I'd tweak a couple things: * Quay puts up a lot of assists, but his solo and TFL numbers look more like a DB than an ILB. I think he's B-tier right now. * Watson is A-tier when healthy, F-tier when injured, which is 50% of the time so it should average to C-tier * Enagbare has actually played more than Wyatt and put up very similar numbers, despite being picked 4 rounds later. I'd move him up to B. * The moment Tom *actually* becomes all-pro, he deserves the S-tier. Right now, he's "only" an A-tier.
I personally put him in more of the B or C tier because of where we drafted him. If he was a 2nd or 3rd round pick it would be different but to spend a first round pick on a middle linebacker you would like a lot more production.
bruv! the enagbare love is CRAZY over quay??? or are just talking value for the pick? tariq is an F Ford is a D Non negotiable i get, if its a when picked thing though
Loving these ranking vids. I generally agree with your assessment, though I would probably have moved Enagbare up a spot. I was also fully expecting you to overrate Toure lmao, so hat's off for putting him in the D tier! I also thought Carpenter was a stinky pick at the time, but I can excuse it with them having so many in the seventh round.
Keep it up with the good content. Wyatt was a beast at Georgia. He could have made a big impact with the team but was held back as a rookie bc there were several veteran DTs competing on contract years. Also with Arod, the Pack were not likely to give a rook DT significant playing time. So last season was like his rookie year. TBH, Wyatt looked dominant at times. Walker also came out of the national champion Georgia roster. He played a Will/Sam role on the team. Nakobe Dean played a smaller, lighter, Mike role in a mostly nickel defense.. Carpenter was like a clone of Dean but that didn't work out. So Walker didn't have enough experience to play Mike as a rookie. Campbell didn't play good as a Mike on running downs. He only played good at the Will backer spot. Joe started to utilize Walker a bit better late last season. Walker will probably make big improvements with McDuffie and Cooper being able to step in at Mike or Will. Wasn't a big fan of the Watson pick. He was a very raw track star. But Watson has been electric on the field when healthy. in Watson's rookie year, Arod was throwing him darts in between zones and he was racking up touchdowns. He looked okay this past year. He still needs to improve on route running. Injuries have been an issue. Doubs was probably the steal of the draft. He played in a weaker conference and nobody knew who he was. He played in an NFL like offense with Carson Strong. Strong was a gunslinger in the Mountain West conference. So Doubs had a lot of experience running routes in a complex passing scheme. You won't find too many receivers from smaller schools who have the ability to be a #1 wideout in the pros. Ford couldn't beat Slaton for the NT spot at Miami. So he probably won't do that with the Pack either. Good draft!
Quay is an S. If you really diagnose his play last year he was basically the one who set the tone on physicality. He was really pounding people into the dirt and was vicious with his hits. Dude will be a superstar.
I like Samori toure and I think he can be a good WR, but our WR room is really good and has a lot of talent so unfortunately I think he will be better off going to a different team who needs a WR.
Nice off-season content. The packers have a great problem to have, not enough ball to go around, who do you see as being the odd man out in the WR room?
No way Rhyan should be above D going based on the last two seasons and not future projections. Runyan struggled mightily most of last season and still outplayed him. Enagbare is probably a C or B player who at least has produced for two years, Rhyan has done as very little and has greatly underperformed for a player taken on day 2.
Quay really cant be an A he has to be a B for now especially for where he was drafted 1st round lb are expected to be elite quay would be a B+ and wyatt would be a B- for me
Devondre Cambell and Ja blame the scheme for the lack of production frm our DFence w mutiple first round picks I believe em but we will see only time will tell
Personally I think "S Tier" is silly and shouldn't exist in these rankings. With that said, there are no true superstar caliber players in this draft IMO. Move everyone down a tier except for Enagbare.
Quay is great. Stuff the PFF grade, what do they know. The measurables are great, he looks great to my eye. Sure he's a bit lost in a Barry scheme at times, everyone is. The stuff Campbell said on Twitter after leaving, amazing. Get him going where he's strong, let him play, he'll be great this year. Might be my favorite player even.
Its worth it to mention that even though he was not drafted by the Packers Bo Melton also was a 2022 draft pick. Great find!
I'd tweak a couple things:
* Quay puts up a lot of assists, but his solo and TFL numbers look more like a DB than an ILB. I think he's B-tier right now.
* Watson is A-tier when healthy, F-tier when injured, which is 50% of the time so it should average to C-tier
* Enagbare has actually played more than Wyatt and put up very similar numbers, despite being picked 4 rounds later. I'd move him up to B.
* The moment Tom *actually* becomes all-pro, he deserves the S-tier. Right now, he's "only" an A-tier.
Enagbare is b tier as a 5th round pick
Quay a b in my opinion
He's only gon get better🥱
It almost put him there, it's just the 177 tackles with only 8.8% missed made me choose A
I personally put him in more of the B or C tier because of where we drafted him. If he was a 2nd or 3rd round pick it would be different but to spend a first round pick on a middle linebacker you would like a lot more production.
Quays a beast you guys are fucked
A below average 1st round linebacker (albeit one with potential) in the A tier is the ultimate homer pick
Packers got over 14 impact players the last 2 drafts. Real chance to have over a dozen pro bowlers drafted by Gutey in a 2 year time span.
