At least she is listening with patience and trying to understand the other point of view. Lots of other social science students r closed minded and do not even indulge the possibility of a different reasonable reality.Rajiv Malhotra is right.This is because of inferiority complex.
the kind of thought process & value system that India actually needs ... feels like a Swami Vivekananda incarnate listening to him ... he's definitely going to go down in history as a hero of every proud Indian
The question made me sick till my stomach. The person asking the question could be so sick in her thoughts trying to divide the society into castes. Look at the perfect answer that came. And this girl is going on arguing with her stupid arguments in layman terms trying to superimpose her communist and so called social science values on the Indian culture.
Manu was certainly sick trying to divide the society into castes-- and codify it! good thing we are finally beginning to look past his stupid arguments so many centuries later
Exactly. So stupid of her. Kancha Ilaiah is the pseudosecular conversion lobby supporter with anti-national agenda. Looks like she came here to whitewash him.
That's why never a wise man wanna miss a foolish question to understand them and enlightens them, but on contrast a foolish person wishes always to avoid a wise question. I hope that student can differentiate between a Wise Malhotra ji and a Foolish Kanche
Maha Rishi Valmiki wrote Ramayana (he is SC/ST according to today's classification), and everyone is fond of his pious work. Their is never a discrimination between celebrating performers and excellence. But, the girl is asking to propagate that work belong to a particular caste, which is wrong, we all are Indians, proud of our ancestors and proud of our motherland. UNITED WE STAND, DIVIDED WE FALL.
The Girl was so confused and probably trying to point out that Dalits are being oppressed by upper class.. We have to get over this idea of backward class/SC/ST and all sorts of non-sense. This can happen only when the conjuncture from both the sides. I cannot imagine that this highly educated girl bringing it up, She might feel she's representing them, but infact she's being critical about things and creating more animosity. I don't see much difference between this learned social scientist, a pseudo-secular (politcian trying to stir emotions of islamists) or a fanatic Hindu priest (A handful who exist in remote villages, who deny dalits entering temples citing them as lower caste) But, I atleast expect some sensibility in this generation youth, who are learned to be pro -collectivism, pro-nationalism rather than to cry about these atrocities in society, which is a by product of what Rajiv Ji explained about Herbert Risley (Lord Risley).
Rajivji had made logical points as always. Also, some people stupidly measure literacy in terms of English language skills. But even during slavery days, majority Indians were educated and literate in their own languages. In pre-slavery days one did not need to be a phd to do a job that gave them money. Even today, a fellow whose goal is to sell vegetables like his father, does not need a degree. As long as he can manage his own little business even if it is selling on streets, he is okay! In many cases their maths skills are better than the so-called educated. I have seen myself.
Rajiv malhotra ji has taught Indians a new way of thinking. A new way of observing the world. His personal anecdotes teach a lot about world and how it functions. He should atleast be given Padma Bushan or Padma ViBhusan for his contribution.
Wow, amazing job.. It is so true that we are being taught everything that is wrong with us. .Teaching us stuff To Make sure that we don't have any confidence with in ourselves to face the world when we will be clouded with self doubt.
I agree with MR Rajiv malhotra, Mr Dharma Defender I totally DISAGREE with your view. I believe Ambedkar DID A GREAT SERVICE to India.Reservation system created a middle class which doesnot recognize caste system and considers itself as HINDU and it was his HINDU CODE BILL that classifed ALL OF US AS HINDUS.Ambedkar was an upright person he didnot succumb to the pressure from the missionaries to convert to any other foreign relgion except Buddhism and i will admire him all my life for it.
Yashwant Mehta Need to learn more about atheism - did you ever hear of Ajivaks, Charvaka, Shramanas? They were atheists - like Buddha and Mahavira - did communism exist then?
Salutations for giving respect and also a befitting but a gentle answer to the would-be scholar if not a Sepoy of Breaking India Force. Poor Girl is the Victim of our educational system. What else can you expect from a slave of our educational system? She just did what she could to put up a brave look!!!, seldom realising braveness is to be inculcated in character and not for showing off. Poor Schooler is not even aware that Valmiki or Vyasa dealits as per her view are credited with Ramayana, YogaVasista (authored byValmiki) and Compiling of Vedas, Mahabaratha, Srimath Bagavatha and 18 puranas and classic book of the spritual Logic / Mimamsa Sastra BrahmaSutra (authored by Vyasa) and were given the respect of Mahrishis'. Read Periapuranam to know about the social hormony that prevailed in southern India before the invasion by Mugal's and British.
Arjit Ganguly do not compare him with swami Vivekananda. Vivekananda Nanda was a sage, a maharishi.. Yes Rajivji is fighting for a great cause and I support most of what he says ( though not all) but do not equate him with Vivekananda whose words echoed across the humanity whenever he spoke.. Vivekananda is on on the same level as Adi Shankaracharya...they are saints..
This problem of social science is deep rooted now in India, or we can call them as Mafia. JNU & DU is a centre for these narrow and close minded people.
Sir, your assesment is really indepth, logical and true. It should be the 1st lesson of our social studies in schools itself..... Does instead of "Social Science" the correct word is "Social Confusion" ...
1st da questioner didn't know about 'U tern Theory'. The lady said about Kancha Ailayya a motivated, infected, influenced western colonial activist who is dalit converted christian. He's hatred man towards Hindu Culture & Veda's. He accuses Shri Ram as killer, for killing their dalit veda preacher. He said he's working 4takeoff da Veda's from the country. Another dalit leader Katti Padma Rao ideology is same. Thus leads and comfortable point4Missionaries2convert dalit behalf their own way of it.
