Muhammad's Lack of Miracles: A BIG Problem for Islam
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 лип 2024
- Islam has a major problem when it comes to a lack of miraculous evidence. Here I review William Paley's thoughts on the rise of Islam and how it stands in stark contrast to the rise of Christianity.
Read what Paley said here: quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text...
Are you a Christian struggling with doubts? Get 1-on-1 counseling at talkaboutdoubts.com
Help support me: / isjesusalive or paypal.me/isjesusalive for a one-time gift
Amazon wish list: www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @testifyapologetics
Visit my blog: isjesusalive.com
Recommended books on defending the Gospels: isjesusalive.com/recommended-...
Mohammed claims he can't do miracles and only God can ... while also admitting Jesus did miracles. Fascinating! Every tongue will confess.
its crazy how many contradictions can be found in the quran
Excellent point!
@@WackyMonkey05 can you quote the contradictions in the Quaran ?
@@carroteer There are too many
Islam is Chock full of such lovely contradictions
When I was still a Muslim and had great doubts in my Islamic faith, I was really terrified in leaving my faith, not because of my safety but as for the punishment Allah would give me in the hereafter. Now, I am saved through Jesus Christ, thanks to Orthodoxy. Christos Anesti! Christ is Risen!💖☦️⛪
❤☦️☦️
Praise the LORD
@@moosa86 the quran barely says anything about jesus, it expects you to read the injeel (gospel)
@@moosa86Muhammadan logic
@@moosa86 there is no Jesus in islam
This is why you have to look at the historical context before criticizing 100% of the crusades
I'm proud of the crusades. It pushed back hell on earth.
Ummm wrong!!! The Crusades were the most evil event ever so many people died it was like the worst tragedy in the history of history!!1!!1!1!!
@@everyonesfavoritesejong Angry muslim detected
@@everyonesfavoritesejong history of history? Brother you need to check things that happened in the 20th century
@@KratosMeatrider It's a joke brah 😭
islam is NOTHING without a sword , we egyptians know it really well
Indonesia and malaysia : huh? 😂
@@han6528
MILLIONS of Buddhist murdered and stoled temples during the Islamization of Indonesia and Malasya just prove how violent islam is !
Even today Buddhist people suffer a lot inside both islamic malasya and indonesia
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05
Crusaders exist cause islam stole Christian lands, without the fake arabic prophet and his fake arabic cult the Crussades would never be necesary.
Brunei, malacca, and , literally every other southeast asian archipelago nation
@@mustaadtheguy Not Peacefull at all !
Even prophets back in the old testament could perform miracles, due to God giving them the authority to do so
Miracles are God's ID Badge. He's never shy to hand them out.
@@The_Christian_Saiyan what is the evidence of old testament prophets performing miracle?
@@matthummel8306The miracles are recorded in the Old Testament. If you don’t accept the verity of these documents, I suppose you won’t be convinced. Although, if you are Muslim, you have to accept the evidence, because it is the word of God, as confirmed by Muhammad (Quran 5:44-47)
not to mention those miracles were always in the aid of people.
@@matthummel8306 You're in a religion entirely powered by "Trust me bro" and you're hell bent on staking your eternity on it. 😭😭😭
I pray Muslims and unknowing sympathizers watch this
Share, share, share.
@@mustafam.leathercoatv.2514 OK, show us the miracles of aulloh through Muhammed. Take your time.
It wouldn't matter if they saw it they wouldn't believe to the lost the truth sounds like lies
@@mustafam.leathercoatv.2514 Thats a really funny and ironic thing to say XD it doesnt make you look like you care whats true
i've watched it n uk what
I've been seeing many vedios like this trying to defame islam almost 99% of these people 𝙙𝙤𝙣𝙩 𝙠𝙣𝙤𝙬 what thier talking about
N u know what most ppl like us do we jus listen what we r told from ppl we dont even know from a place we have no idea about but we jus believe them
What happened to "dont believe everything u see on the internet" how about you try to read what it actually says
Uk what miracles were not given to the prophet Mohammed Saw, its because so many prophets who came before him n the ppls were shown so many miracles they didnt believe n they became used to seeing it thier hearts became hard they called the prophets magicians, hypocrats n ugly names
So when the last prophet was sent he didnt recieve miracles for the eyes to see GOD knew what he was doing the miracke that was given to him Saw is the Qur'an do u underatand now
Its a miracle for the heart its a miracle for the ears not for the eyes n its not for everyone to see
You have to seek it not it seeking you
I hope that you atleast read n understand things in your term
Wish u well
As a ex Ismaili Shia Muslim I found peace in Christ ❤✝️
We’re happy to have you, Brother.
Welcome, brother!
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 sorry I don’t know, I grew up Shia Ismaili we don’t do wudu before reciting dua we don’t even do namaza like traditional Shias and Sunnis. Look up Shia Ismaili or aga Kahn for more information
You clearly weren’t a real muslim
"He wasnt a true mooslim!1!1!1!1"@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05
„Hey, I’m a new prophet, the greatest of them all!”
„Wow, greater than Jesus and Moses? Can’t wait to see God’s power in your hands!”
„Nah, I actually can’t. I won’t even pray if anything happens to you. Btw, I’m just a messenger. But also the greatest prophet”
Yeah, that makes sense
😂
he never said he was the greatest he said he was the last. " the greatest prophet" thing is a way to honor him in islam yet the quran just sees him as a messenger and so does he. so quit overyapping
@@EdwardFishington You definitely should read your own sources. He's the greatest according to the Hadiths. He's the only one in the position to make intercession. Not even Jesus or Moses could according to the Hadith. Try reading your sources 🥱
@@raphaelfeneje486 provide the hadeeth then lol. i want it to be the exact thing you just said
@@EdwardFishington Sahih al-Bukhari 6565, Sahih al-Bukhari 4476, Sahih al-Bukhari 7410. The Hadith is even hilarious and has so many problems. 💀
"The earlier prophets performed miracles, but no one believed them, so what's the point?"
Millions of Christians who believe Jesus' message because of His miracles: Say what?
That's because no one saw the prophets do miracles(except Moses and Elijah), people actually saw Jesus and his miracles so?
The difference is, these prophets did not claim to be God in the flesh. Jesus did.
@@joeroeinski1107 If he did all those miracles and claimed to be God, well can you trust him?
Of course I would.
@@PizzaPartyIndeed
Itʼs not _just_ the miracles, tho.
In proving His identity after His resurrection, Jesus pointed to His fulfillment of biblical prophesy.
And in some of His discourses with the leaders, He referenced His character in support of His claims.
@@joeroeinski1107 I assumed you are a muslim, I thought this was a hate comment.
Everything about Islam is a contradiction just for the first example that comes to mind their "holy" book tells them to trust the Gospels but the gospels clearly refer to Jesus as the Son of God and say that he was crucified and risen but they deny the Divinity of the true God. And there are literally hundreds more contradictions just as bad as that one but when something's inspired by demons in a cave that's what's going to happen. Allah "the greatest Deceiver" as he refers to himself in the Quran is known by a different name in the Old and New Testament. The Accuser. The adversary. The father of Lies, Satan.
Muhamed :“Trust the Gospels!”
Muslims:“Okay, we’ll tell the Christians that their book is wrong and edited!”
Muhamed: “wait a minute”
It didn't say this
It said gospel not gospels
We believe that there was a original gospel that was revealed to isa as
@@yabviewmohamed9013 so allahs words were corrupted is that what you're saying?
1. There is an original gospel given to jesus called the injeel until people made their own version of the gospel called the Bible, which is corrupted. Also, nowhere in the bible does it say jesus is god, can you tell me where it says that?
2. Read and study the quran for yourself, and you will find no contradictions and errors. The only arguement you have against it is that it's false.
3. The verse you are referring to is quran 8:30 and the actual translation is that allah is the best of planners not the best of the deceivers, that's just a mistranslation/misinterpretation, go check it for yourself.
@@Fredrickthe2nd no I didn't say that. there is no stopping anyone from writing something and saying this is from God . And then having gospels (not one) at least 100 years after Jesus is not really that trustworthy. am just putting my thoughts here
Blessed are those who do not see, but believe! Christ is King!!! 🔥✝️👑
@@moosa86 King of existence according to Christians
@@moosa86 all of creation basically
@@moosa86 *THE KING OF MY LIFE‼️🙇🏾♀️💯👑*
Long live the King! 👑 ❤✝️
@@moosa86 King of kings and Lord of Lords.
islam thrived by the sword and dies by the internet
The Islamic empire not Muhammad
how by sword it wasnt started by sword better than pope bussiness tycoon
@@mars2182 I see the opposite
what happened in Andalusia? was that by the word or by the sword?
@@simplicity9653 the spanish were taking back their lands which were christian. the mozlems were the invaders.
This video is misinformation. Mohammad was a middle eastern man that married a six year old and waited three whole years before consummating the marriage. Truly a divine feat for his people.
😂😂❤
This is pure racism, you are essentially claiming that all middle easterners are worse child abusers than Mohamed.
@@RonaldChampagne-og1oe 👍🏾🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
What exactly do you mean by "for his people"? "His people", if you mean Middle Easterners, were also created in the image of God and in need of the Gospel and the grace of God, just like anyone else.
Jesus could raise dead people back to life while muhammad, Islam's most revered prophet(called the last and most powerful) was skilled at doing the opposite.
never was he called 'skilled and powerful' he is known as 'last with the final message' y'll claim anything don't you?
@@dark_panther78but he is the most important prophet for y'll.
@@dark_panther78 and he couldn't do miracles
He even died like a 🐁. Poisoned, in agony with a touch of feeling like his aorta is being torn out. A bad way to go for someone who claims to be god-sent.
@@dark_panther78Bruh, Muhammad claimed that his name is written in Allah's throne. If anyone has the 🏀 to say that without flinching, he is definitely flexing how powerful he is by telling people that he has his back leaning on the wall. Skilled? Yes, he was skilled. How an illiterate caravan robber who stole underwear and called black people as shaitan and raisin heads because of their melanin content on their skin and also claimed that the greatest reward in heaven is to have a 🍆 that will never limp for the sole purpose of cosmic sex was able to convince billions of people to believe in him requires no small amount of skill in deception
Also, what was the final message he delivered that made significance advancement in the way human beings lived and treated each other that can be considered "divinely inspired"? 🤷♂️.
Great series, one episode debunks the entire religion
It's already debunked
The internet was the worst thing that could've happened to Islam.
@@matthewtheron2505Islam is the worst thing that could have happened to humanity
@@monsieurcharcutier4490 thats not a very nice thing to say when your religion is changed so much its not even the same
@@milkboi1773 What? The core beliefs of Christianity is that Jesus is the son God, he got crucified for our sins and resurrected 3 days later, and it remained as such. "Your religion is changed so much its not even the same" It really didn't change mate, all Christian denominations believe that Jesus is the son of God.
I don’t know, it’s a miracle that anyone believes the claims of Islam.
It's a cult. People are brainwashed through victim mentality and punishments to believe Islam
Here to watch before this video is taken down 🗣️🗣️
it's not going anywhere
@@TestifyApologetics Hi! As someone from a Soviet culture (now an immigrant in the USA) I believe that the resurrection was staged by the Romans, as explained in a popular book where I'm from - "The Gospel of Afranius"; like many others, I read it in childhood and never thought about this question again - until coming to the USA and noticing a stark contrast in the discussion of this question. What's wrong with that explanation?? I'm confused, what am I missing here?..
