Games Workshop's Battle of Five Armies Retrospective - Stand-alone game or Warmaster Middle-Earth?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 53

  • @robbyv101
    @robbyv101 День тому

    Hello there! lovely painting and was happy to see the update on this project! Hope to see some battle reports soon, too! Any interested in selling the hills from starter box? Cheers

  • @HappyHungrySleepy23
    @HappyHungrySleepy23 2 місяці тому +10

    I regret not picking this up when it came out

    • @blastvader
      @blastvader 2 місяці тому

      I regret getting rid of it about a decade ago. I mean, chances are it would still just be sitting on a shelf or unloved in the attic but...still.

    • @Dram1984
      @Dram1984 2 місяці тому

      I stared at that box at my LGS for literally years and never bought it :(

  • @Draculord666
    @Draculord666 2 місяці тому +1

    This box set and the additional blisters are one of my biggest hobby white whales, wish I'd have picked it up back in the day, but hadn't discovered my love for 10mm wargaming yet.

  • @nraketh
    @nraketh 2 місяці тому +3

    I wish I’d picked this up back in the day.

  • @generalsmite7167
    @generalsmite7167 10 днів тому +1

    You know I saw another UA-camr making custom 10mm lotr and using fan modified warmaster for rules I did not realize their was actually a GW game that did just that

  • @JMACCSArmiesOfMiddleEarth
    @JMACCSArmiesOfMiddleEarth 2 місяці тому +2

    Wow thats a steal to get that for 50quid! Wonder how long that had sat there. Thanks for the shoutout xD

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому +1

      @jmaccsarmiesofArda I also found and bought a sealed copy of 3rd (or 4th?) Edition Blood Bowl at the same time which had also long been OOP. It was a good day! And no worries, that scene of you rooting through your bin looking for nuln oil had me proper laughing.

    • @JMACCSArmiesOfMiddleEarth
      @JMACCSArmiesOfMiddleEarth 2 місяці тому

      @@TimelessTabletopGaming Jessus thats a blast from the past. Scary thinking thats 2 years ago xD

  • @davidwasilewski
    @davidwasilewski 2 місяці тому +3

    Another sub. I’m here for the 10mm fantasy!

  • @chriskay284
    @chriskay284 2 місяці тому

    I was in posession of a set of rules for a while, bought them on ebay without any idea what they were. I was going to use some very very old 25mm figures with them, but I just could't cope with learning a new set of rules by myself.
    Very impressed with your work to paint 800 figures.

  • @grahamlloyd7157
    @grahamlloyd7157 2 місяці тому

    Good video, thanks for posting, you have my interest!
    I have a copy of this in my loft, fully complete and about 2/3 painted, along with some Copplestone castings miniatures.
    I will be watching your future posts on this with interest!

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому +1

      @grahamlloyd7157 Glad you enjoyed it! Hopefully you'll be inspired to dig them out and paint up the rest! I definitely plan on buying some of those Copplestone Castings miniatures - lovely sculpts.

  • @Ethnarches
    @Ethnarches 2 місяці тому

    Very well done video, I've seen some of these miniatures before but didn't know the game.

  • @jonnowitts
    @jonnowitts 2 місяці тому

    Congratulations on finishing all the painting! 🎉 looking forward to seeing some battle reports 😊

  • @Kymfre01
    @Kymfre01 2 місяці тому

    Like you i found this game in a little hobby shop, that was not long after it came out. To my shame i have never painted anything up. It is a stunning box set though and you have done a great job on yours

  • @danharris8805
    @danharris8805 2 місяці тому +2

    Great video. Subscribed now! 😊

    • @danharris8805
      @danharris8805 2 місяці тому +2

      Apparently, i was already subscribed....great video still though! 😊

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому +1

      @danharris8805 I changed the channel name which might explain that. But glad you enjoyed it and thanks for being subbed!

  • @1rnw792
    @1rnw792 2 місяці тому +1

    There's a possibility we might get a spiritual successor to this with wargames atlantic's grand battle scale minatures. They've shown off some orcs for the range, teased dwarves and strongly hinted there will be an accompanying ruleset.

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому

      @1rnw792 I've seen the Orcs and they look superb and seem a perfect for fit BoFA or Middle-Earth in general. I didn't know they were doing Dwarves as well - that's very exciting!

  • @nagashthegod
    @nagashthegod Місяць тому

    I have six copies and a bunch of extra troops plus the metal units. Second hand shops are good for it. Humans are great alternative Empire or Brets, and the Elves are in my Wood Elf list now.
    The Smaugs make great objectives/scenario event hazards.
    Love the game, and the lists are relatively balanced to run against Warmaster lists.

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  Місяць тому

      @nagashthegod Wow, six sets! That's incredible. That's interesting that you say the lists are balanced with other Warmaster game. I was thinking of creating separate, expanded lists for Elves, Dwarves and Men and I was wondering if I could use some Warmaster ancients lists as a basis but wasn't sure how balanced they would be against the evil list.

  • @Dram1984
    @Dram1984 2 місяці тому

    Warmaster was a really solid game. Played it for a few years, big campaigns, etc…

  • @e-4airman124
    @e-4airman124 2 місяці тому

    thank you

  • @thomas_time7798
    @thomas_time7798 2 місяці тому

    Looks awesome!! I never knew this gem existed.

