@james Deer Hahahaha you are clueless about irony dude The irony is that the people who actually performed the songs and can can actually sing them, are lip syncing in this video.
Hasta los muertos se paran a bailar con este super ritmo, excelentes voces de Real Milli Vanilli pero los Milli Vanilli (Fab Morvan y Rob Pilatus) eran un mejor espectáculo, eran el toque especial, extrovertidos, cierto hacían playback pero por algo fueron y seguirán siendo un FENOMENO MUNDIAL ¡¡ Gracias por compartir.
yo recuerdo que solo cantaron una canción en el festival acapulco 91 que fue keep on running,,,,no recuerdo que esta cancion la pasaran por la TV,,pero no cabe duda que Rob Y Fab eran mejores aunque no cantaran...lastima que historia tan triste de los milli vanilli
Lo que paso con este grupo demuestra que lo mas importante es el talento estos tenían las voces y los otros el baile todos juntos hubieran construido en gran grupo.
Well said @nightdreamin! I don't understand either why they were lip syncing at a festival. As the "REAL" MV it should have been a piece of cake to create the original sound....... ; )
Exactly! ;) This whole ''Real'' milli vanilli theme is strange because gina and rayland not to the real singers include. Belonging intended only for the real milli vanilli, because they look good for the audience, just as with rob and fab. I would have liked it if the real singer and rob and fab cooperated, it would have sight on long perhaps brought more and not for only 2-3 years :)
The real milli vanilli eran unos falsos; tanto criticar a Rob & Fab y mira, ellos también hacían playback, y en vivo un concierto con ellos es un aburrimiento, al contrario que Rob & Fab que bailaban, tenían coreografias, y en la mayoria de los conciertos el playback casi no se notaba
+Dani N Fan pues el detalle es que ellos hacian la musica y la cantaban ..y eso no se puede cambiar eso ah sido siempre en la historia de la musica pero el detalle es que los pescaron con la mano en el grammy ,,y tanto no se notaba como dices que por eso los pescaron por no hacer bien un play back ..como vez
Lo importante es que canten bien y nos hagan disfrutar . los falsos o los verdaderos à mi me Gustan los dos Los dos grupos tenian sus propios talentos .
Hola real villi vanilli porque ustedes no cantaron en los ochentas con su voz verdadera porque se ocultaron tanto tiempo en escucharlos en verdad con su voz propia de cada uno de los cantantes yo lo admiro a todos ustedes por su trayectoria como cantantes famosos y cuando vienen en el Perú para hacer conciertos en vivos y en directo
If u come to think about it if it wasn't for fab and rob we would have never known this amazing songs even thought they were not the real voices it was there sexy bodys there charm that made thi songs but it shows that is mess up that the original voices made not have been what the audience wants..lets focus more on the music not looks.
Everything I have seen from the "real" milli vanilli is ALSO clear lip synching! You would think that type of thing would be "off the table" after the whole "rob and fab" thing.
But at least it was their actual voices doing the singing this time (regardless of whether they were really singing live, which they clearly weren't here), and not pretending to do so to someone else's like Rob & Fab were though. ;)
To all the people saying that they are hypocrites for lip syncing, its their shit. They made their shit. They can do whatever they want with their shit. As for Rob and Fab, its NOT their shit. They DID NOT make their shit and thats the way it is. There is a difference between YOUR SHIT and NOT YOUR SHIT.
@ 1:05 fist pump and finger shoot while playing the keyboard singing the best part of this groups history. This guy was cooler in four seconds than I will be in my entire life.
El farsante fue ese productor para mí Rob y Fab siempre serán Milli Vanilli muchos los preferimos pues ya nos encariñamos con ellos y a quien no de le partió el corazón cuando Rob se suicidó
Well Ramos não, porque a Gina Mohammed e o Ray Horton não cantam nada nessa música mas eles estão no palco. A Gina está dublando os vocais da Jodie e da Linda Rocco e o Ray está dublando os vocais de Brad Howell (o cara de óculos escuros). Os vocalistas dessa música são: John Davis, Brad Howell, Linda Rocco, Jodie Rocco e Frank Farian.
nada que ver con Rob y Fab, ellos tenían un carisma para interpretar y sus bailes hacían que la canción llegue más al público y lo complementaban con lo guapos que eran, aunque no cantaran Rob y Fab por siempre Milli Vanilli....
este es un claro ejemplo que la verdad siempre sale tarde que temprano, por muchas envidias milli vanilli resulto un mal negocio al final para la productora y los reales milli vanilli, por que no quisieron arriesgarse y prefirieron vender imagen y show ese fue su gran error ,tal vez si hubieran intentado ellos sobresalir hubieran pegado siendo realistas la música es muy pegajosa no hubiera sido quizás un gran éxito pero al menos serian ellos desde un principio, y paso que llego el éxito mundial y ahí si no les gusto nada y decidieron a echar a perder todo, acabando con la vida de uno de ellos ,no valió la pena nada de lo que hicieron todos siempre recordaremos a rob y fab.
