What Happened to the TOP 10 PASSING QBs in NCAA History???

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 161

  • @ScottFisherCFB
    @ScottFisherCFB  Місяць тому +11

    What is a random topic I could cover next?

    • @michaelinhouston9086
      @michaelinhouston9086 Місяць тому +1

      What about top players in the lower NCAA divisions and NAIA - most passing yards, best running backs, etc.

    • @Soundersfan2023
      @Soundersfan2023 Місяць тому

      How about the top 10 quarterbacks in the last 10 years who played for the pac-12 and what happened to their careers afterwards?

    • @DevinHoyt
      @DevinHoyt Місяць тому +1

      Kellen Moore deserves a video, but if you do, ya gotta promise your viewers your gonna do it right, flemlo did it years ago and butchered it.. it was the last flemlo episode I watched. No pressure I'm just one guy

    • @BuzzsawBrent
      @BuzzsawBrent Місяць тому

      Best two way players in college history?😊

    • @ericveneto1593
      @ericveneto1593 Місяць тому

      Top 10 RB/WR

  • @BuccaneerBruce
    @BuccaneerBruce Місяць тому +140

    Mayfield wasn't traded to the Buccaneers. He signed as a free agent.

    • @AmiriteorAmarillo
      @AmiriteorAmarillo Місяць тому +21

      Amazing how few people know the difference. Lol

    • @pmarr98
      @pmarr98 Місяць тому +15

      Also left out a he had good first year in Cleveland and his stint with the rams which really restarted his career

    • @chicodalianis8004
      @chicodalianis8004 Місяць тому +3

      @@pmarr98i don’t even feel like his next two years were that bad, he caught a lot of unnecessary hatred i felt… and i guess i was right!

    • @donnywilliamson5807
      @donnywilliamson5807 Місяць тому

      Ask the people in Cleveland if they would rather have him or the S.A. predator they have now

    • @aidanorsino1
      @aidanorsino1 Місяць тому

      Wow , you had all these players correct and came away with “ not traded , signed “ awesome , such a useful piece of info

  • @zanemosholder5097
    @zanemosholder5097 Місяць тому +34

    Mayfields career started historically, probably one of the best rookie seasons ever

  • @kenyatta3840
    @kenyatta3840 Місяць тому +25

    Interesting to gloss over Baker Mayfield breaking the rookie touchdown pass record and also leading Cleveland to their first playoff appearance in nearly two decades

  • @billcook4768
    @billcook4768 Місяць тому +56

    The quirk is that QBs seen as having NFL star potential generally don’t stay in college long enough to rack up huge numbers.

  • @pryamul
    @pryamul Місяць тому +62

    Players like Gabriel should have an Asterix beside their name. If you are playing in the NCAA for 5+ years, it should have less weight than guys like Keenum who only had 4 years of eligibility.

    • @thedevilsrockstxr2309
      @thedevilsrockstxr2309 Місяць тому

      Bruh no one gives a fuck.....especially bout no case fuck keenum, man ain't been relevant since Minnesota and he will always be known for tht horrible NFCchip

    • @williamstanley5900
      @williamstanley5900 Місяць тому +9

      Keenum had a 5th year. It was just cut short due to injury but I agree.

    • @louispapp7722
      @louispapp7722 29 днів тому

      They should limit how many years they can play. I say no more than 5.

    • @DavidBeserock
      @DavidBeserock 25 днів тому

      Gabriel took over at UCF when McKenzie was injured. He played well next season, but the penchant for head coaches leaving hurt the program. The new coach didn't want Gabriel's style...big mistake. So, he went to Oklahoma.

    • @chuckjacobs3239
      @chuckjacobs3239 24 дні тому

      Case has 6 years in college if I'm not mistaken

  • @DeKayNYAC
    @DeKayNYAC Місяць тому +8

    Moore also spent multiple seasons as the Lions backup QB before Dallas, didn’t just jump straight to the Cowboys

  • @DevinHoyt
    @DevinHoyt Місяць тому +69

    Its sad 4 year star athletes are gonna have there records shattered by players who over stayed there welcome in college football!

