Great reaction again and yet another young rock band and the fact that they are family is even better I liked this cover very much your right her voice is made for rock for sure. as always your ride or die forever Eyy Ooooo
As always young lady you bring a little light into an ever seemingly dark world. Once again you have brought a smile to this weathered face.😊 May you be safe this day as well as you and your family be blessed
They do several Dio covers that are LEGIT. I wanted to hate these kids when I first saw that they had covered Holy Diver, but…. Very Respectable. I judged a book by its cover, and I couldn’t have been more wrong. 🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️ Respect.
Winner winner rock and roll dinner . Yes they are young here but you can find videos of them on and around the Santa Monica pier honing their craft drawing large crowds . She has a variety screams including a Banshee , a Siren , and an outstanding Whistle register . You will find much more information in the comments below . Roll with them and we will roll with you .
Thanks for reacting to this band. They are incredibly talented. Please do more on them, especially originals like Sail Away, Dear Father or Not Afraid.
Great reaction Melody is my favorite vocalist on Planet. They have just Finished there live Tour at yhe Unity Festival in Manipur India.That reaction you gave was phenomenal everytime someone Sees them first time they have the same reaction..
You said it at the beginning, 11M views. They are incredible (been following them since their days playing the Santa Monica pier). And your face when Melody starts singing is priceless.
Nice reaction. Just caught you on my cue. Thanks to Clinton to recommend this. As you pointed out, this is younger Liliac. That age sounds right. MeloDia is 20 now. Will turn 21 in December. You got the name correct the first time. It means bat in Romanian. They busked at an early age on the Santa Monica pier learning. Like the pier, they do covers and originals. I think the Fangs recommended some songs. Just look at Justin to see how young he looks if it's early. He just turned 15. Loved your energy. Hope to see more Liliac. (I support 3 bands now all different genres) till next time. Peace. Stay safe. God Speed. FANG 4 LIFE! RORH 🤘 🦇
I really wish you had started with one of their Originals. This Cover is about 4-5 years old. Mars (Live in Cumming GA), Dear Father, We are the Children, Not Afraid (Extended Version), Sail Away, etc. They are Romanian/American, 100% Independent by choice. Currently Aged 15-23. 3 USA Tours and just did a show in India.
Yeah, I sense a theme with her doing The Warning's old cover of this yesterday. In both cases I wish she started with something original and recent. Maybe she'll follow up with more reactions to both.
I started with this because it's where I started but she's doing Not Afraid next but you can buy her a coffee and she will do whatever reaction you want lol.
@@clintonshepard6107 Nice to know but I'm flat broke. It's great that she's doing Not Afraid (Extended Version) next though. That way she can get a taste of Melody's range and how talented they actually are. As great as their Covers are I don't think it truly shows their skill as well as their Originals.
@@jonathanwatson5818 I remember the first time I heard her sing this and I think she had the same reaction I did, I know you have paid for reactions also and I always appreciate it. I just want to help them any way I can and I just felt I was getting criticized for my choice. But any way I hope you have a great day.
@@clintonshepard6107 I don't pay for Reactions and I wasn't criticizing your choice. I appreciate the donations you make to help get Liliac's name out there and whether Cover or Original I know you can't go wrong with them. Cheers Clint.
Treat yourself go see these guys live...They are humble and polite at the meet and greet..Then showtime..They'll blow you away...110% energy. Melody's voice is even better live
Woot! Another reactor finding Liliac for the first time. Great reaction. Yes. They are nutso amazing. Classic rock voice.. oh yeah, and this is an older one. You should check their cover of Janice Joplin's "piece of my heart" from Cummings, GA live. Also Covered Joan Jett's "I hate myself for loving you". They're great recorded and better live. Another piece from Cummings is "Mars" an original. Must listen. Dig in and enjoy. They started out in CA on the Santa Monica Pier. Dad's a Music producer and originally from Transylvania, thus the band name 'liliac' or 'bat'.
Liliac is a great band whose does great covers and they also have many song that they made that are good as well.RORH!! We need more of this band on this channel.
Subscribed... GREAT reaction!... been following Liliac since their beginning... looking forward to many more reactions from Liliac... you'll be amazed at how far they've come... 🦇🤘RORH🤘🦇
Rosalie, My favorite covers by them are Ronnie James Dio songs. But before you check out the Liliac covers you really need to check out a couple of songs from Dio. In my opinion he was the greatest male metal singer ever. Maybe start with Stargazer from the band Rainbow or Holy Diver from Dio's own band. Thank you and keep up the great reactions.
This band is amazing and I'm almost crying in how good they they are. The lead singer voice has personality and rasp sound. They could stand on their own if they find the right written songs made for them. I hope in the future they could sing their own songs along with holy diver, enter sandman and more. I love their sound and is really good.
Great reaction and I saw your reaction to The Warning as well where you also did a great job. Both are really, really talented family bands and I love both of them. Hard core fans of both seem to think that they have to choose one over the other for some reason and at times make remarks that do not credit them or either of these wonderful groups. Though both groups have done amazing covers, they are at their best in my opinion with their originals. I love the fact that Liliac has made some changes in their style as far as fashion but also as far as their musical direction. They continue to do the old music but also have taken on some music that many would consider out of their sandbox. Some of the fans have expressed disappointment, but I say, good for them. They are still an amazing group and I wish nothing but the best for LIliac and The Warning. Nothing like a little healthy competition...Sort of like The Beatles, The Beach Boys and The Stones from back in my earlier days...I think I may be just telling my age there!
