As someone with adopted siblings, the acknowledgment that adopted love is just as magical and powerful as blood makes me SO HAPPY!! Cannot express how much I loved this ending. And the entire series tbh. There is not nearly enough positive adoption stories in the media. Thank you!!!
I agree that there should be more positive adoption stories. However given that dumbledore understands love magic, this is ultimately what should have happened in the books, either initially or in later years when Sirius was free. If it was called anything other than the bond of blood charm then this would be great
That's because of the grim reality of the foster care system. About 1/3 of kids in foster care are never adopted, age out, and are kicked out onto the streets with nothing. Please, people, if you're wanting to start or expand a family, consider adoption. Approximately 20% of homeless people in the US are those kids that aged out of foster care. Instead of making a new life, make an existing life better
Now we need a Hermione in Ravenclaw what if and a what if Dumbledore was the secret keeper to both Harry and Neville would the boys be able to be raised by their parents?
Pretty sure Hermione in Ravenclaw is already announced. Plus its an easy change since the hat gave that some serious consideration. Draco in Gryffindor though, THAT would be cool.
Y’all Ginny in Slytherin. It actually changes so much of the plot, especially the Weasleys. I wrote a whole plot in my own thread summarizing what i’d do, i left out so much and have so many other ideas. Especially if she dates Draco throughout the series, it literally changes the entire arc for the Malfoys and gives an actual redemption arc. Ginny in Slytherin is actually what we need, everything else is too similar to previous what ifs imho.
Harry...please....you don't have to spell out the entire concept of Horcruxes in order to say "hat is cursed, dark magic bad, don't put on head please". It's really not that hard.
Will we get an epilogue to finish this off? I mean, I'd love to see who ends up with, an insight as to what their kids would be like, and also, most importantly, WHAT SIRIUS AND CEDRIC ARE DOING
Sirius and Cedric end up at the Leaky Cauldron and they wind up discussing how they feel like they're living on borrowed time and don't know why. And laughing over the time they were both vampires who liked brunette women.
This is the best type of fanfiction. I truly hope you guys make more “if blank was blank” videos because they are so high quality, and so awesome to watch
Honestly, I think you should take more time for this what ifs. Not in terms of writing but in terms of in-story-time. Why does every what if have to end in the regular 7 years? I think a timeline where Voldemort takes more time time build up an army but therefore also gives more time to his enemies, could be really interesting. Or a timeline where Voldemort takes over Durmstrang etc
…..but the very what if you are commenting on ended in year 5. What if james had the invisibility cloak ended in like year 6 or something, what if nevile was the Chozen one ended in year 2. You are basically asking them to write an entirely new series just with the same characters however their main rule for what ifs is to change only one thing, make one small change at the beginning that could have happened in the original timeline and then they just play cause and effect. They change one thing and then the domino effect happens and they just put the pieces together from there. They aren’t just making stuff up, they are giving us what i truly believe is the most accurate representation of what the story would be like IF these small changes had happened.
Great series, but I think draco casting expeliarmus didn't progress the story. You just established that Voldemort was too surprised to do anything in time, so draco stops Ron just to do what Ron was going to do? Doesn't make a lot of sense. Why wouldn't draco disarm Voldemort instead? Maybe stop Voldemort from being able to cast a spell. Instead it made killing nagini take longer than needed.
Well, Voldy had the Elder Wand, and was its true master. So perhaps any attempt to disarm Voldy would have failed. But then how does Harry's wand defeat him? How is the Elder Wand beaten in this last confrontation? There's some missing explanation at the end here.
I wish it had been the standard 7 years. A great thing about Harry in Slytherin was how elegant it all turned out. This I felt was a bit more rushed and contrived. But overall I enjoyed it very much and will watch more ☺️
next you should do what if Hermione was in ravenclaw then when that's finished you should do what if harry was in Slytherin, Ron was in Hufflepuff and Hermione was in Ravenclaw.