    • @johndavis9321
      @johndavis9321 Місяць тому +15

      Agreed it's unfortunate imo all records set by 5 year+ college players should have an asterisk next to them

    • @DevinHoyt
      @DevinHoyt Місяць тому +1

      @johndavis9321 not be eligible for the record would be nice also, but that's opens up a whole new side of problems for the NCAA, and we all know they can't have that lol

    • @12thMandalorian
      @12thMandalorian Місяць тому +2

      Anyone who stays in college beyond their years should be having a computer check

    • @DevinHoyt
      @DevinHoyt Місяць тому +5

      @12thMandalorian stay in college however long you'd like but you get 4 years of sports eligibility and no exceptions, it's a contact sport your gonna get hurt no redshirt. Our sport was lost many years ago, but we can still complain 🍻🤝 lol

    • @12thMandalorian
      @12thMandalorian Місяць тому

      @@DevinHoyt sounds suss to me

  • @AerialEmber
    @AerialEmber 13 днів тому +1

    6:55 "He ended up being born in the town of Brownwood, Texas" lol

  • @chrisd6287
    @chrisd6287 Місяць тому +3

    Graham Harrell is the true legend here. He produced those numbers in 3 years whereas the others on this list did it in 4, 5 and some with 6 years. He had like 400 yds his freshman year mainly in mop up duty situations. I was hyped when he was named OC for WVU with JT Daniels at QB but . . . We all know how well that went 😂

  • @blastermike_sd70ace80
    @blastermike_sd70ace80 Місяць тому +3

    I saw Jones play as a kid in New Mexico. He was a legend. Towered over everybody on the field lol.

    • @soulknife20
      @soulknife20 Місяць тому

      My sister went to high school with him in Artesia

  • @thequintanashow5058
    @thequintanashow5058 Місяць тому +8

    Can Rising gonna break all these records over his 9 year college career …😂😂😂😂

  • @justinsuggs1258
    @justinsuggs1258 Місяць тому +1

    Great video! Really takes you back man.

  • @nikoyochum6974
    @nikoyochum6974 Місяць тому +6

    2:40 completely skipped his career in Detroit, which is why he was able to get signed in Dallas after Scott Linehan went from Detroit to Dallas

  • @PBRstreetgang88
    @PBRstreetgang88 19 днів тому +1

    Andre Ware played for Houston and was drafted 7th overall in 1990.

  • @WannaBeRockStar800
    @WannaBeRockStar800 Місяць тому +2

    I get his time with the browns wasn’t great but he did get them a playoff win, that has got to be worth mentioning.

    • @Arcticroberto9376
      @Arcticroberto9376 14 днів тому

      "Not as good as deshawn "the diddler" Watson" -the browns front office

  • @chaddking
    @chaddking Місяць тому +3

    Scott..how could you leave off Colt Brennan from Hawaii..when he left he was college football's all time passing leader in yardage and touchdowns...!!??

  • @tpgorman15
    @tpgorman15 Місяць тому +12

    Case Keenum made Houston relevant? You ever hear of a gentleman named Andre Ware? Also Timmy Chang took over a complete dumpster fire at Hawaii & had to rebuild the entire roster. They could still make a bowl this year, thus calm down on the idea he’s not gonna make it.

    • @valantheflame0193
      @valantheflame0193 Місяць тому

      @@tpgorman15 Without Keenum they dont go from CUSA to the American a year later, then get the golden ticket to the Big 12.

    • @joelwalberg9802
      @joelwalberg9802 Місяць тому

      Don't forget about Kevin Kolb.

    • @RoyPage1970
      @RoyPage1970 Місяць тому

      Andre Ware 😂😂😂😂​@@joelwalberg9802

    • @sconartist
      @sconartist 27 днів тому

      Didnt Colt Brennan (RIP) come before Timmy Chang? My memory honestly escapes me

    • @valantheflame0193
      @valantheflame0193 27 днів тому

      @sconartist He did at QB, he is talking about Chang coaching Hawaii currently

  • @JamesWittman-x4p
    @JamesWittman-x4p Місяць тому +2

    You should do a video on the top 10 greatest games of all time during the action AKA The Mack games during the week from Monday to Thursday

  • @brandonkolaski4802
    @brandonkolaski4802 Місяць тому +9

    Mayfield had three offers rice wsu and fau

  • @chrisd6287
    @chrisd6287 Місяць тому +6

    The real number to track here is all the NIL money Gabriel has made 😂That young man has done quite well for himself.

  • @vernonhurley1300
    @vernonhurley1300 21 день тому +1

    Give Kellen 10 points and he was undefeated. Three losses by a hair.

  • @ahhculdee
    @ahhculdee Місяць тому +3

    Graham Harrell's coaching career is probably done at a high level.