  • @jackcade6344
    @jackcade6344 2 місяці тому +1

    This is the first time I’ve come across your channel and just wanted to say… Great video and I’m excited to see more Middle Earth! 1 new subscriber here 👋🏼
    Also, I would be very interested to know the name of the hobby shop you mentioned… as I work in Hertfordshire (live just outside, in Bedfordshire) but it sounds like it is worth a visit! 😀

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому +1

      @jackcade6344 Ah, cool! The shop is Lost Ark Games which at the time was in Buntingford. It moved soon after to Stevenage, but sadly recently downsized to a smaller shop (still in Stevenage) that focuses on space for gaming tables rather than stock. It's a shame because it used to have a really eclectic mix of stuff. Are there many good hobby shops in Beds? I visited the Bedford Tabletop Expo earlier in the year which was small but showed some promise.

    • @jackcade6344
      @jackcade6344 2 місяці тому

      @@TimelessTabletopGaming ahh, yes I know Lost Ark Games in Stevenage (I work in Stevenage) 😀
      Keep up the great content, always happy to see more middle earth stuff as I mainly just play MESBG 👍🏻 (and board games)

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому +1

      @jackcade6344 Ah excellent! I'm hoping to do l some SBG stuff on here again soon. I've been playing through the Escape from Goblin Town scenarios with my daughter. If you fancy a casual game sometime let me know!

    • @jackcade6344
      @jackcade6344 2 місяці тому

      @@TimelessTabletopGaming sounds good! I’ve just got the new Rise of Angmar book and we’re going to play through some of the narrative scenarios (once the relevant models have been bought, built and painted…. Which might take some time!) 😂 as my fiancée and I only play VERY
      casually!
      We were working our way through most of the Quest of the Ringbearer scenarios… but they we had a baby (who’s now 14months old) and so that fell away 😂
      Thanks for the offer of a game, hopefully we can get that sorted sometime 👍🏻

  • @colinspeirs
    @colinspeirs 2 місяці тому

    I only finished SOME of my figures two years ago, and still have more, much more to go, including third party. I only did the hills last month, that was the hill halves in the box, plus you could buy a second set, and they join together to make a hole hill

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому

      @colinspeirs The hills are excellent aren't they? I need to pick up a second set at some point for that reason.

    • @colinspeirs
      @colinspeirs 2 місяці тому

      ​@@TimelessTabletopGaming​@TimelessTabletopGaming my impetus was a photo shoot for a modelling channel. I painted two hill halves as dark, vertical cliff faces as part of a Morgoth Vs Fingolfin duel
      After that, I thought "might as well do them properly"

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому

      @@colinspeirs Oh wow, I'd love to see that photo.

    • @colinspeirs
      @colinspeirs 2 місяці тому +1

      @@TimelessTabletopGaming emailed to the email you specify for the channel

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому

      @colinspeirs I've just taken a look. Excellent work! I love that you put in the craters made by Grond. You really nailed the scene. Thanks for sending it over!

  • @ja37d-34
    @ja37d-34 2 місяці тому

    I remember this being released. Seems cool. Just would want more from something like that. More releases.. But on the other hand.. If it is good.. Sure, why not?

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому +1

      @ja37d-34 There were supposed to be more scenarios released on the website but I can't find any evidence of it ever having happened. It's a shame, but on the other hand, I quite like that it encourages you to do it yourself.

    • @ja37d-34
      @ja37d-34 2 місяці тому

      @@TimelessTabletopGaming Yeah true!
      Also love that kind of store you can make such finds..

  • @eikmaster8947
    @eikmaster8947 2 місяці тому

    I was lucky to get a copy on ebay. Unfortunately without the rules and terrain, but with all of the blisters! Looking for a rulebook now...

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому

      @eikmaster8947 Excellent! If you're in the UK, there's a couple of loose rulebooks on eBay at the moment for £40-50. Not cheap I know...

    • @eikmaster8947
      @eikmaster8947 2 місяці тому +1

      @@TimelessTabletopGaming saw them too but unfortunately I am not (Germany). But I will look out on from time to time.

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому

      @@eikmaster8947 Schade. Viel Glück!

    • @eikmaster8947
      @eikmaster8947 2 місяці тому +1

      @@TimelessTabletopGaming Danke!

  • @MaiHand
    @MaiHand 2 місяці тому

    I got it when it got out but I dunno where it went ;-; I miss it

  • @shawnzeppo4361
    @shawnzeppo4361 2 місяці тому

    LOL. We get the joke @9:26 where the text refers to units identified by letters, but the graphic uses numbers for each stand. The editors and proofreaders owe Mr. Priestly a pint. Also, I am working on simulating BoFA using a very similar army list but the improved Warmaster Revolution (WR) rules, and in old school 25mm. I am sure you've heard of WR, and you may want to use the improvements made in that fan written system, accepted by GW as not violating copyright.

    • @TimelessTabletopGaming
      @TimelessTabletopGaming  2 місяці тому

      @shawnzeppo4361 Haha, I'm glad someone spotted that in that pic. The rules are written in a very cluttered way and then examples like that just don't help. I've watched a set of videos on the Warmaster Revolution rules. The differences seem quite subtle but I need to look into it more. Capping orders to 3 per unit makes sense though I imagine getting off more than that becomes pretty unlikely anyway. Good luck with your own project, that sounds exciting!

  • @forevermorbid8949
    @forevermorbid8949 2 місяці тому

    Reaches right past Heroquest and Advanced Heroquest 😩

  • @Ed-Irvin
    @Ed-Irvin 2 місяці тому

    I'm a 100% in for 10mm First Age battles...