+leon kali Lo que pasa es que Pilatus no cantaba muy bien que digamos, y ambos hablaban muy mal el inglés. Tal vez mejorando esos aspectos hubieran funcionado, pero no hubieran tenido el éxito que tuvieron. Creo que acá se trató de que la unión hizo la fuerza, porque Rob y Fab tenían carisma e imagen, pero las voces de los feos eran especiales
notan q la mayoria de los comentarios prefiere a rob y fab, la imagen vende muchisimo por eso es q el productor sabia q con la voces no era suficiente para entrar al mercado yo no estoy a favor de lo q hizo ese fraude pero se hicieron famosos tristemente... engañemonos escuchando y viendo a rob y fab como los cantantes originales ;D
look at 1:20 what a beautiful girl, would she even imagine at that moment that almost 35 years later some random guy miles away would be admiring her beauty... thats how casual life is
After listening to Rob and Fab and the so called real milli vanilli. I feel that there’s a real guy who was the real singer but we will never know only the producer who did all this scam.
This was so wrong of Farian to do. He should have had all people involved, including Fab and Rob, for this tour. It would have been a good feel good thing to do to make up for what he did and everyone would have come out winning (including Fab and Rob, and the fans). This was a slap in the face to Fab and Rob!!! Probably increased their mental health issues!!!
small guy with small Sorry, but it just doesn't happen. You ALWAYS hear something if in fact they are singing live, such as breathing in the microphone, or reverb from background sound. NOT happening here.
yes it is happening they are hyping the crowd through the microphone you can hear it. you can hear them yelling and stuff at the same time they are singing . they say make some noise, come on etc etc.
GeekBoy03 Yes they are lip syncing but its their own shit. They made this. Rob and Fab stole their shit so there is a difference between lip syncing to someone else's shit and lip syncing to your own shit.
Great song, but something just seems a little bit "off" about this, with showing the real singers, instead of Rob & Fab dancing/performing to it though. That despite even if it still sounds exactly the same as before however! (L.O.L.!)
There is a reason they were back stage, they never compare to those two beautiful men Rob and Fab what made Milli Vanilli famous was those two perfect faces of Rob and Fab not this ugly people
The presentation and appearance of the fake milli vanilli is what matter not the real ones, the look of the not real milli was what they where looking for, the pretty look that all😁😁😁😁
Ya sabiamos que eran los originales pero si apoco nos creian estupidos y en ese programa TODOS HACIAN PLAYBACK por que asi era Siempre en Domingo ellos seran los unicos en Mèxico.
So weird seeing the real musicians performing this song and not the 'faces' of Milli Vanilli. It's like they're taking a song from the 'real' artists. Like a cover band. Strange.
The "real" Milli Vanilli, on stage, dancing, lipsyching. Ironic.
@james Deer Ray Horton had no part in the original album yet lip syncs over the vocals of the songs especially Keep on Runnin’
@@rohanquinn exactly. Also Gina Mohammed
Exactly lol. And look how nuts the people in the audience are getting down lol
@james Deer You don't understand irony. lol
@james Deer Hahahaha you are clueless about irony dude The irony is that the people who actually performed the songs and can can actually sing them, are lip syncing in this video.
Hasta los muertos se paran a bailar con este super ritmo, excelentes voces de Real Milli Vanilli pero los Milli Vanilli (Fab Morvan y Rob Pilatus) eran un mejor espectáculo, eran el toque especial, extrovertidos, cierto hacían playback pero por algo fueron y seguirán siendo un FENOMENO MUNDIAL ¡¡ Gracias por compartir.
estos tambien hicieron PLAYBACK que no lo notastes?
I miss Rob and Fab a lot!!!
Even if they never sang at all though?
When I close my eyes hearing this song here, only two faces shows up in my mind...
Lol, same here :)
The faces of two clowns lol
hahahah yup, two clowns that made more money that you could do in you entire life.
And more money that you will ever see Rosangela too
moron
Rob&Fab forever!