They did a massive series on what if harry was in slytherin. Like not much would change if they were all in different houses compared to harry being separated from the other two since he is the only protagonist
@@sim771well arent you uncreative. No. That would be crutially diffrent. (And how she should have done it.) it would have to feature all four houses and unify hogwarts completley. Under all its champions. It would have to feature the true slytherin using the locket, the true hufflepuff using the cup, the true ravenclaw using the diadem and the true griffindoor using the sword for good.
This what if was truly amazing, i never thought id be able to say that anything would top your what if harry was in slytherin but im happy to be wrong. You guys are mind blowingly talented! I love this channel so much but recently ive kinda forgot to keep up with the uploads but this one just reminded me EXACTLY why i watch all of your content and why you guys are my favorite UA-camrs of all time. You guys are the kings of UA-cam and nobody can change my mind, I’ll die on this hill.
My headcanon for this timeline is that in the epilogue, Harry and Cho go on to live happy lives together having the same amount of kids as canon timeline, though probably not named Albus Severus. I think Cho would talk Harry outta that one. 😂
Head cannon inside of a what if. I love it. Only the carlin brothers are good enough to make a what if and have us all immediately treat it as a factual timeline in an alternate dimension. This what if was mind blowing.
@@timothygodwin7575 agreed! What fascinates me is the whole alternate dimension trope. when it comes to it, pretty much anything and everything goes. whether we like it or not lol (like if you think about it.... there's another alternate timeline where Hermione's aim ISN'T so good. or where Ron lets Harry take the cup alone)
[IDEA/REQUEST] I was just watching Halfblood Prince again and I had the thought, what if Snape hadn't arrived in time and Harry's Sectum Sempra would have killed Draco? What would happen to Snape's unbreakable vow - would he drop dead as a violation to do his best to protect Draco from harm? Would Harry be arrested and send off to Azkaban? Would it have split Harry's soul? - Before anyone comes for me: Yes, I have read the books multiple times, but I have watched the movies way more often and don't remember each and every difference ;)
I have some ideas for some series that I would love to see you do! What if Harry was evil? What if Hermione was in Ravenclaw? What if Harry and Malfoy were friends? What if Harry was a red head girl with his father’s eyes? I love your videos so much! 😊
Harry and Mafoy could have been friends if Harry was in Slytherin, which we already had. I doubt there wouldnt have been another scenario in which They could have been friends, since Malfoy was too arrogant and for Harry towards other house students. Not to mention the bullying towards Griffindor.
Love the adopted family lore addition (!!!) but have some issues with other parts. Why would Voldemort be surprised or enraged to learn they found the locket? He was there when the three of them retrieved it from the lake, and had no idea that the locket in the cave was fake. He should've been under the impression that they already had the locket. If he did check the bowl before they arrived, he would've been searching through Regulus' things immediately after killing Dumbledore bc he knows who RAB would be. Second (edited), why would Harry's wand react with golden flames to the Elder Wand? Isn't the reason Voldemort looks for the Elder Wand because he believes it's strong enough to withstand Harry's supercharged original wand?
16:53. Lol beautiful Hermonie. Emma Watson really shattered the reality that Harmonie was not supposed to be a knockout looking girl. Hollywood really does destroy the dreams of the ugly. Every "ugly" character in hollywood is just a supermodel under a frumpy sweater and the character designers just go "yeah, they will buy this person as a normal, not-increadibly pretty priviledged person...." and we all just accept it
Future ideas What if Petunia Evans was a witch? What if Dudley Dursley was a wizard? What if Ginny Weasley was sorted into Slytherin? What if Albus Dumbledore was made Minister for Magic instead of Cornelius Fudge?
It’s literally called the bond of blood charm though. They don’t share the same blood. I don’t see how it would work. I think it’s more accurate that the elder wand would simply fail or that dumbledore sacrificed himself giving additional protection.
Y'all just keep getting better and better at this! Your re-imaginings have far surpassed the original writer, and I wish we could get them in published book form!
