@@Truth1561 I don't know. If I'd been responsible for a baby's death in this horrific way, I think I'd just plead guilty. Maybe her family convinced her not to plead guilty for their sake--so that she'd have a chance (which is exactly what happened) to come back to them. And I don't blame them for that. What a horrible, horrible thing. No happy outcome for anyone.
They unfortunately have to show her and question her about the photographs this was IN ORDER to have the photographs submitted into evidence, otherwise they can’t use them
I cannot fathom having agonizing, raw grief over your deceased loved one (child especially) and having it broadcasted for thousands to see when babies don’t leave themselves in cars. My heart aches for her.
This here is why i always had my young babies kids at a half day preschool i took them then had a half day one on one college young woman babysit after preschool Id pick up toddler st lunch Take to girls apartment Or shed meet at my house
@@lovepet4565 But if you think about it, that was roughly a half day here as well. Morning to lunchtime. I do understand your thoughts of doing that. Smart!
Omg I shed tears watching this momma cry 😢 I hope the person who did this ends up in prison for life! There should never be any excuse to leave a child in a car alone on a hot day! Check your backseats every single time. My little boy is almost 14 and I still check
This is why you cannot trust babysitters, child care providers, daycare workers, etc. No one is going to love and care for your child like YOU would. Not a single person.
I worked as a nanny for many years and I watched so many kids. Even though I did take care of these kids like they were my own children, I would not trust in anyone neither after watching this horrible case.
@claribelmunozguillen3042 Yeah and it's the sad reality that the people they hire now are just not educated enough in child development nor are they stable enough - it's just a job to them. I just watched another case where they hid 25 kids in the basement of a home daycare. A parent called the cops because they showed up to pick their kid up and no one was where they dropped their kid off at...everyone is trying to make more money and cut corners in areas.
They do that in ALL trials. And the victims know ahead of time. But the prosecution NEEDS to let the jury see the devastation it causes. Plus the autopsy photos HAVE to come in so they like for juries to see the deceased in life, not just in death.
Just shows what kind of woman the babysitter truly is for not taking accountability for what happened and at least have spared this mom from reliving this..
So unnecessary to show that poor mother pictures like that. As if she isn’t traumatized enough. She’s so brave she testified so well given the circumstances.
The witness has to positively identify the images as her child and the home in order for them to be shown to the jury. They’re not just doing it to be cruel.
That mothers broken heart will never heal for a long time. So sad she has to do this. How could anyone forget a child for 5hrs? That is inexcusable. RIP beautiful baby. Many prayers to Ariya's family.
Aw why are they doing this? Why put a grieving woman on the stand and show her pictures that traumatize her even more? That’s gut wrenchingly sad to watch.
you have to show evidence properly, this is how it works in every trial. she is there by choice testifying to get justice for her baby. they didn't "put" her there, she could've said no.
As others said, it has to be positively identified by the witness in order to show the jury and have it included in evidence for them to consider during deliberations.
I experience loosing a baby as well, this is so heartbreaking 💔 that’s a pain that will never go away 😢 my deepest condolences 💐 to the parents and family… Rest in Paradise Ariya 🕊️🕊️🕊️
It is shameful forbthe babysitter to put this family through this when she knows she left the baby in the car whether by accident or on purpose😢😢. She is still guilty.
Worked in criminal justice for years. It happens more often than you think. There is not an excuse. Went to a trial where a father left two of his children in the car, and they both passed. He was a single father, was an Uber driver was up all night driving. Also, work an 8 hour shift at another job during the day. He wasn’t a bad father, due to sleep deprivation and exhaustion it was an accident. But because he panicked and got the girls out of the car and placed the babygirl in her crib, and the toddler in her bed and cut on the air conditioning in the house it made matters worst. He was eventually found guilty, because they were his responsibility and if he felt over worked he should had called the mom to pick them up, to get some relief, but he didn’t instead he accidentally left the girls in the car, and went into the house and went to bed, when he woke that’s when it hit him that he forgot that he left them in the car. It was a sad situation. It was cringing watching it during trial on surveillance.
