Murdaugh Podcast 48: Bad Day for Murdaugh in Retrial Bid
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 жов 2024
- Anne Emerson, Charlie Condon and Drew Tripp recap an important day in court ahead of Alex Murdaugh's upcoming evidentiary hearing on controversial jury tampering allegations.
Alex Murdaugh's defense team entered the ring throwing haymakers in a pre-hearing status conference on January 16th, hoping to bludgeon open a clear path to a retrial in Murdaugh's murder case. But retired South Carolina Supreme Court Chief Justice Jean Toal, the newly appointed judge on the case, parried and rebuffed Murdaugh's ambitious volleys in stunning and decisive fashion. Now Murdaugh's opening to land the decisive blow against his dual murder convictions and life sentence appears vanishingly small.
Read more: abcnews4.com/n...
#alexmurdaugh #truecrime #murdaughmurders #podcast #southcarolina #charleston #truecrimepodcasts #truecrime #legalpodcast #lawpodcast #law #crime #crimenews2024
____________________
ABC News 4 (WCIV-TV) covers local news, weather, sports and more in the Charleston, South Carolina metro area and surrounding communities.
Website - abcnews4.com
Facebook - / abcnews4
Twitter - / abcnews4
Instagram - / abcnews4
Download our iOS Apps:
News - apps.apple.com...
Weather - apps.apple.com...
Download our Android Apps:
News - play.google.co...
Weather - play.google.co...
Submit news tips: desk@wciv.com
Submit photo/video: abcnews4.com/c...
The Jury got it right. Ole Becky Hill didn’t need to taint the jury. Lol and judge sees through it all.
Yes, pooty was put in his place right away..I love it! He loves to grandstand and ramble on, and obnoxious. He thinks too much of himself. Thinks he a great orator. In my view he's a big bag of wind. Good discussion. Ty
You guys seem like you feel sorry for team Murdaugh. I don’t believe he will be granted a retrial, and frankly I don’t think he deserves it. He was given a fair trial and was found guilty by all 12 jurors in short order. Justice Toal is handling based on law, not based on the public opinion or the manipulation of the defense team. They have played the game, and I believe they will lose big! Y’all were one of my favorites during the trial, but somewhere y’all have changed teams. Alex Murdaugh is a convicted double murderer and a self proclaimed and convicted thief!!!! He doesn’t deserve your sympathy, he is exactly where he belongs!
They don’t
AM a pos his entire life and now the world knows it!!
Yes and his financial crimes are a life sentence anyway … so what’s his point
Valerie totally agree now dig into AM’s daddy if you wanna expose the real rot. I think revealing the contents of his estate will ups be an eye opener. Kinda like a mini version of a poor elected official going to DC and leaving a multimillionaire ..
Open court helps South Carolina citizens to believe in justice a little more. This case has presented the rich and powerful as being able to get away with breaking laws.
He's still being treated "special". Would an ordinary person get this level of defense?
💯
I ALWAYS appreciate this-thank you so much for showing up with your great discussion!
No jury trial would stand up to this amount of scrutiny.
All this boils down to is 🥚juror is mad she was dismissed from jury. AM’s attorneys don’t care about these jurors, this is about punishment for them convicting. IMO which i know not everyone agrees
Exactly. AM & his attorneys are as arrogant, controlling & manipulative as he is. Losing to them is not in their wheelhouse, especially the high & mighty Harpo.
Why was egg lady dismissed from the jury in the first place?
She was dismissed for talking about the trial with others before deliberations.@@debbie2520
and that was the egg lady sitting behind the white haired lawyer, ''her lawyer'' and when he got up to speak the judge clipped his wings too..lol..
OHHH that's funny 🤣didn't know that. That attorney is behind this whole Becky Hill chaos too with of course the Murdaugh troop from before the trial started. They set her up perfectly to be the fall girl & she fell for it. Imo@@yelaineq1
Alex Murdaugh should be in prison for the rest of his life-, or worse, for what he has done. I certainly hope that his lawyers don't finagle his way out of that. The damage and evil he has done is incalculable.
Wonder why his lawyers are so proud to represent Alex?Seems like there are a lot of people that doesn't feel that way about all of the hurt and harm that has been caused down through the years! So much heartache and heartbreak❤😢
Why? To keep the ‘protected class’ protected.. that’s why. Imagine if ‘the people’ demanded accountability of the corrupt systems (everywhere), that Murdaugh trial/ crimes have exposed. Hmmm
@@irisramsey62 There was a lot of publicity for the defense attorneys involved in the case. To the extent that they're now known on a national level. I'd imagine keeping this saga going is of some benefit to their law practice and/or political career. That might be the motivation if Alex Murdaugh can no longer afford their services.
