There is a lot of inconsistencies in this review. Not the same classes or engine types. Would have made a lot more sense if it was BMW X3 Vs. Audi Q5 Vs. Porsche Macan. All 4 cylinder.
yes defenetly also the video in general seems a bit like they didnt had much of an idea when it comes to cars. But yeah the fairest would have been q5 x3 and macan
bigb7965 that's what I thought. I'm wondering if the X5 won because of its hybrid-like gas mileage. Maybe it still would have won without a hybrid engine but perhaps you should have used such a vehicle, especially since this was a value-bias comparison. The Porsche and Audi here would never have a fair chance against this BMW.
How do you compare an X5 Hybrid with a Cayenne GTS vs Q5... You compare an X5 V8 twin turbo vs the cayenne gts or the cayenne turbo n X5M in the same class. That’s like asking my 11 year old son to take an arm wrestling challenge with the Rock.
The q5 is not in the same class as the other 2. It's compact sav. The q7 compares with the x5 and the cayenne. The q7 actually shares it's platform with the cayenne. Come on Bloomberg, do ur due diligence.
Are you serious Bloomberg? Yours is a brand name I really respect but this comparison video is absolute garbage. None of these cars are even in the same segment... The Audi Q5 compares to the BMW X3, so why did you pick an X5? Then you even have the ignorance to call an X5 comparatively roomy? Had you picked a Q7 like you should have (when comparing to X5) why would you take the X5 Hybrid??? You're now bringing in a completely new and different angle. At this point I can't even begin to comment on your choice of the Cayennne GTS .... GTS!!!! - are you serious? Do you know anything about the cars you're reviewing??? Super disappointing and definitely taking a hit to your brand here.
This is like an add for Bloomberg. You should use our service to determine the best information and present them accordingly, otherwise, you get a video comparing three different car segments, which doesnt make any sense at all. Only thing these three have in common is that they all have 4 wheels.
This video destroyed any credibility you might have given your brand name. The three "contestants" are not even trying to compete with each other. Someone who is looking at a Q5 is not going to be comparing it to a Porsche Cayenne (any trim level). Just because they are all loosely called "luxury SUV" does not mean they should be lumped together. Pure waste of time. Nice assignment though. Where can I get that job?
Nonsense test. Not even fair and square. It should have been the Audi Q7, not the Q5. And luxury SUV... where's the Volvo XC90, the favourite among rich mums?
Du gros n'importent qoui, ce duel est la même chose que prendre une twingo, une Morgane rs et une Ferrari, ils sont rien à voir les uns avec les autres, pour moi ce match est null, il faudrait prendre dans ce cas, audi q7 3l v6, x5 3l v6, cayenne 3l v6 pour que ce soit un vrai match
Reviewer must be off her rocker (or paid by BMW). She thinks the BMW is ONE THIRD better than the Audi? Because that's the difference in price. I look at those two cars and looks like a tossup. Why the hell would I spend 20k more for the beamer? Looks like crap inside by comparison. If you want "performance" calm down and realize you probably shouldn't be speeding with your kids in the car anyway.
Loss of 5 mins 30 seconds I will never get back. As already pointed out by lots of other people, this review is stupid and pointless. In the end I wondered if this review was a joke. Pathetic Bloomberg!! If you are going to group test cars, test like for like or at least test vaguely comparable cars.
I don't see any luxury vehicles here: they all use smelly, dirty gasoline, a 20th-century technology. Only Tesla Model X qualifies as luxury now. Sorry Porsche, BMW, or Audi -- but it's time to up your game.
Why would you compare a Q5 with the other two? It's a compact SUV. Audi Q7 is the one you should have used.
Just wanted to say that
But the Cayenne IS just another version of Q7, so it's already represented here.
goddesseddog Cayenne is just VW Tuareg on steroids
Then porsche macan should be used. Nonsense test
Yes and no: Tuareg + steroids = Q7; Q7 + HGH = Cayenne; Cayenne + cocaine = Bentayga
There is a lot of inconsistencies in this review. Not the same classes or engine types. Would have made a lot more sense if it was BMW X3 Vs. Audi Q5 Vs. Porsche Macan. All 4 cylinder.
yes defenetly also the video in general seems a bit like they didnt had much of an idea when it comes to cars. But yeah the fairest would have been q5 x3 and macan
or just using an sq5..
