Death sentence for Shanghai primary school knife attacker
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 тра 2019
- Subscribe to our UA-cam channel for free here: sc.mp/subscribe-youtube
A knife-wielding man who killed two schoolboys in 2018 has been sentenced to death by a court in Shanghai, China.
The Shanghai No1 Intermediate People's Court handed down the sentence to Huang Yichuan on May 23, 2019. Also injured another child and an adult during his attack near the Shanghai World Foreign Language Primary School last June.
Follow us on:
Website: scmp.com
Facebook: / scmp
Twitter: / scmpnews
Instagram: / scmpnews
Linkedin: / south-china-morning-post
"to vent anger" so he just took out his anger on a bunch of little children by slaughtering them.. That's horrible
Still, giving murderers the death penalty is not right! They deserves to live like normal people. This is what human rights are for.
@@june6661 and so do the kids he killed. Dont they deserve justice..?
I do see where you're coming from but I just feel like it would be letting him off the hook after killing innocent children who had their whole lives ahead of them, he's already had his life and chance to live
@@june6661 oh my goodness imaging if your kids is the one he killed, what would you say
@@june6661 "they deserve to live like normal people". So they deserve to be a member of the general public after murdering children? Cmon now
@@june6661 Human rights have a certain threshold;limited in a sense of the severity of the crime being carried out.This clearly is the right choice made by China,u just cost the lives of two children and it is justifiable as he doesn't suffer from any mental issues etc.He did the crime due to not holding in his overwhelming inner emotions and tbh he should be better off rationalize and keep it to himself.
I love it when justice is dished out like that. Murderers should stop using mental illness as an excuse to escape the gallows. Your excuse is mental illness, but what about the victims? What do they have to deserve death?
Exactly. Mental illnesses are so easy to fake.
@@toyoyoyo104 rip
i condemn the action, but about your opinion. somoene called mentally ill because imo they dont think as normal people do.
@@godohembon5697 mentally ill people aren’t except from all reasoning unless they are clinically insane. Which this guy isn’t
Has he been executed yet
He is an ordinary criminal, the justice was done.
True
an*
*underrated comment*
You don't know that
What's ordinary about what he did? Idiot
Meanwhile in America there are shootings with dozens of lives lost and they blame video games.
Or blame mental illness
Darnell T. That’s a Bruh moment
If they do get the death sentence, it's followed by 30 years of appeals.
I blame the government for even allowing guns in the US licensed or not.
@@leon4903 mental illness is a big factor tbh. Doesn't take away from their horrific crime, but
perfectly mentally stable people aren't shooting up schools.
For once I agree with the Chinese legal system.
And you should agree for 10000000+ times that China execute drug dealers
They have had better legal system than America since 1990s.
It really shouldn't be "for once", as criminal laws in China (including Taiwan but excluding hk and Macau) is highly logical, due to being based on the Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (German Civil Code), which had a revolutionary impact throughout the world, on all aspects of law.
not "for once" at all
but the chinese legal system has a problem tho. most legal systems assume that youre innocent and people have to prove you guilty, while in china youre assumed guilty and you have to prove yourself innocent. proving yourself innocent is actually way harder than others proving you guilty sooo there will be misjudgments :(
Killed innocents and therefore gets killed. Sounds fair to me.
Hahahahahahahah
And they were kids aswell
@@user-wk2vv2wf6f Agree with sentence but kids shouldn't command more punishment....all lives, young or old are equally important!
E Miller killing a kid is way worse than killing an adult
E Miller So killing a 8 year old boy is the same as killing a 103 year old man on his death bed with stage 3 cancer set to die in a couple months?
LMFAOAOAAOAO!!!
We need this as mandatory punishment in America for school shooters.
Instead we say they’re misguided and misunderstood lolol.
TenTaur Tv lol
Basically any kinds of murderers.
The prison will be empty if all homicide hood ghetto gets death penalty. And some people will cry out loud for there defend knowing they are culprit and may possibly play race card too, so it's not possible sir. Specially in the great country like USA.
看来你们还是赞成死刑的，对吧？/ turns out American people r in favor of the use of capital punishment in certain cases , isn't it?
@@Qyu1000 hey idiot the majority of people in prison are in there for non violent offenses. like drug use.
that is how you run a court, everyone is respectful, even the guards. no one chit chatting, no one doing anything other that the job at hand.
@goku san i totally agree with you, but just one small question: why u lied?