Hy my friend Jim. Some of you said was right but some didn’t made any sense. Family bands yes, but comparing Liliac to the Warning, it’s just like compared the Beatles to all the others. Especially painful was comparing the Fab Four to The Beach Boys. These surfer boys tried so hard, that the Wilson guy got crazy when the Beatles released Sgt Peppers before they released their disastrous LP “ animal sounds “ and the last song was on the Beatles record “ Good morning “ full with all kind of animal sounds. The Beach Boys were noticed only in the US, but the Stones and the Beatles were known world wide. Back to the youths of today, I’m not arguing about which band is better or worst than the other, both are made of family members, but one thing is the deciding factor for me, it’s the numbers of those members. Liliac have five members, and all of them are masters of their instruments. But their version is just a copy of the original, played masterfully. And the Warnings version just like they reinvented the song turned upside down and inside out in just seven days, and earned to be the first song on that Black anniversary album. With just a tiny budget they have or had that time, they played,edited,and made a video of it. And here coms the comparison in place. Many bands were invited to do that song, and this three girls blown away any other bands version. Back to old times again, the Beatles didn’t competed against anybody, better say, they didn’t needed to compete to anyone, but them self. The Stones played a totally different stile, with different lyrics and playing their instruments like craftsman’s. But the Beatles wrote and played on a different level than anybody else, and the only danger they had was the Searchers and the Hollies. And the Warning is running on the same train as they were running. No competitions in sight! Three member bands are a penny for a dozens, but not them! And their age can be a deciding factor, the youngest is not even 18 yet, and the oldest is younger than any of the Beatles was when they started to play. Got my view about them? Releasing an album when the oldest was just 16 yrs old written by a 13 yrs old genius Paulina it’s unheard yet. Ok it’s not unheard because the Jackson’s did it even younger, but to know the circumstances about them, I just feel sorry of them. And all things put together, the Warning is not just a meteorite, shining for a short time only. They are here to stay for a long time, which we can’t say about the Fab Four. And Liliac? Sooner or later they gonna have their differences because of male female differences or misunderstandings. It could happen to the Warning to, unexpected love affairs which in my mind is the only reason they can have a real fight. But as one Audio engineer said about them ( the family is the most important thing for them. ) so my friend, good that at least we have a choice, which according to one sentence of PAU in the song “ error “ It’s killing the mind, we all can have our favored artists or bands, and being old like dirt at least we seen and heard some of the great ones!!!!
@@bubamaranovichok4901 Well, Opinions are just that...Opinions. While mine might be different than yours, it doesn't make either more valid or less important...at least in our own minds. You have a good day!
@@bubamaranovichok4901I'm not here to start an argument or argue if one band is better than the other as I like them both. Just here to spit some facts. Liliac- Enter Sandman actually isn't a copy of the Original, they added pinch harmonics, keys, and a child prayer to it with an actual child, they just didn't flip it completely like The Warning did. Alessia Cara was actually the one invited to do the song (Not The Warning) but Cara didn't know what to do and was on same label and obviously the label knew TW did Enter Sandman earlier so Cara asked them to help her. As far as the no competitions in sight comment (Liliac actually has more YT Subs and Views) Maybe, Liliac will have their fights or differences and maybe they won't (so far they get along greatly with each other), you can say the exact same thing about The Warning, there's no guarantee either of them will be a long time staple despite their ages, Liliac has 2 members younger than The Warning's youngest. I would just enjoy it while it lasts and root for both to succeed.
@@bubamaranovichok4901 Also just in case you didn't know. UA-cam: The Warning, 475K Subs, Joined Feb 11, 2007, 98,957,973 Views. UA-cam: Liliac, 487K Subs, Joined Sep 12, 2012, 109,116,234 Views.
Hi Rosalie! Great reaction. This is the 1st song by Liliac I heard as well. What got me was Melody's voice! It is so unique that you could hear a song she does and know it's her. New sub here!
Melody is a welcome breath for metal vocals. They all play multiple instruments. The middle son now mostly plays bass, and the youngest, on keys, is also learning guitar and bass. Need to hear her do Dio.
Happy Wednesday, Rosalie!! ✨💗🤗 Hope you're doing really well! Thank you so much for bringing so many bands and performers to all of our attention! It's so fun and informative to see the varied music and creativity your channel brings to light! And, as always, your excitement and positive love of the quality in performance is soooo contagious! Thank you so much for this reaction (and all the others you do so frequently too!). Love your channel, my friend! And thanks to all the subscribers and supporters that pass along their requests to you as well! The whole community on your channel rocks!! (no pun intended - haha) Liliac did a great job on this! Totally head banging! Peace and rock on!! xo 🤗🥰✨
hahah brilliant "not-pun" :D Hi Avila!! thank you so much for your kind comment. You're a light here! seriously! peace and blessings. rock on!! See you on the next one. :)
Great reaction,, please keep going down the Liliac rabbit hole and I'll follow along, you will love their covers, but their originals are amazing, "We are the children" and their ballad "Sail away" please do
I get so much joy from people discovering the sheer amount of talent that exists in the metal scene. It is so much fun watching people mind slowly melting. Think back one year ago and assesbyour attitude and thoughts about metal and I am sure you will smile too.