Can we have an epilogue? Pretty please with sugar on top? I want to see the alternate universe ships and what happens to the characters who survived this time but didn't last time!
that was fun. no epilogue to see who got with who in the end, but I guess we can use our own imagination Ron with Hermione and Harry with Cho and some kids (though Cho's probably very scarred, mentally, due to what she had been forced to do)
Many good suggestions for what-ifs in these comments.. May I suggest some, that I think you have already touched upon in Throught the Griffin Door, but that I would really like to see full videos on? 1) What if Harry wrote to Lupin at the beginning of GoF, and 2) What if Lily's parents weren't dead, and Harry went to them. Love your work! :D
Could you do a "What If Ron Was In Ravenclaw", then, if you'd like, for fun, a hufflepuff!ron, ravenclaw!hermione, and slytherin!harry, all in the same thing (What If The Golden Trio Were In All Different Houses)
After the last vid, I was hoping Dumbledore would somehow survive, because it was never confirmed if he was dead or not, but I guess it was his destiny in any plotline
My headcanon is that hermionie starts explainin what happened to cho, not unlike how Jay explained it to us. And then harry was like. Soul = body control via bluetooth. And i can see through eyes and emotions = me have soul. Atleast in that way harry doesn’t turn into a super genius at the end all of a suddden. Perchance.
You should do what if Hermione was in Ravenclaw. You should also do some lesbian fanfics including either Hermione with Luna or Ginny or Ginny with Luna or all three.
All that's left is "What If Hermione Was In Ravenclaw?"! And then Harry in Slytherin, Ron in Hufflepuff, and Hermione in Ravenclaw ALL AT THE SAME TIME!! Lol.
Now hold on a second. The Elder Wand isn't supposed to lose a battle for its master. If Voldemort truly IS the master of the Elder Wand in this scenario, Harry shouldn't be able to beat it, Horcruxes destroyed or not, and golden flames or not.
Loved the series! I do wonder if I missed something along the way. How does harry's wand shoot the golden flamee at the end? He no longer is a horcrux at that point and also not master of the elder wand this time around, right? Did I miss something that explains why harry didnt just die from the avada kedavra shot at him at the end?
Sorry but no. Lily's protection working for Ron makes NO sense! Sure Harry loves him as a brother but Lily didn't die for him she never even knew he existed! Also shame on you for ruining Neville's big moment!
This overall pales in comparison to What If Harry was in Slytherin. Harry in Slytherin was more well thought out, exciting, had compelling romances and had an epilogue! Ron in Hufflepuff was drawn out and boring half the time, with a convoluted and rushed ending, and sadly no epilogue and no care put into developing romances.
At the celebration feast for Voldomort's death Cedric Diggory ate a cherry and choked to death on a pit while Sirius got too drunk and fell down the stairs and broke his neck.
Now we need what if the golden trio were all in different houses - Ron hufflepuff, Harry slytherin, and Hermoine Ravenclaw. Now that would be a different story!
well, you have to give us an epilogue! If the elder wand always wins duels for its master, and Voldemort is truly the master this time, how did they win? Is the elder one destroyed? Does Harry pass his history of magic OWL since he won’t have to collapse in the middle of it this time? These are important questions!
The elder wand is a farce. It loses more often than it wins, perhaps Death intended it that way. It is barely a step above Fred and George's trick wands 😂
Love the series! But wouldn’t Voldemort be able to attack the castle and Harry any time since he doesn’t call blood relatives house home? That’s why he had to go “home” every year
People have joked in the past about how each What If makes the path of the Elder Wand more complicated, but this one decided to make Sacrificial Love more complicated. I enjoyed this, but...Lily sacrificing herself not for Harry, but Harry's family? And therefore all the Weasley's are protected? That feels a little contrived
I was actually genuinely disappointed when it was revealed that the head that was cut off by Draco is nagini's and not voldemort's. That would have been way more awesome. And they could have just dealt with the snake easily enough to finally fully be rid of Voldemort.
At this point, I'm convinced they write What-Ifs solely to make the ending more complicated each time 😂
Omg, I'm listening to Dumbledore's explanation to them and you are 1000% correct. 😂
@@animatedpsychologist I mean I guess it's just wanting to be original and different... but still...
And there is no reason for them to not to.
@@abucket14 It isn't a criticism!
