Say it in a whistle

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 164

  • @Trokonzah
    @Trokonzah 6 років тому +195

    I dead thought a little girl was walking up that mountain at 0:24 lmbooo

  • @chrisandersen2456
    @chrisandersen2456 6 років тому +79

    Good for them it brings tears to my eyes to know that they want to keep the old ways alive

    • @nicovaniseghem
      @nicovaniseghem 3 роки тому +5

      Spain is famous for its many leanguage preserving projects

  • @AllisChalmersMN
    @AllisChalmersMN 6 років тому +34

    This is beautiful and amazing! I think it’s awesome they are passing it on and keeping it alive.

  • @darcybrummett7004
    @darcybrummett7004 8 років тому +206

    "... learning to tweet." Good pun.

  • @thekraken1173
    @thekraken1173 4 роки тому +44

    Turkish villagers from black sea mountains: finally a *worthy* opponent

  • @eleeveeayees3425
    @eleeveeayees3425 Рік тому +9

    Spansih: "I was born and raised Madrid."
    Canarian: "I was hatched and raised in Canary Islands."

  • @argobronwynzygor1954
    @argobronwynzygor1954 6 років тому +69

    just imagine two character in a movie who would speak silbo wouldn't be so cool ?

    • @OhTheEzekiel
      @OhTheEzekiel 5 років тому

      R2d2

    • @jairrojas7093
      @jairrojas7093 4 роки тому

      @@OhTheEzekiel like this movie?
      ua-cam.com/video/U94GHVpWJVI/v-deo.html

    • @teese1630
      @teese1630 4 роки тому

      @@jairrojas7093 hahahah

    • @yodan00b
      @yodan00b 3 роки тому +1

      there is a movie called "the whistlers" several characters in the movie speak silbo and one learns how to "speak" it to use it in the city from rooftops to relay information about some convict or something like that they are trying to break out of custody at a hospital holding.. or something like that.. it's been a while since I watched the movie, but it does sort of show how to make the tones while the guy is learning the language. and it is a unique plot line for sure =)
      EDIT: link to the trailer.
      ua-cam.com/video/nfB-Lih2qvE/v-deo.html

  • @sticknstonesbrkbones
    @sticknstonesbrkbones 12 років тому +75

    haha I like that, " the cellphone generation is learning to tweet"!! I want to learn this and sign language asap.

  • @MEEOOSH
    @MEEOOSH 6 років тому +80

    Can we please turn the clip of the news reporter trying to whistle at 0:42 into a meme?

  • @dedusmuln820
    @dedusmuln820 6 років тому +71

    they don't call them canary islands for nothing

    • @cdemr
      @cdemr 5 років тому +2

      :OOO

  • @nanichi3781
    @nanichi3781 6 років тому +13

    Beautiful to keep the culture going

  • @willfr8
    @willfr8 3 роки тому +11

    GAH I wanna learn that so badly
    We need a youtube teacher teaching this

  • @iceee_gt
    @iceee_gt 5 років тому +12

    This looks like something id watch in social studies class

  • @bambino9235
    @bambino9235 2 роки тому +2

    "Lago Mera" her pronunciation of La Gomera really grinds my gears

  • @susan8282
    @susan8282 9 років тому +1

    love love love Sunday Morning segments like this...fine piece.

  • @Rubywing4
    @Rubywing4 4 роки тому +4

    I came here because someone said Prime Bumblebee's beeps are to Cybertronian language like the Sylbo language is to Spanish.
    I can hear the resemblance. x)
    Very interesting and curious language though! :)
    I can hand whistle and make a decent tongue whistle but that's pretty much it.
    Can't imagine how hard it must be to learn this one.
    Would be pretty cool to learn sometime though.

  • @YourLordAnon
    @YourLordAnon 9 років тому +165

    I love that they had to throw in the "girls are better than boys" comment. Classy CBS, classy.