I feel no sympathy whatsoever for the defendant. She is responsible for the death of the little girl. The moment she took on the responsibility to care for her, ‘forgetting’ is not only irrelevant, it’s criminal.
I am so sorry. The grief of losing a child never ends. From one mother to another, my heart breaks for you. From one mother who also lost a child, I understand your pain and I'm so very sorry you're having to go through this. There's nothing like it. Praying for you to have a little peace. What a senseless preventable tragedy.
This attorney needs to be publicly admonished for this insensitive action to a Mother who is deeply hurting! Rhonda Jewell, with all due respect, I think you should take a brief course in proper writing and sentence structure! This caption reads as if a seconder grader or an adult who dropped out of school at the tender age of 7 wrote it.
Why are we at trial. This whole nightmare is clear- baby was left in car and died from the heat. Person driving the car did not take her out of the car. So many broken hearts 💔 😢…devastating.
OMG I'm bawling right along with her. Sweet, sweet Brooke, I'm so sorry for what's happened. I doubt you'll ever see this but I hope you know I'm praying for you. Ariya is at peace baby. Rest in paradise Ariya.🙏👼💔❤🩹
It happens some times in Spain where one parent forget his/her child in the car. Mostly it happens because the baby felt asleep and in many cases pressures of day to day life rakes over.. 😭😭😭. Prayers for the baby and this mum.
I felt that young mothers pain deep in my heart and gut. My deepest condolences to those two parents. Im so sorry. ❤ You dont forget kids in a car. Its not acceptable. Some form of responsibility needs to be dished out to this woman. I dont think she forgot.
Y’all included five minutes of the state seal? LAME. IT COULD HAVE BEEN 5 minutes but y’all are now getting that ad money on her tragedy by rolling past 8:30 in video length
@@melissahughes33it WAS live this is a CLIP they clipped it enough to get the ad money from the video by leaving the state seal part of the trial which WAS live up for half the video
During Alex Murdaugh trial, the photos that were graphic in nature of the bodies were kept from the gallery and Alex. They were only shown to the jury and not displayed on any kind of screen for the general public. The fact that this poor mother had to see the photo of her sweet girl on paper, and then for it to be on a screen for the gallery to view has got to be a form of torture for this poor mother. 😢
Shame on that woman for not pleading guilty and sparing Ariya's family a trial.
Maybe if the prosecution had got the charges right she would have. The jury’s finding is the difference between a possible 15 or 30 years in prison.
@@Truth1561 I don't know. If I'd been responsible for a baby's death in this horrific way, I think I'd just plead guilty. Maybe her family convinced her not to plead guilty for their sake--so that she'd have a chance (which is exactly what happened) to come back to them. And I don't blame them for that. What a horrible, horrible thing. No happy outcome for anyone.
That was completely cruel. 😢
When one momma hurts we all hurt 😢
@@francescagibbons5842 absolutely 😢
Heartbreaking 💔
That’s so true!
Absolutely 😢❤
So true
Omg that poor mother. 😢
Babysitter
@@marysteckler-qk9vx That's baby Ariya's mother on the stand.
@@marysteckler-qk9vx mother
SHE PUTTING HER THROUGH THIS AGAIN BY GOING TO TRIAL. SHE HAS NO DEFENSE FOR HER ACTIONS.
How do you show this to a mom with no warning?
There is warning. They tell them before hand but OBVIOUSLY she’s still going to break down.
Why would they show her. I couldn’t look.
They unfortunately have to show her and question her about the photographs this was IN ORDER to have the photographs submitted into evidence, otherwise they can’t use them
A lot of times they show them the pictures beforehand, but it’s still heartbreaking
No sound
Oh, sweet momma, I am so, so sorry for this. Thinking of you and sending you positive thoughts. ❤❤
I cannot fathom having agonizing, raw grief over your deceased loved one (child especially) and having it broadcasted for thousands to see when babies don’t leave themselves in cars. My heart aches for her.
