@@Nomaybe-ei4hn no, you didn't. Gerard does main vocals and back up ones, you can check it out if you search for isolated mcr vocal tracks. Ray only sings the backing vocals during concerts.
@@megajackproductions9154 that's called a leslie rotary speaker affect. It's used by musicians and sound engineers to give that whirling soind in music.
Ray never got enough credit. Gerard is an amazing singer but his greatest talents are his creativity, charisma, and ability to connect with other people. Ray's range and vocal clarity is actually astounding. I'd say he's a more technically gifted singer than Gerard.
While I agree that Ray deserves a lot more credit. He doesn't sing in this song, he only sing in the concerts, all the recorded songs is Gerard as main singer and back vocals
@@Luke4207 Yeah. The records are reused and amplified in some parts but is Gerard, except in Danger Days. Frank and Ray do some of the back vocals in that album. That's why you always see Ray practically screaming at the mic in the lives but doesn't sound at all in the records
I see backup vocal mostly have higher vocal range and better tone than the main vocal,but the matter is the main vocal have more unique voice and better with express the music that they wrote themselves
gerard wrote this in memory of his grandmother's passing and i am currently going through my own nana's passing and extreme anger at having to deal with my corporate job. this version is helping me out so much
Finally something that actually sounds like I’m in a cathedral Basically, my friend made something like this with Sleep but it just sounds like Gerard having a mental breakdown in the bathroom stall next to yours, sorry Mikay
Imagine: You're on your way home and get caught in a terrible rainstorm, so you hurry to the nearest building for shelter - and it just happens to be an old cathedral. As you open the doors, you hear this echoing off the walls of the gloomy interior. Making your way to the sanctuary, you see Gerard standing alone at the altar, singing his heart out. Call it dumb but I found this whole idea beautiful ^-^
Long ago Just like the Hearse you die to get in again We are so far from you Burning on Just like the match you strike to incinerate The lives of everyone you know And what's the worst you take From every heart you break And like the blade you'll stain Well I've been holding on tonight What's the worst that I can say? Things are better if I stay So long and goodnight So long and goodnight Came a time When every star fall Brought you to tears again We are the very hurt you sold And what's the worst you take From every heart you break And like the blade you'll stain Well I've been holding on tonight What's the worst that I can say? Things are better if I stay So long and goodnight So long and goodnight Well, if you carry on this way Things are better if I stay So long and goodnight So long and goodnight Can you hear me? Are you near me? Can we pretend to leave and then We'll meet again When both our cars collide What's the worst that I can say? Things are better if I stay So long and goodnight So long and goodnight And if you carry on this way Things are better if I stay So long and goodnight So long and goodnight
I literally can't listen to Helena without doing the little teardrop motion at "brought you to tears again" and violently reaching forward like he does at "WELL I'VE BEEN HOLDING OOOOON TONIGHT" my emo soul literally won't allow it
His shoes squelched with every step up to the front doors of the church. The sky growled, snapping at humanity with cracks of lightning. Her grave was only feet away now. The Man's body was drenched as he opened the doors. A repulsive mixture of sweat, muddy rain, and blood that didn't belong to him soaked everything from his stringy black hair to his rotting shoes. The Man wasn't different than before he made the deal, only half of a whole with much more blood on his hands. He dragged himself like a zombie veteran walking in a battlefield across the aisle of endless pews, remembering the silence that followed being greeted by Death with the scream of a bullet. The blood on his hands never ceased, staining the rusty gun he constantly held in the same hand she gripped as the stars in her eyes died and still smiled as her brain matter leaked onto his lap. The cold mud seeped through his shoes, creating unpleasant puddles for numb feet. He was no different from the men he'd killed. The storm carried on, a parade of chaos partying above the cemetery. He found her grave. It was no different than the other tombstones. He knelt, and wept. The many undeserved pleas for mercy stuffed his brain with shame, leaving the grief sidelined. He wanted it to stop. Please someone make it stop! The lightning was reflected beautifully in the silver shine of his gun. Unlike the others, he didn't beg for his life. Didn't think he deserved a second chance. With the scream of a bullet he ended his journey the same way it began: Desperate, a gun in one hand, and with the corpses of thousand evil men. Edit: Thank you guys so much for all the likes and comments! ❤
Been an MCR fan for a couple years now and I’ve been looking for something like this for ages. Gerard’s vocals are amazing. Both main and back (since Gerard sings backing on the studio versions)
This songs always meant a lot for me, at first i just empathize with Gerard's and Mikey's lost, but when I lose my granny it became an hymn for me. Everytime i play this song i think a lot about her, and this version it just killed me. Sorry for my english I'm mexican.