    • @wayner396
      @wayner396 7 років тому +35

      Jeziel Vargas I noticed that as well. made my eyes roll

    • @FwireFwower1989
      @FwireFwower1989 6 років тому +6

      So stating a observed phenomena make CBS sexist assholes? Men are physically stronger in general to women. Is pointing that out sexist?

    • @Adam_A
      @Adam_A 6 років тому

      Right

    • @Adam_A
      @Adam_A 6 років тому +5

      Hic Kori say that in front of liberals and see what you get. It is sexist to them

    • @brandon9271
      @brandon9271 6 років тому +2

      Double standards of course

  • @AlejandroPRGH
    @AlejandroPRGH 3 роки тому +5

    Strictly speaking it's not a language but a code. The sounds of Spanish (in older times it would be the native language, Guanche) are translated into whistles. It could be done with another code, such as Morse code. Of course, the Silbo is a brilliant code that could be used even by illiterate people.

  • @pomiw
    @pomiw 4 роки тому +4

    **Whistles a curse word and gets whooped by my mom**

  • @HiroMahtava
    @HiroMahtava 8 років тому +64

    tutorial?

    • @cameoshadowness7757
      @cameoshadowness7757 7 років тому +5

      Hiro Mahtava
      I want one too.

    • @t-rexdabeast7787
      @t-rexdabeast7787 6 років тому +3

      Nigga you are watching this on UA-cam just search it up.

    • @cameoshadowness7757
      @cameoshadowness7757 6 років тому +4

      T-Rex DaBeast
      There isn't one. There are just basic whistle tutorials on UA-cam. No tutorial to learn the language.

    • @t-rexdabeast7787
      @t-rexdabeast7787 6 років тому +1

      ua-cam.com/video/1guTK2PY0a0/v-deo.html
      Boom, just literally watch and learn.

    • @cameoshadowness7757
      @cameoshadowness7757 6 років тому +1

      T-Rex DaBeast
      It's not marked as a tutorial so I missed it. Thanks for helping out.

  • @RuckalltheFules
    @RuckalltheFules 6 років тому +9

    Holy shit I'm almost doing it! I gotta work on my tongue placement but I'm headed in the right direction xD This is awesome!

  • @Combat-Mindset
    @Combat-Mindset Рік тому

    I would be highly interested in learning that. How long does this take to master? Years probably? Its great for people who ard into bushcraft & survival.

  • @marc6604
    @marc6604 4 роки тому +8

    I wanna learn the "proper finger and mouth technique."

  • @SwamiAdvayanandaji
    @SwamiAdvayanandaji 8 місяців тому

    Wonderful teaching. I am living in Reunion island, south of Indian ocean.

  • @f.horstmann8447
    @f.horstmann8447 7 років тому +11

    And this is how you speak with your pet bird

    • @khalilmartinez3541
      @khalilmartinez3541 7 років тому

      If you get a parrot that can talk but it only speaks Gomero then it's just like a normal bird

  • @mikielee735
    @mikielee735 4 роки тому +1

    These guys are the definition of wind talkers......

  • @teaishot2620
    @teaishot2620 5 років тому +4

    Man i wish i could communicate with friends like this. We used morse, but that got boring. People would think we were crazy if we whistled to eachother.

    • @JCMLR
      @JCMLR 3 роки тому

      Nerdddd

  • @MartyArnold
    @MartyArnold 11 років тому +3

    Do a little reading on the subject, just look up Silbo Gomero on Wikipedia. No matter what you think, it is classified as a language.

  • @celeste8360
    @celeste8360 2 роки тому

    I had no idea this existed until someone talked about it on TikTok. So cool 😎

  • @danutdracula
    @danutdracula 4 роки тому +5

    I've squeaked and chirped at birds and I've had them respond by coming to me, opening their mouths for food, and going away when I create a polyphonic screech like a pterodactyl. I would love to actually learn a whole language of it. I could squeak at close range instead of blowing your ears off with a whistle that loud.

  • @nicoisgro9418
    @nicoisgro9418 5 років тому +3

    I want to learn this so I can make whistling sounds to my bird

  • @SmellTheCanvis
    @SmellTheCanvis 5 років тому +15

    "finger in mouth technique" Giggity

  • @MrTensai100
    @MrTensai100 6 років тому +17

    Learning this in school is a nightmare for tone deafs.