This here is why i always had my young babies kids at a half day preschool i took them then had a half day one on one college young woman babysit after preschool
Id pick up toddler st lunch
Take to girls apartment
Or shed meet at my house
@@lovepet4565 But if you think about it, that was roughly a half day here as well. Morning to lunchtime. I do understand your thoughts of doing that. Smart!
This is why that woman should have pleaded guilty!
Oh my gosh.. my heart just broke into a million pieces. I am so sorry mama. This is unimaginable.
I can't believe this babysitter is putting this momma through this smh
Prison is scary. It's pretty typical
@@na7845you’d be surprised how many cases end in plea deals. Either the plea was terrible or this woman is a narcissist
She was obviously hoping to avoid significant jail time by going to trial,
Yeah I get that. Sorry I felt horrible and cried for her. Ya know, I have feelings for others. My bad
This poor mother. Her pain is so palpable.
Babysitter is so selfish for not pleading guilty.
Why plead guilty and risk a longer sentence when she could go to trial and hope the jury might sympathize with her?
Going to trial is taking the risk too, she could get longer sentence than the original plea deal…
@@ibike825💯
Poor mom
Poor baby
That babysitter is a beast to make her go through a trial
Not plead
My heart breaks for her. Losing a sweet child so senselessly is heartbreaking
Omg I shed tears watching this momma cry 😢 I hope the person who did this ends up in prison for life! There should never be any excuse to leave a child in a car alone on a hot day! Check your backseats every single time. My little boy is almost 14 and I still check
This is why you cannot trust babysitters, child care providers, daycare workers, etc. No one is going to love and care for your child like YOU would. Not a single person.
I worked as a nanny for many years and I watched so many kids. Even though I did take care of these kids like they were my own children, I would not trust in anyone neither after watching this horrible case.
@claribelmunozguillen3042 Yeah and it's the sad reality that the people they hire now are just not educated enough in child development nor are they stable enough - it's just a job to them. I just watched another case where they hid 25 kids in the basement of a home daycare. A parent called the cops because they showed up to pick their kid up and no one was where they dropped their kid off at...everyone is trying to make more money and cut corners in areas.
Not true. Parents kill their kids every day. It's sick and we are in the end times.
Facts!
@fl_snorkeldork I saw that too. Those women were VERY strange.
It's sick they had her look at the photos
They do that in ALL trials. And the victims know ahead of time. But the prosecution NEEDS to let the jury see the devastation it causes. Plus the autopsy photos HAVE to come in so they like for juries to see the deceased in life, not just in death.
They must have the choice not to look.
That poor mother!!!
My heart breaks for this mother. 💔
Blessings to her and prayers for peace beyond understanding
Amen 🙏😢
Just shows what kind of woman the babysitter truly is for not taking accountability for what happened and at least have spared this mom from reliving this..
That was very classless of the attorney, she didn't even look like she was ready for it.
I’m sure the DA and she reviewed what would be addressed as she testified 🙄. This is her Baby so, of course, her emotions are running high!
You don't understand trials obviously.
You're correct. Usually there a preamble so the witness gets ready. It was unexpected. Even though, I assume it would be hard anyway.
@@surgedeb yeah obviously, I def didn't call the way the YSL trial would go. You were probably part of the free ysl groupies.
My daughter has been gone for almost 5 years, only the other day I saw a picture that totally brought it all back. It never goes away..
So unnecessary to show that poor mother pictures like that. As if she isn’t traumatized enough. She’s so brave she testified so well given the circumstances.
They warn them ahead of time but it’s obviously still very emotional. And the jury NEEDS to see the devastation it causes.
Is this a picture of the baby after she passed?
The witness has to positively identify the images as her child and the home in order for them to be shown to the jury. They’re not just doing it to be cruel.
@@mcal3602 yes, probably on the autopsy table as well which adds to the disturbing nature of the photo. poor mother.. my heart goes out for her
@ thanks for the response. That whole situation is more than I could handle and I hope I’m never put to the test.
Poor mama this is brutal 😖
Why did this woman plead not guilty??? This is so 😞 awful
Weird emoji choice. 😬
@ oops
That mothers broken heart will never heal for a long time. So sad she has to do this. How could anyone forget a child for 5hrs? That is inexcusable. RIP beautiful baby. Many prayers to Ariya's family.