@@valinorean4816
The book you are referring to denies historical context, political unrest, and traditional Jewish history and belief.
@@valinorean4816 If the explanation to a miracle being fake doesn't make sense, then do not trust it.
@@valinorean4816
"The Gospel of Afranius" was written in 1995 by a Russian scientist who was explicitly coming from an anti-religion perspective, not even counted as a heretical book when the Church was compiling the books that would become the Bible because the guy who wrote it & the country he wrote it in didn't even exist yet.
'Coooomer' Muhammad wojak is really funny.
Historically accurate and supported by the Quran + Hadith
This is Muhammad when he saw a woman outside and had a hard time keeping it in his pants so he ran back to his wife immediately.
He said that he would kill one of the enemies of the Muslims, Ubay ibn Khalaf, which he achieved at the Battle of Uhud.[34]
Before the Battle of Badr, he showed exactly where each of the enemy chiefs would be killed; they all died in the exact locations stated.[34]
He said that his daughter Fatimah would be the first of his family to die after him; which eventuated.[34]
On several occasions he provided food and water supernaturally.[35]
He quenched the thirst of thousands of his soldiers during the Battle of Tabouk and enabled them to use water for ablution after causing water to pour forth.[33][35]
He caused two trees to move at his command.[35]
He caused a well to swell with water after he rinsed his mouth with some water and then threw it out into the well. This was during the event of the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, enabling his followers with him to drink and use the water for ablution.[36]
He threw a handful of dust at some of the enemy during the Battle of Hunain, causing them to be blinded. This miracle is mentioned in the Quran (Q8:17).[33]
He caused Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud to convert to Islam after he made a barren ewe, which produced no milk, to produce milk.[34]
He used his saliva to cure Ali's sick eye, during the Battle of Khaybar, and it became healthy.[37]
His companions would hear the food before him praising Allah.[37]
He caused it to rain during a drought in Medina.[38]
His prayers were instantly answered.[39]
Stones and trees used to greet him before and during his prophethood.[40][41]
He used to understand the language of animals.[42][43]
He comforted a palm tree that was crying and upset after he stopped leaning on it during his sermons.[44]
He had The Seal of Prophethood (Khatam an-Nabiyyin) between his shoulders, specifically on the end of his left shoulder blade, It is depicted as a mole, in size compared to the egg of a partridge or to a pigeon's egg and its color was the same as that of Muhammad's body.[45][46][47][48][49] It is believed that each prophet sent by Allah had this Seal on a certain part of his body.[50]
It is reported, that Muhammad did not cast a shadow, interpreted as a sign of his "light".[51]
When Muhammad ascended Mount Uhud and he was accompanied by Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. The mountain shook beneath them. Muhammad then hit it with his foot and said, "O Uhud! Be firm, for upon you there is none but a Prophet, a supporter of truth and two martyrs."[52][53][54][55][56]
The same event occurred on Jabal al-Nour in Mecca.[57][58][59][60][61]
Muhammad used to hear the voices of persons who were being tortured in their graves.[62][63]
When Abu Jahl was going to trample Muhammad's neck or smear his face with dust as he was engaged in prayer, Abu Jahl came near him but turned upon his heels and tried to repulse something with his hands. It was said to him: "What is the matter with you?" He said: "There is between me and him. A ditch of fire and terror and wings." Thereupon Muhammad said: "If he were to come near me the angels would have torn him to pieces."[64]
He used to speak to the dead and hear them. It also occurred with the bodies of the enemy chiefs after the Battle of Badr in the presence of his companions.[65][66][67]
@@Faithexplorer4376 Sunan Abu Dawud 203- The eyes are the leather strap of the anus
@@JesusSavedYouu Indeed, those who disbelieve - it is all the same for them whether you warn them or do not warn them - they will not believe.” (Quran 2:6)
“Allah has set a seal upon their hearts and upon their hearing, and over their vision is a veil. And for them is a great punishment.”(Quran 2:7)
Non-Muslims asks; If Allah is sealing the hearts of disbelievers, he is taking away their free will so they can not be judged !! Firstly this verse does not refer to all the disbelievers rather it refers to those who bent on rejecting the truth although they KNEW it.
Allah did not wronged this people rather they wronged themselves. so it is not because Allah has set a seal on their hearts that these disbelievers do not understand and believe, but it is vice-versa. It is because these disbelievers bent on rejecting the truth and whether they are warned them or not they will not believe, that Allah has set a seal on their hearts.
Their hearts are only sealed for as long as they wish to keep themselves in denial and ignorance. So, if a person wishes to open his eyes and learn, his seal will be removed because the door of repentance is always open.
“Except those who repent, have faith and good deeds, those Allah will charge their sins for good deeds. Certainly Allah is most forgiving and merciful.” (Quran 25:70)
Without *_death penalty_* islam dies.
There is a death penalty in Christianity too
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad bro
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamadwell, it did happen often indeed. But also, the entire nations converted voluntarily and stayed in Christianity forever. Why? Simply because they were enlightened by God
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad
Judaism. Not in Christianity.
@@JesusSavedYouu my brother, please, for each and every thing, context comes along with it. The Quran was revealed gradually, such as the verse you stated.
This is during the war times, such as during the Battle of Badr, Uhud, and others. Basically, during the sacred months, no fighting was allowed (I think there were exceptions, like if the enemy were to attack you first during the battle, but anyways), and then after those months ended you could proceed to attack them if they were being unjust, etc.
Such is the case with several verses taking place in the chapter of Baqarah as well.
And please, if we truly were a barbaric religion, why is it that the world still stands firm with approx 2 million people following this religion?
Please, I ask you, respect our religion, as even the Quran states that we are commanded to respect yours, and I have sourced the verse below in the brackets.
(and you will find the nearest of them in affection to the believers those who say, "We are Christians." That is because among them are priests and monks and because they are not arrogant. 5:82)
I m currently Muslim I wanna covert to Christianity so bad but sadly I can’t since where I live it s illegal to change ur religion from Islam :/
كتبهم محرف ليه تغير دينك
Do it anyway, I will pray for you earnestly, it’s what Jesus wants us to do.
If the world hates you, remember that it hated me first. John 15:18
Yes, and all who desire to live godly in Christ Jesus will suffer persecution. But evil men and impostors will grow worse and worse, deceiving and being deceived.
2 Timothy 3:12-13
Blessed are you when people insult you, persecute you and falsely say all kinds of evil against you because of me. Rejoice and be glad, because great is your reward in heaven, for in the same way they persecuted the prophets who were before you.
Matthew 5:11-12
Consider it all joy, my brethren, when you encounter various trials, knowing that the testing of your faith produces endurance. James 1:2-3
Bless those who persecute you. Don’t curse them; pray that God will bless them. Romans 12:14
and when they had called in the apostles, they beat them and charged them not to speak in the name of Jesus, and let them go. Then they left the presence of the council, rejoicing that they were counted worthy to suffer dishonor for the name. Acts 5:40-41
Maybe you could save up money and try to escape to a country that has freedom of religion, you could bring a lot of souls to heaven and could be a very powerful speaker if you spoke about why the Quran is corrupt and why we should trust in Jesus
I urge you to read the Gospel of John, Matthew, Mark and Luke, you can download the Bible app on your phone with a VPN, and I hope that you will become very strong in the faith ❤️✝️
You don’t have to tell them. Besides, did Roman Christians pledge allegiance to Caesar even when they were being given the death penalty?
Stay safe
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 cause where I live some Muslim people would kill me for switching religions
pray that my moms client gets saved from islam, she is in an abusive household and is very devoted
Aisha was 9
And since their only response to that is “Rebecca was 3 and Mary was 12” let me just say that those are lies. Rebecca was an adult and there is not a single source confirming Mary or Joseph’s ages. Even if it were true it wouldn’t justify the false prophet
Jesus in the NT supports the marriage of 3 year olds from the Talmud.
Aisha was a mature woman btw, read the Hadiths.
Some historical context Mary was 16 because most historians agree Jesus was born in 4 Bc while true Mary was young in the context of that culture and with the life expectancy being much lower it happened more often back then.
Imagine Rebecca with the age of three years fetching water for the servant of Abraham and all his camels 😅 according to bible. Also holy scriptures don't mention her age, but granted we can reaspond to muslims three year old Rebecca was already a menstruating woman as Muslims asume with aisha
also even if Mary were 12 (which she wasn't) she was a virgin for her whole life. No one abused her
@@stephanusmojiseyev2030 imagine aisha was 9 and leading armies into battle, she was 19 btw
Muhammed sounds like an older Joseph Smith.
Correct, but he married a 6 year old. Thats the only difference😂
Emperor Constantine, a lifelong skeptic, witnessed a Christian miracle- He was so moved by it that he made Christianity the religion of his entire empire. Mohammad witnessed no such miracles.
Based Byzantine Lore
@@casper2694 Roman*please use the right term🇮🇹🙏
Maybe the real miracle is the friends we made along the way
Without a state Islam would not exist!
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 because the mozlem immigrants are fleeing the sh!1tty islamic state while still being brainwashed
Muhammad is the only person in history to have established a nation, a religion and an empire. That's his miracle.
@@zacka9438 Barbarian nation.
If the Quran is connected to the bible that's not true, it's people.
Wasn’t Muhammad and also Joseph smith illiterate? I know Joseph smith was for sure but I keep seeing mixed things if Muhammad was or not
He had scribes, and the hadith records their names.
@davidcow4889 yes, Muhammed himself was illiterate as well, it even says so in a hadith when he was visited by The Angel (supposedly Gabriel), and he squeezed him saying "READ!" But Muhammad said he could not.
@@MisterEGamer1He wasn't illiterate. He called for writing material to write a note on his death bed.
Actually there are hadith mentioning Mohammad writing this gs down for his companions later in life and also close to his death which prove that he was lying from the start.
Joseph Smith had 3 witnesses and one of them called him a false prophet. Joseph Smith said that his books are from Satan btw.
Muhammad had many witnesses and cursed Satan.
I hate how it is ILLEGAL to leave Islam in some countries like forcing people's to your belief is just ain't morally good no matter what is your religion
What is the Hadith that says the prayer of one sitting is half of one who is standing?
Sunan an-Nasa’i Book 19 Hadith 1831, I believe
@@MacacoMoninheiro its sunan an nasai 1660. In Sunan an Nasai 1659 Mohammed was confronted for sitting down while praying and he said he wasnt like us and was allowed to do it.
@@nothingnothing7958
Always, "rules for thee, but not for me"
😂😂😂
NOP its sunan an nisai 1660 when he was asked that, in 1659: { It was narrated that Hafsah said: I never saw the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) offer his voluntary prayers sitting down until one year before his death. Then he used to pray sitting down, reciting the surah so slowly that it seemed to be longer than a surah that is longer. }
@@nothingnothing7958what’s the verse that talks about Allah wanting people to stop bothering Muhammad.
All Muhammeds miracles only took place from 6 - 9. He begins his miracle at 6 and consummates it at 9.
Kafir, there’s blessings in breaking in some 9 y/o cheeks
@@matthewtheron2505 Mohammed became a prophet at 40
@@Aziz_axisit’s a joke about his marriage to Aisha.
