I’m the creator, thank you so much for the consideration for the reaction!! I have a lot planned going forward, MatPat is gonna LOVE season 2 for a very certain reason
One thing I'd like to point out: UA-camr Wendigoon did a phenomenal, comprehensive analysis of this series, and actually got in contact with the creator. The creator of the series has said that the videos are uploaded out of order intentionally, and that the optimal viewing order is "The THINK Principle," "Mandela Catalogue Vol. 1" "Overthrone," and "Intruder Alert." Beyond those four Viewing order is unknown as the creator has not said anything about the new ones afaik
The creator has also said that there are pieces of the puzzle that have not been introduced yet. If I had any idea how long will it take for season two to arrive, I would advise MatPat to not make a theory until that is wrapped, but that ain't happening.
Caesar was actually calling from home because he was an alternate. He was just pretending to be driving to the hospital. There isn't even any car noise. Honestly I'm concerned about how gullible Mark is.
13:55- The funny thing here is that angels, as they were described in the Bible, were utterly terrifying- there was a reason that the first thing they typically said to people was "be not afraid".
Angels were both those terrifying rings and eyes and humans with wings. There's a physical hierchy based on who's closer to god in height. I recommend watching wendigoons video, he's very detailed in explaining the christian aspect
I think it's mentioned that they are like this to scare demons, while demons are cute and defenseless looking to seduce humans easier, kinda of a whacky plan if you ask me, seeing that most of the time the humans are easier scared by cute little girls with big red eyes than winged creatures XD
I think the reason the Doppelgänger part was kinda chilling was because the context of it straight out tells you that you that one of them is a threat, but because the people/pictures look so similar and your brain can't identify the threat it gets much scarier, because your brain _knows_ that something is supposed to be wrong.
That and also the fact that once you stare long enough, you will find some differences, and are primed to see those as something being wrong and not just differences.
It actually reminds me of the blue car. A report goes out to be on the lookout for a blue car and all of a sudden there's an increase of blue cars. What's actually happening is your mind is primed to notice them in that moment. Really fascinating stuff
I think the biggest thing you missed in explaining the Mandela effect is WHY it's called that. The fact that there is a large portion of the population that believed they watched Nelson Mandela's funeral ON TV and news long before he even died. It was such a widespread phenomenon that they gave it a name.
The mandela effect is the dumbs thing to happen in internet culture a person with more then two braincells would know mandela died in 2013 after being president of south africa
Yeah the mandela effect is really cool. Another example is Looney Tunes where people genuinely believe that it was spelled "Looney Toons" when they watched it when it's actually spelled Tunes
NO! you don't really think!? It can't be! There's no way that Matpat; a theory content creator would EVER do something like that! You simply MUST be CRAZY! I've never heard something so Obscure!
@@terraSpark902 ikr completely impossible that matpat one of UA-cams most famous theory content creator would make a theory about a analog horror series it’s not like he has done this before with others before *coughs Gemini home entertainment oh sorry *coughs Walters files.
When the call operator says “don’t talk too much, you might accidentally reveal your fear” i think that could also be related to the angel Gabriel saying he will discover our fears
I think the alternates are an alien race attempting to invade earth, and I believe they are trying to manipulate religion in order to do so. Faith is a very strong thing, so its strategically smart to weaken that strength. The angels seen are lies made up by the alternates in order to weaken faith.
@Darkquill Maroon Angels are incomprehensible to the human mind and generally take on a human form or are described as weird and monstrous. Depictions of Gabriel exist because the aliens or whatever, not the other way around.
It's natural to be disturbed by an image of a humanoid with lack of/indistiunguishable facial features, because facial recognition is such a key part to us as social beings. That lack of information scares us and it's often assessed as strange/a threat, just like how the ambiguity of a stranger in a dark alleyway is immediately assessed as a threat.
beauty is decided by symmetry, proportions and recognition. if we see something asymmetrical, with no right proportions, no recognition, it strikes us as disturbing. i might have or not have gone off topic, but the point i made still has some connection to what you said.
As a childhood cancer survivor, I thank you for fundraising for such a great cause. I wasn't treated at St. Jude, but I know they help a bunch of families every year and it's because of these donations that they can keep going. Thank you.
@@sauvagess it's not garbage Hollywood horror its back yard made in someone's basement with a shitty computer and a wish. Which is what makes it good :D
for context on why the angel had a weird head. that was most likely because it was an alternate. it shows that one of the alternate types can have heads that are unnaturally large.
I think the grey blob was a shed It opens and then the next time we see it, it is closed and the thing inside moved to the dark hallway door that is opened
Hmm, well, I wore a shirt that had magical, funny, pasta-loving, secretly-strong skeleton brothers just yesterday…….I wonder if they are a real thing now
Honestly, it makes sense Matpat is getting into this, considering he's been doing videos about analog horror (Local 58, Gemini Home Entertainment, etc) these past few months.
Just a bit of insight for those confused, the one that was "Ceaser" was actually the Doppelganger, it lied to Mark to get another doppelganger a body, the show to that was when it said "take a good look at back hallway-" and got cut off by the weird smiling face showing that it was the actual Doppelganger
Something about that confuses me a bit tho. Ceaser was called the second victim, so is that because he was confirmed dead/an alternate later or something?
@@zoroverse8358 do take into account cesars specific wordage however; “hey, can you COME over and turn on the cameras?” Instead of go over. He was supposed to be driving his mom to the hospital. I could be looking too deep but a lot of the time wordage makes the scene and intended thoughts.
I love how (non-mirror) Matt’s reaction to the “record your toddler’s response” section was almost exactly the same as Markiplier’s- as in him just narrating how variously peaceful/stressed it made him feel (and thus assuming the role of the toddler)
Matpat, PLEASE keep watching these, I’m not even in a home right now, I’m in a fucking dorm where it would probably be better, but like, I don’t wanna watch this alone
I love how he noticed the binary text, which is very important for realizing that it's not aliens, but the devil itself that replaces Gabriel; and just forgets to check that out.
Yeah and the title "overthrone" shows it's the devil who successfully overthrew God in this timeline and therefore tampers with the birth of Jesus who is the one who speaks at the end of the clip about how he is stripped of his all powerful abilities. This would probably make alternates hellspawn
wake up joseph :) wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up
When I first played Grandia, the game opens to a scene of one of the characters shouting "Hey, Juuuustin!" (fully voice acted). It was weird, because I hadn't told it my name. Turns out the main protagonist (unbeknownst to me) is named Justin.
Yes, they were called Neanderthals. Or, alternatively, “those guys from that other tribe with traditions and culture you don’t understand, who happen to want to take your food” Or diseased people, before we knew what “disease” was and just assumed everyone who looked weird was cursed Or serial killers/generalized violent sociopath Not that hard to come up with explanations lol
@@balrogdahomie Aliens taking human forms Demons tricking innocent souls Ghouls that take forms of animals and creatures to guide you to your death (eternal entrapment?)
i’ve read that it could be because humans needed to be able to distinguish the dead/diseased from the living. Or it could also be to distinguish btwn us & neanderthals who’d have looked kinda like us but not. Or skinwalkers lol
"Hey, my mom is bleeding out on the floor" "Oh, bummer man." Gotta say, I thought that instead of the 'bummer, man' he was going to pull out the old Zuko "That's rough buddy." But thats just me.
I watched it like a month ago and I literally had the kind of chills I would get as a child for watching any kind of horror film or whatever haha. Hugeeee mistake
I should have. I watched the first video alone and actually had to call my mom to bring me down from a massive panic attack I was hallucinating and everything. It was bad. I was avoiding mirrors and shadowed corners and I even thought my cat was an alternate Very very bad times
Something I find so interesting is that other video's I've seen about Mandela Catalogue finds the distorted angels absolutely terrifying, and here's MatPat just laughing it all off
Same thing happened when my friend first saw Archangel Gabriel, he found it extremely funny, and I'm like "REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE I GOT FUCKING TRAUMATIZED AND YOU'RE JUST LAUGHING ?"