The thing is indians believed in passing knowledge systems to future generation, to them knowledge was a sacred thing and couldn't be owned by anybody. Best example of this indian mindset can be seen through Jagdish Chandra Bose who discovered Electro magnetic radiation and due to which today we are able to excess internet and global communications. But he never patented his discovery. Similarly whatever the inventions different communities of India did they were never credited just because we had a tradition to embrace the knowledge and not explorer of that knowledge.
Sir I am highly inspired by your thoughts and I strongly agree that colonization and mind mapping of so called scholars has greatly altered our hind originality BUT my concern is although we get an idea as to how things should have been kindly guide us and suggest us an actual action plan which can be practically implemented to bring back our old knowledge system and also to make our society immune to any further cultural attacks.
I think in our schools, the western 'moral science' books must immediately be changed with Indian Sanatan manner of 'society Ethics' where one can study Indian society but in Indian perspective and not with western malicious agenda. Also the subject names must be in pure Hindi and there must be one medium and standard of Indian education system as many mediums are causing chaos in respective mindsets. Also that any world university which do not recognize Indian diploma and degree, than we must not recognize their diploma and degree in India too. Today's moral science and history is like feeding your child with poison. Infact what todays history summorizes is not 'Who We Are' but its all about false glorifying congress which was highest distortation of mordern history. Moral Science must be ban and NCERT must be controlled by respected Rajiv Malhotra. And so there must be a compulsory NCC for everyone and these young children should be send to Army Camps and it must be compulsory. Than there must be compulsory apprentice for students of 9, 10, 11 and 12th, Diploma and Degree etc. There must be a government controlled hub under MR Malhotra where all private Indian companies must be listed which than train the youth. And it must be a credit system. Any student who is failed, must not be allowed further. And if anyone get failed continuously than he/she should pursue the same procedure but in private. The schools and colleges must be free overall in India. Teachers number must be cut out immensely. Only the teacher which pass the screening of intellect, IQ, Nationalism, Positiveness and psycho test just to refine weather one is a pervert in behavior or not. HR can prepare such test questions which Teachers needs to be filled while applying for jobs. An outstanding credits and experienced biodata must only be allowed to teach our youth. Besides, students must have to rate the Teacher at the end of each year which needs to be done by schools and institutions and colleges where student name and identity must be made hidden. And so the basis of a healthy and aware society can be made. And most obvious, the right history of our culture by our Indian historian particularly Mr Malhotra must be implemented immediately. Our history books needs immediate reforms. Our history is distorted under burdens, western malicious social abuse, pleasing foreigners and defaming natives, wrong facts and figures, wiping out a huge chunk of time period in BC, and many lies in our history book which has distorted our Indian youth with some west inferiority complex and with self guilt complex. History books misuse issues like social reforms, ill practises and caste system and human rights. All these things must be rewritten with truth, accuracy and these topics must be taken out. And we must introduce what wrong west have done in India, how they misused and propagate lie about caste system and Sanatan Dharam, how islam ruined Indian society. We Indians are ashamed to discuss the truth. But History must be truth and not what abrahamic religion preach, i.e, they preach to distort the history in the manner which suits their ideas and mindset to make looters and invaders as some kind of glorifying people. We need to teach how in the name of persians, the lie about Aryans were injected by western historians. Its time to tell the truth that there is no word like Aryan. In vedas, Ramayana and Mahabharata, its ARYA and they are out Kshatriya class of highly trained Warriors. Perhaps best in the world, with divine weapons which they got with thier Tapasya. We must own our Sanatan heritage which is the oldest and present it with truth rather than satisfying western interests. New history books must be immediately introduced in our syllabus. Infact both ancient and modern history knowledge and curent affairs must be mandatory for all Indian. This happens when same books are introduced in our market. Malicious people must be ban to publish wrong books and must be blacklisted. NCERT books are crap and its high time that a group of scholors like Mr Malhotra must redesign Indian syllabus which laid to the foundation to better future India. congree deliberately ruined Indian text books which was like a curse and they were put into their place by Indian. And I know that all the bad they did to India, they will never ever be able to make any comeback. Indian hate congress so much that Indian are blood-thirsty about congressi goons. Any government gets the mandate to shape the future of that country. congressi goons totally ruined it. Mr Modi Government must start new syllabus immediately. The chaos we see in jnu and such lost youth of today's generation is because of the fact that congress didn't carried Nationalism and Devotional messages through textbooks. Rather congress have ruined the history by their agents which stress less on 'Who We Are' but stress on distorting history to please foreign invaders and looters who lives in India by decades but with their foreign names which has nothing to do with native Sanatan ethics and practice. National Anthem must be made compulsory in every institutions. 15 August and 26 Jan must be celebrated in schools and colleges and attendance must be made compulsory. And those who do not bow their head in front of our Indian National Flag must be thrown out immediately and their names must be circulated as blacklist so that no government and private sector can ever give them a job. And like foreign countries, there must be a centralized Job center where all details of people doing jobs within India is stored. Job center must be geared up and must insure that no single youth is free. If someone is free that put him or hr in Tea stall to sell Tea. Our respected PM have proved that all work are same and you can always have a future if you are hardworking. One last thing, their must be absolute control of media as there are many anti Indian goons in Indian media and many anti Indian people are given a media platform to vomit venom against India. I think all information medium must be put into scrutiny and all those who are engaged in anti Indian activities must not only be blacklisted but RAW must butch them and their families. No license must be issued to anti Indian news channels. All news must be put into scrutiny before they went public by another government centralized agency. All this rule must be applied to anti Indian newspapers also. Beside, such anti Indian must be raid by income tax department and must be send behind the bars for lifetime. More youth oriented programs must be made rather than ektakapoor type crap retarded serials. I think information flow must come entirely under national security. I have noticed how Bollywood slowly turned into urdu. I have noticed how urdu is injected forcefully into Bollywood. I am totally against writing a movie name in urdu too. Any movie name in Bollywood must be strict in Hindi as its our national language and than in english as its so called international which is not even required. I think Bollywood songs must be written only in Hindi. I strongly think that Bollywood needs true nationalists which can show our oldest civilization, our native heros. Rather than celebrating looters, occupiers,invaders and foreigners. I think unlike congress,we must stop appeasing a particular section as it have make them retarded. Our native Hindu religion are Sanatan Dharam, Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism and we must only focus on our native religion, their scripts and their teachings. So foreign share be exactly the same what is Hindu share in foreign land. Simple.