  • @cheddarrandom5969
    @cheddarrandom5969 5 років тому +3

    how do you talk when everyone is sick

  • @barbaras.7828
    @barbaras.7828 9 років тому +58

    I liked the pun at the end. Cheesy stuff, but I approve.

  • @sticknstonesbrkbones
    @sticknstonesbrkbones 11 років тому +8

    Originally the Canary Islands were inhabited by the Guanches, one of the last white tribal people. I don't know if that pertains to this but I find it interesting.

    • @absinthexiii4376
      @absinthexiii4376 6 років тому +2

      sticknstonesbrkbones yes! And they were fucking awesome!

  • @dc1397
    @dc1397 Рік тому

    "Hey, did you hear that Johnny secretly likes Margaret? Let's keep this on the downlow!"

  • @sushimold9993
    @sushimold9993 5 років тому

    They've been doing the whistle talk for 500 years

  • @federicosagun4615
    @federicosagun4615 4 роки тому +2

    Well in Philippines we have silbo as well. Calling a tricycle for transport all you have to do is just wistle. When your in trouble by your parents just listen to that whistle from a distant and better run fast.

  • @voidjest
    @voidjest 6 років тому +2

    The way she says silbar sounds like sill-barr

  • @newdefsys
    @newdefsys 7 років тому +1

    The side note, eh ? Looks more like the main narrative. Which is the only narrative for Tracey Smith.

  • @tabiatbekcisi5841
    @tabiatbekcisi5841 4 роки тому +2

    Some Turkish people (especially Black Sea mountain villager) can speak this language.
    It's name is "kuş dili". kuş dili mean is bird's language.

  • @J.Burrough
    @J.Burrough 5 років тому +1

    Oh please. The media always has to throw in the ‘better than you’ jabs.

  • @Gaibreel
    @Gaibreel Рік тому

    Wait is it just spanish that is whistled? If you know spanish could you whistle this language

  • @farisakmal2722
    @farisakmal2722 6 років тому

    I womder what the customized ringtone of the sylbo master means, probably 'someone is calling'?

  • @Zaete0chan
    @Zaete0chan 11 років тому +20

    This is beautiful, but it's not a "language" comparable to usual spoken or sign language. It doesn't have it's own grammar or vocabulary - It's simply representing certain syllables with other syllables - Encoding the normally spoken language.
    If we do call it a language, we're completely ignoring the linguistics of the world, I suppose.

    • @sooter26
      @sooter26 7 років тому +10

      He's not saying Silbo isn't a language, of course it is, it follows the direct definition. However, Silbo isn't following its own unique set of linguistic rules (i.e. words, sentence structure etc.), it simply transfers another language (Spanish) into a different format of communication, just a reading/writing isn't its own language, just another form of a language. Furthermore, since this whistling can be applied to most all languages meaning it cannot be a language within itself.
      Even with all of this I still think Silbo is a beautiful form of communication and should definitely be preserved. Cheers!

    • @XPimKossibleX
      @XPimKossibleX 6 років тому +1

      It's an odd thin because there isn't another means of communication that works similarly. Maybe writing? Besides inventing a new name, calling it a code, an encoing (which may not translate to Spanish so..), or a "speech subsitution," there really isn't a proper way to refer to it.

    • @andreamoscoso4065
      @andreamoscoso4065 6 років тому

      YPzaete Yes true but I wish it were one. Honestly we can call it a language sure it doesn't really have a written vocabulary nor grammer but it certainly is beautiful. Either way they have their language Spanish Sylbo just goes along with it and it's part of their language.

  • @ngunaye4155
    @ngunaye4155 4 роки тому +1

    They like birds

  • @davidvasquez3564
    @davidvasquez3564 6 років тому +7

    Try doing that after you come out off the bathroom without washing.

    • @garrettk7166
      @garrettk7166 5 років тому +2

      Wait, why would that happen? I always wash after using the bathroom. I hope you do too...

