Alex Murdaugh DENIED Motion for New Murder Trial
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- Justice Jean Toal ruled that convicted murderer Alex Murdaugh should not get a new trial based on allegations of jury tampering by Clerk of Court Becky Hill.
#CourtTV Did the Justice get it right?
MORE HERE: www.courttv.co...
#alexmurdaugh #murdaughmurders
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.co...
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.co...
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE
www.courttv.co...
HOW TO FIND COURT TV
www.courttv.co...
#CourtTV Catch up on the Murdaugh Family Murders here:
www.courttv.com/tag/alex-murdaugh/?
THANKYOU JUDGE for not spending one more dollar of tax payers money on this CONVICTED DOUBLE MURDERER AND THIEF.
He’s still appealing from what I understand
@@C23467He'll be appealing until the day he expires. Nothings gonna happen. This whole thing was a farce from the very beginning.
Indeed!! I watched everyday his trial and no doubt about it he is KILLER!!
@@C23467 Doesn't matter. It won't do any good. He's locked up until he takes his last breath.
Alex had it all , now look 8×9 state cell 😳
I was extremely impressed with this Judge, just as I was with Judge Newman!!
I am too 🙌🏽🙌🏽🤗
What exactly impressed you?
I agree entirely. Both accomplished, experienced and astute judges. Kudos to them 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Me too.
Judge Newman is AMAZING!!!
Nothing short of PERFECTION ON THE BENCH !!!
What a jerk Alex is for smirking during her last statement. He has no remorse and thinks he can still play the system. Such a Narcissist that will never see the light of day!
I Saw that, you can look at him and tell that he is evil
I also saw that! Just imagine what dread he would have expressed if he was innocent! I would be screaming if someone killed my wife and son and I was wrongly convicted of it! He had the smirk as if he was saying to himself "just wait.."
You’ve got to lowest you expectations considering he is a certifiable narcissist n’ all. No empathy meant he can’t feel remorse.
What a horrific decision by the court. When a clerk tampers with the jury for economic gain a New Trial is ordered. End of story.
The judge did an enormous favor to murdaugh by putting the condemnations on record of the clerk. Mistrial will.happen if not at state than at fed
I tell you one thing, this judge definitely runs her court room accordingly, no question about it 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
💯 😊
That’s a CHICK?!?!
Wait. She??
@@abigailh7715 yes that's a woman
Holy crap, I had no idea that was a woman till I saw this comment. That’s a dudes voice. What the!?
All my respect for judge Toal😊👍
Justice Toal is the bomb!
Facts
She's either been a lawyer or a judge for longer than I've been alive and I am in my 40's. She is what you call a legend.
she?
Judge Toal is a maven. First female Supreme Court Justice for South Carolina. Love her.
@@KohalaLover I thought it was a he!!!
@@jomangeee9180ouuuuuu me to!!!
@@jomangeee9180 me too.
He butchered his family because of greed and the risk of being found out. He shows no remorse, no regret.
Right it's still crazy to me that someone would do such a thing unbelievable
I don’t feel for his family at all. But I hope him being in jail forever brings comfort to all the other people he hurt.
😢
Very glad that he did not cost the state thousands of dollars to listen to his lies again. I think this is an extremely wise Judge and she came to the perfectly right conclusions.
He is still appealing from what I understand
@@C23467agree. Everyone seems to think this is over-it’s far from over….they already spoke about appealing this.
Pure evil,no remorse,a real monster.
It’s a b-tch when criminals come up against lawful judges!!! THANK YOU!!!
👏
In my opinion, you win the internet today. Good, fair, appropriate Justices are wonderful! And she is a treasure to SC.
In my opinion, you win the internet today. Good, fair, appropriate Justices are wonderful! And she is a treasure to SC.
In my opinion, you win the internet today. Good, fair, appropriate Justices are wonderful! And she is a treasure to SC.
In my opinion, you win the internet today. Good, fair, appropriate Justices are wonderful! And she is a treasure to SC.
