Paul Weller Album Ranking

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @salvadorromeromolina3719
    @salvadorromeromolina3719 8 місяців тому +1

    MY FAV IS OUR FAVOURITE SHOP ( 1985) : BOY WHO CRY WOLF,WALLS COME TUMBLING DOWN,THE LODGERS,HOMEBREAKERS, INTERNATIONALISTS

  • @DFUK83
    @DFUK83 9 місяців тому +1

    PW legend seen many times live since the style council. whatever he sings is magical, bang bang a stunning version. the b sides a nice cd. our favourite shop tour was brilliant like the album, out of the solo stuff wildwood and stanley road just stand out still

  • @mementoproductions6492
    @mementoproductions6492 2 роки тому +4

    If I were to do a slimmed down, edited version of a Top 10;
    10. Saturns Pattern
    9. Setting Sons
    8. 22 Dreams
    7. The Gift
    6. Wake Up The Nation
    5. True Meanings
    4. All Mod Cons
    3. Sound Affects
    2. Wild Wood
    1. Stanley Road

  • @Zoostation69
    @Zoostation69 8 років тому +12

    I didn't listen to any Paul Weller until 2 years ago. I am a huge Oasis fan and Noel Gallagher always talked about him as an influence. Plus Paul Weller did my favourite Oasis solo in Champagne Supernova. I''m from North America and he never quite broke through here, which is a shame cause he has an amazing catalogue. He should be more revered as he is in the UK. For me Wild Wood is probably his opus and one of the greatest albums from the 90s. The song that really gets me is Hung Up and should have been a single at least in North America. Those first 5 solo albums are amazing and can't say any songs from those are clunkers, all amazing songwriting.

    • @Harpdashian
      @Harpdashian 4 роки тому

      zoostation Opposite way round for me, I was raised on Weller (have a brother named after him and there were pictures of him all over the house growing up) and ended up getting in to Oasis about 3 years ago.

    • @ChrisW444
      @ChrisW444 4 роки тому

      Agreed about Hung Up, what an amazing song as is Brand New Start around a similar time I think.

  • @stephenmcdowell5711
    @stephenmcdowell5711 6 років тому +5

    you know your stuff, young lad - don't agree with your 'order' of lp's but love the sentiment and effort you've put in. Great job!

  • @danieldaniel2
    @danieldaniel2 Рік тому +1

    Hey man you do amazing job here. He is one of the greats 🔥

  • @martineyles
    @martineyles Рік тому +1

    Wow, can't believe you put Heliocentric so low! I really liked the album. It's the albums that followed it (with the exception of studio 150) that I just found forgettable. Saturn's Pattern is where I felt he did something memorable again.

  • @johnjohnnyjohnson9987
    @johnjohnnyjohnson9987 Рік тому +1

    Very informative and well thought out review.

  • @Wellerworld1
    @Wellerworld1 8 років тому +9

    Well done , good review 👍🏻

  • @davecostello560
    @davecostello560 6 років тому +1

    What a great review, Ross. I am one of those old guys in their fifties who saw The Jam twice and bought the Jam albums on the day of release. I loved the Jam albums, and played All Mod Cons, Sound Affects and Setting Sons to death at the time, but don't play them much anymore. Have to say my desert island choice would be Paul's first solo album. Love that you have so much on vinyl!! Go well.

    • @RossGoodallMusic
      @RossGoodallMusic  6 років тому

      Thanks, Those Jam albums were so important to many young people at the time but its the type of music I think what can also stay with you a lifetime. Since filming this almost 2 years ago some will have changed about (plus we've had a further 3 new albums since this) such as the debut solo album probably will be in my top 5. Thanks for watching

    • @davecostello560
      @davecostello560 6 років тому

      @@RossGoodallMusic true. I know all the words to every song still! They deserve to be up the top of your chart. 22 Dreams is my second favourite album. Guess our tastes change slightly as we go through life!