I really appreciate this fundraiser and all the people who donated, cancer has effected my family so much and I despise it. I want to be able to put an end to it as a soon as possible
I love how it plays on the fear of how we find slightly off or seeing something slightly wrong bad or terrifying. Analog horror is genuinely scary to me. Love that it’s all coming back
Theory: If you record "them" on non-magnetic medium they look just normal because "they" emit electromagnetic waves that alternate "their" image in our minds and change data in most types of recorders. The fun starts when you use VHS tapes because they are too sensitive to that waves and in turn they show "their" real face. If only for a moment.
Late viewer here, chiming in with three possible theories about the series (simply from Overthrone): 1. Aliens. Doppelganger aliens who've altered the course of human events. 2. Satan and his cohorts becoming powerful enough to overthrow God and fool the human race into following him instead 3. Eldritch horrors whose powers are beyond that of aliens or God. Power that is incomprehensible to the human race.
This series is horrifying. I watched a tiny bit while hiding in the comments and while someone else was reacting and I still had trouble sleeping for days. I am now completely terrified of being alone in my house, and i'm extremely scared of dark spaces now. My brother literally told me one line from it and it had this effect. I have no clue why i'm watching it again with matpat but IDK it'll be cool I guess. Wish me luck!
I love how he is fully joking because of how desensitized he is after what he has watched on UA-cam and other media This was flat out terrifying to me yet he jokes around fully
Another well known Mandela Effect is the Darth Vader reveal in Empire, where a lot of the time people say "Luke, I am your father" where in actuality Vader says "No, I am your father" in response to Luke's accusation of him killing his father
Matt **sees distorted face with big eyes** Matt: oh it's an alien, that's an alien. (Proceeds to assume aliens are a major confirmed element of which to build all new presumptions off of)
I feel like a carphone is the explanation there. The house is huge, has been broken into once, and has an advanced camera system, these people are presumably loaded. The real question is how often alter encounters were completely unreported just because most people didn't have the resources for the authorities to figure out what happened. I also think we're supposed to assume the guy in the car was filming his approach just in case. The text insert before he confronts the intruder looked like it was stuff he used a function on the camera to write, based on the digital font. If I had to guess, he had no writing implements around and was desperate to leave a last note before what he reasonably and correctly figured would be his death. Completely unrelated, but as far as weird, instinctual kid-fears go, being afraid of something that looks too pointy is A+ sensible.
I'm currently story writing and designing characters for my own analog horror series, and nothing gives me motivation to finish the first Ep as much as Mats pain screams :D
@@isilee2055 XD thank u sm!!! I have my favs deaths as all my PFPs for school too. My fav character is Mondo but i could bring myself to have his death as a PFP so i just made it an ishimondo meme lmao
when matpat said "orbeez" i thought he said "war bees" and got very confused and scared for a second then mirror matt asked if they were wet and i got even more confused before realizing what he said
Imagine if all the analog horror channels did a crossover, confirming they all take place in the same messed up universe. It’d be crazier than Infinity War.
I know that the livestream is tomorrow but ahead of it I want to say thank you guys for holding this event for such an amazing cause. I make it habit to make a yearly donation to St. Jude because their mission is one that I can truly get behind. My mother fought and won her battle with cancer but my grandmother and various other member of my family unfortunately did not. To be a parent of a child dealing with this is something that I can not imagine but I know that it is hard. Needless to say that I will definitely be tuned in to the livestream and even though the donation will not be much, it is one step closer to helping to be rid of this terrible affliction. Anyone who reads this, find it in your hear to tune in tomorrow and engage and if possible donate to help this truly worthy cause!
Weird theory... So Mark killed himself when he saw an alternate, right? And the THINK principle told you to... well, do that. Is this just an elaborate "THINK, MARK, THINK!" joke
This also reminds of that thing about the uncanny valley. Basically it exists because at some point there was a reason to fear things that look like us
Not really that’s a conspiracy that seems somewhat true, just as likely that our brains ability to recognize faces in objects gets fucked when there SHOULD be a face but it doesn’t fit the pattern correctly
I almost made the mistake of watching this late at night. This is the single creepiest analog horror anything I've ever seen. Maybe it's because I'm religious but it managed to worm it's way into my soul, I can't even define why this scares me so much. With say, the Walten Files, I know what scares me, it's the violent shift from relaxed to chaos, Local 58 uses slow decent into madness, which isn't that spooky when you know where it's going. This- I don't know, they're are multiple creepy facets that I don't find creepy on their own, but together scare me like nothing else does. Props to the creator.
Dude I'm literally trying to figure out where I first saw this cuz I thought nexpo or night mind or inside a mind covered it but no one has and I'm so confused lmao
24:06 I think the upside down one most likely is meant to be interpreted as it’s head being stuck on upside down, or at a weird angle. In that case, it’d most likely move by either walking on it’s hands, or spidering around on all fours. So yeah, the most terrifying of the three.
these videos are so creepy, i don't know how anyone can stand to watch them. i've tried to watch three different people just react to them, i haven't even watched the actual videos by themself, and I just can't do it. usually if i watch someone reacting to scary videos like these, it makes me feel better and i'm not as freaked out because the other person is joking around and trying to lighten the mood, but this a whole different level. i think it's the fact that a lot of these things a close to humans which freaks me out. there's something about seeing a human like thing that you know isn't human. I also think that these videos cause paranoia as well because it feels like something that could happen in real life. just my thoughts
Same! I was absolutely terrified when I first saw the film theory on local 58. Whenever I watch these at 6:30 at night knowing bedtime is in like 3 hours, it’s best to remember that it’s all fake.
I love how this series plays both into the themes of fear of the unknown and the Grotesque at the same time. Masterfully done Also all the biblical references like 'the liar' and 'deception' aka Satan himself makes me think it's demons
i love this, i love horror stories but they’re too scary for me to watch (i’m a wimp it’s ok), so having matpat to watch it with me brings a comforting presence that makes me not so scared. i hope he does more of these kinds of videos
The creator Alex said the next season (season one just wrapped up) wouldn't be analog horror anymore, or at least not strictly. It does not fit the story that well anymore and he does not want to limit himself to the genre. I can't wait for season 2!
Hey Mat. Someone has probably already mentioned this but another difference between the THINK principle and volume 1 is that *in volume 1, the second category, the detectable, was cut out*
Cesar that we heard on the phone is definitely an alternate and what we hear at 5:34 AM is it attacking his mom -The imagery shown of Cesar his image distorting seems to be pointing towards what we hear on the phone is an alternate not Cesar -Also his general lack of emotion on the phone from Cesar -If he is on call in an ambulance even if that was possible but we would probably hear some kind of sound (background noise) other than his voice maybe static or the car on the road (or what you usually hear while inside the car driving) -He also never confirms if the house was locked up -The specification of “check the back hallway” may suggest that it’s going to ambush mark there or it will follow him once he leaves the area, seeing Mark being it knowing that it’s him and it will then follow him home -Also by the fact that the the official report of an alternate is to not do anything other than ask questions until the caller stops answering shows that the government knows that the alternates know how to set traps like the one that sounded like Cesar may have set possibly confirming what I said in the previous point (Also fairly terrifying is that if some ones calling to report an alternate that they are pretty much confirmed to be one and that who ever they are impersonating is either a made up person, dead (or missing) due to the alternate or so where safe unaware of the impersonation of them happening at that moment)
It's already terrifying the fact that the authorities are instructed not to help, and even more so, if the person on thephone reporting an alternate encounter is an actual human... then that means they're pretty much doomed, while having a false hope that help will be on the way
One thing I’ve noticed about people who post reactions to this, is that none of them notice the slightly off thing when looking outside at the “grave”. Compare 38:30 to 38:58 and then compare that to 39:16 There’s someone there.