  • @LoveToRelax
    @LoveToRelax Місяць тому +1

    Great video. Thanks

  • @angelsfancrc1
    @angelsfancrc1 Місяць тому +3

    Genuinely thought Colt Brennan was going to be on this list

    • @WillSlags
      @WillSlags Місяць тому

      Used to be before the 5 year starters

    • @xzqzq
      @xzqzq Місяць тому

      Me also. UH hiring Timmy Chang as head coach over June Jones made no sense.

  • @chrisd6287
    @chrisd6287 Місяць тому

    Great video!

  • @JayBigDadyCy
    @JayBigDadyCy Місяць тому +1

    Do this type of list but with Average Passing yards per game with at least 20 games played.

  • @johnmiller678
    @johnmiller678 Місяць тому

    Great video.

  • @ianlindblom6579
    @ianlindblom6579 23 дні тому

    Case was an absolute monster. Great dude too who always earned his spot. A 2 star option qp outa high-school i watch abalone christian murder us quero gobblers in the AAA quarter finals. I hated that dude for if buuut went to u of h so it was all good. Dude was either drafted in the 7th round or went undrafted but worked his tail off to carve himself out a spot. His mentality is unmatched

  • @Suburban-j1b
    @Suburban-j1b Місяць тому +2

    You should make a video about the fall of ole miss this season

    • @darronwilliams4641
      @darronwilliams4641 Місяць тому

      They never went up to begin with. What have they accomplished?

    • @Suburban-j1b
      @Suburban-j1b Місяць тому

      @@darronwilliams4641 a new year six bowl win and where a favorite for a cfp spot now they might not make it

  • @OutWest-BibleStudy
    @OutWest-BibleStudy Місяць тому +3

    Case never got the chance to stick with a good team. The Texans and Vikings would have been better off if they had kept him.

  • @BurntPenguin8371
    @BurntPenguin8371 Місяць тому +2

    It’s always gonna end up a little weird, because the nasty majority of successful NFL QBs declare after 3 years, since QBs good enough for the NFL generally want to enter the NFL as soon as possible. You have to be not good enough to enter the NFL as a true Junior, but also good enough to rack up a ton of stats.

  • @firehammer7585
    @firehammer7585 Місяць тому +1

    What's with all the hate with 6 years? If you are a true freshman, and play straight on through , you have 4 years. A LOT of quarterbacks have a redshirt year. That makes it 5 years. Now we had this little thing called COVID. The NCAA gave an extra year of eligibility. That gives the quarterbacks (as well as other players) 6 years of eligibility.

    • @williamford9564
      @williamford9564 Місяць тому +2

      6 years? How about EIGHT YEARS? Cam Rising is already at year seven and because he got hurt early this year, he is eligible for a " medical redshirt" and return to Utah next year.

  • @tamudawson
    @tamudawson Місяць тому +1

    Case Keenum didn’t make UH relavent, he’s from a long line of UH QBs that like Texas Tech had gaudy numbers in spread offense

    • @kramalerav
      @kramalerav Місяць тому

      David Klingler being another example.

    • @tamudawson
      @tamudawson Місяць тому

      @ Andre Ware has entered the chat

  • @orlandocolon877
    @orlandocolon877 Місяць тому

    Can you do the top 25 quarterbacks of the 2000s in NCAA

  • @brendonbrown9906
    @brendonbrown9906 Місяць тому

    Last time a CSUA/other mid major conference Quarterback got drafted? I think it would be a great video

  • @Rysofly
    @Rysofly Місяць тому +2

    You might as well go ahead and do rushing, reception yards, ints, and tackles.

  • @venturawoods1314
    @venturawoods1314 Місяць тому +2

    “He ended up being born” 🥴

    • @TheRprecupjr
      @TheRprecupjr Місяць тому +2

      I was like, "What? Was he backpacking through Europe before that?" The overuse of the phrase "ended up" would make an interesting drinking game 😁

  • @jamesporter3761
    @jamesporter3761 Місяць тому

    Playing for 3 different schools is insane

  • @SvdSinner
    @SvdSinner Місяць тому +1

    Multiple great quarterbacks from Texas Tech. TT probably doesn't do so well in a video about great defensive players.

  • @thurmanwilliams7961
    @thurmanwilliams7961 20 днів тому +1

    If you spend over 4 years in college your total records shouldn't count for shit. Of course you are going to have more yards than someone who played for 4 years. That is just math. Go back in time and give Colt Brennan 6 years in college. Nobody would have broken his records.

  • @cjbcoleman
    @cjbcoleman Місяць тому +2

    “He ended up being born.” Oooookkkk?

  • @nwj03a
    @nwj03a Місяць тому +3

    Lots of system dudes in here… lots of them.

