Premature Eviction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 жов 2024
- The plaintiff says she and her boyfriend rented a two-bedroom apartment from the defendant, which turned out to be a huge mistake. She alleges that as soon as she complained about lead in the apartment, the defendant served them with eviction papers. She’s suing for $10,100 in damages. The defendant says she got several noise complaints about the plaintiff and her unruly kids, so she told them to leave. She claims the plaintiff contacted an attorney after she left about lead. She’s countersuing for what she’s owed.
Case: 31-112
It’s rich that the defendant called the plaintiff an opportunist when you consider what she countersued for.
She might be a hypocrite, but she isn't lying...
Never get an upstairs unit if you have children. Children will be children and it can be a Nuisance for anyone living downstairs 🤷🏻♀️
I was saying the same thing! I was shown a second floor apartment but when they said the first floor would be available in a month, I jumped on that instead. I knew I was coming in with a toddler. A boy at that lol
It depends on where you live because I can hear my downstairs neighbors
I’m moving wherever I can
I agree. Lived with that for ten years. The upstairs neighbors were SO evil and considerate.
How about don't move into a downstairs unit when you know kids live upstairs and you don't like the noise? Some people can't just turn down places because they have kids. Sorry but the kids downstairs make ALOT more noise than my kids do up here.
A shame how the defendant says that she was like a scammer manipulating and squeezing out the money but evidently the landlord was the scammer she was trying to steal the girls money so that makes her a thief. Beware of who you rent from
Usually when someone says anything like this after losing a case, they are projecting their own self and blaming the other party!
Absolutely, bringing up their domestic situation was very condescending
I really hope this young lady finds a nice place for herself and her babies AND I REALLY HOPE SHE STAYS FARAWAY FROM EVIL MEN
Amen!
Don't move on top of me with that noise
@@Sook995 if u r so noise sensitive request the top floor.
How is the man evil?
@@diofiglio1 They're referring to the guy that kicked in her door... Which is the same one that had assault and domestic violence charges against him...
The landlord in this case was greedy. She wanted two security deposits and she wanted an additional thousand.
When she made the statement children should be able to be children, why do I get the feeling that means their able to do whatever and act anyway they want without any guidance or discipline from her? Then the picture of the door frame proves further that the tenants were right in their claims of them being a constant problem. Laughing saying that wasn’t me when the judge read out the boyfriends past convictions. Yeah, he hasn’t done that to you yet but it’s coming if he’s kicking a door in. Loved how JM called her out on her math. Suing for 10,100. Leaves with only 1300. Big difference.
Ha ha that's what i thought. She's a pain, she's just very professional and well spoken about it.
🤦🏽Right! My first thought when she said "all" the neighbors were complaining and that her children have a right to be "children" was girl get your life. Children need boundaries, structure and guidance. We all want kids to run free and have fun but if they're making noise all day everyday that means she has no schedule for them. I love children however when parents fail to provide stable, healthy, structure environments for them they tend to be wild.
Meaning that mom knows nothing about rules and discipline on children, as she was raised with her brothers and sisters the same way. Sad.
@@thebookwasbetter3650 I’ll look
Childrens are allowed to be children means they can play I have said the same statement about my daughter playing as I’m supervising her I’m not gonna shush her every 2 mins because she’s being too loud. She’s just being a kid.
The landlord knew she had 3 young kids...what did she think was going to happen? Smh sounds like she was in a hurry to rent it out and the heck with the other tenants..when they started to complain she could have lost them..so she booted her out..
Yes she knew better than putting babies over someone, their gonna cry, play, run and jump like🦘I mean seriously!! but some people just like kids to be seen and not heard, always quiet I guess.💔😞
@@youmakemelaugh1797 exactly
You can't refuse a someone , as a landlord, because they have kids. She could of sue the landlord for that.
Yea she could've refused to rent to her & faced $10k for discrimination.