Great point. A little correction, Hindi is not our national language. It is one of the official languages. It is has a privileged status in the sense it is used in conjunction with English by the Central Government. Otherwise, in comparison to most Indian languages, Hindi is a young language. Its forced imposition will not work, not cause of some foreign agenda. For Bollywood, it is okay. Anyways, Bollywood movies hardly display any originality of ideas or Indian-ness. It is a propaganda tool and a funding source for the likes of Dawoods.
Valid point on cast, old days much of brahmins wealthy people and rich people villages, right now what their position in villages, in old days caste value is depend on the importance and demand of their services given to society at that time.
Does not matter....we are proud to be Hindus and our brothers and Sisters from Sikhism, Buddhism and Jainism need to look ahead and stop the hating. We need to be proud and read the best of our culture
we owe all our major epic literature to Dalits.both Veda Vyasa who arranged entire Vedas as we know today and Valmiki who is the author of Ramayana were from tribal section of society.recent genetic study concluded thst intermarriage of various 'castes' could be conclusively said to have begun around 500a.G only.before that the genetics points to interested marriages being the norm.
Thank you so much for educating us through your videos and books! I am blessed with the knowledge on Indian civilisation and I am proud to know the truth about it.
We used positive discrimination which has discrimiated against education/careers prospects of many capable non SC/ST- it has been 30-40 years since reservation - by calling them OBC, SC/ST now we are showing them as someone who is lesser than others snd incapable - positive discrimination can only be temporary - a crutch is only a temporary respite to allow your legs to get strength again - you don’t expect to use crutch for life
The problem with this girl is that she did not even understood that rajivji documented the zinc knowledge that the so called down trodden. Rajivji... paramacharya's work are documented as voice of God. He has mentioned about sutrakaras like abastambar etc. It is clear from those points that the other caste were also involved in some parts of Brahman yagna
*caste-based discrimination in indigenous Indian schools?* 'In the indigenous vernacular schools, ‘parents of good caste do not hesitate to send their children to schools conducted by teachers of an inferior caste and even of a different religion. . . . this is true of the Chandal, and other low caste teachers enumerated.’ - William Adam, British Baptist Minister appointed by the colonial govt to do a census on native schools of Bengal, _Reports on the State of Education in Bengal 1835 and 1838_ page 228.
Well he's does have a point there. Our education system really has created a hidden sense of inferiority in us,this inferiority complex you would find getting subtler and stronger as and as we progress up the "intellectual" ladder
And I wondered it is among one of big serious issue.Shri Rajiv Sir caught at the Social Scientists are agents of Coloniel Society.Her act was like: "Hanumaan ke saamne khulati maarne jaisa vyavhaar tha". They have such a mentality can't accept or follow until their ideology master allow it, 'cos they foretold stories of discrimination n uses their education, knowledge 2mask it. In this lecture I understood da technologies and sectors will shifts and depends on demand competition and probability.
I can give few more examples of the so called "low caste people" being treated with utmost respect and they were doing pretty well! In north Indian traditional Hindu marriages, you always need a barber (Naai). Without him and his wife, your marriage cannot conclude! Similar is the case during funeral rituals. Those so called "low caste people" are treated with utmost respect. Also, in my village, our doctor was an Ironsmith (Lohaar). This Lohaar learnt medicine from his forefathers! This village primarily consisted of Brahmins whose main occupation was farming. Everyone used to consult this Lohaar during illness. Again this so called "lower caste" Lohaar was doing pretty well. Nowadays, all these lower caste people are not doing so well despite benefited by all the reservations and quota systems. They have left their family business. Many of them became lazy, couldn't compete, or looked for government jobs and forgot their family business, and ruined their and future generations lives. Lot of them believe that their misery is the fault of upper caste people!
is ladki ka asli problem yeh hai... agar koi aadmi kehta hai ki "a given technology originated in India". Then this girl has a problem with the word "India". She would rather have "a given technology was pioneered by lower caste people"
I don't know if there was any caste system present in history but what is quite clear that Post Independence there is a caste system which has been imposed through constitution by way of reservation, SC/ST Act. and many more such laws and so called general castes are continuously being suppressed, harassed, and abused.
Hindu India had saree clad female warriors Queens from Rani Laxmibai to Jhalkaribai to Kitturu Rani Chennamma to Rani Abbakka Chowta to Keladi Chennamma. These are countless such political figures, queens, workers, saints leaders in virtually all fields throughout history. When was the last time you had a women president of USA.
