Reused Assets: An Investigation into the Dreg Heap of Dark Souls 3

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 57

  • @swolderbeast5589
    @swolderbeast5589 3 дні тому +9

    Didn't notice most of these. Great vid man. Also noticed that the statue on top of the fountain you showed in the DLC is very similar to the statue behind the lady who gives you the banner before you fight Vordt. The statue in the DLC is much more vibrant as the one in the base game appears more stone-like

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому

      @@swolderbeast5589 I think you're onto something

    • @Smaxx
      @Smaxx 3 дні тому

      Yep, immediately recognized that statue of the knight beheading himself. It's a kind of odd change, making this are "converge" in a weird way.

  • @razz5614
    @razz5614 2 дні тому +5

    i really fuck with the vibes of this video, definitely worth a sub if you want to make more vids like this

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  2 дні тому +1

      @razz5614 yo i really appreciate that. My time to game or make videos is limited, but I definitely plan to keep making them as I can. The vibes will stay the same

  • @MidnightatMidian
    @MidnightatMidian 3 дні тому +8

    Your phrasing, tone and rythm is perfect. Very chill and soothing.
    You should make voice recording for books or media.

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому +2

      That honestly means a lot, as most days I'm pretty insecure about my voice. I appreciate you.

  • @creasedknight6222
    @creasedknight6222 День тому +2

    Cinema 🙌

  • @kajus
    @kajus 3 дні тому +4

    Have you considered doing this for Ariandel as well? Seeing as it has a few points of interest that come straight from Ariamis?
    Did a quick scroll down of your videos page to see if you already had, but didn't see anything, so I figured it was worth suggesting.

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому +1

      @@kajus That would be cool. The painted world of Ariamis is one of my favorite levels in any souls game. It's always had a very unique feel to me. My free time to make videos is extremely limited at the moment, but I'll keep this idea in mind for sure.

  • @GreenEggsSam
    @GreenEggsSam 15 годин тому +1

    The flipped grand archives architecture blew my mind (tho it doesn't really make sense that we fall through and break a window that's supposed to already be broken in the past, guess the scholars must've repaired that lol). I always understood the dreg heap conceptually but never really took the time to map out which locations lined up to where in the base game, so I really appreciate you going through them like this. Great vid!

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  14 годин тому +1

      @@GreenEggsSam same here. I think I said it in the video, but that was my personal favorite of the ones I found.

  • @ianwilliams2632
    @ianwilliams2632 День тому +2

    Fascinating video and comfy length. It's nice to see a more sensibly-timed DS vids, given there are so many 2-hour essays nowadays.
    FromSoft may be the king of reused assets. Some are a little more obvious (all of Elden Ring's building textures, movesets, etc.), and others disguised in the subtlest way. I still know people to this day who are shocked to learn Darkroot's forest covenant area is the same place as upper Oolacile's forest. I'd never stopped to think about this, but the moment you paused on the Dreg Heap bonfire room and made me consider where we are, I said to myself "Greirat!", wow. Great eye!
    Side note: please do ASMR, my god. There's a bit of vocal fry here, so maybe relax a little more and don't force this kind of whisper-talking. But you have great potential for a "radio voice".

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  День тому

      @ianwilliams2632 top notch comment. I feel the same about DS videos...seems like they have mostly become unnecessarily long essays and almost never feel worth it. Perhaps I'm just jaded, though. I mean how long can one game franchise really be one's main source of entertainment across multiple forms of media. (6 years and counting for me.)
      Anyway, I truly appreciate your sharing of that moment of revalation, your kind words, and also the advice.

  • @Smaxx
    @Smaxx 3 дні тому +3

    Nice, randomly stumbled over this on the homepage. I knew most, but never paid attention to the "in-game" references to Dark Souls 3 itself.
    I always loved how the Dreg Heap is a kind of culmination and surprising plot twist after Emma the High Priestess told you about the realms of the Lords *converging* below the High Wall right at the start of the game. It's not just their realms connecting to each other, they're literally converging at one point.

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому

      That's a very cool point that I've never thought of. No matter how much I think I love the souls games, the more I learn..the more I love em.

