

  • @Parul-bx5ig
    @Parul-bx5ig Рік тому

    Yeh bhi agr shi timeline pe bn jaye to bhut bdi baat haii..

  • @VinayKumar-db4qz
    @VinayKumar-db4qz Рік тому +1

    I'm fed up of AMCA news.

    • @RCLepcha
      @RCLepcha Рік тому

      Timeline is very slow and also MK1 will be 4.5Gen and there are already 4.5 gen aircrafts in the world in service. Brits have already started with the 6th gen Tempest program and US with 6th gen NGAD

  • @shantoshanto9550
    @shantoshanto9550 Рік тому

    😁😁😁😁😁😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😁😁😁😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣

  • @kundansah6701
    @kundansah6701 Рік тому

    Kuch ho ya na ho, plan jarur kiya ja rha h😂

  • @dadawhooshdragon52
    @dadawhooshdragon52 Рік тому +1

    AMCA is the Greatest Joke of the DRDO

  • @dhananjoybiswas1154
    @dhananjoybiswas1154 Рік тому

    Indian government ko uk ka tempest program pe invest korna chahiye......

  • @Alinstien
    @Alinstien Рік тому

    Chalo Atleast 2045 Tak 4.5 Gen Fighter to bana payenge....baki 5,6, 7 baad me dekha jayega....

  • @ashleysilver5594
    @ashleysilver5594 Рік тому +2

    Before its even come out this eedyt is saying its 4.5 generation. Before the goose has layed an egg theres no point saying if its going to be golden.

    • @DefenceMatrix
      @DefenceMatrix  Рік тому

      Configuration is frozen, nothing will change with prototype

    • @ashleysilver5594
      @ashleysilver5594 Рік тому +3

      @@DefenceMatrix Of course it will. You do not have access to confidential designs how can you tell fool.

  • @user-ji4my8iz7g
    @user-ji4my8iz7g Місяць тому

    Bhai gripen vs tejas la do

  • @Ronit_9977
    @Ronit_9977 Рік тому +7

    But sir, many countries are using F35, south korea is doing taxi trials with KF21, Russia and China are currently operating Su57 and J20 respectively. Even Turkey has shown it's 5th gen fighter but where is AMCA😢😢. HAL is lagging even the delivery of Tejas mk1A which is 4th gen fighter. Can we even expect Tejas mk2 and AMCA on time? This all capabilities are questions for later but where is it right now. 10 years from now means it's induction will start from 2033😢. But funding is also a main issue. May be with increment in size of economy, this all get boosted. Hope for best.
    Jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

    • @rahulgandhigandhi4242
      @rahulgandhigandhi4242 Рік тому +1

      Saar don't worry modi hai tu momkin hai saar.

    • @MRBasu-rg9nw
      @MRBasu-rg9nw Рік тому

      @@rahulgandhigandhi4242 joke of the century .isme modi kia karega ?
      Ki wo Hitler hai 😂

    • @rahulgandhigandhi4242
      @rahulgandhigandhi4242 Рік тому +1

      @@MRBasu-rg9nw saar you want war saar

    • @MRBasu-rg9nw
      @MRBasu-rg9nw Рік тому +2

      @@rahulgandhigandhi4242 saaaaaar I don't want waaaaaaaar saaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar

    • @Ronit_9977
      @Ronit_9977 Рік тому

      @@rahulgandhigandhi4242 Bro it's sir not Saar.

  • @Amansingh-he4nc
    @Amansingh-he4nc Рік тому +1

    I just laughed seeing this, insted of being sad, don't know why...