Why so many Malaysians are not aware that getting married to any foreigner men would impact their kids citizenship and then blaming Malaysian laws that have been implemented for decades?? Every sovereign country has the right to practise their own rules and regulations for security reasons.
it is not that. married to a foreign man or woman will not void them of being a malaysian if they follow the procedure to have the child registered within 60 days of the birth with the required papers. just that. #personal_experience
Maybe mummy was dalam pantang, and daddy didn't know maybe. Not all people know the rules. Empathy. Besides, if it's Malaysian dad, no matter where the child is born, they're still Malaysian. And anyone even without any Malaysian blood, can apply for citizenship after they fulfill the requirements.
You decided to get married and have the kid, stop blaming the government for your poor choices. I cant go live in japan and have a kid there and expect the kid to be given citizenship
Whats the fuss?? When you got pregnant, go back and deliver the child in Malaysia...register here. Your irresponsibility, ignorance and not giving a fuck to rules and regulations are the cause of their suffering
Why the mother couldn't answer her daughter? Is it not because the father is not a Malaysian. It make no sense if the mother accepts a foreigner to be a husband and father to her children but she cannot accept the country where her husband comes from. She's supposed to follow her husband back where he comes from. And the father of her children would of course wants her children to be of the same citizenship as himself.
So the children who were born in the US (which got automatic citizenship there), did they surrendered their citizenship as an American citizen after accepting Malaysian citizenship? I’m just wondering, because too many cases like this nowadays, and it’s not like they’re stateless… Dual citizenship is against the law here. Most of the time, the adult stupidity that caused the suffering for the children.
Malas nk ckp ler. Berlambak je typeC dan typeI ada dual citizen. Depa tu pandai sorok. Pastu pndai main statement mana bukti. Sdngkn diri sdiri depa tau kebenaran cuma auta je lebih nk cover line.
@MalayWoman-m4r Asal negara ini negara Siam termasuk Singapura. Type M pun asal dari pukau Micronesia dan berhijarah ke Indonesia. Masuk semenanjung zaman Parameswara. Type C Dan I dah beribu tahun mendarat di Semenanjung buat kuil dan dikebumikan dinsini. Batu nesan pun dah seribu dua usianya.
@@yours_sincerely48Salah Thailand dan Vietnam dulu adalah tanah Melayu,tapi tanah Melayu tuh dah di ceroboh bangsa Cina dari selatan Cina yg menyerang dan orang Melayu terpaksa berundur hingga ke Semenanjung seperti sekarang...Thailand tuh adalah bangsa Penjajah yg dah rampas tanah asal orang Melayu ...Jadi salah mengatakan Semenanjung tanah Melayu nih asal negara Siam...Tanah Melayu memang asal milik orang Melayu bukan Siam...ko nih dah nak sesatkan sejarah
@@yours_sincerely48Orang Melayu takkan mengaku yg tanah Melayu nih sebahagian dari negara Siam atau milik Siam..sama macam Melayu di Selatan Thai...itu memang tanah asal mereka tapi di paksa menjadi sebahagian dari negara Thailand...macam mana ko boleh kata dah beribu tahun tinggal di Malaysia tapi sejarah pon sesat nampak sangat bohong ko nih😂😂
Just follow the procedure. Born anywhere in the world, as long as either the parent is malaysian, register within 2 month of birth date, register surat beranak. The problem is when you register as a foreign citizen first, then convert your citizenship to malaysia. Mana2 negara pun susah kecuali negara yg accept dual citizenship.
Tak kira agama, bangsa pun. Kakak aku apply Malaysia citizenship utk anak dia lepas beranak kat Ireland 2018. Tahun ni baru lulus. Tapi pasni kena cancel sbb Malaysia x bagi dual citizenship. Kakak aku Islam, anak dia melayu half Irish,Islam. So sape yg komen sbb race atau agama, adalah orang hati busuk barua talibarut musuh nak provok psl perkauman.
Ye betul kalau bapa warga asing dan lahir di luar negara mmg tipis nak dapat kewarganegaraan tak kira Bangsa apa dan agama apa. Paling kuat dapat PR sahaja.
These children had an opportunity to be US and German citizens, citizenships which can open so many doors for them. What sort of mother would sabotage their children by settling for Malaysian citizenship when they can get a citizenship with better perks?
@@MikoSonya setahu sya lah kan memang wujud pun dual citizenship bagi anak yg baru lahir bawah umur di Malaysia ni dan memiliki surat lahir dan passport Malaysia then balik tinggal membesar di negara bapa and dpt citizens maka anak ini memiliki dua passport shingga umur 18 boleh sja pun klo bgini.. Tapi lepas dri umur tu anak kena decide sndiri sama ada nak lepaskan atau tdk. Sbb undang2 Malaysia tdk boleh terima dual citizenship gov boleh detect lah klo sudah ckup umur trpksa decide lahh pilih negara.
@@grace.c3310 dia tidak terus dapat dual citizenship ye. awak kene faham. bila lahir di luar negara, awak balik kene mohon dulu. bukan auto terus dpt mykid.
bukan semua tahu pasal rules kalau beranak di luar negara. Kalau ayah adalah orang Malaysia, isteri dia beranak kat mana pun malaysia rilek je. Kesian jugak kat Malaysian moms
because ur parents think that its automatic everything , dont need to go register and all. in this case ur father is the one to blame, dont blame others for ur own mistakes
For Information : Dual citizenship in Indonesia is given to children on a limited basis until the age of 18 or before that they are married. After that, the child must choose one of their citizenships. The statement must be submitted no later than 3 years after the age of 18 or marriage. Children with dual citizenship who have not yet decided on their choice of citizenship and are not yet 21 years old can be given an Ordinary Passport. The validity period of the Ordinary Passport is until the child is 21 years old.
fmt sila bertanggungjawab dgn tajuk berita. FMT please be more responsible or shall I say accountable, for your headlines. AFTER 14 yrs, mia finally got citizenship. the headline should've been "After 14 years, I'm finally a malaysian" or "I'm happy to be a citizen after 14 years".. Put something more positive as a headline.
Yeah, headlines always bring problems. I feel bad for the people involved. Just because of headlines and commenters who didn't use their brain, heart, and empathy, these people got so many negative comments. Ugh kinda hate this kind of atmosphere. Keyboard warriors without empathy.
If you're born outside of Malaysia won't it surefire that you'll not gain the nationality. There's people who come back to their birth country to have their child just so that the kids can have nationality 😅.. Idont understand the problem. Live in Japan for 10years, it's hard to even get nationality there.
Because mommy ,mommi'es family not have knowledge or ignorant the path mommy chosen would affect their children future...be responsible citizen please!
@@kuna9147 not future...now already can as long as you renounce your own culture and accept neo Malay Arab culture. Other culture eventhough Muslim is not acceptable, example Rohingya, Uigyur, Hui Chinese etc...
@@tg988sure can get PR if you has lot of money. There is a program called MM2H. For getting citizenship, dont waste your time. There ia no way to get citizenship easily unless you're Bangladeshi & you want to become political voters.
tu dia....senangnye dpt warganegara. Anak kwn suami aku kat US depa ckp tgk pd suami. Org melayu tu. Pui la hayun gini double standard malaysia. Anak melayu mengemis di negara sdiri dh...
These children had an opportunity to be US and German citizens, citizenships which can open so many doors for them. What sort of mother would sabotage their children by settling for Malaysian citizenship when they can get a citizenship with better perks?
tengok type C main komen race card. setiap negara undang2. bila tak dapat citizen blame muslim blame malay. habis anizah dlm clip video nie apa? bukan muslim? bukan malay?
TypeC dan typeI jenis tak tau nk bersyukur. Dh la singapore abis depa tu libas dari tanah melayu asal temasik. Ni nak jajah lg smpai ke semenanjung plak. Ni org ckp spesies naik kaduk. Negara asal nenek moyang depa taknk balik plak tp bawak lg perangai sana nk paksa2 kita plak ikut dia. Pastu depa marah kaly suruh ikut adat melayu sdgkn terang ni tanah melayu. Spesies prngak israhell payoh ler. Kita dh dok tanah org, ikut la adat org melayu ni siap perli lg org melayu mcm2 kalu berkempen. Tak caye korang pegi la kempen depa tu ape depa tak ngutuk org melayu kat blakang. Type je kempen ahem2 typeC dan typeI. Keluar abis isi perut hati pedal busuk depa tu.
