Indigenous people are resilient people and the government should facilitate their way of living, like giving medical assistance periodically and perhaps requiere home schooling (keeping their native language and adding the national one) and definitely children must live with their parents. Gov should enrich the lives of the indigenous people.
...they can't live outside of society though...and that's what they do...but you close your eyes on purpose when it comes to domestic violence and sexual harassment as well as the children basically being forced to continue to live that way...not having a choice. It's very easy to keep language and the positive aspects of that culture alive. And it's very much a lie that they can't do under Russian government. They try to hide that they try to keep traditions alive that are criminal globally.
Sad 😢 . Leave the Indigenous people, they live a life of contentment and peaceful . Dont give empty promises of narcissistic modernlife in the cities..They only meet discrimination in employment.
I find you and your work very inspiring. For a long time I have followed you and your mom on youtube, and I can tell you are a very strong and courageous individual. The work you are doing to document these peoples lives, as well as speak out against your government is the catalyst for major change. Thank you!
So much gaslighting, like: such kind of injustice has happened not only in Russia. And so? It doesn’t mean that problems of these people should be ignored. They still don’t have any help and support. In other countries there are changes, some of them publicly apologized for their actions. Everything should be discussed and not ignored like it had never happened. A lot of indigenous people (I am too) struggle with the actions of Russian government. Have you heard the news that native languages might not be taught at school?!! The new educational program says native languages will be taught if there are some special facilities at school, only headmasters can decide, if those facilities are available. It feels like the Russian government tries to destroy us again. You have no idea how they tried to change the history of invading our territory, our ancestors. It wasn’t a mutual, beautiful act. At all.
Same With My People, The Native Americans! The Government Destroyed Our Life! They Starved Us By Killing All The Bison, They Killed Us With Diseases They Brought upon Us, They Took Over Our Lands That Gave Us Life Itself! They Forced Our Children To Attend Their "Religious Schools" Only To Be Sexually Assaulted & In Many Cases Murdered! To This Day Atroticities Still Happen To The Natives And Is Covered Up! It Is NEVER Good When Governments Interfere With Peoples Way Of Life! The Governments Try Their Best To Destroy Indigneous Cultures! 😤
Terrible! I must say that it is such a sad story. In fact these people should have been helped by the local administration to have everything they need, instead of leaving them to their sad fate! Great video, as usual. Thank you so much
...to have everything they need...but they don't contribute to the society - that should give them those things - at all. Not only this: they want to keep their misogynistic traditions alive. Want to keep sexual harassment, domestic violence and incest alive. And you westerners should be silent regarding terrible things - since to us you belong to those who murdered over 1 million innocent civilians in Iraq.
This morning in church, the priest spoke about how communists hate freedom. Bringing only death and destruction, wherever they trod. Watching your films I am always struck by how beautiful the people are from young to old. The way they move, the way they talk, The happiness of the children, their thoughts, their love and care for each other. These elements are missing and modern cities and in modern society. The suicide of the youth is so painful to bear. May God have mercy on us all. 🙏😢
Your priest is stupid. Communism for ordinary people. But the construction methods were wrong. Now the self-identity of peoples is being destroyed by capitalism, false democracy, multiculturalism, globalism. In Russia, small peoples lived, developed, and worked under communism. Now globalization is eating them up.
Nganasan people are best modern-day representatives of proto-Uralic people, almost living fossils if you could say so. Governments of Finland, Estonia and Hungary should help their brotherly people
I am sure they think they are educating them and then they will live a better life. But America did that and look what happened they destroyed their culture. We humans just can't seem to learn from our mistakes.
Not a fan of Russian government but its the same in Canada or the US or Brazil or the rest of the world indigenous is going away with or without the help of government.2000 the union is already gone and homeschooling is an option. So what exactly is the point here.
I don't believe you have many choices when ordered to do so ... from this side you wonder if a one room school house would be better than forced to be away from love ones and their invested nurturing that couldn't be possible at a boarding school....
Will you go back to shooting your own videos, as when you did those of your family etc. and the various things they did. Now you just edit someone else’s movies. For example your previous video about the Old Believers was originally an RT video. Come on guys do the right thing, don’t cheat like this!
...not mentioning the sexual harassment, domestic violence against women and children and the incestuous structures in such indigenous tribes here, are you. 😉
Indigenous people are resilient people and the government should facilitate their way of living, like giving medical assistance periodically and perhaps requiere home schooling (keeping their native language and adding the national one) and definitely children must live with their parents. Gov should enrich the lives of the indigenous people.
...they can't live outside of society though...and that's what they do...but you close your eyes on purpose when it comes to domestic violence and sexual harassment as well as the children basically being forced to continue to live that way...not having a choice. It's very easy to keep language and the positive aspects of that culture alive. And it's very much a lie that they can't do under Russian government. They try to hide that they try to keep traditions alive that are criminal globally.
We appreciate your effort and hard work. Keep making more great content.
Sad 😢 . Leave the Indigenous people, they live a life of contentment and peaceful . Dont give empty promises of narcissistic modernlife in the cities..They only meet discrimination in employment.