@@greywuuf LOL. Well now that makes a lot more sense. I totally get it now. In that case, VERY well done. You get 3 hand claps, one for each of Biden's IQ points. 👏👏👏
Every member of this band is terrific, all at world class level now. Obviously the older three stand out but as the younger ones grow up they'll show us more. I doubt any better family band has ever existed.
World class is a bit of a stretch. The vocalist is world class, the rest are just pretty good. Best family band ever? There are many great family bands that have certainly achieved far more than they have. They have potential for sure but I would say that they have a ways to go before I would put them in the same league as even Greta, much less the Bee Gees, Jackson 5, Sly and the Family Stone, INXS or Andrew Sisters. I could name many many more.
@@roy19491 Weak argument bro. Its like suggesting I can't have an opinion on a pro football player because I am not a pro football player. I stand by my comment. Never said they were bad, but the best ever?..... come'on man.
Great band and this gives you a look at the past as they were working on their technique. They are awesome in concert and now mix covers and originals. And since they've had 5 or 6 years of playing and touring, they are much improved from this. Check out more - especially originals "Sail Away", "Not Afraid" and "Mars". Melody's voice has improved and she just concentrates on vocals now. Ethan switched to bass so she can just be the kickass frontwoman that she is. She is inspired by Ronnie James Dio and theer cover of "Holy Diver" is on point. Check out more; you won't be disappointed.
You should definitely check out more from Liliac. Dios The Last In Line is amazing and their original stuff rocks! Sail Away ( a beautiful rock Ballad ) Nothing, Mystery, Dear Father and a lot more. Liliac has become my favorite all time...yes they're that good!
Rosalie thank you for your reaction to my favorite band. I am a 59 year old retired musician and I just love these kids. You have just scratched the surface with this video. You did however choose a great place to start as this particular video has garnered the most attention by viewers. I hope you continue looking into these kids and the journey they have been through. It is a fascinating story and the music is just phenomenal. I am a new subscriber in hopes that you react to more Liliac songs. You will not be disappointed. Peace and be well. KMM
@@rosalieelliottofficial and you as well. I've been on this ride for a couple years now and I am anxious for the new album coming soon. Enjoy !!! Rock on and Rock hard !!!
So, after The Warning and Liliac, you should check also Motion Device and GFM. After watching covers, move on to originals of all these bands. Just to start with (all official videos): The Warning: Evolve Liliac: Chain of thorns Motion Device (their name now is Quarter to three): Thick Skin GFM: Give me a sign Spinning Jenny: Hey Jenny Enjoy the new generation of hard rock and metal!
yes ! they are great ! I discover this band 2 years ago and I love them ! They did great covers: le last one "Seven nation army" is awesome , "close your eyes". Melodie is a big fan of Dio so try "last in line", "rainbow in the dark", "holy diver", ... They did their own music too: "Mars" (live is great), "we are children", "dear father", "sail away", .... Have a nice trip with this band.
Welcome to the world of Vamp metal. You havent heard anything yet. Pick any song. Cover to original. All are AWESOME!. Looking forward to more reactions
You have discovered the future mega band Liliac ,do yourself and your subscribers a favour and check out their playlist it starts when Melody was13 she's now 20 with a tribute cover of WILD THING through to day with their latest release NOT AFRAID one of their many original songs that will blow you away, the three oldest siblings have been performing this well since. Melody was 11and did impromptu performances before that , all can be found on their channel . They have just finished their third tour of America and are currently performing at a rock music festival India .they have featured on two KISS cruises adaetwo tribute cover albums and two original albums FANG4LIFE RORH
Melody was nicknamed Melodia by Dio guitarist and Ronnie James Dio's widow, based on their covers of Dio songs, asked them to perform at a Dio tribute concert
Their latest video (Oct 2022) is "Not Afraid" Extended version which was filmed at various concerts they did this last summer. It is an original song of theirs. Plus they have cut their hair since this video. They are going to do a live-on-line concert in December and they are working on their 3rd album that will be released soon. They also did a "Seven Nation Army" remake earlier this year. Wait until you hear Melody's screams on these videos!
WOW! So, for just a moment, forget that they are all family, and that they are all women, and that they are so young. Forget the visuals (video). Just listen. Without knowing ANY of that other 'stuff,' I would say this was an excellent performance. When you factor in all that other 'stuff,' it goes from excellent to mind-blowing. This is the most I have been impressed by a new (to me) group in a LONG time! Did I say WOW??
Amen to your comment on her bass skills. There's a part she does on bass during Sam's guitar solo on Chain of Thorns, and if you listen with ear buds, it's such a cool riff.
I recommend the following songs: Liliac - Dear Father [Official Music Video] ua-cam.com/video/ymQXDJzuHvg/v-deo.html Liliac - Not Afraid (Official Music Video) [Extended Version] ua-cam.com/video/1o4wfK9zlE0/v-deo.html LILIAC - MARS (Original) (Live in Cumming, GA 2019) ua-cam.com/video/CRrqHZNMUko/v-deo.html Holy Diver - Liliac (Official Cover Music Video) ua-cam.com/video/wPfNs_N9nE4/v-deo.html The Last in Line - Liliac (Dio Cancer Fund Tribute) ua-cam.com/video/xxQwjA0amKA/v-deo.html Seven Nation Army - Liliac (Official Cover Music Video) ua-cam.com/video/sLyibJ5btIQ/v-deo.html
Best covers crazy train, master of puppets, 7 nations armies. Best originals mars( live Cummings ga), sailaway, we are the children, mystery, and their latest not afraid extended version 😀 give any of them a listen you will love all of them
I love talent, and they are talented. Many bands cut their teeth on doing covers. Some of the comments poo poo this, but it allows us to see and hear how they were and how they have progressed to now. Always afraid of family bands. Most end up fighting and break up.