These children had an opportunity to be US and German citizens, citizenships which can open so many doors for them. What sort of mother would sabotage their children by settling for Malaysian citizenship when they can get a citizenship with better perks?
True, aren't we always been told that those western nations are better than Malaysia. So those kids are lucky to have the opportunity to become world class citizens.
But why suddently alot of foreigners specially from china gets malaysian citizenship easily ..why alot of sabahan who born and raised in sabah still dont have malaysian citizenship..thats sound wrong to me
Don’t blame the law if you’re lacking the knowledge, it’s not our responsibility to cater to your poor decision making. Pls, this shouldn’t even be a problem in the first place.
*Undang2 Malaysia memang kena ikut, kan Menteri dalam Negeri KDN sudah ulas, bila bapa bukan Warganegara sudah bercerai tak daftar nikah memang akan bermasalah, KDN sudah di bawa ke Parlimen belum lulus lagi, Law kena ikut tgah buat reformasi*
Because your mom decided not to have you as a malaysian earlier. After she has been divorced and has no other place to go, now she has to come back here. So, makan lah dgn nasib tu
this! see the foreigner parent in most of these cases? absolutely not, they hate malaysia , because all of these can be avoided if they do it properly in the 1st place. creating sad story and blaming gov after own mistakes? if all, ALL of the ppl who married foreigner cant have their child be malaysian, we would have like so many others of these stateless child. heck my friend married an indonesian and have no problem registering the child as malaysian. the thing is u have to be doing everything by the rules in the 1st place.
In my opinion, what their kids are going through and suffering should be the responsibility of their mothers for not taking into account the future and nationality issue before they got married to their foreigner men. It is themselves to blame for not having a proper planning.
Because ur father as foreigner not Malaysian....so Malaysia govt not simply to make son of foreigner to be a Malaysian..another reason is Malaysia govt not place of foreigner bllood..k...understood.
this is not about that, even if the father is foreigner if they properly follow rules and procedures, no problem of the child to be citizen, most of the time this happened because the malaysian parent think that malaysia is crap, and by marrying a foreigner they would love to be the citizen of the other country, now, did u see other side of the parent in most of these cases? NO, because things go south, only then did they think of malaysia and create these sad story about blaming gov not giving citizenship. if u do it proper , this wouldn't happened. blame the parent!
Manusia mana pernah puas bro..nasib orang melayu ni islam klu tk dah lama huru hara sebab ada penyakit Amok ni..patut mereka bersyukur sedikit sebanyak negara yg Harmoni ni dibentuk atas asas Islam jugak yg melarang sifat assabiyah dan perkauman dan juga sifat sifat yg melampau lagi melampaui batas dan menganjurkan persaudaraan dan kesederhanaan tapi dari ambil pelajaran malah nk ambik kesempatan plak😢..patut gracefully dan bersyukur mereka tu..@@mgpunya1
DiSarawak tidak lupus dari masalah citizenship. Bapak orang Indonesia emak orang Sarawak. Dibesar dan disekolah diSarawak. Pengesahan kahwin ikut adat tempatan yang dissah ditanda tangani ketua rumah panjang yang juga tidak diktirap kerajaan itu saja. Masalah timbul bila hendak masuk sekolah menengah atau university. NGO termasuk loya buruk menyalah kerajaan tidak peduli. Rayuan terusan berkhir kerajaan tidak berhati perut. Itulah cinta tak kenal sapa, bangsa, agama, negara. Lupa negara. LOVE IS BLIND or BLINDED by LOVE.
X kan x faham undang2 itu la tanggung risiko kahwin org asing..... undang2 dibuat utk lindungi wanita dari dipergunakan org asing...dah nak kahwin org asing tanggung risiko la.....
Ada 1.2 juta pati china hilang. Ada 0.5 juta pati india hilang. Ada berjuta- juta myanmar, rohingya, bangla dan nepal mohon IC. Ada beribu-ribu anak luar nikah tak sah taraf lahir, didalam dan luar negara, tak tahu siapa bapanya, mungkin bukan org malaysia. Jadi fikir fikirkanlah. Jangan sewenang-wenangnya bagi kerakyatan, kerana kena fikir masa depan anak-anak melayu. 😂
Betul2 jgn2 nanti Pak Indon pula yang menjadi timbalan PM pula nanti. Ada 25 Juta PATI Indon dari Palembang hilang sejak tahun 1460 menetap di Melaka kang.
I don’t support blaming the law for your own poor decision making. Unless you don’t mind people calling you dumb then go ahead, you can risk the future of your zygote all you want.
From what I heard it's not about ppl discriminate her but its the daughter thought of herself... So the mother need to explain it to her when the time comes so that she know it...
A/'jus soli' atau hak mendapat kerakyatan berdasarkan kelahiran di negara itu dan 'jus sanguinis', iaitu kewarganegaraan tidak ditentukan melalui tempat kelahiran sebaliknya dengan mempunyai satu atau dua ibu bapa yang juga warganegara sesebuah negara. B/Beberapa persoalan timbul mengenai status kewarganegaraan bagi beberapa kategori kanak-kanak.Ini membabitkan kanak-kanak tanpa warganegara,anak tidak sah taraf,anak angkat,anak dilahirkan di luar negara daripada perkahwinan antarabangsa dan kanak-kanak terbiar tanpa identiti. Terdapat beberapa faktor menyumbang terhadap permasalahan ini, antaranya pendaftaran lewat kelahiran atau tiada pendaftaran kelahiran disebabkan kemiskinan, tinggal di kawasan terlalu pedalaman, kejahilan ibu bapa dan perkahwinan tidak didaftarkan.Implikasi ini menyebabkan kanak-kanak tiada identiti sebagai rakyat Malaysia walaupun mereka dilahirkan di negara ini disebabkan kegagalan pendaftaran kelahiran. Justeru, penting bagi ibu bapa atau penjaga memastikan setiap kelahiran didaftarkan.
Why? That's why your life choice... No one is to blame.. It's enough to blame yourself. Nothing is perfect in the world of life except learning to be perfect.
Malaysia does not have dual citizenship … also Malaysian passport is still consider very strong compared to those in the south east asia region. Also our government giving out free citizen during the past election to foreigner and phantom voters … Says a lot about Malaysia system. What a country ❤
Well yeah! Malay n Islam is one( walaupun ada yg murtad,other story) History is the proof. Our faith gives us courage to fight. Argue all you want but we Malays will not let our rights be taken away just because after a few generations after Merdeka others wants our right!!!
Jadi warganegara jerman ok apa. Dapat pendidikan percuma tau. Untung jugak. Semua negara ada kelebihan masing-masing. Belajar bersyukur dan pandang dari sudut positif je.
Kita percaya bhw krjan perpaduan yg ada skrng adalah tekun, bijak dan mampu menyiasat kanak2 tanpa IC di Malaysia dan berurusan dgn mereka secara adil. Hidup Malaysia! Merdeka!🥳🥳❤❤
According to law if u born in othet country and ur husband is foreigner, the children must follow husband origin. U can check in jabatan pendaftaran malaysia. U dont like, then dont marry foreigner and give birth in Malaysia pls if u are SAID U TRUELY MALAYSIAN.
Ikut undang-undang, Don't play victim la. Dah bercerai baru ingat negara Malaysia. Sblm tu beranak dan tinggal luar negara , lupakan negara. Bila dah hidup susah , dah kena berambus dari negara US/German baru ingat negara sendiri. Haram jadah puak ni.
Looking at these comments it seems there's a general perception of 'this is mother's fault so padan muka' But who is being punished the most here? Its the children who has no control over things rhat happened before they were born
Im 50 50. First, their mothers are ignorant to the rules. Their fault first and foremost. But, the rules should be fair and same standard apply to either man or woman.