Great judge. Honest and thorough.
Way to go judge.
Excellent judgement! She called out Becky Hill for what she was while still upholding a just verdict.
Might as well call her King Solomon, splitting the baby and all.
@@awc658not at all 🤷♀️
Horrible decision. A new trial should be ordered.
@@Solitude47152 Why?
Justice for Maggie and Paul.
Naw, I won’t cry for those people, we are a better world because they’re not in it. Sorry, not sorry.
Paul in particular was a *horrible* human being. His mother was an absentee narcissist parent. Dad here is the malignant narcissist.
@@kateashby3066As raw as your comment may read, it is true. Both parents failed their child Paul, had they invested their time in actually raising their children, not raising them to be privileged & above the law, and everyone else. It’s learned behavior, I somewhat feel bad for Paul, but again, he also was an adult and ultimately knew right from wrong.
Don‘t forget the housekeeper Gloria!!!!!
Mags & Paw Paw 🐾 RIP 🪦 🪦 🕊️ 🕊️
His own wife n son 😮 it come to kill, steal , destroy 😢
Her mentioning the strong evidence speaks volumes
Yes!
@@patriotbella lol, i thought he was too, for a second...the hair.
Agreed
It doesn’t matter. The appeals court will not be looking at it.
Glad she got the ruling done so they can start the appeal on it.
No appeals can change the fact that he killed his family 💔💔
Isn’t that the Truth! I noticed during this entire time he’s shown Zero remorse or sadness for either of them. My sadness as a mother would be so overwhelming you’d have no choice but to put me in a mental hospital
Amen
No, but it can force the state to spend millions and millions to try to get him back in prison for good. And if they fail. Who cares, OJ , he slit the throats of two people. He’s still walking among us. Free as you and me.
Judge Newman help an appropriate trial. His clerk is crazy. Glad this judge agrees with Judge Newman!
OK, Enough with Newman. He’s retired
Brilliant Judge.
I hope there are Judges coming up through the system as great as Judge Newman and Judge Toal. They are both excellent.
Shame on Becky Hill and great investigation by this judge. Thank you jury for keeping your duty
I think the judge is applying the correct standard. She was a former SC judge in SC, right? Pretty sure she knows her law very well
Yes, Judge Toal was the first female Supreme Court judge for South Carolina.
Great-stay in prison FOREVER!
Well it won’t technically be forever. He has to serve the rest of his natural life in prison, yes, but when he dies, they’ll take his body out of prison and then bury him somewhere. No one can be in prison forever.
Throw away the key! Nomore outings!!!! 🤣
@@adamwilliams9487I am sure that there have been some inmates that were thought to have escaped because of not being found. Disposed of by other inmates or guards. Too many people in prisons for too long not to have happened.
He can in four days send that report to the Supreme Court and re trial that way , hopefully his ego and craziness doesn’t
He is still appealing.
One greedy clerk nearly cost the Court a new trial.. hopefully she will not work in the Court system again.
We had this moron where he needed to be. Rebecca Hill is a disgrace. she should be stood down.
Good for the judge calling her out.
I’d say she’s smart and made some money
I agree💯
He's lawyers still made a good record and have grounds to appeal this judge to a higher court to decide if she was wrong, with the way she handled juror z is point 1, the screw up of cellphones 2, and argue standard she is using for this is wrong 3.
Alex surely thought he would be released!
I saw him scratching his hands and scratching his hair and he came in there with his little Dream Team he still wearing orange no matter what he ain't never going to get out of that
Remember the 27 year plea for the financial crimes is currently running which he can’t be released early or appeal - even if new murder trial was granted, he still would have been incarcerated.
That’s how delusional he is.
Hahahahah 😂
😂
The smirk on his face when he thought he would get a new trial because of Becky Hill 😂😂😂 wiped right off his face when judge said DECLINED
Thank🙏🏼You Your Honour.😊
She's running this courtroom yes❤
Im ok with the denial. But Becky needs to be held accountable!!!!!! Look what she caused over a few dollars
Her tail is now permanently tucked between her legs. If she did not experience shame and humility today then she never will.