  • @bindilove3899
    @bindilove3899 7 років тому +2

    You are an amazing young man! Your review has really been helpful and introduced some great new music to me. Than you!

    • @RossGoodallMusic
      @RossGoodallMusic  7 років тому +1

      Thanks for the comment, it really means a lot!!

  • @katoness
    @katoness 4 місяці тому

    Fair play to you, quite a feat to rank all his albums. Good job.

  • @ChrisW444
    @ChrisW444 4 роки тому +1

    Wasn't sure about watching this as it was nearly 30 minutes but I couldn't stop once I started and I think it was great. Really enjoyed it. Disagree with some but pretty much on the money and well described. It also made me re-think some of my opinions on a few and give them another listen. I am glad I did, Saturns Pattern being one. I agree with your number 1 but I would have Our Favourite Shop at number 2. Keep up the good work, very impressive.

    • @RossGoodallMusic
      @RossGoodallMusic  4 роки тому +1

      Hi Thanks for watching and your lovely comment means a lot. To be honest my list has probably chopped and changed since I made this video but one thing that hasn't is Weller being one of the greatest. Cheers

    • @ChrisW444
      @ChrisW444 4 роки тому

      @@RossGoodallMusic my favourites change all the time too but that's testament to how good he is. Just watched your review on Morrissey's new album and agree it tails off towards the end but generally it's pretty damn good. Cheers.

  • @davetilley2026
    @davetilley2026 6 років тому +2

    Ghosts is my favourite song ever from the gift . Also I always liked this is the modern world good to see you do too.well done for a great review

  • @gn841
    @gn841 4 роки тому

    Great reviews! It does give people a feel for the diversity of Paul Weller's musical works. I notice in the UK people tend to put the Jam albums in a higher order, whereas in Canada we would put The Style Council albums higher up on the list. The amazing thing really is how many legendary artists would have such recent releases so high up with their classic work? Well done.

  • @jamiem8680
    @jamiem8680 4 роки тому

    Very good review, could argue back and forth about the rankings but well thought out and glad you got the first solo album so high !

  • @sean280769
    @sean280769 4 роки тому

    Late to the game here mate but only just seen this and enjoyed all 30 mins of it. Good work

  • @DeftonesFan1982
    @DeftonesFan1982 7 років тому +4

    Great video. I´m very very fan of Weller´s solo career. Its great to see some opinions about what is to be the best songwriter ever. If i have to choose one record to be as no.1 or my fav i can't choose only one, because it depends of my mood but definitely Wildwood will be very high on the list.
    Regards from Spain

  • @mementoproductions6492
    @mementoproductions6492 2 роки тому

    Here's mine (per band)
    The Jam
    6. This is the Modern World
    5. In The City
    4. Setting Sons
    3. The Gift
    2. All Mod Cons
    1. Sound Affects
    The Style Council
    6. Modernism
    5. Confessions of a Pop Group
    4. The Cost of Loving
    3. Cafe Bleu
    2. Introducing...The Style Council!
    1. Our Favourite Shop
    Paul Weller
    16. Heliocentric
    15. Illumination
    14. Sonik Kicks
    13. Studio 150
    12. Heavy Soul
    11. On Sunset
    10. A Kind Revolution
    9. As Is Now
    8. Fat Pop
    7. Paul Weller
    6. Saturns Pattern
    5. 22 Dreams
    4. True Meanings
    3. Wake Up The Nation
    2. Wild Wood
    1. Stanley Road

  • @MrBenmanning
    @MrBenmanning 6 років тому +2

    well done with your views on modern world!! id love to hear your views on bruce's 2 albums- particularly smash the clock! i love them both. smash more than wellers recent albums though i guess thats heresy as the singer bruce has- russ hastings- is clearly in pauls image. but i recommend it.

