Are You Really So Obvious? ► Sherlock & Irene [+500 subs]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 26

  • @ajcrowley5735
    @ajcrowley5735 7 років тому +51

    Even john ships it.

    • @hellokafkiana
      @hellokafkiana  7 років тому +23

      John is the Captain of this ship

    • @christinabeyer9298
      @christinabeyer9298 5 років тому

      John doesn't ship Adlock. He was only jealous for Irene all the time because he always thought that she wanted to take his friend away from him.
      Actually he hated to see Sherlock and Irene together.

    • @mrstark1241
      @mrstark1241 3 роки тому +3

      @@christinabeyer9298hi there disrespectful person, you are really on every adlock video I guess. I think you should go to sherlolly videos, there arguments would be way too easy to contradict and I doubt they will have any counterarguments like we have.

    • @mrstark1241
      @mrstark1241 3 роки тому +1

      He sure does

    • @christinabeyer9298
      @christinabeyer9298 3 роки тому

      @@mrstark1241 This is a public video and public comment area and you are not in the position to tell me what I should do or not.
      Are you so bored with your life that you are desperately looking where I left a comment? This is so pathetic.
      I should go to Sherlolly videos? What for a great advice. 😂
      And you guess wrong, I'm mostly to find on Sherlock and John videos.
      Please go and get a life.
      Bye.

  • @vaticancameos4352
    @vaticancameos4352 5 років тому +6

    This is so amazing and the music fits so well with the atmosphere of their relationship... (does that make sense??) Everything about this video is so amazing and I wish I would have found it when it was first uploaded... I cannot get over how absolutely beautiful this is. I hope you make more.

    • @hellokafkiana
      @hellokafkiana  5 років тому

      thank you very much for this comment! I love Adlock so much, I will keep editing them no problem there haha

  • @HermioneWeasley02
    @HermioneWeasley02 7 років тому +4

    This is amazing!! I love them

  • @laurablair287
    @laurablair287 6 років тому +2

    I think I'm going to cry! I love them so much!

  • @aurora5547
    @aurora5547 5 років тому +3

    Wow...i love them so much😍

  • @Asha_Cosplay
    @Asha_Cosplay 7 років тому +1

    This is so perfect

  • @PaigeyNeverland
    @PaigeyNeverland 7 років тому +1

    I love this so much!

  • @shirleynitka5030
    @shirleynitka5030 4 роки тому

    you know where to find me is a text to Lestrade from the first episode. Everybody assumes it's to Irene. Never was.

    • @christinabeyer9298
      @christinabeyer9298 3 роки тому

      Yes, agree, but in the minds of Adlockers it's still there.
      Actually it's so clear: Back to routine, back to work. The circle closes.

  • @oksanapoladko3382
    @oksanapoladko3382 7 років тому +1

    That's amazing!

  • @christinabeyer9298
    @christinabeyer9298 5 років тому +2

    Sherlock didn't text her back. The phrase "You know where to find me" used Sherlock here to offered Greg his help with a case. He used the same line in Asip to Greg with the case of the common committed suicides. You should actually know that.
    Sherlock didn't text Irene back and he never saw her again after he saved her life. The last two scenes are out of context and belong to different episodes.
    Irene is a dominatrix, and yes, she sleeps with men too, it's her job. She is payed for it.
    But I have to admit, that it is a beautiful edit.

    • @hellokafkiana
      @hellokafkiana  5 років тому +5

      She is a dominatrix, I would not be so sure she actually has sex with all her clients. I used to believe that too but a friend of mine actually explained to me that dominatrix not always have intercourses. This is because those that have this sexual preference do not necessarily reach orgasm the usual way. In any case, this does not matter. She is attracted from both women and men because she canonically says so and acts accordingly. She falls for Sherlock and is attracted to him (I mean that's the only reason why she loses the "game") and she has a preference for Women because she openly says so. About the "out of context" scenes I am not the first editor who does that and will not be the last. When the scenes regarding a character are limited (and even if they aren't) it can be fun to add something, it's something that most of us does. Just to make an example, even in this fandom, you'll realise that most Johnlock and Sherolly edit uses parts that canonically do not belong to them. But that's perfectly fine, it makes the videos more interesting and emotional to watch. I should actually know that the text was for Greg? Where am I? In school? LOL. Truth to be told I knew that but it's just a theory. Yes of course the parallel is put there to "close the circle" but in my opinion we can interpret it as we want, even that he texted her back (or did Moffat explicitly tell otherwise?). It's just a show, fans can read what they want between the lines. That final scene, in particular, was very open. Those who were Team John could imagine that he and Sherlock playing with Rosie was a sign that they had become a family (in a conventional or unconventional way), those who were team Molly could deduce that them being friendly meant more, while those that were part of the Adlock yacht could get some hope from that text (not that that was needed since the "Have you had sex?" line but anyway...). Glad you enjoyed the edit, though.