Wonderful points put forth by Mr. Malhotra based on his worldview. However, what is concerning is also the lock-in-knowledge mentality of the young students who are asking questions. They are strongly stuck in a worldview that looks at India from a very negative and emaciated perspective. Not having the courage to learn perspectives that challenge your intellectual compass is one of the sad outcomes of today's modern education.
82% of India is deeply religious and we have a long history of defending this country and its religious traditions with our blood and sinew and if need be it will be done again and again.
100 million visit Kumbh mela. 5 million a year visiting Sabarimala. A lakh to 2 lakh visitors to Tirupathi everyday. Sure Hinduism is waning. Poor poor dear Hindus.
cont.. The so called Brahmins were never rich. This is not disputed. Even now they are very poor. Look at the video on youtube by Francois Gautier called 'Brahmins have become a minority". But were they powerful? Yes & No! Some of them were powerful, some were not. Those who worked for kings & were aristocrats were obviously powerful. The vast majority even back then lived in mud huts & lived off donations struggling for a living. Why are they so hated then?
Indians are combative because they have a distorted version of what actual democracy is. Democracy in the West is understood with limits and rules and restrictions. In india they feel democracy is you can say whatever ver you want anywhere without the fact and truths
Social science as a field of study is separate from the natural sciences, which cover topics such as physics, biology, and chemistry. Social science examines the relationships between individuals and societies, as well as the development and operation of societies, rather than studying the physical world. These academic disciplines rely more heavily on interpretation and qualitative research methodologies.
social scientists seem to forget that entire Vedas n purana literature is attributed to a 'dalit' called Veda Vyasa.n Ramayana also written by another dalit called Valmiki.
forest lion Just to make a point, Veda Vyasa was born of daughter of a fisherman and Valmiki was a rogue in the earlier part of his life. Vedic system doesn't freeze one's status, one could easily improve his/her current status by taking to the right way as recommended by the Vedas.
Modern Surgery started in India where the britisher has his nose cut by freedom fighters and sewn back by our shoe makers. Credit should be given to Mochi .
Oh really ? What is it about Rajiv Malhotra's words that you consider Storytelling ? He presented facts of various kinds. Yet, you call it storytelling ? Rajiv is so right about the Colonised People of India. You are a fine example of that ...
Hindus have never had a problem with someone worshiping some god or not, hell we have the strangest sects from nagas to aghoris to all sort and that never bothered us. As long as they left us alone. Now the Church does not do that. It is the largest non-governmental land holder in India today. Care to explain how and why the Church needs so much land and what it intends to do with it.
problem is, she is too much invested in westernized education of india. Difficult for her to get out of the emotional delusion created by colonizers...
At least she is listening with patience and trying to understand the other point of view. Lots of other social science students r closed minded and do not even indulge the possibility of a different reasonable reality.Rajiv Malhotra is right.This is because of inferiority complex.
Sometimes I feel pity for the Indian students. They think they are learning a lot but in reality they are learning so little.
the kind of thought process & value system that India actually needs ... feels like a Swami Vivekananda incarnate listening to him ... he's definitely going to go down in history as a hero of every proud Indian
The question made me sick till my stomach. The person asking the question could be so sick in her thoughts trying to divide the society into castes. Look at the perfect answer that came. And this girl is going on arguing with her stupid arguments in layman terms trying to superimpose her communist and so called social science values on the Indian culture.
***** can u elaborate wt kind of thievery.and who said hinduism is all about vedas.
***** tere jaise log kisi ko nahi mante - sirf ideology ko follow karne ka natak karte hain - aur usi se roji roti kamate hain
40 pages 😂
Manu was certainly sick trying to divide the society into castes-- and codify it! good thing we are finally beginning to look past his stupid arguments so many centuries later
Exactly. So stupid of her. Kancha Ilaiah is the pseudosecular conversion lobby supporter with anti-national agenda. Looks like she came here to whitewash him.
Bruce Lee once said "A wise man can learn more from a foolish question than a fool can learn from a wise answer",
Hemendra Singh I always used to think the same... Ask the most cliche and stupid question to a wise man to get a good informative answer...
Thank you for making my day with the wise quote 🙏
That's why never a wise man wanna miss a foolish question to understand them and enlightens them, but on contrast a foolish person wishes always to avoid a wise question.
I hope that student can differentiate between a Wise Malhotra ji and a Foolish Kanche
babbal!
I was always deranged for asking such questions in my college. But, I never cease to ask even today in all walks of life
Maha Rishi Valmiki wrote Ramayana (he is SC/ST according to today's classification), and everyone is fond of his pious work. Their is never a discrimination between celebrating performers and excellence. But, the girl is asking to propagate that work belong to a particular caste, which is wrong, we all are Indians, proud of our ancestors and proud of our motherland. UNITED WE STAND, DIVIDED WE FALL.
The Girl was so confused and probably trying to point out that Dalits are being oppressed by upper class..
We have to get over this idea of backward class/SC/ST and all sorts of non-sense. This can happen only when the conjuncture from both the sides.
I cannot imagine that this highly educated girl bringing it up, She might feel she's representing them, but infact she's being critical about things and creating more animosity.
I don't see much difference between this learned social scientist, a pseudo-secular (politcian trying to stir emotions of islamists) or a fanatic Hindu priest (A handful who exist in remote villages, who deny dalits entering temples citing them as lower caste)
But, I atleast expect some sensibility in this generation youth, who are learned to be pro -collectivism, pro-nationalism rather than to cry about these atrocities in society, which is a by product of what Rajiv Ji explained about Herbert Risley (Lord Risley).