  • @ronvavra
    @ronvavra 4 роки тому

    That old lady was whistler's mother.

  • @aziz00181
    @aziz00181 5 років тому +2

    Sylbo is a heritage from the native inhabitants of the islands, the guanches , they are the natives of north africa, the berbers .Good job from Spain to keep this heritage alive !!!

  • @ydsfamapdom6739
    @ydsfamapdom6739 12 років тому

    it just won't let me play this video for some reason the screen just stays black and there's no sound

  • @Larisa605
    @Larisa605 7 років тому

    Das ist richtig cool.

  • @pinkypineblue
    @pinkypineblue 4 роки тому +1

    Just like the birdcity in turkish

  • @sarahmatthews5878
    @sarahmatthews5878 2 роки тому

    I can whistle with all of my fingers and without, but I can't whistle using my finger this way. I will keep practicing.

  • @ameliepage1981
    @ameliepage1981 4 роки тому

    How do they understand each other?
    I guess that the intonation play a huge role but how?
    I would like to learn it^^

    • @elpepe8464
      @elpepe8464 3 роки тому

      the whistle has the exact same melody that the spanish words , if you have a good ear and know spanish is not difficult to understand , its like singing the melody of a word, for example the word "mountain" you usually would use a low tone to say "mount" and then a higher tone to say the "tain" , then you just imitate that same tone variation ,the most important thing is not the precise notes you use because everyone has a different voice range , then important part is the number of notes that are between the tones you use

    • @elpepe8464
      @elpepe8464 3 роки тому

      also in spanish we cut a lot of our words , for example if you want to say "come here" ,
      in perfect spanish it would be "ven para aca"
      but normally no one talk like that, we just say "ven pa ca"
      so when you talk silbo you normally use the sort version because it have less letters and because of that less tones variations

  • @andreamoscoso4065
    @andreamoscoso4065 6 років тому

    Liked the pun at the end 😂

  • @piloctor15
    @piloctor15 6 років тому

    Oh! So this is the whistile from captn crunch commerial!!! Its actually a language!!! Mind blown

  • @loudozer2416
    @loudozer2416 6 років тому

    That's east l.a talk... every homie knows that sound.

  • @f.horstmann8447
    @f.horstmann8447 7 років тому

    All schools? Why is it not in DISS?

  • @legitname6687
    @legitname6687 9 років тому

    Of course, leave it to the female reporter to make unnecessary remarks about how the "girls are better whistlers".

  • @jillian_fitz
    @jillian_fitz 6 років тому

    I can 100% do the tongue whistle thing the lady does and it never had a use

  • @darkicity
    @darkicity 7 років тому +1

    I bet they can't say anything while laughing/smiling

  • @sunwoohwang1752
    @sunwoohwang1752 2 роки тому

    lmao "the new generation is learning to tweet." now I guess we're gonna start ticking

  • @lululipes4382
    @lululipes4382 6 років тому

    Omg the puns.........
    End my syffering plz

  • @peter4210
    @peter4210 4 роки тому

    off the cost of mainland Africa, no not mainland Africa, Madagascar?

  • @reneenoneofyourbusiness5243
    @reneenoneofyourbusiness5243 2 роки тому

    Whenever I whistle at birds, they fly away :/

  • @lala-cp5ct
    @lala-cp5ct 6 років тому +6

    I can whistle nicely without putting a finger in my mouth lol

    • @zkjise
      @zkjise 5 років тому +8

      The finger makes the sound louder and stronger

  • @ikenasiotuagalu816
    @ikenasiotuagalu816 6 років тому

    Because I whistle loudly and can maintain a whistle for quite a while...I pretend to speak this.
    I don’t

  • @OnlineResell
    @OnlineResell 6 років тому

    We do this in the Hood all the time

  • @glavatazelva
    @glavatazelva 5 років тому

    do they understand r2d2 when he talks?