For those who missed some of the finer details: Before Cesar dies (I assume) - the sequence where the camera flashes between the barn outside, the stairwell, and the hallway - on the last visor of the hallway where the door is shut and after the video of the barn where the door is open, you can hear the VERY faint sound of glass breaking downstairs. I believe this is the sound increase detected.
Okay. I didn't realize this either until I took my Wireless Networks class. We just entered 5G in mobile technology back in 2020. G stands for generation. 2010s was 4. 2000s was 3. 1990s was 2. 1980s was 1. The video in question was in 1992 during 2G. Mobile phones were considered big ticket items and small electronics financing was not as established as it is today. So, it makes sense that a guy who has enough money to set up his own in home camera security system would have enough interest in technology and affluence to be able to afford a cell phone in 1992.
Ok so “Cesar” had enough money to buy a cell phone ,so he might have not been inside “his” house Even today it’s almost impossible to not have any background noise come from your phone with 5G phones A 2G phone having absolutely no background noise (being inside a moving ambulance) makes it almost impossible to believe “Cesar” is telling the truth of his situation Combine that with the shadow on the “grave” right before the open door that is gone next time we see it and it’s almost certain that “Cesar” is an alternate
The scariest part when it comes to these types of stories is that (to me in this case), is there is always something that’s gonna make you jump waiting for you to reach the point makes you even more scared because of the suspense (like in this case, the alternate attacking Caesar’s mom)
"We are currently recieving-" I KNOW THAT VOICE. That was the same one saying that same message that was later in the video, but in the Foxy cartoon- the message to discard the tape immediately. I know the other two automated voices, as well. The one in Overthrone was the same one from Faith, and it was a voice synthesizer originally made for the Commodore 64. The "nothing is worth the risk" one was also used in Undertale, for a part of abc_123_a.ogg.
When i watched wendigoon’a video on this i literally could not sleep with the lights off for a solid week. Ive always had weird anxiety/intrusive thoughts about feeling like there’s something in my room watching me at night so this series is just genuinely all of my worst anxieties wrapped up in a little bow. That being said i think the story is so fucking cool and im absolutely gonna watch this and i am absolutely gonna regret it tonight when i try to go to bed
I still think about his video. Sometimes, I'll just be doing whatever, and "Uh oh. Bad decision, Mark!" just pops into my head. I also had a phase where I opened my eyes every 3 seconds while trying to sleep, expecting to see the figure in the corner of my room. Fun times.
I had that mandella effect with a scene from Wreck it Ralph, I was convinced for several years that there was a scene where Felix said that Turbo was his dad. I watched the movie again recently and I haven't stopped being confused about that
See, I'm not usually scared of this stuff. I blinked a few times at Walten Files. But as a Christian who watched the cartoony bible retellings as a very young child and just has an emotional connection to these stories, I wasn't scared but I felt *very* disturbed. Especially since the "angel" lied to the shepherds, that made me upset. (Edit) Aaand guess who- going to sleep last night after watching this- had a nightmare from it. Great, thanks. My fear is worse now and I am making sure my loved ones are indeed my loved ones. Kudos, though, this is really good at being scary.
Same, didn't watch these particular original video retellings of the bible story, but I know how the story goes. This made me uncomfortable and un easy, where the angels were aliens deceiving the shepherds.
I know its not really theory worthy, but MatPat really needs to watch the squimpus mcgrimpus fnaf vhs tapes. It's my favorite take on the fnaf story and I think MatPat will like it too
yes absolutely! those videos are like 5x more terrifying than the mandela catalogue from my experience. the creator of those really knows how to unsettle you
@@Squilly4 ive watched the Mcgrimpus vhs tapes, theyre not as unsettling as these are. These take something holy and make it more satanic, whilst the VHS tapes just take a horror thing and make it more scary.
I like what your going for but the only thing is that he has already done the entire lore and story to FNAF but it would be cool for him to react to them.
A lot of people might have missed this, but I love when Mat was looking at the hallway footage, when he said "antici....pation" he just casually referenced Rocky Horror Picture Show. Such a theater nerd, I love it 🤣
[TW// In depth talking about death, and dead bodies. This is also a long, and I mean LONG read. I may have rambled.] I’ve see people talking about uncanny valley and exactly why we ever had to evolve this defense in the first place and I actually have an answer for this! Something that might’ve “looked like us, but wasn’t” were actually other dead humans. Corpses don’t tend to look right to our brains, and that’s why we often see them re-used in horror media. They’re universally scary. The reason we evolved this way is because if there’s a dead body nearby, then there’s almost certainly danger nearby. ESPECIALLY if the body is mangled, and disfigured. And the eyes get to us so much is because seeing wide open eyes on something unmoving, unblinking, staring, that means they didn’t have time to close their eyes before they died, and that increases the feeling of danger. Another reason I can think of that those eyes are so terrifying is because we weren’t apex predators. We were hunted. So something with wide, open, forward facing eyes dead set on you gives you the instinctual feeling that whatever it is, it wants to eat you. The contrast between eyes and darkness also forces your eyes to immediately focus and hone in on the one thing we can see, because that’s how our brains are built. The smiles I think give off that “It KNOWS it’s going to win.” emotion as well. Usually you don’t show signs of happiness entering a fight you have a fair chance in. That’s all! Sorry I went on a tangent but. You get the idea! Thanks for reading :-)
It's also for the same reason a chimp's smile is unsettling- it's not friendly. If a chimp smiles, it's a *threat*. Humans and other hominids used to do the exact same thing to each other... right before possibly eating each other. We evolved to be scared of non-human smiles because once upon a time that meant another hominid was probably looking at us and thinking "food".
ive been watching game theory ever since the sonic isnt actually fast theory and i never once considered watching these GT lives until now, seeing matpat re watch, screenshot and play with the image, and construct the narrative in real time has its own unique charm that I regret not discovering earlier
What if Caesar (The Alt) called from home never intending to go to the Hospital because it took the mom out, it just wanted to lure Mark into to the house to “off” him
But then why would Mark say it followed dhim home if the alternative killed him at Caesar's house? My guess is he got out quick and got his family killed like an idiot, resulting in suicide.
I have seen a boatload of creepypastas and horror stuff in general, but The Mandela Catalogue is the first one that genuinely makes me want to stop watching out from being so creeped out. Terrifying, yet impressive.
Can't believe Mat failed to mention the reason why it's called the Mandela Effect - the year Nelson Mandela died. Also, I could have sworn that there was a secondary thing about the effect that some people use it as evidence of someone having switched to a parallel reality where there was just that specific thing that was different, and the memory of it being the wrong way was because it really was as it was remembered in the universe they were from (Shaq actually made that movie, Stein instead of Stain, et cetera).
fugit is the 3rd person singular of fugere, which means to flee. So he/she/it is fleeing. Who? Time. because tempus is 1st form singular, so its the subject of the sentence, so it means “Time flees” or how we say today, “time flies” For it to mean time to flee it would need an infinitive :)
I love how they didn't even mention the one the Mandela effect was named for. The fact that many people remember Nelson Mandela dying in prison in the 80's when he was really released and didn't die until 2013. Another one that had nothing to do with spelling.
It's scary to see Matt scared. This is probably the creepiest and coolest creepypasta ever. Or is it a creepypasta? Arg? Analog horror series? Analog horror series...
From what I can make of the story, if the religious cartoons can be taken at face value, it’s implying the origin of alternates and similar paranormal entities date back to the birth of Christ, where in this world, satan had come to Mary disguised as Gabriel and caused them to give birth to a false prophet designed to control people, Satan had also snuck in the original allternate on Noah’s ark in an attempt to destroy humanity. But if it was to be taken metaphorically, it can be implied that an otherworldly force, most likely from another reality had disguised itself from the people and had existed for a long time but only now recently have started attempting to take over
I’m the creator, thank you so much for the consideration for the reaction!! I have a lot planned going forward, MatPat is gonna LOVE season 2 for a very certain reason
We love you king! I could not sleep for a week straight after watching through your videos 💀
You have one f***ed up brain and I am HERE FOR IT.