That girl can be the product of a convent school × pseudo secular teachers × leftist ideologyical institute(IITs)
She probably is intellectually deprived.
THAT GIRL AT IIT bcoz of SC/ST. quota that's why SHE HAS CHEAP MINDSET😂😂😂A CHEAP MINDSET NEVER BE A GREAT WHATEVER YOU WILL GIVE TO YOU😊😊😊
Ramayana was written & credited to Sage Valmiki who was a hunter.We have given him the highest position as"sage"
These liberals and SCs/STs need to get past their persecution complex.
Rajivji had made logical points as always. Also, some people stupidly measure literacy in terms of English language skills. But even during slavery days, majority Indians were educated and literate in their own languages. In pre-slavery days one did not need to be a phd to do a job that gave them money. Even today, a fellow whose goal is to sell vegetables like his father, does not need a degree. As long as he can manage his own little business even if it is selling on streets, he is okay! In many cases their maths skills are better than the so-called educated. I have seen myself.
'Vishwakarma' is the god of masons, carpenters, and others into various arts and crafts.
Yes i am carpenter by birth but i dont believe by quality...but we worship Vishwakarma.
we worship Vishwakarma too 🙂
Rajiv malhotra ji has taught Indians a new way of thinking. A new way of observing the world.
His personal anecdotes teach a lot about world and how it functions.
He should atleast be given Padma Bushan or Padma ViBhusan for his contribution.
I get goosebumps over my goosebumps. This man! He’s so articulate and knowledgeable 🙏🏻
What a great explanation......Proud Indian
Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant, If only we had more thinkers like Rajiv Malhotra in India, we wouldn't be in the state that we are in now.
truely agrees with you... we should be proud of our great civilization rather than westernizing ourself
Wow, amazing job.. It is so true that we are being taught everything that is wrong with us. .Teaching us stuff To Make sure that we don't have any confidence with in ourselves to face the world when we will be clouded with self doubt.
I agree with MR Rajiv malhotra,
Mr Dharma Defender I totally DISAGREE with your view.
I believe Ambedkar DID A GREAT SERVICE to India.Reservation system created a middle class which doesnot recognize caste system and considers itself as HINDU and it was his HINDU CODE BILL that classifed ALL OF US AS HINDUS.Ambedkar was an upright person he didnot succumb to the pressure from the missionaries to convert to any other foreign relgion except Buddhism and i will admire him all my life for it.
tibetan buddhism/athiesm is controlled by communism/athiesm . communism is controlled by the roman catholic church, JESUIT order.
Eric Phelps.
Yashwant Mehta Need to learn more about atheism - did you ever hear of Ajivaks, Charvaka, Shramanas? They were atheists - like Buddha and Mahavira - did communism exist then?
Amar Singh charvak is fake story.
Who want to bet that social scientist got admission in IITB through quota.
Merit and critical thinking chucked out the nearest window.
People without quota are responsible for mediocrity in Indian curriculum and academics
Salutations for giving respect and also a befitting but a gentle answer to the would-be scholar if not a Sepoy of Breaking India Force. Poor Girl is the Victim of our educational system. What else can you expect from a slave of our educational system? She just did what she could to put up a brave look!!!, seldom realising braveness is to be inculcated in character and not for showing off. Poor Schooler is not even aware that Valmiki or Vyasa dealits as per her view are credited with Ramayana, YogaVasista (authored byValmiki) and Compiling of Vedas, Mahabaratha, Srimath Bagavatha and 18 puranas and classic book of the spritual Logic / Mimamsa Sastra BrahmaSutra (authored by Vyasa) and were given the respect of Mahrishis'. Read Periapuranam to know about the social hormony that prevailed in southern India before the invasion by Mugal's and British.
great explanation to a pseudoknowledge girl
actually love this guy, swamy vivekananda reborn
sarvan thulasi
this is what happens when a rotten comments
Bhai is bande be kabhi Vivekananda's ki burai nahi ki.na hi ambedkar ki.
Arjit Ganguly do not compare him with swami Vivekananda.
Vivekananda Nanda was a sage, a maharishi..
Yes Rajivji is fighting for a great cause and I support most of what he says ( though not all) but do not equate him with Vivekananda whose words echoed across the humanity whenever he spoke..
Vivekananda is on on the same level as Adi Shankaracharya...they are saints..
@@premprasad3511 can u please put some light on those point u dont like of his points...!!
You want to know India perfectly ,u'v to read Vivekananda .there is all saluation for india to progress
This problem of social science is deep rooted now in India, or we can call them as Mafia.
JNU & DU is a centre for these narrow and close minded people.
The moment she says Kancha illiah, I know who she is....
Sir, your assesment is really indepth, logical and true. It should be the 1st lesson of our social studies in schools itself.....
Does instead of "Social Science" the correct word is "Social Confusion" ...
Mr. Rajiv has a very clear mind on this issue and he has explained it so simply.
His books must be incorporated into Indian History curriculum. Such intelligent and profound person that he is. Rajiv ji is indeed a great scholar
Its a privilege to listen to Mr. Malhotra!
1st da questioner didn't know about 'U tern Theory'. The lady said about Kancha Ailayya a motivated, infected, influenced western colonial activist who is dalit converted christian. He's hatred man towards Hindu Culture & Veda's. He accuses Shri Ram as killer, for killing their dalit veda preacher. He said he's working 4takeoff da Veda's from the country. Another dalit leader Katti Padma Rao ideology is same. Thus leads and comfortable point4Missionaries2convert dalit behalf their own way of it.