So touch.....such at young age she already grew the love of a country where she belong...pure and sincerity earn her Citizenship..Congratulation Girl...🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
We should revert back to the old rules. Whomever married a foreigner husband will follow her husband citizenship. Damm Tun M for changing that rule due to his internal problem
@@Delina87not at all. But if your foreign husband is the best man you can find, you should accept his country as the best too and reside there permanently. I mean logically that country will be full of better men than Malaysian men, right?.
Don't blame Tun M for everything. Bossku's daughter Nooriyani married a man from Khazakastan. Tun Musa Hitam's former wife, Maria was from Chile. Late Gov, Taib Mahmud's first wife, Toh Puan Laila, was from Poland. His second wife Ragad Kurdi was from Lebanon. Some Malay celebrities have married European men. Mixed marriages are common in Malaysia. 😂🇲🇾👍
I had a good friend (Dad Malaysian, Mum Thai. Born in Thailand but lived in Malaysia) since primary school till uni days where she lived in Malaysia for 24 years on a study visa because the govenrment refused to give her an IC. Now she went back to BKK and worked as a Machine Learning engineer with a house and a car in Lad Prao just by working 5 years. Malaysia wasted a talent 🤦🏻♀️
Are your friend a child out of wedlock? . His father is a Malaysian, if married with official marriage, surely auto citizenship. If official marriage then the prob caused probably caused the parents. This country has law. Why her parents didnot register her after her birth? am sure his father knew about this problem when having her. So why must blame the gov? Now, should we accept every rohingyas, bangladeshi men who are known to marry local women just to do business then divorce them when they rich and get licence?
@@hawaandroid2786 they think becoming citizen is automatic without any registration and paperwork. then blame gov and say wasted talent. he think citizenship is just walk to a shop and verbally say im malaysian born in malaysia by malaysian father ,. and bam free IC?
‘Mummy, why am I not a Malaysian?' what about ‘Mummy, why are you not a Malaysian? Malaysian foreign wife's suffer the same after staying for decades and decades
A foreign spouse has to stay continuously for 12 years in Malaysia, to apply for PR. My friend's wife is a foreigner. She has obtained her PR status. 🇲🇾👍
To be honest, while we sympathise, quite difficult to comment also, cause we don't have the facts of the case. This should be a positive & civil discussions that could educate us all, especially those perhaps with similar cases. But, some of course like to sensationalised things...
1. Kena fasih berbahasa Melayu 2. Kena tahu dan fahamkan 5 Rukun Negara 3. Kena kenal Perdana Menteri Malaysia (PM1 - Sekarang) 4. Kena tahu lagu2 patriotik 5. Kena tahu Perlembagaan Persekutuan Baru layak jadi warganegara Malaysia ! Kalau sebut "Malaysia" jadi "Malayzia" / "Malasia", jangan harap !
When you too obsessed with foreign countries partners..you can't blame the others. Salah najib bossku akhirnya.... Just simply play victim doesn't guarantee you citizenships. A lot of people likes to play victim, hoping of getting something for free. Who cares?
Sorry! If you are the lain-lain bangsa, they make it hard. Unless you decide to “memeluk their agama yang sepatutnya aman atau dianggap aman, walaupun benar-benar aman tak pun tak boleh ditanya, kan”.
Komen tanpa nengok video ke? Bukan je chinese girl tu je tak dapat malaysian citizen, the next person in the clip, Aniza Ismail, a Malay muslim, her 2 children also did not get malaysian citizen. Jangan komen berbaur racist, hati busuk ye. Kalau jenis yang tak nengok sampai habis, tapi komen, sama lah, seperti jenis manusia yang tak memahami keadaan, tetapi buat kesimpulan awal. Akhirnya semua budak2 tu kan dapat warganegara, yang cina tu selepas 9 tahun dan melayu tu selepas 14 tahun naik turun mahkamah.
Jenis tak nengok video tapi sibuk nak komen racist. Clip ke dua tu kan Aniza Ismail, a malay muslim, whose her 2 children also did not get citizenship. Busuk betul hati kamu, semua nak dikaitkan dengan melayu dan islam, sedangkan orang melayu dalam clip tu pon menerima nasib yang sama. Kamu manusia jenis yg tak tak kaji atau memahami keadaan, tapi suka judge dan buat kesimpulan awal.Jenis tak nengok video tapi sibuk nak komen racist. Clip ke dua tu kan Aniza Ismail, a malay muslim, whose her 2 children also did not get citizenship. Busuk betul hati kamu, semua nak dikaitkan dengan melayu dan islam, sedangkan orang melayu dalam clip tu pon menerima nasib yang sama. Kamu manusia jenis yg tak tak kaji atau memahami keadaan, tapi suka judge dan buat kesimpulan awal.
Jenis tak nengok video tapi sibuk nak komen racist. Clip ke dua tu kan Aniza Ismail, a malay muslim, whose her 2 children also did not get citizenship. Busuk betul hati kamu, semua nak dikaitkan dengan melayu dan islam, sedangkan orang melayu dalam clip tu pon menerima nasib yang sama. Kamu manusia jenis yg tak tak kaji atau memahami keadaan, tapi suka judge dan buat kesimpulan awal.
Jenis tak nengok video tapi sibuk nak komen racist. Clip ke dua tu kan Aniza Ismail, a malay muslim, whose her 2 children also did not get citizenship. Busuk betul hati kamu, semua nak dikaitkan dengan melayu dan islam, sedangkan orang melayu dalam clip tu pon menerima nasib yang sama. Kamu manusia jenis yg tak tak kaji atau memahami keadaan, tapi suka judge dan buat kesimpulan awal.
haaa lepas tu salahkan gov la, apa la. sendiri salah tak nak mengaku,. dah siok igt nak jadi warganegara negara maju, lepas cerai cari balik malaysia juga.. jilake
@@runeraider4405 this is one of scenarios, if they marry Malaysian , the problem may not arise. I see so many cases, they marry foreigners, it is source of problems
Biasalah kaduk naik junjung, tak cukup ambik tanah temasik dlunya tanah melayu skrg dh jd singapore....ni nak balun lagi semenanjung. Siap ada sesetengah tu claim tanah chola ape bagai tp lupa nenek moyang depa mendarat di Malaysia sbgai pelombong dan penoreh getah. Dasar manusia biadap macm tu la. Salahkn goverment dan undang2 sdgkn depa tu tak faham sejarah.
simple answer .YOU CANT HOLD TWO CITIZENSHIP! SO it is their parent and kid decision to go back to Malaysia and stay in Malaysia..because of Malaysia has a good food maa..
Why are these women keep blaming the governemnt and our long stand policies on strict citizenship? after witnessing how those foreign nationals like Bangladeshi, Myanmar,Nigerian, Pakistani ,Indian and China using (read: manipulated) our women so they can easily get access in Malaysia for their their wicked and illegal activities, now i understand why it is important to have and to preserve this strict regulations on citizenship. I really thank our founding fathers for not allowing dual citizenship .
kanak-kanak tidak sah taraf bergantung kepada status perkahwinan ibu bapa. Statusnya hanya akan dianggap sebagai sah mulai tarikh perkahwinan ibu bapanya,namun status kelahirannya tidak melayakkan anak itu menjadi warganegara melalui undang-undang sebagaimana yang termaktub di bawah Seksyen 4 Akta Kesahtarafan 1961. Seorang wanita Malaysia berkahwin dengan lelaki warga asing tidak diberikan hak mengikut Seksyen 1 Jadual Kedua Perlembagaan untuk memohon kewarganegaraan anaknya dilahirkan di luar negara melalui kuat kuasa undang-undang. Namun, bagi lelaki warganegara berkahwin dengan wanita asing, anaknya boleh diberikan hak kewarganegaraan sekiranya dilahirkan di luar negara. Oleh itu, wujud ketidaksamaan terhadap wanita dalam perkahwinan antarabangsa.
kahwin dan lahirkan anak luar negara memang tak akan dapat lah, kalau nak juga kena buat proses yang panjang. Lepas tu salahkan kerajaan Malaysia kenapa tak bagi anak warganegara. Kerajaan ada undang-undang macam mana rakyatnya nak dapat kerakyatan. Itu Silap sendiri lah,
Perempuan Malaysia yang lahirkan anak di Malaysia samada kawin atau tidak, anak tetap warganegara. Jika wanita MY melahirkan diluar negara tanpa nikah atau suami warga asing, anak bukan warganegara. Jadi...plan your delivery lar. Langit bukan sentiasa cerah.