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 the moon looks pretty full to me lol
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 the moon never split in two assuming it did happen why are the only accounts based on islamic sources yet Rome Persia china India and the meso Americans had writing why did no-one else record such a major event, I know I would be telling everyone that happened if I saw it
You certainly have much more patience when talking about Islam than i do. I hate the evil in their religion.
Do you think islam is an evil religion?
Indeed, but always remember that Muslims themselves deserve love and respect, they are still God's children
@@Osterriech0707love is an interesting word it can mean a lot of things to a lot of different people to me the best way to love them is to correct them and save them from the fires of hell. The only way to break brainwashing is to be confrontational with facts.
@@monsieurcharcutier4490 True to that. I just mean, be respectful and understanding when doing so
@@Osterriech0707that level of patience I struggle with but its a point well taken
The early Muslims ended up being embarrassed by this lack of miracles, so they made up miracles that he did in the Hadiths, despite it contradicting the Quran
Not true at all. This is a baseless claim.
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 nah he's simply the real Prophet Muhammad, that other guy was just some random bozo.
@@davidmorgan5581 real, it's nice to see mohammed alive in the 21th century
The whole video was literally "all accounts of Muslim Miracles of wrong while the similar accounts of Christianity arent" while taking a verse out of context and saying random blasphemous things.
Legit
Even if the moon did split what purpose does that serve really. Jesus's miracles actually benefited people
6:42 I’m a Christian, but this argument makes no sense. Our depiction of hell is pretty graphic too. Lake of Fire, pit of darkness, weeping and gnashing of teeth, the story of the rich man asking for just a drop of water to quench his thirst in the flames etc. If the Quran is only hyping up hell to instill fear in people, Christianity did the same first. There are better arguments than this
If you think that, I'd say you should probably revisit your doctrine of hell. how is it close to getting hit with maces and burned alive by boiling water getting repeatedly dumped on you? About the worst it says is "their worm dieth not" and that's not talking about being eaten alive by worms but rather pointing to hell being like a garbage dump of the valley of Hinnom.
he didnt say hell is not graphic, but that by way of comparison, muslim hell is even more graphic with punishments described in painful detail.
so no christianity didnt do the SAME first.
@@TestifyApologetics I don’t exactly see the issue with painting hell as bad as and really painful, because it is. That’s not fearmongering, that’s just the truth. Little did Muhammad know he’d be going there too, but my point is there’s no use in talking about Christianity’s idea of hell is “not as bad.” It’s hell. By definition it’s the worst thing possible
Out of love to not have anyone end up in hell, sure, you might describe it graphically to know where you should absolutely not end. This is not true fearmongering, more like a stark warning.
Dante’s Inferno is not canonical.
😢He said that he would kill one of the enemies of the Muslims, Ubay ibn Khalaf, which he achieved at the Battle of Uhud.[34]
Before the Battle of Badr, he showed exactly where each of the enemy chiefs would be killed; they all died in the exact locations stated.[34]
He said that his daughter Fatimah would be the first of his family to die after him; which eventuated.[34]
On several occasions he provided food and water supernaturally.[35]
He quenched the thirst of thousands of his soldiers during the Battle of Tabouk and enabled them to use water for ablution after causing water to pour forth.[33][35]
He caused two trees to move at his command.[35]
He caused a well to swell with water after he rinsed his mouth with some water and then threw it out into the well. This was during the event of the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, enabling his followers with him to drink and use the water for ablution.[36]
He threw a handful of dust at some of the enemy during the Battle of Hunain, causing them to be blinded. This miracle is mentioned in the Quran (Q8:17).[33]
He caused Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud to convert to Islam after he made a barren ewe, which produced no milk, to produce milk.[34]
He used his saliva to cure Ali's sick eye, during the Battle of Khaybar, and it became healthy.[37]
His companions would hear the food before him praising Allah.[37]
He caused it to rain during a drought in Medina.[38]
His prayers were instantly answered.[39]
Stones and trees used to greet him before and during his prophethood.[40][41]
He used to understand the language of animals.[42][43]
He comforted a palm tree that was crying and upset after he stopped leaning on it during his sermons.[44]
He had The Seal of Prophethood (Khatam an-Nabiyyin) between his shoulders, specifically on the end of his left shoulder blade, It is depicted as a mole, in size compared to the egg of a partridge or to a pigeon's egg and its color was the same as that of Muhammad's body.[45][46][47][48][49] It is believed that each prophet sent by Allah had this Seal on a certain part of his body.[50]
It is reported, that Muhammad did not cast a shadow, interpreted as a sign of his "light".[51]
When Muhammad ascended Mount Uhud and he was accompanied by Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. The mountain shook beneath them. Muhammad then hit it with his foot and said, "O Uhud! Be firm, for upon you there is none but a Prophet, a supporter of truth and two martyrs."[52][53][54][55][56]
The same event occurred on Jabal al-Nour in Mecca.[57][58][59][60][61]
Muhammad used to hear the voices of persons who were being tortured in their graves.[62][63]
When Abu Jahl was going to trample Muhammad's neck or smear his face with dust as he was engaged in prayer, Abu Jahl came near him but turned upon his heels and tried to repulse something with his hands. It was said to him: "What is the matter with you?" He said: "There is between me and him. A ditch of fire and terror and wings." Thereupon Muhammad said: "If he were to come near me the angels would have torn him to pieces."[64]
He used to speak to the dead and hear them. It also occurred with the bodies of the enemy chiefs after the Battle of Badr in the presence of his companions.[65][66][67]
Islam is all about this life (carnal life) while Christianity is all about heaven and soul life, and against carnal life. We can see which one is true and which one is better
Mohamed couldn’t have cured a fly of a headache even if he stood on his head and whistled for a year and a day in the land where the bong tree grows.
He actually healed a companion who was wounded
😂@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad Teeheehee!!!
Neither could Jesus. We can all claim whatever we want about 2000 year old men whose only primary sources were fellow cultists
Granted when asked for a sign Jesus said the sign of the prophet Jonah. Which is to say repent. However he still did miracles and gave signs. Whilst for muhammad he was just a "warner."
Not true, he had miracles.
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad name the miracles because splitting of the moon is not a miracle and there’s no evidence to suggest that he ever split the moon and the verse that talks about the splitting of the moon is very vague. All the other miracles come centuries later after he had already died and not reliable
@@noelg.3632 what are the miracles that came century later?
I think you’re doing a great job! Defending the gospel.
Have a blessed day!
Can anyone provide some feedback on Willoam Paley's book? Considering getting it
As always, thank you for another wonderful video!
He said that he would kill one of the enemies of the Muslims, Ubay ibn Khalaf, which he achieved at the Battle of Uhud.[34]
Before the Battle of Badr, he showed exactly where each of the enemy chiefs would be killed; they all died in the exact locations stated.[34]
He said that his daughter Fatimah would be the first of his family to die after him; which eventuated.[34]
On several occasions he provided food and water supernaturally.[35]
He quenched the thirst of thousands of his soldiers during the Battle of Tabouk and enabled them to use water for ablution after causing water to pour forth.[33][35]
He caused two trees to move at his command.[35]
He caused a well to swell with water after he rinsed his mouth with some water and then threw it out into the well. This was during the event of the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, enabling his followers with him to drink and use the water for ablution.[36]
He threw a handful of dust at some of the enemy during the Battle of Hunain, causing them to be blinded. This miracle is mentioned in the Quran (Q8:17).[33]
He caused Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud to convert to Islam after he made a barren ewe, which produced no milk, to produce milk.[34]
He used his saliva to cure Ali's sick eye, during the Battle of Khaybar, and it became healthy.[37]
His companions would hear the food before him praising Allah.[37]
He caused it to rain during a drought in Medina.[38]
His prayers were instantly answered.[39]
Stones and trees used to greet him before and during his prophethood.[40][41]
He used to understand the language of animals.[42][43]
He comforted a palm tree that was crying and upset after he stopped leaning on it during his sermons.[44]
He had The Seal of Prophethood (Khatam an-Nabiyyin) between his shoulders, specifically on the end of his left shoulder blade, It is depicted as a mole, in size compared to the egg of a partridge or to a pigeon's egg and its color was the same as that of Muhammad's body.[45][46][47][48][49] It is believed that each prophet sent by Allah had this Seal on a certain part of his body.[50]
It is reported, that Muhammad did not cast a shadow, interpreted as a sign of his "light".[51]
When Muhammad ascended Mount Uhud and he was accompanied by Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. The mountain shook beneath them. Muhammad then hit it with his foot and said, "O Uhud! Be firm, for upon you there is none but a Prophet, a supporter of truth and two martyrs."[52][53][54][55][56]
The same event occurred on Jabal al-Nour in Mecca.[57][58][59][60][61]
Muhammad used to hear the voices of persons who were being tortured in their graves.[62][63]
When Abu Jahl was going to trample Muhammad's neck or smear his face with dust as he was engaged in prayer, Abu Jahl came near him but turned upon his heels and tried to repulse something with his hands. It was said to him: "What is the matter with you?" He said: "There is between me and him. A ditch of fire and terror and wings." Thereupon Muhammad said: "If he were to come near me the angels would have torn him to pieces."[64]
He used to speak to the dead and hear them. It also occurred with the bodies of the enemy chiefs after the Battle of Badr in the presence of his companions.[65][66][67]
super underrated channel, keep up the quality work
ok so I need help i already disproved these "contradictions" but i could have done better and i want to hear what others have I honestly did only 30 minutes of research and disproved it
"CONTRADICTIONS"
1)Mathew 1:16 says Joseph was son of Jacob(it also says Joseph was husband of Mary and Jesus had a father) while Luke 3:23 says Joseph was son of Heli. Which one is correct?
2) 2 Samuel 24:9 says there were 800,000( šə-mō-neh for eight, mê-’ō-wṯ for hundred, e-lep̄ for thousand) and 500,000(ḥă-mêš for 5 mê-’ō-wṯ ’e-lep̄) men while 1 Chronicles 21:5 says 1,100,000 (e-lep̄ ă-lā-p̄î ū-mê-’āh. e-lep̄)and 470,000 (ar-ba‘ mê-’ō-wt wə-šiḇ-‘îm e-lep̄)
3)2 Samuel 6:23 says Michal had no children till her death while 2 Samuel 21:8 says she had 5(ḥă-mêš) sons.
4)2 kings 8:26 says Ahaziah was 22(
‘eś-rîm for twenty and ū-šə-ta-yim for two) while 2 Chronicles 22:2 says he was 42(ar-bā-‘îm forty and ū-šə-ta-yim two).
5)2 Chronicles 36:9 says Jehoiachin was 8(šə-mō-w-neh for eight) while 2 kings 24:8 says he was 18(šə-mō-neh eight and eś-rê for ten)
6)Acts 1:18 says man fell headlong while Mathew 27:5 says he hanged himself.
7)2 Chronicles 9:25 says 4,000 (ar-ba-‘aṯ four ) stalls while 1 kings 4:26 says 40,000(’ar-ba-‘im forty)
SCIENTIFIC ERRORS
1) 1 Genesis :3-5 says light was created on first day but 14-19 says sun was created on fourth day. How light came into existence before its source?
2)1 Genesis 11-13 says vegetation was created on 3rd day. How can vegetables grow without sunlight?
3) Psalms 102:25-26 says heaven and earth will perish but Ecclesiastes 1:4 and Psalms 78:69 says it will abide forever.