My name is Helena. I want this to play at every of my events. I want to annoy my family with this song so they remeber it once i‘ll no longer wander on this earth. They should be able to memorize every word. I‘ll teach my Kids the backround vocals and they‘ll be thankful once i‘m gone to have a memory.
![I Don't Love You but it's just Gerard Way singing in an empty arena [MCR]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Tm_GmAprS8Q/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m gonna make a new one, which MCR song would you like to hear next?
Do you know what they do to guys like us in prison, if you havent already
Teenagers
Mama
I'm not Ok
I don’t love you would sound beautiful
May your pillow be cold on both sides ❤
Everyone’s truest desire
thank you
you have blessed us
I know. . .that happened 2 days ago. . .i don't want it again. . .so take it back, please? T^T
For real😫😫❤️
pov: you're helena
I really am
hot
@@rinwd76 lol
XD
mhm i actually am
if this isnt played at my funeral im leaving
same
Then I’m not dying
Same
they'll see me dance out that bih
me too
When the backup vocals came in, I whipped my head up so fast that I gave myself whiplash, thank you
lmfao
Ahhahahaha 😂😂😂
What's whiplash?
loll
@@hallie8252 A movie
RAY'S VOCALS OMFG
He’s the back up ones right?
actually is gerard, not ray
@@inmagomez.2068 Gerard is main vocals and ray is the backup ones, obviously you didn’t understand
literally rays vocals are so underrated
@@Nomaybe-ei4hn no, you didn't. Gerard does main vocals and back up ones, you can check it out if you search for isolated mcr vocal tracks. Ray only sings the backing vocals during concerts.
I can hear the drums in my head🥁🎶
Same lol
We all can
Yep
taratarataratarataratarataratara 🥁
I can hear the whole band
2:11 it sounds like Gerard is singing into a giant fan but I love it tho
LMAO This made my day 😂
i actually think he did lol they just erased the fan sounds and try to blend in gerards voice into the fan without air noises
@@megajackproductions9154 wait. THAT IS AWESOME lmfao
Lol haha
@@megajackproductions9154 that's called a leslie rotary speaker affect. It's used by musicians and sound engineers to give that whirling soind in music.
May your black eyeliner never smudge (unless you want it to) 🖤
You think it'll look better smudged or nah?
@@isaiahmatedne7966 yessss
How did I get stuck listening to these acappella versions of their songs and why do I enjoy it so much 😭🤚🖤
You’re not the only one
Because you are emo
Fr i need a playlist of all their songs but acappella
same 😭 I adore these versions sm
Ray never got enough credit. Gerard is an amazing singer but his greatest talents are his creativity, charisma, and ability to connect with other people. Ray's range and vocal clarity is actually astounding. I'd say he's a more technically gifted singer than Gerard.
While I agree that Ray deserves a lot more credit. He doesn't sing in this song, he only sing in the concerts, all the recorded songs is Gerard as main singer and back vocals
@@Punk_Male ALL of them? Ok crazy
@@Luke4207 Yeah. The records are reused and amplified in some parts but is Gerard, except in Danger Days. Frank and Ray do some of the back vocals in that album. That's why you always see Ray practically screaming at the mic in the lives but doesn't sound at all in the records
@@Punk_Male Ray and Frank sang in Dead! On TBP and Ray also did quite a bit on Conventional Weapons.
I see backup vocal mostly have higher vocal range and better tone than the main vocal,but the matter is the main vocal have more unique voice and better with express the music that they wrote themselves
gerard wrote this in memory of his grandmother's passing and i am currently going through my own nana's passing and extreme anger at having to deal with my corporate job. this version is helping me out so much
I hope you're doing well now. 🙏
I play this for my gran, Helen, as often as I can. I lost her almost two years ago. I hope you're doing OK my dear
I know its been 2yrs but i hope you got through your storm. 🤙🤙
Finally something that actually sounds like I’m in a cathedral
Basically, my friend made something like this with Sleep but it just sounds like Gerard having a mental breakdown in the bathroom stall next to yours, sorry Mikay
Lmao
F
You don’t mean too much to Gerard lol
Thank you, now I know how my funeral will sound like
why this is not more famous????????????????????????????????
IT'S FUCKIN GLORY
fr emo peeps get ON IT
2:07 "time to bring out the fan"
Imagine:
You're on your way home and get caught in a terrible rainstorm, so you hurry to the nearest building for shelter - and it just happens to be an old cathedral. As you open the doors, you hear this echoing off the walls of the gloomy interior. Making your way to the sanctuary, you see Gerard standing alone at the altar, singing his heart out.