This is NOT about her writing a book.
@@SeeFair23
Yes it is…
😂😂😂
Did she break any laws?
This judge is amazing. I just love her demeanor. She seems to have handled this so gracefully.
Alex just wanted some fresh air instead the stench of prison cells.
This judge is a year young than our president. We can can hear her make complete sentences without ramblings. She is a boss.!! Great job…
What a horrific decision, what a clerk tampers with the jury for economic gain a new trial should’ve been ordered, end of story.
I’m so proud of this bad ass judge!! I’m writing a letter to her office & the governor of SC to thank them for not allowing this psychopath to waste anymore taxpayer $!! Bravo!!
Drugs didn’t make him kill his family greed did. He is a sociopath 100% and will rot in Jail and then Hell!
Looks like orange is going to be your color for the foreseeable future Alex!😂
And not for deer hunting.
Orange County goes with his skin
It’s the new black, so I hear.
😂
@@jessikathompson3469😂☠️
HARTPOOTLIAN & GRIFFIN Are clowns!!!
They did the right thing. I am unsure that verdict was the right one because Becky did step out of her bounds. If he gets no new trial, she should get no punishment for what she did.
@@hennesseyme9112She's still in trouble for plagiarism in her book.
@@julesservantofjesus972 technically there’s not much that would happen with plagiarism other than no one will publish with her again. Unless she’s sued for it of course!
@@hennesseyme9112 she still faces her own disciplinary charges, I expect she’ll be pressed to resign from her elected position. Just because she may have said something doesn’t mean any influence came from her, it appears that the influence came from the jury itself. I have served on a jury myself, and they do call you in and ask each member to verify that this is your verdict. If there is any lack of clarity from a jury or an individual juror’s verdict, they handle this then and there or they may declare a mistrial. They all did that last year, so they clearly didn’t see what she may or may not have said to them (or one of them) at some point, as having inappropriately influenced their decision. It’s possible that what she may have said was not intended to make them come to a guilty verdict. It came from the prosecutor I think, who said that jurors should watch Murdaugh’s behavior, which would not be wrong at all for one of the prosecutors to say this to a jury. I am listening again to some of the trial testimony and statements, to see if that’s what may have occurred.
@@ErinAbou Yes I'm sure she'll "resign" aka be fired from being a clerk.
Was a fantastic hearing 👌 this judge is truly amazing 👏 and creighton Waters closing was outstanding as usual 👏 now let this be an end to ALEX MURDAUGH
Amen to that !!!!
I really like this Judge she has been around along time and knows her stuff , and conducts her court with know nonsense. She knows her stuff.
Wow!!!! Way to go, Judge Toal!
Judge Newman would’ve denied it too. Happy retirement judge Newman! Great job to the presiding judge!
She’s said what I’ve said all along about that court clerk. This is what a fair judge looks like.
Brilliant Judge! 👏👏👏👏
Justice for Maggie and Paul. Thank you to this judge. 👏👏👏👏
Thank God they didn’t let that monster free!
This judge is very well spoken and took everything into account
Idk, I kinda miss the African
His face told it all.
Amen
Totally, unequivocally, am in agreement with both the jury verdict and with the denial of a new trial!!
He’s guilty of double murder and his punishment is of his own actions and making!!
Time to move on from AM!
She basically said, "He did it. Period."
What a horrible decision. A criminal act was committed. A new trial should have been ordered. Shame on the Court.
Thank you your honour!!! 🙏🏼💗
Still wild that she just thought nobody would catch onto her plagiarizing for the book.
What did she plagiarize. I only heard her say she did, but I didn't hear from who.
@@hennesseyme9112I don't know but I think it was several people's articles? I'm not sure about that.
becky is not a writer. her editor AND co-writer (WRITERS) should have caught that but THEY were star-struck!!!
