OH SCOOP! Do you scoop? My reasons for scooping shave soap.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 136

  • @stagsandstaples1127
    @stagsandstaples1127 Рік тому +5

    Love love love your keys to a "good shave".

  • @DE_Razor_Shaving
    @DE_Razor_Shaving Рік тому +6

    Great vid! 😁👍🏼

  • @r55mannyp
    @r55mannyp 10 місяців тому +4

    Great content on this. I’m a scooper myself and mostly for contamination and I want the fragrance to stay the same strength as a new tub.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  10 місяців тому

      Thanks! I have found that it definitely helps maintain the fragrance.
      Have a good one!

  • @shavingwithpegleg3813
    @shavingwithpegleg3813 Рік тому +5

    Excellent points.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Thanks, Scott! I need to DM you or check out your latest vids to see how youtube handled your issue. Did they ever get back to you?

    • @shavingwithpegleg3813
      @shavingwithpegleg3813 Рік тому +1

      @@Tobins_throwbacks nope. Three emails and just the automated response that they got them. Ridiculous.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Figures, I wondered if you'd be able to reach someone. All the social media sites are like that. Lame AF

    • @shavingwithpegleg3813
      @shavingwithpegleg3813 Рік тому

      ​@@Tobins_throwbacksI guess they don't care anymore. It's probably so out of hand they can't stop it.

  • @leehaseley2164
    @leehaseley2164 Рік тому +7

    You did a good job of putting your point across, Tobin.

  • @daniellow9763
    @daniellow9763 Рік тому +3

    Holy crap, I just noticed! Congrats on 1,000❤

  • @michaeldamisch1367
    @michaeldamisch1367 Рік тому +2

    Good morning brother, 100% right for all the reasons you did mention!
    Happy shaving and stay safe 🪒🌎😎💈

  • @unclelshaves
    @unclelshaves Рік тому +5

    Awesome discussion. Really liked your simple definition of a DFS. I was a tub loader as well for 6 years and changed to scooping when I started collecting large numbers of soaps in mid 2020. So now I scoop and bowl lather build, for many of the reason you talked about but mostly to protect my soaps long term water damage (including scent loss) and I feel I have better control over lather build including soap and water quantities. The only exceptions are rare hard/triple mill soaps whose scrapings don't stick in my bowl then I puck load the brush and bowl lather build. I think if you are the type of shaver that uses one soap until it's empty and moves onto the next soap then it wont matter whether you scoop or tub load as the tub will normally be empty in less than 6 months. Like you said it's always the shavers choice whether they scoop or tub load and comes down to individual shave enjoyment. Have a great WE Tobin.👍🤠

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Thanks, Lawrie! I still cup load with Mitchell's and other puck soaps. And you too! Enjoy the weekend!

  • @toddreese5309
    @toddreese5309 Рік тому +4

    Hard-core and dedicated! You rock Tobin!

  • @lastshadow9351
    @lastshadow9351 Рік тому +5

    Great points and I totally agree! Less messy, having a wet soap container sitting around drying out, sharing soap, scent preservation. I'm sure back in the day that nobody ever thought about doing this, because you only had one soap that you used daily until it was gone. I use bar soap also and you really notice how fast the scent degrades over time and I've had a few that even became scentless before the bar is gone.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +2

      Well said, and I have seen the same thing with bar soaps. I keep mine out of the shower now and in a little soap caddy just for this reason. Thanks brother!

  • @travisfatlan8050
    @travisfatlan8050 Рік тому +3

    Totally agree! I tried both and prefer scooping I feel it preserves the scent and soap quality. Great vid!

  • @daniellow9763
    @daniellow9763 Рік тому +3

    When I first started wet shaving I loaded from the tub. A few months later I started scooping. I'll never go back to tub loading

  • @bathbeachjerry5132
    @bathbeachjerry5132 Рік тому +3

    Enjoyed your video 💙

  • @jamespark6074
    @jamespark6074 Рік тому +4

    Great points made and extremely well delivered. Thanks Tobes

  • @bigbadwolfable
    @bigbadwolfable Рік тому +3

    Great video, and I learned a couple things. Thanks Tobin!

  • @stacylennon2399
    @stacylennon2399 Рік тому +2

    Boom! Love the DFS assessment!

