I have to say I think it’s mainly the style of the players that is causing that effect. The bassist is very good but he’s using about 25 percent of the power that bass has to offer, but the cellist is going all in.
@@Mars-mg7qx well basses have concertos and they also can be solo because in some songs like Paul hindemith syphmatic metomorphis there is one double bass and the rest is a brass and wood wind band I know I'm late but it's always nice to inform someone on the correct truth have a good day if see this
Honestly if anyone would give me a question about orchestra in my school I would be very surprised because everyone thinks the orchestra cases look like guitars
I always saw the violin family as being like dogs. The small ones (violin; like chihuahuas) are agressive, loud, and hyperactive. The medium ones (cello; like, say, golden retrievers) are also active but gentle at the same time and warm and friendly. The large ones (bass), the ones who look scariest and most intimidating, are actually the most gentle ones. Right?
This actually kinda fits with the people who play them, most of the violinists are hyperactive in my orchestra while just sitting there hoping to get a bigger part in the song besides being the beat (I’m a bassist) lol
I’m an elementary school General Music teacher and I’ve been using this video to show kids how the instruments are played, how they sound and what practice looks like! Excellent job.
As someone who is “definitely not” a bassist, I have to give my vote to the bass. :) But the end is really where you see the beauty of these two instruments when they work together in the orchestra.
Susan Howard it’s weird I play viola but I really love the sound of the cello and the bass. I’d say if I had to choose I would pick playing cello but unfortunately I didn’t have a choice. But hey, violas pretty good too 😄
@@velxcity07 although i love Cello the most but i love viola so much! It sounds perfect for me. Not hating on violin but violin is too scretchy and piercing. Viola sounds so balance!
@@iplayforfunsowhat9728 it means that the bassist was playing the same notes as the cellist, but one octave lower. When the cellist went too low, the double bass was not able to go any lower to double the cellist, or play one octave lower, so he kicked to make the illusion of that sound or something or maybe it was just for fun
You would never feel the true difference between these 2 as long as you watch and listen inside a Video .Bass cellos give you Goosebumps When played is like something overwhelming you entire body
I love these comments ! I was expecting everyone to choose cello because it sounds "beautiful", but the bass has such amazing ranges and ways of playing and takes a lot of work to play it. So glad people and non bass players understand that
My 2 fav instruments, even though they're all so beautiful and different in their own ways.... I play the piano for almost a decade now and it's my #1 fav for sure, but these 2 are really up there!! So gorgeous! Especially when they played them together!
As a cello player I think the bass sounds smooth and classic so I'm on team bass and at the same time cello sounds classic and energitical as well so I cant really decide thier but wonderful
The Cello is like that cool middle aged cousin that everyone loves, and the Bass is like the old but humble grandpa that everyone also loves. I like the bass but the cello has a more resonating tone.
This. Both are beautiful sounds, but the warm tone and fuller resonance gives a certain intense and mournful character to the cello. Sort of like the duduk’s velvety sound compared to other similar instruments. The bass was great, but the notes felt less full. They’re correct, but flatter sounding-dryer, I guess you could say. In the end, that subtlety is intentional, I believe. It’s intended purpose is usually to compliment loads of other instruments rather than solos.
For me, it's not much to stand, but having to keep your arm in the right position is harder, in my opinion. As a bassist, it's really hard to press down on the strings, since the strings on the bass are so thick, so I don't really ever worry about my legs.
@@elitaniav1865 Yea. And I already easily broke my bro's violin A strings twice due to my so-used-to-press-on-double-bass-strings-strength 😂 And I was so scare when I press on cello strings 😂😂😂😂😂
Eliana Esther S you won't regret it! As a bassist, I have to tell you it's a lot of fun, and if you really love it, you'll devote a whole bunch of love and affection into playing! You can't stand a day without playing!
Sounds beautiful, the bass sounds softer with these notes cause its higher up on its range of notes, cello sounds more stronger cause they are playing lower on its range
I’m a cellist and I of course love the cello’s energetic sound but my dream is to also someday learn the double bass! I just love dramatic low instruments 😂❤
I think the bass sounded better to me because of how mellow and soothing it was, where the cello was more percussive and more scratchy. Both instruments played good tho. Kicking that bass hurt my soul tho.....
Zachary Owen exactly that’s exactly what I thought. I guess the bass is more soothing because of how high the notes were for a bass, so the shifting made the notes mellower. I play viola so when it comes to mellow I’ve heard it all.
Jaan McFadden yea, ya know great kinda think alike lol. I play bass in a school orchestra and I can tell u, our violas are much better sounding than 90%of our violins who can’t keep their e strings in tune. I much prefer viola because they are more mellow and sound better imop. There are two cellos and myself as the only bass in our orchestra. One question I have for a violist, do you think it’s harder to learn the viola of the violin? I’m also thinking about learning the viola because I have fatter fingers and I tried my friends violin and one thing I learned about violin, my fingers aren’t made for it lol.