@@doctorjay8673 I strive to achieve this compliment one day.
Hello the creator of impostor religion
"for a very certain reason"
are you gonna add Music Man???
One thing I'd like to point out: UA-camr Wendigoon did a phenomenal, comprehensive analysis of this series, and actually got in contact with the creator. The creator of the series has said that the videos are uploaded out of order intentionally, and that the optimal viewing order is "The THINK Principle," "Mandela Catalogue Vol. 1" "Overthrone," and "Intruder Alert." Beyond those four Viewing order is unknown as the creator has not said anything about the new ones afaik
The creator has also said that there are pieces of the puzzle that have not been introduced yet. If I had any idea how long will it take for season two to arrive, I would advise MatPat to not make a theory until that is wrapped, but that ain't happening.
hello fellow man of culture
I'm worried that Mat will overlook his video and make an accidental copy
Boosting this comment, bc Wendigoon did an absolute bang-up job and I highly recommend that vid
@@lzrshark617 He really did, the religious angle he brought to the analysis was absolutely fascinating
“I know what you love”
MatPat: diet coke
“I know what you dread”
MatPat: Lack of diet coke
yes
perfect
amazing
I relate to him to much when it comes to this-
Yes that is true
Caesar was actually calling from home because he was an alternate. He was just pretending to be driving to the hospital. There isn't even any car noise. Honestly I'm concerned about how gullible Mark is.
Was that whole thing not a Columbine reference?
"Caesar" probably was what his mom encountered.
I think Mark being gullible is something we should all be used to by now. There are thousands of videos showing just how smol brain he can be
how gullible Mark *was
:0 you have a point ngl, even i thought it was weird that they “arrived” at the hospital, yet i heard no noises of a car during the call
13:55- The funny thing here is that angels, as they were described in the Bible, were utterly terrifying- there was a reason that the first thing they typically said to people was "be not afraid".
Angels were both those terrifying rings and eyes and humans with wings. There's a physical hierchy based on who's closer to god in height. I recommend watching wendigoons video, he's very detailed in explaining the christian aspect
I think it's mentioned that they are like this to scare demons, while demons are cute and defenseless looking to seduce humans easier, kinda of a whacky plan if you ask me, seeing that most of the time the humans are easier scared by cute little girls with big red eyes than winged creatures XD
I’m in my final year in CCD and I never knew that 😨
The Eastern Churches actually have biblically accurate angels in their iconography
I mean who wouldnt be scared at seeing a flying man i mean that would scare me lol
I think the reason the Doppelgänger part was kinda chilling was because the context of it straight out tells you that you that one of them is a threat, but because the people/pictures look so similar and your brain can't identify the threat it gets much scarier, because your brain _knows_ that something is supposed to be wrong.
That and also the fact that once you stare long enough, you will find some differences, and are primed to see those as something being wrong and not just differences.
@@nairsheasterling9457 furry opinion rejected
@@biggerproblem9409 Oops, you dropped your clown nose. Here you go. 🤡
@@nairsheasterling9457 lol
It actually reminds me of the blue car. A report goes out to be on the lookout for a blue car and all of a sudden there's an increase of blue cars. What's actually happening is your mind is primed to notice them in that moment. Really fascinating stuff
"if you see someone that looks like you, run away and hide"
Identical siblings: *awkwardly glance at each other*
If you suddenly have a third twin that look exactly like you, it's running time
THERE CAN ONLY BE ONE OF US
*Grabs rifle* You know the rulesss, and so do iiiiii~ 🎶 ♥️
*SAY GOODBYE!* _👀_
@@L16htW4rr10r IM A TRIPLET LMAO
@@joemamacaprisun OH GOD NO. X,D
I think the biggest thing you missed in explaining the Mandela effect is WHY it's called that. The fact that there is a large portion of the population that believed they watched Nelson Mandela's funeral ON TV and news long before he even died. It was such a widespread phenomenon that they gave it a name.
I believe he briefly touched on that though
The mandela effect is the dumbs thing to happen in internet culture a person with more then two braincells would know mandela died in 2013 after being president of south africa
@@guilhermecastro9893 unfortunately people are really really dumb
@@Melody_Bird i would say ignorant nore then dumb
Yeah the mandela effect is really cool. Another example is Looney Tunes where people genuinely believe that it was spelled "Looney Toons" when they watched it when it's actually spelled Tunes
I love how the chapters are “The Witty Banter”, “Nope.”, and “The Witty Wrap-Up”.
It's like that meme of the stages of life
Birth
AAAAAAAAAAAAA-!
Death
@@KateCantDraw Such a mood tho
1k like
He is DEFINITELY going to make a theory on this and I am all here for it
Same
NO! you don't really think!? It can't be! There's no way that Matpat; a theory content creator would EVER do something like that! You simply MUST be CRAZY! I've never heard something so Obscure!
@@terraSpark902 haha good point
@@fishzy1210 thx lol
@@terraSpark902 ikr completely impossible that matpat one of UA-cams most famous theory content creator would make a theory about a analog horror series it’s not like he has done this before with others before *coughs Gemini home entertainment oh sorry *coughs Walters files.
When the call operator says “don’t talk too much, you might accidentally reveal your fear” i think that could also be related to the angel Gabriel saying he will discover our fears
It's not the real Gabriel.
I think the alternates are an alien race attempting to invade earth, and I believe they are trying to manipulate religion in order to do so. Faith is a very strong thing, so its strategically smart to weaken that strength. The angels seen are lies made up by the alternates in order to weaken faith.
@Darkquill Maroon Angels are incomprehensible to the human mind and generally take on a human form or are described as weird and monstrous. Depictions of Gabriel exist because the aliens or whatever, not the other way around.
my theory is that alternates manifest themselves into living humans by overtaking their weakened minds (as in weakened by their greatest fears)
@@tikoblocks3224 To add to this theory, in one of the videos, they tell people to stop practicing/partaking in religious thing
It's natural to be disturbed by an image of a humanoid with lack of/indistiunguishable facial features, because facial recognition is such a key part to us as social beings.
That lack of information scares us and it's often assessed as strange/a threat, just like how the ambiguity of a stranger in a dark alleyway is immediately assessed as a threat.
It's also a natural response our brains make to determine whether or not someone is dead or diseased and that's also why the uncanny valley is a thing
beauty is decided by symmetry, proportions and recognition. if we see something asymmetrical, with no right proportions, no recognition, it strikes us as disturbing.
i might have or not have gone off topic, but the point i made still has some connection to what you said.
I am just intrested by it not scared.
Am I broken?
@@Rahul_Sastry No, it just means you have a high tolerance :)
bro said psychiatrist💀 but yea i think you are right that makes a lot of sense
As a childhood cancer survivor, I thank you for fundraising for such a great cause. I wasn't treated at St. Jude, but I know they help a bunch of families every year and it's because of these donations that they can keep going. Thank you.
That’s wonderful, god bless you.
i was gonna say ratio as a joke but i realized that would make me an asshole LMAO
@@donkeedle1127 Why would you even do that?
@@flashfrozen7401 tiktok humor I apologize
@@donkeedle1127 Your current comment alone was enough to be funny, made me wheeze until my sides hurt!