That's also because most of them had members that didn't like the other members. All 5 members of Liliac get along greatly and they hardly ever fight. They have even said that the worst fights they have ever had was because they wanted Ethan to hurry up because they had somewhere to be.
Ok, now you have listened to a cover song they did when they were younger. Now you need to listen to a song they just released. It is an original, "Not Afraid". You will be amazed at how more developed Melodia's voice has become. She will be turning 21 this December and the youngest just turned 15 on the 15th of October. Great reaction. Also, Melodia is a nickname given to her by Ronnie James Dio's Drummer but put an a on the end of it. And spelled the way she spelled it actually means Melody in Romanian. Their parents were born and raised in Romania; the kids were all born here in the USA. There are so much about this band and their performances you need to check out like they just got back from India on their first ever international tour, and they rocked the house down over there. The Fangs in India went crazy when they played. The band name "Liliac". Means Bat in Romania, and so their Fans are called Fangs. So, let's hear more LIliac please! Also, I found out you did this reaction to one of their songs through their Facebook group. They posted you did this. And they ask for us Fangs to like and Subscribe to your channel. So, guess what? You have a new subscriber here and I'm sure many more. Rock on and Rock Hard!
@@clintonshepard6107 It's been a very painful hard journey next week I'll be going to rehab and so things will start to be different thank you for caring I really appreciate you and I will be back in the saddle again
This was the first song I heard them do and my response was the same as yours I was fanged as soon as Melody started singing. Her voice has even gotten better and stronger as you will see in Not Afraid extended version it's my favorite but I love every song they've done. Thanks so much for the great reaction and comments and stay well. Fang4Life!!
They are an amazing family. Their song Mars is awesome and cover of Dio's, Holy Diver is insane. Melody's voice is perfect their style.
Liliac was the headline act at the unity music festival in manupar India 🇮🇳 11-6-2022 and they killed it in front of 1000s of screaming fans.
I saw them in person last year! FANTASTIC young musicians! Family band! 🤷♀️🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻✌️❤️🔥🔥🔥🎶🎶🎶💯😁
Great reaction again and yet another young rock band and the fact that they are family is even better I liked this cover very much your right her voice is made for rock for sure. as always your ride or die forever Eyy Ooooo
Welcome to Liliac 🥰 Great reaction! They are fantastic live too! 🤘🥰
They are working on their 3 original album and are completely independent ( NO Record company at all ) Give them all the Love and Support you can.
from day one horns up for liliac
get ready for your SUBS to go up. these guys are great and their fan base is amazing. loved your reaction, cant wait for more. RORH
I love them being a rocker in my 70s they’re phenomenal, love the vocals. They are perfect ❤takes me to 70s
Ohh haven't you heard about Liliac. I would recommend Holy Diver. 👍 It's really fire 🔥 Love from Norway 🇳🇴
I get such a kick watching peoples 1st reaction Liliac. I saw them live back in August, truly brilliant! I learned of them via Sina drums.
Shout out to Sina Drums. I learned of her through Andrei Cerbu.
This a family band they kick ass all there stuff is great she's a badass vox I love it cus she sounds different too
They kill every single song... Love Crazy Train and The Trooper!!
As always young lady you bring a little light into an ever seemingly dark world. Once again you have brought a smile to this weathered face.😊 May you be safe this day as well as you and your family be blessed
Thank you very much, Charles :)
Welcome to the rabbit hole that is Liliac. Their originals are even better
The new voices of a generation!!!! I am 58 thanks so much ❤
❤❤❤ Это лучшее, что я когда-либо слышал !!! 💜💜💜 Потрясающе !!! Мелоди !!! 💚💚💚
They are having fun you can tell makes all the difference
They do several Dio covers that are LEGIT. I wanted to hate these kids when I first saw that they had covered Holy Diver, but…. Very Respectable.
I judged a book by its cover, and I couldn’t have been more wrong. 🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️ Respect.
Winner winner rock and roll dinner . Yes they are young here but you can find videos of them on and around the Santa Monica pier honing their craft drawing large crowds . She has a variety screams including a Banshee , a Siren , and an outstanding Whistle register . You will find much more information in the comments below . Roll with them and we will roll with you .
Thanks for reacting to this band. They are incredibly talented. Please do more on them, especially originals like Sail Away, Dear Father or Not Afraid.
Great reaction Melody is my favorite vocalist on Planet. They have just Finished there live Tour at yhe Unity Festival in Manipur India.That reaction you gave was phenomenal everytime someone Sees them first time they have the same reaction..
You said it at the beginning, 11M views. They are incredible (been following them since their days playing the Santa Monica pier). And your face when Melody starts singing is priceless.
This is a great band that I have been following for years. Covers are great and so are they're originals.