  • @valantheflame0193
    @valantheflame0193 Місяць тому +1

    Jumping the gun Gabriel has 8 gsmes left if Oregon makes the natty and is 2k behind Keenum. Less 270 ypg to pass Keenum isnt inconceivable by any means.

  • @dfivash
    @dfivash Місяць тому +5

    Baker Mayfield was offered full ride scholarships. He snubbed them to because he thought they were beneath him.

    • @chrisd6287
      @chrisd6287 Місяць тому

      Yea bc they doubted him first. So he said eff it and went and played for a big time program. I don't blame him one bit. It put him in a better situation and it turned out to be the right decision.

    • @dfivash
      @dfivash Місяць тому +3

      As stated he had offers and declined! Good thing his parents had money.

    • @chrisd6287
      @chrisd6287 Місяць тому +2

      @@dfivash true. Yo you remember the video of Baker running from the cops and he hits the wall?? I dunno why but I just thought of that shit 😂

    • @dfivash
      @dfivash Місяць тому +1

      @@chrisd6287 Remember the Cheesecake Factory escapade?

  • @kpopstan237
    @kpopstan237 Місяць тому

    Should have done it with passing TD's

  • @soulknife20
    @soulknife20 Місяць тому

    As far as I know, Landry went to work for his dad's construction company.

  • @Tht1guy63
    @Tht1guy63 Місяць тому

    Heard graham harrel and was like oh shit you aint got a job atm. Im a purdue grad.

  • @arus64
    @arus64 Місяць тому +1

    What happened to the top 15 all time recruits

    • @13Fridays
      @13Fridays Місяць тому +1

      I wouldn’t mind if he made it a series, took the top 100 guys all-time and did em 10 at a time or something

    • @DevinHoyt
      @DevinHoyt Місяць тому

      Idk what happened to em?

  • @vegasegod
    @vegasegod 6 днів тому

    Greatest collegiate passer, Colt Brennan

  • @thelastjohnwayne
    @thelastjohnwayne Місяць тому

    You should have mentioned that these older QBs only played 11 game seasons and for only 4 years or maybe less

  • @neppy6319
    @neppy6319 23 дні тому

    Mayfield had good years with the Browns Mayfield gave the Browns the first playoffs appearance in like 20 years.. and first playoff victory since 94. His rookie year he broke the record for rookie TD passes. And he didn't play for the first two games. Sorry just a bad description of Baker

  • @juddvance8104
    @juddvance8104 Місяць тому

    Give Utah's Cam Rising about 6 more seasons, and I think he'll surpass Keenum's career totals. >:-)

  • @paoloaccomando4778
    @paoloaccomando4778 17 днів тому

    Ummm....Tyson Bagent holds the record for most TD passes,and is currently the Back up in Chicago.....so....not sure why he isn't on here.

  • @williamford9564
    @williamford9564 Місяць тому

    It is 2024 and outside of North Carolina and Indiana, most people don't even know who Sam Hartman is.

  • @allent1034
    @allent1034 10 днів тому

    Wow, it almost seems that being a college top 10 quarterback dooms you to have a lackluster NFL career.

  • @reallyreal101
    @reallyreal101 Місяць тому

    You can’t say Hartman deserves an asterisk then not say mix and Gabriel doesn’t especially those two need one more then anyone

  • @paullupo756
    @paullupo756 21 день тому

    ESPN should pay back NFL football teams when they go ga ga over these college players. They get drafted in the 1st round and only play for 2 years.

  • @sspaay
    @sspaay 15 днів тому

    Did I hear you just say, "He ended up being born in the town of Brownwood, Texas"? Does anybody "end up" being born? Did you mean "He started out being born in Brownwood, Texas"? Did you rehearse or proofread?

  • @frankleespeaking9519
    @frankleespeaking9519 Місяць тому

    Now that guys can transfer through the portal and NOT sit out a season l think you’ll see more passing record holders.

  • @Taedoc7
    @Taedoc7 Місяць тому

    Problem with college players going to the pros has always been where they go not so much if they were good enough to be there... granted you do you have your bad ones... but these pro teams think everyone will fit their system and expect them to do it in their first or second year..... many systems are not qb friendly!!! Miss the days they would stick a qb behind a vet and let them learn a few years first.

  • @cb750k1974
    @cb750k1974 Місяць тому

    Huh? No Jake Fromm?

  • @mikewilson3413
    @mikewilson3413 Місяць тому

    I almost tackled Kellen Moore a few times.... in pop warner....