@goku san Like the whole thing haha
@goku san In every country if you get arrested and charged for a crime you serve the necessary punishment? Most people did not call Trump a dictator for doing whats right? Where do you get that an army gets sent for wanting free speech? literally no one asks for that because people in China say whatever they want?
In Canada, he would get a pension and an apology from the PM for someone being mean to him, great work China.
Probably $30 million too!
😆😆 you guys are so right , out here in 🇨🇦 people rather go to jail then to live on the streets.
@@luckycharms1254 at least they get a roof and meals, living in the street during a canadian winter? no thx
Yeah, and 10 mil. (like they gave the isis terrorist who came back to Canada)
I think Canada's method should apply if he murdered those that were specifically mean to him first in the past. Since he killed innocent children that made no contribution to his sorrow, I agree with China's method.
At least china knows how to punish criminals in america this dude would have gotten served Burger King instead
LOL 😂
And if he lived California, he would’ve gotten a free apartment and free insurance
Chris M in ireland you get mcdonalds
@@gareto_ um no never happened, the Burger King thing did tho
In Italy a person who voluntarly runned over with his car some people, got to live in a hotel in front of a lake and also got to write a book 😂
I live in Shanghai and remember hearing this news... Absolutely horrific, two young children were killed with cold blood right beside their school gate.
it was also right before summer break
Hi.
Sorry it has been 5 yrs, but the SCMP video didn't explain why the killer was "venting anger".
Would appreciate it, if you can give me details.
In the US he would get 20 years and only serve 10.
and waste the US government's money while they could be helping out poor people like single mothers with children...
That's the reason why death sentence should still exist!
Whoa that's deep
Antimatter 3 well the man killed two children
fre _she true
I also love torturing cause it makes the feel the pain others felted.☺️
no it should not still exist the reason while hanging was stopped and death penalties in some countries is cos years later they found out they put wrong man to death
Liberals in the West: That knife attacker just needs a hug and a cookie!
China: Firing squad will sort you out
Somewhere in Berkeley Ca a SJW is weeping and holding a Candlelight Vigil for the killer...
Hard to disagree with tour logic.
China doesn't usually use firing squads. What they typically do is tie the guy up and shoot him in the back of the head. Saves time and effort.
Santa: I will take his hugs on cookie instead.
Conservatives in the west: that gun maniac should get more guns
Justice served
Love this kinda news...
Sad for the boys he killed.
The dudes death penalty was already carried out
The 1 dislike is him on death row...
Yeah if can use UA-cam behind the governments back at that point. It's blocked in China and government can probably identify his VPN.
@@Grassmpl if someone r/woooosh you it's the definition of cringe
RIP to the two children, though your lives will not come back even this guy is sentenced to death
Justice is done
Asthen Yukimori: If he was sentenced to life in prison he would not be able to harm other children.
@@cacampbell3654 If I'm a Chinese citizen, I won't be too fond of the idea that my tax money is going to be used to feed this guy for the rest of his life. If it's all the same, hot lead solves the problem faster and cheaper.
This death sentences I think in a sense, the parents of those poor children can be freed from hating this guy and the darkness that comes from hating him.
C A Campbell You can break out of prison. If you got 50-70 years you’ll find a way. But maybe you love the experience of your hard earned tax money funding a guy that killed children rather then helping the poor or funding new infrastructure. Nice 👍
That's the most organized court room I've ever seen
This is what I call JUSTICE. It is cathartic and brings closure to the victims' families, friends and serves as warning to others who might be thinking of trying the same thing...!
This is called 'revenge', not 'justice'.
Also, data clearly shows that death penalties do not work preventing crimes. Data also shows that many people get wrongfully convicted and executed, but I am pretty sure you don't mind that as long as you can see a bit of bloodshed disguised as 'justice'.
@@subject8332 Well, many people don't seem to mind it when the Yanks inflict a LOT of bloodshed disguised as "democracy". And data also shows that death penalties worked wonders in preventing drug trafficking. Under Mosaic Law, the families of victims are given the right to inflict "an eye for an eye"...
@@subject8332 Mmm ...no... the ancient Hebrews understood human nature better and got it right with Mosaic Law of an Eye for an Eye. Bloodshed can help a lot with the grieving & healing process. Only Christianity preaches turning the other cheek, not that it puts it into practise.