Zachary Owen the viola is easier because with the violin they shift a lot and move their fingers a lot, plus the melody is the most challenging. My school orchestra has 5 violas, 13 violins, three cellos and zero basses. It kind of sucks because the bass provides the rumble of the orchestra and without it, it’s just all scratchy and squeaky and high. My viola is really small almost the size of a violin, but I think my fingers are most suitable for a cello.
Jaan McFadden I would also think so too but think about learning a new clef which I can’t read and didn’t even know about till 6th grade lol. But yea, y’all need a bass player bc it adds a low end foundation to the orchestra. Good thing about bass is that the basics are pretty easy and you don’t get solos at all lol.
Zachary Owen if you thought having no basses is bad listen to this: we have no second violins either. And the violas play so quietly that basically all you can hear are the cellos and violins. Sucks, right? 😂
The cello sounds powerful and energetic, and the bass sounds so smooth and gentle, so therefore I like both.
I have to say I think it’s mainly the style of the players that is causing that effect. The bassist is very good but he’s using about 25 percent of the power that bass has to offer, but the cellist is going all in.
God Christ Jesus bless you all my family, have a nice day today :" )
I own a bass
@BIIIRRRRDDDDDSS bass
Which one is which?
I’m team bass. But when the both played together it sounded amazing!
BoomBass same I love the bass I chose it for middle school its amazing
Bass isn’t bad but doesn’t have as pronounced sound as a cello, mostly because of how big it is
#teamcello
though they are both amazing instruments
#teamcello
As a bass player myself, I am inclined to think the bass was better. I really enjoyed the combination of the cello and bass in this piece.
Is it hard to play? I'm just starting to learn. It's intimating when the instrument is taller than you.
Kirstin The Deviant Ek2900 Not that hard, especially because you wont be solo ever.
@@Mars-mg7qx well basses have concertos and they also can be solo because in some songs like Paul hindemith syphmatic metomorphis there is one double bass and the rest is a brass and wood wind band I know I'm late but it's always nice to inform someone on the correct truth have a good day if see this
People: So do you like the Violin or the viola?
Me: Umm......
I like the bass i play it too
Is it a TwoSetViolin reference?
@@lingling8047 i like the cello i play it
Honestly if anyone would give me a question about orchestra in my school I would be very surprised because everyone thinks the orchestra cases look like guitars
Violins are the best
I always saw the violin family as being like dogs. The small ones (violin; like chihuahuas) are agressive, loud, and hyperactive. The medium ones (cello; like, say, golden retrievers) are also active but gentle at the same time and warm and friendly. The large ones (bass), the ones who look scariest and most intimidating, are actually the most gentle ones.
Right?
And viola?
Oh no, they’re being neglected again!
@@glenngouldschair390 lmao poor Viola
@@glenngouldschair390 the viola is the underdog 0:40 😂
@@H-DA wonder if the dog’s name is Viola
This actually kinda fits with the people who play them, most of the violinists are hyperactive in my orchestra while just sitting there hoping to get a bigger part in the song besides being the beat (I’m a bassist) lol
Team random adorable dog in the background!
I’m an elementary school General Music teacher and I’ve been using this video to show kids how the instruments are played, how they sound and what practice looks like! Excellent job.
Same! Love videos like this where you see similar instruments played side by side.
team Bass!
tilini yeah bass is the best
Team cello ❤❤❤❤👻👻👻👻
Team bass
Team cello
Team cello
I love the cello but, The bass was pretty good.
Even as a bass player I still respect your decision
Bass is great
As someone who is “definitely not” a bassist, I have to give my vote to the bass. :)
But the end is really where you see the beauty of these two instruments when they work together in the orchestra.
I think I love the strings and sound of the Bass better. Much less scratchiness.
Cello all the way❤❤❤
I prefer not to argue about which is better.
I currently play bass, and there isn't a point to argue about which is better, in my opinion.
Reviews To The Point you mean ....... pitch
Nah cello always rocks bou
you can play all of the string in different styles
Kicking that bass hurt me 😭
Erik I agree considering I’m a bass player myself which does hurt me. INSTURMENT ABUSE
SAME
Derpy Hyena 85 I think you missed a zero.
IKR
I know!!!
The cello had really good tone not to many slurs but the bass was right on!! :) :DDDD I also love this song!
It is not a song,..it's a piece!
to the bass player: thank u for sacrificing your knees and neck for this piece
Team cello!!! I am a personal cellist myself! Most beautiful sounding ever! I like the bass too! All is well to me! ❤️❤️❤️
Susan Howard it’s weird I play viola but I really love the sound of the cello and the bass. I’d say if I had to choose I would pick playing cello but unfortunately I didn’t have a choice. But hey, violas pretty good too 😄
@@velxcity07 although i love Cello the most but i love viola so much! It sounds perfect for me. Not hating on violin but violin is too scretchy and piercing. Viola sounds so balance!
