World should get used to India’s strategic autonomy & understand it, says Dhruva Jaishankar

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 164

  • @classoppressorbourgeoisie8416
    @classoppressorbourgeoisie8416 18 днів тому +21

    Is he the son of ForeignMinister S.Jaishankar ?

    • @himanshubhardwaj5574
      @himanshubhardwaj5574 18 днів тому +7

      Yes, he is.

    • @arijitdakshi820
      @arijitdakshi820 18 днів тому

      😂😂😂

    • @tapaschatterjee7993
      @tapaschatterjee7993 18 днів тому +5

      YES, He also looks and talks like him
      Who is the son of Dr Jaishankar?
      Jaishankar was married to his first wife Shobha until she succumbed to cancer. The two had met while studying at JNU. Later, he married Kyoko, who is of Japanese origin whom he met while working in the Indian embassy in Japan. They have two sons, Dhruva and Arjun, and a daughter, Medha.

    • @viswapramodC
      @viswapramodC 18 днів тому +3

      Yes yes & yes. To be more specific, he is the eldest son, born to the first wife.

    • @shikamarunara295
      @shikamarunara295 18 днів тому +1

      Yes he is and he has an amazing sense of humor. He's awesome.

  • @ThunderLightStrikes
    @ThunderLightStrikes 18 днів тому +7

    I am surprised that how people can criticize him for choosing to live in USA. He has the freedom to do so. And he speaks more frankly than S Jaishankar.

    • @gopinathrajee
      @gopinathrajee 18 днів тому

      And they will b ok with people like George Soros, Singham influencing indian elections from other countries

    • @TapanPal-yw7rs
      @TapanPal-yw7rs 18 днів тому +1

      S Jaishankar the Viswa EMA how has Created Hostile Neighbors from Maldives to Bangladesh

    • @m.r.r8408
      @m.r.r8408 18 днів тому

      He seems angry all the time with a huge chip on his shoulder! Most undiplomatic chief diplomat of a nation!
      Product of left wing education and elitism

    • @fauxpaxit8274
      @fauxpaxit8274 18 днів тому

      Just one of the pseudopatriots who migrate to Western countries and then spout patriotism.

    • @shwetankp1603
      @shwetankp1603 17 днів тому +1

      What an incel logic !

  • @TapanPal-yw7rs
    @TapanPal-yw7rs 18 днів тому +2

    Alex this Guy Speaks Practical & Honesty on this Weeks Indian Foreign Affairs 👏

  • @sb9060
    @sb9060 18 днів тому +2

    Very reasonable, insightful, rational and pragmatic discussion...

  • @m.r.r8408
    @m.r.r8408 18 днів тому +2

    Strategic Autonomy is a great concept as long as we are not attacked by a violent external force. For all of our sakes, we must pray that never happens! Jai hind

  • @lilavall4735
    @lilavall4735 11 днів тому

    India shouldn't expect too much from US as far as technology, because of Russia friendship. This can't be a one-sided relationship. India does need to be more self-sufficient and remember only an ally gets special treatment, sharing technology, secrets, military equipment and much benefit.

  • @Godonmars
    @Godonmars 18 днів тому +7

    Bring him through lateral entry.

  • @chinahamyku6583
    @chinahamyku6583 13 днів тому

    There are many things that should be done in this world. If you don't have power and influence, then the so-called things that should be done will become things that shouldn't be done. It will even become a joke in the eyes of outsiders.

  • @YtMgk-hv6op
    @YtMgk-hv6op 18 днів тому +7

    India does not want to be part of any conflict

    • @TarulWarlord
      @TarulWarlord 18 днів тому

      Why not? Maybe not russia-ukraine conflict.
      But why shouldn't india support Tamils against Sri Lanka, madheshis against Nepal and balochis against Pakistan?

    • @deccanheart
      @deccanheart 18 днів тому +1

      While it sounds isolationist , idealistic and peace driven, it is a losing mindset. In the middle of the war, Lord Krishna had to enlighten the confused Arjuna that he had to fight for ‘Dharma’.