  • @anomaly_doopliss
    @anomaly_doopliss 2 дні тому +2

    Wow, this is a fantastic video. Great concept, one that I didn't realize was SO prevalent in FromSoft games but really makes me appreciate the games (and wanna boot em up and play again) even more. Also dig your general tone throughout the video and not being overbearing with it.
    The only problem with this video is the criminally low view count. I learned so much from this

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  2 дні тому +1

      @anomaly_doopliss I'm really glad you enjoyed it. Your words are too kind, and I sincerely appreciate you taking the time to write them.

  • @xsxoxo
    @xsxoxo 3 дні тому +4

    With your calming voice this was like listening fairy tales 😅😊😌

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому +1

      I take that as a compliment for sure! Thank you

  • @stewie666666666666
    @stewie666666666666 3 дні тому +4

    Super cool! Makes me wonder if the re-used assets have any lore implications beyond the whole worlds colliding thing.

    • @mushroomhedges
      @mushroomhedges 3 дні тому +1

      Completely agree, makes me wonder why these particular assets and not others?

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому +2

      I wouldn't be surprised with FromSoftware either way. I think the main thing they are trying to convey is that multiple worlds are converging. Pieces of Lothric Castle (The High Wall, Grand Archives) are used to represent DS3. Earthen peak is used for DS2. And Firelink for DS1.

    • @kajus
      @kajus 3 дні тому +2

      @@TheOldMundane And they're collapsing in order of oldest to newest, with Firelink at the bottom and Lothric Castle at the very top; the new coming in later and piling up over the old.

  • @sashab510
    @sashab510 День тому +2

    A+ Content. More please

  • @he212ro8
    @he212ro8 День тому +1

    I would love listening to you talking about Bloodborne. I sadly never really paid attention to the details in the ds3 dlc. Keep it up!!!

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  День тому

      @@he212ro8 I hope to make that happen soonish, thank you!

  • @C4rdion
    @C4rdion 2 дні тому +1

    First video of yours that I've seen, and I've got to say I could listen to you talk about anything. You have a very soothing voice! Also Great video, Hope to see you grow!

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  2 дні тому

      @@C4rdion Thank you for the kindness, sincerely. I plan to make more quiet/relaxing videos on topics other than video games soon

  • @core-nix1885
    @core-nix1885 2 дні тому +2

    The commonality between the Lothric dregs and the Earthen Peak dregs is *Angel worship*
    Baneful Queen Mytha is a twist on "Medusa defeated by a mirror"; she was demented by her vanity into pursuing immortal beauty and was resultantly cursed with undeath.
    The Desert Sorceresses however used mirrors as tools to commune with angels (like how the crystal sages use their crystal balls) - the Grave Wardens who guard Mytha are also connected to the "Angels of Death" (Fenito/Milfanito)
    P.S. Nito is an anagram of Not-I, which is why basilisks drop his covenant items in DS1 (not-eye).

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  2 дні тому

      @@core-nix1885 woah. The deep lore has arrived. Good stuff

    • @core-nix1885
      @core-nix1885 2 дні тому +1

      ​​​​@@TheOldMundane Drangleic is taken from Drang-Reich meaning "Empire of Will", but "angleic" is also a simple anagram of Angelic.
      If you rest at a bonfire in Drangleic Castle after warping, the "Dr" in the location pop-up actually gets cut off by the bonfire menu (which is what led me to notice the anagram).
      Note also that "Below Drangleic Castle" is the optimal bonfire for challenging the angelic Darklurker.
      To be clear, the "not-eye" stuff I mentioned refers to the fake eyes of the basilisks as well as the "not-Self" that Nito symbolises.
      Also sorry about rambling, I liked your video and wanted to share ideas

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  2 дні тому

      @core-nix1885 naaa you're cookin'. I love it. That DS2 lore you just spit is amazing. Tbh I'm not naturally a lore guy. I'm drawn to the atmosphere, vibes, and mechanics of games first and foremost. But I love when someone points out things like you're talking about. Just shows how awesome FromSoftware is at cultivating such rich worlds. For like 7 years now, It's been difficult for me to enjoy other games due to just how damn good the From games are.