I’ve raised a toddler on a 2nd floor apartment and I never once had complaints. It’s called being respectful. She said it was bc the unit wasn’t carpeted, so buy rugs if you don’t want your kids running on the wood floors. It’s not the landlords responsibility to carpet a unit just bc you have kids. I have a feeling the carpet was removed bc it was disgusting and dirty and the plaintiff would’ve used that as ammo in a lawsuit lol yes kids will be kids but you can teach them to be aware of their space, inside voices, walking feet, etc. sure they might be loud here snd there but you as a parent need to redirect them. If she has a downstairs neighbor hitting his ceiling daily bc of her kids then she’s not doing anything to fix the situation. She took 0 accountability and said her kids have the right to be kids. If you don’t want to correct your kids behavior when every neighbor is complaining then clearly there’s a problem and you need to find a house to rent. The neighbors also have the right to enjoy their home without the noise, which is an actual law. Implied Warranty of Quiet Enjoyment means you have the right to live in a space peacefully and free from recurring disruptions or disturbances. So the plaintiff needs to check herself snd be a little more considerate of those around her.
The defendant says the plaintiff was trying to squeeze everything out, when it was the defendant that was doing that.
"My children should be allowed to be children." And other people have the right to a peaceful life so keep your kids under control.
lmao guessing you don't have kids.
@@LOVE_ALL_AROUND No. I've cared for several, some of which had the propensity to behave like that, but they quickly learned that that kind of behavior wasn't tolerated at my house so they shaped up.
@@DonziGT230 walking around isn’t tolerated at your house? You should never be in contact with children
@@MH-yj4qq Nice try troll.
Loool you always know when people don't actually have children of their own. I worked in childcare for years and had simar sentiments. I think differently now I have a child of my own. Looking after kids and having your own child are two different things.
How do you not have the receipt with you? You’re at home right??
Lmao exactly!! She has no receipt bc the door didn’t need replaced and she never purchased a new door. She purchased one piece of the door frame lol
Some plaintiffs are greedy, some just stupid. It’s the stupid greedy ones that are amusing.
Same with stupid greedy landlords!!
Happy Hump Day everyone. Enjoying some chef salad🥗 and wine🍷for our daily fix of TPC. 😁😉
I ordered a sub and thought about a chopped salad for tomorrow or later 😂😂 i have the wine too omggg enjoy your day lol 😎
Dang I want wine but since I’m at work that would be a bad idea lol! Happy to watch TPC with you all!
I want some wine toooooo lol
I was eating lentil soap soup 🍲
Coffee and blunts for breakfast today. ☕ 💨
She says she's an opportunist because she wanted her deposit back,one word slumlord.
right, how are you not an opportunist for keeping her whole security deposit
Right and claiming she replaced the whole door but has no pictures or receipt, but took pics of everything else lmao
As a mother of a 1 year old I understand her and the other tenants. I had to add rugs throughout the apartment and now saving for a home next year so he is able to be a kid in my home. Of course that don’t mean to do what he want because I like nice things and silent also.
Interesting opening. Usually, Judge Milian lets the plaintiff tell their story, but this time she's directing the narrative toward specific unusual claims.
It’s obvious, her boyfriend has a record of domestic violence the neighbors complain about the domestic noise there’s evidence of his anger by breaking the door so yes we knw the story n we knw she not leaving the man
The plaintiff sounds like a nightmare tenant especially with the amount of money she was suing for. What happened to the "lead claim" I wonder? The defendant probably was annoyed with the lawsuit and that's why she bumped up the amount she was suing for. Wish she had the receipt for the damaged door.
Lmao she don’t have the receipt because she didn’t have to replace and buy a whole new door. She had to buy one piece of the door frame lmao. The landlord isn’t any better than the tenant in this case. She tried to scam as well taking over double of the amount she was really out & should have kept. Judge fixed that quick!!
I can't do apartment living I just can't. Loud music, stomping, and mixture of scents.