Anak aku 3 org lahir di UK takde pulak masalah citizenship ni..I don't understand nape ade org tak dpt malaysian citizenship..maybe salah sorang parent bukan msian kot
tak register dan buat kerja2 berkaitan dengan betul. apa dia igt nak dapat kerakyatan tu automatik ka tapayah isi borang bagai, cukup dengan ckp ini anak saya , saya rakyat malaysia, jadi automatik anak saya rakyat malaysia juga. ramai je org malaysia kawin org luar negara dan anak dapat rakyat, secara peribadi saya ada kawan yg ayah dia kawin indonesia, anak dia semua rakyat malaysia kecuali yg bongsu takda ic mcm kes ni, tapi salah siapa? salah sendiri sebab yg bongsu ni tak register betul2.
kalu kat western country chinese and indian tak brape blh blend dgn western culture sbb western is not family oriented. They are individual. Western want total privacy. Jd kira mcm kene pinggir once u divorcee. Tau tu sbb ramai kawan kawin org luar negara. Depa ckp once divorce, melainkn kwin balik. Mat saleh prefer kulit org sawa matang mcm melayu, indonesia, thailand, filipina tp depa2 ni mane suka org2 n. Tau tu sbb sy ramai kenalan dari sana. If u dont believe me u can ask the westerner which they prefer.
high cost, u think its cheap compared to malaysia especially the medical crap? and of course as usual they got divorced. mostly these ppl are single parent. they need to stop blaming others for their own mistakes
Why so many Malaysians are not aware that getting married to any foreigner men would impact their kids citizenship and then blaming Malaysian laws that have been implemented for decades??
Every sovereign country has the right to practise their own rules and regulations for security reasons.
it is not that. married to a foreign man or woman will not void them of being a malaysian if they follow the procedure to have the child registered within 60 days of the birth with the required papers. just that. #personal_experience
These people will argue that the government discriminates against them.
Malaysian are 'the choosen one' ,not everybodies are able to get citizenship
Betul tu
@ashravicmehmet6055 if you are a male, no issue. But if you are a female, it gets complicated on the citizen process for your children.
Because mummy don't register her marriage & birth according to laws. Another question should be mummy why I can't speak first country language?
If not married, the child follows the mothers nationality provided also the child is born in Malaysia.
💯
Maybe mummy was dalam pantang, and daddy didn't know maybe. Not all people know the rules. Empathy. Besides, if it's Malaysian dad, no matter where the child is born, they're still Malaysian. And anyone even without any Malaysian blood, can apply for citizenship after they fulfill the requirements.
blame ur mommy and daddy..
@@type_Cccctrue.😂
You decided to get married and have the kid, stop blaming the government for your poor choices. I cant go live in japan and have a kid there and expect the kid to be given citizenship
You are right
That is true. And in the first case, German citizenship is much cooler than being Malaysian.
That's what I was thinking too.
@@frankiechong3819Why she doesn't want to stay in Germany? Her husband is a German citizen.
Whats the fuss?? When you got pregnant, go back and deliver the child in Malaysia...register here. Your irresponsibility, ignorance and not giving a fuck to rules and regulations are the cause of their suffering
Why the mother couldn't answer her daughter? Is it not because the father is not a Malaysian. It make no sense if the mother accepts a foreigner to be a husband and father to her children but she cannot accept the country where her husband comes from. She's supposed to follow her husband back where he comes from. And the father of her children would of course wants her children to be of the same citizenship as himself.
Follow the father and become a Singaporean...dont opt to become a Malaysian
So the children who were born in the US (which got automatic citizenship there), did they surrendered their citizenship as an American citizen after accepting Malaysian citizenship? I’m just wondering, because too many cases like this nowadays, and it’s not like they’re stateless… Dual citizenship is against the law here. Most of the time, the adult stupidity that caused the suffering for the children.
No they didn't cuz the US allowed Dual-citizenship so they don't have to give it up but Malaysia didn't
Malas nk ckp ler. Berlambak je typeC dan typeI ada dual citizen. Depa tu pandai sorok. Pastu pndai main statement mana bukti. Sdngkn diri sdiri depa tau kebenaran cuma auta je lebih nk cover line.
@MalayWoman-m4r Asal negara ini negara Siam termasuk Singapura. Type M pun asal dari pukau Micronesia dan berhijarah ke Indonesia. Masuk semenanjung zaman Parameswara. Type C Dan I dah beribu tahun mendarat di Semenanjung buat kuil dan dikebumikan dinsini. Batu nesan pun dah seribu dua usianya.
@@yours_sincerely48Salah Thailand dan Vietnam dulu adalah tanah Melayu,tapi tanah Melayu tuh dah di ceroboh bangsa Cina dari selatan Cina yg menyerang dan orang Melayu terpaksa berundur hingga ke Semenanjung seperti sekarang...Thailand tuh adalah bangsa Penjajah yg dah rampas tanah asal orang Melayu ...Jadi salah mengatakan Semenanjung tanah Melayu nih asal negara Siam...Tanah Melayu memang asal milik orang Melayu bukan Siam...ko nih dah nak sesatkan sejarah
@@yours_sincerely48Orang Melayu takkan mengaku yg tanah Melayu nih sebahagian dari negara Siam atau milik Siam..sama macam Melayu di Selatan Thai...itu memang tanah asal mereka tapi di paksa menjadi sebahagian dari negara Thailand...macam mana ko boleh kata dah beribu tahun tinggal di Malaysia tapi sejarah pon sesat nampak sangat bohong ko nih😂😂
Just follow the procedure. Born anywhere in the world, as long as either the parent is malaysian, register within 2 month of birth date, register surat beranak. The problem is when you register as a foreign citizen first, then convert your citizenship to malaysia. Mana2 negara pun susah kecuali negara yg accept dual citizenship.
true, know to blame others only.
Yeah...they need to know about the laws first
Why ? Because the Constitution say so. Citizenship is not a right but a privilege.
Tak kira agama, bangsa pun. Kakak aku apply Malaysia citizenship utk anak dia lepas beranak kat Ireland 2018. Tahun ni baru lulus. Tapi pasni kena cancel sbb Malaysia x bagi dual citizenship. Kakak aku Islam, anak dia melayu half Irish,Islam. So sape yg komen sbb race atau agama, adalah orang hati busuk barua talibarut musuh nak provok psl perkauman.
diorg tinggal kat ireland ke skarang?
Kita tidak amalkan dual citizenship. Beruntunglah anak dia jadi warganegara World Class.
Ye betul kalau bapa warga asing dan lahir di luar negara mmg tipis nak dapat kewarganegaraan tak kira Bangsa apa dan agama apa. Paling kuat dapat PR sahaja.
Benda kau merapu ni.. kau dah ckap Malaysia x bagi dual citizen dok melalak kat sini buat apa?
Marry local not foreigner then no issue or at least come back to Malaysia. What is this crap
"Because you're German, love". Just say this and be done with the day. It's not the law's fault.
Yeah...why just not tell that...your choice is your own fault...
So cruel
Dia org ni sbb kawen dgn org luar, then bercerai. Anak kena ikut warganegara bapak, tp anak bak tinggal dgn mak
These children had an opportunity to be US and German citizens, citizenships which can open so many doors for them. What sort of mother would sabotage their children by settling for Malaysian citizenship when they can get a citizenship with better perks?
