Taking Poletown: A Community’s Fight Over Economic Justice & Eminent Domain

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 39

  • @johnkomlos3698
    @johnkomlos3698 2 роки тому +4

    I grew up on Sargent Street, (Milwaukee & E Grand Blvd, by St. John's) all my life from 54 to 74 when I left town, and just before the big bust. Everything went to hell right after I left. I'm living in Hamtramck now, walking distance from where I grew up. Odd driving past there with only vague landmarks left. When they said you can never go back, holy cow, they weren't kidding.

  • @davidwronski7076
    @davidwronski7076 3 роки тому +9

    I was born in 1943 and lived in Poletown on East Grand Boulevard up until leaving in 1968 to live in another city. I remember Poletown as a tight-knit, well-kept neighborhood. Chene street was a bustling commercial area. Immaculate Conception Church was my church and parochial school. The images in the video show a rather decrepit-looking area, nothing like the well-kept Polish family homes of my youth. Returning in 2003 I was shocked at the sights of blight in the city in general. The portion of Poletown not taken by GM centered around the beautiful St. Hyacinth Parish Church is now almost as vacant as farmland. I read now currently the prospect of a repurposed Packard Factory on East Grand Boulevard near Mt. Elliot is not off the table. It'll come back. Just a matter of time. And, will.

    • @211212112
      @211212112 3 роки тому +1

      Sad. I don’t think it will come back. Manufacturing has moved to the south and is more spread out. I see the plant was set to close. Figured. But after saying everything negative they could about Elon Musk, and hampering Tesla in every way they plan to build EV trucks at the Poletown plant. If they had took their head out their arse the Poletown plant could have five to ten years of EV building experience already.
      I remember Polish, Italian, Greek, and other tight knit culture based neighborhoods in Chicago. The food omg! But more than that they had real community. That is almost impossible to find now.
      Was there no land just outside the city near interstates, railways, and the lake? I’m sure there was. What harm would come from locating the plant five miles away in an area that is crop, pasture, Forrest, swamp, etc?

  • @purplespeckledappleeater8738
    @purplespeckledappleeater8738 2 роки тому +10

    The destruction of Poletown is legend in SE Michigan. Completely unjust.

  • @Anthony-rm4bd
    @Anthony-rm4bd 2 роки тому +2

    Sad day for me 1981 I lived on Mitchell and Milwaukee went to Park Elementary. I Love the neighborhood it was tight knit.

  • @matthewholmes4350
    @matthewholmes4350 3 роки тому +3

    This is a striking and insightful look into the concept of eminent domain.
    First, it takes an incident that’s impersonal for most of us and personalizes it: the right of the government to appropriate private property (generally for public use). This story raises powerful questions…What if this happened to me? To my family? To my community? These questions are worth asking because this could happen to any of us.
    Second, it lays bare the fact that the “law” is determined and interpreted by the powerful. Does a legal action necessarily always have moral or logical merit? Empirically, we don’t have to look far through history…the answer is clearly “no”. The abomination that was slavery was once legal in the U.S. and around the world.
    Ultimately, this instance of “eminent domain” failed the textbook definition of that very concept because it appropriated private property and transferred that property to a private recipient: a corporation.
    I really enjoyed this piece. It was informative and made me think. Thanks for sharing.

  • @godskid1100
    @godskid1100 3 роки тому +3

    I used to live around the area of St.Hyancinth church.Mitchell & Kirby nothing but empty land there now.Used to br a nice little community. I knew people who lived in the poletown area.

  • @nanibooboo3816
    @nanibooboo3816 3 роки тому +4

    My hometown.

  • @MimiKeel
    @MimiKeel 3 роки тому +3

    Great video.

  • @timdinkins2812
    @timdinkins2812 Місяць тому

    The destruction of poletown was devastating to all of us who grew up in that area, it caused the Closings and demolition of Park elementary, Greusel jr high school & Northeastern high school because of enrollment number decline and mostly homes were loss to many long time residents.

  • @thor800
    @thor800 2 роки тому +1

    the ironic part is that GM probably bought these properties at the height of market at that time

  • @briliantinrushiti380
    @briliantinrushiti380 2 роки тому

    Awesome.

  • @johnf6687
    @johnf6687 2 роки тому +2

    No due process

  • @netabaughman3079
    @netabaughman3079 2 роки тому

    Rosa Kori talked of Forensic Real Estate Appraisal

  • @mightyducks5867
    @mightyducks5867 3 роки тому +1

    I lived here, they paid my dad 3k for his house back then

    • @ohill5703
      @ohill5703 3 роки тому +1

      I was always hoping for them to pay us for our home it was so dangerous I wanted to move out so bad tired of the robbing and mugging and raping

  • @johnf6687
    @johnf6687 2 роки тому

    I don’t have a problem with taking the property but the owner does have the right to a comparable sale price home + pain and suffering

  • @michaelwauschektechnoshama8259
    @michaelwauschektechnoshama8259 2 роки тому

    The untold story

  • @toddprater14
    @toddprater14 9 місяців тому

    Lives in Detroit and drives a subaru

  • @Blackmachismoo
    @Blackmachismoo 2 роки тому

    It's not complicated.