Those blinds are 9.99 at Family Dollar. They break if you breathe on them. I have replaced about half of the blinds in my apartment with sturdier shutter blinds. If I look at windows around the building, I see a ton of broken blinds in other apartments are they are impossible to have for everyday use.
There like $4 at Home Depot nowhere near $107 lmao she got to pocket extra cash
@@thrillerkas yep!
“My children have the right to be children.” I hate when people use that as a justification for their kids being loud and bothering their neighbors. The fact that they’re kids is not an excuse.
Sounds like you don’t have three children whom are toddlers. You’re telling me that every moment of everyday TODDLERS are going to be sitting down and not playing with their siblings? That absurd. Don’t rent to someone if you don’t want to hear their toddlers playing.
@@samanthalugo7471 They can play and have fun without being obnoxiously loud...and yes, my 3 boys were able to figure out how to do that. It just requires this little thing called parenting.
@@gi70st Your boys never got rowdy then? Overly excited playing with their siblings. No amount of parenting can stop kids from getting to loud at some point. So that is just bullshit.
In Sweden loud children, and even pets, are considered "normal living" and can't be reason for throwing someone out.
@@samanthalugo7471 Yeah, but you can either do nothing about it and make excuses for them -or- have them dial it back a bit and be considerate of others.
So obviously as a mother of toddlers don’t rent an upstairs apartment. Problem solved. Children will run around and play which is normal. Some of you people think children need to be quiet all times of the day and just sit around. SMH.
I had noisy neighbors and I never complain, people need to live their lives.
@@LeolaGlamour heck no I pay rent I don't pay to hear patties from 12pm to 6 am
@@krystingrant6292 🤷🏽♀️ it doesn’t bother me. I only get upset at construction noise.
First time living under someone..... Never again! It sucks 😪😡
With an FHA loan you can use that 2k ish as a down on a home. I paid $3000 down. Renting with a first and last and or dep that you lose, if you can find a home within rent range, please put landlords that charge huge dep out of business.
Said she was an opportunist she admitted to 3 different damages in her statement hello??? The landlord was the opportunist telling lies about the door itself being broken with no proof she fixed it
Know that the judge loves the office as much as I do is so heartwarming ❤️❤️❤️
SAMEEEEEE
I feel the plaintiff handled herself well
Never get a downstairs unit if you have issues with noise… as a matter of fact live in a place where you don’t share walls and floor/ceiling……. I lived upstairs and my downstairs neighbor was mad i had a treamill… 🤦🏾♀️
I am confused because blinds don't cost 107.00 they are less than twenty dollars...
Um, no. Nice blinds are expensive. They don’t have to buy your blinds from Walmart, dear.
@@ct6410 but it makes sense to do that. She's just milking the plaintiff
They are a hassle to put up and have to cut unless you have very standard windows, the process is a pain…no pun intended.
@@ct6410 and yet they break so easily, no point in buying expensive blinds if you are renting a place out
If she says something else about her "children being children" I'm gonna scream. Ma'am if you have loud kids, you a single family house. No one wants to hear that all day
No control over her kids and hooks up with a loser dude.. I don't know why they are in court?
PREACH!!!!!.... I would not want to hear that either.
I didn't really understand this one. Were they evicted or did they break the lease? Is there a law that she should get back double her deposit if it is not returned on time? Confusing.
it sounded like the landlord tried to evict her, she went to tenant/landlord court and ended up leaving after the ruling.. Now she is suing because she didn't get her security deposit back after she moved out and the landlord had a right to withhold some monies just not all the monies.
@@shannonbrice8012 Thanks for the clarification.
Depends what state u live in. Sometimes they do double the monies coming back if it is not returned in a timely matter.
I’m in the process of moving my stuff out bc my landlord complained about my 2 yr old. She knew I had a toddler when I moved in and I suggested I take the bottom unit but she wanted the bottom unit and sent us to the top unit. The 2 units look exactly the same for both floors so it didn’t make sense to me and I had a feeling this would happen bc my daughter was only 1 when we moved in and couldn’t walk very good. If you have kids and are on there top floor ppl will complain even if you don’t think your kids are that bad. I’m not sure what to do exactly.