Yeah it got real conveluted
As someone with adopted siblings, the acknowledgment that adopted love is just as magical and powerful as blood makes me SO HAPPY!! Cannot express how much I loved this ending. And the entire series tbh. There is not nearly enough positive adoption stories in the media. Thank you!!!
I was adopted myself, so I also liked that part.
I agree that there should be more positive adoption stories. However given that dumbledore understands love magic, this is ultimately what should have happened in the books, either initially or in later years when Sirius was free.
If it was called anything other than the bond of blood charm then this would be great
That's because of the grim reality of the foster care system. About 1/3 of kids in foster care are never adopted, age out, and are kicked out onto the streets with nothing.
Please, people, if you're wanting to start or expand a family, consider adoption.
Approximately 20% of homeless people in the US are those kids that aged out of foster care. Instead of making a new life, make an existing life better
Now we need a Hermione in Ravenclaw what if and a what if Dumbledore was the secret keeper to both Harry and Neville would the boys be able to be raised by their parents?
For that we would also need a: is it possible to be secret guardian of two different fidelios?
@@liaartist3671why wouldn't it be?
Pretty sure Hermione in Ravenclaw is already announced. Plus its an easy change since the hat gave that some serious consideration.
Draco in Gryffindor though, THAT would be cool.
@@Chrischi3TutorialLPsDraco in Gryffindor could be similar to Harry in Slytherin
Y’all Ginny in Slytherin. It actually changes so much of the plot, especially the Weasleys. I wrote a whole plot in my own thread summarizing what i’d do, i left out so much and have so many other ideas. Especially if she dates Draco throughout the series, it literally changes the entire arc for the Malfoys and gives an actual redemption arc. Ginny in Slytherin is actually what we need, everything else is too similar to previous what ifs imho.
Harry...please....you don't have to spell out the entire concept of Horcruxes in order to say "hat is cursed, dark magic bad, don't put on head please". It's really not that hard.
Harry is canonically a dumbo , unless he needs to get into trouble. Then all of a sudden he becomes a genius.
@@neilgupta2951 I meen yeah he's a rich jock who became a cop...kinda fits the stereotype
@@rachelmanning5709well rich and rich. He grew up as the pet rat.
Hermione in Ravenclaw is a must for 2025!!
Apparently they already have announced it.
Will we get an epilogue to finish this off? I mean, I'd love to see who ends up with, an insight as to what their kids would be like, and also, most importantly, WHAT SIRIUS AND CEDRIC ARE DOING
Sirius and Cedric end up at the Leaky Cauldron and they wind up discussing how they feel like they're living on borrowed time and don't know why. And laughing over the time they were both vampires who liked brunette women.
@@l.tc.5032 I don't hate it
Sirius is killed by being accidentally run over by the Knight Bus. And Cedric dies in one of those rare-but-all-too-possible quidditch accidents.
@@PhilBagels So a What If where Voldi's usual victims survive, immediately followed by Harry Potter and the Final Destination? Interesting concept.
Cedric and Dirius end up with each other as a married couple. They later adopt Scorpius Malfoy and Gilderoy Dolores Potter.
This is the best type of fanfiction. I truly hope you guys make more “if blank was blank” videos because they are so high quality, and so awesome to watch
Lots of love from South Korea. You guys are the KING of HP theories. I think we need a what if Lupin wasn't a werewolf.
There is one from about a year ago
@Garagebooks-2023 my bad
@ that’s okay
Me: Have the Bros finally dropped Better Help? No. No they have not. Shame on you!
It's probably a contract they can't just get out of, I'm sure they must be aware by now.
Honestly, I think you should take more time for this what ifs. Not in terms of writing but in terms of in-story-time. Why does every what if have to end in the regular 7 years? I think a timeline where Voldemort takes more time time build up an army but therefore also gives more time to his enemies, could be really interesting. Or a timeline where Voldemort takes over Durmstrang etc
I think the problem is, that Dumbledore already starts hunting the Horcruxes in the sixth year. So Voldemort is kind of on in a rush.