Justice served!
i wish the usa was like this, no games, eye for an eye
Off topic: Look at the height disparity between the criminal and the guards
Abolishing the death penalty is the dumbest thing a judicial system can do. Because there's no limit on the heinousness of the crime one can do, but you impose a limit on the maximum amount of punishment one can receive. That's not fair.
The UK abolished its death penalty because the last few people it killed turned out to be innocent.
So how was my court system?
troll
Noice
Poor children and those who got attacked and affected by this:<
You all have my prayers:<
Stay safe everyone!
Those shooters in America's schools should get the same punishment.
I really like how China doesn’t give people the rights to own guns, cause knifes can only hurt tens of people, but guns can hurt hundreds or even thousands
Yeah, imagine what this guy would have done if he had an AK-47. It would have been much worse.
Yea but then the people without guns won’t have any thing to defend themselves with
@@chinookh4713 You can much easier defend against a knife attack using your bare fists than a shooting with another gun
smokeSH guns are here to protect you and can be valuable against a tyrannical government China knows this. If they had guns Timmina square massacre. Would’ve been a lot different in addition many of similar events would be different
But the problem in China is, even many police on patrol don't carry guns, in most occations the most powerful weapon they carry is a baton. A month ago, a wanted man stabbed 2 police to death who was about to arrest him. In most countries, the suspect gets shot, but in China the police gets stabbed.
This is exactly how the criminal justice system should be done in America as well. The solid citizens of our country waste millions of taxpayers money keeping these dirtbags fed, clothed, and sheltered-not to mention they also get a free college education. So where is the punishment in that???
Please US take a note in reference to human trafficking and to get rid of the pedophiles, in particular in Hollywood ...
Noted
and in politics and science (hint follow epsteins money trail)
people ARE LAUGHING AT UR PRESIDENT AND UR COUNTRY
Indeed
He should have been given to the parents of the victims. They deserve that much.
Does vengeance restore happiness or do it make pain grow deeper?
Vengeance doesn’t bring your loved ones back
@@MrTuxy depends on the person. Sometimes revenge is necessary to heal
My mom once drove over a already dead cat and she couldn’t sleep for 2 days
How did she know it was already dead?
@@teabag1165 She thought she finished the injured cat?
He deserved it, truly horrifying story. Praying for the healing of the children's families.
And people say criminals should have the same human rights.....they shouldn't because losing the rights is the price they pay.
100% people forget that human right comes with human responsibility, if you break it you void it
In Hong Kong, if He shouted "Democracy", those rioters would say "Police Brutality".
The guy who murdered his pregnant girlfriend is walking freely on Hong Kong street, how ironic.
@@xinliu8472 exactly! yet people shouting "liberate HK" without any mention of the root cause of this whole chaos
@@xinliu8472 like i see no shortcoming with having all criminals punished to the extent that they deserve
Wait so In a country with no guns there was still a school attack with multiple casualties?
There's always ways to get guns.
Imagine if he has access to guns. It won't only be 2 kids.
This incident really shocked me because I went to the same place and exited at the same time 2 days prior for an "interview" to get a place in the school. It was clearly horrible luck for those poor children and their parents and my deepest condolences for all those affected
excellent result.
It deserves nothing less.
`It`, yes, ` it` because for sure it does not belong to the human race.
Greetings from the UK.
I noticed that they didn’t first treat him to a cheeseburger and a pop like they did with Dylan Roof. Strange, these Chinese.
Lol empty calories makes dying more enjoyable?
*His eyes are so dead*
Just like mine
Justice! the man deserved it!
That spells the word JUSTICE.
I bet his sentence was carried out in a week not 10 plus years...
People have been proven innocent after spending years on death row, it might not be the best idea to rush the process.
No, he was executed on 3 Dec 2020, about one year after the appeal.
Justice has been served!
The United States should learn from Chinese legal sanctions
Look at their court room and legal system. Very structured and proper. Justice is done. He is a murderer like any other, the victims cannot be brought back.
He should have done that in Canada. He'll get a playstation 5 while in prison, and a kiss from Trudeau.
China: school knife attack
America: I HAVE A GUN
Meanwhile in america a school shooter just gets 5 years in prison...
This channel was cool but its too short
Mini_Icon but they post like 30 videos a day
This is better, straight to the point and accurate this is how news supposed to be, if you want to wasting your time CNN and Fox has the right formula
if this was America, he would be sentenced 5-10 years in jail only.
careful ur comment might start school shooting *proud muricans intensifies
No, he would get life without parole
I'm really not used to seeing a tribunal in a criminal court... it's weird.