@@CitizenCan its their choice.. respect others decision instead following ur desire
Better perks? Haha... Malaysia is better for them for living...that why granted Malaysia citizenship @@CitizenCan
kes german tu mana ada cerai? nampak bapa dia kat surat khabar, kalau tak tau jgn sembang
@@CitizenCan because Malaysia is better than those countries.. duh
X layak jadi warganegara,salahkan kerajaan. Puiii
Biasa dah puak² ni
lebih ramai gadis akan pilih waki warga asing. 😂😂😂. laki malaysia boleh tengok je tak payah khawin.
laki gaji minimum rm1500. atau laki gaji singapore 3000sgd.
@@msah.fitribahari9022beranak kat Malaysia lah kalau nak anak dia tu warganegara Malaysia tu pun tak tau ke dia ni😅
Please look at other countries like korea, china, usa, saudi arabia, is it easier to be a citizen as compared to malaysia?
if i'm not mistaken it's very very difficult to get malaysian citizenship even if we follow all procedures
If you have 2mil, Sarawak give you PR.
Tak semua negara orang sama undang undang jadi tolong hormat undang Undang negara Malaysia
Jangan nak dual citizenship pulak
byk je depa ni dual. Malas nk ckp. Depa pandai sorok. Tak caye. Ko korek la acu gi check. Tp depa ni ada org jage....inilah nasib tanah melayu.
Suka hati cakap dual..ko ingat Gov tak boleh detek ker..duiiii
@@beetledune9264 hahahahahaa....tgk la kes kat gate klia...ko nak expect semua orang percaya ke kes dual tu tak wujud....hahahaahahahaa
@@MikoSonya setahu sya lah kan memang wujud pun dual citizenship bagi anak yg baru lahir bawah umur di Malaysia ni dan memiliki surat lahir dan passport Malaysia then balik tinggal membesar di negara bapa and dpt citizens maka anak ini memiliki dua passport shingga umur 18 boleh sja pun klo bgini.. Tapi lepas dri umur tu anak kena decide sndiri sama ada nak lepaskan atau tdk. Sbb undang2 Malaysia tdk boleh terima dual citizenship gov boleh detect lah klo sudah ckup umur trpksa decide lahh pilih negara.
@@grace.c3310 dia tidak terus dapat dual citizenship ye. awak kene faham. bila lahir di luar negara, awak balik kene mohon dulu. bukan auto terus dpt mykid.
Waktu kahwin, pasti sudah sedar akibatnya. Bila dah bercerai, baru sedar hak dan undang²?
So disebabkan diaorg kahwin org luar je anak xde hak utk dpt kerakyatan? Sick people
Correct. The constitution exists before these ladies were even born and they expect the constitution to be changed for their convenience.
Mereka tahu semua undang² itu saja nak provoke
Bola kahwin ada jodoh.
Cerai bila lawan, xde jodoh. 😭
bukan semua tahu pasal rules kalau beranak di luar negara. Kalau ayah adalah orang Malaysia, isteri dia beranak kat mana pun malaysia rilek je. Kesian jugak kat Malaysian moms
I was born in Malaysia and my father is Malaysian but my mother is Indonesian, they aren't married and I didn't have a IC
Find a Malaysian as spouse.
Macamna you lahir dekat dunia kalau bapa dengan ibu u belum kahwin😅😅😅
because ur parents think that its automatic everything , dont need to go register and all. in this case ur father is the one to blame, dont blame others for ur own mistakes
For Information :
Dual citizenship in Indonesia is given to children on a limited basis until the age of 18 or before that they are married. After that, the child must choose one of their citizenships. The statement must be submitted no later than 3 years after the age of 18 or marriage.
Children with dual citizenship who have not yet decided on their choice of citizenship and are not yet 21 years old can be given an Ordinary Passport. The validity period of the Ordinary Passport is until the child is 21 years old.
fmt sila bertanggungjawab dgn tajuk berita.
FMT please be more responsible or shall I say accountable, for your headlines. AFTER 14 yrs, mia finally got citizenship.
the headline should've been "After 14 years, I'm finally a malaysian" or "I'm happy to be a citizen after 14 years"..
Put something more positive as a headline.
Yeah, headlines always bring problems. I feel bad for the people involved. Just because of headlines and commenters who didn't use their brain, heart, and empathy, these people got so many negative comments. Ugh kinda hate this kind of atmosphere. Keyboard warriors without empathy.
If you're born outside of Malaysia won't it surefire that you'll not gain the nationality. There's people who come back to their birth country to have their child just so that the kids can have nationality 😅.. Idont understand the problem. Live in Japan for 10years, it's hard to even get nationality there.
If you marry a Japanese woman, they will give you citizenship. 🇲🇾🇯🇵👍
Those while waiting for ic, find a local spouse.
Because mommy ,mommi'es family not have knowledge or ignorant the path mommy chosen would affect their children future...be responsible citizen please!
Children born to Indonesian, Bangladeshi and Pakistani can be Malaysian citizen in just 1 year.
Nope, children born in Palestine definitely will be much easier getting citizenship in Malaysia than the same "Brothers'' from Rohingya and Bangla.
I'm relative to Xi Jinping and stay in Forest City. Can get citizenship? PR?
If you are Muslim,u can get citizenship and Malay status,in future all Palestinian will be Melayu
@@kuna9147 not future...now already can as long as you renounce your own culture and accept neo Malay Arab culture. Other culture eventhough Muslim is not acceptable, example Rohingya, Uigyur, Hui Chinese etc...
@@tg988sure can get PR if you has lot of money. There is a program called MM2H.
For getting citizenship, dont waste your time. There ia no way to get citizenship easily unless you're Bangladeshi & you want to become political voters.
You just need to go to Malaysian Ambassador in China and you will get your Malaysian citizenship in a month
tu dia....senangnye dpt warganegara. Anak kwn suami aku kat US depa ckp tgk pd suami. Org melayu tu. Pui la hayun gini double standard malaysia. Anak melayu mengemis di negara sdiri dh...
OH INI KERJA KAU RUPANYA SELAMA NI😅
Stop spreading racist comment. Aniza Ismail on the clip 1.24..also have the same problem. Whats your problem..BS memanjang 😹
These children had an opportunity to be US and German citizens, citizenships which can open so many doors for them. What sort of mother would sabotage their children by settling for Malaysian citizenship when they can get a citizenship with better perks?
@@CitizenCan 💯☑
Aku tak setuju diorang jdi rakyat Malaysia lebih baik jadi rakyat US, UK atau HK. 😡
@@roafelix8198 negara kita ni pilihan akhir, sbb diorg x dpt warganegara sana tu pasal pusing balik kat sini..lepastu play victim..haha
Diorang tak tengok video sampai habis lepas tu komen ikut suka mak bapak dia.
tengok type C main komen race card. setiap negara undang2. bila tak dapat citizen blame muslim blame malay. habis anizah dlm clip video nie apa? bukan muslim? bukan malay?
TypeC dan typeI jenis tak tau nk bersyukur. Dh la singapore abis depa tu libas dari tanah melayu asal temasik. Ni nak jajah lg smpai ke semenanjung plak. Ni org ckp spesies naik kaduk. Negara asal nenek moyang depa taknk balik plak tp bawak lg perangai sana nk paksa2 kita plak ikut dia. Pastu depa marah kaly suruh ikut adat melayu sdgkn terang ni tanah melayu. Spesies prngak israhell payoh ler. Kita dh dok tanah org, ikut la adat org melayu ni siap perli lg org melayu mcm2 kalu berkempen. Tak caye korang pegi la kempen depa tu ape depa tak ngutuk org melayu kat blakang. Type je kempen ahem2 typeC dan typeI. Keluar abis isi perut hati pedal busuk depa tu.
Biased la typical type C
@MichaelKuruvillatypical Chauvinist Centric Chinese Never be grateful for what they have
betul tapi kerajaan skrang senang sngt bgi muke pada type C dngn K 🧔🏿👲🏻😂
type C mmg suka play vctim
This case came up becoz Malaysia has a problem with "pendatang asing tanpa izin" and the results of this made Malaysia more strict to the immigrants.
These children had an opportunity to be US and German citizens, citizenships which can open so many doors for them. What sort of mother would sabotage their children by settling for Malaysian citizenship when they can get a citizenship with better perks?
