Adora L. They are called closing arguments just saying but that would be brilliant. If only Mike Dodds had sung Tomorrow There'll Be More Of Us from Hamilton as he was dying (Its not on the album)
Not miscast at all. It took the audience a moment, but halfway through, actors and audience are all in it completely. It's truly beautiful and heartfelt.
Actually, the song being sung by men is extremely accurate, as we all know that West Side Story is full of homosexual subtext and was written by gay men in the 50s, hence its powerful relevance today. Somewhere is also a very beautiful song about acceptance and love in all its forms in this dark world
I feel like Raul has a hard time being campy with something like this, he starts out over-the-top and transitions into a really serious and heartfelt performance almost instantly. He and Lin-Manuel are an incredible duo, I can only hope and pray we'll see something with these two together in the future.
@@hannahchambers3331 No, it was never intended to be "camp and over dramatic." Bernstein's music in West Side Story amps up the emotional voltage of traditional musicals into something larger and semi-operatic.
I really wish certain audience members could control themselves long enough to save the applause until the end. This performance isn't a jazz quartet in a bar, or a football game. All of the ridiculous laughing and the sudden outburst of applause stops me from being able to immerse myself in the purity and joy of the moment, makes it harder to hear the performers, and generally detracts from the performance. These audience members want to be part of the performance, instead of shutting their mouths and allowing everyone else to enjoy it.
Lin-Manuel: Uh-oh, my scene partner actually acted and I'm not able to rise to the same bar. Better put on a Sponge Bob Square Pants-worthy facial expression when we turn to the crowd at the end, and hope that sells it.
@@evanveitia Not really. His natural accent is American -- no surprise there, he grew up speaking English. The accent he has here is a feat of acting, and it's fucking impressive.
@@runefaustblack I think they're trying to say that his parents speak english with an accent (cuban, not spanish) so he's able to imitate it more easily than most.
As far as singing, Esparza is just brilliant. When he hits the climax notes during the lyrics, "all.....of my life", and the fact that he holds the money note on the word, "life", for as long as he dies, is also just brilliant. It gives such depth and resonance to that entire phrase. Of course, the the vocal quality he attained when he sang the last note just knocked it out of the park.
I agree. These performances are actually quite amazingly good -- the audience is laughing because they're taking it as camp -- and the actors are taking it seriously!
Oh my god I take a 20-minute break from listening to Hamilton in order to look up other Broadway videos, and what do I stumble upon but this. It's as if the universe if telling me there is no escape from Lin-Manuel Miranda. XD Also on the serious vs. campy topic, I believe the actors were playing it straight, but as Miscast songs are generally humorous, the audience was finding the comedy in it.
Me too. In my case Miscast Schuyler Sister brought me here (I had no choice but to watch). My other favorite performance of this song is by Carol Burnett and Julie Andrews at Carnegie Hall. Carol's look of horror when Julie sings "You should no better. You were in love; or so you said" is priceless.
They both nailed it. Lin is so great, Raul killed it as well. I always thought of this as the most difficult song in West Side Story for the female singers, the guys, or one guy has Maria and that also can be difficult.
When Raul does that little weak in the knees thing at the end as Lin leads him offstage #imshook They were so into the scene that it pulled me in. Seriously this is my 2nd fave recording of this song behind the spanish recording with karen and josefina! This is a great example of how ur dedication to a scene as an actor determines how the audience responds and whether they feel the authenticity of a moment.
Okay, I became a huge fan of Law and Order SVU and Hamilton at the same time, and I especially love Lin and Raul, so imagine my surprise at finding this. It's official; this is the best thing ever.
Go look up Raul Esparza's Broadway career. His Company performance should've won the Tony that year, but revivals are a tough sell for awards. And, he's played Riff-Raff from Rocky Horror on Broadway!
+Lily Mora Very much so. In the 1st episode Daveed was featured on, in the scene where he first appears, I kid you not, I paused the video on my laptop, got up walked around my bed, and was basically just going: oh my gosh, oh my gosh. OK this is about to happen oh my gosh oh my gosh. Seeing him and Leslie on law & order was such a thrill. They're performances were great.
My god Raul is legendary. I clicked on this after watching a series of shaky camcorder Tick Tick Boom vids from 2000, it's good to see he's still killing it.
The I Have A Love section of this is actually really beautiful and heartfelt. I found nothing strange about two men singing this and actually think it would have been even better if the humour was dropped from it completely.