The thing is indians believed in passing knowledge systems to future generation, to them knowledge was a sacred thing and couldn't be owned by anybody.
Best example of this indian mindset can be seen through Jagdish Chandra Bose who discovered Electro magnetic radiation and due to which today we are able to excess internet and global communications.
But he never patented his discovery.
Similarly whatever the inventions different communities of India did they were never credited just because we had a tradition to embrace the knowledge and not explorer of that knowledge.
Sir I am highly inspired by your thoughts and I strongly agree that colonization and mind mapping of so called scholars has greatly altered our hind originality BUT my concern is although we get an idea as to how things should have been kindly guide us and suggest us an actual action plan which can be practically implemented to bring back our old knowledge system and also to make our society immune to any further cultural attacks.
I think in our schools, the western 'moral science' books must immediately be changed with Indian Sanatan manner of 'society Ethics' where one can study Indian society but in Indian perspective and not with western malicious agenda. Also the subject names must be in pure Hindi and there must be one medium and standard of Indian education system as many mediums are causing chaos in respective mindsets. Also that any world university which do not recognize Indian diploma and degree, than we must not recognize their diploma and degree in India too. Today's moral science and history is like feeding your child with poison. Infact what todays history summorizes is not 'Who We Are' but its all about false glorifying congress which was highest distortation of mordern history. Moral Science must be ban and NCERT must be controlled by respected Rajiv Malhotra. And so there must be a compulsory NCC for everyone and these young children should be send to Army Camps and it must be compulsory. Than there must be compulsory apprentice for students of 9, 10, 11 and 12th, Diploma and Degree etc. There must be a government controlled hub under MR Malhotra where all private Indian companies must be listed which than train the youth. And it must be a credit system. Any student who is failed, must not be allowed further. And if anyone get failed continuously than he/she should pursue the same procedure but in private. The schools and colleges must be free overall in India. Teachers number must be cut out immensely. Only the teacher which pass the screening of intellect, IQ, Nationalism, Positiveness and psycho test just to refine weather one is a pervert in behavior or not. HR can prepare such test questions which Teachers needs to be filled while applying for jobs. An outstanding credits and experienced biodata must only be allowed to teach our youth. Besides, students must have to rate the Teacher at the end of each year which needs to be done by schools and institutions and colleges where student name and identity must be made hidden. And so the basis of a healthy and aware society can be made. And most obvious, the right history of our culture by our Indian historian particularly Mr Malhotra must be implemented immediately. Our history books needs immediate reforms. Our history is distorted under burdens, western malicious social abuse, pleasing foreigners and defaming natives, wrong facts and figures, wiping out a huge chunk of time period in BC, and many lies in our history book which has distorted our Indian youth with some west inferiority complex and with self guilt complex. History books misuse issues like social reforms, ill practises and caste system and human rights. All these things must be rewritten with truth, accuracy and these topics must be taken out. And we must introduce what wrong west have done in India, how they misused and propagate lie about caste system and Sanatan Dharam, how islam ruined Indian society. We Indians are ashamed to discuss the truth. But History must be truth and not what abrahamic religion preach, i.e, they preach to distort the history in the manner which suits their ideas and mindset to make looters and invaders as some kind of glorifying people. We need to teach how in the name of persians, the lie about Aryans were injected by western historians. Its time to tell the truth that there is no word like Aryan. In vedas, Ramayana and Mahabharata, its ARYA and they are out Kshatriya class of highly trained Warriors. Perhaps best in the world, with divine weapons which they got with thier Tapasya. We must own our Sanatan heritage which is the oldest and present it with truth rather than satisfying western interests. New history books must be immediately introduced in our syllabus. Infact both ancient and modern history knowledge and curent affairs must be mandatory for all Indian. This happens when same books are introduced in our market. Malicious people must be ban to publish wrong books and must be blacklisted. NCERT books are crap and its high time that a group of scholors like Mr Malhotra must redesign Indian syllabus which laid to the foundation to better future India. congree deliberately ruined Indian text books which was like a curse and they were put into their place by Indian. And I know that all the bad they did to India, they will never ever be able to make any comeback. Indian hate congress so much that Indian are blood-thirsty about congressi goons. Any government gets the mandate to shape the future of that country. congressi goons totally ruined it. Mr Modi Government must start new syllabus immediately. The chaos we see in jnu and such lost youth of today's generation is because of the fact that congress didn't carried Nationalism and Devotional messages through textbooks. Rather congress have ruined the history by their agents which stress less on 'Who We Are' but stress on distorting history to please foreign invaders and looters who lives in India by decades but with their foreign names which has nothing to do with native Sanatan ethics and practice. National Anthem must be made compulsory in every institutions. 15 August and 26 Jan must be celebrated in schools and colleges and attendance must be made compulsory. And those who do not bow their head in front of our Indian National Flag must be thrown out immediately and their names must be circulated as blacklist so that no government and private sector can ever give them a job. And like foreign countries, there must be a centralized Job center where all details of people doing jobs within India is stored. Job center must be geared up and must insure that no single youth is free. If someone is free that put him or hr in Tea stall to sell Tea. Our respected PM have proved that all work are same and you can always have a future if you are hardworking. One last thing, their must be absolute control of media as there are many anti Indian goons in Indian media and many anti Indian people are given a media platform to vomit venom against India. I think all information medium must be put into scrutiny and all those who are engaged in anti Indian activities must not only be blacklisted but RAW must butch them and their families. No license must be issued to anti Indian news channels. All news must be put into scrutiny before they went public by another government centralized agency. All this rule must be applied to anti Indian newspapers also. Beside, such anti Indian must be raid by income tax department and must be send behind the bars for lifetime. More youth oriented programs must be made rather than ektakapoor type crap retarded serials. I think information flow must come entirely under national security. I have noticed how Bollywood slowly turned into urdu. I have noticed how urdu is injected forcefully into Bollywood. I am totally against writing a movie name in urdu too. Any movie name in Bollywood must be strict in Hindi as its our national language and than in english as its so called international which is not even required. I think Bollywood songs must be written only in Hindi. I strongly think that Bollywood needs true nationalists which can show our oldest civilization, our native heros. Rather than celebrating looters, occupiers,invaders and foreigners. I think unlike congress,we must stop appeasing a particular section as it have make them retarded. Our native Hindu religion are Sanatan Dharam, Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism and we must only focus on our native religion, their scripts and their teachings. So foreign share be exactly the same what is Hindu share in foreign land. Simple.