I do agree there isn't much to be proud of in representing a man who stole from vunerable clients, friends, colleagues & even his own brother. And then what he did to his wife & son. I understand that's it's part of a defense attorney's job to advocate for & defend the client. Being vocally proud to do so says a lot about their character or the lack thereof. The defense attorneys aren't stupid. They saw the evidence & understood exactly what, or I should say who it implicated.
This silliness will continue until AM’s buried $$$$$ runs out!!
Everything went wrong for Alex, but right for South Carolina.
I enjoy your show! I would like to give some constructive feedback! It is incredibly distracting, with one of you sitting off to the side, while the other two are behind and to the left. Can you get a table for all 3 of you? Interesting talking points! Thank you!
thats a really good idea
I was so relieved to see the judge take the road she did … Murdaughs audacity is unbelievable
Defense attorneys are not very likable, especially Dick, who comes across as extremely mean-spirited.
He does seem like a nasty piece of work. And the grandstanding seemed to totally backfire with the judge.
he's one of the snobbyest people you could ever know.. he's only nice to clients.
Judge Hunter Carroll from Florida did the process the same way. He laid out what he wanted from defense and plaintiff. What areas of questioning of the juror HE would ask, then if further review was necessary, he took the questions provided by Attorneys on both sides if any, and did his hearing process exactly as he should have. So, I dont understand why everyone seems to be shocked. This is NOT a trial and Becky Hill is the defendant, this is what happened DURING the trial and DID it affect the Deliberating Jurors verdict if any . She was amazing i thought.
I thought the exact same thing having watched the Maya trial and then later the juror questioning. I heard a lawyer on another show say that it was unheard of to have the judge ask Q’s and not the attorney. This obviously does occur.
Judge Toal is the best, most experienced, no-nonsense Judge to take charge of this matter. ⚖️☮️
Why..is a state senator his lawyer?? An Acting state senator? He should resign and stop collecting the tax payers money if he choose to do so
SC state senator's only get paid $10,400/yr so the state has to change their system entirely to fix this issue.
@@nancyh9030 try $174,000 / yr.
source: Senate.gov
I can't agree with you more; first, if I was his constituent, I would be pissed at his lack of morality, and second, I would be pissed that he isn't addressing state issues but rather trying to get a murderer off while pocketing a ton of $$.
Thank you Anne, Drew, and Charlie. I enjoy your discussions and respect you all.
You're at the top of my "legal-ise" podcast, who better to include than the former AG for SC?
I love it when you can get Charlie to laugh, ie 1) throwing cell phones per expert witness at trial, 2) what is Crimecon? Etc 😊
I'm praying the executive producer gets help for his health problems.
Can you pray without bragging it off ?
"KUDOS to the new judge with "sound mind" (she isn't in to any circus events!) Straight forward with the actual truth for a refreshing change!!
this new judge that is hearing this case is doing two things, trying to find the truth without it being a circus and protecting the jurors from being harassed by lawyers, who should know better, but their pride won’t stop them
Exactly, I think Drew said this...a guilty verdict wasn't going to increase the sales of Becky's book; in fact, IMO, a not guilty verdict may have gotten even more book sales. 😊
I’ve been waiting for tor these panel to review the murdaugh hearing,Finally
Well, if you block out all the noise (he said / she said Becky ,Becky ,Becky )then you have to admit the Jurors should have brought these comments to light at time of trial .To me, after you have verified that's your verdict , you look foolish coming BK and claiming misconduct. I mean come on this Judge is absolutely spot on with this witch hunt. Prove this tampering or you are wasting courts time and money. She sees the arrogance of Dick Harpootlian and his theatrics have no place in her court. Love her professionalism and rule of law. It's about time someone in higher court puts a stop to Murdaugh and his manipulation of the judicial system.He is guilty of these murders.
I agree with Charlie Condon. I want to hear the witnesses testify in court under oath. Mistakes can be made in affidavits.
One has to wonder whether Joe McCulloch’s obvious ties to Harpootlian could taint his preparation of his client regarding the question of being influenced. Of course, the same could be said of the attorneys who have publicly applauded the guilty verdict and represent other jurors.
Who was paying Joe to sit through the trial?and for what purpose? I'm betting his job was only to find appeal material
Juror 630 will be contracting his/her affidavit if he/she suddenly says Ms becky influrnced him/her. He/she went in the deliberation with a NG opinion - thats why the other jurors made him/her change his/her verdict.