4)Leviticus 12:1-5 says woman remains unclean for 80 days when she gives birth to a female child and for 40 days when to a male child which is both unscientific and mysogynist.
5) Nehemiah 7:67 says 245 singers while Ezra 2:65 says 200 singers.
6)Jeremiah 36:30 says no one will sit on David's throne after Jehoiakim but 2 kings 24:6 says Jehoiachin sat on the throne
7) Leviticus 11:20 says fowl got 4 feet.
The below is my response to it though i could have done better
1. Matthew 1:16 Jacob [biologically] begat Joseph the husband of Mary
Luke 3:23 Joseph the [legal] son of Heli
2. genesis 11-13 are not contradictions yes some plants can grow without sunlight
3. First let us take up verse [Ecclesiastes 1:4];
“One generation passes away, and another generation comes; But the earth abides forever.”
ANALYSIS: The ‘earth’ used in this passage means “soil or land”, and not the planet Earth. This earth, soil, or land refers to the delightful or good people who abide the will of God.
Kindly read the verses below to identify who is this earth, soil, or land;
[Malachi 3:12] “All the nations will call you blessed, for you shall be a delightful land,” says the LORD of hosts.
In this verse, the righteous Israelites are called a ‘delightful land’ by God.
[Luke 8:15] And the seed that fell on the good soil represent honest, good-hearted people who hear God’s word, cling to it, and patiently produce a huge harvest
In this verse, ‘seed’ represents the word of God [Luke 8:11]; and ‘good soil’ represents good people. God liken the good people as good soil which produces huge harvest. They are the ones who have influenced others to come to God. ‘Good soil or people’ are the ones who abide the will of God.
Kindly compare [Ecclesiastes 1:4] with [1 John 2:17] that says;
[1 John 2:17] And the world is passing away along with its desires, but whoever does the will of God abides forever.
Therefore, it is man who does the will of God that will abide forever, and not the planet Earth.
B. NOW, let us take up the second questioned verse from [Psalm 78:69] which says;
“And He built His sanctuary like the heights, Like the earth which He has established forever.”
ANALYSIS: I believe this verse is not accurately translated, because in other translations we can find the following verses;
Aramaic Bible in Plain English
He built his holy place upon the height and he prepared it in the Earth for eternity.
Douay-Rheims Bible
And he built his sanctuary as of unicorns, in the land which he founded for ever.
Based on the translations above, it is obvious that it is not the earth which is founded forever, but the sanctuary (Church) of God prepared on Earth. This is referred to the Church built by Jesus on Earth, and this Church is for eternity. Meaning the Catholic Church is the kingdom to be brought to the Heaven.
Kindly compare (Psalm 78:69) to its parallel verses in (2 Samuel 7:13 & 1 Chronicles 17:12) we can know;
[2 Samuel 7:13] He will build a house for my name, and I will establish the throne of his kingdom forever.
[1 Chronicles 17:12] He is the one who will build a house-a temple-for me. And I will secure his throne forever.
God wants a descendant of David to build His house or temple, and He will establish His throne forever. This descendant is Jesus whom God will establish His throne or kingdom, kindly read the following verses about the kingdom of Jesus;
[Jeremiah 23:5] The days are coming,” declares the LORD, “when I will raise up to David a righteous Branch, a King who will reign wisely and do what is just and right in the land.
[Daniel 7:14] And to Him was given dominion, Glory and a kingdom, that all the peoples, nations and men of every language might serve Him. His dominion is an everlasting dominion which will not pass away; And His kingdom is one which will not be destroyed.
[Luke 1:33] and He will reign over the house of Jacob forever. His kingdom will never end!
Therefore, it is the kingdom of God Jesus which is founded forever, and not the planet Earth.
4. All translations of 2 Kings 8:26 are in agreement that Ahaziah of Judah was 22 years old at the start of his reign. And most translations of 2 Chronicles 22:2 also have his age at 22. However, some versions, such as the KJV, NKJV, ASV, and NRSV, state that Ahaziah acceded to the throne when he was 42 years old, not 22. this was most likely a error in the text not a contradiction 5. First, Both Ezra and Nehemiah agree that the total was 42,360 (Ezra 2:64 & Nehemiah 7:66). And if we sum up their two lists respectively will give us 29,818 for Ezra, and 31,089 for Nehemiah. Further calculations show that Nehemiah lists 1765 persons who are not in Ezra, and Ezra has 494 not mentioned in Nehemiah. By adding Ezra’s 494 to Nehemiah’s total, and adding Nehemiah’s 1765 to Ezra’s total, we find that they will both add up to 31,583, with every name being on both lists. Subtracting 31,583 from 42,360 gives a difference of 10,777. This difference was not broken down by name or town because they were not associated with the former Southern Kingdom. Both [Ezra 2:1] and [Nehemiah 1:3] hint that the list’s purpose was to name those of the Southern Kingdom who returned from Babylon. The 42,360 is the whole or total assembly of Israelites. Since there were long years gap from Ezra to Nehemiah in their returns to Jerusalem, I believe there was adjustment made in Ezra’s time, that 45 were added to the previous 200 singers. This 45 must be coming from the undesignated or unnamed 10,777 people in the list.
Second, assuming that this slight numerical disagreement occurred, this cannot discount the veracity of the history since there are many categories or figures that are agreeing. Just like when there are two witnesses testifying against you that you robbed a house. One witness stated that, he saw you went out from the house at 3 a.m. last night carrying a large bag, you wore a black jacket and a cap. The other witness also stated that he also saw you went out from the house carrying a large bag at around 2:30 a.m. last night, you wore a black jacket and a cap. The verdict is you actually robbed that house since there are many agreeing testimonies despite the minutes differential of time.
Third, we should identify from whom the information comes, is it from God or not, and which type of information is this, is it prophetic or historical? As you know, the Bible contains not just prophetic but also historical information. In the historical side, the Bible could contain any event. For instance, King David lusted Uriah’s wife Bathsheba in the Bible, this is not good information, but it should be put in the record since it actually happened. Early Christians were not hiding something even hideous matter (this proves that Christians did not correct the Bible contrary to the accusation of Islam, if so, you could not find any numerical discrepancy inside it). This numerical contradiction is historical. The Bible is God-inspired when it comes to the words of prophesy. Kindly read the verses below;
[2 Peter 1:20-21] Above all, you must understand that no prophecy of Scripture comes from one’s own interpretation. For no such prophecy was ever brought forth by the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.
[Revelation 22:18-19] I testify to everyone who hears the words of prophecy in this book: If anyone adds to them, God will add to him the plagues described in this book. And if anyone takes away from the words of this book of prophecy, God will take away his share in the tree of life and the holy city, which are described in this book.
God is only concerned on matters of prophesy. A Scripture containing a prophetic blunder like Quran is certainly not from God.
6. according to 2 Kings 24:6, Jehoiachin the son of Jehoiakim “reigned in his place.” Is this contradictory? Solution: This is not a contradiction. Although Jehoiachin did take over after the death of his father, he was in Jerusalem only three months before the city fell to the invading armies of Nebuchadnezzar.
7. they didn't even do the verse correctly as the verse goes “‘All flying insects that walk on all fours are to be regarded as unclean by you."
@@josiahbundy-yl4ykThx bro
Ironically, Momo's demonic possession could have easily faked miracles. A false revelation seemed to have sufficed The Devil's goal.
So he cursed Satan while being possessed by him?
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad
I'd curse satan too if I was in spiritual agony and torment
Didn't work though, did it?
But what did work, was The Devil's deception. Suddenly appearing as Gabriel to give a false gospel that takes Momo away from Christ Jesus thus eternal life with The Lord.
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad what kind of profit is itto curse satan, meanwhile doing the works of the devil like having sexual intercourse with little children, animals, corpses and even hos own aunt? 'Marrying' women in the same night when they have killed their husband and father and whole family
@@hermit2639makes no sense if he's possessed he follows Satan's order
@@Faithexplorer4376Unless Satan's orders are for Muhammad to make his "revelation" as convincing as possible, after all Satan is the greatest of all deceivers.
Let this guy reach 100k subs!! This needs to be spread 🔊🔊 Jesus is King ✨🙏🙏🙏
Thanks for confirming the Quran by making the exact same argument as the idol worshippers who were mentioned in the Quran. The Quran itself was the sole miracle and a solid proof of Muhammad, but it wasn't enough for the idol worshippers. (29:51) So they either rejected the message of God, or made up more "miracles" of Muhammad
That sounds kind of circular
That’s not confirming, because a book is not evidence, a book is not a miracle, your prophet couldn’t perform miracles like the other mighty prophets who have proof they were from God.
Its just sad to see how many christians would blindly believe in what you say by not verifying or thinking about what you are saying. I wanted to write a response did so but due to some reason couldnt post the whole reply as yt keeps refraining me from posting. It is sad to see the people being decieved.
You deceive yourself by not believing Jesus Christ is God.
@@MikuSlay69 you decieve yourself believing a man is god, believing in a book not worthy of being devine or even trusted, written by unknown authors. truly you are a blind believer.
@@MikuSlay69 you decieve your self believing in a god man, believing in a book which is unworthy of being devine, corrupted, containing contradictions. truly you are a blind follower.
@@moosa86 you think christians read the bible?
@@kufr_antagonistI think you forgot that Jesus became human. He is both man and god
Did you change the title of the video?
Yes, because I got tired of getting comments that miss the point. People originally followed Jesus because of miracles. He drew large crowds because of miracles. The apostles drew large crowds by miracles. Paul appeals to his miracles to the churches of Corinth and Thessalonica. He appeals to the miracles happening in the church of Galatia. There are early church fathers who talk about the miracles that led to the spread of Christianity. There's also even modern research done saying that most Chinese Christians convert based on witnessing or hearing credible reports of miracles.
But I kept getting "yeah but colonialism, Constantine" etc. Even though this is crudely put by the opponent, and not quite true, it's not totally inaccurate either, to some extent. If I changed the title to ORIGINALLY SPREAD it's just too long for people to see on their phones. So I settled in on this.
@@TestifyApologetics thanks testify for another well put video! That sounds fascinating. Would you be willing to make some content on that period from the early ministry of the church and how people converted? Like post-apostles and pre-Constantine.
Hey Erick,
I was wondering if you could do a video on how many Jews converted to Christianity in the 1st century. I was curious about this as some Jews argue that the fact not many converted at the time suggests Jesus wasn’t the Messiah, and I found that there’s some debate to be had around it given the numbers recorded in Acts such as the tens of thousands in 21:20. I even found an academic paper arguing that hardly any more than 1000 did, but I’d be curious to hear your thoughts on it.