Take her to court.
Always get the bottom & don't let you kids run wild. They can play but there needs to be structure & discipline.
@@briasworld8 walking around is not the same as running wild.
@@Jahmai203 Every toddler run. They don’t walk around the house all day😂. The Landlord knew still rented the apartment and now want her out. That’s shameful.
Imagine trying to charge 2000 for a door frame. And then calling her tenant a scammer, shame on the landlord
How unfair that the plaintiff is being held financially responsible for a criminal act of another adult, especially when the violence to the property was directed towards her.
Imagine being in a shopping mall parking lot, having a disagreement with someone and that person punches and breaks someone's car window, and then getting the bill because someone else broke the window during a disagreement with you.
Ridiculous!
7:22 That at most is $50.00 worth of damage!
WOW...JM was in a giving mood today...
When the plantiff laughs dismissively that she wasnt the victim of domestic violence from her ex(?), like that excuses his violent tendencies.
men act the way they are rewarded for acting. stop rewarding violent jerks with affection and they'll stop doing it. better to have an ugly prince than a hot abuser.
@@kyoto32001 ❤️ A MAN WITH A GOOD HEART IS MUCH MORE ATTRACTIVE ANY DAY THAN A JERK WHO'S "GOOD LOOKING."
A GREAT SENSE OF HUMOR HELPS TOO ☺️😂🥰
No idiot she’s laughing because the judge assumed it was her
She’s probably been through it before. I honestly understand why she’s laughing because it wasn’t her. I get it because I’ve been there... it’s a nervous laugh like thank God that wasn’t me.. she could’ve even been thinking thank God it wasn’t me again.. you guys are too judge mental and it’s weird..
Unless you're an age restricted complex, the LANDLORD can't refuse to rent to you cause you have children.
240 is a lot to paint one wall! Binds look cheap, 5.00 with tax! LANDLORD took the opportunity to add money, she didn't deserve.
My Son once lived below 3 kids upstairs. The rolling ball popper & riding toys up til 10 pm was over the top. Wood floors didn't help. When you get up at 6 & can't watch a movie, that shit gets old.
the defendant said the plaintiff was nickel and diming her, but the defendant was the one doing that to the plaintiff.
Hubby LOVES The Simpson's, we watch Family Guy, American Dad and Cleveland Show together. Been married 22 yrs, together 23, married at 18 me and 25 him and Humor is definitely a GREAT thing in a relationship
Lol. You married your hubby when you were 1? (I am guessing there is a second number missing) kidding aside, congrats. Humor is so important and I am glad you two are able to share this.
@@MissaPality lol meant married him at 18, thank u I'm gona edit now lol
Nowhere in Philadelphia do those plastic blinds cost $107.00(for 2)! The apartment looks dated & CHILDREN SHOULD BE ABLE TO BE CHILDREN! with respectful discernment and consideration for the neighbors. However, we know when 1 person complains of noise, they "all" complain! Most neighbors are grumpy! You dont pay rent to carry children around the floor to suffice the bottom resident!
I suspect the fighting between the adults had a lot to do with it as well. Three small children and two parents who are fighting to the point things get broken is a lot for neighbours to handle.
Exactly she's lying
So glad this young lady got some of her money back
Imma assume rayquan is caucasian for my personal enjoyment
Rayquan lol. The moment I heard that name I knew this would be ratchet.
Ok Bengy
The fact that they watch the office…. Gold ! ❤️❤️❤️
Someone had to have kicked in that door for that kind of damage to occur!
Just because you have rug rats running around like elephants don't mean my quality of life should be interrupted. Fix the issue.
Then buy a house. Issue fixed.
Those cheap blinds don't even cost 30 dollars
Wait!!!! Did I see the plaintiff not being awarded her FULL judgment bc this judge didn't look up her states current law?! I would be pissed!