Oh for sure. The producer or director of Leap of Faith got him the gig on SVU when that show closed cause he’s just way too freaking talented to not be working constantly. And he was freaking robbed of the Tony Award for his Bobby in Company by David Hyde Pierce in Curtains cause stupid senile voters were like “oh… Niles Crane? I’m sure he deserves it”
I also got to see him, Elizabeth Moss AND Norbert Leo Butz in Speed the Plow… Butz filled in for Jeremy Piven after sushigate and it was definitely an upgrade
This is downright phenomenal! Lin and Raul are both superb! That moment at the end they're both crying! :(...And is it me, or was Raul possibly crying so hard he nearly fell :/ I wish they both did the roles like this in a longer movie :p I could watch them at it longer!
It's the audience who are making it camp, not the performers. Raul has a quality which is ambiguous, and his singing is so emotional and uninhibited it sometimes seems feminine, but it's always thrilling. A great pairing, I just wish the audience could shut up. It's they who want it to be camp and sent up, and the two guys are determined to play it truthfully.
Not quite. The exaggerated Spanish accents as well as certain expressions cue parody to the audience. Still, thrilling. One does wish that they could have entered into it completely straight, though.
Agreed. These two men are putting such passion into the performance, they are playing the roles and delivering with the power of an opera, layering the voices. Raul is blowing me away.
@@arthurboehm I not quite your not quite. I think they played it seriously from the beginning. And the OP is correct - the audience members that were laughing well into the number were either terribly young, terribly immature, and/or terribly drunk.
Miranda was probably coming as close as he is able to actually acting, but check out that facial expression at the end. He was as camp as it comes. Experience this video with as much confirmation bias as you need to, though.
I can't be the only one who notices how similar Barba and Hamilton are, right?! Also, Lynn - Manuel Miranda and Raúl Esparza singing together. Thank you, Lord!
Raul’s voice has aged so well since tick tick boom!! He sounds a bit like he’s straining, but That Note was pretty good hot damn :0 and Lin looking like he’s about to cry really got me wow
If you put two of the most dramatic kings in a heated and emotional scene and song like this, they will pop off like the kings they are. And they did, putting their entire sassy asf selves into it.
I love how serious they both took it
the audience was laughing in the beginning but Lin and Raúl were IN IT
and they pulled the audience in, too
+littleboatfullofwater those are my favourite entries in Miscast. Where the actors are acting the roles they're singing, and not just being comedic.
littleboatfullofwater If you don't take it seriously, it doesn't translate well.
The mark of a master preformance. It will make one suspended beliefe.
And the fact that Both of them captured the characters that they were playing as well as they did just speaks for how skilled of actors they are.
totally disagree- they camped it up...wish they had played it for real
Hamilton and Barba practiced the law. They practically perfected it.
Benson and the SVU squad watches in amazement in the court room as Barba sings his ending statement.
Adora L. They are called closing arguments just saying but that would be brilliant. If only Mike Dodds had sung Tomorrow There'll Be More Of Us from Hamilton as he was dying (Its not on the album)
Jodi Shapiro laurens interlude, you mean, that's what it's called normally
(4:40 Miranda’s heartbroken face) 😂
Mary Ella Dorotan MY TWO FAV PEOPLE AND I LOVE HAMILTON AND L&O SVU😂
Not miscast at all. It took the audience a moment, but halfway through, actors and audience are all in it completely. It's truly beautiful and heartfelt.
Actually, the song being sung by men is extremely accurate, as we all know that West Side Story is full of homosexual subtext and was written by gay men in the 50s, hence its powerful relevance today. Somewhere is also a very beautiful song about acceptance and love in all its forms in this dark world
I love it how Raúl goes from comedy to "wow such talent" in like 0.5 seconds
If you’ve never heard his version of Being Alive from Company it is AMAZING.
I feel like Raul has a hard time being campy with something like this, he starts out over-the-top and transitions into a really serious and heartfelt performance almost instantly. He and Lin-Manuel are an incredible duo, I can only hope and pray we'll see something with these two together in the future.
Isn't that how this song is meant to be...camp and over dramatic and then serious and heartfelt?
I’d love to see the two of them together in something.
@@hannahchambers3331 ...In a word, no.
@@hannahchambers3331 No, it was never intended to be "camp and over dramatic." Bernstein's music in West Side Story amps up the emotional voltage of traditional musicals into something larger and semi-operatic.