Optional for permanent resident in Germany.
Sabotage?
True, aren't we always been told that those western nations are better than Malaysia. So those kids are lucky to have the opportunity to become world class citizens.
@@nuurulbasarmohdbaki6046western country better than Malaysia? Hahaha...go outside world bruh...
you sohai or what? underage can take care themselves?
Rule of law
Sorry no empathy. You made the mistake and blame govt.
But why suddently alot of foreigners specially from china gets malaysian citizenship easily ..why alot of sabahan who born and raised in sabah still dont have malaysian citizenship..thats sound wrong to me
full story how they end up being that. Need to both side of the stories. Selamat menyambut hari Merdeka
Don’t blame the law if you’re lacking the knowledge, it’s not our responsibility to cater to your poor decision making. Pls, this shouldn’t even be a problem in the first place.
*Undang2 Malaysia memang kena ikut, kan Menteri dalam Negeri KDN sudah ulas, bila bapa bukan Warganegara sudah bercerai tak daftar nikah memang akan bermasalah, KDN sudah di bawa ke Parlimen belum lulus lagi, Law kena ikut tgah buat reformasi*
Can u speak malay?
Yes, go find for malay version.
Cepat,senang.
Go to Sabah Sarawak first
Can you speak mandarin or tamil?
@@mono8476go to india dan china 😂
@@haniida1827 go to indonesia first
My cousins registered their children two countries in England. Later I don't know.
Because your mom decided not to have you as a malaysian earlier. After she has been divorced and has no other place to go, now she has to come back here. So, makan lah dgn nasib tu
Woa such a mean comment w/o knowing the full story
The kittens follows their mum. The cats look after their kittens. That's nature law.
this! see the foreigner parent in most of these cases? absolutely not, they hate malaysia , because all of these can be avoided if they do it properly in the 1st place. creating sad story and blaming gov after own mistakes? if all, ALL of the ppl who married foreigner cant have their child be malaysian, we would have like so many others of these stateless child. heck my friend married an indonesian and have no problem registering the child as malaysian. the thing is u have to be doing everything by the rules in the 1st place.
@@mr.bee5225 So why would they hate Malaysia?
In my opinion, what their kids are going through and suffering should be the responsibility of their mothers for not taking into account the future and nationality issue before they got married to their foreigner men. It is themselves to blame for not having a proper planning.
Because ur father as foreigner not Malaysian....so Malaysia govt not simply to make son of foreigner to be a Malaysian..another reason is Malaysia govt not place of foreigner bllood..k...understood.
Depends on where the child is born too.
Stuju!
Marry local not foreigner then no issue or at least come back to Malaysia. What is this crap
this is not about that, even if the father is foreigner if they properly follow rules and procedures, no problem of the child to be citizen, most of the time this happened because the malaysian parent think that malaysia is crap, and by marrying a foreigner they would love to be the citizen of the other country, now, did u see other side of the parent in most of these cases? NO, because things go south, only then did they think of malaysia and create these sad story about blaming gov not giving citizenship. if u do it proper , this wouldn't happened. blame the parent!
Meanwhile there are some ignorant in the rural Indian community didn't even bothered to get birth cert ended up given red IC instead blue IC.
Allah opined that those Indo, Bangla, Filipino Muslim, they all can get citizenship over native Malaysians.
So don't blame the Malaysian government.
Don't bring religion into this, if you've problem with the govt then bring that matter with the government. But, pls don't touch religion into this...
Manusia mana pernah puas bro..nasib orang melayu ni islam klu tk dah lama huru hara sebab ada penyakit Amok ni..patut mereka bersyukur sedikit sebanyak negara yg Harmoni ni dibentuk atas asas Islam jugak yg melarang sifat assabiyah dan perkauman dan juga sifat sifat yg melampau lagi melampaui batas dan menganjurkan persaudaraan dan kesederhanaan tapi dari ambil pelajaran malah nk ambik kesempatan plak😢..patut gracefully dan bersyukur mereka tu..@@mgpunya1
Puak yang dihati busuk sentiasa tak puas.....alhamdullilah Islam ajar kita bersabar....maka keamanan Dan harmoni dikecapi.....
Wow... that's rude😠
Those who say don't bring religion has completely missed the point.
Islam is the basis of many problems in Malaysia.
DiSarawak tidak lupus dari masalah citizenship.
Bapak orang Indonesia emak orang Sarawak. Dibesar dan disekolah diSarawak. Pengesahan kahwin ikut adat tempatan yang dissah ditanda tangani ketua rumah panjang yang juga tidak diktirap kerajaan itu saja.
Masalah timbul bila hendak masuk sekolah menengah atau university.
NGO termasuk loya buruk menyalah kerajaan tidak peduli. Rayuan terusan berkhir kerajaan tidak berhati perut.
Itulah cinta tak kenal sapa, bangsa, agama, negara. Lupa negara.
LOVE IS BLIND or BLINDED by LOVE.
X kan x faham undang2 itu la tanggung risiko kahwin org asing..... undang2 dibuat utk lindungi wanita dari dipergunakan org asing...dah nak kahwin org asing tanggung risiko la.....
Kita lahir UK, boleh je dapat warga negara kalau memenuhi syarat yang ditetapkan oleh perlembagaan Malaysia.
Ada 1.2 juta pati china hilang. Ada 0.5 juta pati india hilang. Ada berjuta- juta myanmar, rohingya, bangla dan nepal mohon IC. Ada beribu-ribu anak luar nikah tak sah taraf lahir, didalam dan luar negara, tak tahu siapa bapanya, mungkin bukan org malaysia. Jadi fikir fikirkanlah. Jangan sewenang-wenangnya bagi kerakyatan, kerana kena fikir masa depan anak-anak melayu. 😂
Benar. Satu hari nanti tak mustahil jadi PM seperti Mahathir yang bapa dan datuknya asal Kerala...
Betul2 jgn2 nanti Pak Indon pula yang menjadi timbalan PM pula nanti. Ada 25 Juta PATI Indon dari Palembang hilang sejak tahun 1460 menetap di Melaka kang.
Ade lagi 20 Juta Orang Bugis dari Kepulauan Jawa Indon pula hilangkan diri dan menetap di negeri Selangor, Johor dan Singapura.
Ade lagi orang2 Siam dan Pattani telah menakluk Perlis, Kedah, Tanjung dan Kelantan...malah mendirikan candi2 sejak Tahun 200 SM...
Anda kena angkat PATI dari Indonesia supaya Malaysia kekal dominan Melayu. Jika tidak Malaysia akan menjadi Malaydesh dalam masa terdekat.
u answered the problem @ 0:16... come on lah
FMT is trying to free Malaysia from what?
The current Government? Constitution? Peace?
Malaysian Itself maybe?
Because mommy married with foreigner and didn't register her marriage with Malaysian government. Citizenship are privilege.
mummy only think of malaysia after divorced. but since no register... then good luck mummy
Free Malaysia Today, You're amazing! I hit the like button as soon as I saw it!
u can keep dreaming la type K
I don’t support blaming the law for your own poor decision making. Unless you don’t mind people calling you dumb then go ahead, you can risk the future of your zygote all you want.
Your mummy's choice
Merdeka is still about getting independence from the British, even after 67 years. Nothing more, nothing less.
just on the surface...for the public..
From what I heard it's not about ppl discriminate her but its the daughter thought of herself... So the mother need to explain it to her when the time comes so that she know it...
Mak Salleh good for marriage now what happen .....
Married bec of love.
Sometimes, love never last.
Even in Malaysia, the divorce rates are high, esp among the Muslims. 😭
A/'jus soli' atau hak mendapat kerakyatan berdasarkan kelahiran di negara itu dan 'jus sanguinis', iaitu kewarganegaraan tidak ditentukan melalui tempat kelahiran sebaliknya dengan mempunyai satu atau dua ibu bapa yang juga warganegara sesebuah negara.
