“Israeli settlements are not an obstacle for peace” | Conflict Zone
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 січ 2017
- The Israeli government has approved thousands of new housing units in settlements in the West Bank despite a recent UN resolution calling for a halt to building and saying the establishment of settlements in the Palestinian Territory “constituted a flagrant violation under international law and a major obstacle to the vision of two states living side-by-side in peace and security.” Conflict Zone host Tim Sebastian visited the settlement of Efrat to speak to its mayor, Oded Revivi. Are settlements hindering peace in the Middle East? Join the debate below.
Why cant more American journalists be more like this interviewer. He does not play nor mince words. He is objective and to the point. He is actually fun to watch.
tim is a brutal interviewer.
He's not an interviewer. Interviewers don't interrupt you every 3 seconds. That guy is a fart with an opinion he must shove the interviewed person, otherwise he won't sleep well.
What Israel do is brutal. Asking questions, or trying to force real answers is not.
I love Tim Sebastian. ".....throwing children onto the street....doesn't it ever give you pause for thought?". Silence........"....I didn't realise you were so dramatic."
After watching Tim's most recent VISCOUS session with a Palestinian, I decided to watch this OLD Conflict Zone interview to get a sense of balance. Surprisingly I came away with an understanding of why, Bibi is NOW ... attempting to CASTRATE Israel's supreme court. CZ has become one of my favorite programs because of Tim, the man is an OG. A fair peace between the Israelis & Palestinians on their terms, will be added to my LONG LIST of prayers for this world, but I won't hold my breath.
21:56 we took it fair and square after they tried to obliterate us with 6 arab armies so they can cry me a river , revivi doesnt know how to answer .
It is still a military occupation, irrespective of who attacked. Doesn't make it your land.
On 5 June 1967, Israel launched a series of airstrikes against Egyptian airfields which started the Six-day war.
This war was Israel against Jordan, Syria and Egypt from start to finnish.
Tim is the best interviewer! He asks the difficult questions that need to be asked and doesn't accept a weak answer or lie. All journalists should take lessons from Tim and try to follow his lead.
4:20 he is right, the world doesn't see what Israel does to the Palestinians because if they did they would end up alone
The Israel's demolish homes of Palestinians that they say were built without permits, who gave the Israeli's a permit to build illegally in the West Bank, on Palestinian land?
Palestinian land? There has never been a country called Palestine.
When country A attacks country B and loses the war, it can also lose land. That has happened everywhere in history.
Brilliant
Jesus was born on palestine land so he was a palestinian
@@LiranBarsisa losing war doesnt mean you demolish homes of civilians!!!! this is war crime
This man lives in an alternative universe.
he knows how to talk thats for sure, master
We wonder if the situation was reversed would Israel think Palestinian settlements in Israel would be seen as an obstetrical to peace? - the interviewer did an excellent job of exposing the untenable position Israel has put itself in
+Trev S
But the situation is reversed and you're a victim of an elaborate hoax perpetrated against the Jewish people:
Hamas minister : The Arabs Are Aliens In The Land Of Israel
/watch?v=r1l5mRP_fzw
I bet you have not seen this yet, have you?
There amazing Jews they left black & returned white 2 millenia later claiming to be the same people
It may be amazing to someone who doesn't know how genetics work. But for those of us who do, it isn't such a miracle. A particular trait may become widespread in a species or a subset of a species as a result of environmental factors. So, why can't the same happen in response to the pressures on a human population? Especially over a period of at least one thousand years?
@@trevortrevortsr2 Nice :)
And that's an amazing lesson on democracy.
I love this guys.
These
@@whisperer1998 Maybe he means "I love this, ladies and gentlemen"
11:28 build by mistake
yeah right
WHERE IS YOUR EMPATHY?!?! HAVE YOU NO HEART AMONGST YOU?!?! If your neighbors wish to belong to 'Israel' so badly, and not 'Palestine', does that justify the eviction of real people who lived there for 20+ years? Why evicting peaceful people and not Palestinian Authority?!