    • @FreeYourImagination
      @FreeYourImagination 17 днів тому

      That's because that was Arjuna's war. You fight your own battles, not be a part of others. ​@deccanheart

    • @deccanheart
      @deccanheart 17 днів тому +1

      @@FreeYourImagination - By the same reasoning, you can’t expect others to help you in the hour of our need

    • @FreeYourImagination
      @FreeYourImagination 17 днів тому

      @@deccanheart and pray tell me who's helping whom in the current crisis/ needs that certain countries are going through.
      Also, the way you put it is not how diplomacy and the world work.

  • @VirdanRach
    @VirdanRach 18 днів тому +2

    Not necessarily though! respect Sovereignty & sound economy - primal causes of Dignity

  • @chakradharmahapatra1958
    @chakradharmahapatra1958 18 днів тому

    Dear Alex, you can very well spot the level of sophistication in his answering and answers. My wish is Indian Media professionals, especially the newer digital media ones, excel in that type of sophistication. Thanks

  • @rabisahoo7681
    @rabisahoo7681 18 днів тому

    Knowledgeable Gentleman on the subject.
    Very much enlightened 😊

  • @ashokkandimalla5962
    @ashokkandimalla5962 16 днів тому

    Very interesting. Yes, the world should learn about India's strategic autonomy and that makes sense but only at a very narrow level. If all nations pursue the same doctrine, then will India also agree to everyone's strategic autonomy?
    Coming to his stay in US, that is of course his choice. However, that is not surprising either. It is quite common for politicians' children to stay/settle aboard. The former US ambassador to India, Patrick Moynihan wrote about this in his biography. In the morning speech in the Parlaiment criticizing the US and an evening phone call to enquire about the son in US. But then we are not hypocrites, right?

  • @shripadbhagwat6566
    @shripadbhagwat6566 18 днів тому +15

    I love how he is talking about India's success blah blah..while sitting in the US. Same with jaishankar.. he talks about India while his children are not even living here.

    • @arijitdakshi820
      @arijitdakshi820 18 днів тому +4

      😂😂😂

    • @vroomvroom5534
      @vroomvroom5534 18 днів тому +3

      You have spoken the truth.

    • @Akash-ok7su
      @Akash-ok7su 18 днів тому +3

      Monthly USD is credited to their account per month

    • @AnuragSinha7
      @AnuragSinha7 18 днів тому +10

      Bro he is a scholar. His job is researching and studying international relations. Our scholars are sitting in Taiwan and China and Japan doing the same. Have some perspective __/\__

    • @user-uh1kp3kc3l
      @user-uh1kp3kc3l 18 днів тому +3

      smells like jealousy. Did your US Visa got rejected?

  • @Riccardocampagnieri
    @Riccardocampagnieri 18 днів тому

    Snehesh ji another wonderful video to discuss a very important topic. Long time fan sir well done.

  • @deccanheart
    @deccanheart 17 днів тому

    ‘Strategic Autonomy’ - The new country who is adopting this is - Bangladesh. Indian policy of being concerned only for the Hindus in Bangladesh has resulted in a decline of India’s standing in Bangladesh.
    Moreover, ‘Strategic Autonomy’ also conveys that India will not be participating in events that that does not involve India. In today’s Global interconnected World, this seems to be a Non-Workable policy.

  • @balrajseth6310
    @balrajseth6310 18 днів тому

    Wonderful interview, where us perspectives of the indo us relationship has been well stated.

  • @jaydeepgadhavi5465
    @jaydeepgadhavi5465 18 днів тому +1

    India US defense relationship needs to be viewed in much more transcational way by both the countries. In fact India must view it more transactinally. That might help initially to build on the strategic component later.

    • @redatticus7606
      @redatticus7606 18 днів тому

      H aha best of luck explaining that to the US -who views all this strategically - with "expectations" attached to them. The US is the most conniving, ruthless and shrewd player of the great game there is on the planet. Lets wait what it does in Bangladesh - soon you will see a US naval base 100Km from BENGAL.
      India is and always transactional.