Nice reaction. Just caught you on my cue. Thanks to Clinton to recommend this. As you pointed out, this is younger Liliac. That age sounds right. MeloDia is 20 now. Will turn 21 in December. You got the name correct the first time. It means bat in Romanian. They busked at an early age on the Santa Monica pier learning. Like the pier, they do covers and originals. I think the Fangs recommended some songs. Just look at Justin to see how young he looks if it's early. He just turned 15. Loved your energy. Hope to see more Liliac. (I support 3 bands now all different genres) till next time. Peace. Stay safe. God Speed. FANG 4 LIFE! RORH 🤘 🦇
Listen to not afraid, and piece of my heart cover to see Melody at her finest!!!
I really wish you had started with one of their Originals. This Cover is about 4-5 years old.
Mars (Live in Cumming GA), Dear Father, We are the Children, Not Afraid (Extended Version), Sail Away, etc.
They are Romanian/American, 100% Independent by choice. Currently Aged 15-23. 3 USA Tours and just did a show in India.
Yeah, I sense a theme with her doing The Warning's old cover of this yesterday. In both cases I wish she started with something original and recent. Maybe she'll follow up with more reactions to both.
I started with this because it's where I started but she's doing Not Afraid next but you can buy her a coffee and she will do whatever reaction you want lol.
@@clintonshepard6107 Nice to know but I'm flat broke. It's great that she's doing Not Afraid (Extended Version) next though.
That way she can get a taste of Melody's range and how talented they actually are.
As great as their Covers are I don't think it truly shows their skill as well as their Originals.
@@jonathanwatson5818 I remember the first time I heard her sing this and I think she had the same reaction I did, I know you have paid for reactions also and I always appreciate it. I just want to help them any way I can and I just felt I was getting criticized for my choice. But any way I hope you have a great day.
@@clintonshepard6107 I don't pay for Reactions and I wasn't criticizing your choice. I appreciate the donations you make to help get Liliac's name out there and whether Cover or Original I know you can't go wrong with them. Cheers Clint.
Great reaction!!! I first saw Liliac five years ago playing down at the Santa Monica Pier here in California. They totally blew me away.
Treat yourself go see these guys live...They are humble and polite at the meet and greet..Then showtime..They'll blow you away...110% energy. Melody's voice is even better live
Woot! Another reactor finding Liliac for the first time. Great reaction. Yes. They are nutso amazing. Classic rock voice.. oh yeah, and this is an older one. You should check their cover of Janice Joplin's "piece of my heart" from Cummings, GA live. Also Covered Joan Jett's "I hate myself for loving you". They're great recorded and better live. Another piece from Cummings is "Mars" an original. Must listen. Dig in and enjoy. They started out in CA on the Santa Monica Pier. Dad's a Music producer and originally from Transylvania, thus the band name 'liliac' or 'bat'.
Love me some Liliac Vamp Metal. Check out Liliac’s original music awesome 🤘🏻🤘🏻
Liliac is a great band whose does great covers and they also have many song that they made that are good as well.RORH!!
We need more of this band on this channel.
I'm a new subscriber! Great reaction! I love this band. Please check more of their covers and originals.
Thank you for your reaction to Liliac. I enjoyed your honest reaction and perspective Rosalie!
Subscribed... GREAT reaction!... been following Liliac since their beginning... looking forward to many more reactions from Liliac... you'll be amazed at how far they've come...
🦇🤘RORH🤘🦇
Welcome to the FANG GANG 😜🤘🏼😜🤘🏼
AAAAAARRRRRGGGGHHH!
Excuse me while I give a metal scream. The headbanging Partridge Family.
Rosalie, My favorite covers by them are Ronnie James Dio songs. But before you check out the Liliac covers you really need to check out a couple of songs from Dio. In my opinion he was the greatest male metal singer ever. Maybe start with Stargazer from the band Rainbow or Holy Diver from Dio's own band. Thank you and keep up the great reactions.
This band is amazing and I'm almost crying in how good they they are. The lead singer voice has personality and rasp sound. They could stand on their own if they find the right written songs made for them. I hope in the future they could sing their own songs along with holy diver, enter sandman and more. I love their sound and is really good.
They bring tears to my eyes too. They are awesome 💯
Great reaction and I saw your reaction to The Warning as well where you also did a great job. Both are really, really talented family bands and I love both of them. Hard core fans of both seem to think that they have to choose one over the other for some reason and at times make remarks that do not credit them or either of these wonderful groups. Though both groups have done amazing covers, they are at their best in my opinion with their originals. I love the fact that Liliac has made some changes in their style as far as fashion but also as far as their musical direction. They continue to do the old music but also have taken on some music that many would consider out of their sandbox. Some of the fans have expressed disappointment, but I say, good for them. They are still an amazing group and I wish nothing but the best for LIliac and The Warning. Nothing like a little healthy competition...Sort of like The Beatles, The Beach Boys and The Stones from back in my earlier days...I think I may be just telling my age there!