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Thanks Stacy! Often times too much pressure is put on the shave, just enjoy it 🤘

  • @pjwroblewski
    @pjwroblewski Рік тому +3

    Nice video. I've been in this hobby a long time so I have evolved over the years. Early on, I a was a tub loader but for years now I am a bowl guy.. Now the only time I don't is with a very hard triple milled soap. Scraping those out and trying to smash them into a bowl is problematic. Often that chunk starts dancing around the bottom.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Same, I still mug/cup load the hard soaps, it's the croaps that I scoop. Have a good one and thanks!

  • @Tenn3nts
    @Tenn3nts Рік тому +3

    Really enjoyed the video Tobin and nice discussion point. I personally do both - I enjoy bowl lathering when it’s a soft soap or cream, but at the same time when my soap is from a tub I have no problem lathering straight from it. Each to their own I guess but appreciate your knowledge on it, particularly on the loss of fragrance, that was news to me. Have a good weekend!

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      Thanks! And most definitely! To each their own. Have a great weekend!

  • @wendellowens2447
    @wendellowens2447 Рік тому +2

    Great video. Love the explanation of a DFS.

  • @AshleyRoseSimmons
    @AshleyRoseSimmons 8 місяців тому

    I scoop, and you're one of the guys that influenced that decision. Thanks Tobin!

  • @robertfagan3970
    @robertfagan3970 Рік тому +3

    I started off as tub loader now I only scoop

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      I don't know that I could tub load now if I tried. It would just feel wrong. Have a good one Robert!

    • @robertfagan3970
      @robertfagan3970 Рік тому +1

      @@Tobins_throwbacks I’m with you on that. Right back at you brother!!

  • @rickpacheco1093
    @rickpacheco1093 Рік тому +2

    Hey Tobin
    Great review. You have a lot of great points.
    I'm a scooper myself. It makes me feel like I'm keeping the soap original and preventing contamination.
    I'm like you I love seeing the lather being created in my bowls.
    Thank you for the great content.
    Take care

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      Thanks, Rick, once I committed it didn't take long and there was no turning back lol. Have a great week!

  • @hairywookie6501
    @hairywookie6501 Рік тому +1

    The damn fine shave description is PERFECT

  • @huronchess4810
    @huronchess4810 Рік тому +1

    I have heard that mould can grow underneath the puck too. Like you I am a convert to scooping.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      I've heard that too, and can see it happening. Although I've never had it happen to me. Have a great weekend!

  • @MichaelSchinella
    @MichaelSchinella Рік тому +2

    Great video Tobins, bowl lathering for preservation and longevity not to mention the resell value as you had mentioned is the way to go. Enjoyed your thoughts on this one.

  • @shavingfordollars5766
    @shavingfordollars5766 Рік тому +2

    Well done sir!

  • @bowtiern8292
    @bowtiern8292 Рік тому +3

    I definitely prefer scooping. I prefer to keep the water out of the tub to prevent contamination. I didn’t think about scent loss but it makes sense. You can still school place in bowl and load the brush for a face lather. I prefer to watch the lather build in the bowl but I get that some people like to face lather. Thanks for the video

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Thanks, Mike, definitely different strokes for different folks. Have a great Saturday!

  • @robertross8565
    @robertross8565 Рік тому +3

    I scoop; never tub load. I measure 1/16 tsp of soap and add 1/2 tablespoon of water. I mash the soap into the water with my thumb and turn it into a slurry. With a slightly damp brush, I then whip the slurry into a fantastic lather. This method works for softer soap, not hard triple milled soaps. I scooped to avoid contamination of the soap.

    • @robertross8565
      @robertross8565 Рік тому

      I use a Supply Marble lathering bowl.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      I need to try this! Hope you're doing well!

    • @robertross8565
      @robertross8565 Рік тому +1

      @@Tobins_throwbacks I have been using 1/16 tsp to 1/2 Tbsp of water for the past 6 months or so. When I started traditional wet shaving about 15 months ago, I was using 1/2 tsp. Thus I have reduced my soap use by 87.5%. I only have 2 soap tubs. If you use my method, your soaps might last you 100 years!!

    • @10floz30minutes
      @10floz30minutes Рік тому

      One-sixteenth of teaspoon has not been enough for the soaps I have counted & measured. Mine seem to have been needing about one-eighth teaspoon of soap.

    • @robertross8565
      @robertross8565 Рік тому

      @@10floz30minutes Whatever works for you. That’s great.

  • @idreamofshaving8172
    @idreamofshaving8172 Рік тому +1

    Congratulations on 1k Tobin! I seriously enjoyed yhis video. I tub load and scoop depending on my mood. But you made some great points in this video and I admire your dedication to the hobby👍👍

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Thank you! I have a couple tubs that I still load from, but tbh that's in part because I think of them as beyond repair/salvage. Have a good one brother!