Amazing series debunking the idiocracy of Islam
A shame islam beat him to it by more than a millenia ;)
He said that he would kill one of the enemies of the Muslims, Ubay ibn Khalaf, which he achieved at the Battle of Uhud.[34]
Before the Battle of Badr, he showed exactly where each of the enemy chiefs would be killed; they all died in the exact locations stated.[34]
He said that his daughter Fatimah would be the first of his family to die after him; which eventuated.[34]
On several occasions he provided food and water supernaturally.[35]
He quenched the thirst of thousands of his soldiers during the Battle of Tabouk and enabled them to use water for ablution after causing water to pour forth.[33][35]
He caused two trees to move at his command.[35]
He caused a well to swell with water after he rinsed his mouth with some water and then threw it out into the well. This was during the event of the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, enabling his followers with him to drink and use the water for ablution.[36]
He threw a handful of dust at some of the enemy during the Battle of Hunain, causing them to be blinded. This miracle is mentioned in the Quran (Q8:17).[33]
He caused Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud to convert to Islam after he made a barren ewe, which produced no milk, to produce milk.[34]
He used his saliva to cure Ali's sick eye, during the Battle of Khaybar, and it became healthy.[37]
His companions would hear the food before him praising Allah.[37]
He caused it to rain during a drought in Medina.[38]
His prayers were instantly answered.[39]
Stones and trees used to greet him before and during his prophethood.[40][41]
He used to understand the language of animals.[42][43]
He comforted a palm tree that was crying and upset after he stopped leaning on it during his sermons.[44]
He had The Seal of Prophethood (Khatam an-Nabiyyin) between his shoulders, specifically on the end of his left shoulder blade, It is depicted as a mole, in size compared to the egg of a partridge or to a pigeon's egg and its color was the same as that of Muhammad's body.[45][46][47][48][49] It is believed that each prophet sent by Allah had this Seal on a certain part of his body.[50]
It is reported, that Muhammad did not cast a shadow, interpreted as a sign of his "light".[51]
When Muhammad ascended Mount Uhud and he was accompanied by Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. The mountain shook beneath them. Muhammad then hit it with his foot and said, "O Uhud! Be firm, for upon you there is none but a Prophet, a supporter of truth and two martyrs."[52][53][54][55][56]
The same event occurred on Jabal al-Nour in Mecca.[57][58][59][60][61]
Muhammad used to hear the voices of persons who were being tortured in their graves.[62][63]
When Abu Jahl was going to trample Muhammad's neck or smear his face with dust as he was engaged in prayer, Abu Jahl came near him but turned upon his heels and tried to repulse something with his hands. It was said to him: "What is the matter with you?" He said: "There is between me and him. A ditch of fire and terror and wings." Thereupon Muhammad said: "If he were to come near me the angels would have torn him to pieces."[64]
He used to speak to the dead and hear them. It also occurred with the bodies of the enemy chiefs after the Battle of Badr in the presence of his companions.[65][66][67]
Of course Mohammed did one miricle.
Sahih al Bukhari: 4428 - basicly, Mohammed got poisend by a Jew and that it why he died. And by this, his aorta was cut off.
And in the koran says, which is btw older then sahih al bukari. 69, 44-46 that if Mohammed wouldnt be a prophet, his aorta will be cut off.
Glory to Jesus Christus.
King of Kings, Son of God.
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 Of course.
I am not a prophet or anything.
But if i would be one and i would like to proof it to you, i would proof it to the world.
And not by saying, that i will not die in a certain way but by for example: Healing sick people, walking on water, dividing the sea. etc etc.
You can also claim and will probably will be right if u say, that you wont die eg suicide, this isnt a miricale but probability.
And here is the kicker.
The qoran knows a lot of miricals which actually happens. But fortunally, those are copied out of the bible so they dont proof anything for Islam.
Mohammed - may our and his lord Jesus Christ judge and condemn him - claimed, that he will die a painful death if he is not a prophet. His aorta will be cut off.
It wasnt probabil that it will happend.
But god himself spitted on his face by letting him die this way. Mohammed said, that it feels like his aorta will be cut off.
Here is god himnself condemning Islam.
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 Your Koran and your Hadith is proof.
I love these types of videos i have to put some in a playlist and private it so i can send the videos to my friends and other people 😂😂 great work man and stay safe
This looks like the perfect place to drop some of my favorite Hadith/quran verses.
Sahih Muslim 1422 c
'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that Allah's Apostle (ﷺ) married her when she was seven years old, and he was taken to his house as a bride when she was nine, and her dolls were with her; and when he (the Holy Prophet) died she was eighteen years old.
Muhammad ﷺ does have miracles and he’s the only one that has miracles we can see today and also has miracles that were only for the people that accompanied him
And the verses you took out of context you don’t know what they were talking about. Also what did you want as a description of hell? A beautiful garden where you have fun? No! Also to say people converted to Islam for lustful gain is so insincere why would the pagan Arabs join Islam if they lost so much? They now had to worship one god, not drink alcohol, had a limit on wives, and so much more. Is the only way you can attack Islam by lying about it to your Christian viewers? May god guide you to be more sincere
And what do you mean that Jews and Christians have to be second class citizens? You liar do you have no shame?
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 sorry im not an Arab and don’t understand Arabic if you could translate your comment into English that would be wonderful since I can’t copy and paste
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 Allahu ekber
No we can't see his miracles today, and only miracles for those who accompany him is worse than miracles for the sick etc.
While watching this video, I got a headache, it is just unbelievable. All the points mentioned were simply nonsense. Scholars have already refuted such false claims. It is funny to see how Christians tend to willingly present verses in a false light or hide the context from those who they preach to.
The Qur'an says that Allah (swt) is the one behind the miracles and the one that allows the prophets to perform them. This does not mean, and I repeat: does not mean, that Muhammad (saw) or rather all of the prophets did not perform miracles, but that God gave them the authority to do so.
Allah (swt) says in the Qur'an that for those who believe, the Qur'an i.e His word should be enough evidence for the righteous. He does NOT say that the Qur'an is the only miracle, but that if they are not pleased with the Qur'an that they would not be pleased with any other miracle, just like they did with earlier prophets.
Not to mention that Muhammad (saw) predicted many things from the Muslims taking over Constantinople to airplanes and the return of two Pagan gods from Saudi Arabia. He has even healed people that have been harmed in battle, which you, of course, would not mention as a Christian because it would prove how wrong you are.
Ali Daschti is not a scholar, he is merely a Shia and you know that, but of course, you hide this fact because you know that the Shia have nothing to do with Islam. He obviously denies the Qur'an as being from God, since the Qur'an speaks against the Shia specifically even though they claim to follow God's word. The book is clearly biased and we see that when we consider how many studies have proven that the Qur'an is written in a way nowhere to be seen. That is why the Qur'an challenges you to create a book or at least a chapter like it - it is simply not possible, it is a completely new and unique art of literature.
No Muslim says that the moon did not split. The scholars all say that it did happen. There are many sources that agree that it did happen. From the king of Kerala, who wrote a letter mentioning the miracle, to the many hadiths that say it. Also, there is no scientific evidence needed for a miracle, this is just pure nonsense now. A supernatural event does not require to be proven by something natural.
Every time Christians say something wrong regarding ahadith, you make me feel smarter than I actually am. A Hadith is originally a verbal transmission from the time of Rasulallah (saw), which have been collected and written down by many such as Imam Bukhari (ra) or Imam Muslim (ra). This does not mean that they are biased or unreliable, which does not even make sense when we consider that there are many ahadith that say something good for Islam but are called fabricated by scholars. A hadith is classified as authentic by the chain of narration and in this case, the chain of narrators contained trustworthy people and is not missing any narrators. It is even backed up by there being more than just one authentic hadith about the moon splitting, there are many. The good thing is that you can look at the chain of narration and see it yourself. Historians even treat ahadith like any other historical document even if the things said in them are seen as silly or off by them.
This has not really much to do with all of this nonsense, but it is also funny to mention that the oh-so-educated creator of our beloved and definitely not biased video cannot even pronounce the word "Hadith" properly (He also cannot pronounce "Qur'an" or "Islam" but I will not mention that since this is a common thing for Christians). Anyways, back to educating someone that does not even know that two verses in the same book can be related to each other (But only when it comes to the Qur'an of course, he would not do the same if it were the Bible.)
The Qur'an is not even the word of Muhammad (saw). First, you take verses from the Qur'an as an argument but do not mention the verses that say that Allah (swt) has intentionally chosen Muhammad for a reason. Apart from that, you show how uneducated you are about Islam. If you read ahadith, you will see that Muhammad's way of speech does not match up with the Qur'an. I won't even mention the tons of miracles in the Qur'an or how it introduces new words and a new type of grammar to the Arabic language, which is interesting for an illiterate in a nation of illiterates.
Muhammad (saw) actually said that sickness or rather a fever is a sign from Allah (swt) to show that he forgives them. And guess what? Some of the Sahaba had a fever when they were in Medina. So why should someone pray for a sign of Allah (swt) to vanish? Allah (azzawajal) likes to bring hardship to his servants so that they can learn from it and become stronger, which is why Muslims stay strong during such times, especially in Salah, when facing God. He brings you hardship so that you come to him and ask him for forgiveness and blessings. Surely, nobody would ask for help when they are strong, which is why Allah says that man has been created weak.
I will not even mention how Al-Kasim died before Muhammad even became a prophet. I love how Christians just remove the context from anything in order to make Islam seem bad. I love it, it helps me laugh when remembering how the "Followers" of Christ are.
Clearly, you are also uneducated about Islamic history. This "folklore" was there during the time of the Salaf and the Sahaba, which makes no sense if it really appeared later without any evidence. We purposely made sure to ask for narrators and the chain of narration to make sure that it is authentic and not fabricated.
There is nothing wrong with hell being eternal suffering, hello? You choose between Satan and God and willingly follow Satan who wants to drag you down to hell with him, it is your wish. You cannot expect that bad people do not get punished at all or get rewarded, it is unjust to those who followed or even died for God.
As for having four wives, you keep proving how uneducated you are about Islamic history and ahadith. This verse was revealed because many men would die on the battlefield, leaving many widows that had to be taken care of. The verse that you mentioned and I referred to earlier, is not even about marrying four wives, but about how people find it hard to stay away from sin and God saying that he made it just for us and that it is possible for us. Reading the verses afterward, confirm it, saying that you shall not commit major sins so that you can be put in a place of honor by Allah (swt).
As for adultery, Islam says to not come near it and to lower your gaze. We seem to be better Christians in that case, since we actually do that. We even encourage marrying young so that you will not fall into the sins of lust, but can go to your wife to relieve yourself just like the wife can go to you to do the same.
The claim about Islam only existing for power, wealth, and lust is just blatantly false and further proves that you know nothing about Islamic history. The Quraysh have oppressed the Muslims for many years and they did not retaliate until God commanded it, telling them to fight back so that the religion would not be changed by the oppressors for power, like they did with Judaism and Christianity. Also, the Quraysh offered Muhammad (saw) wealth, power, and women and even the key to the Kaaba, which he all refused, saying that he would not give up spreading God's message even if they were to place the sun in his right hand and the moon in his left. Muhammad had nearly no possessions and even had traces on his arm from not even sleeping on a mattress. The claim about women is as you could have guessed also very false, Muhammad (saw) only married one wife out of love and the other 10 for mostly for political or religious reasons. He did not have spouses for many years and married people of any age, whether they were good-looking or not.
Reading the verses after 8:12 actually shows that it is in the context of war against the Quraysh, the Mekkans, but you people love to remove the context from such verses. I must congratulate since I actually expected you to show 9:5 and not 8:12. I would have nearly laughed even more at how biased you are. Anyways, no one was ever forced to convert to Islam, which the Quran even says in Surah Al-Baqara, that there is no compulsion in religion.