Hy my friend Jim. Some of you said was right but some didn’t made any sense. Family bands yes, but comparing Liliac to the Warning, it’s just like compared the Beatles to all the others. Especially painful was comparing the Fab Four to The Beach Boys. These surfer boys tried so hard, that the Wilson guy got crazy when the Beatles released Sgt Peppers before they released their disastrous LP “ animal sounds “ and the last song was on the Beatles record “ Good morning “ full with all kind of animal sounds. The Beach Boys were noticed only in the US, but the Stones and the Beatles were known world wide. Back to the youths of today, I’m not arguing about which band is better or worst than the other, both are made of family members, but one thing is the deciding factor for me, it’s the numbers of those members. Liliac have five members, and all of them are masters of their instruments. But their version is just a copy of the original, played masterfully. And the Warnings version just like they reinvented the song turned upside down and inside out in just seven days, and earned to be the first song on that Black anniversary album. With just a tiny budget they have or had that time, they played,edited,and made a video of it. And here coms the comparison in place. Many bands were invited to do that song, and this three girls blown away any other bands version. Back to old times again, the Beatles didn’t competed against anybody, better say, they didn’t needed to compete to anyone, but them self. The Stones played a totally different stile, with different lyrics and playing their instruments like craftsman’s. But the Beatles wrote and played on a different level than anybody else, and the only danger they had was the Searchers and the Hollies. And the Warning is running on the same train as they were running. No competitions in sight! Three member bands are a penny for a dozens, but not them! And their age can be a deciding factor, the youngest is not even 18 yet, and the oldest is younger than any of the Beatles was when they started to play. Got my view about them? Releasing an album when the oldest was just 16 yrs old written by a 13 yrs old genius Paulina it’s unheard yet. Ok it’s not unheard because the Jackson’s did it even younger, but to know the circumstances about them, I just feel sorry of them. And all things put together, the Warning is not just a meteorite, shining for a short time only. They are here to stay for a long time, which we can’t say about the Fab Four. And Liliac? Sooner or later they gonna have their differences because of male female differences or misunderstandings. It could happen to the Warning to, unexpected love affairs which in my mind is the only reason they can have a real fight. But as one Audio engineer said about them ( the family is the most important thing for them. ) so my friend, good that at least we have a choice, which according to one sentence of PAU in the song “ error “ It’s killing the mind, we all can have our favored artists or bands, and being old like dirt at least we seen and heard some of the great ones!!!!
@@bubamaranovichok4901 Well, Opinions are just that...Opinions. While mine might be different than yours, it doesn't make either more valid or less important...at least in our own minds. You have a good day!
@@bubamaranovichok4901I'm not here to start an argument or argue if one band is better than the other as I like them both. Just here to spit some facts. Liliac- Enter Sandman actually isn't a copy of the Original, they added pinch harmonics, keys, and a child prayer to it with an actual child, they just didn't flip it completely like The Warning did. Alessia Cara was actually the one invited to do the song (Not The Warning) but Cara didn't know what to do and was on same label and obviously the label knew TW did Enter Sandman earlier so Cara asked them to help her. As far as the no competitions in sight comment (Liliac actually has more YT Subs and Views) Maybe, Liliac will have their fights or differences and maybe they won't (so far they get along greatly with each other), you can say the exact same thing about The Warning, there's no guarantee either of them will be a long time staple despite their ages, Liliac has 2 members younger than The Warning's youngest. I would just enjoy it while it lasts and root for both to succeed.
@@bubamaranovichok4901 Also just in case you didn't know.
UA-cam: The Warning, 475K Subs, Joined Feb 11, 2007, 98,957,973 Views.
UA-cam: Liliac, 487K Subs, Joined Sep 12, 2012, 109,116,234 Views.
@@jonathanwatson5818 I have seen them both live. I can tell you that The Warning is much much tighter.
I saw them in concert in 2019. They are the real deal. Melody's voice is one of the best female rock voices I've ever heard.
Love the look on your face when queen melodia blasts her voice 😍 ❤
You should check out the original song by this incredibly talented family called "Dear Father".
Hi Rosalie! Great reaction. This is the 1st song by Liliac I heard as well. What got me was Melody's voice! It is so unique that you could hear a song she does and know it's her. New sub here!
Liliac the warning,plush hero the band and starcrawler are some of my favorite bands.I hope you can check some of them more!
This is one of their best covers. Her voice doesn't overwhelm the whole band here.
Melody is a welcome breath for metal vocals. They all play multiple instruments. The middle son now mostly plays bass, and the youngest, on keys, is also learning guitar and bass. Need to hear her do Dio.
Happy Wednesday, Rosalie!! ✨💗🤗 Hope you're doing really well! Thank you so much for bringing so many bands and performers to all of our attention! It's so fun and informative to see the varied music and creativity your channel brings to light! And, as always, your excitement and positive love of the quality in performance is soooo contagious! Thank you so much for this reaction (and all the others you do so frequently too!). Love your channel, my friend! And thanks to all the subscribers and supporters that pass along their requests to you as well! The whole community on your channel rocks!! (no pun intended - haha) Liliac did a great job on this! Totally head banging! Peace and rock on!! xo 🤗🥰✨
hahah brilliant "not-pun" :D Hi Avila!! thank you so much for your kind comment. You're a light here! seriously! peace and blessings. rock on!! See you on the next one. :)
Best female rock voice ever
Big fan been subscribed to their channel for over a year now
Would love to see them at Sweden rock in June, that would be great
They have a European tour in the works for next year, be on the lookout RORH!
@@studio920 Nice
Great reaction,, please keep going down the Liliac rabbit hole and I'll follow along, you will love their covers, but their originals are amazing, "We are the children" and their ballad "Sail away" please do
I get so much joy from people discovering the sheer amount of talent that exists in the metal scene. It is so much fun watching people mind slowly melting. Think back one year ago and assesbyour attitude and thoughts about metal and I am sure you will smile too.