Call it dumb but I found this whole idea beautiful ^-^
i-ive finally found my dream
That's beautiful
If I saw Gerard way singing in a cathedral in the middle of a rainstorm I'd die
What about ray tho-
@@fireleftovers3576 ray's the ghost that haunts the cathedral🖤
ray's vocals are everything
His vocals only show up live
ray doesnt sing in this
@@byggarebob9324 he does, you just have to pay attention
@@008Ree he doesnt. he only sings the backups live. not in the studio verison.
@@byggarebob9324 if you say so
2:58 ❤️
this is my favorite part of the whole song
@@pimpinhoez same mine too!
0:10 *gerald's voice sounds so raspy to the point he's whispering*
The fact that you called him Gerald
@@nimrod8613 XD
@@nimrod8613 JAJAJAJJAJA
gerald
@@nimrod8613 when autocorrect hates you lol
This is absolutely beautiful if it doesn’t play at my funeral I’m not dying
just revive and leave the funeral if this doesn’t play fr
Long ago
Just like the Hearse you die to get in again
We are so far from you
Burning on
Just like the match you strike to incinerate
The lives of everyone you know
And what's the worst you take
From every heart you break
And like the blade you'll stain
Well I've been holding on tonight
What's the worst that I can say?
Things are better if I stay
So long and goodnight
So long and goodnight
Came a time
When every star fall
Brought you to tears again
We are the very hurt you sold
And what's the worst you take
From every heart you break
And like the blade you'll stain
Well I've been holding on tonight
What's the worst that I can say?
Things are better if I stay
So long and goodnight
So long and goodnight
Well, if you carry on this way
Things are better if I stay
So long and goodnight
So long and goodnight
Can you hear me?
Are you near me?
Can we pretend to leave and then
We'll meet again
When both our cars collide
What's the worst that I can say?
Things are better if I stay
So long and goodnight
So long and goodnight
And if you carry on this way
Things are better if I stay
So long and goodnight
So long and goodnight
Me reading the lyrics while listening in time
THANK YOU
i love singing along to these but also have horrible auditory processing
@@nerdywolverine8640 sameee
Come on there's no way anyone needs the lyrics by now
You will wake up with ur phone and AirPods fully charged
Maybe it's only me,but I seriously need to sing like this into a church
It’s important to remember. We all will say goodnight one day.
The words “Cathedral” and “Helena” gave me unwelcome flashbacks to RE6
That part is a nightmare to play
Nice pfp
this needs more attention. its beautiful.
2:10 RIGHT THERE RIGHT THERE. SERRATONIN
* Casualy does the hand motions Gerard does in the music video *
I literally can't listen to Helena without doing the little teardrop motion at "brought you to tears again" and violently reaching forward like he does at "WELL I'VE BEEN HOLDING OOOOON TONIGHT"
my emo soul literally won't allow it
i wish the one person who disliked a very bad day
RAYS BACKING VOCALS ARE JUST UAHAUAHUAHAUAGAUAH
ray is so incredibly talented. his voice is heavenly.
His shoes squelched with every step up to the front doors of the church. The sky growled, snapping at humanity with cracks of lightning. Her grave was only feet away now. The Man's body was drenched as he opened the doors. A repulsive mixture of sweat, muddy rain, and blood that didn't belong to him soaked everything from his stringy black hair to his rotting shoes.
The Man wasn't different than before he made the deal, only half of a whole with much more blood on his hands. He dragged himself like a zombie veteran walking in a battlefield across the aisle of endless pews, remembering the silence that followed being greeted by Death with the scream of a bullet. The blood on his hands never ceased, staining the rusty gun he constantly held in the same hand she gripped as the stars in her eyes died and still smiled as her brain matter leaked onto his lap.
The cold mud seeped through his shoes, creating unpleasant puddles for numb feet. He was no different from the men he'd killed. The storm carried on, a parade of chaos partying above the cemetery. He found her grave. It was no different than the other tombstones. He knelt, and wept. The many undeserved pleas for mercy stuffed his brain with shame, leaving the grief sidelined. He wanted it to stop. Please someone make it stop! The lightning was reflected beautifully in the silver shine of his gun. Unlike the others, he didn't beg for his life. Didn't think he deserved a second chance. With the scream of a bullet he ended his journey the same way it began: Desperate, a gun in one hand, and with the corpses of thousand evil men.