    • @fauxpaxit8274
      @fauxpaxit8274 18 днів тому

      ​@@redatticus7606Exactly! Modiji wants Russian oil for best friend Ambaniji. What transaction is that.

  • @user-cf3cr8ki7e
    @user-cf3cr8ki7e 18 днів тому +1

    Strategically Surrounded 😂😂😂😂

  • @shobhitsingh6330
    @shobhitsingh6330 18 днів тому +1

    Bhai mujhe lagta tha ki amitabh bachchan ka beta amitabh bachchan sirf movies mein hi ho sakta hai. But yahan to, matlab ditto humshakal. Bachon ki shakal papa se milna common hai lekin ekdum double role.

  • @Star-ds4sd
    @Star-ds4sd 18 днів тому

    Frank and Honest " Ukraine Asking to Choose Thier Side " 😂

  • @majgenrajankochhar9361
    @majgenrajankochhar9361 18 днів тому

    There is nothing like strategic autonomy in Today's Geopolitical Scenario. Lets understand in a more pragmatic manner. Welcome a debate with this young man.

  • @Vader19k8
    @Vader19k8 18 днів тому

    Strategic autonomy should not become strategic indecision

  • @vivekchand4316
    @vivekchand4316 18 днів тому +1

    the problem is not agreements..it is ability of the US on deliver on existing contracts...take the GE404 engines...GE claims supply chain issues while similar engines are being delivered to South Korea.

    • @redatticus7606
      @redatticus7606 18 днів тому

      That is tactical short term stuff. Long term the US is "expecting" India to fully tilt west - its not happening ad India has to play up the yanks for as long as possible.

    • @LikeDeep-q6w
      @LikeDeep-q6w 18 днів тому

      In most cases, the goal is not to help but to stall the development of the aircraft or at least slow it down significantly.

    • @fauxpaxit8274
      @fauxpaxit8274 18 днів тому

      Exactly! Modiji wants Russian oil for best friend Ambaniji. What transaction is that.

    • @FreeYourImagination
      @FreeYourImagination 17 днів тому

      ​@@fauxpaxit8274ambaniji us tel ka storage banayega. Wohi tel bharat ko chalata hai. Moron!!

  • @nehulbhakta1542
    @nehulbhakta1542 10 днів тому +1

    Wealthiest country's Vs Emerging economies along with capitalist policies vs rest. another's possibilities democratic nation vs princely rules kingdoms Vs Rest political systems.

  • @Article39A
    @Article39A 16 днів тому

    Dhruva is fantastic I like this guy

  • @SukumarfineArtPhoto
    @SukumarfineArtPhoto 18 днів тому

    Was it "strategic autonomy" that caused us to stop buying oil from Iran?

    • @jarjarbinks3193
      @jarjarbinks3193 18 днів тому

      YES! Strategic autonomy is NOT being a contrarian just for the sake of it. You do something because it is in your strategic interest. Russia is not just an energy supplier, it is also an arms supplier to India, a permanent UN Security Council member (with veto), and has a long history of supporting India in that body. In other words, Russia is A LOT MORE important to India's strategic interest.

    • @Star-ds4sd
      @Star-ds4sd 18 днів тому

      It's Jaishanker DNA Topi 👒

  • @sabesankandasamy9331
    @sabesankandasamy9331 18 днів тому

    Biden Administration could be divided on ties with India. Biden and Kamala could be anti - India while Sec of State and Defence Sec could be more pro - India. Anthony Blinken's close personal rapport with Jaishanker is quite well known.

    • @indian9632
      @indian9632 18 днів тому

      Stop believing in relationships and values bs. Its just interests ehat matters.
      Survival of the fittest

  • @tapaschatterjee7993
    @tapaschatterjee7993 18 днів тому

    Mr Modi, Opposed the attack on the Children's Hospital in Ukraine during his meeting with President Putin... '' it breaks my heart to see several young Children have been killed''

    • @fauxpaxit8274
      @fauxpaxit8274 18 днів тому +1

      Modiji welcomes Russian oil for Ambaniji.