Of course settlements are not an obstacle to peace cause we know Palestinians aren't bothered by Israel's land grabbing and positioning of settlements at all! It has nothing to do with the problems between Palestinians and Israelis. Just ask the Israelis 🙄
Alexplus20 please provide links to this supposed Arab land stealing in 1948 for us who are not as educated on this topic as you.
this was excellent program--why cant you set up an interview with Assad
Ha! We'd jump on that, so if you have any contacts, let us know ;)
@@dwnews ıf you want you can interview with me i have a crazy cat
כל הכבוד עודד
7 years ago and nothing has changed 😂
Criticizing Israeli Politics doesnt make you a Antisemit. People have to speak more about this Issue.
this is conflict comedy
lol
Tim Sebastian is a legend. Some may say he interrupts but he doesn't let politicians get away with pre cooked answers and thoroughly interrogates them to hold them to account. He is like that strict dad who wouldn't let you get away with BS.
love you
Faraz Khan Tim and Andrew Neil.... awesome smackdown power
He is what journalists should strive to be. I’m not only referring to this interview either. He is tough with every politician he sits across from. You must be knowledgeable about the topics to do this of course and most just don’t bother to do much research.
More like cut them off when they try to talk to make it look like they have nothing to say
@@lecorsaire2283 -the research is that arabs conquered israel in 632 jihad and now lie to the world saying that documented home to jewish was always paliestin,they home is arabia,rome kick out jewish,not palestines
So the settlements are the obstacles to peace? How come Israel didn't have peace before 1967, then?
And why was the PLO created before 1967?
Why would they even be considered illegal, if Israel was being attacked by other countries and won the land, fair and square?
Why if they were the obstacle for peace, hasn't the Palestinians agreed to any offer given to them about land, including those that include where the settlements are built?
The Palestinian didn’t have an army the war was with civilians the Israeli where arm to the teeth fighting a war with civilians what a great army Israeli is then the put them in a open prison and bomb them for good measure what a great and Gods people are this ?
Thanks be to God!
Palestinians want the whole peace, the whole land. Europeans seams to want to give the Palestinians half the land unconditional. The Palestinians are willing to just take what Europe is offering but they will not give peace.
No true. Even Hamas has agreed to settle on 1967 border within the international agreed status. Do you have any official evidence that the recognised Palestinian representatives want the whole land?
This is the kind of person you wanna punch in the face for 3 weeks, 24/7 non stop
wow, this reporter isn't biased at all....
That's my British style journalism. Just LOVE IT!
This matter has already been solved with book, mathed by logic and holds stronger a solution than any Constance of debate.
I would love to see bill burr cohost with Tim
You can't go into someone house say its yours
Tim long time no see!
Why Tim Sebastian doesn't use his ''I'm not gonna listen your answers just shot my questions to your face while you are trying to answer'' skill when it comes to western politicians/people or their lovely friends?
Dont change thé topic. This is thé style. If u dont like it dont Côme on thé show.
Tim is a gangsta!!!!
Where is this Judea and Sumeria located at today?
Same as always was, it just got a new name "The West Bank".
It’s the biblical name of the West Bank.
It's just names to the mostly-mountains region in the east of Israel.
Judea in the north, Samaria in the south.
@@LiranBarsisa But the West Bank belong to the Palestinians!
@@elcalich33sehead then why did israshit not establish itself in the West Bank and Palestine in israshits territory
Tim is straight up 😂
Israel hasn't violated resolution 242. "Withdrawal of Israeli armed forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict" is exactly what happened when they withdrew from the Sinai peninsula, which was over 90% of the area. Notice how it doesn't say "all territories", just "territories".
I am happy with the answers provided Israel spokes person.
Before I watched two more interviews from Jordan MP, and one more person, but they're not able answer his questions.
Very fair answers from this person.
kind like i love this m8 mr Revivi.
What about experimenting to give them some rights, that is the take away of all this interview. I love the way the journalists stands for all human rights.
I love Tim Sebastian. Free Palestine!! 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸
Resolution will only come when financial means are cut-off from both sides.
"but what"
Wow, how did they agree to be torched! DW must have leverages,,,,
What kind of country throws families that build homes on other peoples land with out a permit ? Every country in the word that's who
Well I applaud this interviewer for being consistent in his interviewing style & for factchecking this smug bastard to his face.
Oh yeah housing people is monsterous
Israel makes that same excuse and won't be honest
Tim was brilliant
Every follower of a religion lives in an alternative universe,
Religion is no longer useful. It promotes medieval morality in the digital age.
alernative facts lol, he just read my mind... or i his.
The interviewer is kinda rude. He can have his opinion or objection but let the other man finish his first, not interrupting him all the time.
“The fact that, that ‘fact’ is written doesn’t make it a fact” Get outta here.
These types of discussions only serve to prove one thing… the people running “Israel” have little to no humanity towards not only Palestinians but those in Europe and elsewhere who support the Palestinians.
Ynez Yante here ♥️ you Interrupt your guest a lot.