I love how they're not overusing loud sonds to scare you but instead giving you that unsettling feeling
That's how Analogue Horror works, it's not some jumpscare factory. It's all environment and familiarity tugging.
agreed. I felt on edge whenever the screen wasn't focused solely on Mat
@@sauvagess it's not garbage Hollywood horror its back yard made in someone's basement with a shitty computer and a wish. Which is what makes it good :D
As soon as he finds something, he's like:
"So anyway, I started brightening"
FNAF really has long term effects 😔
MatPat literally every time an unknown creature shows up: A L I E N S
If he does a theory and says it’s aliens i am done
@@rollingkirby idk to me is obviously demons/ those under Lucifer, but my theological background colors my perspective
Aliens make things so much less scary
Him calling “Jesus” a women is really funny to me
well, by definiton that what it is lol
"Walten files, what are you doing in my Mandela catalog."
This timeline is great.
Truly the weirdest timeline
for context on why the angel had a weird head. that was most likely because it was an alternate. it shows that one of the alternate types can have heads that are unnaturally large.
That was Satan himself
I love how Mat *never noticed* that there was a shadow on the grey blob.
Or the really long arm moving on the side of the house
I think the grey blob was a shed
It opens and then the next time we see it, it is closed and the thing inside moved to the dark hallway door that is opened
@@Doodle_1019 what do you mean? When and where
@@zoroverse8358 When there's the footage of the guy driving into the driveway, there's something on the left side of the house
@@zoroverse8358 rewatching it, I think I didn't see it right
"See i am wearing a shirt, that's how you know it's a real thing." - Pat, Mat 2021
I'll start doing shirts of everything I want to be real
Talks about mandela effect, use an handfull of exemple, the only one they dont mention it, nelson mandela.
Me a furry:
"bill gates gave me fourteen billion dollars"
So if I wear a shirt from The World Ends With You. The Reapers Game will be real. Noice
Hmm, well, I wore a shirt that had magical, funny, pasta-loving, secretly-strong skeleton brothers just yesterday…….I wonder if they are a real thing now
12:54 He's saying swath cloth. It means cloth made from grains or grass, usually cut by a scythe
first markiplier, now matpat. its all coming together
wendigoon hours?
The videos have the same thumbnail
Absolute terrifing when the eyes pop up
Honestly, it makes sense Matpat is getting into this, considering he's been doing videos about analog horror (Local 58, Gemini Home Entertainment, etc) these past few months.
@@catherinelee1206 how could you forget about the majestic twf
Just a bit of insight for those confused, the one that was "Ceaser" was actually the Doppelganger, it lied to Mark to get another doppelganger a body, the show to that was when it said "take a good look at back hallway-" and got cut off by the weird smiling face showing that it was the actual Doppelganger
If I’m correct and don’t worry I did too, did you get that theory from wendigoon
Something about that confuses me a bit tho. Ceaser was called the second victim, so is that because he was confirmed dead/an alternate later or something?
@@valeelens i guess it took them a bit to find ceaser's body
Well it isnt confirmed. So dont present it as fact as if the creator said that that was correct.
@@zoroverse8358 do take into account cesars specific wordage however; “hey, can you COME over and turn on the cameras?” Instead of go over. He was supposed to be driving his mom to the hospital. I could be looking too deep but a lot of the time wordage makes the scene and intended thoughts.
The Mandela Catalogue freaked me out for a good two days, but now all fear I once felt is gone. But the idea of Alternates is still super intriguing.
I feel like Joseph knew what was going on and kept his eyes closed while trying to ignore it.
ah yes links to the advice given in a later video
Who's Joseph?
@@Alex16582O Bruh, the dude in the beginning of the video. The angel was whispering to Joseph when he was sleeping
@@DePoker hahahahaha my bad completely forgot
I kind of think that it would be "cool" for this happening in this world, would add a little peps 😂
I love how (non-mirror) Matt’s reaction to the “record your toddler’s response” section was almost exactly the same as Markiplier’s- as in him just narrating how variously peaceful/stressed it made him feel (and thus assuming the role of the toddler)
Also how they both said the exact same thing about the glitch in the picture of Mark’s face XD “That’s a happy guy right there”
22:28
The reason people used to use iiii for 4 is because that way, the clock was divided into three equal parts
Four I, four V and four X parts.
Matpat, PLEASE keep watching these, I’m not even in a home right now, I’m in a fucking dorm where it would probably be better, but like, I don’t wanna watch this alone
BRO SAME
me too!
I can't watch these unfiltered, I nearly started crying from fear just watching Wendigoon's video 😭
I love how he noticed the binary text, which is very important for realizing that it's not aliens, but the devil itself that replaces Gabriel; and just forgets to check that out.
Classic Hack-Pat
He’ll probably do that if he does a theory on it
excuse me- wHAt?
Yeah and the title "overthrone" shows it's the devil who successfully overthrew God in this timeline and therefore tampers with the birth of Jesus who is the one who speaks at the end of the clip about how he is stripped of his all powerful abilities. This would probably make alternates hellspawn
@@daseapickleofjustice7231 wait jesus doesnt know if theres a god lol
17:31
The fact that MatPat literally made one of the scariest scenes in the video so funny 💀
He made it?
@@rose-mz5tn he made it funny
Nah, it's goofy.
Wooow that was so funny
Being someone named Joseph hearing "wake up joseph" really freaked me out.
wake up Joseph : )
wake up Joseph (:
nahhh fam
wake up joseph :) wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up wake up
When I first played Grandia, the game opens to a scene of one of the characters shouting "Hey, Juuuustin!" (fully voice acted).
It was weird, because I hadn't told it my name.
Turns out the main protagonist (unbeknownst to me) is named Justin.
I like how this plays with the uncanny valley here is a quote "at some point humanity evolved to notice somthing that looked human but wasn't"
Yes, they were called Neanderthals.
Or, alternatively, “those guys from that other tribe with traditions and culture you don’t understand, who happen to want to take your food”
Or diseased people, before we knew what “disease” was and just assumed everyone who looked weird was cursed
Or serial killers/generalized violent sociopath
Not that hard to come up with explanations lol
@@balrogdahomie Aliens taking human forms
Demons tricking innocent souls
Ghouls that take forms of animals and creatures to guide you to your death (eternal entrapment?)
Well in folklore when babies were born and came out with deformities they assumed farried or troll replaced their kids
i’ve read that it could be because humans needed to be able to distinguish the dead/diseased from the living. Or it could also be to distinguish btwn us & neanderthals who’d have looked kinda like us but not. Or skinwalkers lol
"Hey, my mom is bleeding out on the floor"
"Oh, bummer man."
Gotta say, I thought that instead of the 'bummer, man' he was going to pull out the old Zuko "That's rough buddy." But thats just me.
You thought he'd reference Avatar?
That's rough buddy
A GAAAAME me. Thanks for watching.
@@redsprinkle This is exactly the kind of dumb comedy I love! Well done, sir/madame/Mx.
Pov: You waited till Mat reacted to this so you don't have to watch it by yourself.
Lol same, I came from Mark's video but I was too much of a baby to watch the vid collection without MatPat holding my hand ;v;
I watched it like a month ago and I literally had the kind of chills I would get as a child for watching any kind of horror film or whatever haha. Hugeeee mistake
I should have. I watched the first video alone and actually had to call my mom to bring me down from a massive panic attack
I was hallucinating and everything. It was bad. I was avoiding mirrors and shadowed corners and I even thought my cat was an alternate
Very very bad times
I watched this alone at 3am and hated it. Now, I’m watching it at 3:44am while matpat reacts. I still hate it. Loll
False my man
Something I find so interesting is that other video's I've seen about Mandela Catalogue finds the distorted angels absolutely terrifying, and here's MatPat just laughing it all off
MatPats reaction to spooky stuff is just to laugh
I feel like Matpat is more susceptible with jumpscare rather than odd characteristics.
MatPat just commonly laughs at stuff he's scared of
Same thing happened when my friend first saw Archangel Gabriel, he found it extremely funny, and I'm like "REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE I GOT FUCKING TRAUMATIZED AND YOU'RE JUST LAUGHING ?"