  • @the2dtvlogreport-theddreamsInc
    @the2dtvlogreport-theddreamsInc 2 роки тому

    "If he wins, he is going to jail". God to me in 2015, on the night of the elections, while I slept & He lifted me up & those words came out of my mouth. How do I know it was God & not speaking as I woke up?
    1. I felt my body set up & the felt my move & heard those words & then I opened my eyes & asked: "If who win & he is going to jail?" & then I said: "dump? that fool better not win" & went back to sleep.
    2. I was sure Hillary had that. America voted for a black dude, 2 times. Why not a white woman, now? I also saw how the Michigan republicans stole it: "I need you to go down the county building & verify your identity".
    Yep, I was about to beat him up. I put both fists on the table & said: "I ain't going nowhere until I vote".
    He must have seen the seriousness of what was about to happen to him & he called over & elder white woman, his supervisor, & she called the county & started "cake mixing" over the phone with the county & I barked: "MY ID IS ON MY ID" Then she asked the county person: "oh, he can vote?"
    Look, I ain't about violence but there are certain things I would kick your butts over. My family. My body. My works. My vote. My people & 3 (1 black & 2 whites) have lost lives over the right for me to vote & messing with it, is like they are continuing to spit on their graves.
    Not on my watch.
    After I got through checking everybody in that mug, I turned to see a line full of black & brown people filling up from the line "I" had them create to call the county, instead of me leaving. Knowing people would leave & not come back.
    And a vlog episode I had done months prior where God saw it & I said: "If this dude wins, the rest of the world would think we are a nation full of douchebags" & I also said: "If he wins, I ain't gonna do The D Dreams Inc".
    God heard that & He wanted me to not worry about him taking credit for its results because he gonna be in jail soon because he won.
    Taking credit? Yes, that is why I haven't called or typed his name since, because I knew he made money on his name & I didn't want to help with that & I knew if he won, his supporters would give the credit to him & put it into books & do what I had supposed had done for doing it under President Obama & cause his image on Mt. Rushmore.
    With what God has given me to do, this was have made them do that for him & YO! If you think I'ma douchebag now, piss me off like that? So, I didn't push as hard as I wanted to, under the dump. But I kept creating & soon I am finna do.
    Taking credit for other people's works is what hate does, just like he & they did of President Obama's economy in about a few months after their stealing aka "winning". Look it up.
    These people are complaining about an election being stolen & they actually have actually stolen it. Twice. And trying to do it some more, at the local levels.
    That is why I know it was God & not me.
    wins, he is going to jail & he won, didn't he? So all of this evidence coming out is no surprise to me.
    I kind of expected it.

    • @the2dtvlogreport-theddreamsInc
      @the2dtvlogreport-theddreamsInc 2 роки тому

      @@M0dernArcher My pills? Do you not think karma, to the heathen, aka, God's "whoopings" isn't real?
      The Bible says we are to beat our son with the rod & save his soul from hell.
      Do you think 45 has ever gotten whoopings, growing up?
      Nope, so he has never learned that there are consequences to bad behavior.
      So, he came into the "white peoples' house, illegally" & left illegally & committed theft on his way outL "It's not there's, it's mine" is what was report of him saying to a Staff member.
      Sounds like somebody hasn't learn to hear "no"? I am judging that man too much, right now, but I am trying to make a point.
      I can count over 15 crimes this man has done while in office & he hasn't gotten a "whooping" for it, yet.
      However, I do know if America doesn't give him a whooping, he will doomed you people.
      That Maga? Yep, once he gets out of hands, the people would rise & you then could find yourselves running out of bullets & bombs.
      Then what? You daydram of a race war or civil war when it was God Who had "whooped" America with the firts one.
      Because of slavery against His Tribe of Judah. Black People.
      He punished both sides to had the North & the South to lose 620,000 American men in this nation's soil, all because of sin & mistreatment of other human beings.
      Yet, today? You can't even say: "Black Lives Matter". So, if the USA doesn't hold him & all that helped him commit these crimes, it would show the kids that it is all a lie.
      Then? They might take to the streets & not just downtown either.
      And they're good thieves, they might steal all of those guns & bullets you have saved up?
      However, I already know, he will get a whooping because the Lord thought it was important enough to tell me about it.
      On the night he stole it. Thanks to the "some people" who had power in these states?
      God saw all of it & He is also seeing your support of it?

  • @moriahshiddat4420
    @moriahshiddat4420 2 роки тому

    This is so unethical that's the problem the city always prioritized industry over the people at the expense of long-term community development.

  • @David53D
    @David53D 2 роки тому

    Did anyone catch a glimps of Joe Biden involved in the negociation arount 7 min in?