    • @deccanheart
      @deccanheart 18 днів тому

      Mr Modi should have also said that - his friend, Putin should respect Sovereignty of Small countries and honor the Budapest treaty that was signed with Ukraine

    • @tapaschatterjee7993
      @tapaschatterjee7993 17 днів тому

      @@fauxpaxit8274 it really doesn't matter what you say... some people are negative-minded .. every single PM/ President promotes the country's corporate.. If Biden does not make weapons, why is he trying to sell .. for the US Economy and jobs for the US people.. he is not a ''DALAL'' for Lockie Martin..

  • @translawlexis
    @translawlexis 18 днів тому +2

    India is great but I will ensure US citizenship for my son.

    • @Mr.Nobody.1001
      @Mr.Nobody.1001 18 днів тому +2

      US citizen working for ORF? 😂😂 If you don't get the act, sorry😂

    • @fauxpaxit8274
      @fauxpaxit8274 18 днів тому

      Nothing different from the other pseudopatriots.

  • @caveman4351
    @caveman4351 18 днів тому

    All it took was a fall of Bangladesh

  • @AbcXyz-dd8yo
    @AbcXyz-dd8yo 18 днів тому +9

    Nepo kids everywhere nowadays.

    • @chinmaypadhye6472
      @chinmaypadhye6472 18 днів тому +7

      What is nepotism here? He is not part of Indian bureaucracy

    • @shikamarunara295
      @shikamarunara295 18 днів тому +2

      Dhruva is a scholar unlike the others. There's a distinction.

    • @LikeDeep-q6w
      @LikeDeep-q6w 18 днів тому

      He is not a minister or a leader of any political party. He is not even a bureaucrat. What are you saying?

  • @terminator6199
    @terminator6199 18 днів тому

    Ab ki baar Trump sarkaar - Inke pappa ke maalik

  • @Hypocritial
    @Hypocritial 18 днів тому

    Sonrise

  • @liuxian558
    @liuxian558 18 днів тому +1

    Ask him when is he appearing for UPSC ? Or is it not required in his case ?

    • @3008venky
      @3008venky 18 днів тому

      But why do you care Chinese stooge😂

    • @terminator6199
      @terminator6199 18 днів тому

      Lateral entry FTW.

  • @EdmundLam-ku8ro
    @EdmundLam-ku8ro 18 днів тому +2

    Why Endia keep on bag for Tec transfer 😂😂 shame 😂😂😢

    • @jarjarbinks3193
      @jarjarbinks3193 18 днів тому +4

      Please get help from somebody, probably an elementary school kid, before posting!

  • @residentindia
    @residentindia 18 днів тому +1

    Sorry what is the nepotism here? is it Print giving the guest a chance?

    • @shikamarunara295
      @shikamarunara295 18 днів тому

      The guy is a foreign policy scholar. Read about him before commenting.

  • @james432ful
    @james432ful 16 днів тому

    Not as impressive a speaker as his father

  • @sanjaysaksena619
    @sanjaysaksena619 18 днів тому +4

    Strategic Autonomy is a euphemism for moral spinelessness

    • @HellBot-gi5si
      @HellBot-gi5si 18 днів тому

      Look Dhruva Jaishankar is selling you Bull Shit. You cannot be strategically autonomous. Why? 85% percent of your oil to run your nation comes form the Arabs and Persians of the Middle East. If they go to war for whatever reason you may have to send in your military in to make sure the oil keeps flowing into India.

    • @3008venky
      @3008venky 18 днів тому

      You ares saying it’s ok for US to support Pakistan in 1971 and fund its terrorism program.. is it called moral correctness.. have some sense.. you want to bend and beg before USfor everything you want to do..😂

    • @varun2250
      @varun2250 18 днів тому +2

      Or pursuing your own national interest.
      There are no good picks in both Russia and Ukraine.
      Do tell us which side you want India to take.

    • @AnuragSinha7
      @AnuragSinha7 18 днів тому +2

      But when the same done by US it's moral greatness :D :D

    • @sanjaysaksena619
      @sanjaysaksena619 18 днів тому

      ​@@varun2250 It would be in my self interest to steal your watch but it's not something I should do. Morality requires us to do the right thing even if it does not serve our interests