Why would you compare a standard SUV to a hybrid suv to a performance SUV?
bigb7965 that's what I thought. I'm wondering if the X5 won because of its hybrid-like gas mileage. Maybe it still would have won without a hybrid engine but perhaps you should have used such a vehicle, especially since this was a value-bias comparison. The Porsche and Audi here would never have a fair chance against this BMW.
And where's the all-electric SUV, Tesla Model X P100D?
bigb7965 yeah i agree, they shouldve used the 3.0 TDI Diesel Q5 which surpasses the X5. Oh well. all i I know is my Q5 TDI wrecks X5 on all aspects
You don't do Face-Off between a 97k and 41k SUV lol
You might have added the Prius for a much better comparison !
:)))))))
Did... did y'all just compare a Cayenne GTS to a Q5? Not even an SQ5? And a Q5 to an X5?
And you let the X5 win? LMAO.
SQ5 would keep up with the Porsche.
You know. . Q5 & X5 since they both have 5 in the name they must be comparable. Obviously they know nothing about cars.
@@Mk87019 Yep, and I guess a 5-Series is the A5's counterpart too
Next video: Fiat Panda vs McLaren P1 vs My bike
lmao nice one
How do you compare an X5 Hybrid with a Cayenne GTS vs Q5... You compare an X5 V8 twin turbo vs the cayenne gts or the cayenne turbo n X5M in the same class. That’s like asking my 11 year old son to take an arm wrestling challenge with the Rock.
Why would anyone compare a GTS with a hybrid X5 and a base Q5??! Hannah is SOOO INCOMPETENT!! Why isn't she fired yet? Does her dad own Bloomberg?
This test makes no sense. You have 3 SUVs from 3 different categories.
The q5 is not in the same class as the other 2. It's compact sav. The q7 compares with the x5 and the cayenne. The q7 actually shares it's platform with the cayenne. Come on Bloomberg, do ur due diligence.
???.They have chosen wrong cars to test.I didn't understand why they tested cars from different leagues. ???.
did you just say that iPhones are affordable?! wheres the lr4, wheres the xc90, wheres the range rover, wheres the merc, c'mon!
Looks to me like they asked to borrow some SUVs from the winery parking lot, and made this video.
The worst review ever.
I rarely make comments !
Very disappointed in Bloomberg.
This comparison is like comparing an apple with a lemon and a pear! 😳
Are you serious Bloomberg? Yours is a brand name I really respect but this comparison video is absolute garbage. None of these cars are even in the same segment... The Audi Q5 compares to the BMW X3, so why did you pick an X5? Then you even have the ignorance to call an X5 comparatively roomy? Had you picked a Q7 like you should have (when comparing to X5) why would you take the X5 Hybrid??? You're now bringing in a completely new and different angle. At this point I can't even begin to comment on your choice of the Cayennne GTS .... GTS!!!! - are you serious? Do you know anything about the cars you're reviewing??? Super disappointing and definitely taking a hit to your brand here.
This is like an add for Bloomberg. You should use our service to determine the best information and present them accordingly, otherwise, you get a video comparing three different car segments, which doesnt make any sense at all. Only thing these three have in common is that they all have 4 wheels.
This video destroyed any credibility you might have given your brand name. The three "contestants" are not even trying to compete with each other. Someone who is looking at a Q5 is not going to be comparing it to a Porsche Cayenne (any trim level). Just because they are all loosely called "luxury SUV" does not mean they should be lumped together. Pure waste of time. Nice assignment though. Where can I get that job?
There are SO many things wrong with this video I don't even know where to start!
In other news the BMW 7 Series is better than the Rolls Royce Phantom.
Okay but I'm actually concerned about her health
best bmw, beautiful
Lets compare 4x4s but not show you how well they perform off road or in the rain or on ice........