B/Beberapa persoalan timbul mengenai status kewarganegaraan bagi beberapa kategori kanak-kanak.Ini membabitkan kanak-kanak tanpa warganegara,anak tidak sah taraf,anak angkat,anak dilahirkan di luar negara daripada perkahwinan antarabangsa dan kanak-kanak terbiar tanpa identiti.
Terdapat beberapa faktor menyumbang terhadap permasalahan ini, antaranya pendaftaran lewat kelahiran atau tiada pendaftaran kelahiran disebabkan kemiskinan, tinggal di kawasan terlalu pedalaman, kejahilan ibu bapa dan perkahwinan tidak didaftarkan.Implikasi ini menyebabkan kanak-kanak tiada identiti sebagai rakyat Malaysia walaupun mereka dilahirkan di negara ini disebabkan kegagalan pendaftaran kelahiran. Justeru, penting bagi ibu bapa atau penjaga memastikan setiap kelahiran didaftarkan.
kawin dengan orang luar takkan tak tau kesan dan masalah yang akan dihadapi?
asik komplen gomen je
Inform embassy if you having child born out the country.
Why? That's why your life choice... No one is to blame.. It's enough to blame yourself. Nothing is perfect in the world of life except learning to be perfect.
Malaysia does not have dual citizenship … also Malaysian passport is still consider very strong compared to those in the south east asia region.
Also our government giving out free citizen during the past election to foreigner and phantom voters …
Says a lot about Malaysia system. What a country ❤
Islam is the impediment to a united and prosperous Malaysia.
Gold glory and gospel..during that time until today only gospel they failed..that the case..
My ancestors fight this land with our tears and blood ..Islam the reason we merdeka..
@@zulimanismail1966 Islam is the reason Malaysia merdeka?
Are you even serious?
Well yeah! Malay n Islam is one( walaupun ada yg murtad,other story) History is the proof. Our faith gives us courage to fight. Argue all you want but we Malays will not let our rights be taken away just because after a few generations after Merdeka others wants our right!!!
pendatang sudah mai...🤣
Jadi warganegara jerman ok apa. Dapat pendidikan percuma tau. Untung jugak. Semua negara ada kelebihan masing-masing. Belajar bersyukur dan pandang dari sudut positif je.
Entah la mungkin betul apa u ckp baby😅
Kita percaya bhw krjan perpaduan yg ada skrng adalah tekun, bijak dan mampu menyiasat kanak2 tanpa IC di Malaysia dan berurusan dgn mereka secara adil. Hidup Malaysia! Merdeka!🥳🥳❤❤
According to law if u born in othet country and ur husband is foreigner, the children must follow husband origin. U can check in jabatan pendaftaran malaysia. U dont like, then dont marry foreigner and give birth in Malaysia pls if u are SAID U TRUELY MALAYSIAN.
Ikut undang-undang, Don't play victim la. Dah bercerai baru ingat negara Malaysia. Sblm tu beranak dan tinggal luar negara , lupakan negara. Bila dah hidup susah , dah kena berambus dari negara US/German baru ingat negara sendiri. Haram jadah puak ni.
Looking at these comments it seems there's a general perception of 'this is mother's fault so padan muka'
But who is being punished the most here? Its the children who has no control over things rhat happened before they were born
interview pon ckp omputeh....lpas tue nk jd org Malaysia...sejak bila masa bahasa kebangsaan bahasa omputeh nie vangang
Let’s look at the positive side to this story .. in the end they got Malaysian citizenship ! Hooray
Lol now they want to blame the rules
Im 50 50.
First, their mothers are ignorant to the rules. Their fault first and foremost.
But, the rules should be fair and same standard apply to either man or woman.
Why u want to be malaysia i thought this is a third world country said by Dap. Why not go singapore or hongkong 😂😂😂
@@namazlur78 what?? DAP say like that.. Ish ish.. Noe they in goment of this 3rd word contry.. 3rd rate party maybe.
Be citizen of the world, live & work where you can. Make best of what life gives you. 🙂
So touch.....such at young age she already grew the love of a country where she belong...pure and sincerity earn her Citizenship..Congratulation Girl...🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
We should revert back to the old rules. Whomever married a foreigner husband will follow her husband citizenship. Damm Tun M for changing that rule due to his internal problem
Why? Because you're jealous that local women prefer marrying foreigners
@@Delina87not at all. But if your foreign husband is the best man you can find, you should accept his country as the best too and reside there permanently. I mean logically that country will be full of better men than Malaysian men, right?.
Marry local not foreigner then no issue or at least come back to Malaysia. What is this crap
@@Delina87 its not about preference. those foreigners can change their citizenship..
Don't blame Tun M for everything.
Bossku's daughter Nooriyani married a man from Khazakastan.
Tun Musa Hitam's former wife, Maria was from Chile.
Late Gov, Taib Mahmud's first wife, Toh Puan Laila, was from Poland. His second wife Ragad Kurdi was from Lebanon.
Some Malay celebrities have married European men.
Mixed marriages are common in Malaysia. 😂🇲🇾👍
I had a good friend (Dad Malaysian, Mum Thai. Born in Thailand but lived in Malaysia) since primary school till uni days where she lived in Malaysia for 24 years on a study visa because the govenrment refused to give her an IC.
Now she went back to BKK and worked as a Machine Learning engineer with a house and a car in Lad Prao just by working 5 years.
Malaysia wasted a talent 🤦🏻♀️
Are your friend a child out of wedlock? . His father is a Malaysian, if married with official marriage, surely auto citizenship. If official marriage then the prob caused probably caused the parents. This country has law. Why her parents didnot register her after her birth? am sure his father knew about this problem when having her. So why must blame the gov? Now, should we accept every rohingyas, bangladeshi men who are known to marry local women just to do business then divorce them when they rich and get licence?
@@hawaandroid2786 they think becoming citizen is automatic without any registration and paperwork. then blame gov and say wasted talent. he think citizenship is just walk to a shop and verbally say im malaysian born in malaysia by malaysian father ,. and bam free IC?
Congrats to both of the families!
not surprised... my mom get her IC after 30 years.
‘Mummy, why am I not a Malaysian?' what about ‘Mummy, why are you not a Malaysian? Malaysian foreign wife's suffer the same after staying for decades and decades
A foreign spouse has to stay continuously for 12 years in Malaysia, to apply for PR.
My friend's wife is a foreigner.
She has obtained her PR status. 🇲🇾👍
If you have 2 mil, Sarawak govt will give you PR to move there.😅
because ur mummy doesnt do proper registration and documentation for u. mummy only think of malaysia after mummy got divorced
Actually, it's a good thing; Germany is better than here.
Yes, we also would like to know. If you dont mind sharing your correspondence with the relevent authorities pls...
To be honest, while we sympathise, quite difficult to comment also, cause we don't have the facts of the case. This should be a positive & civil discussions that could educate us all, especially those perhaps with similar cases. But, some of course like to sensationalised things...
Malaysia is not a dumping ground for unwanted babies
1. Kena fasih berbahasa Melayu
2. Kena tahu dan fahamkan 5 Rukun Negara
3. Kena kenal Perdana Menteri Malaysia (PM1 - Sekarang)
4. Kena tahu lagu2 patriotik
5. Kena tahu Perlembagaan Persekutuan
Baru layak jadi warganegara Malaysia !
Kalau sebut "Malaysia" jadi "Malayzia" / "Malasia", jangan harap !
When you too obsessed with foreign countries partners..you can't blame the others. Salah najib bossku akhirnya.... Just simply play victim doesn't guarantee you citizenships. A lot of people likes to play victim, hoping of getting something for free. Who cares?
Foreigners n pedatang sob stories..boohoohu😭
Ikutlah warganegara ayah . Apa masalahnya
Sorry! If you are the lain-lain bangsa, they make it hard. Unless you decide to “memeluk their agama yang sepatutnya aman atau dianggap aman, walaupun benar-benar aman tak pun tak boleh ditanya, kan”.