I would give Watson a C grade
Good stuff bud!
Grading JJ in C tier is wild!! He’s literally done more than C watt for the team! He deserves to be A tier! B at least!
He has not done more than Watson lol
this is crazy work lol
S: Tom, Walker
A: Doubs, Enagbare
B: Watson, Quay, Wyatt
C: Rhyan, Toure, Ford
D: Carpenter
Not bad but Engabare should be C tier at best.
bruv! the enagbare love is CRAZY
over quay???
or are just talking value for the pick?
tariq is an F
Ford is a D
Non negotiable
i get, if its a when picked thing though
@@trvstrx1774 yes, i'm basing performance relative to draft position.
To be fair Gutie was able to build this team because he traded his predecessor's two HOF picks.
Loving these ranking vids. I generally agree with your assessment, though I would probably have moved Enagbare up a spot. I was also fully expecting you to overrate Toure lmao, so hat's off for putting him in the D tier! I also thought Carpenter was a stinky pick at the time, but I can excuse it with them having so many in the seventh round.
Keep it up with the good content.
Wyatt was a beast at Georgia. He could have made a big impact with the team but was held back as a rookie bc there were several veteran DTs competing on contract years. Also with Arod, the Pack were not likely to give a rook DT significant playing time. So last season was like his rookie year. TBH, Wyatt looked dominant at times.
Walker also came out of the national champion Georgia roster. He played a Will/Sam role on the team. Nakobe Dean played a smaller, lighter, Mike role in a mostly nickel defense.. Carpenter was like a clone of Dean but that didn't work out. So Walker didn't have enough experience to play Mike as a rookie. Campbell didn't play good as a Mike on running downs. He only played good at the Will backer spot. Joe started to utilize Walker a bit better late last season. Walker will probably make big improvements with McDuffie and Cooper being able to step in at Mike or Will.
Wasn't a big fan of the Watson pick. He was a very raw track star. But Watson has been electric on the field when healthy. in Watson's rookie year, Arod was throwing him darts in between zones and he was racking up touchdowns. He looked okay this past year. He still needs to improve on route running. Injuries have been an issue.
Doubs was probably the steal of the draft. He played in a weaker conference and nobody knew who he was. He played in an NFL like offense with Carson Strong. Strong was a gunslinger in the Mountain West conference. So Doubs had a lot of experience running routes in a complex passing scheme. You won't find too many receivers from smaller schools who have the ability to be a #1 wideout in the pros.
Ford couldn't beat Slaton for the NT spot at Miami. So he probably won't do that with the Pack either. Good draft!
We're in the DEEP end of the off-season now boys😂
Yep lmao
Rasheed is an A (7th rd)
Quay is a B
when rasheed lost,
he lost bad.
but like jordan, his last 9 games were special.
Quay is an S. If you really diagnose his play last year he was basically the one who set the tone on physicality. He was really pounding people into the dirt and was vicious with his hits. Dude will be a superstar.
Can’t wait for practice to start man. Only a couple weeks
Do you not take into account of draft position? Because in my opinion JJ and Walker would be higher considering what pick they were taken at
I like Samori toure and I think he can be a good WR, but our WR room is really good and has a lot of talent so unfortunately I think he will be better off going to a different team who needs a WR.
Exactly he never can prove anything if he cant play ever
You should do packers all time tier
Walker A Wyatt B Watson B(for right now because of injuries) Rhyan C Doubs S Tom S Ford F Walker C Enagbare B Toure F
Toure has actually done something when ford hasnt even played i would say D minimum
Nice off-season content. The packers have a great problem to have, not enough ball to go around, who do you see as being the odd man out in the WR room?
No way Rhyan should be above D going based on the last two seasons and not future projections. Runyan struggled mightily most of last season and still outplayed him. Enagbare is probably a C or B player who at least has produced for two years, Rhyan has done as very little and has greatly underperformed for a player taken on day 2.
Thanks Bas
Quay really cant be an A he has to be a B for now especially for where he was drafted 1st round lb are expected to be elite quay would be a B+ and wyatt would be a B- for me
bear suck 👍💯🔥
Toure would probably be more successful on a different team. Too many ahead of him.
Exactly when he got snaps he was open many times they just never gave him the ball or a fair shot so he is overshadowed by that one punt muff😂
Yo first comment?
First reply?
@@GBG.Productions First reply to first reply?
@@balakrishnausa First reply to first reply to first reply?
Devondre Cambell and Ja blame the scheme for the lack of production frm our DFence w mutiple first round picks I believe em but we will see only time will tell
Personally I think "S Tier" is silly and shouldn't exist in these rankings. With that said, there are no true superstar caliber players in this draft IMO. Move everyone down a tier except for Enagbare.
Tom is a superstar
Yo second comment?
Quay is great. Stuff the PFF grade, what do they know. The measurables are great, he looks great to my eye.
Sure he's a bit lost in a Barry scheme at times, everyone is. The stuff Campbell said on Twitter after leaving, amazing. Get him going where he's strong, let him play, he'll be great this year. Might be my favorite player even.