The Jizya is a tax for protection, you must pay 2.5% for protection against foreign power if you live in the lands of the Muslims, because they are not obliged to protect you when there is no treaty. If you do not want that then go into a country where you are a majority, this is common sense. And if you refuse then you have to be punished, just like Western nations imprison you for not paying your 50% to the government.
There are not only numerous miracles attributed to Muhammad (saw), but also many found in the Qur'an. The Qur'an mentions the land-to-sea ratio of the Earth, the Big Bang, the fact that living beings are composed mostly of water, the orbits of celestial objects, iron originating from space, the number of human chromosomes, and the Earth's iron core, among other things, either directly or indirectly. Additionally, it features linguistic miracles, such as its ring composition with matching rhymes, the introduction of new words and grammar, and various other remarkable aspects. It even challenges people to copy the Qur'an, also saying that they will all fail. It straight up denies being authored by any human, devil or anything else.
The Quran is a book that persuades people of the existence of a divine, all-powerful God and the reality of Satan. It has been remarkably successful in this regard. Why would Satan spread the word of God? Why would he command Arab Bedouins to adopt foreign Jewish values? Why would Satan insist that you curse him, seek refuge from him, and drive him out? Before the Quran, Arabs were disunited, idol-worshipping, indulgent in drunkenness and rampant sexual immorality-all traits that Satan would favor. Why would Satan create a religion that opposes his own interests? Why would he create a faith that teaches people to hate him? Why would he promote a religion that condemns promiscuity, pre-marital sexual relations, alcohol consumption, and gambling? Why would he establish a religion that mandates fasting, praying five times a day, and submission to God? Why would Satan create a religion that encourages good character and morals, emphasizing cleanliness and purity, even in personal hygiene practices? Why would he abolish polygamy, slavery, and the murder of children (which was common during the Prophet's time) and promote monotheism? Why would Satan establish a religion when he promised to deceive all of humanity and guide them to evil?
Through Jibreel (as) the Prophet (saw) received verses of guidance, light, and great signs that Satan could neither create nor endorse. It is inconceivable for a rational person to believe that Satan would encourage belief in Allah The Almighty and His Oneness, urge people to pray, pay Zakah, fast, respect kinship ties, and uphold countless moral values and good deeds, while also warning against bloodshed and immorality. How could anyone rationally think that Satan would deliver revelations that curse him, expel him, disbelieve in him, and caution against following his ways?
When we stand before the Christian God and he asks us how we could not or could have believed in him being a human, I could say that I could not imagine the perfect God going through humiliation and suffering. But what are you gonna say when he asks you how you could believe that he became a human? You say that he became weak and let himself be tortured and tread on because he loved you and died to forgive your sins even though he does not require that to forgive you. Not to forget, that he gave you the original sin and punished you for what two people did just to die for you and tell you that you have to believe in him dying for your sins because he will be mad at you if you don't.
Christians, let us be real for a second. Your faith is exactly what Satan wants, he wants you to worship idols through the trinity. Tawhid is pure monotheism while many Christians cannot explain the trinity without committing a heresy. Your religion has become irrelevant in your own nations. You claim to love Jesus, but you do not follow his word as said in the Bible. Instead, you follow your ancestors and the Church. Only someone who has lost. No sane person would believe what you believe and claim what you claim. I would have a lot more respect for Christians if you were not the biggest hypocrites of all time.
Allah (swt) knows best.
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad was gonna refute but I’m not reading allat 💀
@@GoatOfAllTrades Well Well Well, another Christian classic. It does not surprise me, I already know that you can not read.
The way the Church interpretes the Bible and forces you to understand so that you can be called a Christian definetly did something with your brain. That is the only explanation that I can come up with when it comes to Christians who can not read the Qur'an or Bible.
You ignore your own texts but use them against us when you find them in ours. You take away the context from verses but do not like it when others do that to you.
May Allah bless you with eternal bliss and the highest heaven my brother in Islam. Well done
@@GoatOfAllTrades Intimidated by facts and logic because it is not given to you in a memed video format?
Iddah (waiting period after marriage and only needed if consummation of the marriage occurred) notice the three females given as examples of who falls under the iddah.
At-Talaq 65:4
And those who no longer expect menstruation among your women - if you doubt, then their period is three months, and [also for] those who have not menstruated. And for those who are pregnant, their term is until they give birth. And whoever fears Allah - He will make for him of his matter ease.
He threw a handful of dust at some of the enemy during the Battle of Hunain, causing them to be blinded. This miracle is mentioned in the Quran (Q8:17).
How do you explain that? That was during his life with his own men witnessing that?
if you throw sand or dust into somebodies eyes, they can’t see? i don’t see how thats miraculous
@@captainblocker4324 it happen to an entire army.
Real
Paley was a Chad.
He was Sigma 🗿
I guess he would have to be, Alpha and Omega were already taken 🤣
He had miracles other than the moon splitting, and one of the biggest ones is the ascendeing from Mecca to Jerusalem and then heaven in one day. I am surprised at, even, the question.
So you're saying the Qoran lied? Way to throw your book under the bus 😂
2:40 I don't quite understand how the moon-splitting verses in chapter 54 could be considered as an endtime prophecy/eschatological rather than a literal statement describing a miracle that supposedly happened already considering the verse says that the moon "was split" and not referring to something that will happen
The term "End of times" can be pretty broad at a times, it is relative (to a timeline from God's perspective). We are near the end times and like Muhammad predicted it, the Muslims took Istanbul even though he said at the end of times. End of times can be anything aslong as it is closer to the end than to the beginning.
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad as a muslim, do you take the verses talking about the moon-splitting as describing something that happened during muhammad's time or something that will happen in the future?
I think this is a pretty bad argument against Islam. The Qur'an involves in-real time stuff going on at the time of "revelation", but it isn't a biography like the gospels, so it isn't intended to describe Mohammed's life like the gospels do with Jesus, miracles and all. And it still contains things that may be describing miraculous events like the isra and miraj or the splitting of the moon.
You hand waive the hadith of Mohammed's miracles away, but that he performed miracles (or, rather, "Allah" performed miracles throughout his ministry) is mutawatir. This is the HIGHEST standard of any hadith, and disbelieving in genuinely mutawatir hadith are said to take you out of the fold of Islam. Mutawatir hadith (widespread, independent reports) are MORE authoritative than hadiths which are only sahih.
Frankly it is like taking the words of the Gospels out of context to try to prove Jesus didn't do miracles, ie "The only sign they will be given is the sign of Jonah".
Even in today's age there is a big information barrier for non Arabic speakers about Islam, so I imagine that it was even worse in Paley's day. And the question of why Mohammed would let his sons die if he could do miracles is because it is Allah who does the miracles, not an innate power in Mohammed, who is submitting to Allah's will even if it leaves him without sons.
If quran is not biography of muhammed, why does it talk about his sex life in full surah ahzab, tell muslims to not bother muhammed s house with visits, and why allah makes muhammed and his bride marry? And why muhammed s wives becomes mother to muslim boys after his death so that they cannot marry? Bla bla. Quran could talk about more important, global and moral stuff but did not
im paying for the muslims therapy for all this nonsense
True, i also agree that Islam is nonsense so i will help you with therapy for they
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 nah id win
@@Zidane-is-the-GOAT05 idk
im not jewish
what religion are you
Curious question,
What’s the difference of sin in Christianity vs Islam?
I kind of think those are other small things that mislead people from truth.
Edit: Or have you ever seen anyone discuss that?
In Christianity, God is so holy he can leave no sin unpunished and cannot dwell with sin. Every sin must be accounted for. In Islam, Allah can pardon sins without justice being done.That's why Christian's believe Jesus lived a sinless life and died. He gives them forgiveness because he paid the penalty of sin on behalf of those who surrender their lives to him.
"The real treasure was the friends we made along the wau"ahh religion😭🙏
It is very illogical what ali dashti saying here
To think someone like him born in iran not fully arabic speaking nation and lived in the 1900s to judge the quran?
Insted of the arabic poets and all the writers before him who were amazed by the quran not to mention that the prophet saw himself cant read nor write? And having this as the only argument against the quran?
No hate or anything just putting my two cents
Ligerally, tens of miracles i can recall from my memories he did 😭
Why are you lying 🤥
Did you watch the video?
@@TestifyApologetics The video is a lie
@@AhadunAhadFarraduSamad you are a lie
@@johnslick8940 Christianity and Islam are both lies but the Apologists of any of them are the bigger liar. Faith is faith and that alone, logic and reason undermine that faith
This channel is a true blessing. Thank you for all your work
I do think he sometimes bites off a little more than he can chew, but he does some fantastic work for sure.
1:15 If muhammed believed that only God can preform miracles, then wouldn’t that be proof that Jesus is God since it says in the quran that Jesus preformed many?
Allah can will miracles through them, when you use this logic for the trinity, why doesnt it apply when reading other texts Human worshipper?
Without lies, Islam dies.
Same goes for all religions.
@@davepugh2519 except Christianity, if not watch this man's videos
@@t.bo.a7061Wrong, goes for Christianity too.
@@LieMac explain to me why you say so. And I'll explain to you why you're mistaken
@@LieMac also what lies+
Dude I love these taking down islam videos.
He said that he would kill one of the enemies of the Muslims, Ubay ibn Khalaf, which he achieved at the Battle of Uhud.[34]
Before the Battle of Badr, he showed exactly where each of the enemy chiefs would be killed; they all died in the exact locations stated.[34]
He said that his daughter Fatimah would be the first of his family to die after him; which eventuated.[34]
On several occasions he provided food and water supernaturally.[35]
He quenched the thirst of thousands of his soldiers during the Battle of Tabouk and enabled them to use water for ablution after causing water to pour forth.[33][35]
He caused two trees to move at his command.[35]
He caused a well to swell with water after he rinsed his mouth with some water and then threw it out into the well. This was during the event of the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, enabling his followers with him to drink and use the water for ablution.[36]
He threw a handful of dust at some of the enemy during the Battle of Hunain, causing them to be blinded. This miracle is mentioned in the Quran (Q8:17).[33]
He caused Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud to convert to Islam after he made a barren ewe, which produced no milk, to produce milk.[34]
He used his saliva to cure Ali's sick eye, during the Battle of Khaybar, and it became healthy.[37]
His companions would hear the food before him praising Allah.[37]
He caused it to rain during a drought in Medina.[38]
His prayers were instantly answered.[39]
Stones and trees used to greet him before and during his prophethood.[40][41]
He used to understand the language of animals.[42][43]
He comforted a palm tree that was crying and upset after he stopped leaning on it during his sermons.[44]
He had The Seal of Prophethood (Khatam an-Nabiyyin) between his shoulders, specifically on the end of his left shoulder blade, It is depicted as a mole, in size compared to the egg of a partridge or to a pigeon's egg and its color was the same as that of Muhammad's body.[45][46][47][48][49] It is believed that each prophet sent by Allah had this Seal on a certain part of his body.[50]
It is reported, that Muhammad did not cast a shadow, interpreted as a sign of his "light".[51]
When Muhammad ascended Mount Uhud and he was accompanied by Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman. The mountain shook beneath them. Muhammad then hit it with his foot and said, "O Uhud! Be firm, for upon you there is none but a Prophet, a supporter of truth and two martyrs."[52][53][54][55][56]
The same event occurred on Jabal al-Nour in Mecca.[57][58][59][60][61]
Muhammad used to hear the voices of persons who were being tortured in their graves.[62][63]
When Abu Jahl was going to trample Muhammad's neck or smear his face with dust as he was engaged in prayer, Abu Jahl came near him but turned upon his heels and tried to repulse something with his hands. It was said to him: "What is the matter with you?" He said: "There is between me and him. A ditch of fire and terror and wings." Thereupon Muhammad said: "If he were to come near me the angels would have torn him to pieces."[64]
He used to speak to the dead and hear them. It also occurred with the bodies of the enemy chiefs after the Battle of Badr in the presence of his companions.[65][66][67]
@@Faithexplorer4376 What do you hope to accomplish with words from a rubbish book(your quran) fit only for wiping and toilet paper?