They don't all end in 7 years. This one ended in year 5. "What if James kept the cloak" ended in year 6
Cuz it’s What if, not an original fan fiction storyline
You are absolutely right. It feels like they catch onto everything (or stuff just works out nicely for them) way too fast.
…..but the very what if you are commenting on ended in year 5. What if james had the invisibility cloak ended in like year 6 or something, what if nevile was the Chozen one ended in year 2. You are basically asking them to write an entirely new series just with the same characters however their main rule for what ifs is to change only one thing, make one small change at the beginning that could have happened in the original timeline and then they just play cause and effect. They change one thing and then the domino effect happens and they just put the pieces together from there. They aren’t just making stuff up, they are giving us what i truly believe is the most accurate representation of what the story would be like IF these small changes had happened.
*New Achievement Unlocked: A Happy Ending*
Regulus "dies". By that,of course, we mean he faked his death and became a cat
I mean naturally, of course!
@alettagijsoppelaar8077 naturally, naturally
Obviously
Quit playing games with my heart! I thought you guys had given up on this story. Thank you for the Friday surprise. Merry Christmas!!
Sweet, I’ve been looking forward to this, and was hopeful that this series would finish before the new year would finish. This’ll be great!
Does this mean Fred survives too? Or am I forgetting a detail because this story was kinda drawn out? X3
Fred, Sirius, Cedric, Snape, Colin Creevy and several others all survive.
@bendowson3124 YAAAAAAAAY!
It includes lupin and tonks so teddy isn’t an orphan!
And Dobby… Right?
@@MarinaTilich Nothing to suggest Dobby didn't survie so I think yes. DOBBY LOVES! But Kreacher was probably the trade fo that.
Great series, but I think draco casting expeliarmus didn't progress the story. You just established that Voldemort was too surprised to do anything in time, so draco stops Ron just to do what Ron was going to do? Doesn't make a lot of sense. Why wouldn't draco disarm Voldemort instead? Maybe stop Voldemort from being able to cast a spell. Instead it made killing nagini take longer than needed.
Otherwise, no notes, great series
Well, Voldy had the Elder Wand, and was its true master. So perhaps any attempt to disarm Voldy would have failed. But then how does Harry's wand defeat him? How is the Elder Wand beaten in this last confrontation? There's some missing explanation at the end here.
Orrrr hear me out, Draco kills Voldemort in revenge, someone else kills nagini
I think that they added that moment, just to post Voldemort laughing.
I wish it had been the standard 7 years. A great thing about Harry in Slytherin was how elegant it all turned out. This I felt was a bit more rushed and contrived. But overall I enjoyed it very much and will watch more ☺️
next you should do what if Hermione was in ravenclaw then when that's finished you should do what if harry was in Slytherin, Ron was in Hufflepuff and Hermione was in Ravenclaw.
They did a massive series on what if harry was in slytherin. Like not much would change if they were all in different houses compared to harry being separated from the other two since he is the only protagonist
@@sim771well arent you uncreative. No. That would be crutially diffrent. (And how she should have done it.) it would have to feature all four houses and unify hogwarts completley. Under all its champions. It would have to feature the true slytherin using the locket, the true hufflepuff using the cup, the true ravenclaw using the diadem and the true griffindoor using the sword for good.
This what if was truly amazing, i never thought id be able to say that anything would top your what if harry was in slytherin but im happy to be wrong. You guys are mind blowingly talented! I love this channel so much but recently ive kinda forgot to keep up with the uploads but this one just reminded me EXACTLY why i watch all of your content and why you guys are my favorite UA-camrs of all time. You guys are the kings of UA-cam and nobody can change my mind, I’ll die on this hill.
My headcanon for this timeline is that in the epilogue, Harry and Cho go on to live happy lives together having the same amount of kids as canon timeline, though probably not named Albus Severus. I think Cho would talk Harry outta that one. 😂
No Snape redemption in this one. The idea doesn't even cross his mind.
Head cannon inside of a what if. I love it. Only the carlin brothers are good enough to make a what if and have us all immediately treat it as a factual timeline in an alternate dimension. This what if was mind blowing.