  • @kamerarosak
    @kamerarosak 6 років тому +3

    23. The Style Council - The Cost Of Loving
    22. The Style Council - Modernism: A New Decade
    21. Paul Weller - Heliocentric
    20. Paul Weller - Studio 150
    19. The Style Council - Confessions Of A Pop Group
    18. Paul Weller - Illumination
    17. The Style Council - Cafe Bleu
    16. The Jam - In The City
    15. The Jam - This Is The Modern World
    14. Paul Weller - 22 Dreams
    13. Paul Weller - As Is Now
    12. Paul Weller - Heavy Soul
    11. Paul Weller - Wake Up The Nation
    10. Paul Weller - Sonik Kicks
    9. The Jam - The Gift
    8. Paul Weller - Wild Wood
    7. The Style Council - Our Favourite Shop
    6. Paul Weller - Paul Weller
    5. Paul Weller - Saturns Pattern
    4. The Jam - Sounds Affects
    3. The Jam - Setting Sons
    2. Paul Weller - Stanley Road
    1. The Jam - All Mod Cons

    • @Riviera660
      @Riviera660 3 роки тому +1

      Thank you for spoiling it for me

  • @neilfitzsimmons1800
    @neilfitzsimmons1800 4 роки тому

    Great review young man. Brilliant to see your enthusiasm for an amazing artist.

  • @ewanellis2176
    @ewanellis2176 6 років тому

    Great video mate, really enjoyed watching this, been a paul weller fan for the last 5 years now, seen him live 3 times, and I agree with all mod cons being the best jam album :)

  • @edwardbrinson6137
    @edwardbrinson6137 7 років тому +1

    So glad you give Modern World some love.

  • @truckystiv
    @truckystiv 4 роки тому

    Just stumbled on this (with Sunset Blvd just released). I'd love to hear what Weller would think of your rankings, it's very thoughtful. Enjoyed the episode a lot! I'll be watching more of yours

  • @VinylCollectorJames
    @VinylCollectorJames 8 років тому

    hey Ross, very ambitious video, you are brave haha. It's so difficult to compare the 3 projects but I would say you did a very good job on this, and while I'm still very new to Paul Weller apart from The Style Council, and the Jam a bit more, and the solo stuff just building on it a little bit, I think our opinions are going to line up pretty well on the ranking. Kudos to you for this video, this would be very difficult. Great job.

    • @RossGoodallMusic
      @RossGoodallMusic  8 років тому

      Gald you liked the video mate.

    • @VinylCollectorJames
      @VinylCollectorJames 6 років тому +1

      Ross Goodall rewatched to see how my ranking is looking. We have some differences for sure. Where would you put A Kind Revolution? Top 10 for me. I'm going to make my version of this video a few weeks after the new album drops. You're the best Ross, enjoyed this so much.

    • @RossGoodallMusic
      @RossGoodallMusic  6 років тому +1

      Not sure where a kind revolution would rank, I loved it on release, buts its mellowed somewhat for me. probably in the lower part of the top 10.

  • @mrquiff123
    @mrquiff123 7 років тому +6

    I think you wrong regarding the Cost of loving album, but hey we all have our own opinions