Alexander Hamilton and Rafael Barba arguing is the best thing in the world.
unstoppable force vs immovable object
I place my bets on Barba, he wasn't D.A for nothing :)
Mikaela Girardot omg i love u
damn RIGHT that "life" note from raul deserved the mid-song applause!! unreal. and the harmony at the end is simply gorgeous
I really wish certain audience members could control themselves long enough to save the applause until the end. This performance isn't a jazz quartet in a bar, or a football game. All of the ridiculous laughing and the sudden outburst of applause stops me from being able to immerse myself in the purity and joy of the moment, makes it harder to hear the performers, and generally detracts from the performance. These audience members want to be part of the performance, instead of shutting their mouths and allowing everyone else to enjoy it.
Audience laughing
Raul: just wait and see, let me put all my emotions in this song
Audience:........
Lin-Manuel: Uh-oh, my scene partner actually acted and I'm not able to rise to the same bar. Better put on a Sponge Bob Square Pants-worthy facial expression when we turn to the crowd at the end, and hope that sells it.
This is the greatest duo ever on Miscast! Raúl's accent was so on point, it was hilarious
Athena Sabaria It’s cause his parents are Spanish
@@evanveitia Cuban.
@@evanveitia Not really. His natural accent is American -- no surprise there, he grew up speaking English. The accent he has here is a feat of acting, and it's fucking impressive.
@@runefaustblack I think they're trying to say that his parents speak english with an accent (cuban, not spanish) so he's able to imitate it more easily than most.
His parents are Cuban so he's probably familiar with it!
seems perfectly cast to me
Yup
Yes
Totally
Raul Esparza can make you laugh while tears are running down your face. His voice can be a hug one minute, and a hammer the next, How does he do it.
I didn't even realize this was Lin I just clicked on it and almost screamed when he came on screen
Katie M same
I'm so late but Raul's smile when he sings "I love him, we are one, there's nothing to be done~" is like. The best.
Lin is a wonderful creator, performer, interpreter, actor but as far as vocal singing, Raul is the man and they both know it.
As far as singing, Esparza is just brilliant. When he hits the climax notes during the lyrics, "all.....of my life", and the fact that he holds the money note on the word, "life", for as long as he dies, is also just brilliant. It gives such depth and resonance to that entire phrase. Of course, the the vocal quality he attained when he sang the last note just knocked it out of the park.
OH MY GOD Lin-Manuel as Anita omgomg
Emma R. Sele it's perfect
HE IS PERFECT I LOVE HIM❤️❤️❤️❤️
i've grown so accustomed to seeing Raul as a tv actor that now his voice catches me off guard. ugh i got chills. :')
I agree. These performances are actually quite amazingly good -- the audience is laughing because they're taking it as camp -- and the actors are taking it seriously!
i take a break from SVU for ONE SECOND...
Diana S. ,NO
Omg me too!!
I didn't know he could do that. What breath control!
It finds you out! It always does.....
If there was a male Anita of course it would be Lin. He is incredible!
Diane Devendorf amen! He's perfect as Anita
If there is ever a miscast production of West Side, I would love to see these 2 reprise their roles of Anita and Maria.
Oh my god I take a 20-minute break from listening to Hamilton in order to look up other Broadway videos, and what do I stumble upon but this. It's as if the universe if telling me there is no escape from Lin-Manuel Miranda. XD
Also on the serious vs. campy topic, I believe the actors were playing it straight, but as Miscast songs are generally humorous, the audience was finding the comedy in it.
literally same omg
Me too. In my case Miscast Schuyler Sister brought me here (I had no choice but to watch). My other favorite performance of this song is by Carol Burnett and Julie Andrews at Carnegie Hall. Carol's look of horror when Julie sings "You should no better. You were in love; or so you said" is priceless.
Oh my gosh, thank you so much for introducing me to that performance! Julie & Carol sang this song amazingly!
+Karen Mitchell the Mis cast of Schuyler sister brought me here too hahhah
OMG SAME! Savior Lin 😂 Its funny how this was before Hamilton anyway.
Total props to Raúl for not only singing amazingly but doing it in an accent. Lin was also amazing, of course.
RAÚL IS SO GREAT AS MARIA I'M CRYING
FUCK YEAH RAUL AND LIN ARE SO ICONIC I LOVE THEM
They both nailed it. Lin is so great, Raul killed it as well. I always thought of this as the most difficult song in West Side Story for the female singers, the guys, or one guy has Maria and that also can be difficult.
When Raul does that little weak in the knees thing at the end as Lin leads him offstage #imshook They were so into the scene that it pulled me in. Seriously this is my 2nd fave recording of this song behind the spanish recording with karen and josefina!
This is a great example of how ur dedication to a scene as an actor determines how the audience responds and whether they feel the authenticity of a moment.