Their kid will be named Gilderoy Dolores Potter
@@timothygodwin7575 agreed! What fascinates me is the whole alternate dimension trope. when it comes to it, pretty much anything and everything goes. whether we like it or not lol
(like if you think about it.... there's another alternate timeline where Hermione's aim ISN'T so good. or where Ron lets Harry take the cup alone)
@crazysasha1374 you know... very fair point. didn't consider that.
Bro I have NO IDEA what has been happening, but I am HERE FOR IT
yooooo this series has been so good. so happy you put so much work in to make these videos so good. keep up the great work!❤
First was what if Harry was in Slytherin, now what if Ron was in Hufflepuff. Could What if Hermione was in Ravenclaw be next?
Hopefully this is also the finale of SCB taking sponsorships from Better Help
[IDEA/REQUEST]
I was just watching Halfblood Prince again and I had the thought, what if Snape hadn't arrived in time and Harry's Sectum Sempra would have killed Draco?
What would happen to Snape's unbreakable vow - would he drop dead as a violation to do his best to protect Draco from harm?
Would Harry be arrested and send off to Azkaban? Would it have split Harry's soul?
- Before anyone comes for me: Yes, I have read the books multiple times, but I have watched the movies way more often and don't remember each and every difference ;)
I have some ideas for some series that I would love to see you do!
What if Harry was evil?
What if Hermione was in Ravenclaw?
What if Harry and Malfoy were friends?
What if Harry was a red head girl with his father’s eyes?
I love your videos so much! 😊
Harry and Mafoy could have been friends if Harry was in Slytherin, which we already had. I doubt there wouldnt have been another scenario in which They could have been friends, since Malfoy was too arrogant and for Harry towards other house students. Not to mention the bullying towards Griffindor.
@@Lotuswalkerthat is true. I didn’t think about that. Thanks!
What if Harry offered to help Hermione to research appeal of the Buckbeak's case?
pretty sure they were already thinking of doing hermione in ravenclaw, since they've done both slytherin harry AND hufflepuff ron
Harry can't really be evil, or at least not be on Voldy's side cuz the prophecy
Love the adopted family lore addition (!!!) but have some issues with other parts. Why would Voldemort be surprised or enraged to learn they found the locket? He was there when the three of them retrieved it from the lake, and had no idea that the locket in the cave was fake. He should've been under the impression that they already had the locket. If he did check the bowl before they arrived, he would've been searching through Regulus' things immediately after killing Dumbledore bc he knows who RAB would be.
Second (edited), why would Harry's wand react with golden flames to the Elder Wand? Isn't the reason Voldemort looks for the Elder Wand because he believes it's strong enough to withstand Harry's supercharged original wand?
Ron had Harry's wand when he fought Voldemort in the Graveyard.
The golden flames came up in the battle of the 7 potters when voldy used Malfoy's wand
@@darksca1804 omg you're right, I just checked! I was totally in wrong on that, thanks!
16:53. Lol beautiful Hermonie. Emma Watson really shattered the reality that Harmonie was not supposed to be a knockout looking girl.
Hollywood really does destroy the dreams of the ugly. Every "ugly" character in hollywood is just a supermodel under a frumpy sweater and the character designers just go "yeah, they will buy this person as a normal, not-increadibly pretty priviledged person...." and we all just accept it
Future ideas
What if Petunia Evans was a witch?
What if Dudley Dursley was a wizard?
What if Ginny Weasley was sorted into Slytherin?
What if Albus Dumbledore was made Minister for Magic instead of Cornelius Fudge?
I m pretty sure they made the what if petunia evans was a witch
@@ananyamishra1898 that was the Irish guy Harry Potter Folklore
We NEED a what if Hermione was in Ravenclaw and then what if all three of them were in different houses
It’s literally called the bond of blood charm though. They don’t share the same blood. I don’t see how it would work. I think it’s more accurate that the elder wand would simply fail or that dumbledore sacrificed himself giving additional protection.
Y'all just keep getting better and better at this! Your re-imaginings have far surpassed the original writer, and I wish we could get them in published book form!