You both debate really good ill will always pray for Israel its the one true God's lands what is wrong with people and this was years ago its so much worse now 😢
Mr. Revivi should have been allowed to answer the questions rather than be faced with a barrage of inaccurate accusations.
what accusation was inaccurate?
The real interviewer. For all those people who feel sorry for this rancid politician and get upset because the interviewer won't let him get away with it when he's going to answer pre-cooked questions
Revivi - you are amazing. Bennett should learn from you.
Sarcasm or schmuckism
Listen to Esau trying to spin lies into truths.
No I'm the chosen one in gods eyes, I am more entitled to your land then you are. I have special words just to explain things that we all go through. That's why people don't like me.
The world is counting and crying over every house destroyed be it built illegal or the home of a terrorist. But the world is silent and couldn't give a hoot when hundreds of thousands of lives and houses are being destroyed in Syria.
that smirk
the two states solutions the europeans are talking about... dude you are european
Goo Tim goo, you are the man👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Yes they are
Two people claim the same land. How can you think the solution is two states?
If Germany does not implement Shari'a law, it will cause violence. If you do not give them what they want, then you are the cause of violence.
If you notice since the interviewer began talking, Revivi had a smirk on his face and then at 3:05 he couldn't hold it anymore lol
..."it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine ..." Balfour Declaration.
Amazing.. so much respect for Revivi.. Such an unproductive interviewer .. im surprised Revivi had the patience to stand his annoying interruptions.
Revivi is so delusional that he may be clinically a psychopath
Ironically, in the end, trump was the one who supported Israel the most. Haha, sad journalist.
Can Palestinians from the West Bank build houses in Israel?
you cant build houses in israel after 24hours police come and break your house its
No.
Am Yisrael Chai!
Just everyone get along ffs
Ok mate, thx
Titus 1:10-11
Tim Sebastian owned completely his guest. Period.
This matter needs to be settled in a secular court, based on International law not based on some religious book.
It doesn't
Israel has a separation of religion and state.
BTselem as a source 😂😂😂
DAAMMM TIM... YOU TORCHED THAT DUDE 😁😁👍👍👍👍👍
Yes dear muslim people God did have a son his name is Jesus Yeshua in Hebrew he loves you he is over the moon for you.
What about indian people this guy loves us too doesn't it
Tim should stop interviewing others and start interviewing himself,his countrymen and country itself after what they have done to others.No wrong doing? Yes of course .after all civilised can do no wrong.Shamles.
most of the world are landgrabbers
Taxi for Oded Revivi .
Interesting fact,Yasser Arafat was an Egyptian, playing the roll of a Palestinian, for the disgruntled Arab world. It was never about land, but the bloody nose they all received after the 1948 war of independence. They failed to prevent a State of Israel. and will never get over it. The western world wanted their oil, invaded these countries, changed their governments, then used Israel as the bargaining chip, to offset their own guilt that continues to this day. If you don`t accept that Jerusalem is Israel`s Capital then you perpetuate the problem.
Of course something wrong with you....
this interviewer is bias and one sided! he's not asking questions he's expressing his bias opinion.
2 state solution, Jordan is a Palestinian state.
Israel's current gov't has tons of wrongs, but one's gotta admire and appreciate the Israeli Supreme Court. You can't abandon law.
Oh and I LOVE how some Arabs act like they were always oh-so-innocent and as if they didn't side with the British in the WW1 against Turkish Empire to get handed in a gift box the key to an independent Arab state, getting pretty nasty in doing so at times, too. Look where did that get ya.
Hey Tim, how dramatic was the situation in the Farhud in 1941 in Iraq, where Jews and their children were not only evicted from their homes, but also murdered, and their homes, their property, their land stolen and confiscated. I don't see you defending their cause. When you'll interrupt your guest next time wondering about the "BUT WHAT?! WHAT'S THE BUT?!" from your high horse, remember this fact of history that is so conveniently left out from the mainstream news and shows like yours.
And remember that because of persecutions like these the Jews had to evacuate their increasingly hostile diasporas from Morocco to Iran and eventually came to Israel. Why don't muslim Arabs do the same and return the favor and evacuate from Judea and Samaria to their wast lands they have now from Africa to Asia? Who really has the moral high ground here? When you look at the ignored facts of history, it's obvious the Jews have it, but that is not "politically correct" to say, isn't it, Tim?
To use your own words:
"Don't you ever have a twinge of guilt about that sort of situation? Doesn't it ever give you pause for thought?"
Bozz#37 +
Thank you for explaining why the settlements are definately a problem.