@@kostakis5084 traumatized? exaggerating or no haha
I really appreciate this fundraiser and all the people who donated, cancer has effected my family so much and I despise it. I want to be able to put an end to it as a soon as possible
I love how it plays on the fear of how we find slightly off or seeing something slightly wrong bad or terrifying. Analog horror is genuinely scary to me. Love that it’s all coming back
Theory: If you record "them" on non-magnetic medium they look just normal because "they" emit electromagnetic waves that alternate "their" image in our minds and change data in most types of recorders. The fun starts when you use VHS tapes because they are too sensitive to that waves and in turn they show "their" real face. If only for a moment.
Late viewer here, chiming in with three possible theories about the series (simply from Overthrone):
1. Aliens. Doppelganger aliens who've altered the course of human events.
2. Satan and his cohorts becoming powerful enough to overthrow God and fool the human race into following him instead
3. Eldritch horrors whose powers are beyond that of aliens or God. Power that is incomprehensible to the human race.
This series is horrifying. I watched a tiny bit while hiding in the comments and while someone else was reacting and I still had trouble sleeping for days. I am now completely terrified of being alone in my house, and i'm extremely scared of dark spaces now. My brother literally told me one line from it and it had this effect. I have no clue why i'm watching it again with matpat but IDK it'll be cool I guess. Wish me luck!
@TrainerblueTube know when to walk away
@@knine1359 And know when to run
@@bluelfsuma
“If you see someone with biologically impossible characteristics, run away.”
i’m watching this is my college cafe and idk if it was a good idea
@TrainerblueTube and right now its folding time.
I love how he is fully joking because of how desensitized he is after what he has watched on UA-cam and other media
This was flat out terrifying to me yet he jokes around fully
That’s why I watch him do spooky things lol
Another well known Mandela Effect is the Darth Vader reveal in Empire, where a lot of the time people say "Luke, I am your father" where in actuality Vader says "No, I am your father" in response to Luke's accusation of him killing his father
Matt **sees distorted face with big eyes**
Matt: oh it's an alien, that's an alien.
(Proceeds to assume aliens are a major confirmed element of which to build all new presumptions off of)
ITS MATPAT, THE SAME GUY WHO THOUGHT SANS WAS NESS!!!
@Golden BoxHed Lol
I mean, its not a bad idea. This whole thing could either be some sort of supernatural phenomenon or some sort of weird alien technology.
@@gorbulations2425 if you read the binary text and think a little about the first clip you'll realise it's the devil (yes literally the devil)
@@daseapickleofjustice7231 Oh, I know. I'm just saying it in defense of Matt since it's an easy mistake for someone to make on first viewing.
For those wondering, the binary says:
"I am the one true savior. I must reverse the delusion. Joseph is next. "
Thank you for this, I was actually wondering that! Also- Super creepy, lol
Thanks
I feel like a carphone is the explanation there. The house is huge, has been broken into once, and has an advanced camera system, these people are presumably loaded.
The real question is how often alter encounters were completely unreported just because most people didn't have the resources for the authorities to figure out what happened.
I also think we're supposed to assume the guy in the car was filming his approach just in case. The text insert before he confronts the intruder looked like it was stuff he used a function on the camera to write, based on the digital font. If I had to guess, he had no writing implements around and was desperate to leave a last note before what he reasonably and correctly figured would be his death.
Completely unrelated, but as far as weird, instinctual kid-fears go, being afraid of something that looks too pointy is A+ sensible.
I'm currently story writing and designing characters for my own analog horror series, and nothing gives me motivation to finish the first Ep as much as Mats pain screams :D
Bro what was that reply?
Axolotl Supreme It's probably a bot.
Ok I just wanna say I love your profile picture and also NAGITO NOO
@@isilee2055 XD thank u sm!!! I have my favs deaths as all my PFPs for school too. My fav character is Mondo but i could bring myself to have his death as a PFP so i just made it an ishimondo meme lmao
here for it, take sub
when matpat said "orbeez" i thought he said "war bees" and got very confused and scared for a second
then mirror matt asked if they were wet and i got even more confused before realizing what he said
*W* *A* *R* *B* *E* *E* *S*
Beware of the w a r b e e s
Your Nagito pfp makes this better
@Asian G R I L S • © Lol bots cant spell “Asian G R I L S”
m o i s t
Imagine if all the analog horror channels did a crossover, confirming they all take place in the same messed up universe. It’d be crazier than Infinity War.
Yooooooooooooooo that’s the hunger games I’m a horror fan so let’s do it🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️
I know that the livestream is tomorrow but ahead of it I want to say thank you guys for holding this event for such an amazing cause. I make it habit to make a yearly donation to St. Jude because their mission is one that I can truly get behind. My mother fought and won her battle with cancer but my grandmother and various other member of my family unfortunately did not. To be a parent of a child dealing with this is something that I can not imagine but I know that it is hard. Needless to say that I will definitely be tuned in to the livestream and even though the donation will not be much, it is one step closer to helping to be rid of this terrible affliction. Anyone who reads this, find it in your hear to tune in tomorrow and engage and if possible donate to help this truly worthy cause!
Weird theory...
So Mark killed himself when he saw an alternate, right?
And the THINK principle told you to... well, do that.
Is this just an elaborate "THINK, MARK, THINK!" joke
Lol
One bold trap: "KYS" to throw off suspicion on the real trap: "Although we make exceptions when executing it yourself"
Matpat: "are you gonna jump into the giant tub of orbes?"
Mirror Mat: "can I?"
And I'm that moment I realized the man really is my spirit animal
If MatPat has been replaced, can we call the new one MandelaPandela?
The incredible ManPan
Matdela Patson
WJREUYJANSUBENHG ok that got me 😂
This is clever. And YES 😂
Matrick Pathew
This also reminds of that thing about the uncanny valley. Basically it exists because at some point there was a reason to fear things that look like us
Not really that’s a conspiracy that seems somewhat true, just as likely that our brains ability to recognize faces in objects gets fucked when there SHOULD be a face but it doesn’t fit the pattern correctly
It's probably either to recognize dead body's because if someone is dead nearby that means there danger or to identify Neanderthals
I almost made the mistake of watching this late at night. This is the single creepiest analog horror anything I've ever seen. Maybe it's because I'm religious but it managed to worm it's way into my soul, I can't even define why this scares me so much. With say, the Walten Files, I know what scares me, it's the violent shift from relaxed to chaos, Local 58 uses slow decent into madness, which isn't that spooky when you know where it's going. This- I don't know, they're are multiple creepy facets that I don't find creepy on their own, but together scare me like nothing else does. Props to the creator.
it's 1 am im dying
Seriously man I accidentally put this on once by myself at night and scared the crap outta myself, the Gabriel alternate was what really got me😂
I remember watching this for the first time, safe to say I wouldn’t leave my completely lit up room at night.
I always do that
Dude I'm literally trying to figure out where I first saw this cuz I thought nexpo or night mind or inside a mind covered it but no one has and I'm so confused lmao
@@celticmelody7574 you might be getting it confused with Walten Files
... it's 1.30am for me right now... time to get everything ant not leaving my room until 8am today.. got it thanks for the warning xD
@@MasumiSeike No Problem Mate, just trying to warn people
I recommend a game I saw Markiplier play called "Maple County," which is basically based off of Mandela Catalouge.
Same! I saw that today
@@Vickydoessomething same
And the thumbnail is the same too
It is made by Mandela catalogue I’m pretty sure(I was wrong)
@@TenNineD Fr? Swear it was made by Thorne Baker, the musician dude who goes by Teenage Disaster.
24:06 I think the upside down one most likely is meant to be interpreted as it’s head being stuck on upside down, or at a weird angle. In that case, it’d most likely move by either walking on it’s hands, or spidering around on all fours. So yeah, the most terrifying of the three.