  • @dancody6003
    @dancody6003 Рік тому +1

    Love the shirt - great record

  • @robertross8565
    @robertross8565 5 місяців тому +1

    I have a Pereira shaving bowl. It will be my last. I absolutely love it. It generates an incredible lather.

  • @robertross8565
    @robertross8565 Рік тому +3

    I have calculated that I will get over 200 shaves out of a 4oz tubs because I accurately measure my soap every time (1/16 tsp aka a PINCH).

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      😮 I definitely have to give your method a go! Thanks brother!

    • @robertross8565
      @robertross8565 Рік тому

      @@Tobins_throwbacks My pleasure. Let me know how it works. I use Lothur Grooming and Barrister & Mann soaps. “Uncle Bob’s Slurry Method” (1/16 tsp soap to 1/2 Tbsp of water) works equally well with both brands of soap. Have a great day in beautiful Oregon.

    • @kurtismiller4045
      @kurtismiller4045 Рік тому

      😮😮😮

    • @robertross8565
      @robertross8565 5 місяців тому

      I now use 1/8 tsp of soap to 1/2 Tbsp of distilled water. I bowl lather exclusively.

  • @10floz30minutes
    @10floz30minutes Рік тому +1

    The set of methods for pulling the soap in preparation to create the lather is this one: brush-load, scoop, scrape, cut or slice. I would say "scooping" is for taking a shaving cream from a 'tub' because the material is not so neat to handle. I like slicing for a firm soap if it is not stuck in a tub container, and I like scraping for a soap either stuck in its container or for a very hard soap which is too difficult to slice with a knife. Also, scrape or slice allows for better precision in knowing the quantities you use.

  • @jackcapone4375
    @jackcapone4375 2 місяці тому +1

    Great job. I agree with all of the rationales . Most of all I think it does really affect the scent potency so I have always been a scooper

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  2 місяці тому

      @@jackcapone4375 thanks Jack, I don't see how I'd ever go back to tub loading. I have a couple old tubs that i still do. But when it comes to new ones I just can't do it.
      Have a good weekend!

    • @jackcapone4375
      @jackcapone4375 2 місяці тому

      @@Tobins_throwbacks I recently saw where a guy claimed he had tallow based soaps that 'spoiled'. He thought it was because they were in uncontrolled storage - I guess not in a house or something. I've never had a soap spoil on me, honestly. Some of my soaps (not as huge a collection as yours) are still quite old and when I use them, they are fine.

  • @JulioRodriguez-vs1qp
    @JulioRodriguez-vs1qp Рік тому +2

    Happy 1k subs sir

  • @stevem1563
    @stevem1563 Рік тому +1

    I have been tub loading myself. I haven’t noticed a problem after 7 years. I will be scooping this week just for the hell of it. I bought a scooper from through the fire fine craft at Maggard and will break it in.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      If taken care of properly most guys generally won't notice an issue. I have heard Artisans
      (one in particular Monica) Share with me how she has done bacteria tests on tubs that people have sent her. I should see if I can get her to join me for a live. This gives me a great idea, wonder of she'd be game. Have a great weekend Steve!

  • @Sinnerboy88
    @Sinnerboy88 Рік тому +1

    I totally agree on all points, Tobin! I too only scoop my soap.. I never tub lather. I feel so much more at home with scooping. 👍
    I could be wrong, but in my opinion, tub lathering just couldn't be great for the product. 🤔 You know introducing tap water which could have impurities etc in it and possible bacteria or skin/hair from the brush to your soap.. not to mention the repeated wetting and drying process.. a bit like a turbo wearing out after heating and cooling so many times (not the best analogy, I know!)
    But yeah, I'm a bit of a hygiene freak in some respects and I always just feel like tub lathering seems a bit "dirty" to me and like it's polluting the product! Tobin's video with the used Pineapple Bay Rum(?) he got on eBay which came with free hairs reinforced that view for me! Oh man that was gross! 😩 I wouldn't buy a used soap anyways but I certainly wouldn't buy one that had been tub lathered. No offence to anyone who does tub lather but it's just not for me.
    I definitely feel scooping is the way to go. Especially if you have a lot of soaps.. you really want to take as good care of them as you can to prolong their lifespan.. because, well.. with larger collections or soaps are going to be waiting around a while, even with a collection of say thirty soaps, used in rotation each soap only gets six uses in a year if shaving every second day. (I think that's right.. I never was any good at math!)
    I just use a teaspoon for scooping though. I just scoop some out, put it in my bowl of choice (I tend to like bowls with ribs/channels/dots etc on the surface etc to help make the lather) I don't have anything special for scooping but I do love the little custom swords Tobin posted videos of. Especially the little broadsword one that looks like something from The Legend of Zelda! I just bought a pack of teaspoons from the store which I keep especially for my soaps.
    I used to just dig in and take some from the side but now I tend to like skim off the top to keep the soap relatively level.. just to keep it looking nice and I suppose it would help if I ever want to sell or PIF it on. The teaspoon works great for this, like a little blade. Just like skimming butter from a tub. 🧈😊