Great point. A little correction, Hindi is not our national language. It is one of the official languages. It is has a privileged status in the sense it is used in conjunction with English by the Central Government. Otherwise, in comparison to most Indian languages, Hindi is a young language. Its forced imposition will not work, not cause of some foreign agenda. For Bollywood, it is okay. Anyways, Bollywood movies hardly display any originality of ideas or Indian-ness. It is a propaganda tool and a funding source for the likes of Dawoods.
@@RKB192000 yes, i agree with you
Valid point on cast, old days much of brahmins wealthy people and rich people villages, right now what their position in villages, in old days caste value is depend on the importance and demand of their services given to society at that time.
Excellent Excellent Excellent ....what to say other than this
I pledge to gain knowledge and read about India through Rajeev jis lense and his books and if possible will carry forward this baton.
Does not matter....we are proud to be Hindus and our brothers and Sisters from Sikhism, Buddhism and Jainism need to look ahead and stop the hating. We need to be proud and read the best of our culture
Indian guys carry a huge baggage of guilt. 👏👏🙏🙏
If I could donate my life to this man! मैं आपके अभियान से जरूर जुडूंगा।
Wonder there are people who disliked it...
He predicted the "Fascist" part so accurately *7 years ago* !
we owe all our major epic literature to Dalits.both Veda Vyasa who arranged entire Vedas as we know today and Valmiki who is the author of Ramayana were from tribal section of society.recent genetic study concluded thst intermarriage of various 'castes' could be conclusively said to have begun around 500a.G only.before that the genetics points to interested marriages being the norm.
Rajiv ji I am so proud of you
spacelion There was no word like Dalit 200 yrs back.
excellent view by rajiv ji
Thank you so much for educating us through your videos and books! I am blessed with the knowledge on Indian civilisation and I am proud to know the truth about it.
they always start with an explanation of their viewpoint.. and then ask the question.. is not asking a question directly part of our culture?
Maybe it is. We always like to share a lot of knowledge. So that kinda creeps in during our questions.
We used positive discrimination which has discrimiated against education/careers prospects of many capable non SC/ST- it has been 30-40 years since reservation - by calling them OBC, SC/ST now we are showing them as someone who is lesser than others snd incapable - positive discrimination can only be temporary - a crutch is only a temporary respite to allow your legs to get strength again - you don’t expect to use crutch for life
The problem with this girl is that she did not even understood that rajivji documented the zinc knowledge that the so called down trodden. Rajivji... paramacharya's work are documented as voice of God. He has mentioned about sutrakaras like abastambar etc. It is clear from those points that the other caste were also involved in some parts of Brahman yagna
Well explained Rajiv ji 🙏🏼
brilliant response ji ... my sincere request please do more Q and A's in india and upload it on youtube ...
India has great culture and sciencebe proud of being Indian.
Thank you Sir. :)
Why kancha illeya is considered representative of all SC, st and obc
*caste-based discrimination in indigenous Indian schools?* 'In the indigenous vernacular schools, ‘parents of good caste do not hesitate to send their children to schools conducted by teachers of an inferior caste and even of a different religion. . . . this is true of the Chandal, and other low caste teachers enumerated.’ - William Adam, British Baptist Minister appointed by the colonial govt to do a census on native schools of Bengal, _Reports on the State
of Education in Bengal 1835 and 1838_ page 228.
Amazing research and knowledge of Rajiv Malhotra...
Well he's does have a point there. Our education system really has created a hidden sense of inferiority in us,this inferiority complex you would find getting subtler and stronger as and as we progress up the "intellectual" ladder
And I wondered it is among one of big serious issue.Shri Rajiv Sir caught at the Social Scientists are agents of Coloniel Society.Her act was like: "Hanumaan ke saamne khulati maarne jaisa vyavhaar tha". They have such a mentality can't accept or follow until their ideology master allow it, 'cos they foretold stories of discrimination n uses their education, knowledge 2mask it. In this lecture I understood da technologies and sectors will shifts and depends on demand competition and probability.
I can give few more examples of the so called "low caste people" being treated with utmost respect and they were doing pretty well!
In north Indian traditional Hindu marriages, you always need a barber (Naai). Without him and his wife, your marriage cannot conclude! Similar is the case during funeral rituals. Those so called "low caste people" are treated with utmost respect.
Also, in my village, our doctor was an Ironsmith (Lohaar). This Lohaar learnt medicine from his forefathers! This village primarily consisted of Brahmins whose main occupation was farming. Everyone used to consult this Lohaar during illness. Again this so called "lower caste" Lohaar was doing pretty well.