No you did not. You saw a judge following the law. That’s why weeeeee went to law school and not yoooooou, because you couldn’t logic your way out of a fucking paper bag. Clear your ears out, get all your remaining brain cells to hold hands, and rewind to the sentence that starts with, “Doesn’t matter for my purposes.” That means it’s irrelevant-the situation is governed by black letter law that is unaffected by whether that accusation is true or not.
@@ct6410 Aren't you a ray of sunshine?
I was confused by that as well. The show has people who do legal research for these cases. It shouldn’t have been an issue for the judge to take a quick break to look at the law the plaintiff was referencing. That’s what she would have to do in a real court.
If someone was being shady she would know the state laws and hammer the defendant but just just threw this case away. I seen a video of a person being awarded 3 times the rent
She needs to get away from this man. Immediately.
Totally agree, my mother and I had to move when a tenant moved above us with five children we have been at our unit for five years without any problems soon as they arrived it was hell! Never again we’re very quiet people and we respect our neighbors. From then on my mother and I always rented the upstairs unit. And we have never had any complaints
Yes, that is a problem. I don't know why people with kids don't understand that living in an apartment/space like you have to respect the others around you.
“Rayquon”. LOL… I knew it as soon as the defendant’s text was read regarding the pistol whipping, etc.
All right I'm gonna tell the true story about what happened when the downstairs neighbors kept banging on the ceiling because our toddlers were walking around - any noise and she'd hit the ceiling of her unit. We tried the best we could but the lady downstairs would immediately bang the ceiling wherever our kids were walking- which was scaring the hell out of our kids.
I had a friend who just got out of prison who was one of the most buff and dangerous looking people you could imagine. I think it's fair to say he was a sociopath.
He was very friendly and charming- a true sociopath. Good looking guy. No remorse. No fear. He beat up cops.
We left the apartment for one weekend and let him have the place along with a couple 12 packs of beer and a simple request:
"Yo, the lady downstairs keeps banging on the ceiling. Do me a favor, whenever she bangs on the ceiling, go down there and ask her if she wants sex or something."
He was thrilled.
She had a very muscular husband and I think she had no fear. Big mistake!
He was happy to oblige. Every time she banged, he went down to ask if she wanted to bang with him.
He kept knocking on her door asking her to make up her mind.
Her husband was useless against this guy. He went down there even when he was there asking if she wanted to "f" or, if not, why was she banging? He was very descriptive with his offers, husband or not.
We never heard anything from that lady after that weekend. They moved out soon after.
He went down there to let her know he was there whenever he came over "in case." He brought condoms to show her, etc.
Yeeeessss! The Office! A favorite of ours too!
This young mother,should have had her documents in order.
Yes,I can see,someone coached her inappropiately.
That is so funny. The Judge and her husband watch South Park a lot for laugh's. LOL
Anyone who has a problem with kids playing and running around IS THE PROBLEM!! Don't rent to a family with kids to a 2nd.floor apartment if you know kids will be loud ! They are kids for God's sake !! Is she really blaming the victim for what her ex.did? Unless she took him back and allowed him there after that?you can get minni blinds for cheap at Walmart
I love her dress when her and her husband are talking!🤗
I woulda titled: "Premature Evacuation"
Exactly, missed opportunity.
Those blinds are between $5-$10 depending on the size at Dollar General. I just bought some..
i loved them already but the fact that the watch the office on repeat….for life!!!😊
Watch who have children with and who you bring around your children. This young lady needs to make better decisions.
As much as the judge brags about knowing construction, she does not know the difference between molding and a door jam. It’s very difficult to replace the jam and not the door. Both get replaced. 😅
Omg. I thought kourtney Kardashian was talking when the defendant started talking
In PA she can't charge twice for that. most POS landlords here will even charge 3x & turn around & just call them different things. Big BIG time scams going on in this state with landlords screwing over tenants.