Same
Cello and Bass sound so beautiful together
I'm a cellist but I love the bass as well
the bassist kicked the double bass? Woow, i never expect it happened to add some percussion effects 😹😹😹
At the end I laughed my head off as the bassist kicked the instrument every time he couldn’t double the cello. Haha.
what does that mean im not a musician
@@pondererofdumbshit2669 oh ok that makes sense but it also doesnt really
@@iplayforfunsowhat9728 it means that the bassist was playing the same notes as the cellist, but one octave lower. When the cellist went too low, the double bass was not able to go any lower to double the cellist, or play one octave lower, so he kicked to make the illusion of that sound or something or maybe it was just for fun
wAiT… He KiCkEd It?.?…….
I didn’t laugh, as someone who plays the double bass, I was like “STOP IT!!! NO!”
You would never feel the true difference between these 2 as long as you watch and listen inside a Video .Bass cellos give you Goosebumps When played is like something overwhelming you entire body
Cello: "Excuse me, you fine large fellow, care for a bit of sport?"
Bass: "HONK"
Cello: "Good heavens, in that case, a duel"
I think I'm the only one who likes the cello better.
Nope, I love the cello
Team cello
I prefer the cello too!
No
Stop trying to make yourself look special
I love these comments ! I was expecting everyone to choose cello because it sounds "beautiful", but the bass has such amazing ranges and ways of playing and takes a lot of work to play it. So glad people and non bass players understand that
They are both so handsome! GOD gave you a lot of talent!
OHHHHHHHHHH!! My mouth was open the whole time!! The double bassist did a Fantastic job! They both were amazing. #cellogoals
honestly cello and bass together sound amazing, honestly the best sections in a orchestra in my opinion.
That will be so beautiful if you play a violin, viola, bass, or cello out in a backyard with flowers or in a garden. So beautiful
i love the Double bass and cello's low pitched sound
vraiment très interessant merci beaucoup à ces deux jeunes très bons musiciens !
This is just beautiful... You guys are amazing.
Unpopular opinion:
The cello won
AVGw whoop whoop!
Yup
Cello gang
I just LOVE THE SOUND OF THE LOW SOUND
Both the cello and the double bass sound fantastic!
It was this video about 2 years ago that inspired me to play the cello and the bass
as a cellist, bass sounds soooo good
Wonderful playing!
Both guys and both instruments are just marvelous, gems really!!!
Doble Bass sounds so gentle that I can go to sleep listening to it :)
The bass is louder and more smooth and gentle, while the cello is powerful and the energy of it is very beautiful so therefore I like both
the dog at 0:40 is the true star of this video
The Bass player is hot, like a spicy meatball. GO TEAM BASS, GO TEAM J-YARD
yuuup
interesting choice of words
Oh no don’t kick it those things cost a ton!!!!
I just love the sound of the bass thats why i play it im sorry cello but u both play amazing
My 2 fav instruments, even though they're all so beautiful and different in their own ways.... I play the piano for almost a decade now and it's my #1 fav for sure, but these 2 are really up there!! So gorgeous! Especially when they played them together!
As a cello player I think the bass sounds smooth and classic so I'm on team bass and at the same time cello sounds classic and energitical as well so I cant really decide thier but wonderful
The Cello is like that cool middle aged cousin that everyone loves, and the Bass is like the old but humble grandpa that everyone also loves.
I like the bass but the cello has a more resonating tone.
This. Both are beautiful sounds, but the warm tone and fuller resonance gives a certain intense and mournful character to the cello. Sort of like the duduk’s velvety sound compared to other similar instruments.
The bass was great, but the notes felt less full. They’re correct, but flatter sounding-dryer, I guess you could say. In the end, that subtlety is intentional, I believe. It’s intended purpose is usually to compliment loads of other instruments rather than solos.
Both such beautiful instruments!
Loved this so much! More, please!
Terrible duel , bon boulot !
Clearly the bass won...it took guts to kick it...nd pluss...bassists have to stand...so...good stamina
Im a profeconal cellist
For me, it's not much to stand, but having to keep your arm in the right position is harder, in my opinion. As a bassist, it's really hard to press down on the strings, since the strings on the bass are so thick, so I don't really ever worry about my legs.
standima
actually in an orchestra setting we sit on specially designed high chairs.. I mean cmon we aren't gon stand for 2 hours straight
@@elitaniav1865 Yea.
And I already easily broke my bro's violin A strings twice due to my so-used-to-press-on-double-bass-strings-strength 😂
And I was so scare when I press on cello strings 😂😂😂😂😂
The bass won but the cellist was better I’m pretty sure cello would’ve won.