Its so sad for the children.... Thank you fore showing this sad situation...
I find you and your work very inspiring. For a long time I have followed you and your mom on youtube, and I can tell you are a very strong and courageous individual. The work you are doing to document these peoples lives, as well as speak out against your government is the catalyst for major change. Thank you!
Thanks to this wonderful channel for bringing us to a new world for the the person like who born in a tropical south east asia. ❤
So much gaslighting, like: such kind of injustice has happened not only in Russia. And so? It doesn’t mean that problems of these people should be ignored. They still don’t have any help and support. In other countries there are changes, some of them publicly apologized for their actions. Everything should be discussed and not ignored like it had never happened. A lot of indigenous people (I am too) struggle with the actions of Russian government. Have you heard the news that native languages might not be taught at school?!! The new educational program says native languages will be taught if there are some special facilities at school, only headmasters can decide, if those facilities are available. It feels like the Russian government tries to destroy us again. You have no idea how they tried to change the history of invading our territory, our ancestors. It wasn’t a mutual, beautiful act. At all.
Same With My People, The Native Americans! The Government Destroyed Our Life! They Starved Us By Killing All The Bison, They Killed Us With Diseases They Brought upon Us, They Took Over Our Lands That Gave Us Life Itself! They Forced Our Children To Attend Their "Religious Schools" Only To Be Sexually Assaulted & In Many Cases Murdered! To This Day Atroticities Still Happen To The Natives And Is Covered Up! It Is NEVER Good When Governments Interfere With Peoples Way Of Life! The Governments Try Their Best To Destroy Indigneous Cultures! 😤
Великорусский шовенизм, имперскость
All natives in US an etc come from tundra! They are all one! Russia use be connected to US. So they traveled from there.
Terrible! I must say that it is such a sad story. In fact these people should have been helped by the local administration to have everything they need, instead of leaving them to their sad fate! Great video, as usual. Thank you so much
...to have everything they need...but they don't contribute to the society - that should give them those things - at all. Not only this: they want to keep their misogynistic traditions alive. Want to keep sexual harassment, domestic violence and incest alive.
And you westerners should be silent regarding terrible things - since to us you belong to those who murdered over 1 million innocent civilians in Iraq.
Think you don't understand.
This morning in church, the priest spoke about how communists hate freedom. Bringing only death and destruction, wherever they trod. Watching your films I am always struck by how beautiful the people are from young to old. The way they move, the way they talk, The happiness of the children, their thoughts, their love and care for each other. These elements are missing and modern cities and in modern society. The suicide of the youth is so painful to bear. May God have mercy on us all. 🙏😢
Your priest is stupid. Communism for ordinary people. But the construction methods were wrong. Now the self-identity of peoples is being destroyed by capitalism, false democracy, multiculturalism, globalism. In Russia, small peoples lived, developed, and worked under communism. Now globalization is eating them up.
socialists**
Not only communist government. Common. What happened to the native Indians in the USA , the aborigines, and the Maori in Nz.
So America's not the only ones who destroyed indigenous people's lives.😢Makes me sad.
:( beautiful and strong people...... i wish them well from america
Great video! Thank you so much for sharing! 👍🏻♥️
Just come across this channel , am a new subscriber, 💪 great content here
Wow mind blowing Humm so similar in the US TOO .. 😮 .. changing... language.. ect
Its so sad, that the children are killing themselves.. I pray for them and the parents
Now globalization is eating them up.
Technology is killing us.
I love to watch your vlog and I want to learn how is there culture ❤❤❤
Thank you for sharing this.
I like your channel
قناة جميلة ❤👌👍
Nganasan people are best modern-day representatives of proto-Uralic people, almost living fossils if you could say so. Governments of Finland, Estonia and Hungary should help their brotherly people
What year was the video shot?
What's the reason for govt taking nomad kids to the town?
I am sure they think they are educating them and then they will live a better life. But America did that and look what happened they destroyed their culture. We humans just can't seem to learn from our mistakes.
❤❤❤
Hard workind woman and kids man 😢
HELLO ❤️
👍❤️🍀🙌
❤
😢
Not a fan of Russian government but its the same in Canada or the US or Brazil or the rest of the world indigenous is going away with or without the help of government.2000 the union is already gone and homeschooling is an option. So what exactly is the point here.
I don't believe you have many choices when ordered to do so ... from this side you wonder if a one room school house would be better than forced to be away from love ones and their invested nurturing that couldn't be possible at a boarding school....
💔🙏🏿
Hai i am from India
🤭❣️
Will you go back to shooting your own videos, as when you did those of your family etc. and the various things they did. Now you just edit someone else’s movies. For example your previous video about the Old Believers was originally an RT video. Come on guys do the right thing, don’t cheat like this!
Sovjets are not Russian government… same happens everywhere with indigenous people: Australia, Sweden and Norway, Brasil, Chile, South Africa …
...not mentioning the sexual harassment, domestic violence against women and children and the incestuous structures in such indigenous tribes here, are you. 😉