"assesbyour." Well that's a word we don't hear everyday. Well done. 👏
@@joshuaburba1048 my Biden impersonation
@@greywuuf LOL. Well now that makes a lot more sense. I totally get it now. In that case, VERY well done. You get 3 hand claps, one for each of Biden's IQ points. 👏👏👏
Every member of this band is terrific, all at world class level now. Obviously the older three stand out but as the younger ones grow up they'll show us more. I doubt any better family band has ever existed.
Beats the Partridge Family, right?? Yeah, they rock the walls down!
World class is a bit of a stretch. The vocalist is world class, the rest are just pretty good.
Best family band ever? There are many great family bands that have certainly achieved far more than they have. They have potential for sure but I would say that they have a ways to go before I would put them in the same league as even Greta, much less the Bee Gees, Jackson 5, Sly and the Family Stone, INXS or Andrew Sisters. I could name many many more.
Ethan has become a beast on that 5 string bass he plays most of the time
@@joee790 pretty good? at what level is YOUR guitar playing?
@@roy19491 Weak argument bro. Its like suggesting I can't have an opinion on a pro football player because I am not a pro football player.
I stand by my comment. Never said they were bad, but the best ever?..... come'on man.
Great band and this gives you a look at the past as they were working on their technique. They are awesome in concert and now mix covers and originals. And since they've had 5 or 6 years of playing and touring, they are much improved from this. Check out more - especially originals "Sail Away", "Not Afraid" and "Mars". Melody's voice has improved and she just concentrates on vocals now. Ethan switched to bass so she can just be the kickass frontwoman that she is. She is inspired by Ronnie James Dio and theer cover of "Holy Diver" is on point. Check out more; you won't be disappointed.
You should definitely check out more from Liliac. Dios The Last In Line is amazing and their original stuff rocks! Sail Away ( a beautiful rock Ballad ) Nothing, Mystery, Dear Father and a lot more. Liliac has become my favorite all time...yes they're that good!
And another good one 😉😉😉
Rosalie thank you for your reaction to my favorite band. I am a 59 year old retired musician and I just love these kids. You have just scratched the surface with this video. You did however choose a great place to start as this particular video has garnered the most attention by viewers. I hope you continue looking into these kids and the journey they have been through. It is a fascinating story and the music is just phenomenal. I am a new subscriber in hopes that you react to more Liliac songs. You will not be disappointed. Peace and be well. KMM
thank you for watching. I've got another Liliac video coming in just 2 days :) Enjoy the Ride!
@@rosalieelliottofficial and you as well. I've been on this ride for a couple years now and I am anxious for the new album coming soon. Enjoy !!! Rock on and Rock hard !!!
So, after The Warning and Liliac, you should check also Motion Device and GFM.
After watching covers, move on to originals of all these bands.
Just to start with (all official videos):
The Warning: Evolve
Liliac: Chain of thorns
Motion Device (their name now is Quarter to three): Thick Skin
GFM: Give me a sign
Spinning Jenny: Hey Jenny
Enjoy the new generation of hard rock and metal!
Also "Plush" and "Sixsters Band" (young Ukrainian band all girls)
Also please react to VOB enter Sandman, show in france 2021
Yes, Gyal! That was my reaction when I saw them for the first time but I saw their video on the beach. Crazy train. Respect Gyal and blesses.
You will not regret listening to ANYTHING they release. You will expect beyond perfection and Liliac delivers that.
This is a Liliac Classic already.❤️🔥🎸🥁🤘🔥
Only been a little over 6 years
yes ! they are great ! I discover this band 2 years ago and I love them ! They did great covers: le last one "Seven nation army" is awesome , "close your eyes". Melodie is a big fan of Dio so try "last in line", "rainbow in the dark", "holy diver", ... They did their own music too: "Mars" (live is great), "we are children", "dear father", "sail away", ....
Have a nice trip with this band.
They are totally amazing an there music is ageless would love to see the here in New Zealand
Her voice is like no other check them out doing Dio covers she nails every song she sings kills Holy Diver.
Hey hey, Rosalie reacted to Liliac? Oh this is gonna be good. Looking forward to it.
Welcome to the world of Vamp metal. You havent heard anything yet. Pick any song. Cover to original. All are AWESOME!. Looking forward to more reactions
That girl gives me chill bumps
Thanks for reacting to my favorite band ❤️
They rock. No question about it. They have a future.
They do a cover of Crazy Train on the Santa Monica Pier when the oldest one (Sam the lead guitar player) was 18. Crazy Train Ozzy
Lol the first time hearing Melody singing jaw drop !
Love your reactions!! You really need to checkout their original song "Sail Away." You will love it!!
I love how clean her voice is. Amazing so young.
You have discovered the future mega band Liliac ,do yourself and your subscribers a favour and check out their playlist it starts when Melody was13 she's now 20 with a tribute cover of WILD THING through to day with their latest release NOT AFRAID one of their many original songs that will blow you away, the three oldest siblings have been performing this well since. Melody was 11and did impromptu performances before that , all can be found on their channel . They have just finished their third tour of America and are currently performing at a rock music festival India .they have featured on two KISS cruises adaetwo tribute cover albums and two original albums FANG4LIFE RORH
My favorites are their Ozzy covers.. and yes, they all got good hair genes!!
You need to watch them live on the pier doing crazy train
She's been giving me chills up my back for years now.