PotatoTomato Lambily *if the cellist was better*
U TELL HIM MISTAKE! Y HE NO CORRECT IT!?
@@Cellistontheinternet oops i never saw sorry
Ok
In my opinion the cello sounds nicer but they are both unique instruments. You guys did a great job
I really liked it when you two played in unison. Encore for Lulu. 🐶
The ending gave me goosebumps! Absolutely beautiful.
Team bass!!!!
Cello has the edge in an outdoor setting.
Wow this makes me want to play bass now! So amazing 👏🏽👏🏽😻😻
Eliana Esther S you won't regret it! As a bassist, I have to tell you it's a lot of fun, and if you really love it, you'll devote a whole bunch of love and affection into playing! You can't stand a day without playing!
I just love how they are both bearfoot while playing, lol. Team bass all the way through!!!!!!!!!
Honestly, it depends on how good the player of both instruments are and they both sound amazing!
Great musicianship
This is totally me and my friend 3 years from now! :D Thank You! :D
Sounds beautiful, the bass sounds softer with these notes cause its higher up on its range of notes, cello sounds more stronger cause they are playing lower on its range
Yes, Team Bass!!! Wuhuhhhh, Wonderful!!!
Amazing performance.
Great video, guys! What's next? :)
Thank you for playing solo and together at 2:39.
Bass won
Wild Fiyre noo
the double bass color really flatters
What an idyllic video. ♥
I’m a cellist and I of course love the cello’s energetic sound but my dream is to also someday learn the double bass! I just love dramatic low instruments 😂❤
I liked the sound and phrasing of the bass player and the intonation of the cello player
Mind blowing. Keep it up guys.
They're both amazing but I think cello's better😋😍
Base both sounded amazing
I like the cello and the bass
Very talented bass player
“The bass is the man of instruments”
-My dad
Wouldn’t it be the octo bass. Or maybe the octo bass would be the grandpa?
very nice. is this a 3/4 or 4/4 bass? keep up the nice music 👍👍👍☺️
Pretty awesome guys!!!
Damn. Just no words. Awesome Timbre !
The dog...!!🤣 But truly, guys, you did a superb job on this! KUDOS!!!
Wonderful!! 👏👍😎
my fav is when they play together😍
The video is amazing! We can compare the sound of both instruments.
*Bass!* lol
- but both are amazing in their own way! -
Cello! You got a bass!
that kicks is the greatest musical jokes 🤣
Tremendo Duelo Vatos
How are you supposed to carry a double bass around?
The cello feels like it has a more dynamic range while the bass specializes in smoother “moodier” tones. Also…I vote cello 🥰
😍😍😍 I just love it
Goosebumps
as a bass player for nearly 9 years now i am team bass but they both sound amazing together tho i love the bass more
this is awesome!!!!!
Nice guys
just for you people wondering, they play together at 2:40
I'm just wondering, What kind of strings do you use William Swett ?
I think the bass sounded better to me because of how mellow and soothing it was, where the cello was more percussive and more scratchy. Both instruments played good tho. Kicking that bass hurt my soul tho.....
Zachary Owen exactly that’s exactly what I thought. I guess the bass is more soothing because of how high the notes were for a bass, so the shifting made the notes mellower. I play viola so when it comes to mellow I’ve heard it all.
Jaan McFadden yea, ya know great kinda think alike lol. I play bass in a school orchestra and I can tell u, our violas are much better sounding than 90%of our violins who can’t keep their e strings in tune. I much prefer viola because they are more mellow and sound better imop. There are two cellos and myself as the only bass in our orchestra. One question I have for a violist, do you think it’s harder to learn the viola of the violin? I’m also thinking about learning the viola because I have fatter fingers and I tried my friends violin and one thing I learned about violin, my fingers aren’t made for it lol.
Zachary Owen the viola is easier because with the violin they shift a lot and move their fingers a lot, plus the melody is the most challenging. My school orchestra has 5 violas, 13 violins, three cellos and zero basses. It kind of sucks because the bass provides the rumble of the orchestra and without it, it’s just all scratchy and squeaky and high. My viola is really small almost the size of a violin, but I think my fingers are most suitable for a cello.
Jaan McFadden I would also think so too but think about learning a new clef which I can’t read and didn’t even know about till 6th grade lol. But yea, y’all need a bass player bc it adds a low end foundation to the orchestra. Good thing about bass is that the basics are pretty easy and you don’t get solos at all lol.
Zachary Owen if you thought having no basses is bad listen to this: we have no second violins either. And the violas play so quietly that basically all you can hear are the cellos and violins. Sucks, right? 😂
This is a really uneducated question but can a bass player and cello player play both instruments or are they a lot different to learn?
I play the Cello. But I like the Bass way more.
So y dont u play bass instead xd
Great song I love to integrate into my drone video ~~