Drew, you are so right, it makes no sense that Becky wanted guilty verdict to write book.
Oh, you got your information from Reddit just like the rest of them, reliable source I’ve heard that in another trial recently
The only jurors that should be questioned is the ones that deliberated.
Great presentation
Another great Podcast. Anne you look GORGEOUS! Thank you Charlie, Anne, Drew and Crew.
Becky Hill needs to be moved off post via public vote
Alex has got to have sooooooo much dirt on those two lawyer
Not unless they know where the money is buried
Reporters can't even say his name right. It's "AleX mur-daw" not "Alek mur-dock". Am I right?
He refers himself as alek and all his friends and family calls him alek and it started since he was young
Pronounced “ Elleck”
Good information. All 3 are knowledgeable. Drew Tripp is hard to follow. He staggers and stutters which is his lack of confidence committing to an opinion. But it’s hard to be patient to listen to.
If Becky Hill can screw around with the jury without consequences, then why even have these rules and standards?
and if killers can get by with murder, why have jails
@@yelaineq1 nice non sequitur there
I think we found where Alec might have hidden his money
Like nailing jello to a tree.
Justice Toal bullied juror Z, intimidated her and asked her leading questions and manipulated juror Z to say Justice Toals predetermined outcome of the inquiry hearing.
SO LET IT BE 😊
Going straight down the "hill". Hahaha no pun? 😊
Why these guys have to use so many analogies?
It would not make sense for juror 630 (defense witness) to say that Becky Hill influenced his/her decision while also claiming that the other jurors forced him/her to vote guilty. Where is the outside influence ? When he/she came in there having a NG mind. This is just defense trying to hit a bird with a straw and some bobba pearls.
If a tour is willing to change his verdict after he cast his verdict, and use that as an excuse, then he should be more than willing without any reprehensive get up and state it openly in court
You three are sitting in such strange positions.
The producer or what ever he does should stay behind the scenes he’s annoying let experienced on camera people do the talking
The state doesn't want to spend all that money again just to have a jury find him guilty. Waste of money and time. But everyone deserves a fair trial. Even Alex M.
What money? Murdaugh didn't have any money left that I know of ( which is very little by the way). He was stealing his clients money for his drug habits.
oh, I shouldn’t have mentioned it because you know it might not be true, but let me just throw it out there to see if I can destroy a judge before trial even starts really Mr. lawyer you need to step down yourself if that’s the best you know how to do. You didn’t go verify for the truth before you opened your mouthto try to destroy another human being
loved how this judge put pooty in his place several different times🥴. he honestly thinks he is someone we all need to bow to.. and how about the egg lady👿 and another woman sitting there behind the white haired lawyer that is her attorney.. lol.. and this attorney also got his wings clipped by this judge..
You could see the embarrassment in those lawyers that defended him they knew he did it yet they can sit there and support his lies, they are almost as bad as him
A miraculous you had a memory of something that happened years ago because somebody supported somebody else really will you bunch of idiots grow up. We all run for something in our life. Somebody’s gonna win somebody’s gonna lose just like an sport you’re not supposed to hold onto it forever, Mr. lawyer or maybe you do but the rest of the world grows up and gets over it so we don’t try to look up things that are multiple years back saying he might’ve hurt my feelings. I didn’t get what I want.
Bad wig
What's wrong with her Head bobblehead.
No one is above the law, not even the clerk . With such a high profile case, she should have been even more professional.
My goodness news will happen -no worries. Come on ,every one convicted goes on their way!!
That new judge is a woman?
The timeliness of the finding of alleged jury tampering was preserved by prosecution for later appeal.
It may not have influenced the outcome but ANY unlawful actions at all demands a retrial. He will be found guilty. Finding a jury with zero info in their knowledge base will be impossible. They will call for a change of venue etc…
I’m sorry but this guy is difficult to listen to
Then go watch something else… why be rude about free content? 🤷🏼♀️
Sounds like the judge has already been bought off and or at the very least has made her mind up on his guilt. this has no fairness about it subconsciously or even without you knowing it could’ve changed your verdict it’s persuasion
Bought off by whom??
Regurgitating court which was televised?!?
Toal is making SC Judicial system look really bad. Becky Hill contact with jury is completely out of bounds.
you mean like murdaugh made sc look bad?
No. I'm saying the Clerk of Court screwed up bad and this judge is further creating distrust in the SC judicial system. @@yelaineq1
He is guilty but if someone interfer yes give him a new triel