Raul Esparza is one multi-talented man.
And sooooo hot.
When Bobby finally finds someone he's asked to forget the person. Haha.
On another note, this performance made me laugh and cry. Brilliant!
.... and then my heart exploded. OMG!
Forever in love with how Lin aggressively sings "very sMART, maria, vERY SM A R T"
Okay, I became a huge fan of Law and Order SVU and Hamilton at the same time, and I especially love Lin and Raul, so imagine my surprise at finding this. It's official; this is the best thing ever.
Go look up Raul Esparza's Broadway career. His Company performance should've won the Tony that year, but revivals are a tough sell for awards. And, he's played Riff-Raff from Rocky Horror on Broadway!
Dude, SAME. The giddiness I feel about this is UNREAL. It has no business being as good as it is!!
Is anyone else a Hamilton/Law and Order:SVU/Broadway fan?
Alexander Hamilton vs Rafael Barba. BEST THING EVER!
Literally all of them
Mikaela Girardot HOLY FUCKING SHIT I COULD NOT HANDLE THAT
+Lily Mora Very much so. In the 1st episode Daveed was featured on, in the scene where he first appears, I kid you not, I paused the video on my laptop, got up walked around my bed, and was basically just going: oh my gosh, oh my gosh. OK this is about to happen oh my gosh oh my gosh. Seeing him and Leslie on law & order was such a thrill. They're performances were great.
Lily Mora I JUST FOUND THIS AND I LOVE BOTH FANDOMS AND AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Mr. Esparza accented English is perfect.. very good... great sincerity too
The way he throws his whole body into the high notes and holds them forever...
He's born of Cuban parents. And Miranda's Puerto Rican. They fit their 'side' of West Side Story pretty well.
HOW DID I MISS THIS PIECE OF PERFECTION
My god Raul is legendary. I clicked on this after watching a series of shaky camcorder Tick Tick Boom vids from 2000, it's good to see he's still killing it.
The I Have A Love section of this is actually really beautiful and heartfelt. I found nothing strange about two men singing this and actually think it would have been even better if the humour was dropped from it completely.
I never realized how talented ADA Barba is.
+Cali Nightingale I know. I found out last year that he was on the recording of Tick Tick Boom and had a Broadway career. I was so surprised.
Check out company
Company and Tick Tick Boom!
Oh for sure. The producer or director of Leap of Faith got him the gig on SVU when that show closed cause he’s just way too freaking talented to not be working constantly. And he was freaking robbed of the Tony Award for his Bobby in Company by David Hyde Pierce in Curtains cause stupid senile voters were like “oh… Niles Crane? I’m sure he deserves it”
I also got to see him, Elizabeth Moss AND Norbert Leo Butz in Speed the Plow… Butz filled in for Jeremy Piven after sushigate and it was definitely an upgrade
They both did spectacular, I’m a huge fan of Lin, and Raul holding that note DAMN!!
I only knew him from SVU I am now a total fan of Raúl Esparza!!!!
Raul’s voice is so heavenly ❤️❤️
This is downright phenomenal! Lin and Raul are both superb! That moment at the end they're both crying! :(...And is it me, or was Raul possibly crying so hard he nearly fell :/ I wish they both did the roles like this in a longer movie :p I could watch them at it longer!
I think the nearly falling part was choreographed
Emotion is Emotion is Emotion… This is very moving. A testament to the compassion coded in the music.
Yes! In the middle of my Hamilton marathon, I find this little treasure!!!
Two of the most amazing men in theatre and on tv and in general singing together this is a dream come true
It's the audience who are making it camp, not the performers. Raul has a quality which is ambiguous, and his singing is so emotional and uninhibited it sometimes seems feminine, but it's always thrilling. A great pairing, I just wish the audience could shut up. It's they who want it to be camp and sent up, and the two guys are determined to play it truthfully.
Oh Leon, I so agree. Thanks for saying so. I think the audience is embarrassed at how emotionally honest it is.
Not quite. The exaggerated Spanish accents as well as certain expressions cue parody to the audience. Still, thrilling. One does wish that they could have entered into it completely straight, though.
Agreed. These two men are putting such passion into the performance, they are playing the roles and delivering with the power of an opera, layering the voices. Raul is blowing me away.
@@arthurboehm I not quite your not quite. I think they played it seriously from the beginning. And the OP is correct - the audience members that were laughing well into the number were either terribly young, terribly immature, and/or terribly drunk.
Miranda was probably coming as close as he is able to actually acting, but check out that facial expression at the end. He was as camp as it comes. Experience this video with as much confirmation bias as you need to, though.