Even then the real singers are off cue, probably one of the most painful scandals of all time..
I love how no one notices this is the studio recording.
WTF? Even the real singer is totally lipsincing! I really want to hear they performing live for Milli Vanilli songs
xhemexx he meant that the real singers are even lip syncing a a live performance. But then again, a lot of pop acts did
If they're lipsyncing they're doing it to their own voices.
raymann lol “if”. Yes, these are the real people (well the guys on keyboard and guitar), but the studio recording is playing
the bass player even know what is a bass
para mi villi manilli seran siempre rob y fab
Rob and Fab are the real Milli Vanilli to me
No
Ron y Fab por siempre los mejores fueron y serán ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Rob & Fab only
yo recuerdo que solo cantaron una canción en el festival acapulco 91 que fue keep on running,,,,no recuerdo que esta cancion la pasaran por la TV,,pero no cabe duda que Rob Y Fab eran mejores aunque no cantaran...lastima que historia tan triste de los milli vanilli
Fab and Rob are the real Milli vanilli to me,the Drummer is fantastic lol
Drummer should have stayed with Rob and Fab.
1:21 Grandma was in the groove!!
Te pasas de verga homi😂😂😂
😂
Lo que paso con este grupo demuestra que lo mas importante es el talento estos tenían las voces y los otros el baile todos juntos hubieran construido en gran grupo.
I don't care what happens now or then. this is real and they made many memory's for everyone who hear their music. my credit to them .. Thank You
ROB & FAB THE BEST!!!
Well said @nightdreamin! I don't understand either why they were lip syncing at a festival. As the "REAL" MV it should have been a piece of cake to create the original sound....... ; )
Exactly! ;) This whole ''Real'' milli vanilli theme is strange because gina and rayland not to the real singers include. Belonging intended only for the real milli vanilli, because they look good for the audience, just as with rob and fab. I would have liked it if the real singer and rob and fab cooperated, it would have sight on long perhaps brought more and not for only 2-3 years :)
The real milli vanilli eran unos falsos; tanto criticar a Rob & Fab y mira, ellos también hacían playback, y en vivo un concierto con ellos es un aburrimiento, al contrario que Rob & Fab que bailaban, tenían coreografias, y en la mayoria de los conciertos el playback casi no se notaba
Dani N Fan yes...
+Dani N Fan pues el detalle es que ellos hacian la musica y la cantaban ..y eso no se puede cambiar eso ah sido siempre en la historia de la musica pero el detalle es que los pescaron con la mano en el grammy ,,y tanto no se notaba como dices que por eso los pescaron por no hacer bien un play back ..como vez
+Jodie Rocco
Nowadays no famous singer sings live except Elton John and opera singers.
Fortunately, this is going to change :-)
Lo importante es que canten bien y nos hagan disfrutar . los falsos o los verdaderos à mi me Gustan los dos Los dos grupos tenian sus propios talentos .
Después de ver estos payasos mw,quedó con fab & rob😍😍😍
Hola real villi vanilli porque ustedes no cantaron en los ochentas con su voz verdadera porque se ocultaron tanto tiempo en escucharlos en verdad con su voz propia de cada uno de los cantantes yo lo admiro a todos ustedes por su trayectoria como cantantes famosos y cuando vienen en el Perú para hacer conciertos en vivos y en directo
playback yes!
Sad again.... They were all singing to all a Playback!!!!!
If u come to think about it if it wasn't for fab and rob we would have never known this amazing songs even thought they were not the real voices it was there sexy bodys there charm that made thi songs but it shows that is mess up that the original voices made not have been what the audience wants..lets focus more on the music not looks.
excelente me encantan esas voces
I always loved their music, and Brad sounds awesome when he comes in on this song.
La gente hacía los pasos de Rob y Fab.. LoL 🎶
Seeeee
Jajajaja mal
Everything I have seen from the "real" milli vanilli is ALSO clear lip synching! You would think that type of thing would be "off the table" after the whole "rob and fab" thing.
But at least it was their actual voices doing the singing this time (regardless of whether they were really singing live, which they clearly weren't here), and not pretending to do so to someone else's like Rob & Fab were though. ;)
Will the true artist be ever known?
Adelantados a su tiempo.
Honestly rob and fab were showman they are part of milli vanilli as the real singers fire !
To all the people saying that they are hypocrites for lip syncing, its their shit. They made their shit. They can do whatever they want with their shit. As for Rob and Fab, its NOT their shit. They DID NOT make their shit and thats the way it is. There is a difference between YOUR SHIT and NOT YOUR SHIT.