    • @simonholyoak8869
      @simonholyoak8869 4 роки тому

      I like The Cost of Loving. Would have put Studio 150 below that personally. Think it's become lore that it's not good. Personally, I reckon it's great. Modernism, a New Decade was not good but interesting and a brave thing to do. Trying to move Mod dance music onwards. Heliocentric deserves it’s position except that Cost of Loving is better. Studio 150 is far too high for me. Do like Wishing on a Star though. Confessions of a Pop Group is fucking brilliant! Would put that above Sonik Kicks. You seem to not like Style Council that much. Illuminations by anyone else would be great but average for Weller. Cafe Bleu too low. Not a Style Council fan. Worth it just for the piano version of My Ever Changing Moods.
      In the City in about the right place. Hasn't aged well and too much Feelgoods copying going on. Agree with Modern World placing. Life From a Window good and Tonight at Noon good though.
      Twenty-Two Dreams far too low. It’s a masterpiece. Weller’s White Album. Philistine!😁
      As is Now in about right place but again has some great tunes.
      Heavy Soul great but as a follow up to Stanley Road it doesn't stand up as well. Wake Up The Nation not great to me. A bit lazy. No way is it better than 22 Dreams. Sonik Kicks only got one great song on. Don't want to call it shit because he means it but it comes close.
      I love the Gift. Underrated. He’s trying to push forward. Carnation is genius. Precious is fantastic. Love those Lyrics man.
      Wild Wood is one of his gold standard one’s for me. Too low. Wish you hadn’t used the ”diversity” word though mate!
      Our Favourite shop is indeed brilliant.
      The Paul Weller album is good but NO WAY as good as Wild Wood!!
      Saturn’s Pattern far too high, good though it is.
      Sound Effects only FOUR!!!! You’re having a giraffe mate!!
      Setting Sons would be in my top three.
      Stanley Road at two? I can live with that I suppose.
      A worthy number one. You rescued it at the end. You need to update with a Kind Revolution and True Meanings. That’ll make it tough.
      Can’t agree but a great effort mate. God bless

  • @adammm__alltogether
    @adammm__alltogether 8 років тому

    Hi Ross, congratulations on a good review of Paul Weller's work. I don't quite agree with all of your rankings but I do agree with much of what you say and I'm glad that you rate Sonik Kicks & Saturn's Pattern so highly because they're top class albums. A Solid Bond my brother !

  • @jonathansteadman7935
    @jonathansteadman7935 4 роки тому

    As an old school fan from the Jam days gotta say well done, I'd go along with your ratings of the Weller fella'!

  • @vinylpride80
    @vinylpride80 8 років тому

    Good one Ross always enjoy your reviews. Keep em comimg 🎶🎶🎶

  • @Harpdashian
    @Harpdashian 4 роки тому +2

    Top 3 for me has to be
    Wild Wood
    Setting Sons
    Our Favourite Shop

  • @emeraldscorpio
    @emeraldscorpio 3 роки тому +2

    Helocentric is a brilliant album! Being so low is criminal!

  • @justinliberati150
    @justinliberati150 9 місяців тому

    very good review

  • @tefltoulouse
    @tefltoulouse 7 років тому

    Yes, great review. Will have to check out "our fave shop"! Also to note that the sound clips here sound much better on my laptop speakers than the Jam do on my stereo... somehow!

  • @somamusika
    @somamusika Рік тому

    Cant believe Helliocentric is that far behind. Thank you, good review.

  • @safetyman4967
    @safetyman4967 7 років тому +2

    You forgot fly on the wall

  • @randyrowe3097
    @randyrowe3097 5 років тому

    You have a good ear for music. Paul Weller to me is a great artist and has great arrangements. He does fall short on some albums. I think it's a lot of that could be due to label obligations though.

  • @TheOompahRoundabout
    @TheOompahRoundabout 7 років тому

    Great stuff Ross. 👍🏻😃🇦🇺

  • @thatpeterboy
    @thatpeterboy Рік тому

    I love Heliocentric such a great album imho…but interesting to hear others opinions.

  • @DackRambo
    @DackRambo 7 років тому +3

    your nerdiness is so cute BUT NO WAY COST OF LOVING #23!! ?? love that album

  • @Urlocallordandsavior
    @Urlocallordandsavior 2 роки тому

    To be frank, I kind of think Weller's stuff's a little too British, but I like a lot of his hits. "Here's a New Thing" is very good.

  • @kieronseamonsstudio6774
    @kieronseamonsstudio6774 6 років тому

    good job, don't aree with order but were all different. STANLEY ROAD, HEAVY SOUL AND THE paul weller, top three. good run down and good info too

  • @wellerfanuk
    @wellerfanuk 4 роки тому

    What an Impossible thing to do. With an ELO tee-shirt on

  • @TheKwod
    @TheKwod 4 роки тому +1

    I find it odd that weller rarely performs 3 of his best songs.....
    1 its a very deep sea
    2.has my fire really gone out
    3 time passes(stanely rd)
    I bought 5 weller DVDs and not one of them have any of these 3 songs.