It doesn't seem right to call this "Miscast" when they have done such a BEAUTIFUL job!
Lin-Manuel: Note to myself. Cast this guy in a future musical.
I cried at that ending... I love the passion they put into it. ❤️
Two of the MOST talented performers of the 21st Century right there...Love 'em so much!
the laughing stopped. It happened. It worked. Love.
Raul really put his hart into this and I always appreciate that
I CAN'T BREATHE MY FAVES
That left me wanting more...more please...
Their integrity, so pure - gorgeous
The piano, and the piano playing is very complimentary to the singing
No matter how hard you try to camp it up, once it gets to Maria's solo no one can laugh.
They make me cry every time. One of the best performances I have ever seen in my 71 years
It's 2014 and Lin's hair is getting longer. I think he may be growing it for something...
hmmm I wonder what it was for
I guess we have to wait for it to find out
+Lilith Blackfyre just we wait
just we wait...
I think it's has something to do with New York? They say you could be a new person there.
the greatest city in the world?
LOVE THIS. Best vocal performance of Lin's I've heard.
LIN AND BARBA HOLY MY LIFE IS COMPLETE
When you notice around 2:30-3:00 that Lin is about to cry
+Claire Walker He's a great actor!!
Claire Walker Lin cries alot
One of THE most charming things about him.
Claire Walker Lin doesn't fuck around. When he does something HE GOES IN
right? I love that.
I can't be the only one who notices how similar Barba and Hamilton are, right?! Also, Lynn - Manuel Miranda and Raúl Esparza singing together. Thank you, Lord!
One of my favorite songs and so well executed. Brilliant! Leonard would have loved that.
I'm obsessed with Hamilton and SVU and this has now killed me and brought me back to life all at the same time
Raul is so incredibly hot, brilliant, and talented. He was born to play the lead in my musical!
Raul’s voice has aged so well since tick tick boom!! He sounds a bit like he’s straining, but That Note was pretty good hot damn :0 and Lin looking like he’s about to cry really got me wow
This was the best thing I've seen all year! Come on now...Lin-Manuel and Raul together?! It's my two favorite worlds colliding 😍🤩
Get Raúl Back on Broadway 👏🏽👏🏽
That little stumble as they're exiting at the end. Perfecto!
I would pay for them to make a miscast album
I didn't know I needed this in my life. God, I want to watch the whole musical gender-swapped now, with Lin as Anita.
When two amazing performers take it seriously it works so well it is just breathtaking. I gotta go clean my mascara off of my face.
At 1:23 Raul tries to make Lin laughs and at 3:46 Raul’s lung power 😲🤗
I'm crying. It's so beautiful
Totally, wonderfully perfect! (Love Esparza!)
Me, to the audience: STOP LAUGHING!!
They’re laughing because it’s a miscast performance it’s supposed to be funny
Wow. Funny, and then stunningly beautiful. Tears and thanks. Somehow, I think Leonard would be proud.
I want them to do this again without the audience laughing.
HOW AM I JUST FINDING THIS?? I LOVE THEM BOTH
I didn't know Dr. Frederick Chilton and Alexander Hamilton sang a duet
SPNAPH me neither
Oh man Usnavi and Rafael Barba are killing it
Where is our Hannibal musical episode? Buffy and supernatural got one riverdale got like 5. Life ain’t fair 😂
I love theses two. They are amazing. Can't stop watching it❤️❤️😃😃
I’m crying
The writer of Hamilton and In The Heights, the star of both, and BARBA
I have been waiting to see these to together
*WHY DID I ONLY FIND THIS TODAY????!*
I can't stop watching this. For me, this is the definitive version.
Raul is killing it!
Amazed every time I watch this. Superb!
Two amazing men, OMFG THIS IS AMAZING
this is perfection 😍
It really touched me. Beautiful!
That was wonderful....love you both...
Fantastic!! Then the final 45 seconds!! 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
If you put two of the most dramatic kings in a heated and emotional scene and song like this, they will pop off like the kings they are. And they did, putting their entire sassy asf selves into it.
You have two actor singers who are excellent They did an amazing job it was terrific
LIN IS PERFECT I LOVE HIM SO MUCH😍😍❤️❤️❤️🎶🎶🤤🤤🤤
Came for the comedy, stayed for the heart-wrenching notes.
Their commitment to the reality is mesmerizing --- and the singing....the performance......So Freakin Cool
MY TWO FAVORITE PEOPLE O H MY GOD
Two Giants in scene BRAVO