Their courts look really strict and scary. More intimidating than the U.S ones
Because our justice system is a joke!!!
ah you see the difference is that one of them is a place where punishment is handed out to criminals, and the other is a reality show
Correct sentence for heinous crimes
I actually went to the same school when I was in 1st grade through 3rd
Oh man I was there when I was in first grade. What year did you attend your first grade? I might know you.
I don’t get why the death sentence, that’s just a way out, but if you let him rot in prison it’s more of a punishment
You see, the thing is that when u severely punish a person for a crime, provided that its broadcasted across the nation, no one will ever gonna do it
If all of America allows death sentence, the crime rate will drop drastically. Yes, those sentence to death may not have a second chance, but they are part of a reminder for people contemplating to commit the crime, to not do it
Heng Yu Hen Exactly so many people say its not right but fear is the only deterrent that works 99% of the time.
If "no one will ever gonna do it", why did this guy do it?
Those police are so tall, they're like a foot taller than him
The average height in China is usually pretty short. If you're like 5'9 you look really tall relative to everyone else.
If only Tatooine's legal system was like that. Then there would be no Darth Vader.
Does Tatooine even have a legal system?
Agree with this sentence. Insanity should be a defense for some crimes but not when it results in the loss of life.
dude looks like he just woke up from a nap lol
The crazy thing is, this happens quite often in China. There have been many, many cases like this in China.
The population there is huge.
He looks like he doesn't think he deserves this.
And that's sad.
The human mind is biased to itself, every human is affected to varying degrees.
That is the likely explanation, as people are more accepting of arguements that support their side than the other.
It takes great mental will to admit that you are wrong.
@@leehongjin6884 I mean, look at flat earthers.
That is one of the reasons there is very little violent crime in China. The punishment is severe and swift. This combined with drugs offences also being punished very hard leads to a safer society in general. In my 13 years in China now I have never felt scared or in danger when walking the street late at night. They do have scams and pick pockets, but very little person on person crimes.
We need to utilize the death penalty more often
He deserves it. I wish there was more death sentences for these sort of criminals, especially serial rapists and murderers
justice
This is even much more tragic if you realize the boys were probably Only-children and were the most precious thing their parents had
No sympathy for murders.
and when will there be a punishment for the big oil companies that are killing the planet
Meanwhile Colorado movie theater shooter is sipping coffee while doing life...
The fact that he planned it makes it so much worse
You can see how evil his eyes is
Great move to minimize overpopulation and opens room for those who deserve to live
@@Azamatcomments nah, dont give me that bs. Some ppl are just dont deserve their life when they took others easily.
@@Azamatcomments then lay it out man, those solution you talking abt, along the way also find a better way to console the families who lost their loved one.
An eye for an eye, a hand for a hand. Justice should be done for the loss of those poor souls.
That guy has watched too much Adventure Time.
Both the attacks and this sentencing. Very scary! I wouldn't want to be in the shoes of his victims or himself!
Outstanding, only sentence that was fitting for the crime.
For some reason I was expecting like a British announcer to speak
Why?
Justice
Death by fire ants I say.
California would love to take in a person like him
No 20 years of Appeal?
Fun Fact: I was living in shanghai when this happened
You know after they walked him out the door they shot him
Child killer are a burden on earth
Very swift justice too. Compared to courts in the U.S. and Europe.. the court trials can take years!
Some people just don't deserve a second chance.
Those uniforms and that clean court room.
China popo uses the same uniform throughout the country. That's the winter outfit and is the one that looks cool. The summer ones look much lamer but from a practical standpoint it works.
Children? 😡🤬
Applause for China from Australia!
Here in the PH is total opposite the comission on human rights will ask the court to forgive the suspect and to be set FREE...
I once studied in the primary school he attacked. By the way I'm 15 now.
Nice
Even though firearms are strictly banned in China mainland all these years, the perpetrators can harm innocent people with blades.The same in the UK.
Evil!
That’s how to lower crime rates.
His eyes looks like mine .. so empty and angry .. i feel no emphaty for him so to the others
Cringe
@@saiyanwatch3630 yeah i know
Zhark Faye: I have a suggestion if you’d like to hear it?
@@cacampbell3654 what
Zhark Faye: Find the help you need to restore your love of life and yourself.
Eye for an eye
I worked at the middle school when this happened . 💐