@ 1:05 fist pump and finger shoot while playing the keyboard singing the best part of this groups history. This guy was cooler in four seconds than I will be in my entire life.
Probably his entire life too lol
Real Milli who?
El farsante fue ese productor para mí Rob y Fab siempre serán Milli Vanilli muchos los preferimos pues ya nos encariñamos con ellos y a quien no de le partió el corazón cuando Rob se suicidó
It's just not the same....
So the real singers lip sync too??
+Jesus Saves Everybody lip syncs, at least at the superstar level. The scrubs playing tiny clubs are really singing.
That's mainly due to keeping the song going when you are performing and running out of breathe. A lot of times they sing with the backing track
Christopher White they could be, but the track is clearly overlaying any voices we could be hearing.
aquí estoy porque quería escuchar e imaginar que están Rob y bob
Todos los del grupo son excelentes
I love this performance.
+Ashley Williams theyarealsolipsyncing
what r u slow? this performance sux
playback sim,yes
Para mim Milli Vanilli mesmo ter sido uma farsa, continuo a amar Fab e Rob no palco, domínio total
Critican a milli vanilli., y estos también hacen play back.
Aqui, se realmente for playback, é deles mesmos; os outros dublavam outras vozes.
Well Ramos Mas era uma sacanagem as pessoas irem nos shows pra ouvir playback kk
Well Ramos não, porque a Gina Mohammed e o Ray Horton não cantam nada nessa música mas eles estão no palco. A Gina está dublando os vocais da Jodie e da Linda Rocco e o Ray está dublando os vocais de Brad Howell (o cara de óculos escuros). Os vocalistas dessa música são: John Davis, Brad Howell, Linda Rocco, Jodie Rocco e Frank Farian.
@@miguelmusicajw das gêmeas né
@@davim.barbosa8908 sim
nada que ver con Rob y Fab, ellos tenían un carisma para interpretar y sus bailes hacían que la canción llegue más al público y lo complementaban con lo guapos que eran, aunque no cantaran Rob y Fab por siempre Milli Vanilli....
Que bien que suenan!!!
este es un claro ejemplo que la verdad siempre sale tarde que temprano, por muchas envidias milli vanilli resulto un mal negocio al final para la productora y los reales milli vanilli, por que no quisieron arriesgarse y prefirieron vender imagen y show ese fue su gran error ,tal vez si hubieran intentado ellos sobresalir hubieran pegado siendo realistas la música es muy pegajosa no hubiera sido quizás un gran éxito pero al menos serian ellos desde un principio, y paso que llego el éxito mundial y ahí si no les gusto nada y decidieron a echar a perder todo, acabando con la vida de uno de ellos ,no valió la pena nada de lo que hicieron todos siempre recordaremos a rob y fab.
+albertojimenes365 hubieran perdurado con la verdad desde el principio acompañando de buenos bailarines e imagen tremendo error de mercadeo.
+leon kali Lo que pasa es que Pilatus no cantaba muy bien que digamos, y ambos hablaban muy mal el inglés. Tal vez mejorando esos aspectos hubieran funcionado, pero no hubieran tenido el éxito que tuvieron. Creo que acá se trató de que la unión hizo la fuerza, porque Rob y Fab tenían carisma e imagen, pero las voces de los feos eran especiales
Rob and Fab had charisma and even they cheated, fans will always love them ❤️ ♥️
This guys were good enough to make it. Look at everyone having a good time. Too bad how this whole thing went down.
Las voces sin duda son las que mandan....
Show muito bom este som
notan q la mayoria de los comentarios prefiere a rob y fab, la imagen vende muchisimo por eso es q el productor sabia q con la voces no era suficiente para entrar al mercado yo no estoy a favor de lo q hizo ese fraude pero se hicieron famosos tristemente... engañemonos escuchando y viendo a rob y fab como los cantantes originales ;D
+Joel Dante Pauccar Guerrero cierto pero hay caminos diferentes a mentir pudieron integrar los modelos bailarines al grupo en lugar de mentir
These guys were slip syncing too. In that case I would have preferred to see fab and rob dancing xd...
Los reales
look at 1:20 what a beautiful girl, would she even imagine at that moment that almost 35 years later some random guy miles away would be admiring her beauty... thats how casual life is
Talent is much more important than image...and i repeat those guys have really talent
After listening to Rob and Fab and the so called real milli vanilli. I feel that there’s a real guy who was the real singer but we will never know only the producer who did all this scam.