@@PantalonRougechristians will never fail to default back to their echo chambers sad
Guys I don't think we should be arguing about historical context its important to to calm in every situation and get to understand one another.
Them believing that Jesus Christ is not God and just another prophet is enough.
doesn't contradict anything
Splitting the moon, supplying his people with a trey of unlimited food, water coming out of his fingers to increase water supply, curing Ali Ibn Abi Talib’s eye. The night journey, foretelling the future, splitting a massive rock with his staff and causing water to rush out of it, the ability to speak to animals, and of course the Quran.
Are these not miracles?
last time I checked the moon is intact, typical mohammedan L
You would sooner think miracles like those would count. But they don’t if you’re Christian.
@@johnslick8940 well if you actually read the Hadith, you would know it came back together
@@johnslick8940 and last I checked there aren’t genetic bottlenecks of every single living organism due to a global flood.
@@johnslick8940 the moon was joined, yet another typical L
You again miss points. Islam sais that prophets dont have the natural power of doing miracles Allah does the miracle through them.
Also you talked about men's wifes in heaven but you didnt explain it correctly. There is no ayet that sais Huris are only for men. Also there is no ayet that give Huris a gender,they are just shown as servents in heaven for both women and men. You apparently didnt research Quran's Surahs.
About language,Arabic in Muhammed's times were very limited about grammar therefore the only way to truly understand Quran is by reading it in Arabic. It is no proof about Quran being fake.
You should do much more research before making videos. Miracles arent neccesary to know a religion is true. We are Muslim because Islam makes sense.
"About language,Arabic in Muhammed's times were very limited about grammar therefore the only way to truly understand Quran is by reading it in Arabic. It is no proof about Quran being fake. "
I believe the claim here, not made by him, pertains the arabic text. I know no arabic so I can't say a thing about it. People really like the KJV bible because all the poetic intonations and high level speech, when it's actually just the way people talked 500 years ago. This claim about no text matching the quran seems to be subjective.
"Also you talked about men's wifes in heaven but you didnt explain it correctly. There is no ayet that sais Huris are only for men. Also there is no ayet that give Huris a gender,they are just shown as servents in heaven for both women and men. You apparently didnt research Quran's Surahs. "
Just noticed you're an eternal-sex salafi believer :(
"You should do much more research before making videos. Miracles arent neccesary to know a religion is true. We are Muslim because Islam makes sense."
what does make sense? Monotheism? So we have quite a handful of religions to pick and choose from. Even Hindu can be said to believe in One God.
@@user-qh4dr1vy9d It isnt subjective. In Muhammed's times Arabs were living as tribes,civilization wasnt so developed neither was language. Also Bible was written in Greek,a language that affected almost all European languages therefore there are gramatical similarities unlike old Arabic.
It isnt only about believing one God. I am talking all the other things combined. I think Quran and Islam makes more sense then other religions so I am Muslim. Just like many other people. My point was that you dont need to see some supernatural thing happening to believe a religion what matters is if this religion matches with your logic,makes sense to you.
@@user-qh4dr1vy9d Christians when it comes to Allah granting anyone their wish : 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭. Seriously, by this logic. sex in marriages should be a sin of lust. Nothing implies in our text that the Hoor Al Ayn which is of the merits of Jannah if you wish, that they be forced on you and you shall take them,
I just totally love your channel it's opened my eyes to a lot and has been a great help.
Additionally, the 'argument for literary excellence' can be applied to other things.
I cannot write plays as good as Shakespeare's, or songs as brilliant as Mozart's, so therefore their art was... from God?
Obviously, that's not how it works.
Similarly, the Qur'an also claims that if it were NOT from God, there would be within it 'much contradiction' (Surah 4:82). (not even the claim 'no contradiction', just not 'much contradiction' for some reason).
However, books on simple mathematic axioms don't have any contradictions. Are those math books from a prophet?
If I wrote down a book filled with basic math equations (2+2 = 4, 2+3=5, etc.), I would have written something with no contradictions: would I be a prophet?
-----
The Qur'an's arguments in its favor are as weak as the Qur'an is dull.
Muslims who think otherwise: have you actually read the Qur'an with the intent to understand it, in your own language? It is a winding, plodding, repetitive, and contradictory slog.
Don't believe me? Try to read Surah 2 in one sitting, in your own language, while trying to understand each verse (don't cheat by skimming).
The Qur'an finds within itself 'much contradiction', and it is not a book of literary excellence.
Muhammad is dead.
Christ is risen.
7:39 , dude you relize that islam does not permit unjustified killing right, that verse refers to self defence.
@@JesusSavedYouu most of yall? never in my entire life have a I known a true Muslim that killed anyone without reason.
Again, I’m loving this series, bro! Great work!
"A wicked and adulterous generation asks for a sign"
Keep on preaching brother! We must educate the Muslims that they are following a pagan religion built on the lies of Muhammad, police be upon him. Jesus Christ is Lord and God of all ❤❤❤
Because Muhammad in Islamic context is just a messenger. He received the message and transfer it. There is no point of comparison with Christianity. Islam is a way of life. Each faith has their pros and cons. But the main point is how you live your faith and your life. How your feel more identify to communicate with god if you are happy in that way is ok. If you want to find evidences to destroy a faith you'll find them for sure, even Christianity do not escape for having a history stained with blood of innocents in the name of Jesus. I think that we must respect the faith people decide to choose. Remember that god works in different ways.
“Christians” going against what the Bible says doesn’t disprove it.
@@falcon131000 But Muhammad was not just a warner, was he? He only said so, but the reality was he dropped a whole bunch of new teachings, that differed with previous teachings (Christianity and Judaism), while claiming that he was preaching from the same God. The one God that did give miracles before. So, yeah, it's reasonable to ask for miracles to Muhammad.
He did do a miracle!
And if he (Muhammad SAW) had forged a false saying concerning Us (Allah), We surely should have seized him by his right hand (or with power and might), And then certainly should have cut off his life artery (Aorta), (Quran 69:44-46, Muhsin Khan)
Sometime after Muhammad ate poisoned meat and was dying he exclaimed,
….Narrated ‘Aisha: The Prophet in his ailment in which he died, used to say, “O ‘Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar, and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison.” (Sahih Bukhari 5:59:713)
Tafsir Ibn Kathir:
“Allah says,
وَلَوْ تَقَوَّلَ عَلَيْنَا
(And if he had forged a false saying concerning Us,) meaning, if Muhammad forged something against Us, as they claim, and added or removed anything from the Message, or said anything from himself while attributing it to Us, then We would surely be swift in punishing him. And of course, Muhammad did not do any of this (as the disbelievers claimed).' Thus, Allah says,
لأَخَذْنَا مِنْهُ بِالْيَمِينِ
(We surely would have seized him by his right hand,) It has been said that this means, We would seize him by the right hand because it is more stronger in grabbing.'
ثُمَّ لَقَطَعْنَا مِنْهُ الْوَتِينَ
(And then We certainly would have cut off Al-Watin from him,) Ibn Abbas said, "It (Al-Watin) refers to the artery of the heart, and it is the vein that is attached to the heart." This has also been said by Ikrimah, Said bin Jubayr, Al-Hakim, Qatadah, Ad-Dahhak, Muslim Al-Batin and Abu Sakhr Humayd bin Ziyad. Muhammad bin Kab said, "It (Al-Watin) is the heart, its blood, and whatever is near it." Concerning Allah's statement,
فَمَا مِنكُم مِّنْ أَحَدٍ عَنْهُ حَـجِزِينَ
(And none of you could have prevented it from him.) means, `none of you would be able to come between Us and him if We wanted to do any of this to him.' The meaning behind all of this is to say that he (Muhammad ) is truthful, righteous and guided because Allah determined what he is to convey from Him,
There are some things to keep in mind when reading these verses.
The word used to describe the severed part is “Al Wateen”(ٱلْوَتِينَ).
The penalty would begin with the seizing of his RIGHT HAND
The punishment would be swift.
The verse is in the past tense. (IF Muhammad made up a verse)
Now let us take a look at the claim:
In Sahih Bukhari Volume 5 Book 59 Hadith 713, Aisha (R) narrated that “The Prophet (ﷺ) in his ailment in which he died, used to say, ‘O `Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar, and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison.’”
(Grade: Sahih)
For some context, there is an opinion that Muhammad (Peace be upon him) died of an illness from the poison he was given by a Jewish woman at Khaibar, an oasis around 150 kilometres away from Makkah. Aisha narrates here that Muhammad felt the pain caused by the aforementioned poison, and it felt like his aorta was being cut.
This hadith is used to say that Muhammad (Peace be upon him) fabricated verses of the Holy Quran because he is feeling pain in his aorta. The hadith also mentions that he said this during the ailment in which he died. Essentially, they claim that because of the pain by his aorta during his death, Muhammad must have altered the word of Allah, as stated in the Quran.
There are a multitude of problems with this, however. Recall the statements I said to keep in mind.
(The word used to describe the severed part is “Al Wateen”{ٱلْوَتِينَ})The word for aorta in the Hadith is different from the word for aorta in the Quran. The words said are the “Al-abhar”, which is a long vein from the head to the feet, and the “Al-wateen” which extends to the back.
As compiled by Zawadi, Al Wateen is a part of Al Abhar, and when the Prophet (SAW) was referring to Al-abhar, there was no way to know that he was referring to the Al Wateen vein or the aorta.
As quoted by Zawadi: “So here we observe that al-wateen is actually a part of al-abhar. This is why al-wateen is sometimes used synonymously with al-abhar in some dictionaries. It is because al-wateen is a part of al-abhar, however likewise can't be said vice versa, for Al-abhar doesn't necessarily refer to al-wateen.”
Zawadi’s article is a refutation to a video made by esteemed Christian apologist David Wood and his video “Who killed Muhammad?”. The full article is very intriguing so I highly recommend you read that and Zawadi’s other work.
(The penalty would begin with the seizing of his RIGHT HAND) It is said in the Quran that the punishment would begin with the grabbing of Muhammad’s right hand. However, this does not have any merit because Muhammad’s hand was not affected in his death. His body was fine, as shown in Sahih Muslim 2444e:
'A'isha, the wife of Allah's Apostle (ﷺ), reported that he used to say: Never a prophet dies in a state that he is not made to see his abode in Paradise, and then given a choice. 'A'isha said that when Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) was about to leave the world, his head was over her thigh and he had fallen into swoon three times. When he felt relief his eyes were fixed at the ceiling. He then said: O Allah, along with the high companions (i. e. along with the Apostles who live in the most elevated place of the Paradise). (On hearing these words), I then said (to myself) He is not going to opt us and I remembered a hadith which he had narrated to us as he was healthy and in which he said: No prophet dies until he sees his abode in Paradise, he is then given a choice. 'A'isha said: These were the last words which Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) spoke (the words are): O Allah, with companions on High.