So we were renters most of my life and my dad who was retired military had several rules for rentals as the father of 4 children. We always got a bottom floor apartment and if that wasn’t possible then he always bought inexpensive large are rugs to cushion the noise. You do what you gotta do to not get evicted.
I quickly glanced at the title and was like "no way" 😳👀... then I read it again lol
Defendant is a clown. The plaintiff admitted to the damages despite the defendant being a greedy scammer. People who wanna “squeeze” what they can don’t own up to damages or admit not understanding paperwork.
They’re TODDLERS y’all they’re just learning how to behave indoors and not make a lot of noise. The 5 year old on the other hand should know better. You can’t be mad because toddlers are loud, it can’t be helped. It doesn’t matter whether they’re on the top floor or not because kids make noise downstairs as well. Not to mention I’ve heard ppl without kids be just as loud as ppl with kids upstairs and downstairs. Also if you really don’t want to hear kids, move into an apartment complex that doesn’t allow them lol.
And where did the lead paint come in.? Was never mentioned
the door is leaning against the wall
Defendant is a lying landlord. Scamming money from the plaintiff.
Very slimy and that fool had the nerve to call the plaintiff an opportunist?
She always cuts her husband off. i dont like that.
If they would have written prematuee evacuation it would of been golden ..hahaga
O oh...rent certificate???
Kira is very lovely ! 😃 - She probably isn't used to hearing the word no.
The plaintiff is so pretty! 😇
8:20 a clear sign of someone in a DV situation. She minimize their interaction. Disagreement. I but if he called asking to get back together she will ask if he needs help moving back in!
Welp, I can tell she let her kids run wild 😶 Make sure you get 1st floor apartments only!!
$240 to paint ONE WALL! hell i panted multiple rooms for less than that
Can’t get over how much she looks like Tinashe and Doja Cat.
Why do people on court shows always say: To be honest?
Random question “PC” crew, but please tell me I’m not the only one who gets excited after the defendant’s intro , you hear the cash register for a counter claim!!?!🤓
4:25 this statement is telling me that shes a mother the will enable bad behavior from her kids, according to the plaintiff her kids will always be victims!
Very sweet lady. I'm glad that all's well that ends well. The landlady was something else.
Hate parents like this. Kids have the right to be kids but do not have the right to be a nuisance. Their right to scream stops where someone else's ears start.
I love the office ❤
The renter knows how to play the system. Nice looking dirt bag
It’s against the law to charge a victim of DV= domestic violence for damages that they suffered on account of their abuser & the judge should have known that. It’s also illegal to evict a DV victim because of damage their perpetrator has done to a residence. The DV victim Needs to file a police report to make sure they are protected from the perpetrator & to keep from being responsible for damages & being evicted
No it's not.
@@briasworld8 , You are Not a lawyer so you are replying out of ignorance of the law
Not all laws are equal e everywhere. And plus the plaintiff said it wasn't her while chuckling.
I have children and my house was always the ones my little cousins wanted to come to! This is the reason I ALWAYS requested a bottom unit! I'm never going to make my kids tip toe in their home! If you want to dictate your neighbors movements maybe you should buy a house!
She laughed saying that it wasn’t her that her boyfriend pistol whipped . But what does she thinks going to happen in her future not going to be laughing
The zoom shows are awful. The latency just kills the flow.
I hope she is not with that man
All of that damage in just 6 months...just imagine what would have been done if she stayed longer! Those blinds alone were horrendous, that is kids being kids? I would have been in serious trouble if I ever did anything like that!!! Watch your kids.
Raekwon ? As in the 👨🍳 ? 🤣💀 he kicked in the 🚪 ?
She got way too much money for those $10 blinds
The plaintiff is so attractive
No way, the judges are The Office fans 🤩
They both seem terrible.
No one with toddlers should be living above someone. So inconsiderate.
No one who can’t handle normal noise from toddlers should be living in an apartment.