A pesar de ser los verdaderos hacen playback... Ni bailan.... Los verdaderos siempre serán Rob and fab..
Sem Rob e Fab ñ tem graça nehuma.
This was so wrong of Farian to do. He should have had all people involved, including Fab and Rob, for this tour. It would have been a good feel good thing to do to make up for what he did and everyone would have come out winning (including Fab and Rob, and the fans). This was a slap in the face to Fab and Rob!!! Probably increased their mental health issues!!!
LOL! They are Lip syncing too
small guy with small Yes thy are. The singer on guitar is working up a sweat, but voice sounds like a recording studio..yeah right..
small guy with small Sorry, but it just doesn't happen. You ALWAYS hear something if in fact they are singing live, such as breathing in the microphone, or reverb from background sound. NOT happening here.
yes it is happening they are hyping the crowd through the microphone you can hear it. you can hear them yelling and stuff at the same time they are singing . they say make some noise, come on etc etc.
You are correct. They are lip syncing. This is off the cd .
GeekBoy03 Yes they are lip syncing but its their own shit. They made this. Rob and Fab stole their shit so there is a difference between lip syncing to someone else's shit and lip syncing to your own shit.
This ain't no milli vanilli were's rob & fab please ...
The fans must've been confused.
They did not have sex appeal like Rob and Fab! Not even close!
Milli vanilli got criticized for lip syncing, and then this lip syncing by the “real singers”. What a joke.
Great song, but something just seems a little bit "off" about this, with showing the real singers, instead of Rob & Fab dancing/performing to it though. That despite even if it still sounds exactly the same as before however! (L.O.L.!)
why didn't they sing live??!
Get out there! Milli Vanilli name was given by Rob. Make up your own name. Milli Vanilli now is Fab
Concuerdo con la opinión q el grupo real junto con Rob y Fav habría sido tremendo.
Yes...
There is a reason they were back stage, they never compare to those two beautiful men Rob and Fab what made Milli Vanilli famous was those two perfect faces of Rob and Fab not this ugly people
Rob und Fab❤❤❤❤❤
🔥
Los verdaderos haciendo playback no pues nos quedamos igual.
After all the drama , they were still lip syncing smh
Who sold out the guys you used for their youth and beauty? Dirty.
Mile vanile e rob e fab
Nunca fue lo mismo sin Rob y Fav
Kakoi ujas!
Ficou estranho sem a dupla
Milliception : the real were not real.
Los verdaderos haciendo playback, no mamen, pero eran buenos tiempos
They are also miming!! What hypocrites!!
Perhaps it was not their fault
Where can we get the version of the song in this video? I believe it's the same as the music video and I have yet to see it on CD anywhere!
también hicieron playback, ademas tenían carisma nivel cero
They may be lipsyncing too but put some respect on their names for being the original musicians.
You are on few people who think as me
rob y fab prefiero a ellos lo primero que se me viene ala mente al escuchar estas canciones es su imagen estos aburrian
Fab Morgan y rob tenían más show ... A pesar de no ser sus voces ... Igual excelente su música
So let’s show the real band performing to a track.
The presentation and appearance of the fake milli vanilli is what matter not the real ones, the look of the not real milli was what they where looking for, the pretty look that all😁😁😁😁
no son de mi tiempo......,pero........como decirlo..solo de verlos me fastdia......!!!!!!!! prefiero a Rob y Fab-----mmmmm......como bailan.....
que no se note el "play back " mejor me quedo con rob & fab
Con razón cantaban otros, fomes los verdaderos, además también hacían playback,
FRANCISCO GALARCE si playback pero de ellos mismos ,no voces prestadas
Q onda
la gente de ese concierto se preguntaba: Y las Cabelleras?
Ya sabiamos que eran los originales pero si apoco nos creian estupidos y en ese programa TODOS HACIAN PLAYBACK por que asi era Siempre en Domingo ellos seran los unicos en Mèxico.
claramente se ve q es la misma q doblaban rob y fab ellos tampoco cantan
The group did a good job. Its their song. Not Rob and Fab's and its my opinion damn it. Thats like NKOTB lip syncing to Candy Girl.
Prefiero a Rob y Fab!
I’m guessing this was a Karaoke encore?
😂😂😂😂
hypocrites
So weird seeing the real musicians performing this song and not the 'faces' of Milli Vanilli. It's like they're taking a song from the 'real' artists. Like a cover band. Strange.
What a mess created by Farian !
Oooops I made a mistake… was actually searching for the fake Milli Vanilli 😅😅😅