It looks grounded to the ground.
Great video !
Video is well done but as everyone has said...these cars are in different competitive classes. Btw...Cayenne GTS all day
Wow... unfortunately this "review" was an 'apples vs oranges' comparison and missed the mark completely. No bueno.
i LIKE BMW X5
Did she say the entire width of the ceiling?
And Porsche one of the first luxury car makers to introduce an SUV....?
I....just...can't...
You should have used the X3 instead, and not the hybrid engine. The SQ5 would make more sense to compare it with the Porsche Cayenne!
you compared a base level Audi, a hybrid BMW, and a sport version of a Porsche.. 🤦♂
Audi Q5 shouldn't be used in the same sentence as Porsche Cayenne and BMW X5!
Blasphemy!
BMW x5 has no business being in the same category of a Porsche Cayenne.
None of those are apple to apple comparisons. Not even close.
It wasn't a fair test. Next time test 3 cars on the same level. You simply describe 3 cars...
how come Q5 is in this comparison????
You should've added a bike, a ferrari and a bus to the comparison! Just for completefulness
Bad comparison, Audi Q5 is smaller segment. Both of those are competitors to the Q7. Which now I see why they had to use the Q5 😂
Nonsense test. Not even fair and square. It should have been the Audi Q7, not the Q5. And luxury SUV... where's the Volvo XC90, the favourite among rich mums?
I have to agree with many of the commenters here that this is not a fitting test by class or even price and you did not bring in the real competitors
And what about the lexus?? Quality is sooooooooo much better.
Where is the tesla model X?
What about reliability ????
I still think the q5 is a better vehicle out the bunch.
Lmao I hated this review
This video was sponsored by audi Q5 😂🤣
Crossovers, not SUVs
Without a Tesla X this test does not make sense
So BAD test. Next time compare them with your bicycle too :)
Should be q7
What's wrong with you?
It would be nice if you just take your glasses off, thank you.
Du gros n'importent qoui, ce duel est la même chose que prendre une twingo, une Morgane rs et une Ferrari, ils sont rien à voir les uns avec les autres, pour moi ce match est null, il faudrait prendre dans ce cas, audi q7 3l v6, x5 3l v6, cayenne 3l v6 pour que ce soit un vrai match
Pretty lame comparison. It's like apples vs. pears vs. oranges :(
At least we know that female motor journalists are great at what they do. This one is high😒
Fuck yeah
I will take a BMW X5 Hybrid! It seems to have the most sitting area, roomiest, and moderate price tag.
man what a lame inconsistent review. Re-do this review with my Q5 3.0 TDI and watch it wreck the X5 on all aspects
Unfair match
Reviewer must be off her rocker (or paid by BMW). She thinks the BMW is ONE THIRD better than the Audi? Because that's the difference in price. I look at those two cars and looks like a tossup. Why the hell would I spend 20k more for the beamer? Looks like crap inside by comparison. If you want "performance" calm down and realize you probably shouldn't be speeding with your kids in the car anyway.
Loss of 5 mins 30 seconds I will never get back. As already pointed out by lots of other people, this review is stupid and pointless. In the end I wondered if this review was a joke. Pathetic Bloomberg!! If you are going to group test cars, test like for like or at least test vaguely comparable cars.
WRONG! PORSCHE WIN$ ALL THE WAY AROUND RELIABILITY AND EXCELLENT RESALE VALUE OF ALL!
First mistake.. base model Q5.. vs top of the line Porsche and bmw... second mistake.. lady reviewing.. get back in the kitchen
No Tesla Model X? Disappointed....
tesla model x
useless comparison...... woman for you :)
Interior of the porsche looks incredibly dated..
I like BMW X5 and all the BMW cars and i hate AUDI and Porsche
comparing 3 overpriced ancient shitboxes from different category? I see what you doing there.
I don't see any luxury vehicles here: they all use smelly, dirty gasoline, a 20th-century technology. Only Tesla Model X qualifies as luxury now. Sorry Porsche, BMW, or Audi -- but it's time to up your game.