Your solution of evicting the palastinians will most probably not be acceptable to anyone except the extremists from both sides. Bringing up past wrongs to justify illegal land grabbing and picking and choosing which un resolutions to abide by agitates the situation further.......unless that is the intention.
+Fatma Ramadan Still resorting to lies? Even after your lies are exposed?
Hamas minister : The Arabs Are Aliens In The Land Of Israel
/watch?v=r1l5mRP_fzw
You can claim you're an atheist (I don't believe you), but your
inability to admit your error when you see such proof, shows you are
clearly on the side of the extremists you speak about and that you will continue to lie no matter what. You're clearly not a righteous person. The only illegal land grabbers and agitators in Israel, according to the above video, are the muslim Arabs themselves.
+Fatma Ramadan Stop obfuscating the matter with your ad hominems and address the evidence provided.
Hamas minister : The Arabs Are Aliens In The Land Of Israel
/watch?v=r1l5mRP_fzw
Are you able to do so or are you a hypocrite?
The British Hope-Simpson commission in the 1930's acknowledged the illegal immigration of the Arabs into the land of Israel, Sir Winston Churchill also noted the massive Arab invasion into the land of Israel in his time. The Brits actually had a backbone and spoke the truth in those days, not so anymore.
+Fatma Ramadan
They are censoring me, the spineless hypocrites they are, thus proving I am right. I can't even see your replies anymore, only in the notification. More evidence:
Churchill: Jews did not uproot Arabs. To the contrary, more Arabs came to Palestine because of the Jews
www.gatestoneinstitute.org/comments/21289
The Hope-Simpson Commission talking about the illegal Arab immigration
www.palestinefacts.org/pf_mandate_hope_simpson.php
The Palestine Royal Commission Report talking about illegal Arab immigration and much more
themuslimissue.wordpress.com/2017/01/24/palestinians-terrorists-protest-burn-posters-of-lunatic-fascist-donald-trump/
Bozz#37 +
All you are doing is making a case for people who believe the land being illegally grabbed by jewish settlers is a problem.
You are confusing what you think is a solution with a fact. The fact being the israelis are not going anywhere and neither are the palastinians so strong arm tactics to gain land will not help serious negotiations. And for the last time SETTLEMENTS ARE A BIG PROBLEM whatever you are hoping for,denial of this fact does not help the situation neither does getting angry or giving history lessons,shall we split it between all the previous occupiers? The British and turkish for example . I begin to doubt you seriously want peace.
Again you climb your high horse "They are censoring me becsuse i am right"
I will print your posts because i want everyone to see all you have is.......revenge or a settling of old scores to declare and an unreasonable request the palestinians leave which on the other hand you found deplorable when forced on the jews in iraq or morroco. .....your words ,hypocrite.
How could you shake Revivi's hand? I couldn't stand to be in the same room as him.
What you didn't like about him?
Religion. What more can i say....
Love Israel from India
Ý
burning their own train stations... why can't the palestinians ever have nice things...??
When Israel evacuated Gaza, they also left them dozens of functioning factories and greenhouses, so the Palestinians can start building themselves up and provide work for the Gaza citizens... Those factories used to provide work for thousand so Palestinians as well, but as soon as the last Israeli left Gaza, The Palestinians leaders just went and bulldozed all those factories to the ground!!! This is the mentality of the people Israel needs to deal with and make peace with... Unbelievable.
Does this journalist have pause about the money he makes and the houseshe lives in compared to homeless people? take in the homeless people Tim and then you can talk.
Israel and American don,t care what others say.
Liar + No shame what's worst than that i don't know .
thanks the interviewer ,a genius old wise man. may ALLAH bless him. for his patience with this devilish person.
You are siding with Palestinians only due to your religion. Prejudiced person!
Are Israelis arab
They used to be one people 10,000 years ago.
They don't want peace.
This is the worst kind of interviewer. He doesn't listen to the answers because if he did he would lose the argument, not knowing any more than the quotes and statistics he printed out from the internet.
Win the argument what planet do you leave in you are a pro child killers gangster state
@@armandoramirez9159 How are they pro child killers? I don't understand your comment
TOM IS THE LION 🦁 of press
Tim not Tom, but I agree :D
They have unconditional support to oppress Palestinians.
His face will tell you how eval is he
ahmed abdulahi he is smart and telling facts...the palestinians leaders are just stupid..had so many time opportunities to have a country and refused..now its the time for israel to refuse...they missed their change thinking they cisrael all israel..stupid did i said already???
ahmed,ur book say how evil u are