  • @PoliceBoy465
    @PoliceBoy465 8 років тому

    The Gift and All Mod Cons are my fav Jam albums. Our Fav Shop my fav SC. Wild Wood and Stanley rd my fav solo.

  • @wovokanarchy
    @wovokanarchy 7 років тому +3

    Great to hear a young perspective rather than some old tosser in his 50s reliving past days.

  • @mod69
    @mod69 8 років тому +2

    Although I have followed Weller all through his career I would still put all the jam albums top of the pile,he has an amazing back catalog but he has never topped the jam...how could he?they where and still are in my opinion the best band ever

    • @RossGoodallMusic
      @RossGoodallMusic  8 років тому +1

      Thanks for commenting, I think its telling 4/6 Jam albums are in the top 10 of my list, and 3 in the top 5. They we're truely amazing and he definitly had a hard time topping it. For me personally I perfer Stanley Road on the whole over Setting Sons or Sound Affects since its got a bit more variety in music/sound but in all honesty give me Thick As Theives over The Changingman any day. Thanks

  • @stevemcniel5513
    @stevemcniel5513 7 років тому

    Well done young man.

  • @grock9263
    @grock9263 6 років тому

    good to see the youth digging the man , I think Heliocentric is well under-rated , it sounds great nowadays my least favorite Weller solo album has to be Illumination

  • @pedroafung5774
    @pedroafung5774 7 років тому

    Good try at ranking a prolific career. I am puzzle when you say that the first album of Style Council is Cafe Bleu. I thought it is “Introducing the Style Council” ua-cam.com/play/PLDCuqqk0vh9zNhX8NKM7Tg7URFvaZe8yv.html. This album ranks as one of my favorites from beginning to end. The album Cost of Loving is the album where Paul Weller sings the most soulful and is in my top 10.
    1. Internationalist/Our Favorite Shop
    2. All Mod Cons
    3. Paul Weller
    4. Introducing The Style Council
    5. The Cost of Loving
    6. Wild Wood
    7. Setting Songs
    8. Stanley Road
    9. Heavy Soul
    10. Confessions of a pop group

    • @RossGoodallMusic
      @RossGoodallMusic  7 років тому +1

      Hi, Introducing The Style Council was never an album in the UK, it was put together by the record label and issued in Europe Only, plus its not a full lenght album. Surprised Cost of Loving would make a top 10 of his whole career but i'm glad theres a lot of love for the style council.

    • @tompreiss1361
      @tompreiss1361 2 роки тому

      @@RossGoodallMusic Introducing has the best Headstart for Happiness. That was the song that got me into Weller/Style Council 35+ yrs ago.

    • @salvadorromeromolina3719
      @salvadorromeromolina3719 8 місяців тому +1

      ​@@RossGoodallMusicMY FAV IS OUR FAVOURITY SHOP TOO. BOY WHO CRY WOLF,WALLS COME TUMBLING DOWN OR THE LODGERS ARE GREAT😮❤

  • @kevenglish
    @kevenglish 5 років тому

    Good stuff mate. Would have had Illumination much higher but pretty good otherwise. Well done.

  • @oldskertonion
    @oldskertonion 5 років тому

    Nice one Ross

  • @Mod-rw9cw
    @Mod-rw9cw 4 роки тому

    If you had of been there to see The Jam play their albums live . You would rank them 1 to 6 he has spent the rest of his career trying to better them and he can’t do it. Stanley Road was close along with Wild Wood the rest are good but that’s just my opinion and I’ve got them all. Seen him play with both bands and solo. Been a fan for 43 yrs.

  • @komoleeray687
    @komoleeray687 6 років тому +1

    Good that you rated Weller's debut lp highly. I think it's the best of his patchy solo career.