Komen tanpa nengok video ke? Bukan je chinese girl tu je tak dapat malaysian citizen, the next person in the clip, Aniza Ismail, a Malay muslim, her 2 children also did not get malaysian citizen. Jangan komen berbaur racist, hati busuk ye. Kalau jenis yang tak nengok sampai habis, tapi komen, sama lah, seperti jenis manusia yang tak memahami keadaan, tetapi buat kesimpulan awal. Akhirnya semua budak2 tu kan dapat warganegara, yang cina tu selepas 9 tahun dan melayu tu selepas 14 tahun naik turun mahkamah.
Yeah like your agama aman, bs
Jenis tak nengok video tapi sibuk nak komen racist. Clip ke dua tu kan Aniza Ismail, a malay muslim, whose her 2 children also did not get citizenship. Busuk betul hati kamu, semua nak dikaitkan dengan melayu dan islam, sedangkan orang melayu dalam clip tu pon menerima nasib yang sama. Kamu manusia jenis yg tak tak kaji atau memahami keadaan, tapi suka judge dan buat kesimpulan awal.Jenis tak nengok video tapi sibuk nak komen racist. Clip ke dua tu kan Aniza Ismail, a malay muslim, whose her 2 children also did not get citizenship. Busuk betul hati kamu, semua nak dikaitkan dengan melayu dan islam, sedangkan orang melayu dalam clip tu pon menerima nasib yang sama. Kamu manusia jenis yg tak tak kaji atau memahami keadaan, tapi suka judge dan buat kesimpulan awal.
Jenis tak nengok video tapi sibuk nak komen racist. Clip ke dua tu kan Aniza Ismail, a malay muslim, whose her 2 children also did not get citizenship. Busuk betul hati kamu, semua nak dikaitkan dengan melayu dan islam, sedangkan orang melayu dalam clip tu pon menerima nasib yang sama. Kamu manusia jenis yg tak tak kaji atau memahami keadaan, tapi suka judge dan buat kesimpulan awal.
Jenis tak nengok video tapi sibuk nak komen racist. Clip ke dua tu kan Aniza Ismail, a malay muslim, whose her 2 children also did not get citizenship. Busuk betul hati kamu, semua nak dikaitkan dengan melayu dan islam, sedangkan orang melayu dalam clip tu pon menerima nasib yang sama. Kamu manusia jenis yg tak tak kaji atau memahami keadaan, tapi suka judge dan buat kesimpulan awal.
Masalah tak nak baca akta jpn.. sedap2 buat anak malas dafta anak jpn di kedutaan malaysia diluar negara walaupun beri tempoh setahun
haaa lepas tu salahkan gov la, apa la. sendiri salah tak nak mengaku,. dah siok igt nak jadi warganegara negara maju, lepas cerai cari balik malaysia juga.. jilake
Maaflah, tapi nak cakap gak. Dalam video ni, ngaku Malaysian.
Tapi interview, semua cakap English 🤦
Be patient...
Because You marry ah mo
find out more before you talk kok
@@runeraider4405 this is one of scenarios, if they marry Malaysian , the problem may not arise. I see so many cases, they marry foreigners, it is source of problems
Marry local not foreigner then no issue or at least come back to Malaysia. What is this crap
@@leealex24 then you have to ask gov
@@YouKUMov No, I agree with the govt move. You marry/live in foreign countries for sooo long, you expect to get citizenship? Grow up man.
Best country in the world. Regardless how bad we are to the world
type C and K 🧔🏿👲🏻 want to increase population here 😂
Biasalah kaduk naik junjung, tak cukup ambik tanah temasik dlunya tanah melayu skrg dh jd singapore....ni nak balun lagi semenanjung. Siap ada sesetengah tu claim tanah chola ape bagai tp lupa nenek moyang depa mendarat di Malaysia sbgai pelombong dan penoreh getah. Dasar manusia biadap macm tu la. Salahkn goverment dan undang2 sdgkn depa tu tak faham sejarah.
Type c dgn k tu apa benda senanye? Tak pahamlah..
It’s good that the government is making harsh and stern rules and regulations on citizenship.
simple answer .YOU CANT HOLD TWO CITIZENSHIP! SO it is their parent and kid decision to go back to Malaysia and stay in Malaysia..because of Malaysia has a good food maa..
So you decide to marry a guy from Germany, having kid in German, and confuse why it is hard to get Malaysian citizenship?
It is what it is.. no hurts feeling bruh.. just accept the faith..
follow the requirements of Government Policies. If you comply, you can get. but must wait.
Why are these women keep blaming the governemnt and our long stand policies on strict citizenship? after witnessing how those foreign nationals like Bangladeshi, Myanmar,Nigerian, Pakistani ,Indian and China using (read: manipulated) our women so they can easily get access in Malaysia for their their wicked and illegal activities, now i understand why it is important to have and to preserve this strict regulations on citizenship. I really thank our founding fathers for not allowing dual citizenship .
kanak-kanak tidak sah taraf bergantung kepada status perkahwinan ibu bapa. Statusnya hanya akan dianggap sebagai sah mulai tarikh perkahwinan ibu bapanya,namun status kelahirannya tidak melayakkan anak itu menjadi warganegara melalui undang-undang sebagaimana yang termaktub di bawah Seksyen 4 Akta Kesahtarafan 1961.
Seorang wanita Malaysia berkahwin dengan lelaki warga asing tidak diberikan hak mengikut Seksyen 1 Jadual Kedua Perlembagaan untuk memohon kewarganegaraan anaknya dilahirkan di luar negara melalui kuat kuasa undang-undang.
Namun, bagi lelaki warganegara berkahwin dengan wanita asing, anaknya boleh diberikan hak kewarganegaraan sekiranya dilahirkan di luar negara. Oleh itu, wujud ketidaksamaan terhadap wanita dalam perkahwinan antarabangsa.
Answer: too good to be malaysian.
kahwin dan lahirkan anak luar negara memang tak akan dapat lah, kalau nak juga kena buat proses yang panjang. Lepas tu salahkan kerajaan Malaysia kenapa tak bagi anak warganegara. Kerajaan ada undang-undang macam mana rakyatnya nak dapat kerakyatan. Itu Silap sendiri lah,
Perempuan Malaysia yang lahirkan anak di Malaysia samada kawin atau tidak, anak tetap warganegara.
Jika wanita MY melahirkan diluar negara tanpa nikah atau suami warga asing, anak bukan warganegara. Jadi...plan your delivery lar. Langit bukan sentiasa cerah.
Before planning for children elsewhere..take sometime to learn the law of your own country.Do not blame the government.
Anak aku 3 org lahir di UK takde pulak masalah citizenship ni..I don't understand nape ade org tak dpt malaysian citizenship..maybe salah sorang parent bukan msian kot
tak register dan buat kerja2 berkaitan dengan betul. apa dia igt nak dapat kerakyatan tu automatik ka tapayah isi borang bagai, cukup dengan ckp ini anak saya , saya rakyat malaysia, jadi automatik anak saya rakyat malaysia juga. ramai je org malaysia kawin org luar negara dan anak dapat rakyat, secara peribadi saya ada kawan yg ayah dia kawin indonesia, anak dia semua rakyat malaysia kecuali yg bongsu takda ic mcm kes ni, tapi salah siapa? salah sendiri sebab yg bongsu ni tak register betul2.
Go to you husband country,you love him so much
Tidak mengusai & mcintai bahasa kebangsaan , gagal
Germany is a great country, why not live in Germany?
kalu kat western country chinese and indian tak brape blh blend dgn western culture sbb western is not family oriented. They are individual. Western want total privacy. Jd kira mcm kene pinggir once u divorcee. Tau tu sbb ramai kawan kawin org luar negara. Depa ckp once divorce, melainkn kwin balik. Mat saleh prefer kulit org sawa matang mcm melayu, indonesia, thailand, filipina tp depa2 ni mane suka org2 n. Tau tu sbb sy ramai kenalan dari sana. If u dont believe me u can ask the westerner which they prefer.
Get real laaaa....you think western society accept non whites aaaaa?
high cost, u think its cheap compared to malaysia especially the medical crap? and of course as usual they got divorced. mostly these ppl are single parent. they need to stop blaming others for their own mistakes