Melody was nicknamed Melodia by Dio guitarist and Ronnie James Dio's widow, based on their covers of Dio songs, asked them to perform at a Dio tribute concert
She was given the nickname MeloDia by Vinny Appice drummer for Dio& Black Sabbath
@@studio920 my bad. That's what I meant. The widow did the invite
@@studio920 She was given the name MELO-DIO by Dio's Family/band. Melo herself changed it to MELO-DIA later on.
No worries
Try their cover of The Trooper
Their latest video (Oct 2022) is "Not Afraid" Extended version which was filmed at various concerts they did this last summer. It is an original song of theirs. Plus they have cut their hair since this video. They are going to do a live-on-line concert in December and they are working on their 3rd album that will be released soon. They also did a "Seven Nation Army" remake earlier this year. Wait until you hear Melody's screams on these videos!
Love your initial reaction that's gold.
Love this band.
WOW! So, for just a moment, forget that they are all family, and that they are all women, and that they are so young. Forget the visuals (video). Just listen. Without knowing ANY of that other 'stuff,' I would say this was an excellent performance. When you factor in all that other 'stuff,' it goes from excellent to mind-blowing. This is the most I have been impressed by a new (to me) group in a LONG time! Did I say WOW??
I love watching first time watchers to Liliac. Most are like “awwww cute kids”‘then get their faces blown off once they start playing lol
No sé quién sean pero está muy padre su canción
Need to check there new stuff out they do there own songs too but a lot of rock covers
The Trooper is a must see
I suspect this band is so good because Melody stole Ronny James Dio's soul...I miss Melody playing bass. She is a VERY good bass player!!!
More like Dio and Joplin passed their souls onto her and she acquired their skills.
Amen to your comment on her bass skills. There's a part she does on bass during Sam's guitar solo on Chain of Thorns, and if you listen with ear buds, it's such a cool riff.
I recommend the following songs:
Liliac - Dear Father [Official Music Video]
ua-cam.com/video/ymQXDJzuHvg/v-deo.html
Liliac - Not Afraid (Official Music Video) [Extended Version]
ua-cam.com/video/1o4wfK9zlE0/v-deo.html
LILIAC - MARS (Original) (Live in Cumming, GA 2019)
ua-cam.com/video/CRrqHZNMUko/v-deo.html
Holy Diver - Liliac (Official Cover Music Video)
ua-cam.com/video/wPfNs_N9nE4/v-deo.html
The Last in Line - Liliac (Dio Cancer Fund Tribute)
ua-cam.com/video/xxQwjA0amKA/v-deo.html
Seven Nation Army - Liliac (Official Cover Music Video)
ua-cam.com/video/sLyibJ5btIQ/v-deo.html
New Metal Queen is here. 👍
Great my music you Rock
Best covers crazy train, master of puppets, 7 nations armies. Best originals mars( live Cummings ga), sailaway, we are the children, mystery, and their latest not afraid extended version 😀 give any of them a listen you will love all of them
My dear try not afraid.
🤘😎🤘 Song of the year
#HOGsupport LOVING YOUR CHANNEL GIRL !
Thank you :)
LILIAC" HOLY DIVER! BEST I HAVE HEARD IN 64 YEARS!
I love talent, and they are talented. Many bands cut their teeth on doing covers. Some of the comments poo poo this, but it allows us to see and hear how they were and how they have progressed to now. Always afraid of family bands. Most end up fighting and break up.
That's also because most of them had members that didn't like the other members.
All 5 members of Liliac get along greatly and they hardly ever fight.
They have even said that the worst fights they have ever had was because they wanted Ethan to hurry up because they had somewhere to be.
Ok, now you have listened to a cover song they did when they were younger. Now you need to listen to a song they just released. It is an original, "Not Afraid". You will be amazed at how more developed Melodia's voice has become. She will be turning 21 this December and the youngest just turned 15 on the 15th of October. Great reaction. Also, Melodia is a nickname given to her by Ronnie James Dio's Drummer but put an a on the end of it. And spelled the way she spelled it actually means Melody in Romanian. Their parents were born and raised in Romania; the kids were all born here in the USA. There are so much about this band and their performances you need to check out like they just got back from India on their first ever international tour, and they rocked the house down over there. The Fangs in India went crazy when they played. The band name "Liliac". Means Bat in Romania, and so their Fans are called Fangs. So, let's hear more LIliac please! Also, I found out you did this reaction to one of their songs through their Facebook group. They posted you did this. And they ask for us Fangs to like and Subscribe to your channel. So, guess what? You have a new subscriber here and I'm sure many more. Rock on and Rock Hard!
SEE THEM LIVE!!
Hi Cristy so good to see your comments again I missed you, take care!
@@clintonshepard6107 It's been a very painful hard journey next week I'll be going to rehab and so things will start to be different thank you for caring I really appreciate you and I will be back in the saddle again
@@cristyrawks6325 That's great news! Thanks Cristy if there's anything I can do let me know. Take care.
This was the first song I heard them do and my response was the same as yours I was fanged as soon as Melody started singing. Her voice has even gotten better and stronger as you will see in Not Afraid extended version it's my favorite but I love every song they've done. Thanks so much for the great reaction and comments and stay well. Fang4Life!!
You could put on a concert and advertise it a a Family event, and have The Warning and Liliac play...heeheeheehee.