@@hennesseyme9112
He said an article from a British tabloid, but didn’t mention specifically. I’m sure if you search the net you’ll find exactly what it is.
@@julesservantofjesus972 I wonder what publishing house she used? If she used KPD (Amazon) to publish her book she could get away with plagiarism, but now that she admitted that, if she went with a publishing House, they are going to pull her book.
What we all hoped to hear.
100% the right call, two fine judges handled this case especially Judge Newman.
This wonderful judge is probably thinking I can’t believe I have to deal with this crap! It’s never ending with this guy! The smirk on his face
Thank you judge. 👍
What a wonderful speech from the judge and justice has been served! May Paul and Maggie finally be at peace. It’s so mind blowing to think Alex Murdaugh did what he did. He is the face of evil. It truly sends chills down my spine.
The absolute best decision that could have been made! Keep Hill's reputation down the toilet where it belongs and Murdaugh in jail, where he belongs! Justice have been served today!
What an awesome judge!! Love her no nonsense attitude and professionalism. This was very interesting!
The judge Jean Toal for denying the motion of a murderer who had murdered his whole family.may God be blessing to your family.
He guilty
Darrell Brooks' Judge Jennifer Dorow was great but can you imagine what the trial would have been like if Judge Toal would have tried his case😮
I love Jennifer Dorow!!!
No judge would have been able to control Brooks. At minimum he has ODD, probably a lot more. Dorow did an amazing job - I was shocked she came back so soon after the trial. She had the most impossible defendant but she managed to avoid a ton of appeal issues. I'm not sure who could have done better but I think she did an impeccable job.
I'm tired of hearing about this guy. Lock him up and throw away the key already.
WOW!!! What a ROLE MODEL to all JUDGES and LAWYERS.
This judge been around for awhile. She does not have time for bullshit …
Murdaugh looks amazing, all the weight back, relaxed and glowing complexion. Prison suits him clearly. Can’t be that bad.
Gross!
It’s all the buttock Sechs he’s free to enjoy now.
He’s finally with his own kind. I think he’s at home.
Sounds like someone is turned on by big red.! 🤮
His gullible siblings are probably sending money to put on his books, and he must be hitting that commissary pretty hard and also he might be getting extra honey buns from his fellow inmates in exchange for legal advice. He's apparently adapting well, like a snake to its natural habitat.
Excellent news!
Love this judge. This fair, but no-nonsense courtroom style and judgement along law & order, is how the founders intended🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Whilst it was pointless him having a new trial, as he is going to spend the rest of his life in jail anyway, that clerk should be immediately sacked and charged with interference.
She retired after the trial.
But, if charged with interference that makes it permanent and helps his appeal.
She did NOT interfere with the verdict! DID NO ONE LISTEN TO THE JURORS?!
I’m not a lawyer I have never studied law, but today Justice was done. I learned a lot.
Good 🙏
The praying hands is not an inclination of praying but in fact confidence.. sorry Alex
Where is he getting money from to hire an attorney? This Judge is a Legend.
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 Judge Toal great she knows the law, wise woman!!!❤
Justice.
MURDAUGH MAKES ME SICK.....IN HIS SICK MIND HE STILL THINKS HES INNOCENT!!!!!!! UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!💯💯💯💯😱😱😱😱😱🚔🚔🚔🚔🚔
Superb Justice ❤
I love this Judge so much ,Shes a rock star and she called out Becky for being a horrible person for what she did ,AWESOME JUDGE ,LOVE HER.
For a moment his face went as Orange as his prison gown. Bye Alec IF YOU DIDNT DO IT, then WHO???
When was this? Thank u
Is Alex is paying his attorneys from stolen money.
The appeals court won't go against her
🗣️🗣️You better Judge, Judge🫰🏽🫰🏽🫰🏽 sis did her thang and the boys knew who was in charge🙌🏽🙌🏽 s/o to us women with deep voices too! ✌🏽 Murdaugh! Go away from us nahh
That juror should be investigated. There’s no way that just by someone telling her to keep an eye on Murdaugh that it affected her decision to vote guilty
Hell to the yes!!! Denied!!!