So cosplaying ballora from fnaf?
Australian?
these videos are so creepy, i don't know how anyone can stand to watch them. i've tried to watch three different people just react to them, i haven't even watched the actual videos by themself, and I just can't do it. usually if i watch someone reacting to scary videos like these, it makes me feel better and i'm not as freaked out because the other person is joking around and trying to lighten the mood, but this a whole different level. i think it's the fact that a lot of these things a close to humans which freaks me out. there's something about seeing a human like thing that you know isn't human. I also think that these videos cause paranoia as well because it feels like something that could happen in real life. just my thoughts
the whispering and long pauses are what get me
Same! I was absolutely terrified when I first saw the film theory on local 58. Whenever I watch these at 6:30 at night knowing bedtime is in like 3 hours, it’s best to remember that it’s all fake.
its more of a “the more you watch it the less scarier it gets” scenario
For me most of the faces look funny
i didn't think it was that scary. The faces remind me of sus jerma. The thought of aliens stealing your identity is scarier.
I love how this series plays both into the themes of fear of the unknown and the Grotesque at the same time. Masterfully done
Also all the biblical references like 'the liar' and 'deception' aka Satan himself makes me think it's demons
i love this, i love horror stories but they’re too scary for me to watch (i’m a wimp it’s ok), so having matpat to watch it with me brings a comforting presence that makes me not so scared. i hope he does more of these kinds of videos
Your dog pic makes me feel safer
true
I'm the same but having another person doesn't help me ;-;
Me 2 I freak OUT
Same dude
The creator Alex said the next season (season one just wrapped up) wouldn't be analog horror anymore, or at least not strictly. It does not fit the story that well anymore and he does not want to limit himself to the genre. I can't wait for season 2!
Hey Mat. Someone has probably already mentioned this but another difference between the THINK principle and volume 1 is that *in volume 1, the second category, the detectable, was cut out*
Cesar that we heard on the phone is definitely an alternate and what we hear at 5:34 AM is it attacking his mom
-The imagery shown of Cesar his image distorting seems to be pointing towards what we hear on the phone is an alternate not Cesar
-Also his general lack of emotion on the phone from Cesar
-If he is on call in an ambulance even if that was possible but we would probably hear some kind of sound (background noise) other than his voice maybe static or the car on the road (or what you usually hear while inside the car driving)
-He also never confirms if the house was locked up
-The specification of “check the back hallway” may suggest that it’s going to ambush mark there or it will follow him once he leaves the area, seeing Mark being it knowing that it’s him and it will then follow him home
-Also by the fact that the the official report of an alternate is to not do anything other than ask questions until the caller stops answering shows that the government knows that the alternates know how to set traps like the one that sounded like Cesar may have set possibly confirming what I said in the previous point
(Also fairly terrifying is that if some ones calling to report an alternate that they are pretty much confirmed to be one and that who ever they are impersonating is either a made up person, dead (or missing) due to the alternate or so where safe unaware of the impersonation of them happening at that moment)
And the alternate standing in the room is probably what see saw or it’s was she was screaming about
Raises the question.....where is Caesar?
Dead
@@cjaxvr868 Exactly what I was thinking (it also probably doubles as what we heard on the call too)
It's already terrifying the fact that the authorities are instructed not to help, and even more so, if the person on thephone reporting an alternate encounter is an actual human... then that means they're pretty much doomed, while having a false hope that help will be on the way
One thing I’ve noticed about people who post reactions to this, is that none of them notice the slightly off thing when looking outside at the “grave”.
Compare 38:30 to 38:58 and then compare that to 39:16
There’s someone there.
It’s a shadow along the ground hitting the stone, maybe from the car lights
I always thought it was a shed
That’s a person
That’s just jerry he escaped the basement again, sorry!
I thought it was a shed but the door opened and closed like the hallway door, perhaps to show the alternate hid until Mark was inside the house?
It's a shed that the alternate was hiding in
I like how he points out that Mark and Cesar are very chill.
Very subtle but it's really good storytelling. The alternate hasn't expressed distress.
For those who missed some of the finer details: Before Cesar dies (I assume) - the sequence where the camera flashes between the barn outside, the stairwell, and the hallway - on the last visor of the hallway where the door is shut and after the video of the barn where the door is open, you can hear the VERY faint sound of glass breaking downstairs. I believe this is the sound increase detected.
Okay. I didn't realize this either until I took my Wireless Networks class. We just entered 5G in mobile technology back in 2020. G stands for generation. 2010s was 4. 2000s was 3. 1990s was 2. 1980s was 1. The video in question was in 1992 during 2G. Mobile phones were considered big ticket items and small electronics financing was not as established as it is today. So, it makes sense that a guy who has enough money to set up his own in home camera security system would have enough interest in technology and affluence to be able to afford a cell phone in 1992.
Good detective work Becky
Ok so “Cesar” had enough money to buy a cell phone ,so he might have not been inside “his” house
Even today it’s almost impossible to not have any background noise come from your phone with 5G phones
A 2G phone having absolutely no background noise (being inside a moving ambulance) makes it almost impossible to believe “Cesar” is telling the truth of his situation
Combine that with the shadow on the “grave” right before the open door that is gone next time we see it and it’s almost certain that “Cesar” is an alternate
@@AJOlaks Cesar's face also distorts several times
The scariest part when it comes to these types of stories is that (to me in this case), is there is always something that’s gonna make you jump waiting for you to reach the point makes you even more scared because of the suspense (like in this case, the alternate attacking Caesar’s mom)
"We are currently recieving-"
I KNOW THAT VOICE. That was the same one saying that same message that was later in the video, but in the Foxy cartoon- the message to discard the tape immediately.
I know the other two automated voices, as well. The one in Overthrone was the same one from Faith, and it was a voice synthesizer originally made for the Commodore 64. The "nothing is worth the risk" one was also used in Undertale, for a part of abc_123_a.ogg.
thats why it sounded so familiar
YES I RECOGNIZED THE FAITH VOICE I LOVE FAITH
When i watched wendigoon’a video on this i literally could not sleep with the lights off for a solid week. Ive always had weird anxiety/intrusive thoughts about feeling like there’s something in my room watching me at night so this series is just genuinely all of my worst anxieties wrapped up in a little bow. That being said i think the story is so fucking cool and im absolutely gonna watch this and i am absolutely gonna regret it tonight when i try to go to bed
SAMEEE I COULDNT SLEEP WITH LIGHTS OFF TOO, alex is good at these
The only reason I’m not freaking out is my dog. I know she’d bark or let me know if there was something here. But yeah I got the lights on, too lol.
I’m watching this with my Bluetooth keyboard over the screen for a reason
same, I love scary stuff but hate it because it makes me paranoid
I still think about his video. Sometimes, I'll just be doing whatever, and "Uh oh. Bad decision, Mark!" just pops into my head. I also had a phase where I opened my eyes every 3 seconds while trying to sleep, expecting to see the figure in the corner of my room. Fun times.
I had that mandella effect with a scene from Wreck it Ralph, I was convinced for several years that there was a scene where Felix said that Turbo was his dad. I watched the movie again recently and I haven't stopped being confused about that
Yes me too.
See, I'm not usually scared of this stuff. I blinked a few times at Walten Files. But as a Christian who watched the cartoony bible retellings as a very young child and just has an emotional connection to these stories, I wasn't scared but I felt *very* disturbed. Especially since the "angel" lied to the shepherds, that made me upset.
(Edit) Aaand guess who- going to sleep last night after watching this- had a nightmare from it. Great, thanks. My fear is worse now and I am making sure my loved ones are indeed my loved ones.
Kudos, though, this is really good at being scary.
That's exactly what I was thinking😭 as a Christian who's grown up and has read this story many times, it was so uncomfortable and scary
Sammmeeee
Same, didn't watch these particular original video retellings of the bible story, but I know how the story goes. This made me uncomfortable and un easy, where the angels were aliens deceiving the shepherds.