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      Well said, bro! You honestly made me laugh out loud when you mentioned the eBay soap! 😂
      Thanks!

  • @10floz30minutes
    @10floz30minutes Рік тому +1

    I had used brush-loading at the beginning, but later I changed to a different way. No more brush-loading for me.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      It's cool to look back at things and see how we have evolved/grown. 🙌 A bunch of things that I thought would never happen. Lol

  • @kurtismiller4045
    @kurtismiller4045 Рік тому +2

    War Pigs is probably my favorite song, but Ultimate Sin is my favorite album from Ozzy 🤘

  • @SIGSOLO
    @SIGSOLO Рік тому +2

    Awesome vid, Brother!
    And again: Congrats on reaching 1000 subs!!
    Have a great weekend!
    🤙
    #WAD

  • @leehaseley2164
    @leehaseley2164 Рік тому +5

    Good lord almighty! How on Earth, in all good conscience, could anyone try to sell that tub of soap? I feel physically unwell just thinking of it!

  • @flynn6306
    @flynn6306 Рік тому +1

    I think I saw that soap for sale, and I didn’t buy it because it was tub loaded (even though I want space nog!). I scoop, because I don’t want to add water to the soap and let it sit in the container, also because I’m ocd and a scooped tub is more appealing, and lastly for resale purposes. I figured there could be more than just water in a loaded tub. I think what if the person cut themselves and then went over it again with their brush and then went back in for more soap. I know that’s worst case but it’s definitely possible

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Hey Flynn. I feel ya 100% and yes sir, it's Spacenog 😎🙌 I LOVE Spacenog!
      Regarding bloodborne pathogens, I'm not worried about that due to a lack of a host.
      Whether it be HIV, HBV, HCV, or something like syphilis, etc all of them need a living host. So, inside a tub of soap, they wouldn't live for more than a few minutes, a few hours tops. The only reason i know this is because it's a conversation my wife and I have had, she is a Healthcare provider at a family practice, otherwise, it'd likely be a concern of mine as well. So while it does sound disgusting, according to her we are safe there. Thanks for watching!

  • @nikitassamprakos8734
    @nikitassamprakos8734 Рік тому +1

    hey Tobin! i agree with you and i was doing some tests the past days and i realize that i lost some of the soaps protections slickness etc when i used the scooping method, maybe thats me or i need more product? i used 1/4 tsp and maybe some more but to be honest i think i need more practice cause until now i used to load directly from the tub and then face lather. for example i used to find some some down to the bottom of my bowls.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  10 місяців тому +1

      Hey sorry for the late reply I meant to reply much sooner but then I got distracted or something happened and I forgot until just now when I noticed.
      How has this gone since your post? This is the first I've heard of something like this. Doesn't sound possible but anything is possible I'm definitely curious to know how it has gone since the original post again sorry for the late reply have a good one

    • @nikitassamprakos8734
      @nikitassamprakos8734 10 місяців тому +1

      hey @@Tobins_throwbacks no worries! for your information i'm total scooper now and im joining the scooping club :P, i found that when i spread the soap around the bowl but near the walls of the bowl i can load the brush easier and without any problems. my previous comment is in a period that i was trying to find outifit is worth it or no (about scooping and i was doing some experiments). thank you for your reply!