This matter is now adjourned!
I ABSOLUTELY!!! LUV this very competent Judge Jean Toal!!! She's BAD A**!!! 👍😜
Wonder why was he smiling 🤷♀️
Because he is a psycho.
I think he was smiling because he was a lawyer and he knows that Judge Toal knows the law and came to the right decision. He knows he is guilty.
@@ruthagar6707 Very true😊
He never says let’s find the true killer cuz he has already been found, convicted, and now DENIED a new trial. RIP Maggie & Paul ❤
Tampering with a jury for economic gain is a criminal act. What that clerk did is an abomination. Should have been referred to the District Attorney for prosecution.
The judge made the right call! That's why he was overruling all of the prosecutors objections.
What a horrific decision. When a clerk tampers with the jury for economic gain a new trial should’ve been ordered, end of story.
Judge Toal, no matter what she ruled has to be one of the best judges I have seen. They couldn't have found better to deal with this matter. The Clerk is absolutely unethical, but nothing she said had any weight on the jurors verdict. The alternate that they sought out and had Sunday dinner with seemed a little bitter she was sent home. I still think they had to have paid her to be there and say what they needed said. The fact that Judge Toal read everything from the trial and mentioned the amount of evidence, including the correct verdict speaks volumes. Alex should just resign himself to his sentence before he doesn't have any money left to buy soups.
The smirk on his face when the Judge was all, "Yeah, the evidence is overwhelming and the verdict unsurprising". So gross.
Great Judge. Only a fool would say some dumb hateful bs like you did.
@@ozzybloke-craig3690 I believe you may have misinterpreted my comment. The judge was indeed great. The judge wasn't smirking. Murdaugh was smirking when the judge said the evidence was overwhelming. And I find that gross. It's gross to smirk when there is overwhelming evidence that you murdered your wife and son.
He smirked through the whole thing. Narcissistic at best
Becky Hill sounds like that song by Shaggy-- IT WASN'T ME. 😆
I hope they can now do something about the court reporter who caused all of this. Like voting her out of office. Then looking pressing charges on her and prosecuting her for them.
Court Clerk, not court reporter. She’s still facing her own investigation.
"I agree. The evidence was overwhelming and the juror verdict not surprising."
Seriously
Well done Madam the Judge... Once again Justice was served for Maggie and Paul...
Go back where you belong Mr Murdaugh...
Btw Aimee's comment "I am highly educated" was not necessary
I am SHOCKED! I watched part of these hearings and I thought the judge was completely leaning toward giving Alex a new trial!
I REALLY wonder if old Poot bought that one juror!!!
Where is Alex getting , or how is he paying his highest pay lawyers 🤔
Very good question ⁉️
Of course his motion is denied. But she should've have written a book.
@michelleayres5608 she did write a book? Do you want another one?
@@Just.D I don't care. I didn't buy this one.
@@michelleayres5608 you said she should have written a book? Who should have written a book?
@@Just.D I my opinion, no public servant who worked on the trial should profit from it. Plenty of journalists are familiar with the trial. Some of them wrote books. Fine.
@@michelleayres5608 but you said she should have wrote a book..how can she profit if she did not write a book...reread your comment
She rendered the appropriate verdict. Furthermore, Becky Hill should be fired. She willfully abused her position and failed to demonstrate restraint and leadership as her job requires.
Dude is guilty why go threw all of that again just to get the same verdict
Judge is right. Denied and full ordered. He’s grasping at straws…
WRONG. Horrific decision, a clerk tampered with the jury for economic gain a new trial should’ve been ordered, end of story.
Great back end summary..
It went how I prayed it would..praise God..but
I see honorable judges emerging to the surface..wonderful..
Judge Newman..Great man..has earned his retirement with grace, honor and humility..
jewels among us..
God continue to bless S.C...
My concern is for the judicial system. The clerk should be fired!!!