Nowadays, all these lower caste people are not doing so well despite benefited by all the reservations and quota systems. They have left their family business. Many of them became lazy, couldn't compete, or looked for government jobs and forgot their family business, and ruined their and future generations lives. Lot of them believe that their misery is the fault of upper caste people!
Shrikant Talageri is in the audience. Wow!
Getting tears, you so clearly exposing deep rooted Indian complexes.
Amazing knowledge this man has. I hope to learn everything from him.
is ladki ka asli problem yeh hai...
agar koi aadmi kehta hai ki "a given technology originated in India". Then this girl has a problem with the word "India". She would rather have "a given technology was pioneered by lower caste people"
You are the light bearer sir. Respect. Pranam
Great explanation sir!
राजीव जी नमस्ते 🙏
चरण स्पर्श
Really a great explanation to the sceptic Indian with huge inferiority complex🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I don't know if there was any caste system present in history but what is quite clear that Post Independence there is a caste system which has been imposed through constitution by way of reservation, SC/ST Act. and many more such laws and so called general castes are continuously being suppressed, harassed, and abused.
Hindu India had saree clad female warriors Queens from Rani Laxmibai to Jhalkaribai to Kitturu Rani Chennamma to Rani Abbakka Chowta to Keladi Chennamma. These are countless such political figures, queens, workers, saints leaders in virtually all fields throughout history. When was the last time you had a women president of USA.
On point.. Very good to hear this
THE GIRL HAS SLAVERY IN HER GENES, BLOOD, FLESH & BRAIN EVERYWHERE THIS IS THE FUTURE OF INDIA SLAVERY
Would love to see the video of the whole meeting. Great job sir...
Wonderful points put forth by Mr. Malhotra based on his worldview. However, what is concerning is also the lock-in-knowledge mentality of the young students who are asking questions. They are strongly stuck in a worldview that looks at India from a very negative and emaciated perspective. Not having the courage to learn perspectives that challenge your intellectual compass is one of the sad outcomes of today's modern education.
Brilliant analysis! .
The words social and scientist do not belong in the same scientist.
Very well said Sri Malhotra
the last shown table in the video is well explained by the speaker
Knowledge people have many questions!!!!! and many of them just talk and think..
Rajiv Malhotra is Super Son Of India.
82% of India is deeply religious and we have a long history of defending this country and its religious traditions with our blood and sinew and if need be it will be done again and again.
Social Scientist 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Social has nothing to do with science. Those illiterate social studies and humanities studens are joke.
Great explanations Sir
100 million visit Kumbh mela. 5 million a year visiting Sabarimala. A lakh to 2 lakh visitors to Tirupathi everyday. Sure Hinduism is waning. Poor poor dear Hindus.
cont.. The so called Brahmins were never rich. This is not disputed. Even now they are very poor. Look at the video on youtube by Francois Gautier called 'Brahmins have become a minority". But were they powerful?
Yes & No! Some of them were powerful, some were not. Those who worked for kings & were aristocrats were obviously powerful. The vast majority even back then lived in mud huts & lived off donations struggling for a living.
Why are they so hated then?
His persistence is amazing
Indians are combative because they have a distorted version of what actual democracy is.
Democracy in the West is understood with limits and rules and restrictions.
In india they feel democracy is you can say whatever ver you want anywhere without the fact and truths
Social science as a field of study is separate from the natural sciences, which cover topics such as physics, biology, and chemistry. Social science examines the relationships between individuals and societies, as well as the development and operation of societies, rather than studying the physical world. These academic disciplines rely more heavily on interpretation and qualitative research methodologies.
Abolish use of words caste system by law. This lady is confused about it. Speaker is knowlegeable. Will certainly read those books.
social scientists seem to forget that entire Vedas n purana literature is attributed to a 'dalit' called Veda Vyasa.n Ramayana also written by another dalit called Valmiki.
forest lion Just to make a point, Veda Vyasa was born of daughter of a fisherman and Valmiki was a rogue in the earlier part of his life.
Vedic system doesn't freeze one's status, one could easily improve his/her current status by taking to the right way as recommended by the Vedas.
Rajiv Malhotra sir... Respect..._/\_
I thought RM was a serious chaap
Dudes this was hilarious
shri. RM
hats off
since hats off is western
then I offer my pranaams to Shri RM
Modern Surgery started in India where the britisher has his nose cut by freedom fighters and sewn back by our shoe makers. Credit should be given to Mochi .
the young lady is a clear thinker, the malhotra is a storyteller without substance. a hotairproducer.
Oh really ? What is it about Rajiv Malhotra's words that you consider Storytelling ? He presented facts of various kinds. Yet, you call it storytelling ? Rajiv is so right about the Colonised People of India. You are a fine example of that ...
Why the leftist person when loose their arguments they suddenly became angry ? Jade khokhli hai unki.
Jai Shree Ram 💪🏼🚩
Hindus have never had a problem with someone worshiping some god or not, hell we have the strangest sects from nagas to aghoris to all sort and that never bothered us. As long as they left us alone. Now the Church does not do that. It is the largest non-governmental land holder in India today. Care to explain how and why the Church needs so much land and what it intends to do with it.
problem is, she is too much invested in westernized education of india. Difficult for her to get out of the emotional delusion created by colonizers...
Sir, need a book from you for children of India. Please
Well said...
I'LL NEVER PUT MY FUTURE KIDS IN ANY SCHOOL BCOZ INDIAN EDUCATION SYSTEM IS FULL OF SHIT
Damn! That was brutal
Lol she asks him to refer to kancha illiah hahaha
Sir you are the best