    • @christinabeyer9298
      @christinabeyer9298 5 років тому

      @@hellokafkiana The "Have you had sex?" line from Eurus meant nothing, because Sherlock didn't answered Eurus directly. He said only: "Why do you ask?"And Eurus told him that she had sex with a nurse, but didn't care about if it was a man or a woman. And Sherlock told her that is was a woman. And this psychopathic person should have known that her brother had sex with Irene, only because he played a theme that sounds like sex? When you remember, Sherlock composed her theme right after her "death." This had nothing to do with sex, only with the fact, that Sherlock have found himself in her, Irene was like a mirror to him. She was the only woman, with whom he could compare on an intellectual level. He admired her and have a lot respect for her, because of her high intelligence and cleverness.
      Remember, Sherlock saw Irene never again, she could start a new life somewhere in the world and she did it probably not alone, she took certainly Kate with her, her personal assistant and girlfriend.
      What else would he want from her and she from him? Nothing.
      I know these idea that Sherlock probably texted Molly or Irene in Tfp, because he "loves" women so so much.
      Nothing of it is true. Does a man looks so who sends a message to the love of his life? No. He looks very serious here, rather businesslike. The text message had to do with his business, believe me. And he texted Greg. The most people read it so. Nothing else make sense here.
      But of course can you believe what you want, even that Adlock is canon. Season 4 is long over and it's not.
      Only Sherlock, John and Rosie at the end with no girlfriends or wifes who could mess up with her common adventures. As a big fan of the original ACD canon I am happy with it. Besides, it was always a Sherlock and John story, not more and not less
      I know what a dominatrix is.
      Irene took in every case money for her very special services in her business even is it not sex she has with every client.
      That's the difference between you and me. I like it more when video makers stay by the truth, and only take scenes from episodes which belongs together, and not scenes which are out of context, which have actually nothing to do with each other. But's it's only my opinion.
      By the way, only Sherlolly fans do these things, they like to replace John by Molly to get what they want.
      I have watched so many Sherlock/John videos, and I have never noticed, that there are scenes out of context in it. The makers of these videos must do this, because it's true that only the two boys belong together. It's canon for over hundred years. All others constellations would contradict them.
      Sorry, but these all are my points of view.
      Have a nice day or evening what time is right with you.

    • @hellokafkiana
      @hellokafkiana  5 років тому +7

      Are you kidding? Johnlocker use Adlock lines from ASiB all the time. That's ok, I totally support it, but those lines are not related to that relationship so if you want to be purist they are not "in context". Anyway as someone who has edited for a long time now, I want to tell you something. What editors do is time-consuming and often frustrating (like you have an idea in your mind but then that totally crashes with reality and this "annoys" you because in your mind it was completely different, or worse you edit everything but then youtube forces you to change the background music or the colouring you have done looks different after the upload) so the most important part is that they are enjoying what they are doing. For this reason, I tell you I completely support all the kinds of AUs, manips or manipulations from the canon because the important thing is that the author finds something that challenges him/her and satisfies him/her. At the same time, I understand that someone might prefer remaining strict related to the canon, that's perfectly fine as well, everyone has different personal preferences. About the "Play You" part, you are free to ignore what has been suggested (as I already told before I strongly believe that everyone has the right to give his own interpretation) but to me it was quite clear what the message behind was. He chose that piece to describe himself, not something that he had written for John, Greg, Molly or whomever. The writers clearly tried to give some relevance to the Adlock dynamic with that part (as they did for the other relationships at different times), as they did in many others episodes (even in 3x01 when John remembers Sherlock looking at his room he hears the Irene Theme, just saying, or The Woman was brought up even when it was unnecessary, see 3x03 or the Christmas special). Anyway don't get me wrong, I loved the finale and I found it quite adequate, I loved to see John and Sherlock living together once again and solving cases, as I loved seeing that Sherlock and his family kind of accepted and loved Eurus, despite everything. If that would remain as the series finale I would be totally ok with that. There is no reason the create ship wars, especially in a series whose focus is not at all on ships. Have a nice day or evening as well :)

    • @christinabeyer9298
      @christinabeyer9298 5 років тому

      @@hellokafkiana I'm not kidding. Adlock scenes or lines who are in Johnlock videos? All the time? Sorry, but there are barely such things I can remember. There are more scenes from TRf in Johnlock videos, almost in every second.
      I admit, that you are right in the most points, and I don't want a war between different ships, I accept these, even when I don't agree with them.
      And it's good that we agree with the end of season 4 and that Sherlocks and Mycrofts parents accept and love Eurus as her daughter, although she did so terrible things. She still belongs to the Holmes family.
      Not that you think that I don't like Irene. I like her as a character. She is clever, smart and a beautiful woman.
      And she will for ever be a nice memory for Sherlock as "The woman" who beated him and have a place in his mind palace.
      Good bye.

    • @mrstark1241
      @mrstark1241 3 роки тому +2

      @@hellokafkiana agreed BTW this is a perfect edit.