(The punishment would be swift) It is also said in tafsirs that the punishment that would dawn upon Muhammad for changing the word of Allah would be swift, as in a quick punishment that nobody could stop. This does not match what is said in the hadith, however, because Muhammad died roughly three to four years after consuming the poison. It is even questioned whether or not he died from this poison.
Taahir ibn 'Aashoor (May Allah have mercy on him) said in his interpretation of the Quran, At-Tahreer wat Tanweer: “The meaning of {We would have seized him by the right hand}, is ‘We would have seized him by force, that is, without hesitation…”
He also said: “The meaning is: “We would have taken him sooner and We would have severed his aorta. This is to magnify the manner of seizing; therefore, Allah did not say for instance ‘We would have made him perish.” This did not happen, as stated earlier.
(The verse is in the past tense. {IF Muhammad made up a verse}) The verses that I mentioned earlier are in the past tense, meaning that IF the Prophet were to have fabricated anything, THEN he would be punished. This means that Muhammad had not lied, for the punishment did not come upon him.
In conclusion, the argument used by these Christians to discredit Muhammad's (peace be upon him) message based on the death of the Prophet does not hold up under scrutiny. The claim that Muhammad fabricated verses of the Quran due to his pain in the aorta is flawed for several reasons as described. Therefore, these arguments fail to undermine the authenticity and truthfulness of Muhammad's message as conveyed in the Quran and Hadith.
TLDR: He did not get seized by his right hand and did not sever his own vein as the verse says (also the word for the aorta Al Wateen, is different than the one used for the hadith)
It is the same as Christianity in the adultery one, but not publicly punished! Also the paying one if not converting!
This is so Inaccurate, i don't even know where to start the argument against it.
Just start by responding this why your prophet didn't perform any miracles?
@@helligusvart2384 Now, I am an ex-Muslim atheist who doesn’t sympathize with any particular religion, however, sayin Muhammad never performed miracles is plain wrong. In multiple hadiths, he is said to heal the sick by simply blowing on them. In another hadith, he is said to understand animals’ language. And he is said to have provided food and water supernaturally
@@Kozkayn Well, either you don't know, or you are being dishonest because in the Quran it says that Muhammad did not perform any miracles and that God only gave him the task of delivering His message. Now, I don't believe anything the Hadiths say because they came hundreds of years after Muhammad's death and cannot be considered a reliable source of information.
@@helligusvart2384 He did: In fact there is over 4400 different miracles that were recorded, they were categorized into four branches, the ones that happened before his prophethood, the one's that happened after him being chosen as prophet, the one's that happened after the first conversions and the ones that happened after him passing away.
1. The miracle of him praying for rain when there was drought in the land and heavy rain immediately coming down in middle of the drought at that very moment.
2. The predictions in the Quran of the future events that happened. (An actual miracle in the Quran).
3. The miracle of not being able put forth something similar to Quran in a way of nothing similarly structured existing before it. So that Iranian person calling those traits out as mistakes only proves this further.
4. The fact that prophet read the Quran without knowing how to read.
And many more...
@@helligusvart2384 The Quran doesn’t say Muhammad can not perform miracles, it says that Muhammad isn’t divine and his main duty isn’t to do miracles, but rather to deliver the message. When they ask why a sign wasn’t sent, they are asking why a divine being wasn’t sent to “confirm” prophethood. The main emphasis here is that Muhammad is human.
And also, hadiths are oral history traced to contemporaries. Now, oral history is unreliable, but we aren’t debating if Muhammad actually performed miracles, we are debating if miracles are attributed to Muhammad. In most schools of Islamic theology, hadith are seen as sources second only to the Quran. It doean’t matter if you think they are reliable or not, most Islamic scholars affirm the importance of the hadiths and attribute it to Muhammad.
Besides, there are still the two miracles mentioned in the Quran: The moon split and thw Miraj
The lack of research mentally hurts me
God bless you for this amazing, simple and logical video 🙏🏾
7:36 i think someting wrong here. The original Quran 8.12 "Recall that your Lord inspired the angels: "I am with you; so support those who believed. I will throw terror into the hearts of those who disbelieved. You may strike them above the necks, and you may strike even every finger." I think God doesn't order muslims to attack someone in this passage.
Thanks for video.
as a catholic, the comments hurts me
and this video hurts me cause of how misleading he is
@@nothing_inside9922You guys worship a cube shut up
@@playfulwaddles here’s the dumb one!
Allah just means God in Arabic.
Yes but their god is not God
@@monsieurcharcutier4490 because there is no god
couldnt the arguments regarding evidence of miracles be applied to christianity? the sources regarding jesus' miracles generate a lot of questions in terms of veracity as well
6:28 to be fair the real bible doesnt really hold back when it comes to the description of Hell either. "weeping and gnashing of teeth" and all that. Although, the new testament's approach in general was "repent and turn to me, I will forgive you" and I assume the Quran has a much different emphasis akin to "obey me or this is your fate"
Brother, if your belief system really rely on bombastic visual experience and magic healings only... Aren't witches and wizards able to do that also?
On top of that, visual miracles like splitting the sea only has it effects on people who actually saw it first hand
Ironically Quran's and Muhammad's relevance up to this day 1400 hundred years later is indeed a miracle
If 1400 years ago a random dude said, "I want you to show me some miracle right now", he would get the same answer if he asked today. Everlasting relevance.
Now sit back and think, eventhough Islam lacks visual miracle, there are still billions of Muslims today and it proves that the values and teachings of Islam through the Quran is indeed an everlasting miracle.
Speaking of everlasting, It's been 1400 years and still no one has been able to produce a chapter like Quran? Why don't you give it a shot then?
May Allah guide you to the Straight Path since you invested your time so much on Islam
Replying to see what Testify’s response is! ✝️
Well if we were to speak of how no one could produce a chapter like the Quran, shouldn't we contemplate how the Bible was written way before the Quran by many, many people at different points of times (over 1000 years), yet has no contradictions whatsoever? Along with 4 different eye-witnesses of Jesus Christ and His miracles. The Quran was written by one man with a very similar story and outright wrong doctrine
Miracles aren't the whole point of Christianity, but it's definitely something that only Christianity has, because it's real. Witches and wizards act on the power of the devil, not God
In the end, the Bible promotes love, patience, and going the extra mile, while Islam outright promotes violence aside with killing unbelievers, not much to contemplate here
@@Evan-et3wf Bible was written by many "People".
They wrote the parts they liked and discarded the parts they didn't like. Hence making many versions.
Quran is the words of God sent through angel Gabriel (A.S) to the Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W).
and was written exactly as was revealed by God and no word of it changed.
Hence only one Quran is followed till this day.
And speaking of violence, for context:
Many surahs were revealed by God to Muhammed (S.A.W) at the times of war to warn him about the evil plans of the opponents and clear commands on what to do.
So obv they will contain stuff about violence.
Nothing in the Bible was discarded, only translated into multiple versions to help reach a broader audience. All of them hold the same meaning, same gospel, same message.
The point stays that there were no contradictions between all these authors, because the Holy Spirit spoke through them. The Bible isn't something you could possibly think up yourself, like the Quran, as you say.
Yet the Quran writes an extremely similar story as to the Bible, that's written by 40 different authors, with once again, no contradictions over all those years
If we were to even try to think of it logically, it would be far more reasonable to say the Quran isn't the word of God because it was written by one man alone, which can be even-more-so easily faked and changed
@@Evan-et3wf Yes its true that a word of a single man can be changed throughout history but hear me out..
the Quran was revealed little by little throughout the prophethood of Muhammed.
it was revealed at many places to which it was quickly written on items like, camels hide, leaves, stone etc.
now these written words were placed at a praying place for the public to learn it by heart and use it in there prayers.
so it became a cycle of memorizing the Quran word by word with no change.
Now when you say that Quran has same story laid out in it as the Bible, so let me tell one thing.
Our belief is that there are four Holy Books that were sent by God to certain prophets to preach the existence of God.
now The Bible (Injeel) is one of the holy books that was given to Jesus by God for the same purpose.
Quran hold the same purpose as the Bible.
God sending Jesus with the Bible for the jews.
then God sending Muhammad with the Quran to the pagan arabs.
Don't you think that an Author of a book would use same terminologies if the purpose of both works is same...?
Well, the Quran is a miracle
There was literally no witnesses giving Muhammad the quran
"They say, 'why has a sign not been sent down to him from his lord?' Say, ' The signs are only with Allah, and i am only a clear warner." u got the meaning all wrong bud it meant hell, or in other words prophet Muhammed was warning them ( the disbelievers ) from hell. and he wasn't talking about any signs or miracles, not even 1 bit. so find a better source and don't throw goofy insults towards something u don't even fully understand or didn't make sure of.
I just wanna say one thing
Facade of realism
Things that the unbelievers/atheists say COULD'VE happened
For example let's say i want to prove a scenario where I fought 10 people and won
I can go on to say mention details that make sense in mind but in reality it's impossible
like my opponents looked like they didn't get a wink of sleep in days,
We fought at the beach and my opponents don't have the same familiarity i had while fighting in the sand
And I cleverly used agility to dodge attacks and when they caught hold of me i tripped their balance, poked and threw sand in their eyes, few cheap shots to the groin and boom i won a 1 vs 10
All of that can be possible logically but think about it, is it really?
Christians: bUT mUhammad diDnt HavE anY mirACles
Jesus pbuh: “A wicked and adulterous generation seeks after a sign”
Jesus Christ actually told us to watch out for false prophets or 'antichrists'. But "SHUT UP AND ACCEPT WITHOUT QUESTION" is a very Islamic value :P
Muhammed had signs of demonic possession.
Christ Jesus showed authority over demons.
@@BongBing11 Yeah he told you to watch out for false prophets like Paul 😝. And in Islam you are encouraged to question the faith, the Quran encourages people to produce something better then it so I don’t know what you are on. But looking after miracles is something that is continuously frowned upon in your gospels. In the Parable of Lazarus and the Blind Man Abraham pbuh says “if they do not believe in Moses pbuh and the prophets then they will never believe even if a man rises from the dead” showing that people who demand miracles are never gonna listen even when given those miracles. Only those who observe the teachings and the Book sent down by God and believe in them have true faith. Those who seek out miracles are “wicked” and “adulterous”
@@mustafakhizar9799aren't we told to test the person by their fruits to judge according to God's word which moh contradicted? I don't seem to understand where your voice of Paul contradicted the gospels come from can you give evidence
@@mustafakhizar9799Paul tested his revaluations by going to the disciples like Peter ect thought and paul was not a prophet he just saw Jesus and converted. Early on it’s established by Tacitus and Josephus that Christianity was about Christ. Where is the evidence and claims that Jesus was Muslim before and outside the Quran.
This man is probably the best Christian propagandist I've seen yet
What does he personally gain from putting his time into this research? It is not propaganda it is teaching
@@richardkeck4918 He gains... advocacy for Christianity
Any somewhat educated Muslim will easily tell you that he is misrepresenting the hell out of the facts he presents
@@mortarman83095 I’ve read the Quran (in English, I don’t speak arabic) and have educated Muslim friends, and I feel like the facts are presented very accurately
@@richardkeck4918 respectfully, you're not a Muslim