    • @core-nix1885
      @core-nix1885 2 дні тому +1

      ​​​​​@@TheOldMundaneTrue that. My love grew and grew as I noticed more and more of the wordplay and symbolism.
      Velka is a reference to the novel "V." which is also why Marvelous Chester is a reference to "V for Vendetta".
      Prism Stones and Rainbow Stones are a reference to "Gravity's Rainbow", the sequel to "V.", unofficially called "V2" in reference to the *arc* of the V2 rocket.
      "Kalamit" (Kalameet) is an anagram of Kalimat,
      like how "Malika" and "Mikala" (Marika and Miquella) are anagrams of Kalima
      (meaning Words/Word in Arabic; a reference to the concept of "Logos")

  • @JesterBM
    @JesterBM День тому +1

    8:20 im not sure if anyone else has commented on the missing doorways fir that room but the missing doorway and the room it leads to were moved so that it becomes the new entrance

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  День тому

      @@JesterBM I believe you are right. Thanks for pointing that out

  • @blakesinge6716
    @blakesinge6716 4 дні тому +1

    I seen your video on reddit and thought I'd give it a watch, totally worth it I see these areas so differently now👏👏. Great video.

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  4 дні тому

      @blakesinge6716 That's awesome, thank you for the kind words.

  • @dadiddde.3568
    @dadiddde.3568 3 дні тому +2

    Very good! Keep going.. will be big

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому

      Haha, thank you. I do not have the time nor the desire to be big, but if a few people like my videos or at least find them relaxing, I am happy.

  • @Kawaiilolrofl
    @Kawaiilolrofl День тому +1

    It's not called a glitchy foot thing! It's called inverse kinematics, a technique used since the n64 era

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  День тому

      @Kawaiilolrofl good info, I've heard that term but did not know it's what caused the souls floppy foot. I have leveled up, and I thank you for that

  • @Krutonkreatura
    @Krutonkreatura 2 дні тому +1

    goated channel

  • @BaerndXP
    @BaerndXP 2 дні тому +1

    Holy shit your voice!! You really know how to use it, do you? Almost like as a weapon ^^.
    No, really, it's so cool how you do that.
    Nice video, I did not notice most of these elements.
    You deserve way more subscribers. +1 from me.
    Btw: YES, we DO love DS2. Well, at least I do. It's just a question of taste, and, for some of us, DS2 ist the best game FROM has made so far. :)

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  2 дні тому +1

      @@BaerndXP oh, I love me some DS2 as well. There’s several things that it does better than all the others imo. May be worth making a video on that topic sometime.
      Thanks for the kind words.

  • @vicedtea
    @vicedtea День тому +1

    10:41 damn i always thought the bonefire in the future firelink shrine was placed there because that's where laurentius sat in the past but its a tree lol guess theres some symbolism there or im in too deep but yeah cool video sorry to ruin your 169 sub count lmao

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  День тому

      @@vicedtea haha. Souls games are bastions for lore and symbolism hedonists. You can indulge yourself with any detail until you've plumbed the depths of it...and there's always more.

  • @bunchacolors1501
    @bunchacolors1501 День тому +1

    Video is awesome, but the voice fry isn't

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  День тому

      @bunchacolors1501 I agree completely. Luckily, there's about a million dudes out there doing souls videos with different types of voices. I prefer them as well, so let's boycott this channel together.

  • @ragabufragsome3426
    @ragabufragsome3426 День тому +1

    dude lay off the weed while streaming

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  День тому

      @ragabufragsome3426 I do not stream, nor was I high during the making of this video, but this comment makes me want to blaze one and get streamy with the cheese whiz

  • @satanamogila9251
    @satanamogila9251 3 дні тому +1

    Yes, fromsoftware are very lazy when it comes to game design. There's a ton of reused assets in every game

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому +3

      @satanamogila9251 to each their own. I think FromSoftware's tradition of reusing base game assets for DLCs in ways that make them feel fresh is awesome. Does it help cut some work load, sure, but they do it in such a way that for me actually adds to the experience instead of making it feel repetitive or lazy.

  • @psychogore
    @psychogore 3 дні тому +1

    5'33" : That rooftop with the fences is in highwall of Lothric, right above the winged knight with the alberd

    • @TheOldMundane
      @TheOldMundane  3 дні тому

      Heyyy I think you're right. That's awesome. I'm sure there's more that I missed.