This has been an absolute blast. Little disappointed there wasn’t an epilogue but I’ll take what I can get for Ron centered stories
SPOILERS!!!
Harry: I want to kill the snake.
Ron: No, I want to kill the snake!
Draco: Hold my butterbeer...
I love all your What Ifs, and this one was by far my favourite! Was seriously hoping you kept it going indefinitely lol
TONKS DOESN'T GO DOWN!?
The one fall in all seven books I have wanted to change. Ben. Thank you. This is a Christmas gift
YOU HAVE TO DO HERMIONE IN RAVEN CLAW NOW PLEASE
3:38 The only issue I find with this What If story is that Monster Energy Drink didn't come out until April of 2002
Can we have an epilogue? Pretty please with sugar on top? I want to see the alternate universe ships and what happens to the characters who survived this time but didn't last time!
WOW! Just WOW this what if scenario has been quite a wild ride and I loved it.
Well done, I’m looking forward to the next What If? multi-parter.
Did someone take notes on Dumbledore's explanation? I need to read it 10 times first and then ask questions.
Peaks and valleys, twists and turns...
The stories you write are incredible!
that was fun. no epilogue to see who got with who in the end, but I guess we can use our own imagination
Ron with Hermione and Harry with Cho and some kids (though Cho's probably very scarred, mentally, due to what she had been forced to do)
Rocking the beard! 🧔🧔🧔
There's a mustache too.
Many good suggestions for what-ifs in these comments.. May I suggest some, that I think you have already touched upon in Throught the Griffin Door, but that I would really like to see full videos on? 1) What if Harry wrote to Lupin at the beginning of GoF, and 2) What if Lily's parents weren't dead, and Harry went to them.
Love your work! :D
Could you do a "What If Ron Was In Ravenclaw", then, if you'd like, for fun, a hufflepuff!ron, ravenclaw!hermione, and slytherin!harry, all in the same thing (What If The Golden Trio Were In All Different Houses)
Edit this before someone notices you said Ron instead of Hermione!
Too late.
@CosmicMercury56 NOOOOOOOO!
Lol.
After the last vid, I was hoping Dumbledore would somehow survive, because it was never confirmed if he was dead or not, but I guess it was his destiny in any plotline
What if Hermione was in Ravenclaw?
My headcanon is that hermionie starts explainin what happened to cho, not unlike how Jay explained it to us. And then harry was like.
Soul = body control via bluetooth. And i can see through eyes and emotions = me have soul.
Atleast in that way harry doesn’t turn into a super genius at the end all of a suddden. Perchance.
Awesome as always thanks guys ❤ MERRY CHRISTMAS AND HAPPY HOLIDAYS TO YOU AND ALL WHO CELEBRATE!
MERRY CHRISTMAS EVERYBODY
22:07 BEN, I AM CRYING OUT HERE!!!!
You should do what if Hermione was in Ravenclaw. You should also do some lesbian fanfics including either Hermione with Luna or Ginny or Ginny with Luna or all three.
Can't wait for the supercut!
This alternate timeline was soooo cool! Thanks for such work!
All that's left is "What If Hermione Was In Ravenclaw?"!
And then Harry in Slytherin, Ron in Hufflepuff, and Hermione in Ravenclaw ALL AT THE SAME TIME!! Lol.
Could you do a series of what if Hermione was sorted into Ravenclaw? PLEASE!!!!
Seems like putting Hermione in Ravenclaw just has to be done next
Now hold on a second. The Elder Wand isn't supposed to lose a battle for its master. If Voldemort truly IS the master of the Elder Wand in this scenario, Harry shouldn't be able to beat it, Horcruxes destroyed or not, and golden flames or not.
I love the "what if" scenarios created by you guys.
I'm kind of disapointed we didn't have an epilogue for this one like we did for Harry in Slytherin...
Wow, it was complicated but also really good!🎉🎉
Another fantastic series. Keep up the good work. Can’t wait to see what’s next.
Yay! I thought this got abandoned for a hot second there, so glad it got an end!❤
I love it!!! The multiple plottwists were amazing!
This proves it, Hufflepuff is the best house.