  • @Marduk314
    @Marduk314 6 років тому

    I'll whistle and clean my room

  • @ehixxz
    @ehixxz 4 роки тому

    Oml I can freaking do it, I was joking around and pretended to do it and now I can! 😂😂 except I don’t know Spanish so it doesn’t really do much for me

  • @colinhoek
    @colinhoek 6 років тому

    Holy shit i tried and it worked. I got a tone at my 3rd try.

  • @haideramin7739
    @haideramin7739 4 роки тому

    I thought this was a language only in turkey

  • @sticknstonesbrkbones
    @sticknstonesbrkbones 11 років тому +2

    I know, the Spanish Conquistadors left quite a bit of carnage in their wake. The thing about it though is the Spanish were nothing more than foot-soldiers for the Pope. They never would have done anything outside their own country had it not been for the finances provided by kings and ultimately having the Pope blessing to do so. It truly is a long drawn out story but it really is worth knowing. Anyhow, I would love to learn this Whistle Language someday.

  • @blazortheepic0384
    @blazortheepic0384 5 років тому

    Why do they whistle so weirdly

  • @mizheanfrazier5441
    @mizheanfrazier5441 4 роки тому

    Above Africa? Whaaaaat?

  • @kuzmavolkov
    @kuzmavolkov 5 років тому

    Man I can whistle without my fingers or palm... But trying it that way I can't at all 0.o

  • @holyxbord
    @holyxbord 6 років тому

    Tweeting in real life

  • @Remembertosmile
    @Remembertosmile 4 роки тому +1

    Can they record video of it so other people can learn too and the language won't die?

    • @UhideNcryWhileIseek
      @UhideNcryWhileIseek 3 роки тому

      Lol no they don't want to record it haha. If it dies that's actually a good thing. I don't think it's really a language either just to be frank.

  • @Karikalan143
    @Karikalan143 4 роки тому

    சூப்பர்

  • @brandonolivas1101
    @brandonolivas1101 6 років тому

    Anyone else got spitty fingers now?

  • @jessegomez4755
    @jessegomez4755 6 років тому

    Eso es algo qie se debe que aser en todas las colturas

  • @chapiit08
    @chapiit08 6 років тому

    Damn cute...

  • @zeoutlaw171
    @zeoutlaw171 6 років тому

    MUCH STRONGER ... hmmmm 🤔🤔

  • @coisadolatinoamerica19s48
    @coisadolatinoamerica19s48 5 років тому

    Yup, that communication system will be dead soon

  • @luziaaparecida8804
    @luziaaparecida8804 12 років тому

    gostei pena que so entendo portugues mais fui assistindo e lendo nos labios

  • @jqueen3508
    @jqueen3508 4 роки тому

    Jenevieve

  • @vivifyer
    @vivifyer 6 років тому

    omg please stop cat calling everyone. gosh, triggered

  • @Hotpack7279
    @Hotpack7279 3 роки тому

    Twitter Beta

  • @trapped_monkey
    @trapped_monkey 6 років тому

    The last of us part 2

  • @roddiyako3d
    @roddiyako3d 12 років тому

    ouch my ears

  • @wazikaxani4879
    @wazikaxani4879 4 роки тому

    I see a lot of spit

  • @Mario87456
    @Mario87456 4 роки тому

    Let it die out it’s not a real language anyway

  • @NELOPES7
    @NELOPES7 6 років тому

    Why the american interviewer didn't want to learn their language

  • @PinkPoo
    @PinkPoo 7 років тому

    why not just use a whistle

    • @kylenavarro1600
      @kylenavarro1600 7 років тому +4

      Because if you whistle with your mouth, you don't need a whistle.

  • @mrd471
    @mrd471 6 років тому

    S

  • @jetskechers5354
    @jetskechers5354 2 роки тому

    Girls were better whistlers,, Because women are better with their mouth;)
    Much better 😜

  • @KillDozer44
    @KillDozer44 6 років тому

    dumb af

  • @abd-al-haqal-haqiqi6981
    @abd-al-haqal-haqiqi6981 7 років тому

    Viva guanches Viva Moriscos Viva Berberos Viva north africa