How utterly cruel!! Is this necessary??
Yes, it is. Not sure why so many people watch court proceedings without fully understanding how they work.
@@scribe712no, it’s not necessary if the nanny would have had the decency to have spared the family from going trial.
Aw why are they doing this? Why put a grieving woman on the stand and show her pictures that traumatize her even more? That’s gut wrenchingly sad to watch.
you have to show evidence properly, this is how it works in every trial. she is there by choice testifying to get justice for her baby. they didn't "put" her there, she could've said no.
@@user-fc2xk3uv8yYou don't say no to a subpoena as a key witness. I'm sure she wants justice. Going to court was also not her choice to decline
Why do they always force the victim’s family to look @ those photos, “for the record,” as if they don’t know why they’re there. 😠💔
To move the jury
For the Jury!
As others said, it has to be positively identified by the witness in order to show the jury and have it included in evidence for them to consider during deliberations.
I experience loosing a baby as well, this is so heartbreaking 💔 that’s a pain that will never go away 😢 my deepest condolences 💐 to the parents and family… Rest in Paradise Ariya 🕊️🕊️🕊️
Made me cry just watching her cry 😢
It is shameful forbthe babysitter to put this family through this when she knows she left the baby in the car whether by accident or on purpose😢😢. She is still guilty.
I can’t even imagine! I wish I could hug her while she’s up there 😢
She definitely didn’t see these pictures before. You can’t do this to her!! I feel so sorry for her and shame the prosecutor
What possible excuse could the sitter have for a defense
Worked in criminal justice for years. It happens more often than you think. There is not an excuse. Went to a trial where a father left two of his children in the car, and they both passed. He was a single father, was an Uber driver was up all night driving. Also, work an 8 hour shift at another job during the day. He wasn’t a bad father, due to sleep deprivation and exhaustion it was an accident. But because he panicked and got the girls out of the car and placed the babygirl in her crib, and the toddler in her bed and cut on the air conditioning in the house it made matters worst. He was eventually found guilty, because they were his responsibility and if he felt over worked he should had called the mom to pick them up, to get some relief, but he didn’t instead he accidentally left the girls in the car, and went into the house and went to bed, when he woke that’s when it hit him that he forgot that he left them in the car. It was a sad situation. It was cringing watching it during trial on surveillance.
She probably has PTSD- I never cried - but after my daughter died of cancer all I did was cry if I thought of her. She was my BFF
I am so, so sorry for your loss.
*_May your Daughter rest in eternal peace._* 🕯❤🕯
I’m so feel so bad for this family. Hug your babies & be grateful you still have them.
WThaaaa… how could they do this to her - clearly gave no warning; wrong on so many levels. Prayers for their healing. 🙏❤️🩹🙏
Why would he show her those photos without telling her?!!!! That is ridiculous.
They warn them. She knew she would have to see them.
Oh I felt that to my core. Breaks my heart for her. What case is this? I haven’t heard of it before.
I feel for this mom. How devastating!
These poor parents. Absolutely heartbreaking 💔
My heart breaks for her 💔💔😥😥
Who wrote that headline?! Sheesh.
I don't know what happened, but I am so very sorry for her loss 😢 I can't even imagine
Babysitter left this poor woman’s 10 month old daughter in a car for more than 4 hours😡. LWOP!
I feel no sympathy whatsoever for the defendant. She is responsible for the death of the little girl. The moment she took on the responsibility to care for her, ‘forgetting’ is not only irrelevant, it’s criminal.
Such a sad situation for everyone involved. I feel so sorry.
I wouod like to know what she was doing for 5 hours that she “forgot” about the baby.
I honestly feel ashamed watching this... 💔💔💔 I'm so sorry
I am so sorry. The grief of losing a child never ends. From one mother to another, my heart breaks for you. From one mother who also lost a child, I understand your pain and I'm so very sorry you're having to go through this. There's nothing like it. Praying for you to have a little peace. What a senseless preventable tragedy.