Edit: Thank you guys so much for all the likes and comments! ❤
This makes me want to have a book about Bullets and Three Cheers cuz this is really well written lol
@@waffulz thank you! 😊
this is genuinely fucking beautiful, id love to see some sort of story from you, this is lovely
@@bubbletea6320 aaah thank you so much!! 😊
holy shit dude i'm so here for this
My broken emo heart ;-;
Edit: 2:58 im actually crying
I feel it too 😪
I totally get it TT_TT
Same 😭
Me too that was sad i miss my friends
bro the acapella is so perfect wtf
DAMN. I always knew that Gerard was a good vocalist but this just made me realize that he is on another level…. My Lord….
Pov:
You're singing at your bathroom
This is also what happens when you let Gerard sing at my funeral.
Basically me.
Whenever my parents aren't home.
this is what the little roaches in my walls hear at 3 am
0:20 *this part gets me everytime*
Been an MCR fan for a couple years now and I’ve been looking for something like this for ages. Gerard’s vocals are amazing. Both main and back (since Gerard sings backing on the studio versions)
now make "Helena but you're in the coffin"
his voice is so pretty ,,,,
I'm tempted to go and sing this in my local Cathedral.
*crying* I needed this so much
This genuinely gives me chills. God i love this band
The one who dislike this video probably gerard himself
Why?
Why-
Why?
Tell Them That It's Human Nature
Why ? Why ?
If this was on Spotify it would be on loop every single f*cking day
I just love you for doing this
Growing up is realizing Ray was the tea heartthrob
This songs always meant a lot for me, at first i just empathize with Gerard's and Mikey's lost, but when I lose my granny it became an hymn for me. Everytime i play this song i think a lot about her, and this version it just killed me. Sorry for my english I'm mexican.
i got shiverzzz i love this
No One:
All M.C.R Fans: _If Don't Play "Helena" At My Funeral I Don't Die!_
Omg Gerard's voice is AMAZING! His vocals are so completely unique. What a beautiful treat. Thank you so much!!💋💕🤟🤟
thx for this
bro im gunna fuckin fall asleep they're voices are so lovely
My name is Helena. I want this to play at every of my events. I want to annoy my family with this song so they remeber it once i‘ll no longer wander on this earth. They should be able to memorize every word. I‘ll teach my Kids the backround vocals and they‘ll be thankful once i‘m gone to have a memory.
ray and gerard’s voices work AMAZING together. it’s unreal and beautiful ❤️🖤
Okay but I need this over an organ cover to really bring it together.
This one is better than the other versions. I just hate when there is an echo
POV: Priest Gerard singing alone in the cathedral before helena's funeral
Wow I have actual, literal chills.
thank you
this made my soul yearn but i don't know what for.. it gives me a home sick feeling in my stomach
Came for Gerard's vocals, stayed for rays
Them shivers tho
Everyone needs to calm down with the funeral shit but this is god damn amazing.
That's rich coming from you little rocket man.
this is the only reason i sleep soundly at night
the switch from the whispers to the screams goes way harder without the instrumentals
2:12 might be the sound you'll hear when you're finally leaving your physical body
This is a dark emo masterpiece I love it!
Now I want to sing this song in a cathedral.
Rays vocals are EVERYTHING
The sound of paradise
I literally got chills all over
Like..all over? 0.0
This was almost like hearing it again for the first time. SO MANY FEELINGS!
If this isn't played at my funeral, I don't want that shit
2:11 gets me just that whole part just sounds amazing.
Goosebumps all over 😲🤘👏❤️
I miss his voice! I miss MCR era 💔🙁
they’re back together
This gave me chills!
This was therapeutic to me
After hearing this my hair dyed itself black and black eyeshadow and eyeliner appeared on my eyes
No one:
Me: pretending to be dead lying on my bed while waiting the Helena choreography part Lmao
So this is what happens when you take Gerard to a church
me and the boys at 3am on a cathedral.
me crying? no, why would i be doing that? but can we talk about ray’s vocals??? man i love him and he deserves more appreciation ❤
Dude, this sounds so eerie, but AMAZING!
2:11 - this.sounds.so.COOL!!!!
Play this at my funeral.
Its currently 4:30 in the morning, this is majestic
Omg the beginning is terrifying
This is the only reason I'd ever walk into a "holy place" willingly
Perfect harmony
why has this version of this song been stuck in my head 24/7
MMMMM how did i not come upon this sooner. my ears have been BLESSED
Thank you
Stop your crying helpless feeling. Because we are already ghosts in the fog.
This song live will break me
im obsessed with this 😭
Soul : Ascended