  • @peeky24
    @peeky24 6 років тому +1

    Difficult task consider you are comparing contempary recordings with 20-30-40 year old records. Interesting order; the suprise is here is "Modern World"! I agree with what you say about "Wild Wood", which has dropped down my own personal "Weller Ranking" list over the last 20 years. It does not sound as good as it use to, particulary the second half of the album. Never tire listening to the Jam though.

  • @braddersthemod
    @braddersthemod 8 років тому

    swap all mod cons with sound affects, sonik kicks with saturns pattern and we would agree completely. I totally agree with your defense of this is the modern world however.

  • @hugo2216
    @hugo2216 3 роки тому +1

    Orange album crap! Modernism very crap! Heliocentric his worst ever, nice strings. 150- great! Confessions good and dull. Illumination-great. Cafe Bleu-brilliant! City-Raw! Modern-great. 22-brilliant!
    As-brilliant! Heavy-Brilliant! Wake-ok nah bad. Sonik-really nice. Gift-genius! Wildwood-utter brilliant. Shop-good. Paul-utterly brilliant! Saturn-good. Sound Effects-GENIUS! Sons-Amaze! Stanley-v.good! Mod Cons-brilliant!

  • @varsityfan2000
    @varsityfan2000 8 років тому

    This doesn't have anything to do withyour current video, but I wanted to let you kmow that there are 2 huge Tom Petty vinyl box sets coming soon that will contain all of the studio albums, including Wildflowers. Not sure if the vinyl albums will be available separately as well, but this is very good news for people who don't want to shell of the going price of hundreds of dollars for a single copy! Here's a link to an excellent site that you hopefully already know about www.superdeluxeedition.com/news/tom-petty-the-complete-studio-albums-across-two-new-vinyl-boxes/

    • @RossGoodallMusic
      @RossGoodallMusic  8 років тому

      Thanks Ive see thoes boxes and I'm hopefully getting vol 2 for Christmas. Take Care.

  • @mountart2
    @mountart2 Рік тому

    Been a Weller fan since the very beginning, and love his adventurous nature, but have never understood the praise for 22 Dreams. Maybe it's a British thing as it seems to be revered over there, for me, besides one or two songs, I think although I admire the effort, for me it's a major failure. And, may I just say... Wild Wood #8... below Our Favorite Shop. Oh my.

  • @bigmicky71
    @bigmicky71 6 років тому

    totally agree with the number one but for me sound affects should be number two

  • @imposs-up1hg
    @imposs-up1hg 3 роки тому

    Ouch. The Cost of Loving is a great album.

  • @wr6312
    @wr6312 3 роки тому

    "Cafè Bleu" at 17?! Sorry but you lost me right there....

  • @moonbase68
    @moonbase68 8 років тому

    i was with you until you put Cafe Bleu at 17 and Modern World above In The City!!!

  • @wovokanarchy
    @wovokanarchy 4 роки тому +2

    The entire Style Council , aside from their first EP , were compete shyte.

  • @anfrankogezamartincic1161
    @anfrankogezamartincic1161 4 роки тому

    IN THE CITY beats most of '77 albums

  • @TheBillwilliam
    @TheBillwilliam 8 років тому

    Your a funny young cat,Keep up your love for music...And hey im old grew up with the Jam hated the Style Council but he was trying to change up befor being a "Who" or "Stones" like your insight into "Sure is sure" look man do yourself a favor buy Cutis Mayfield-Superfly l p .It is the high water mark of Chicago Soul and Wellers Hero.Take care man.-billy sedlmayr check out a song of mine on you tube .bye-billy

  • @anfrankogezamartincic1161
    @anfrankogezamartincic1161 4 роки тому

    THE JAM-great band, fantastic singles, STYLE COUNCIL-boring, i can tolerates single collect ion, PAUL solo-hit & miss

  • @user-ys3qq6rf6z
    @user-ys3qq6rf6z 4 роки тому

    i dont like him at all