Bless her heart this is heartbreaking 😢😢
Heartbreaking. That could have been presented to her with more thoughtfulness. She should be able to have a victim advocate beside her for support. 😢.
This attorney needs to be publicly admonished for this insensitive action to a Mother who is deeply hurting! Rhonda Jewell, with all due respect, I think you should take a brief course in proper writing and sentence structure! This caption reads as if a seconder grader or an adult who dropped out of school at the tender age of 7 wrote it.
Why are we at trial. This whole nightmare is clear- baby was left in car and died from the heat. Person driving the car did not take her out of the car.
So many broken hearts 💔 😢…devastating.
Why make the mother go thru all that? They know what happened!!
FYI: Nothing to hear or see after the 2:45 mark.
Thank you. 😊
So sad I can't imagine. Prayers for your family
OMG I'm bawling right along with her. Sweet, sweet Brooke, I'm so sorry for what's happened. I doubt you'll ever see this but I hope you know I'm praying for you. Ariya is at peace baby. Rest in paradise Ariya.🙏👼💔❤🩹
I do not think it is right to have this mom have to take the stand ! 😮😮😮
I’m so sorry for your loss. Just heart breaking.
I think the Mom is holding herself together quite well considering…..
The mother or father shouldn't have to go through this 😢
That poor lady how dare you !!!
💔😪💔😪💔😪 I can't even imagine the grief this mother is going through
I can’t imagine, but it’s something you’d never get over.
It happens some times in Spain where one parent forget his/her child in the car. Mostly it happens because the baby felt asleep and in many cases pressures of day to day life rakes over.. 😭😭😭. Prayers for the baby and this mum.
That poor mom!
This is so horrible 😭🙏🏽
That is so terrible 😢
Poor mom my heart goes out to her and family x
Oh heck this is just heartbreaking for poor momma ❤
I felt that young mothers pain deep in my heart and gut.
My deepest condolences to those two parents. Im so sorry. ❤
You dont forget kids in a car. Its not acceptable. Some form of responsibility needs to be dished out to this woman. I dont think she forgot.
Prayers
Poor mother 😢❤
My heart 😩💔
So heartbreaking to see this
What a waste of time
Rest in love beautiful girl
That is cruel.
My heart breaks for this woman looting her precious daughter and such a horrific manner
Heartbreaking for this poor mom having to go through this and seeing photos. Traumatizing her again 💔💔 💜💜
Y’all included five minutes of the state seal? LAME. IT COULD HAVE BEEN 5 minutes but y’all are now getting that ad money on her tragedy by rolling past 8:30 in video length
This is live.
@@melissahughes33this is a video.
@@melissahughes33it WAS live this is a CLIP they clipped it enough to get the ad money from the video by leaving the state seal part of the trial which WAS live up for half the video
My hearts breaks in a million pieces for mom.
Prayers for this Mother and family..🙏💗🙏
So sorry for this mom and family 💔🙏
Where's the compassion for the mother here....
Shame on the court system for inflicting more heartache and emotional trauma...
Was that completely necessary? How heartless to do that to a grieving mother. A traversty.
During Alex Murdaugh trial, the photos that were graphic in nature of the bodies were kept from the gallery and Alex. They were only shown to the jury and not displayed on any kind of screen for the general public. The fact that this poor mother had to see the photo of her sweet girl on paper, and then for it to be on a screen for the gallery to view has got to be a form of torture for this poor mother. 😢
She loved her baby to the moon and back again.
So sorry for your loss loss
Sad
HEARTBREAKING 💔
Why would they show her that..absolutely cruel..
Poor mama, I’m so sorry beautiful 💔💔💔💕💕💕
This is why I can’t leave my baby with anyone 😢💔🙏🏼 I can’t even imagine this loss as a mother
Where is this at
What's the reason for even showing her the pictures ..
Poor woman
Precious gorgeous baby omg poor mama I praying
Well, that brought tears to my eyes.
I can’t even imagine. This wasn’t even my baby and I’m about to cry too. 😢