Loved the series! I do wonder if I missed something along the way. How does harry's wand shoot the golden flamee at the end? He no longer is a horcrux at that point and also not master of the elder wand this time around, right? Did I miss something that explains why harry didnt just die from the avada kedavra shot at him at the end?
I think the golden flames are because of priori incantatem. Twin cores. Maybe?
To quote the amazing Ninth Doctor, "Just this once, everybody lives!!!"
Hey Ben and J you should definitely try and make an animated series of all your what if Harry Potter videos
Sorry but no. Lily's protection working for Ron makes NO sense! Sure Harry loves him as a brother but Lily didn't die for him she never even knew he existed!
Also shame on you for ruining Neville's big moment!
This overall pales in comparison to What If Harry was in Slytherin. Harry in Slytherin was more well thought out, exciting, had compelling romances and had an epilogue! Ron in Hufflepuff was drawn out and boring half the time, with a convoluted and rushed ending, and sadly no epilogue and no care put into developing romances.
At the celebration feast for Voldomort's death Cedric Diggory ate a cherry and choked to death on a pit while Sirius got too drunk and fell down the stairs and broke his neck.
As soon as I realized the finale was only the first half of the half blood prince, I’m very worried on what’s coming
Oh please everyone knows Voldemort’s prefered energy drink in Venom.
No it’s the drink from the grave
excellent storytelling. well deserved viewership for your videos.
I was in a very bad mood before I watched this but now I feel better! Thank you J and Ben
Now we need what if the golden trio were all in different houses - Ron hufflepuff, Harry slytherin, and Hermoine Ravenclaw. Now that would be a different story!
Hi Ben!
Thanks for another great series!
The Sirius not knowing his brother was good part really messed me up. Was not ready for that.
Loved this series! Thanks For this ❤❤❤❤
I can’t wait until it’s “what if Harry was in Slytherin, Ron was in Hufflepuff, and Hermione was in Ravenclaw” 😂😂😂
We need an epilogue episode now lol
It all comes back to a Portrait of Looked Like a Large Pile of Ash in the end
I’ll give you another one: “what if… Snape was sorted in griffyndoor”
well, you have to give us an epilogue!
If the elder wand always wins duels for its master, and Voldemort is truly the master this time, how did they win? Is the elder one destroyed? Does Harry pass his history of magic OWL since he won’t have to collapse in the middle of it this time?
These are important questions!
The elder wand is a farce. It loses more often than it wins, perhaps Death intended it that way. It is barely a step above Fred and George's trick wands 😂
Yeah, they left out a very important explanation at the end there.
A suggestion for a new series: I would love it if there was a situation where Draco sees the error of his ways, a series on that would be fun I think
Love the series! But wouldn’t Voldemort be able to attack the castle and Harry any time since he doesn’t call blood relatives house home? That’s why he had to go “home” every year
This was the worst what if ever i am sorry 😭
HE BETTER NOT
Love this series. I can't wait for the supercut!
Anyone else wonder how it would be if after the eventual "Hermione in Ravenclaw" they made one where they ALL made it into their alternative houses?
Can you do what if Hermione was in Ravenclaw? That would be so cool
4:49 I salute the Captioner.
Now all we need is Hermione In Ravenclaw! You gotta finish the trio ❤❤❤
As a Hufflepuff, I definitely appreciate this What If story!
Now I'm eagerly anticipating the What If Hermione was Sorted into Ravenclaw story!
What if idea: Voldies soul jumped to the potters cat instead of Harry :P
Evil Croockshanks!!
People have joked in the past about how each What If makes the path of the Elder Wand more complicated, but this one decided to make Sacrificial Love more complicated. I enjoyed this, but...Lily sacrificing herself not for Harry, but Harry's family? And therefore all the Weasley's are protected? That feels a little contrived
this is the greatest harry potter fan fiction I've saw
Hermione swinging a sword at Cho's head is WILD
I was actually genuinely disappointed when it was revealed that the head that was cut off by Draco is nagini's and not voldemort's. That would have been way more awesome. And they could have just dealt with the snake easily enough to finally fully be rid of Voldemort.