  • @Zepi827
    @Zepi827 Місяць тому +2

    Just reading over a slide show

  • @j.bryanmartin6351
    @j.bryanmartin6351 Місяць тому

    Comparing career numbers of guys who played 5 and 6 years with those who played 4 or less is meaningless.

  • @cgh7337
    @cgh7337 Місяць тому

    Ty Detmer did not deserve the Heisman Trophy over Rocket Ismail.

  • @valantheflame0193
    @valantheflame0193 Місяць тому +1

    Why the Hartman slander when Gabriel is also on year 6 and Nix was a full-time starter for 5 years. Both benefitted the same as Hartman with thr extra year.

  • @Hamtown1979
    @Hamtown1979 День тому

    Wonder how many times is appropriate to say insane or nuts when describing someone as successful?

  • @MichaelPressler970
    @MichaelPressler970 Місяць тому +11

    Bo Nix doesn't count!! He was a 15th year senior

    • @jdunc3789
      @jdunc3789 Місяць тому +5

      He played 1 extra year, bro smh😂

    • @DeKayNYAC
      @DeKayNYAC Місяць тому +1

      Had a rock solid college career and went first round still. Cope harder

    • @alfonsecoppola5938
      @alfonsecoppola5938 15 днів тому

      same for gabriel

  • @bobfoster687
    @bobfoster687 22 дні тому

    David Klingler. Andre Ware. U of H.

  • @truthiscensored
    @truthiscensored Місяць тому +1

    I think the QB Yardage stat should stop wherever the receiver catch the ball and the receiver yardage should start wherever they caught the ball.
    A QB can throw the ball 3 yards, but the receiver can run 90 yards and break 5 tackles after the catch and the QB gets credit for those yards, when all he did was throw 3 yards. QB yards are very misleading

    • @TerrebellumGermany
      @TerrebellumGermany 19 днів тому

      That's correct. But over hundreds of passes everything balances out. A factor should be how many games a QB plays. 😉

    • @TheBlueDogMan
      @TheBlueDogMan 17 днів тому

      And takes off of their passing yards, not off rushing totals.

  • @Thrashman-ye4cf
    @Thrashman-ye4cf 21 день тому

    Jeez I guess Graham Harrell just really isn’t great in the post player coaching career, eh? Lol

  • @user-ms4ef8xz9t
    @user-ms4ef8xz9t 13 днів тому

    I've only heard of 2 of these. Keep in mind I am an avid NFL fan. Not a good sign.

  • @HemiHitter
    @HemiHitter Місяць тому

    Was at U of H when Case was QB. It was a fantastic time to be a Cougar fan. Hell I was on Campus eating lunch and Case and is center were sitting right next tom me. Ahhh good times.

    • @kramalerav
      @kramalerav Місяць тому +1

      David Klingler was the nineties version of Case.

  • @jimmartin2548
    @jimmartin2548 Місяць тому +3

    0:42 Are we sure these are actually Baker lol why does his face look so, idk wide eyed n goofy and just all around much less cool in the Tech jerseys

  • @Iam123-i5j
    @Iam123-i5j Місяць тому

    Sam Hartman is a Vogue model disguised as a QB.

  • @DJ_Cub
    @DJ_Cub Місяць тому

    I dated Ty Detmer’s daughter for a bit. Just thought I’d share that lol

  • @MrTtnj67
    @MrTtnj67 13 днів тому

    ? COLT BRENNAN

  • @djmaineycashe
    @djmaineycashe 25 днів тому

    Landry was the worst QB Oklahoma ever had….no accuracy no speed great arm 🎉 mediocre leadership

  • @J_needs_more_golf
    @J_needs_more_golf 13 днів тому

    Smh. Lots of mistakes in this. 😂😂😂

  • @bttmlesspit25
    @bttmlesspit25 Місяць тому +1

    Umm you couldn't be more off even with baker Mayfield. The dude had broke several rookie records and led the Browns to a 7-8-1 record, their best finish since 2007. Not to mentions ending a long playoff drought the browns had.
    Sources and related content

  • @nc2933
    @nc2933 Місяць тому

    Sam Hartmann would make me gay

    • @ernestoaguilar5681
      @ernestoaguilar5681 Місяць тому +1

      Don't kid yourself, you are already.

    • @nc2933
      @nc2933 Місяць тому

      @ernestoaguilar5681 can I have your number?

    • @extragoogleaccount6061
      @extragoogleaccount6061 Місяць тому +2

      What if I wanted to be his woman? That’s not gay, right?