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  10 місяців тому +1

      @@nikitassamprakos8734 awesome! Good to hear! I'll have to experiment with the exterior walls. 👍

  • @JulioRodriguez-vs1qp
    @JulioRodriguez-vs1qp Рік тому +2

    Can you hook me up with the artisan making those brush handle scoopers

  • @Kenoji8
    @Kenoji8 10 місяців тому +1

    Heh, funny how you refer to yourself as a fraghead considering how much you know about scent notes and such (very similar to me in ways). I'm surprised that you don't review more EDTs / EDPs / Parfums / Extraits from fragrance companies, but then again, fragrances in that sphere are quite expensive. I've been a fraghead for about 4-5 years, but on the parfum side of stuff and it is not cheap at all. Still, I've been a part of the community and know a few perfumers and lots of fragrance reviewers, so I'm glad to look at that side as a part of the shaving community, too.
    Anyways, I used to be a scooper when I initially started this, but you see so many people in the YT shaving community tub lather that it's almost like, "You know what, that's easier to do." Looking at the two tubs you presented with one being scooped and the other being brush loaded...man, what a difference in appearance. And I never considered the fragrance, shrinkage, and BACTERIA arguments towards tub loading...especially as a person who loves fragrances and understands storing fragrances in cool, dark places away from light and changing temperatures to preserve fragrance oil longevity. So, I'm going to probably buy a few guitar picks and start scooping my soaps that way. This was a very helpful video, thanks Tobin. Always nice to meet a fellow fraghead! 😁😁😁😁😁

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  10 місяців тому +1

      Thank you! Man, I've thought about doing fragrances a few times. I will likely dive in at some point. I have a good-sized collection, enough to allow me to get started anyway.
      Glad the video is helpful, have you seen my other video? The one with the random hair in the tub lol.
      I'll find it and link it below. Have a good one!

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  10 місяців тому

      ua-cam.com/video/9Pn_OLKMPzs/v-deo.htmlsi=K209cRbCYKSz_0N4

  • @lawrence1md
    @lawrence1md Рік тому +3

    Congratulations on 1k! Thanks for the shoutout. Wanna trade for my harvest moon set?

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      Thanks! You have my attention lol You want Harvest, or are looking to trade yours?

    • @lawrence1md
      @lawrence1md Рік тому +2

      @@Tobins_throwbacks I have harvest moon and will be happy to add it to your collection

  • @ericstanford7670
    @ericstanford7670 Місяць тому +1

    Do you still sell on eBay? If so do you sell brushes and or would you sell samples of soap?

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Місяць тому

      @@ericstanford7670 hey Eric, I don't but I need to. I still have TONS of vintage Razors.
      If you're willing to pay for shipping I'd be happy to mail you soap samples. You can dm me, my link tree should be in the description of this video.
      Have a good one!

  • @brianinski
    @brianinski Рік тому

    melt the soap in a double broiler and repour it into the tub

  • @hairywookie6501
    @hairywookie6501 Рік тому +1

    Tobin!

  • @RobertsReviews1974
    @RobertsReviews1974 Рік тому +1

    I don't have a scoop😞

    • @kurtismiller4045
      @kurtismiller4045 Рік тому +2

      Hey Robert, anything will work. I use a butter knife sometimes. I also have used a broken plastic spoon handle

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому +1

      No worries, like Kurtis said just about anything will work. You could even use a button. A flathead screwdriver also known as a standard screwdriver 🪛 a clean coin could work too. Lots of every day items. Have a great week brother!

    • @RobertsReviews1974
      @RobertsReviews1974 Рік тому

      @@Tobins_throwbacks I was actually joking! I don't need a scoop or anything to get shaving soap!🤪

  • @AdamBarbara
    @AdamBarbara 3 місяці тому +1

    Oh yes I scoop and I blame it on you lol

  • @10floz30minutes
    @10floz30minutes Рік тому +1

    You mention in this video, "50 shaves or more from a 4 oz. tub"? The "... or more" needs greater emphasis. I have counted this. MUCH more than 50 shaves from 4 ounce soap.

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      Yeah, it depends on how much is used. For example, if you use Matt's methods you can get 58 shaves. But if you use Robert's methods of 1/16 of a teaspoon you can get as many as 200 shaves!😮 Crazy on paper. Robert has his measurements listed in a comment below this one. Look for Robert Ross. It all just comes down to the individuals style/preference. I don't measure and often end up with much more than I needed. So for me 50 is a good guesstimate

  • @robertross8565
    @robertross8565 5 місяців тому

    Separate your soaps into two categories. Those that you have tub loaded and those you have scooped. Use all the tub loaded soap first. If something happens to you, your wife will have more stuff to sell.

  • @theluxuryshavinghobbyist
    @theluxuryshavinghobbyist Рік тому +1

    Great video Tobin. We are on the same path with regards to scooping! Happy Father’s Day!

    • @Tobins_throwbacks
      @Tobins_throwbacks  Рік тому

      Indeed we are! Thanks, Glem, and Happy Father's Day to you too!

  • @garys_shave
    @garys_shave Рік тому

    I get better lather is I use the scoop method. ~cheers 💈🪒💈