It is not real though relax, it is called Alternates for a reason
I know that these are in very sensitive areas, but just take it with a grain of salt, just hold tight to your believes
I know its not really theory worthy, but MatPat really needs to watch the squimpus mcgrimpus fnaf vhs tapes. It's my favorite take on the fnaf story and I think MatPat will like it too
Yus
yes absolutely! those videos are like 5x more terrifying than the mandela catalogue from my experience. the creator of those really knows how to unsettle you
@@Squilly4 ive watched the Mcgrimpus vhs tapes, theyre not as unsettling as these are. These take something holy and make it more satanic, whilst the VHS tapes just take a horror thing and make it more scary.
I like what your going for but the only thing is that he has already done the entire lore and story to FNAF but it would be cool for him to react to them.
A lot of people might have missed this, but I love when Mat was looking at the hallway footage, when he said "antici....pation" he just casually referenced Rocky Horror Picture Show. Such a theater nerd, I love it 🤣
Check out the binary text, MatPat. It’s an important part to realizing it isn’t aliens, it’s actually demons/the devil
"I am the one true savior. I must reverse the delusion. Joseph is next."
[TW// In depth talking about death, and dead bodies. This is also a long, and I mean LONG read. I may have rambled.]
I’ve see people talking about uncanny valley and exactly why we ever had to evolve this defense in the first place and I actually have an answer for this! Something that might’ve “looked like us, but wasn’t” were actually other dead humans. Corpses don’t tend to look right to our brains, and that’s why we often see them re-used in horror media. They’re universally scary. The reason we evolved this way is because if there’s a dead body nearby, then there’s almost certainly danger nearby. ESPECIALLY if the body is mangled, and disfigured. And the eyes get to us so much is because seeing wide open eyes on something unmoving, unblinking, staring, that means they didn’t have time to close their eyes before they died, and that increases the feeling of danger. Another reason I can think of that those eyes are so terrifying is because we weren’t apex predators. We were hunted. So something with wide, open, forward facing eyes dead set on you gives you the instinctual feeling that whatever it is, it wants to eat you. The contrast between eyes and darkness also forces your eyes to immediately focus and hone in on the one thing we can see, because that’s how our brains are built. The smiles I think give off that “It KNOWS it’s going to win.” emotion as well. Usually you don’t show signs of happiness entering a fight you have a fair chance in.
That’s all! Sorry I went on a tangent but. You get the idea! Thanks for reading :-)
wow
great comment!
Woaa :0
Nice debunk! :D
It's also for the same reason a chimp's smile is unsettling- it's not friendly. If a chimp smiles, it's a *threat*. Humans and other hominids used to do the exact same thing to each other... right before possibly eating each other. We evolved to be scared of non-human smiles because once upon a time that meant another hominid was probably looking at us and thinking "food".
Why would u put a trigger warning lmao
ive been watching game theory ever since the sonic isnt actually fast theory and i never once considered watching these GT lives until now, seeing matpat re watch, screenshot and play with the image, and construct the narrative in real time has its own unique charm that I regret not discovering earlier
The scariest part of the video was seeing Pat having light mode on UA-cam.
not me having light mode on 😅
When the intruder popped up at 51:00, my town did its routine tornado siren test and now I feel immensely unsafe. 😂
that would make me freeze up and not movw for like an hour, and call my mom lol
Coincidence? I think not.
Do you, perhaps, live in Stagtown? (please say someone gets the reference omg)
u have to be the unluckiest person watching this video
Do you live in Oklahoma? They have Saturday tornado siren tests there.
11:40 Mirror Mat was mistaken: pikachu having a tail was never a question, it’s the pattern on the tail that people remember differently.
Probably got mixed up with the "did Curious George have a tail?" mandela question
What if Caesar (The Alt) called from home never intending to go to the Hospital because it took the mom out, it just wanted to lure Mark into to the house to “off” him
But then why would Mark say it followed dhim home if the alternative killed him at Caesar's house? My guess is he got out quick and got his family killed like an idiot, resulting in suicide.
Caesar isn’t an alternate an creature took years to buy a house just a fool one person doesn’t add up
32:18
If you had skipped back just a _little_ further, you would have seen that the angel had erased themself from the tape
Oh my lord 😢😢
the 4 year old's hand writing changes at the final part at 49:45 meaning the child didn't write the ending.
38:36
Matpat: Can’t trust anything at 3 in the morning.
Me, watching at 3 in the morning: Haha, I’m in danger
Why
I am in 2:16 state: safe
When will Matt learn that its never as simple as just aliens. Too corporeal, too in this universe, not existential enough.
it's because hes lazy and he's not that good at making theories so be resorts to the easiest thing
@@SahilFR Why are you watching his videos if you dislike him so much ⁉️
@@SahilFR 😐
@@SahilFR or really that being the first thought made sense and we all have different first impressions cuz were not perfect robots.
@@SahilFR lmao stop crying
I love when Mat said "it's running time" truly inspirational and shows the development of his channel. 10/10
This was easily one of the scariest things I've seen on the internet. They really did a great job.
I have seen a boatload of creepypastas and horror stuff in general, but The Mandela Catalogue is the first one that genuinely makes me want to stop watching out from being so creeped out. Terrifying, yet impressive.
My favorite part was covering my phone screen and listening to you scream at something I couldn't see
Can't believe Mat failed to mention the reason why it's called the Mandela Effect - the year Nelson Mandela died.
Also, I could have sworn that there was a secondary thing about the effect that some people use it as evidence of someone having switched to a parallel reality where there was just that specific thing that was different, and the memory of it being the wrong way was because it really was as it was remembered in the universe they were from (Shaq actually made that movie, Stein instead of Stain, et cetera).
50:41 MatPat being a dad and calming the child who is scared of the dark. 💖
Dadpat
We stan DadPat
28:10
You mean the kind of fear when your like
“F***…. Thats not right”
You really should do the "monument mythos" series next. Its astonishingly good and, furtheremore, has the rarest quality of all - a clear timeline!
The fact that I have the original dvd with this cartoon and seeing like this was amazingly frightening, brought back memories
sometimes i forget ceasers alternat was the one calling mark- its so impressive how alex dose the series!!
“Tempus Fugit” actually means “time to flee” - this little detail makes everything even more terrifying
bruh
It means time flies
@@lemondigit7309 no it means time to flee. Matt just assumed it was time flies because time clears doesn’t make sence
fugit is the 3rd person singular of fugere, which means to flee. So he/she/it is fleeing. Who? Time. because tempus is 1st form singular, so its the subject of the sentence, so it means “Time flees” or how we say today, “time flies”
For it to mean time to flee it would need an infinitive :)
Doesn't it mean "time flies"? (Maybe fly and flee were the same word on that language, idk)
I love how they didn't even mention the one the Mandela effect was named for. The fact that many people remember Nelson Mandela dying in prison in the 80's when he was really released and didn't die until 2013. Another one that had nothing to do with spelling.
41:23 all I image is an alternate at there computer typing away thinking to himself.
“What a loser”
I CANT STOP PICTURING IT
It's scary to see Matt scared. This is probably the creepiest and coolest creepypasta ever. Or is it a creepypasta? Arg? Analog horror series? Analog horror series...
From what I can make of the story, if the religious cartoons can be taken at face value, it’s implying the origin of alternates and similar paranormal entities date back to the birth of Christ, where in this world, satan had come to Mary disguised as Gabriel and caused them to give birth to a false prophet designed to control people, Satan had also snuck in the original allternate on Noah’s ark in an attempt to destroy humanity. But if it was to be taken metaphorically, it can be implied that an otherworldly force, most likely from another reality had disguised itself from the people and had existed for a long time but only now recently have started attempting to take over